Lenny Kaye
Before the Ramones and the Sex Pistols, Lenny Kaye was clerking at Village Oldies on Bleecker Street. In 1972, he compiled Nuggets—and its liner notes helped shape the emerging idea of Punk Rock.
Questlove and Lenny nerd out as fellow record obsessives, swapping stories about organizing vinyl, seeing Jimi Hendrix twice, meeting Patti Smith (whom he played guitar for ever since), and recording “Piss Factory” in the final 15 minutes of a session at Electric Lady. Lenny also talks about his new solo debut, Going Local, out now on Yep Roc. Made for artistic closure, not to chase a trend, the personal, unhurried record came from a simple conviction: “because I’m my favorite artist.” He reflects on creativity, his enduring love of music, and the crates he’s digging through now.
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Quest left show is a production of i heart radio.
00:00:03
Speaker 2: All right so i gotta warn you i i over prepared.
00:00:16
Speaker 1: For this that's good better than uh the reverse as they say well you know it's rare that i get to to nerd out on uh A fellow record obsessive. Yeah, record connoisseur. Yeah, yeah. If we get the horses, I'm going to be shocked. Okay, great. I have so many questions about your life as a record connoisseur.
00:00:37
Speaker 3: Well, I still got those records.
00:00:39
Speaker 1: Wait, wait, wait. Let's not talk. Okay. That's what I want on the air. Greetings. What's up? Welcome to the Questlove Show. I'll try not to show all 38 teeth. If I still have 38 teeth, I don't know. because I'm so enthused about what we're about to do today. All right, so if you follow the Questlove folklore, then I'm borderline certain that those of you that know about me know that I've spent a lion's share of my creative life in the village. And if you followed my Quest for Craft series on YouTube, plug, plug, plug, you'll recall my interview with Patti Smith and her recalling Her days in the village, most notably the day that she ran into a random cat named James Marshall Hendricks on day one of the opening of the legendary Electric Lady Studios. Not to mention the many record stores and vibrant clubs and jam sessions. And the list goes on and on and on and on and on of the experiences that basically led to her becoming an artist. And through the time spent at those landmarks that defined a space and a time for a generation, not just her. And if you are a record collector like I am, and I put that lightly, then you already know of the legend of our guest today, I Can't Stop Smiling. He's basically a walking definition of cool. I also want to know if that's burdensome. I will ask him that. Probably next to... I would say, well, you know, worked at 30 Rock. So being in proximity of Hal Wilner or even with Steven Van Zandt, I can't think of a better music snob to chop it up with and talk shop and learn from that we can all learn from. We don't book celebrities more than we book sources. So I want you to picture New York City circa late 60s, early 70s, 70s, 71s. And there's a kid behind the counter at Village Oldies on Bleecker Street and, you know, clerking by day and writing for the Rock Press by night and digging through dollar bins and for these lost, snotty two and a half minute 45s that nobody thought to save. And in 1972, he takes all of that digging, the original digging in the crates, and turns it into a compilation called Nuggets. And in the liner notes, he uses this word. that we still use to this day, which is called punk rock. Basically, he hands a whole genre the mirror that it didn't look in yet, that it didn't know. This is way before the Ramones, way before the Sex Pistols, way before the idea of Bullocks, any of that stuff. He named the room before anybody moved in, and that's important, that's history. And same guy, and now a woman walks into that store, And because she read his essays on acapella doo-wop groups, uh, which my father's part of that lineage, they basically had this meeting of the minds and, and wrote to it. And of course that woman is the legendary Patti Smith. Look, I can go on and on and on and on and on and on. The show is going to be over. I have a lot of questions. Lenny K. I want to welcome you to the Questlove show. Thank you so much.
00:04:08
Speaker 3: Thank you so much for having me. Uh, one, uh, record obsessive to another.
00:04:13
Speaker 1: Okay, can I ask you, is it burdensome to be that guy? Like, to this day, do people ambush you on the spot about some group name or some song or whatever? And in my case, there's always almost a slight glee if I don't know what they're talking about. Like, you don't know about da-da-da-da-da-da-da? You don't have the Japanese B-side of that? No. I'm like, congratulations. Like you stumped me. You get your quote of the year. But I mean, is it burdensome to be the wise sage?
00:04:47
Speaker 3: It helps to have a sense of humor. I mean, I walk into a record fair. One of my favorite used to be down in Allentown, the 45 show. Yeah. 45.
00:04:56
Speaker 1: Still happens.
00:04:58
Speaker 3: And you walk in there and you know there's half a million records. I like to think I know something about something, but maybe I know 10% tops of those. I might know another 10% of the artists. But there's 80, you know, and in there, there's incredible records. I just like, I call it digging in the fields of the Lord. You just go out there. I'm not looking for anything now, but you find something that you've never heard before. It sends you down a rabbit hole. You meet all the related artists. And that's a fun thing. You know, if somebody wants to stump me, great, because... I don't pretend to know everything. I, I pretend to know what I like and that's all over the place.
00:05:41
Speaker 1: Is there still a Holy grail album or 45 that you're desperately in search of right now? Or do you have everything?
00:05:50
Speaker 3: I've actually just found my Holy grail. It's called my soul solo album going local. I can go into a record store and buy it. That's my Holy grail. I mean, you know, there, there's a couple records that, uh, There was a group called The Webs, I can't remember their name, that I really had a hunt for their record. But at this point, I have more records than if I started today and listened to every record for the rest of my life. I'd only get to like maybe D or E in the unfiled pile that I've accumulated. So much music in the world. And I have to tell you, I think that making music is one of the most beautiful things about the human species, that we can, you know, through frequency response and these weird notes, that we can provoke emotion and reveal ourselves to each other. And that, to me, sets us apart from all the other species, except maybe humpback whales.
00:06:51
Speaker 1: No, well, I mean, they have a soul, too. Actually, you said that, and someone asked me this question, like, I think two years ago, and I'll pose it to you. If given the chance to only claim one, would you rather listen and discover music or would you rather create the music?
00:07:13
Speaker 3: I'd say I'd rather create the music because you're playing the song of yourself. And that's a discovery. I mean, all the songs that I write are ways in which I try to understand who I am emotionally, what a situation is. what it reveals about me. They're kind of interrelated. And the feeling you get when you create a piece of music, when that chord or that lick comes to your hand and you say, hmm, that's kind of interesting. Where does it lead? And you really got to listen carefully because most of the time, if you try to push it somewhere, it's going to lead to something generic or something that's been heard. you know, millions of times before, but you got to really listen to yourself. And that is in a weird way, the greatest discovery of all is to find that note deep inside you.
00:08:09
Speaker 1: Yeah. I wrestle with this because I think my ratio might be 45% create the music, you know, and I've had, I can recall at least 10 times in which I was in utter ecstasy, you know, sometimes like When a show is so good or when you know that you're meshing in with your bandmates or that you have a magic moment.
00:08:33
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:08:34
Speaker 1: I had that moment two Saturdays ago. We got to finally headline Macho Jazz Festival. I mean, that achievement alone was like, wow, we've made it. Because also like our very first gig as after busking in local band roots, like when we got established, was the Macho Jazz Festival. You know, it was like a dusty tent. We weren't even advertised. We were like, last minute edition. And it was a horrible show. And to cut 34 years later, like, wow, this is the mountaintop. And then on top of that, it was the perfect show. It was almost as if all 10 members of The Roots knew, like, ooh, this is Montreux. I better give my A game. And usually as a coach, like... I got notes. I got the second microphone. Come on, man. Stop that. Get in your spot. Like I'm that person. And I got to admit, like, I think I might've shed a tear or two, but that's 45%. Then I can name the thousands of times where like a song has stopped me in my tracks. And, you know, you stare at the speaker in a way that you think your family would stare at the speakers. If they're listening to like Orson Welles is war, the world's, you know, back in the thirties on radio, like, is this like, and to me, playing records. I think I created this whole universe just so that I can collect the clout to put myself in the position that I can get all the music. You know, I'm off music now, like now on artifacts. So, you know, to have every last Soul Train episode, every Burt Sugarman Midnight Special episode, and now I'm working on trying to get all the bands to stand up. Like, I'm... I'd rather receive it than give it, which feels a little selfish.
00:10:25
Speaker 3: Well, I try not, I'm not a divisive person in my brain. I'm a writer and that's a very solitary kind of, you know, you're working, it's not a performance art. And then music, even if you're just listening to it, is a performance art because you're kind of experiencing the movement between one note to the next. And I try to not divide my sensibility like that i try to make it all interactive in whoever i am i mean you know if i'm listening to a record and being transported as as i often am you know i'll i'm imagining that i'm in the band when i started out as a writer my thing was trying to imagine what it was like not there but with it how you felt within the band i've just been listening to uh Neil Young's On the Beach album, because I'm going to.
00:11:21
Speaker 1: What year is the On the Beach album?
00:11:23
Speaker 2: 1974.
