Sept. 8, 2022

Introducing: Psychoanalyzing the Patient

Introducing: Psychoanalyzing the Patient
Introducing: Psychoanalyzing the Patient
The SH*T That Happens To Me
Introducing: Psychoanalyzing the Patient

New show alert!
On Psychoanalyzing The Patient Podcast, we’ll take a peek behind the scenes, talking to the cast and crew about what it was like to create these darkly complicated characters. We’ll also play armchair psychologists, talking to experts...

New show alert!
On Psychoanalyzing The Patient Podcast, we’ll take a peek behind the scenes, talking to the cast and crew about what it was like to create these darkly complicated characters. We’ll also play armchair psychologists, talking to experts in the field of psychology, uncovering the themes and motivations of the characters, speculating about their past, and plotting their fate.
Welcome to the first episode of Psychoanalyzing the Patient! Our hosts (Stacey Nye & Lindsay Jones) welcome Dr. Frank Summers to the show.

New Podcast Up Here Click the link to Listen:
Straw Hut Media Up Here Podcast

From Straw Hut Media

0:01 Straut Media. Hi, and welcome to Psychoanalyzing the Patient podcast. Join me Stacy Nye and me Lindsay Jones as we try to uncover each character's dynamics by talking to experts in the field of psychology as well as members of the cast and crew. So don't be late. Our session begins now. All right, we're going to talk about the first episode of The Patient. But before we talk about the first episode of The Patient, we have to say we're literally about to tell you the entire episode. So if you, for some reason have not watched the first episode of The Patient yet, please stop this podcast right now and go watch it on Hulu and then come back and hit play so that we will not have spoiled any of it for you. You have been warned. It opens on Alan, who is a therapist played by Steve Carrell. He wakes up in a dimly lit bas and discovers that his ankle is chained to a bed. He tries to get free, he can't figure out where he is. He's yelling for help. No one responds, and while worth with him, we start to flash back on his life.

1:12 He's a therapist, he sees patients, he has a new patient that has recently come into his practice, Gene played by Domhall Gleason, who's sort of like this generally looking guy who seems like he has problems. He won't take off his sunglasses, he's kind of uncooperative as a patient goes. He says that his dad beat him up a lot as a kid, but we can't really seem to get to what's going on with Jean, so eventually Alan sort of tries to inspire Jean to sort of be more forthcoming, and that doesn't really seem to work out all that well. Meanwhile, we learn more about Alan. We realize through his interaction with his patients that his wife has recently died. We also see him briefly interact with his son and doesn't seem like it's going very well, and for the most part, Alan lives a very solitary life as a therapist by himself. Where we go back to the basement and we discover that in fact, Jean has locked him up in this basement and that he has locked him up there and tells him first of all that his real name is not Gene, it is Sam. But in fact, in addition to that being a big secret. The real secret is is that Sam is in fact a serial killer, and he believes that he needs to have help for his problems, and so he took Alan's advice to really confront the problem head on by kidnapping Alan, bringing him to the basement, and

2:46 forcing him to provide therapy for him in the hopes that Alan can somehow make him feel better. We also find out that he wanted specifically a Jewish therapist. He looked for the three jew therapists and he could find and he thought Alan was the best one, and that's why he's here, and that is how we end the first episode of The Patient. So that was a remarkable moment for me when he says, you know, I met with three different Jewish therapists and I chose you, And then he smiles like he's real proud of himself, and Steve Carrell's face is like, oh what, you know, because he's already locked up at this point, you know, like, oh no, I don't feel too good about that. You know, like it was essentially a compliment, but you know, like not the kind of compliment anyone wants, right, No, no, no one ever wants to feel like you're the right person for me to kidnap and put in a basement right right there. There was also there were a couple of interesting things that happened that I just wanted to, you know, chat about too. So there was this um dream that Alan has right where he wakes up and um, well you don't know it's a dream at first. He wakes up and his wife is lying next to him and she's holding her guitar, and then you hear this baby crying in the distance, and he goes to check on the baby, and that baby's got this like monster face. That was like

4:21 totally creepy. So what do you think that means? Any thoughts about that? No idea? No, I mean I really don't. Like I was just grappling with the part where I feel he's so traumatized for being in this situation that he has no control over that. Who knows what the dreams mean at this point. The other thing that I thought was interesting was just like his kind of quiet life right Like he's flossing his teeth. He seems like it does a good job flossing his teeth and you know, making himself food and cutting up his fruit and putting like foot cream on like like that's kind of I don't know. I was just wondering about that, Like, what did you think about that, Lindsay. I mean, it definitely reinforces the part where he is alone and lonely, and definitely seems like in a way he has kind of retreated from himself a little bit. He seems definitely like his entire demeanor feels very heavy, as if he is really holding a lot of stuff in about himself, and he doesn't seem to be at ease with anything. He's just looks like he's kind of going through the motions a little bit. I have one other thing to add because I was telling talking to my friend Stephie. Here's a shout out to my friend Stephie. I watch all these shows with anyway. She sent me a text yesterday that said something

5:56 like I kind of hate it when they make the serial killer kind of attractive. And I just like burst out laughing when I read that, Like, Okay, like, I guess we're not supposed to be attracted to the serial killer, but um, you know, and and I and I texted you yesterday and I said, wait, this Dominal Gleason is you know, played one of the Weasley Twins in all the Harry Potter films, and um, he's Brendan Gleason's son, so he's really, you know, um, quite well known. Of course Steve Carrell is um so well known. Um, so it's gonna be a great show. Yeah, you wouldn't know that he wasn't American from the show, right, He's got no trace of his Irish accent at all, none at all nothing. So what do you think is going to happen next? I mean, we know we watched the second episode right away, but where do you think it's gonna go. Do you think he's gonna cure him? I don't know. I mean, I don't know, can you cure him? What does it cure? Mean? What is that? What is that? I don't even know there's I mean, on the one hand, you're like kind of rooting for Steve Garrel just to get free, but then you're like, what happens if he guests free? Like how do we get out of this? So yeah, I don't know.

