Reviews

Rate Show
In My Top Five
From the first time I heard Erica, SFTC leaped into my top 5 favorite podcasts. Her soothing, storytelling voice is so suited to the cases she covers. Her research is thorough and I always look forward to new episodes. She has thoughtful and compelling insights. Keep up the great work! Take care now 😉
Love it!
Love hearing Erica’s voice and her love of/ understanding of southern culture. She doesn’t sugar coat anything and I really like hearing her take on things, even if I disagree with a small point from time to time. Anyway, just wanted to say I’ve listened to every episode and you all are doing a great job!
My Favorite Podcast
Compassionate, intelligent, authentic, and nuanced. Erica captures the very southern practice of simultaneously seeing both sides of each coin. It is scripted, which demonstrates preparation and solid research, something I strongly prefer to listening to some podcasters who natter on. This is an excellent podcast for anyone who is interested in the “why” of criminal acts rather than the gory details. Erica digs into family dynamics and personal histories and presents a wholistic picture of each of the characters. Additionally, she always includes an informative narrative about the history of the locales. The south has such a remarkable history and, even though I’ve lived here all of my life, I continue to be delighted by the variety of cultures across our region. I look forward to each new episode and tend to gobble it up a little too quickly. But, the good news is that each episode is as interesting when I revisit them. I often go back and re-listen to older episodes and sometimes find that I actually pick up more information the second or third time around. I can’t recommend this highly enough.
My Absolute Favorite Poscast
I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts and this one is hands down my favorite. Erica is so thorough and unbiased in telling these sad stories. Highly recommend!
I love this podcast!!!
Great true crime stories, & the host’s voice & accent are incredibly soothing (I know that sounds odd since she’s discussing sometimes gruesome murders!). As a Memphian, I love her references to Tennessee & her stories about murders in our state.
Insightful
I really enjoy how Erica researches the regions to add context and history to settings of some of these cases. It really helps set the scene and aids her awesome way of telling the stories of the cases she covers.
Great storyteller
On the edge of my seat, easy to follow, respectful to victims. No banter, all good storytelling!
The best storyteller
This is my favorite podcast to get stuff done to. I get so into the story I forget I’m working. I wish there were more episodes released each week.
Best Podcast of the South
Great Podcast! As always, I can’t wait for the next episode! Thanks Erica, keep up the great work!
One of my top 3
This is an amazing podcast! When anyone asks for suggestions this is one of the true crime ones I always suggest! Erica’s voice gives me southern summertime vibes on those slow hot days!
Best Ever.
My favorite true crime podcast for many reasons. Erica does an amazing job and is a natural storyteller.
Love this podcast
Love listening and replaying this podcast!
Great show!!
Love this show. Erica is so easy to listen to.
Best True Crime Podcast!
I love this podcast and it’s creator/narrator.
Love this podcast
Nice sweet voice. A lot of work found into research and info I couldn’t find on my own!
Great podcast
Just listened to my first episode, Jennifer Hyatte. Will definitely be back for more!
SFTC
The podcast is great and well researched. Erica Kelly is a GEM!!! This in in my top 3 of podcast faves.
Absolutely the BEST
I LOVE this podcast! Awesome storyteller and so thorough on facts and research! Tells you the whole story while keeping you engaged, wanting more! A 5++++ for sure!
Excellent podcast
Love this podcast! It’s clear that Erica puts in the effort in her research. She definitely has southern storytelling gene, and I love her point of view and how respectful she is of the people in her stories. It’s apparent she tries to see the good in everyone.
Such a great show!
I absolutely love this show! Erica does a superb job explaining the ins and outs of the crimes she’s chronicling and makes all the participants (victims, the guilty, and law enforcement) all human and not just names in the page. Add to that the Southern twang and sense of humor and it is absolutely the most enjoyable time when I’m listening in my car. Keep up the good work Erica!
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Love this podcast ! Love Erica and the information her and her team dig deep to inform the listener on each episode! This is one of my favorites and will continue to listen. Keep up the amazing work as always ❤️❤️❤️
Outstanding
I listen to this podcast so often that Erica’s voice is a comfort for me when I am feeling anxious, especially as I progress through my pregnancy. Erica, Haley and the others who work on this podcast put in an unmatched effort getting the facts of each story straight, and tell each story with respect for the victims and their families. As a native daughter of the South, I like being able to hear about events that took place right in my metaphorical backyard, and it’s a bonus to learn more about the geographic location as Erica sets the scene for each true crime story. I also like that listeners can suggest cases and that Erica takes those suggestions into consideration! Thank you Erica & Co for your efforts and keep up the good work!
True Crime Done Right
Erica Kelly does it right! She tells the story in a meaningful and respectful way. We learn the background of the offender and the victim to humanize them outside of the crime. She sets the stage where most podcasts demonize the offenders with bias. Erica states well-researched facts and provides listeners the full picture of the area and of those involved. She sprinkles in side notes of opinion and I often find myself saying the same thing! Erica has a smooth, smoky, Southern voice that lulls me into the world she is describing, where you can almost feel the stickiness of the humidity on your skin. I listen to a lot of podcasts, but I will always come back to Erica!
One of my top favorites!
Erica not only had the most soothing voices in the podcast world she also has the most compassion. From her careful and accurate explanation of a city’s history to a the history of a the perpetrators to the devastation left behind by the loss of the victims, Erica gives them all compassion and a voice.