00:11:23
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:11:24
Speaker 3: And it's not, you know, my favorite of his is Tonight's the Night, but this was kind of the one he made around that wacky time. And I'm listening and I can feel like I'm in the band and I can feel like the keyboard player, not really sure of what the next is, you know. And I just try to experience music in all ways and understand that whoever's listening to it, might not be hearing it like I hear it you know.
00:11:51
Speaker 1: For you is it hard to do you still have people in your life that speak your language that really understands like the the science of what music is I.
00:12:06
Speaker 3: I do but I have such a wide range of of musical interests and styles I'm certainly not a musical snob I don't like a lot of stuff let's be honest I'm you know I'm gonna listen to it but I like metal music and I love pop music. You know, I may not be able to make either one of them. But, you know, when I'm in the mosh pit, you know, crunching down to Opeth, I'm there. And, you know, if I'm listening to the radio and something tick tocky comes on, I can appreciate the killer hook and the sense of humor and maybe some weird underlying synth pattern. I'm not a judgmental person and working in a record store. I mean, you would have people coming in asking for, you know, the weirdest records or the weirdest genres, and you realize that's what they love. That's, you know, that's part of the freedom of incredible choice we have, especially now. I'm not asking someone to go down the rabbit hole as I did last year listening to Umm Kalsum and Egyptian music. I was like... swimming around in a sea that I had no idea any parameters, but being taken on these 25-minute journeys with incredibly precise music that they're playing, and she's just singing. Who knows? I just try to keep myself open. I've made a lot of, you know, I don't like this artist, and then one day, messing with the radio, and the song comes on, and I've realized, I know every note of it, and I'm singing along, and my arm's out the window going, whoopee.
00:13:48
Speaker 1: Right, right. So your inner Jack Black from High Fidelity is not a part of you, like the stomp and.
00:13:54
Speaker 3: No, no. I mean, you know, I appreciate somebody walks into the record store.
00:13:59
Speaker 1: Okay, so say if in 75 someone comes into the record store and wants like the Andrea Moore connection, like they want like more, more, more, or... Great song. Silver Connections, get up.
00:14:13
Speaker 3: And when you're at the Studio 54 of your mind and it comes on the deck, you're dancing along, you know. Right. Because sometimes, yeah, I don't ask pop music to be as artistically deep as someone like Patti. I want pop music to have a hook and to make me happy and maybe I'll remember it or maybe it'll be gone tomorrow. When I was a rock critic, I learned that I stopped being a rock critic when I was asking groups, you know, when I'm reviewing a group, to do what I wanted them to do. That's not my, my opinion is worthless. What are they trying to do into their thing? You know, people say, oh, I don't know, Paul McCartney, silly love songs. Man, I looked at him and I thought, this is guys, he's not trying to, be anything but that at that moment. And if I want them to be meaner or tougher or more dissonant or whatever, I can make my own music. And in a sense, when I started really working with Patti Deepley, that's what I did. Now when I write about music, I'm not putting my opinion in there. It's not like, oh, this record is better or worse than the next. I'm trying to illuminate what is this record trying to say for the artist at this moment in time. And it's a good way to enlighten not only your readers or whoever you're yakking it at that random record store, but yourself to understand how music is being made.
00:15:52
Speaker 1: But, okay, like kind of in the post-Bang, Bang's cream effect, you know, and I'll see this occasionally like on Pitchfork or whatever, even like, Some of these writers are now at established places like the New York Times and whatnot. Sometimes I can tell there's a... Well, the meme is always like, whenever an artist is about to get panned, kind of a, hold my beer, guys, watch this. And then they'll write the most scathing thing ever. And I'm in a privileged position in which I can reach out to that person. And a few times I'll be like, all right, man, the album wasn't that bad. So obviously... you are writing for your fellow writers. It's almost like the critic's version of the aristocrats, like just write for each other and pan as well. You didn't notice that at all? I mean, as a writer.
00:16:50
Speaker 3: I noticed it all, especially in the early years of Roland's. I mean, Led Zeppelin was trashed. And I got to say, you sit in front of those speakers. I mean, Led Zeppelin is like the Colossus of Rhodes. Yes. And those records... They're really smart. That is a perfect group as far as I'm concerned. And to sit in front and see what's, you know, I'm taking a weird critical position on something. No, give it a real listen and then try to figure out how it works, you know, because if you don't like it, well, that's your opinion. And, you know, we all have those opinions, but why does it move people? how does it move people, and the components of that. And that's, to me, what I'm interested in. And we've seen so much of, you know, Moby Dick sold nothing when it came out. He thought he had a failure. He went back to work as a customs inspector. It took 70 years before Moby Dick to be realized as one of the greatest novels of all time. And You know, you just got to do your work. I mean, Patty, I always liked it when Horses was received so rapturously and, you know, well said. And then our next record where we kind of upped the volume and got a little weirder, it was like we were betraying our roots. It's like, no, we're the same band. We're just taking a different thing. You can't listen to all the noise. You just got to say, what is it I'm trying to say? Who do I want to be? I mean, I have to say my record, anybody who knows what I've been, you know, there's no garage rock on it. It's kind of sensitive in a weird way.
00:18:39
Speaker 1: Did you know that it would throw your audience off if it didn't feel like Nuggets outtakes or like that?
00:18:46
Speaker 3: You know, Nuggets was the kind of music I made when I was a teenager back in the 60s. I outgrew that. Five years after Nuggets came out, I've been through every musical genre. I've tried to play most of them. I didn't do too bad of free jazz, even though I don't know the chords that free jazz comes out of. I play a kind of passable pedal steel guitar when I'm in my country thing. But all musics are great. And I just like to move through all of them. And this one finds me almost... returning to the folk singer I hoped to be when I was, you know, wanted to be Eric Anderson.
00:19:26
Speaker 1: Yes. As far as you can go back into your childhood memory, what was your first musical memory?
00:19:43
Speaker 3: I remember, and I've never found it, and I've always looked for it. There was a 78 in my house. called Golden Wedding. I don't remember what it sounded like, but I love that song. And I've looked at other golden weddings over the years on 78s, and I don't know. I don't even remember the song. But my first real musical memory, especially in terms of rock and roll, was hearing Little Richard on the radio when we lived in Brooklyn. And I must have been, what, six, seven, eight, something like that.
00:20:19
Speaker 1: And here in.
00:20:21
Speaker 3: Tutti Frutti, it was the wildest, most incredible release of madness and energy. And me and my sister just started laughing, and we were rolling and rolling on the floor. And so I guess that's about as good. musical memories can be. And of course, the soundtrack to Robin Hood, Walt Disney.
00:20:43
Speaker 1: Nice, nice. How old were you when you realized that, like, when did you start seeding the mind of critical thinking? Of like, not just taking music in as like, oh, they're cool, but more like, hey, there's something about this that's different about this and having opinions, especially in a time period in which critical thinking, journalism, and all that stuff wasn't a thing yet.
00:21:10
Speaker 3: Well, I mean, you know, I got into, obviously, growing up in New York in the late 1950s. I loved doo-wop music and, you know, all the older kids were sitting on the corner singing it. And I kind of moved through, you know, the elements of, obviously, Magic Moment, Beatles, Ed Sullivan. We've all heard that story before. But I never started thinking about about the music until I saw an issue of Crawdaddy. I bought it at a head shop, as they say, on St. Mark's Place. I think it was number seven. And I started reading these writers. And I'd always wanted to be a writer. I worked on the college newspaper and all that. But they were writing about music with the same intensity as the music provoked within it. It wasn't like, you know, favorite color or some teenage obsessions, they were writing about the music as if they were the music themselves. Sandy Pearlman, Richard Meltzer, John Landau, Paul Williams especially, they were my role models for thinking about how to create words to describe an aesthetic experience. And that's not an easy thing to do. The first review I ever wrote was for a jazz and pop magazine. And I thought, wow, I'm getting free records. And it was that Small Faces, Ogden's, Nut Gone Flake record, you know, the one in the round store.
00:22:41
Speaker 1: It's a great, great record.
00:22:43
Speaker 3: And my first line kind of set the tone for my entire way to look at music. How do you describe an aesthetic experience? And, you know, it's in the same way that writing a song describes an emotional experience, right? You're creating a piece of art that allows you to look at something from outside to see what it looks like inside. That's a tricky thing, and I try to keep that in mind whenever I'm doing a piece of writing or playing a guitar solo even. You've got to understand what you're trying to express. What are you trying to say? I say that to myself all the time when I'm doing a piece of something What am I trying to say? Because I don't want to take the easy way out. That's why I write maybe one song, two songs a year for myself anyway. I want to make sure it's true because there's so much music out there. And even though I'm very broad-minded, most of it is very disposable. So if you want to contribute to the mass of musical illumination, you have to make sure It needs to be written. I've written three books. I don't have a fourth one in me. I would love to have a great topic, but I feel like my three books have a place in the literary universe. I'm just not like, okay, here's the next piece of churn out. That's why I've waited so long to do a record because I just don't want to toss out something that sounded like whatever the hot fad is of the moment. You know, so I looked at these songs and I said, yeah, these have worth. And I want artistic closure on them, even if nobody hears them. You know, because I wanted to listen to them myself because I'm my favorite artist.