7:23 I have to say I'm really worried for him. Yeah, I think that's a good question, because like how can this possibly end? You know, like, he's not gonna I'm gonna tell you right now, he's not going to cure him in ten sessions, and so someone has to die. That's my prediction. Someone has to die, and it's either going to be Alan or Sam. All right, well, it sounds like we need an expert here, Stacy, who is our guest this week? Doctor Frank Summers is a training and supervising analyst at the Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis. He has authored several books and has published widely in psychoanalytic journals. He holds several honors and distinctions for numerous distinguished professional organizations around the country, including the Professor of Clinical Psychiatry and the Behavioral Sciences at Feinberg School of Medicine at Northwestern University, where he was my clinical supervisor. One of the things I'm going to say that I do want to say, just to kind of lead in here, is because I know that you know that you were my supervisor in graduate school.

8:33 And I don't know if you know this, you probably do, but you know you were a little intimidating back then, you know, a few years ago that was Do you know that that you were a little intimidating back then? Frank I have heard that, said, yes, have you heard that? Okay, I never experienced myself that way, never quite believed it. But you're not the first person to tell me that. So yeah, okay, well, but I'm so glad that you know, um, we're on the other side of that now and I we can just be colleagues. So so I'm just gonna say, welcome, Frank, how are you. I'm just fine, thank you, and thank you so much for having me in the show and inviting me. I'm really looking forward to this. Thanks for being here. I'm totally not intimidated by you. There's no reason to be.

9:24 Okay, good, my children aren't. I don't know anyone else, shit be I have a similar relationship with my children. So I thought of you, Frank when UM we came up with this idea to UM do a podcast on this show, because I thought, who what, what psychologist? What I most want to talk to about? How how the psychologist is you know, UM played here and the patient and the whole process. So so I'm really excited and I'm just gonna say, like, what do you think of the show? So are you watched the first episode? Yeah? I did. It was actually I watched the first two as I was the second one also but sneak the head. But I really liked it. I thought it was very creative. The idea is very creative. I think there are some, as you'll see, I think some flaws in it, but I think that a concept is creative. I think it's very dramatic. I think it's fascinating the interaction between the two characters. Whoever thought of the idea I think deserves a lot of credit for coming up with a real thoughtful, creative way to kind of get two people to interact Tom in ways that they would not ever have been able to do in any other context. I don't think you know so um so I like to show it to kind of show that potenty in and I probably will watch all the episodes. Oh good, good, thank you. How it comes out, I have to say, watching it right away, the first thing that really occurred to me was just like

10:58 what a daily life of a therapist is like that? Like that when they it's flashes back to his life at the big you know, before before the scenario begins, and you're sort of seeing this sort of like collage of patience, this montage of patients, that go by. And this is probably because um, I'm not a therapist at all, and I only understand therapy from being a patient, which is basically, I walk into the office and I talk all about myself and then I leave and I think, wow, that must have been really interesting for the person who had to sit there with me. But that actually it is like this sort of montage of people who are coming in with their their things. Does it feel like that when you're a therapist? Does it feel like you're just like in a wash of people and there and their problems and it starts to all blend together like that? Is that? Is that how it is? And well everything I would say yes up until when you say they blend together, And to me, people don't blod together so much. But the montage of people coming in, that's what's fascinating about it. That's what I love about it. Everybody's different. One thing you learn right away as a psychotherapist, and I think I conveyed this to Stacy would Choose my student alone many years ago, is that you first you realize that everybody's different, and everybody assumes the way they are is the way the world is. Everyone assumes, well, of course this is how it is, because that's how they were brought up. That's all they know, right. But it's totally different from the next person who walks in, who says, well, of course this is how it is, and it's

12:30 totally different, right, because whatever your experience was, that's how you just think the world is. That's how you think a family is. If you were beaten up, you think every kid gets beaten up. If you were treated with kid gloves and in a sensitivity, you assume that that's how all parents are. And so that's one of the fascinating things about it. My impression, Frank from this the therapy that Alan is doing. It looks to me like he's doing some psychodynamic psycho therapy, so he's not doing analysis. But um, I loved the comment he makes to who he thinks is Gene at the time about Gene not opening up and how he feels a little frustrated, and so he wonders if Gene feels that way too. He was using his counter transference to get, you know, to make a like an interpretation and get Gene to kind of open up. What did you think about that?

