Reviews

This is a great podcast notwithstanding reviews from people who can’t spell about being woke (eye roll) or those who feel entitled to free continuous content and updates just because they like something (2nd eye roll). I hope the host is doing well and thriving and grateful that she still allows these episodes to be available for all to listen.

Floorbends
Oct. 18, 2025

Awesome

I absolutely love Erica’s voice! I have this show on rotation and have listened to its entirety more than a few times. Many of these cases I’ve not heard of. Her research is fantastic as well. 💜

BenApplsmiles
Oct. 6, 2025

Always satisfied

I appreciate the details you provide with each crime review. I don’t always want an extreme deep dive into a case and I feel your details are satisfactory. I LOVE how you recognize the Indigenous people of the land when you’re giving the intro before the main storyline. Thank you for that.

CookinAZ
Aug. 19, 2025

The best

Your voice was born for this. Love love your viewpoints, your research and your voice. . Fantastic podcast 🧡

krinklekrinkle
July 11, 2025

SFTC

Erica Kelley, you are BY FAR my favorite podcaster! I love your content. Thank you for your work!

TeressaJFreeman
June 25, 2025

♥️

I love your podcast so much. Your voice and drawl are so soothing. I look forward to your return! ♥️

Crimson's Mom
May 30, 2025

Miss you!

❤️

Inpursuitofglam
May 23, 2025

Missing SFTC!!!

Erica, we miss you and hope you're well and doing great! Please let us know if and when SFTC will be coming back! Still love the Facebook group!!!

Alamance Gal
May 19, 2025

Miss you

Like so many others have commented hope you’re well love your show dearly. Hope to see you uploading again .

wholemeal29
May 18, 2025

Hope you are doing good

Hope you are doing well miss the show

05/21/73
May 6, 2025

The best podcast

I hope you are doing well. I think we all miss your voice❤️

True Crime Junkie65
April 26, 2025

Where the heck are you girl?

Miss your show!!!

kblomquist
April 22, 2025

Best of the best

Wishing you well, Erica. You really gave us the perfect true crime podcast. I miss your voice.

Wilco615
April 9, 2025

Happy with this y’all

Hoping all is well with Erica. Her voice is smooth and she’s openly, unabashedly honest!

NurseRebecca
April 4, 2025

Ericka

Miss This hoping all is well. Everything about this podcast is right.

Perilus
April 2, 2025

Has this podcast ended?

Wonderful, well-researched cases told by the podcaster with the best voice in the industry.

factsmustbechecked
March 12, 2025

Where r u

I love this show, please come back. We need this show!

medic9666
March 1, 2025

Worried about you

I can’t find anything that explains what happened to your show. It was one of my favorites. Hope your doing okay

Girl Fred
Feb. 26, 2025