00:24:47
Speaker 1: I love this, man. I love having this platform. Like every episode is almost like I got to change the title so it could be like, you know, music therapy for me because the things I learned. Do you ever fear running out of ideas or the well being dry? Because even I, too, thought like when I first got my book deal, I thought max two. Okay, I'm going to write about food, too. So maybe I can write five books. And I'm on nine books. And they're kind of like, hey, what's up? And I don't know. I mean, if I sit and think about it, okay, I can turn. And I never want to turn anything out just for contractual reasons. Like, I really want to spit it out. But then I also get in my head, like, man, like, I always feel like people roll in their eyes. Like, here he goes again with another rant about this time in 1977 when he discovered the da-da-da-da. But do you ever fear just running out of ideas?
00:25:48
Speaker 3: Well, sometimes I'd like to because then I could lead a more relaxed life. And I could sit on the porch and have a cocktail and gaze out at the sunset and realize, you know. But when that idea comes up, it's fun to chase it. I mean, when I finished the record, all of a sudden there was two songs sprung up in front of me. And I thought, okay, I'm going to keep doing it because it's what keeps you alive. You know that as well as anybody else. as long as you have something to do that day creatively. What does Jimi Hendrix say? Hooray, I wake from yesterday. And so when I wake up and I got this piece of song that maybe I'll sit and chew on for a while and see if it goes anywhere, or I'll organize my records.
00:26:43
Speaker 1: You dare do that?
00:26:46
Speaker 3: It's been on my list for years. My albums, I can kind of find an album if I have an hour or two.
00:26:52
Speaker 1: How do you categorize them?
00:26:54
Speaker 3: Well, I got the, you know, the wall, it's the pop, and then there's jazz and the reggae and the weird ones. And then the 45s are like, which is my favorite storage medium, but they're a holy mess. You know, if I have to find a 45. But I'm going to get them to, I promise you, I'm going to get it together. I'm going to devote a week to it.
00:27:17
Speaker 1: I don't feel bad about myself now because mine is in a disarray. Okay. I always wanted to know from you, I could say that maybe for me, there are like four moments that I lived through and knew instantly on day one when these seeds were planted that this is going to be a historical moment. The first time I heard like the first single from the second Public Enemy album. And it was a War of the Worlds moment. Really taking in the psychological after effects of what Thriller did. Like not just as an album. Like Thriller to me, I remember a time in which there were no street vendors. I could walk down the block and the block be clear. And suddenly, in the heart of 52nd Street in West Philadelphia, suddenly, Posters, vendors, pocketbooks, Thriller wallets, Thriller buttons. And after Thriller sort of faded out, that still remained. And I was like, wow. I didn't realize the effect that Thriller had just on the Canal Street-ization of everywhere America. Do you recall a pop culture juggernaut? of historical importance that you were able to say, nothing's going to be the same again. Like, I don't know, maybe for all the folklore I've read about like exile on main street, I tend to think that a lot of this stuff is done revisionist style, like 10 years later. Okay. That was a classic moment, but How did you feel about it the day it first came out? So for you, no, I'm not asking about your opinion on that.
00:29:10
Speaker 3: I gave it a kind of wishy-washy review in Rolling Stone, I have to say. People are still bringing it up. I can't believe it. But I didn't see the forest for the trees, let's be honest. It's not a song album.
00:29:22
Speaker 1: Yeah, of course.
00:29:23
Speaker 3: It's an atmosphere.
00:29:25
Speaker 1: Exactly. But for you, when what we now declare as a historical moment in music Are there moments in which you were a day one and knew that nothing was going to be the same after this moment and it actually happened?
00:29:42
Speaker 3: Well, I always go back to that moment that I'm standing outside of this rundown Bowery bar called CBGB. And there was a bunch of renegade bands playing there and I happened to be in one of them. And it's really about as off the beaten path. And And I'm just standing out there and the bands are starting to filter into the world. And I start thinking, this reminds me of another scene that really changed my perspective on life, which was the San Francisco Summer of Love gatherings at the Fillmore and the Avalon, which I traveled to in a 56 Ford with my buddy Larry and got to see in person. And I started thinking as I'm sitting there, You know, the bands are starting to get articles in the English press and everybody's kind of figured out who they are because it took maybe a year or two before all the bands understood their very, very different personalities. And I'm thinking, you know, this is a lot like San Francisco was. And you're starting to see the cultural impact of this very, very localized scene start to move into the world and change the music in an evolutionary way. That to me is what going local is about. That you have these little scenes, Brian Eno calls them scenius, because it's not just the geniuses on the stage, it's the people, it's who was in the audience, what they were reacting against, what the culture needed to move things to change the channel essentially. And I always remember that moment just standing there and suddenly thinking, wow, this is like San Francisco in 67 or Liverpool in 62 or all these little moments in time where the music evolves. And it's great to watch that happen because you can't predict it. It always happens some out of the way place. I mean, CBGB's was like a, a true dive on the Bowery where you just never went to. I mean, even though there's, you know, all of New York, 40 blocks north. But this was so out of the way, you know, same 25 people, all of whom were swapping members. And all of a sudden, you can feel like the cultural force, like Thriller, suddenly becomes something. And a few years later, it needed to become something else because then it got to be punk with a capital P Ramones template, great records, but very predictable. And that to me is when it's time for a change.
00:32:36
Speaker 1: Is it better to shock or be consistent? I think we want consistency, but then.
00:32:44
Speaker 3: Well, we like a good shock to the nervous. You know, it's like the, it was the Frankensteiner. I am alive.
00:32:52
Speaker 1: Right.
00:32:52
Speaker 3: But then, you know, once you got the shock, you got to do something with it. You got to make it evolve and work and do the hard work of making that revelation real, I guess. And I'm a hard worker. I have a lot of things that I've done, but I've done them past tense. What I really like to think about is I'm going to get up this morning and I'm going to go down there and smoke a joint and see what comes out. And that's... That's the fun part, really. To live in the present, that's so hard.
00:33:32
Speaker 1: It's the hardest thing in the world.
00:33:33
Speaker 3: Hardest thing. You're always thinking about, oh, this, or I got some over there. Right.
00:33:37
Speaker 1: How would my future be affected? Yeah. What trauma in my past is going to be?
00:33:41
Speaker 3: And that's why it's great that we're musicians, because when you're playing, you're totally in the present. You might think of the bridge coming up, but if you start doing it, you know you're going to screw up the chorus. You know, going to take your mind. I mean, I went through a motorcycle time when I was in my 40s. What a surprise. And, you know, I'm going around a curve at 80 miles an hour. And the one thing you can do is think, man, I'm looking good. You know, because you'll dump that bike in a second.
00:34:13
Speaker 1: You're completely aware, right.
00:34:14
Speaker 3: So, you know, and I translated that to guitar solos. Because if I'm playing a guitar solo and I hit a note that, like, surprises me, I can't dwell on it. Because that other note is coming up. And if I think, wow, you really bent that well. Well, you're going to just, you know. Wow.
00:34:33
Speaker 1: You actually answered a question that I wasn't able to articulate to people. So one of the things I love doing, one of the things that people make fun of me the most in my personal life is my favorite thing is, okay, so zip car is kind of like. uber without the driver right you go on your app and you can drive any car america you know go to blah blah blah street and you can open up with your app and after the pandemic i couldn't figure out why music and books felt different to me when i'm driving as opposed to when i just put a You know, something on the stereo at home or read a book and that sort of thing. And I realized that maybe driving is almost the equivalent of sleep. So in other words, you're fully aware of what you're doing.
00:35:31
Speaker 3: Right.
00:35:32
Speaker 1: But your subconscious is picking up. Like I hear subliminal parts in a song way more. Like when I really want to listen to a record, I will simply, I mean, the amount of times you really want to catch me in New York. Like, where do you hang? I will, on a Sunday, 1 p.m., I'll get in a Zipcar, and I will circle the West Side Highway FDR. Wow, that's great. Five hours. And somehow, this is how I'll judge my mixes, this is how I'll judge. For some reason, I hear it different driving, and I think it's because it forces me to use my subconscious to receive the music in a different way. But when you made the analogy of the motor, I was like, oh, that's why... You're present, but you're also, there's other factors of your psyche that's there.
00:36:23
Speaker 3: I mean, it makes me sad that you can't have CD players anymore. I used to listen to CDs all the time in the car and it was great because, you know, instead of trying to find something on the radio, sometimes you can. WFMU does exist in the world. But, you know, if you really want to like Listen to something and keep listening to it. It's a good way to do it. So next time you get the zip card, just pick me up. We'll go for a ride.
00:36:49
Speaker 2: Hey, man.
00:36:50
Speaker 1: We'll do this. We will do this. As a writer, I know that you've been privy to many a show, most notably probably many a debut. Can you name five notable first-time performances of people that are now the establishment?
00:37:19
Speaker 3: I'm going to get you on this one.