13:30 That's interesting because I had a different take on it. I didn't like it, really, I, oh, you didn't like it. I didn't like it because I felt he was angling to get rid of the guy. That's how it sounded to me. Like he was saying, Wow, you know, look, let's face it, this isn't working. You know, you're not opening up. This is not working. I feel frustrated. You feel frustrated. You know. Now the patient didn't let it get there, But I thought the next thing I expected out of his mouth was saying, you know, maybe this just asn't working. That's how it sounded to me. But what I didn't like about it is that to me, it sounded too much like blaming the patient. You know, it's like we're not getting anywhere and it's your fault because you're not opening up, And that I don't think is helpful to people. What I would have said, and I wouldn't have said all that at one time like you did, because I don't believe you should talk that much at one time because the patient is too much to respond to. But I could see myself saying to this guy something like, you know, I noticed that every time we start to get to something that feels that all emotional, you deflect if you notice that yourself, you know, this is in the context of moving the process forward, not that you're frustrating me or you make it difficulty, you know, because if you were not getting anywhere, it's like, have you noticed that, because that's part of the process. I have never had a patient who didn't defend against their feelings ever, Ever, salthiest the sickett You know, everybody wants to get better, but nobody wants to change, right, Well, I do think

15:01 that. Actually Jean didn't take it well, and you know, says something like, well, maybe I'm not cut out for this, and then basically kidnaps the therapist, so well, maybe they'll work better here, So you you know, it's I think you're right about the whole thing. So when he said, you know, maybe I'm that could out for this, this is the kind of thing you would expect commentation when most patients would say something like that. So you're telling me I'm let a good candidate for psychotherapy. You're telling me I can't be helped. That's how post patients would react to it. And you can sort of tell that he's agitated, even though you can't necessarily understand why he's agitated like that that clearly hasn't been there. And I guess this is probably my number one question as a non therapist, which is probably an incredibly stupid question. But what is the difference? Can you assess the difference between a person who has actual difficulties versus a person that's just really annoyed? You know what I mean? Like, this is just like an annoying person versus like a person who actually is is struggling with something like that, they have a personality that is um aggressive or is is difficult versus Okay, I can see they're actually they're actually dealing with something. How do you how do you assess that? Well, tell me what you mean by annoying person? I mean, what's just an annoying person? Like a person who is just let's say, naturally defensive or naturally um uh, just not

16:34 terribly outgoing. They're not very they don't like to share their feelings. There that their personality is such that they um, they are not it's not a natural conversation. You feel like you have to drag information out of them U Versus a person who you can tell is reticent because they are hesitant to share. In this case, they're hesitant to share that in fact, they have a compulsion to kill people. But I'm assuming that's not usually how it always goes that, But that people that you feel like they're you're sort of looking for the secret of that person, and you're trying to determine whether that person's holding out because they're afflicted in some way or just they don't want to share it with you. Yeah, yeah, I see what you mean. Well, the person you're calling just annoying person is basically you're what you're describing as a defensive structure. Okay, they're characterologically defensive, is what you're saying.

17:34 That There isn't there isn't such a clear distinction between those two as you think there is. Okay, somebody who's just like you say, they're characterologically overaggressive, or they're they ascend people or whatever. They're defensive, but their defenses are much more difficult to do with because they're characterologically defending. Okay. The other kind of person also uses their defenses, but they use them in a more circumscribed way. Okay, that's what you're talking about to protect themselves against something then, and want of other people to know about it, or they're afraid about it themselves. The other person is too, but it's just characterological. It's what they do. What they're defending against is basically a weakness in the sense of self. Okay, so the difference between the two isn't that one is just annoying the differences. They're both defensive, they're both pathological, but one is characterologically passed pathological and takes a lot longer to do with and sometimes it is very difficult to do. The usually is very difficult to do.

18:34 That's actually really helpful. Thank you that that really illuminates that for me. Yeah, I had another question about this show that I found really sort of unusual, which is that in the practice of Alan Steverell's character, he appears to be seeing patients in his home and that seems I mean, obviously in this show it illustrates why that might be a bad idea, which is that patients can come back and find you at home. But is that something that happens that often? And is that actually a good idea? Like, it doesn't seem like it's a good idea. That's a really really good question.

19:15 It's nothing I would ever do, but some people do do it. It does happen. It's realistic, especially in New York. It is geographically, it's a geographical question. Chicago, I don't know that. I know a few people who have an office, a regular office downtown and then they have a part of their home that's sectioned off with a private entrance. Okay, and so yeah, it's their house, but the person never sees their house. They know where they live, but the consulting room is separated off it as a private entrance and exit, so they really aren't part of the living space. I don't like it. It's not something I would ever be comfortable with. Okay, I've never done that. I've always kept it too completely be separate in New York, and this is something I've never seen in Chicago. I have colleagues and good college smart people who use their living room as their consoling room. I mean, people just come in and you know it's because New York. If you know what New York rental prices are, like, they save themselves a lot of money. I mean, it's ridiculous.

20:22 People pay thousands of dollars for these little closet spaces, you know, to see patients. So this is what people do, but I could never feel comfortable that way because I feel like it's too much of a boundary blurring between my private life and my professional life. And I really believe in keeping those two things separate. I think that the most professional way to help to deal with patients is to have a separate space, separate place. They don't know where I live. They can find out, maybe, but I'm not going to tell them, you know, and to keep them things separate so that it's very clear what we're about. We're about helping them. We're about a professional relationship or professional contract. We're not about forming a personal relationship.

21:11 Although ironically, if you really works well, sometimes the relationship that develops with compatient and analysts is about as close a relationship as you can have because it's so intimate the material that you discuss and who you're telling it to. And very frequently patients tell me things or any therapist, things that they never tell anybody else, often not even their spouts, okay, and so in that way, it's very intimate. But for that very reason, it's important that it be kept separate from my private life. Okay, they can tell me that because they know it's progly on a professional basis, okay, and they know I'm not going to anything they tell me stays within our relationship. I know no one else is going to find out. And people will ask.

21:56 I'll often say, now, what if I tell you this? If I tell you that you know? And I've had some people who you know, are public figures, you know, and they're particularly concerned about their privacy, you know, And it's important that they trust me to know that no one will ever know that they see me. I mean, you know, an occasion I get the phone calls, people will say, um, I just want to talk to you about my friend. I think it's important important information. First thing I say is anything you tell me, I will tell the patient. Don't tell me anything you don't want me to tell them, okay, And that usually shortens the conversation a great deal, you know. But it's important that my patient know that anything I hear from anybody else, they will hear, and I will only listen. I'm not going to tell them.

22:45 Have either of you ever googled a patient? Like? Do you ever do that? In reverse? Where you're like, you get a new person and you think, oh, I should learn more about them I've never done that, and I never would to do that, And I'll tell you why. I don't even like to get information. Like sometimes I get a referral and someone says, well, let me tell you about the patient. I said, just tell me who it is, tell me what they're looking for. That's all I want to know, because I want to hear it from the patient. I don't want to get it on Google. I don't want to hear it from their relatives. I don't want to hear from another therapist anything. I want everything as much as possible that I know about the patient to come from the patient, and I want to be able to respond to it as though it's coming from the patient. They start getting things from external sources, what am I going to do with it? If I bring it in, I'm bringing in something that patient didn't bring into me, right, I'm introducing into their analysis or therapy, which something I don't ever right to do, right. And if I don't bring it in, I'm sitting at it. I'm holding the secret from the patient. I don't keep secrets from my patients, right, So I don't want to hear stuff, you know, And I'm never with Google anybody you know, I can imagine the circumstance who I might look at. I was really concerned that somebody was a serial killer or something like that. Maybe then you know where I think there's a crime that could be committed for something, but fortunately that hasn't happened. It's like I've done it. It's actually like an ethical it's an ethical violation, you know to do that. So oh okay, yeah, um, I also wanted to ask. Okay, So at the end of the episode,

24:18 we learn that, um, that Geane whose real name is sam Um, that he has a compulsion to kill people and he's he's interested in stopping and obviously that's a major revelation. And um, when you're in a therapy session where something massive like that is sort of dropped in the session, is that a place where you're like, Okay, I need to I need to completely rethink how I've been dealing with this person up to this point, or is it like you is it usually is there sometimes when you're in a session and suddenly, like a big piece of information will just be revealed and suddenly it's like, Okay, I've got to completely start over because what I thought was going on is not what's going on at all? Here. You have a way of asking the best questions, you know. I really loved the righteous one of the most interesting parts about the therapy and analysis. Yes there are cases. I haven't had it too often, but I've had on occasion.

25:29 I've had times not as dramatic as somebody telling me they're a serial killer, but revelations because they wanted to wait, you know, until they really trusted me, although I didn't know this until they reveal something. Often it's that they're gay. Okay. Some people will hide that, you know, for a long time. Not as frequently now, but over the years I've definitely had that, you know, and after a year they'll say, yeah, actually, the real reason I came was because I was afraid I was gay. They never said before. Okay, wow, and um, you know, now I start thinking everything differently. I started thinking about, oh, that's the reason they came, so the presumed reason was which not the reason? So I have to rethink that, you know, that was just a camouflage, right, and why are they so fearful of acknowledging that their case?

26:15 So that happens. I had one um a really interesting case which actually wrote up in a paper, a professional paper that was published. Um, it's a woman who was its waspy looking as you'll ever find, you know, blonde, very skin you know, very nice, sweet young lady. And she said that her parents were from Argentina, but she was born here Okay, and every summer they would go to Argentina for summer vacation, and that was a certain part of her life was involved in that. Now, I've been Argentina a couple of times, I happened to love when society.

26:56 In fact, my wife and I actually expect thought about retiring there when point. So it's not going to happen. And so when she said Argentina, I heard Buena side, so I just assumed that every summer she had been to Buenoscaids. So somehow we have we had obsession in which I said something about Buenocieds and she said, oh, I've never been to Buenacidees. And it completely changed the whole case because where they had one was this remote rural area, Okay. And the remote rural area was where her parents were from and where she had spent her summers, and it was a completely different culture from the one I assumed that she had been exposed to and Buenosiees and explained a lot of things to me about her okay, and unexplained things that I was wrong about. Okay. So I had to rethink a lot of things because the culture of Buenciedes is so different from where she was. Was like two different countries, okay, And so what you've been exposed to, the influences on her were totally different. And I felt totally embarrassed, you know, that had made this assumption, okay, Um, and I had as I sat there and she's telling you this, I'm rethinking the whole therapy and her whole background and what influences were hunter and it quite frankly was embarrassing, but um very revealing. So yeah, sometimes that that happens, and that's exactly what you have to do. You have to rethink the whole kids somebody told me they were a serial killer, I would rethink everything I heard from this person, everything, Yeah, I bet. Yeah. Um. I