00:37:21
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:37:23
Speaker 3: Summer 1966, Cafe Go-Go. It's called a blues bash. It's in the afternoon. I'm sitting there. John Hammond, Richie Havens plays. John Hammond says, I want to bring a friend of mine from down the street. His name is Jimmy James. He comes out on the stage. I have no idea who he is. Does everything, you know, with the car and the teeth, behind the back, playing, you know, a billion notes, completely like insane. So that's a pretty good one.
00:37:57
Speaker 1: How many times have you got to witness Jimi Hendrix in the flesh, like play?
00:38:02
Speaker 3: I saw him twice. Both of the weirdest shows. I mean, that was the first one. The second one. was the night after Martin Luther King's assassination in Newark.
00:38:13
Speaker 1: April 5th, 68. Okay.
00:38:17
Speaker 3: And so I'm going. I mean, yeah, Newark is closed down. They're waiting for the riots. But they keep the early show. And there I am. I've got my Nehru shirt on and my beads. And Jimmy comes out, symphony theater. And he's like, you can tell he's disgusted. He's looking out at the sea of white faces who are just waiting for him to smash his guitar. And I've never seen, I mean, I've seen a million films of him, but he's like looking at his watch, completely sullen. And at the end of the show, he takes his guitar. He says, you want this? Kind of drops it on, you know, no drama. Everything walks off the stage. The funny thing is I've read things about that show. Oh, he was triumphant. No, I was there. He really felt his alienation from his audience at that moment.
00:39:19
Speaker 1: He was mourning. Wow.
00:39:20
Speaker 3: Yeah, so those are the only two times I got to see Jimmy, except when he appeared as a ghost when we did Are You Experienced in Electric Ladyland. And we're playing it. We're doing it live. And for the solo, I go to kick on my wah-wah pedal.
00:39:36
Speaker 1: Right.
00:39:37
Speaker 3: And I kick it so hard, the plug comes out. I thought, oh, God, and the band's playing great. So I'm there trying to get it back.
00:39:44
Speaker 1: I go.
00:39:47
Speaker 3: Anyway, get it back in, finish the take, really good take. And we're listening to it. And Tony Shanahan says to me, he says, well, we should take that out. And I say, no, that was Jimmy. He was like, he wanted that kind of, you know, trying to plug in some great things. So that was the only other time I saw him.
00:40:14
Speaker 1: Any other notable moments? Moments of performance that you've seen of people in their firsts? Or what was the show that literally just gobsmacked you?
00:40:25
Speaker 3: Neil Young doing Like a Hurricane at Fuji Rock. I'm standing on the side of the stage. He finishes. I think he did an encore too. And then he starts doing Like a Hurricane. And it goes on and on. And you can really feel him like calling down the thunderbolts and the lightnings. I'd say that's one of my top 10 moments.
00:40:46
Speaker 1: What year is this?
00:40:48
Speaker 3: I don't know, 15 years ago maybe. I don't remember. Maybe 2000.
00:40:52
Speaker 1: Oh, okay. It was recent.
00:40:54
Speaker 3: It was Fuji, you know, the Japanese wacky festival up in the mountains.
00:40:59
Speaker 1: I've seen that version of him before doing the SNL 50 documentary. The one thing that I regret not putting in that documentary because I didn't want to put just a piece in it. But if people will ask me, you know, they know that I watched all 50 years of music performances on that show. This is when Freedom had just come out. I think it's 1989. And I know Jordan's on drums. And, you know, they're doing Rockin' in the Free World. And SNL, I mean, at the most, is a three-minute and 40-second affair. If you're of note, You know, I've seen moments where, like, you know, McCartney does all seven minutes of Hey Jude. But, man, I got to tell you, like, when I got to his episode of Rocket in the Free World, you know, and it wasn't like I was watching, like, oh, some historical is going to happen. Like, it's on and I'm in the kitchen or whatever. And, you know, I have this theory about repetition, right? especially when a band is locked and repetition happens, to the band it might be boring that, wow, I'm playing the same thing bar after bar after bar after bar, now it's 32 bars, like I gotta do something different. For some reason, that quartet played the same thing for at least three minutes in a row, but each round got more intense and more intense.
00:42:32
Speaker 3: Turn it up, turn it up.
00:42:34
Speaker 1: And it's to the point where I actually stopped what I was doing in the kitchen and just started looking at the television And I was like, wait, what is it about this? And I watched it again. And it's hard to explain the magic. Because I know if I would go to someone else and be like, yo, man, you got to see this thing. They'll just be like, he's doing Rock in the Free World. Like, what's the big deal? But it's a synergy moment that is hard to, unless you're paying attention or trying Not paying attention. Again, the subconscious thing, I think, is where the magic happens.
00:43:05
Speaker 3: Because that's where the music comes in first.
00:43:07
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:43:08
Speaker 3: You can think about it later, but you're not thinking about it. It's not like, oh, man, that's an interesting chord progression.
00:43:15
Speaker 1: Right.
00:43:15
Speaker 3: The chord progression is like making your heart move for it. Yeah.
00:43:19
Speaker 1: So I can totally see how that grabs you.
00:43:21
Speaker 3: Another one I always remember, R.E.M. in some Paris arena once. And there was lots of talk. And sometimes it's not even the band, it's like the occasion. The world is supposed to, one of those, the world is going to end at a certain, you know, day. And so, you know, of course we all live through it. Anyway, they played It's the End of the World as we know it for their encore. And I actually felt like, yes, we've survived the end of the world.
00:43:49
Speaker 1: Right, right.
00:43:50
Speaker 3: And the audience is there and it's, oh my God, it's so great.
00:43:53
Speaker 1: So the I feel fine part, it was really apropos. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I do remember hearing that. And, you know, I'm in the eighties was for me, like here in 1999 by Prince, it was always the fear of like, ah, man, when we get to 2000, it's going to be fucked up. And I joke with people now that like, once I got to 2000 and it was like, oh, this is it. Like now I just think of the really tacky outfit that like Britney Spears and Justin Timberlake wore to the MTV awards. Like, oh, 2000 tacky outfit. Not like, oh, we're going to die. What was the first 45 that you purchased with your own money?
00:44:35
Speaker 3: I went down to the record store that was right near Church Avenue on Flatbush Avenue. I think it was called Halpern's or Vogel's or something like that. I bought four 45s. I was going to receive a conga drum. The record player shaped like a conga drum for Christmas. It had a little thing, and it was kind of cute. So I bought 445, so I always remember this. It's only make-believe by Conway Twitty. It's all in the game, Tommy Edwards. Okay. The Purple People Eater, Shev Woolley.
00:45:12
Speaker 1: Nice.
00:45:13
Speaker 3: And the wrong version of To Know Him Is To Love Him, I bought the one by Cassie Carr instead of the teddy bears. And that was it. And that's what I'm about. Romance and novelty.
00:45:24
Speaker 1: I was going to say, this is how I know you're a true connoisseur, because I'll ask people this question. And of course, they're going to give me the hippest shit in the world. Yes, well, I had a, you know, Golden Lady by Stevie Wonder. And I used to be that person because I was really, really embarrassed to tell people what my first 45 was. What was it? You can tell me.
00:45:48
Speaker 3: Just lie down on the couch and tell me.
00:45:52
Speaker 1: No, I mentioned it before on this platform that my attraction to records wasn't even the music. For some reason, I was always transfixed with how the logo rotated in 360 motion once I won the record player. I mean, there was points where You know, and I've slowly sort of left crumbs in my books about my light autism journey. But there would be moments where, like, babysitters. My aunt once tested me. Like, she put a record on the turntable. And she would tell the family, like, he sat there for 20 minutes, like, watching it. And they're like, yeah. And she's like. I didn't put the music on. So that said, I felt like the best logo in music in the 70s was the Rocket logo for MCA Records. Elton John was on that label, and so was Neil Sedaka. And so I think John had produced Sedaka's Bad Blood. Mm-hmm. And, you know, the combo of the green and the blue, and if you remember the Rocket logo, it looked like a, what's the show that Ringo Starr hosted in the 80s, The Train?
00:47:15
Speaker 3: Oh, Thomas the Train.
00:47:17
Speaker 1: Thomas the Train.
00:47:17
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:47:18
Speaker 1: It was basically, it looked like a Thomas the Train... Sorry.
00:47:23
Speaker 3: I'm falling down a hell of a rabbit hole.
00:47:26
Speaker 1: We're in a rabbit hole now.
00:47:27
Speaker 3: Yeah, sorry, man. Wait, the little bunny's coming out of the hole. We're going to Wonderland.
00:47:31
Speaker 1: Dude, I like detail. Well, here's the other thing. I will let people know that my entry to anything post-Rubber Soul or even Pet Sounds was damn near my 30s because I never liked the Capitol Records logo. I saw it as old and ancient and never touched it. Like when they modernized it in the 70s, then I came to Capitol. But if you had a bad logo, I wasn't going to listen to your record.
00:47:58
Speaker 3: Well, if you came into Village Oldies, I would be going to, look at this logo. See? And I'd be jacking up the prices. It's not a dollar record. No, you need that.