28:33 work in theater, so uh when I write music for theater and for film, and so when I go see a movie or I watch a play, I sit around and I think about I just I automatically without even trying. I judge, I judge the music in the movie, or I judge the music in the play. Let chants the thing I do? Do you do? Either of you do a thing? I know. I know you're watching a show about a therapist, and we can we can talk about that in a second, because I'm sure each of you have opinions about like, ah, I would have done that differently, you know what I mean, because you're watching another person do your job. But like, are you ever out in public and you see people and you're like, oh, you know that person needs a therapist, or like I bet their therapist isn't that good because of the way they're behaving, Like are you are you ever judging people based around how they would react in your therapy? In the interests of authenticity and self revelation, I do do some of it. I have to admit, and I don't feel I feel guilty that I do that because you don't know the whole story. You feel guilty because you don't know the whole story.

29:40 You don't know what really happened in their therapy, And how who am I to judged how good your therapist is, your how or what they're about, you know, from just some little incident on the street. Right, you don't really know, and I have to remind myself of that. I really try not to do that. Okay, first of all, not to judge whether someone needs a therapist or not. Just for one thing. I'm seeing patients all day long, Okay, ten or twelve patients a day. Enough is enough? Right when I go out or I see a movie, I don't want to be assessing people, you know, That's what I do for a living, you know. I want to be able to go to people in a completely different way. So I don't do it. I try not to do it for that reason, and for the reason that I think it's very cheap to judge things. You can't judge from some of my patients.

30:22 What they might tell somebody else about me and what they've done is not going to reflect what happens between me and them, right, And I could see someone else thinking what the hell is this guy doing, you know, just from what he's hurt, you know. So for that reason, I really try not to do that. But it's impossible to stay away from that completely, at least for me. You know, there's always the sense of what is going on with this guy, what's going on in his therapy? You know, but he may have been much worse before he wasn't there. I mean, what's funny about that question is I don't know if this probably happens to you, Frank. When people meet me and find out what I do, they go, oh, you're probably sack analyzing me right now. And I actually like hate that comment because I'm like, in that moment, I'm not doing therapy. I'm like, you know, at working out or at the you know, with out with friends or something like that. So I'm trying not to psychoanalyze people when I'm not working, so I don't psychoan with people. And I agree, I get that all the time, almost universal when I tell people I'm an oh no, now I gotta watch myself or oh my god, yeah, you know, yeah, and how it works anyway, right, Like that that makes it sound like you guys have X ray vision or something, but you like that's what people think. They kind of think of it that way, like, oh, yeah, I don't watch myself because you're gonna see inside my mind somehow like a like a like an X ray like some sort of vision. Right, It doesn't work that way, but people don't know that, you know, they get immediately intimidated.

31:56 And you know when people say, oh, you're probably psychoanalyzing me right now, I say I am probably not, because I do that all day long. And the last thing in the world I want to do is psychoanalize somebody at a party, you know or anywhere. Yeah, you know, it's awesome. Yeah you don't want to necessarily say I could not care less about you, but probably you really couldn't, but I probably do. I did look at the ways in which you know, this therapist and the show responded to things and thought about how I might respond in those situations, Like there was one thing that that he said, um, although that might have been in the second episode, but m I mean, I did think about, like, well, what would I do because like he's he's chained up, right, and and gen Sam comes in and Steve Carrell tries all these different methods to get him to, you know, let him go, Like he says, unlock this right now, you know, so he tried us to tell him, you know, in a very like you know, assertive way, unlocked this right now. And then he says, come on, this isn't going to work here. We have to do it at my office.

33:07 He tries all these different ways that don't work right, And so I did think about, like like what would I do? Would I would I panic? What I scream? What I cry? Would I you know? What? What methods would I try? So? And not that I came up with anything better. I mean I think I think this is you know, and I probably would say something like there was that moment he goes, I loved this line. Oh you're gonna give me the silent treatment? Now that sounds that sounds pretty immature for a therapist. And Steve carrell answers, well, I'm no longer your therapist. I'm now your prisoner. Like I might have said something like that, you know, I might have gotten a little passive aggressive also, So yeah, what do you think, Frank?

33:52 Do you think you would have responded similarly? Um? You know, it's how do we know how we really respond if we really got changed up by a patient? You know, it's such an horrifying kind of experience. But what I do think is that the notion that what trust patient doesn't notice, but to chain somebody up and say you have to cure me, okay, is an impossibility. Okay, it's it's an oxymoron. It's a contradiction in terms you cannot. I always say. I always say to my patients, you know, or I say to my students, you know, we have a our technical piece of equipment. Is they door with a one way lock.

34:37 Okay, nobody can get in, but you can always get out, okay, because the patient has to be free to come and go. So none of what's what I'm saying to them is that everything I do here is based on the premise that you come here at your own free will. Okay. You want to be here, okay, for some reasons. Up to me maybe to figure out what reason, But I'm basing everything on Matt okay, and everything I do trying to figure that out now. I never thought of it from the other point of view the therapist who can't get out, right, But the same applies. I mean, the therapist has to be free to operate in whatever way he feels as best for the patient. When you're chained up, no matter who you are, you can't possibly be operated the way you would if you were free. Okay. And furthermore, when it comes to the point of he's saying, well, you know, I'm not going to be your therapist, and he says, well, then where does that leave us? You know, and then he decides he better be the therapist, right, especially Gene. Yeah, he had no choice.

35:40 Jean says, you know, I'm going to do it again. So therefore he would he would have to turn him in, right. So now he's stuck. What does he do? Right, But it's an impossibility because he's now operating under the pressure that literally, right, you cure me or else it's life or death. Okay, you can't operate as the therapist that way. You've got to be free, to be able to think and feel whatever you do, and to have that the ultimate pressure of life and death on you doesn't work. I don't even believe in. You know, sometimes companies will hire a therapist to you know, work with their clients, and I think all they can do is do an assessment for them out. You can't do real therapy that way because the therapist is an agent of the company and not on the side of the patients. They're on the side of the company.

36:31 Well, this is an even more extreme version of that situation, right, And so I would. I know at one point I would have said to him, this is impossible. You can't work. I can't do your therapist. Well, I'm chained up. You know. Therapy is based on the premise that we are both here of our own free will, and yeah, here we're not, you know. But you know what's kind of interesting though, is okay, Like, yes, absolutely, I want to make it clear that you should never kidnap your therapist and chain them up in order to force therapy, right, like, I want to make we haven't made that disclaimer already. I want to take a moment now to make sure that everyone understands that's what we're all a favor of here. But at the same time, the way that Dom Hall Gleason plays Sam, he does seem to have a logical point of view, which is like, I've got a problem.

37:25 It's really serious. And he even says the line which is I've got bigger problems than most of your other patients. And so he is he is taking action, decisive, definitive action to really address his problems. Now, it's definitely not the way to do it, but he unlike other places, other television shows and films where serial killers are sort of seeing as these monsters who are somehow soulless or are somehow like you know, on autopilot. He seems to have a solid case as to why he would do the things he did, and um doesn't want to say, I don't want to say they sound reasonable, but they're close. Well, he has a solid basis for saying, we've got to do something different here. Okay, that's fine.

38:22 He doesn't have a solid basis for saying I have to chain you up because it's actually in the real world, that's totally counterproductive. That's not going to get him his goal of getting cured. It's quite the opposite. But he could say, you know, I've got worse problems than your patients. What you're doing here isn't working. You know, we got to do something different. He could say that, right, which would be fine because that was really good things going. And that's where I go back to the comment that the therapists made, which I think was that, in my view, a blunder to say you know, um, well, you know you you're avoiding everything. That's why we're not getting anywhere, you know. I think if the therapist had handled that differently in the real world, the patient wouldn't have locked him up. The patient would have felt like, maybe you need to get somewhere. Okay, Wow, this guy is addressing me, okay, not dismissing me. Okay. He wants to understand me. He doesn't want to dismiss me because I can't do it. But I can't doing it is all part of the process, okay, and we deal We'll deal with that.

39:20 So if Alan hadn't confronted him, he might not have been locked up. I don't think so. I don't think you would have. I think I think the guy would respond it differently if the analyst had said, you know, I can see that you're hiding something here, and I think that's really important that you're avoiding stealings, and so there's got to be something here that you're really troubling, you know. I wonder if you could give me an indication of what that might be, or have you thought about that yourself? You know, have you thought about it yourself? Might be better, you know, and engage the process of reflection of what that's going on. And of course the patient knows exactly what because he's a serial killing, you know, And I think that that would have gone out in that way. I'm not going to disagree with you, Frank, but I am going to say that I think it was inevitable that at some point he would have done this. I mean not only because it's a television show, but because I think this guy is a narcissist and it's all about him. And so Steve Carrell or his therapist could have said anything that he would have turned around and made it about him, because his solution in the end is, you know, for him to say, well, I wasn't able to open up in your office, Like that's bologny, you know, like you don't need to be like you don't have your therapist locked in the basement to have him, you know, open up to you. So I kind of think so I agree that, you know, like Steve Carrell probably could have been a little more delicate, but I kind of think that it was inevitable that it might

40:52 have happened this way anyway, because that's the way that's the patient's pathology. Yeah, yeah, isn't it Isn't it possible that the reason why he's locked the therapist up is in order to have control? Yes? And that also like serial killers, I feel like also maybe kill people for that sense of control as well. Right, So it's it's kind of logically follows. Well, you certainly that that would be it to achieve control. But you see, there are better and worse ways of handling the patients avoidance, right, And I think if it had been handled differently, who can say? I mean, it's fiction, you know, the writer can write anything they want, right, but a patient like that had seen in the real world.