00:48:09
Speaker 1: Were you that person? Because I know for a fact that when I come walking in, that they're already, there's two places in America where I can still shop. And I know they don't know who I am. There's a really good record store in Omaha, Nebraska. And to this day, I maintain that Portland, Oregon is hands down the best place for record shopping.
00:48:38
Speaker 3: That big record store next to the ballroom, the Crystal Ballroom.
00:48:42
Speaker 1: Across the street. Across the street, yeah. There I found, I forget the record I found. It was super rare and they didn't know it. And I felt so guilty of when I seen it. And I'm that person that like has to do the. The right thing. Well, I mean, I do the poker face. Sometimes I bring a wingman in. Well, I have to bring a wingman in because I know like there's some record stores that instantly see me coming. And then suddenly this Eugene McDaniels record is $ 200.
00:49:13
Speaker 3: Yeah, but I usually get the nuggets discount. They're like, oh, yeah. oh, yeah, take it.
00:49:22
Speaker 1: They see you coming and then it's like, okay.
00:49:26
Speaker 3: Maybe it'll be on Nuggets 75, you know.
00:49:29
Speaker 1: I got you. As far as radio was concerned, who... was your North Star as far as your trusted voice of who your hero was? Like, did America ever have a John Peel? Like, who was our John Peel?
00:49:45
Speaker 3: I mean, you know, I grew up listening to AM radio. So it was Murray the K on the swinging soiree with a blast from the past. This is for all you submarine race watchers out there. You know, I was there when Peter Tripp on WMGM stayed up for 200 hours straight. a stunt that actually affected his mind in later years.
00:50:09
Speaker 1: I'm not familiar with the legend of this.
00:50:11
Speaker 3: There's a guy named Peter Tripp, two Ps, and I think it was like in 1959 or something, he, as a stunt, because, you know, that's what DJs did, he wanted to stay up for 200 hours straight. And, you know, so attracted a lot of attention and he did it, but What I read was that it permanently altered his brainwaves.
00:50:35
Speaker 1: Seven Days Street.
00:50:37
Speaker 3: Yeah. And they covered it. It was like, yeah, yeah.
00:50:41
Speaker 1: What was his last record?
00:50:43
Speaker 3: I don't remember what he played. I just remember the thing. But I love Murray the K. He was my guy. But my favorite DJ of all time is... Jerry Blavitt, the geater with the heater, the boss with the hot sauce broadcast. No, you yawn teen foxes and coyotes.
00:51:01
Speaker 1: Yeah, man. I'd seen Blavitt at some event in Philadelphia, like 2010, maybe, and still dancing.
00:51:12
Speaker 3: Still doing it. I mean, he has passed into the great beyond.
00:51:15
Speaker 1: Right, I know that.
00:51:16
Speaker 3: We know that. But he lives forever in our hearts. I said to this day, but in the mid-aughts, I still got to see him. He did that thing down at the shore. It was at Margate or some wacky place. He would go there and have his thing.
00:51:29
Speaker 1: He used to throw these, where's the spot in Atlantic City? The Steel Pier? Yeah, so a lot of, like my dad's re-entry into music. Like he, Leandro's in the Heart stopped in 64, 65. And then I didn't realize how instrumental Hendrix was in the idea of nostalgia culture because I didn't know that he insisted that if he does Woodstock, that they must book Sha Na Na and they must go on before him. And I was trying to figure like, well, that's odd because the Sha Na Na I knew, you know, was came on like with soupy sales in the seventies or whatnot. And I didn't realize that like, oh, this is the first round of nostalgia culture. Exactly. And the idea that I can be 30 years old and the music I was listening to when I was 12 and 13 could still be a thing. Of course, I guess the legend is there's a promoter, a New York promoter. His name is Dick Fox.
00:52:38
Speaker 3: Oh, he's got them all. He had Frankie Avalon and Bobby Rydell and Fabian, the big three.
00:52:46
Speaker 1: Yeah, so suddenly the post... Woodstock effect of shot on not being there selling nostalgia. Then started this whole round of like, okay, well, did Fox presents, you know, Dick Clark's circus of the data.
00:53:00
Speaker 3: I think that's when Richard Nader's rock and roll revivals came around too. That's where I actually got to see bill Haley in the comments.
00:53:06
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:53:07
Speaker 3: It was exciting.
00:53:08
Speaker 1: So my dad would be part of that circuit. Yeah. And you know, for the most part, I'll say that up until greet like 77, like it was a good, it seemed like, oh, we're going to do this forever. And then my dad had the wisdom to realize that like nostalgia wave only lasts for like five years. And then you got to jump to the next thing. So then he would, after 77, he developed a nightclub act because DJ culture hadn't taken over nightclubs yet. That sort of thing. So in that circuit, like that's where I discovered really my, like I really thought that oldies music was contemporary. And I was in a rude awakening once I got to school. Like what the hell is Rick D's disco dub? In your teenage years, like what record stores were your heaven?
00:54:14
Speaker 3: I got to go to the legendary Times Square Records. which at that point was in the subway arcade at 6th and 42nd Street.
00:54:23
Speaker 1: So it was underground?
00:54:24
Speaker 3: It was in the subway. And it was the first oldies store. I mean, you got to remember that in 1962, 3, 4, you know, these records were hardly five, six years old. So the concept of oldies was like, what? You know, and village oldies and, you know, all the oldies store down there, it meant that this music was past dated. It was done even though, you know, in a weird way, that's the story of Nuggets too. I mean, when I put that record together in 1971, 72, those records were four to five years old. It wasn't really an exercise in nostalgia. It was just something kind of coming to the surface. But I went to Times Square Records. It was mostly group records, Vocal Harmony, lining the walls. I couldn't spend $ 5 on a record. They had Elvis Presley Sons for $ 20. I couldn't afford that at all. But it was just great to see this subculture kind of grow out of nowhere. Because before then, you would have stores that sold 78s, like Commodore Records. But things move quickly Bleeker Bob, when he left Broadway Alley and opened up his Bleeker Bob store, his specialty was like 60s and even 70s rarities of which there were starting to become a whole thing. It all kind of moves forward. I mean, pretty soon those Katy Perry CDs that you threw out on the way to get something, that's going to be a lot.
00:56:15
Speaker 1: I'm a hoarder to this day. Like I'm up to 200,000, even though I don't need.
00:56:19
Speaker 3: Good for you. Make me feel great.
00:56:22
Speaker 1: I'm not a quantity guy. I know you're a quality guy, but we're also in the age of the first generation of those one-stop shop owners. Now, like the kids or the widows of my dad used to service these 200 bars and diners for their jukeboxes in New England. And now there's like 38,000 records just sitting there. And we heard you like records, Questlove. So now I'm in that business now where we don't want to throw it away. Do you want these 7,000 pieces? So that's how I accumulate it. But also, I also joke that I don't need 400 Billie Jean 45s. But that's what it is mostly.
00:57:07
Speaker 3: So did you ever think about opening up a record store? I could see it now. A chain. I know, it's hard.
00:57:15
Speaker 1: At the most of your record collecting height, what was the number?
00:57:21
Speaker 3: I don't know. I always say 3,000. I haven't counted them for 30 years, but I have a wall of records, so I figure there's maybe 3,000 there. There's probably another 3,000 45s in the a couple other rooms. There's the CDs, which seem to replicate without me doing anything. They're just mating, and here's a new one.
00:57:43
Speaker 1: Right. You discovered that you didn't have that.
00:57:45
Speaker 3: And since I just got a voice of music half console from the 50s, my interest in 78s has been reawakened, even though I try to deny that. Because when you hear a 78 on a 50s mono speaker pumping out of one of these consoles.
00:58:05
Speaker 1: It's like I'm in the room.
00:58:07
Speaker 3: It's transforming. You play an old R & B record from like, you know, 1952, you know, on Hollywood or something. Yeah. And man, it just, and I thought, okay, but I'm not going to cylinders.
00:58:23
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:58:23
Speaker 3: No, no way.
00:58:24
Speaker 1: No way. None? None, none. Wow.
00:58:27
Speaker 3: And I always hated cassettes. So that's good. Really?
00:58:29
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:58:31
Speaker 3: I know very easy, but you know, they always break or, you know, and they, you go to a studio, you listen on this great stuff. You take a mix home on a cassette and you listen to it and you, that's it. I'm out of the music business. Yeah.
00:58:45
Speaker 1: But I feel like we need that because I mean, the theory is that, you know, most people listen to music on crap and it's almost like the song has to sound perfect, even in the most crappy situations. I mean, I will say that I'm not proud of it, but probably 70% of my consumption is now on this laptop, which isn't ideal.
00:59:10
Speaker 3: But you can hear the song. In the end, with all of this stuff we're talking about, you know, when I'm in the studio mixing something and worried that, you know, is there enough this or is that bass drum beat somewhere there?
00:59:22
Speaker 1: No.
00:59:23
Speaker 3: You know, you get a month away and it's just a song. You just hear all, you know.
00:59:29
Speaker 1: I'm wilted right now because, you know, I have 700 jazz pieces from a collector and they're in awesome condition. They're 10 inches, 78s. And I'm never going to play them, but. Oh, maybe you will.
00:59:49
Speaker 3: I'm starting to, I can see a little bit.
00:59:51
Speaker 1: But when you said that someone there, there are a few people that are like, Hey, like, you know, I have a 78 players, like, you know, selling me on the thing.
01:00:01
Speaker 3: The faster it revolves, the better the sound quality. Just, just saying I might, I might have a good duplicate. Wait till you hear my Arabic 78s that I've been finding. They're insane.
01:00:12
Speaker 1: Do you have a collection of, um, x-rays?
01:00:16
Speaker 3: Don't tempt me.
01:00:17
Speaker 1: Okay, so in Russia, the only two places I know, Cuba and Russia, American jazz was banned. However, there was a sort of underground operation in which I guess the same material for which after you get an x-ray. Right, right. That, you know, like the thing that you get in magazines, the little floppy lacquer thing.
01:00:41
Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:00:43
Speaker 1: They started printing up Billie Holiday records on used x-ray charts. So someone gifted me like 10 of those from Russia, like in the late 60s or whatever. And that's how they consume music. Like people just go to these underground markets to get someone's x-rays that were discarded, but also had Charlie Parker on it and.
01:01:08
Speaker 3: I mean, there's so much music. I met a guy when I was in California last week. He collects like beat groups from Singapore, you know, from the 60s.
01:01:18
Speaker 2: Yeah.
01:01:18
Speaker 3: And, you know, he was showing me some of these, you know, 45 sleeves and, you know, these people are crazy. It's a great expanse. I'm so glad that at least part of our wacky human condition is pointed toward doing stuff like that as opposed to building bigger weaponry. You know, because hobbies will save your life.
01:01:42
Speaker 1: Still, I believe that.
01:01:44
Speaker 3: All right.
01:01:45
Speaker 1: We're kidding there. What five albums define you as a human being?
01:01:51
Speaker 3: Oh, God.
01:01:52
Speaker 1: And I don't know if I'm asking you what are your favorite five albums.
01:01:55
Speaker 3: Is this a pop quiz?
01:01:57
Speaker 1: No, but I feel, you know, moments in your life. What five albums would you say?
01:02:02
Speaker 3: All right.
01:02:03
Speaker 1: This is better than your albums burning down and what five would you save?
01:02:07
Speaker 3: Right.
01:02:08
Speaker 1: You know.
01:02:09
Speaker 3: This is a really naughty question, but I do think about these things. I guess the records that really have impressed me, I think Spirit of Eden by Talk Talk.
01:02:22
Speaker 1: What is it about that record?
01:02:23
Speaker 3: It's a record like no other. It has so much dynamic range. It gets really loud, it gets really soft, and yet it's all about the space. I've never had a record that you could enter into... and feel the sense of space between the musicians and what they're doing. I just find that an amazing record. Blonde on blonde, gotta say. If I'm going to the gallows- Can you school.
01:02:59
Speaker 1: Me to that? Because unfortunately I was raised on Kristen Dillon.
01:03:05
Speaker 3: Okay, yeah, the best Bob Dylan concert I ever saw was Christian Dillon, where he was actually not pulling your leg sometimes.
01:03:15
Speaker 1: And the audience was with it? They were fine? There was no revolt?
01:03:18
Speaker 3: No, you know, he was in Spokane, Washington, of all places. He just happened to be playing there.
01:03:24
Speaker 1: What is it about Blonde on Blonde? Lyrically.
01:03:28
Speaker 3: surrealistic and amazing and so heartful. And to me, the most beautiful song ever written is Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands. And I've listened to it in various states of consciousness, I must say. And it's just one of, I don't know, it's just a transcendent thing that, you know, if they're taking me to, you know, be executed for my political views.
01:03:54
Speaker 1: That's the last thing you want to hear.
01:03:55
Speaker 3: I just want them to play that as they're, you know, loading the howitzers.
01:04:00
Speaker 1: Okay, I can go.
01:04:02
Speaker 3: I'm halfway to heaven now.
01:04:04
Speaker 1: You make that sound. Now it's like I want to be in the same position.
01:04:08
Speaker 3: Well, you never know.
01:04:09
Speaker 1: Yes, we do know. We're getting out of this. All right, your third one. Oh, my third.
01:04:13
Speaker 3: Okay. I'll go back to my doo-wop acapella roots. The Zircon's Lonely Way. First acapella record I ever heard over WNJR in Newark. I didn't realize it didn't have any instrumental backing. And I would also, if we're going down this particular rabbit hole, pair that with the Storm by the Vitones, which came out on Times Square Records.
01:04:43
Speaker 1: Just for... My curiosity, what is the nuggets of the acapella world? Because I too, I love oldies, but I rarely, rarely, rarely get to hear, like there's always music accompanying with it. And I always want to hear acapella groups, but I never hear them on record.
01:05:03
Speaker 3: Well, I can send you a list of some of my faves.
01:05:06
Speaker 1: Okay.
01:05:07
Speaker 3: Because the Chessmen, that's what brought me together with Patty, because I... I felt I was the only writer who actually knew this weird niche acapella thing from New York to Philadelphia put out by oldies stores. And the records are beautiful. I mean, Lonely Way by the Zircons will transform your heart. And The Storm is one of the most weird records of all time. If you start with those two, you'll at least have two. And then call me up sometime and I'll say, yo, Oh, let me get out my best of acapella volumes one through seven.
01:05:46
Speaker 1: I'm at your house already. Don't, don't, don't. Get ready to kick me out. Number four.
01:05:51
Speaker 3: Television's Marquee Moon. Okay. One of the most, you know, Tom Verlaine, still under-recognized as a genius. A perfect record made when they were actually a perfect group before the center of power really shifted toward Tom. You know, Richard Lloyd. under-recognized in what he helped Tom do. Fred Smith, may he rest in peace, you know, just a perfect bass player. And Billy Ficka, a jazz drummer, just like Jimmy had Mitch Mitchell. Billy was not like your boomer.
01:06:31
Speaker 1: Straight ahead.
01:06:31
Speaker 3: No, he was like, you know, all over the place. Perfect, perfect record.
01:06:36
Speaker 1: Your last one? Oh, God.
01:06:38
Speaker 3: Doing really good, right?
01:06:41
Speaker 1: Let me try this. The pressure forces you to tell the truth.
01:06:44
Speaker 3: Well, yeah. Truth is all when you're in the world of record obsessives.
01:06:50
Speaker 1: What can I say? All right.
01:06:53
Speaker 3: I love reggae, right? To me, that's my go-to music when I'm home. There's a record called by, it's called Dadawa. I think it's called Love and Peace. It's very rootsy. It's not even reggae so much as like tribal chants. Okay. And I don't know, when I'm there, I feel the beautiful power of my idea, I don't know if it's the real idea, of what Rastafarianism is, you know, which I can't say that I'm going to ever be Jamaican, but I just love that music so deeply. And my new rabbit hole, should you like to go down it, is Jamaican gospel, which is It seems like it's done in somebody's house. It's got like a lot of lap steel guitars. The woman you should search out is called Lucy Myers, M-Y-E-R-S. Unless, of course, you have five.
01:07:53
Speaker 1: Of her records. I probably do and don't know.
01:07:56
Speaker 3: So that's kind of like my current obsession.
01:08:01
Speaker 1: So my answer for this is it depends on the genre. My heart's in hip-hop, so the answer's always 1988. But kind of quasi-gun to your head, what is the year of music with a capital M? What is this year in music was the year and no other year? All the magic happened this year. What is that year for you?
01:08:30
Speaker 3: I always believed that in terms of the music that I've pledged allegiance to, rock and roll, partially because of my identity, my gender, my race, whatever. I believe that the mid-60s was like the Italian Renaissance. You had larger-than-life geniuses. Jimi Hendrix is Michelangelo. You know, Jeff Beck is Fra Angelica. We could keep on going like that. You know, but the amount of musical movement and expanse, I mean, I touched on a little bit of Nuggets because that's why I call it the first psychedelic era because it hadn't really happened yet. But that expanse when the music that I was a part of suddenly had all artistic musics at its disposal. All of a sudden it moved from being some teenage thing to being art. And so, you know, I would say 66, you know, because that's when it was all percolating. You know, Jimmy's getting ready. San Francisco is finding its place. You know, I mean, to watch the Grateful Dead expand music beyond melody and rhythm into the music of the spheres to align themselves with Sun Ra and meet somewhere in the middle when they got the most out there. And yeah, the tide comes back and it becomes more songs. But I like that moment when all of a sudden the expanse of the universe opens up. And, you know, I always think, you know, with Patty, that's what we try to do to, you know, we love great singles. We love Smokey Robinson. We always tried to make them. But I always liked those things we called fields, where all of a sudden you're out there in space listening to each other, trying to align the vibrations and to understand where you might go beyond music when all of a sudden you're just within each other's emotions. And I think at its best, I'm not saying it was better. I'm not nostalgic at all. I don't want music to sound like 1966 or 67. I'd hate that. I love the fact that we have so many new tools to make new music of the 21st century. But to be honest, the explosion of creativity when music was really the arrowhead of the culture when it was leading it, I mean, that to me is my magic moment.