41:44 I think if you engage them in showing your interested in understanding you know what is so troubling to them that they're avoiding it that very frequently people will open up to you and they'll need to Patients like that always need to be in control. As had a lot of patients who need to be in control. Luckily so find none of them locked me up. But you know, you talk about that, you talk about them need to be in control, they'll control the therapy. They'll say, this is what we're going to talk about, and this is how we're going to do it, you know, and talk about that. You know, it seems like it's important that you call the shots here, you know, and we talked about it, you know, um and this guy as much as he as he has killed people, he's also said he wants to do it again. There's this guy he's obsessed with, but he goes to therapy instead, and that's an open that means he's not totally acting out everything they feel. I love that you just said so far no one has locked me up as if there's still is still a shot at that. UM. I have a question, Um, so what did you think about this idea that? Um he that the patient wanted to pick a Jewish therapist, that thinking that Jewish accountant. It's like, I

43:15 know this is whole Jewish thing. Yeah, I guess you think that's just simply it. I don't know. I thought it was fascinating, but it never We didn't get any more material than that. He just said, I picked out three Jewish therapists, and I picked out the best one. I was Jewish. It would me I would have think, why only Jewish doctors Jewish? Yeah? Um, that was a fascinating, uh little vignette. And I didn't know what to make of it other than he wants the best anythings, Jews are the best. That made me wonder is the patient jewish? You know? He didn't look. Yeah, yeah, Um, you know many people feel like I feel like Jewish doctors are the best. I always or the growing up the desk because I'm Jewish and every one of my relatives were Jewish, and now said the Jewish doctors. Um, And you know he wanted the best and his concept the Jews, Jews were the best, are the best. WHI is a fascinating thing for someone to say.

44:16 I've never had a patience say to me, I was just looking for a Jewish therapist. Yeah, yeah, of course, most I've had people. Yeah, no, I've had people say ask me about my you know, in more recent years, my political views and and have that be part of you know, why they would choose me or not. But yeah, So, Frank, was there anything in particular else about the episode that you wanted to be sure to um talk about? Um. That's a good question. Um, the I guess the main thing was the um the dramatic situation.

44:58 He quits the therapist skin by saying, UM, you know you've got to cure me before I let you go, and the therapist saying and saying, well, you know, you got to let me go before I can hear you, which is true okay, And then the patient says, well, but then you turn me in. You have to turn me in, and that therapist says, only if you say you're going to do it again. So immediately he says, I'm going to do it again, you know. So that traps the situation, that traps the therapist. So I thought it was a blunder on the therapist part, but obviously a difficult one to see at the moment. Right, But if you could think of that, you know what, the therapist should have said, everything's better to see in hindsight.

45:43 You should have said, um, listen, I don't have to turn you in, you know, Um, you know, there's nothing you know, and and and just leave it at that. Um. Yeah, But the gains of the patient and opening and therefore got trapped and to a situation that's basically impossible, you know. It's he's got to try to cure somebody in a situation where it's impossible to cure them. And serial killers are notoriously hired to cure anyway, right, but especially that by the way, I like, can you curious the earlier killer? And like, how long does that take? I feel like longer than ten episodes? Yeah, yeah, right. I've I've never heard of a case in which a serial killer was actually cured by therapy or anything else for that matter. You know, maybe there are cases, but I've never heard of one, because you know, what they're doing is they're they're enacting, you know, whatever it is that's bothering them. It gets enacted by killing somebody, right and so um.

46:47 And to take them into therapy, you'd have to get them into a situation where they'd be willing to deal with whatever it's bothering them that leads them to do the shooting without doing the shooting. And maybe that's theoretically possible, but in practical terms, i'd seen a lot of you know, I haven't seen myself stre of killers, but I've read about them, and I've seen portrayals and documentaries and so on, and none of them seem to me to be at all amenable, you know, anything like that, because they're so narcissistically vulnerable that they have to kill, you know, that's the only way they can resolve it. I remember hearing seeing this one case in a documentary for this guy was asked why he killed his bus drik and he said, well, I got on the bus and the guy said you needed token, he needed something and I said, no, I don't have him or something, and he said, well, you have to get off the bus. He said he didn't know. That's when he got executed. He didn't know who he was dealing with, and he shot him. He killed him. You know, now, somebody like that is not curable, okay, because anything that said, oh, indicative that there's anything that he has to do or someone else tells them what to do. He's to kill me, right right, That's just not a curable situation, you know, and serial killers of that. You know. So if you were Alan, if you personally were Alan and you were in the basement chained up to a bed and Sam said to you, I'm not letting you leave this basement until you cure me of

48:20 being a serial killer, your first thought is probably I'm never leaving this basement, that's right. And I would probably say that to him. I would say, that's an impossibility. I can't kill you what I'm locked up. It can't happen, So you'll kill you. But you know, well, and your comment earlier, Frank, Yeah, your comment earlier about everyone wants to be better, but no one wants to change. Is really relevant here because every time Steve Carrell is going to say to him, you have to do maybe try it this way. You know, he's gonna you know, he wouldn't take his sunglasses off in the beginning. He's certainly not unlocking him.

49:05 He says, promise me, you're not going to do it. And the best thing he can say as well, I'll try. You know. Um, he's going to have a hard time taking any of the suggestions. In fact, I found myself wondering if he just hadn't already killed someone. I don't know, but he's killed several people apparently. Oh, I mean even since starting to see him that promise. Yeah, it would take an absolutely heroic effort, okay, a piece of therapeutic history for somebody to gain enough trust in somebody like that, and they have they have enough trust in you that you could actually help them think about what they're doing rather than kill somebody and understand what's wrong about it and not do it again. That would be heroic. I would never say it's impossible, but it would be a heroic effort. Would make history. Wow, all right, well, I think that sets us up really well. For the rest of the series then, because yeah, we still have nine episodes ago at least, right right, right right, could be interesting. Yeah, well, Frank, thank you so much for coming on. That was really that was really a fun discussion and about a very dark topic. Um and it was fun to kind of, you know, because you were my teacher, to just trade ideas about the way the way it could be done or should be done or might have been done. Um. So, yeah, that was really great.