01:11:31
Speaker 1: To compile Nuggets, great, we got to 1972 now. To compile Nuggets, how were you able to literally, because I don't even think the idea of a compilation or a soundtrack or, I mean, yeah, okay. There was Woodstock and one of those things, but this specifically, you know, and I know as a person that has to license music and all that stuff for film and TV and clear stuff for the tonight show, what is the process of finding the masters or first of all, are you using the masters? Are you using the 45s to make these compilations?
01:12:12
Speaker 3: If, uh, I mean, I had the 45s, but we could get tapes. I mean, it was so primitive, licensing. The reason Nuggets happened was because there was a lawyer named Michael Kapp, whose father was Mickey Kapp, but he was a lawyer. And Jack Colesman asked me to put together this record, gave me a couple of suggestions, which I didn't pay any attention to because I was slightly full of myself. But he only told me that he wanted things to be a little bit under the radar. He didn't want a hit thing. Nuggets, to me, was like a combination of those late night, K-Tel, you know, 20 things. Cut with Yazoo Records, Blues of Southeastern Georgia, 1927 to 1931. It was kind of this weird mashup.
01:12:58
Speaker 1: He gave it to me.
01:12:58
Speaker 3: I wrote up a list of 60 songs. some of which had nothing to do with what Nuggets, you know, I think Wayne Cochran and the CC Riders going back to Miami was on there. Great record, but, you know.
01:13:16
Speaker 1: That wouldn't have been your first choice?
01:13:19
Speaker 3: Well, I don't know. Were you responsible for all the choices made? I was the guy. I mean, Jack Holtzman gave me the keys to the kingdom. I had left Elektra by then. I was supposed to be a talent scout. He didn't want to look at anything like anything. I brought him, and I gave him the list. Six months later, they call me up and they say, we have the rights to 21 or 22 songs. What do we do with them? And I thought, it's still happening. So I filled it out. You know, I, I, I wrote the line. I just, I didn't think that we would be talking about it 50 plus years in the future. Otherwise I know I would have screwed it up. I mean, it's like, you know, that needs to be there that, you know, right.
01:14:00
Speaker 1: There's really the historical weight of what you were providing.
01:14:04
Speaker 3: He just let me do what I wanted. He, I don't even know how he did it because he could have signed all those bands. And it was funny because when they negotiated with the bands, the band said, oh, well, how about if we do our new album for Elektra?
01:14:18
Speaker 1: I was like, what?
01:14:21
Speaker 3: I mean, to me, all the records on there sound so completely different then. Now, in 50 years, I can see that they're kind of They got a theme going. They got a thing. A lot of it's not garage rock at all. You got something like Sagittarius' My World Fell Down, which is Brian Wilson-esque symphonic record. I don't know. I was just putting my favorite records in. And that, to me, is the key to Nuggets. It's not really about garage rock. It's about great records. Every one of those, if you came to my house and I said, man, listen to this slab, we would say, that's great. I mean, I was in bands, you know, in the 60s. So I was that, we didn't make any records or write any original songs, but it was kind of like my, I could sense the yearning in these bands. I always think Nuggets Beyond Music, it's about desire. It's about trying, you know, I was terrible at sports. I wasn't that great a student, but I was yearning to become. And when I put on that guitar and turned it up to... I guess I wasn't up to 11, so it was probably eight or nine. I was figuring it out. I felt like I was starting to understand myself. And I guess I translated that into Nuggets. It's a very specific thing. It's not like there weren't other musics happening. There's a million other musics. But I always think that you can go, and a lot of Nuggets is like stuff that was a medium-sized hit. It wasn't. But in the liner notes, I said, Now, you know, the archaeologists will fan out and find, you know, that group from Iowa who pressed 500 that, you know, that will be that.
01:16:06
Speaker 1: The ripple effect of.
01:16:07
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:16:08
Speaker 1: So I'll ask you, what is your greatest fear as a curator? Like that you left the wrong song off or that you perhaps canonized. An inferior song that probably couldn't get cleared or whatever. Like now that it's out, when did you realize like, oh, this shit is not just a compilation. This is a Bible and a beginning for what comes.
01:16:32
Speaker 3: It's a beginning. And the same thing I felt when I came across this series called Brown Acid, which comes out of California. They have 20 volumes now. And it's like weird. metal-ish groove, proto-metal from the early 70s. Some of it's a little deep purplish, some of it's a little Black Sabbath, some of it's a little proggy. And I saw this, I was down at that record store on 4th Street. It's no other music. That's where I first saw it. And I looked at it and I thought, oh, I never thought of this as a genre. And I feel that's what happened with Nuggets is that people picked it up and it hadn't been defined as a genre, especially in Europe where a lot of the records, they didn't know from the 13th floor elevators. They didn't know from the Cs. So it was a real revelation over there. But if you go to any genre and pick out 25 great records, not the generic ones, because I used to go out to Brooklyn in the 70s to the West Indian record shops, and I just have them play me every single. And a lot of them sounded like this single or the last single But every once in a while, Carl Malcom's No Gesturing would come on and you'd be transformed. Lloyd Park's Mia Mafia. Just great, great songs. And I accumulated them. So if I wanted to do a Reggae Nuggets, which I've always wanted to do, of that kind of mid-70s, not quite R & B, not quite yet toasters, I got like 25 records, which will blow anybody's mind, even if they're you know, classic reggae. You can do that with any genre, you know. You can do it with hair metal. I think it's a great, at least 10 years ago, it was a great time for female pop singers. You know, I just think you could do that. I mean, maybe it's hip, maybe it's not. But when I hear Katy Perry's roar, that window goes down and I'm going, yeah.
01:18:38
Speaker 1: You're buying what she's selling.
01:18:39
Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, I'm just like, you know, it's a great record. It's not that deep. It's probably too smart for its own good. It's probably some producer manipulating whatever. But it gets to me.
01:18:51
Speaker 1: You know what? I have a different relationship with pop music now. I mean, I did subscribe to that school that you had to, like, I went to school with one guy who's forcing Beefheart, in my left ear and then one guy that's forcing like this particular charlie parker solo is is important for history and and i thought i had to be that person like you know better than thou and you know you minions you like that sort of thing but then i realized my dad one of the things that um my dad sort of instilled in me as far as wisdom is concerned, whenever it was time to hire a new musician. And this is the nightclub phase of his show. We're not in the doo-wop phase. So there's my dad's doo-wop songs. And then there's like these intricate, my mom's part of the show as well. So these intricate songs with these changes and all that stuff. So naturally I'm thinking that, okay, let's take the song that has the most changes Let me see, 78. Okay, great example. I know it's a joke of a song. Maybe it's not. But if you remember the original version of MacArthur's Park, non-Donna Summer version, there's a lot of intricate changes and time signature stuff in there. So easily, I'm like, Dad, this is the cannon jump that they have to master. Let's do that. He says, nope. He says, give them the easiest song ever. what is my dad's ballads? You know what I mean? So now we're doing like teardrops and I'm like, well, this is just a one, four, five, like there's, and he's like, a musician will reveal everything about themselves. Hey, yeah. If you give them the most simplest shit ever, he said, I'll know instantly. If, if you do what's required for the song, I know if you're a good musician and sure enough, right. They would try to fill in the spaces and overcompensate and, True that. And wow. And then that's like what I learned. First of all, I want you to be a mainstay on this platform only because I didn't even start the actual interview portion.
01:21:15
Speaker 3: I'll be back.
01:21:16
Speaker 1: I'll say 70% of this is just me engaging with you. We're having a good time. But I know people will kick my ass if I don't go further up the scale. So with the little time that we have left, I do want to ask just some specific questions just to scratch my itch. A lot of your fan base will probably know this story, but for the benefit of those that are on this platform that might not know, can you describe how you met Patti Smith and how you two connected?
01:21:47
Speaker 3: We met when I wrote The Best of Acapella for Jazz and Pop. I had seen her around the New York scene. Max is hanging out with Robert Mapplethorpe. I went to see her in a Jackie Curtis play called Femme Fatale, where she played a speed freak. I had a crush on her immediately. I remember watching her and Robert at Ratner's, the Jewish dairy restaurant next to the Phil Maurice. He's in a fur vest. She was just cool. I didn't meet her. Then after that article came out, she called me up. I was staying at Richard and Lisa Robinson's because I didn't have an apartment.
01:22:26
Speaker 1: How expansive is that record collection? Once a month, Lisa will hit me up and be like, yo, take these records off my, and I don't have the time to go there.
01:22:36
Speaker 3: They have multiples. She has multiples. Richard, you know.
01:22:40
Speaker 1: Lisa, I love you. We got to get Lisa Robinson on the show, by the way. So good.