50:38 It was This was a lot of fun. Thank you both so much. I appreciate the invitation. I thank you for it. And it's wonderful to see my former student doing so well. It's so gratifying to me to see her being so successful, you know, aren't you sweet? Thank you Lee. Yeah, that's what they're talking about. Celia Killers could be so gratified. This is great. This is bringing us all together. Yea. Yeah, well, thank you both very much. So thank judging so much. Thank you. So that was doctor Frank Summers, training and supervising analyst at the Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis. Um Man, I learned a lot from him about this. This was really exciting and interesting. Um and yeah, I don't I'm also feel like I feel like I was here to witness some sort of personal like circle for you personally that you're sort of like able to, like the student becomes the master kind of. I don't know if that's exactly the right metaphor here, but you see where I'm going with this. Well, I mean it could have been that, but he, you know, told me I was wrong in the first ten minutes. But that's okay, never mind, yeah, no, no, but no, it was great.

52:01 It was it was um. It was very cool hearing his his perspective on that. So we were talking about um one of the remarks that Alan makes to Um Sam about Um him opening up, and I said, well, I thought that was really interesting. You know that he made that comment. We used his counter transference to say, I'm I'm feeling a little frustrating. Maybe you're a little frustrating Frank. Frank was like, I didn't like that comment at all. I think that's the whole reason why he got kidnapped, basically because he's too fragile and he went in too quick and blamed the patient. And I was like, oh, okay, But other than that, was that's the true mark of a teacher, though, right is the person who's able to stand back and be like, ah, there you go.

52:49 That was no, don't do it. Don't do it that way, s Daisy, we gotta go back. Yeah, yeah, I mean I think there you go. That's a less and for all of you therapists out there is just be aware that if you confront your patient, it's possible you'll be locked up in basement. I'm grateful to the both of you indulging my neophyte questions about therapy since I don't understand any of it, and so like, I will try to ask less embarrassing questions as this show goes along if I can possibly figure it out. Frank loved your questions, lindsay yeah and worry about it. No, no, don't worry about it at all.

53:32 And it really kind of gave him the opportunity to talk about, you know, the things that he knows best, you know, like how do you decide how many sessions a week someone needs? How do you decide any analysis who doesn't need analysis? But also, um, you know, basically when when you when you dive in and confront the patient when you don't. But I really appreciated like his comment, it's about you know, people finding us thing, people finding out things about the therapist. You know that vignette in the beginning of the episode where the patient goes, I'm really sorry about your loss um and and the and the basic premise of the whole show, which is that you really can't. It's it's nearly impossible to do therapy without that trust. And not only does the patient have to trust you, but you know, you need to be able to trust the trust the patient. You know that the patients that people like often don't tell you everything, but you hope that they're you know, being forthright enough that you've got something to work with. And if you're being impinged in any way, it's it's hard to it's hard to be our most present, you know, helpful selves if we're if we're afraid or angry or you know, locked up in a basement.

54:57 So yeah, I mean, I think that's a really interesting point, is that, And it goes back again to my sort of my experience of therapy, which is that I come in and everything is about me, But really it's it's equally as important that the therapists feel comfortable and safe in order for them to be able to make make real progress. Otherwise if they don't, then that affects everything, right, because it's it's a relationship. Therapy is a relationship, and so it might feel or appear like it's a one sided relationship. And patients say that all the time to me, like, well, I've told you everything about me. I don't know anything about you.

55:39 But people know things about me. And I don't mean like, well they know that you know I like to wear blue. They get to know like how I'm going to respond to them, They get to know my personality. They know they know me and they can't they know they can learn to trust how that I'm going to be open to them and what they have to say. So um, and that's a relationship. And as Frank said, it's one of the most intimate relationships you can have with a person. So yeah, that's really true. Yeah, And I mean, like when you are you ever surprised by how intimate things can get? Are there? Even after all this time of being a therapist, are there times where you're like, WHOA, I wasn't expecting this level of intimacy? No, oh okay, no, you're going yeah, no, I I I have not been surprised.

56:36 People tell me all kinds of things, and I'm I'm extremely appreciative, and I never you know, you know, I don't take it for granted. It's really amazing because I think we don't really think about it or talk about it. But it's a huge, it's an it's it's a real sacrifice for you, I think, to be able to put yourself in that relationship and really focus so deeply on the other person, and that's something that maybe we don't necessarily have in our lives. And so, like, I guess once you do that, once you make the commitment to do that, then you're kind of ready for anything. Yeah. Well, and so I'll just like and I wonder if this will happen at all, but you know, just to turn the tables for a minute, like therapists and therapy. Frank made a comment about that. I once went to a support group for a medical condition that I have, and um, I hated every second of it.

57:36 And I had I had you know, we all know, you know that I have a few control issues, but um I sat in that room and had not that I'd never considered this before, but had this sudden revelation like oh, I asked my patience to do this all the time, to basically like reveal everything there is a themselves to me, and now I don't feel willing to do that, you know, in this group of people. So it's a it's a big ask, you know. And then patients give us this like little delicate flower and we have to really protect it, you know, and hold it and be willing to not stomp on it. So it's time to wrap up this week's session, but we'll see you next week on the next session of Psychoanalyzing the Patient. Bye bye.