01:22:43
Speaker 3: Anyway, so she calls me up, just a little voice. Hi, hi, it's Patty. Steve Paul gave me the number. I really liked that article. I said, oh, that's really sweet. Because it reminded her of growing up in Philly. And we shared some of the same music, aside from the Jerry Blavitt adoration. Maureen Gray's Today's the Day. The Blue Notes. I mean, just the greatest music. So she would come into the record store where I was working. our village oldies, and I'd put on our favorite records, and sometimes we'd do the Bristol Stomp. And one day she came in and she says, I want to shake up this poetry reading I'm doing at St. Mark's, February 10th, 1971. I heard you play a little guitar. I said, well, I play a little guitar. And she said, would you back me up on a couple poems? So I went over to the loft where she was staying with Robert on 23rd Street over the Oasis Bar. And she read me her poems, and I just played some simple, you know, I watched how she breathed. Essentially, that's all I've ever done over the 50 years we've been together, just try to, you know, watch how the words form and be there. And, you know, I just played like, you know, He'd have dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum-dum, you know, and then finally at the end we did a car crash at the last song, and it went over pretty well, but it wasn't supposed to be a thing. You know, we didn't perform together again until November of 73 when she called me up again, and I'd go see her perform, play, you know, and she said, I'm doing a reading at Les Jardins over at the Hotel Diplomate. Do you want to come up and do our three songs again? I said, sure. So I went up there. Instead of Mack the Knife, we did Annie Had a Baby for our cover. And same two other songs. And then she got a little gig at the West End Cafe up by Columbia. She asked me to come up, and I played the three songs. And then she got a gig opening Phil Oakes at Max's over the holidays. And that's when I was on stage the whole time. And we had a succession of piano players. But like you said about somebody playing the most simple thing, we finally found Richard Soule, who was a consummate piano player. When he came to his audition, he said, what do you want, Rachmaninoff? But when he just needed to sit behind those three chords of Gloria, man, he just did that. He did not.
01:25:30
Speaker 1: Very intense playing.
01:25:32
Speaker 3: Yeah. I mean, he understood how to... I think it's accompanying.
01:25:38
Speaker 1: That's the word.
01:25:39
Speaker 3: To be a true accompanist. And without him, there would have not been a band. And we were a trio for a while until we started to need more and need more. And finally, by the spring of 1975, we actually added a drummer and became a real band. But that long evolution... where we didn't try to force it. I thought, we're gonna have a rock and roll band. No, we didn't know what the heck we were doing. So it grew organically until when we had all the components, we sounded like ourselves.
01:26:13
Speaker 1: Okay, second to the last question. Okay. You know, the elementary school I went to, fame schools or performing arts schools are the norm now, but in the 70s, it was like a new thing or whatever. And so this is really like when it's just a mishmash of every type of student. And I'm in a school with literally from first grade to senior year at college. So on, you know, on this campus, there's a high school and elementary school and college students. And so kind of the real education is just being in the atmosphere and, you know, you're on the third floor and, you know, damn eighth graders are trying to learn smoke on the water or whatever. But one song I always wanted to know, I mean, and you remember how you said earlier, like there might be some songs that, you know, like the back of your hand that you yourself might not have purchased or whatever, but you've heard it so many times. Oh yeah. Just for me, I want you to tell me souped nuts, the story of piss factory. the song that I don't know what it was about. This is, I believe these were, um, the seniors, like every day at lunch, the seniors always had like run a run of the land during lunch. Lunch was the one time in which everyone from first grade to we all shared this large ass like cafeteria. And there will also be like workstations for bands to jam out. So, You know, they get tired of playing that run in, you know, Freebird, like 20 minutes or whatever. But tell me the story of Piss Factory.
01:28:00
Speaker 3: That's amazing. Piss Factory started out as a poem of Patty's. It's obviously her sense of discovery and wanting to get out of a really shitty factory job inspecting baby bumpers. And one time the women there, caught her reading, I believe, a book of Rimbaud and thought she was uppity and took her in the bathroom and tried to put her head into the toilet. It's all there in the story. Anyway, she did it as a poem and we started doing a little musical accompaniment to it. I think the chords... have some resemblance to Steely Dan's.
01:28:43
Speaker 1: Back, do it again, do it again.
01:28:46
Speaker 3: Anyway, we would just do it. Richard would play it, and I'd doodle around. We booked three hours at Electric Lady in June of 74, June 5th, as a matter of fact. I mean, we knew we had an effect on an audience, but how do you put that on a record? No idea. So Robert Mapplethorpe gave us enough money for three hours in Studio B in the back of Electric Lady. And we went there and we recorded The A-Side, which was a version of Hey Joe centered around. At that point, the opening poem was about Patty Hearst. And Tom Verlaine came down and added some lead guitar. And I actually put the first percussion on one of our record. I went out and put a bass drum going, you know, like bump, bump, which I had to discuss with Patty because it was so radical. And we had 15 minutes left over. So what are we going to do?
01:29:46
Speaker 1: All the magical songs happen when time is ticking on the clock.
01:29:49
Speaker 3: So, you know, hey, let's do Piss Factory. You know, like three full starts. one we actually completed, and then another false start, and then the version that's on the record, which is a true example of what we were like as, I guess, a power trio. Richard is comping away. I'm just playing the, you know, and Patti's really reciting that poem as if she means it, and she does, because I've never seen Patti sing a false note in my life. She's there. She's not putting on a show. She's not anything. And in that 15 minutes, we made the B-side of Mayer 601, which I then took to Philadelphia and pressed up in an edition of 1,500 copies. They gave me recycled vinyl because if you look at the edge of the first pressing, it's gray. you know, and of course it's got a very nice logo on it. It's got the little swan. I'm sold.
01:30:54
Speaker 1: I'm sold.
01:30:55
Speaker 3: So anyway, that's, that's how Piss Factory happened in a beautiful moment in time. All right.
01:31:00
Speaker 1: I want to do you a solid, like in my mind, when we first started this, I was like, okay, we're going to go through this whole entire life or whatever. And then I told you before, if you guys are wondering, I'd, Pretty much said, I'm going to do a selfish act and just really interview him as the record connoisseur. And then there's the journalist side of him and just the music fan side of him, but then also the artist. I had so many questions about you as a producer, like what is it like to deal with Todd and Soul Asylum and all your clients. As far as going local is concerned, why did it take so long for you to finally get to a place where it's like, I don't want to be on the left side of someone and really just put my, how hard was it to put yourself in the center?
01:31:44
Speaker 3: It was actually remarkably easy. Uh, I mean, I, I'm, I've been very busy and sometimes you take that creative energy and you put it toward the artist you produce or with Patty, you write a song and you take it to her or you're writing a book and books are intense. I mean, all three of my books took years and, uh, You know, you always, the priority is the last. And plus, I didn't have a record company like saying, hey, come on, let's do something. You know, so I had to do it myself. The key to it, I really was finding a studio eight minutes drive from my house in Pennsylvania with a really good engineer with really good equipment that was pretty inexpensive. And I just decided I have these songs. I'm going to go and get some artistic closure, essentially. I got encouragement from Yep Rock, which was a beautiful thing. But to be honest, I couldn't have done this record 10, 15, 20 years ago. I needed the weight of who I've been to move forward into who I'm becoming, I guess. Again, this doesn't sound a lot like what I'm associated with. A lot of it's very personal, vulnerable, hard on a sleeve, simple. I didn't want a bunch of guest stars. I got some great people on there. Matthew Shipp played piano on one of the tracks. John Jackson, David Mansfield arranged the track my uncle wrote lyrics for. But really, I just wanted to keep it modest, who I am. I mean, this is who I am as a human being, really. And as a musician, I don't have any grand ideas on my place in the world. I love when people buy me a beer for whatever I've done. But on the other hand, I just really did this record for myself. I don't particularly understand the music business these days, how records get out there. I'm not expecting a hit single. I'm not expecting anything except the pleasure of doing my work. And that's a blessing, let's be honest.
01:34:02
Speaker 1: Man. You know, we've been in rooms together outside of what I call the room where it happens at Rock and Roll Hall of Fame when it's like 40 angry humans all at war to not nerd out or when you're there. It was a hard thing, but I'm glad we got.
01:34:20
Speaker 3: To see it. You can nerd out at me anytime. I'm quite nerdable.
01:34:23
Speaker 1: Well, thank you very much. Thank you. Lenny K.
01:34:26
Speaker 3: It's a real pleasure, Questlove.
01:34:27
Speaker 1: Thank you so much. This is the Questlove Show, and we'll see you on the next Go Round. Thank you. The Questlove Show is hosted by me, Amir Questlove Thompson. The executive producers are Sean G., Brian Calhoun, and me. Produced by Brittany Benjamin and Jake Payne. Produced for iHeart by Noel Brown. Edited by Alex Conroy. iHeart video support by Mark Canton. Logos, graphics, and animation by Nick Aloi. Additional support by Lance Coleman. Special thanks to Kathy Braun. Special thanks to Sugar Steve Mandel. Please subscribe, rate, review, and share The Questlove Show wherever you stream your podcasts. Make sure you follow us on socials. That's at QLS. Check out hundreds and hundreds of QLS episodes, including... The Questlove Supreme shows in our podcast archives. The Questlove Show is a production of iHeart Radio.
iHeartRadio
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
TuneIn
Castro