Listener Reviews

I want to come out and be called they/them/it and if the person cares that much they could call me he. My friends won’t care and my area is all that homophobic. I just don’t know how to come out. Or if I should.This will probably be never read.~FelixTheFurry~

I listen to this every night as a 12 year old, even though it scares me, I’m addicted to this podcast, and can you please keep this up and never stop!

Despite these ladies not having a problem with the term “birthing person” being temporarily substituted in for the term “woman” in congressional hearings—-because I guess biology only matters when it’s politically correct and it’s advantageous to true crime—-or using the terminology “undocumented” instead of “illegal”-because I guess it’s okay to break some laws but not others—-this podcast is pretty great. It empowers the viewers to take action and to put pressure on public officials and supports survivors. The best of true crime podcasting, not the “Saw” type of material a lot of horror-centric crime people tend to focus on. This podcast is the humanizing kind that puts the focus where it should be: on victims and survivors. The only major complaint I have is these women have made it clear that political correctness is very important, and often it is that SAME mindset that puts these cases on this unsolved hiatus in the first place. Fascinating.

What is up with the (seemingly) bot reviews, griping about politics or liberal ideologies? PEOPLE, if this podcast is not your jam, keep moving along until you find a podcast that suits your personal agenda! This is an easy listen podcast and Brit and Ashley deliver stories in a way that doesn’t leave me feeling traumatized or unnerved. Keep on delivering your magic! You two are the best.

Dying at all the reviews saying “too political!” like huh crime is political? it’s… the law? like huh? Are yoh people ok? Anyway I love CJ. I fall asleep every night listening to old ones, which yes is probably not the healthiest, but it works! Ashley and Brit’s storytelling is like fine wine, & only gets better with time. If you’re a REAL true crime girlypop this show is for you.

The best show ever made

I’ve been religiously listening to your guys podcast at work. I just finished the Asha degree episode. And just food for thought but did they ever do a deep dive into people at her church? Was the church in the direction she was walking in? U hear a lot of stories about how kids get groomed at church. 🧐

I noticed a 1 star review by someone saying this podcast is too political. Which is funny considering life is political and is so is crime. Anyways, this has been the true crime podcast I had been looking for, real people, real emotions, real stories, real morals, and good dialogue. I have been binging it since 2025 and can say this is the best podcast I’ve ever tuned into. Consider me a junkie, love you Ashley and Brit, “stay weird, be rude, stay alive”.💕

This is jimmy🤠-l-/\He likes to travel, so spread him to other podcasts

Just make one about pets going missing maybe please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please

Just recently found your podcast about Mary Yoder and loved it. I scrolled to the beginning and started at Laci Peterson… when I was a young mom and lived just an hour away from Modesto. Since then, daily listener. Thank you for the work you do. - @joeyaynn

Thank you for helping me get through my workday.

5/5 clean, well-spoken, and just wow!

Love this show! I like how there’s shorter and longer ones. Such an easy listen- I love their voices.

I enjoy listening to your podcast. Learning the in and outs of investigation.

Please look into her case from Bay Village, Ohio in 1989. They just received a $15,000 donation to do more DNA testing. I think your platform could help. Thank you!

Love the Podcast!! Are you planning on being at CrimeCon in Vegas?

Top tier podcast, well researched and fascinating stories. Brit, and Ashley are the best!!

I was looking fo something true crime to binge on and came across this and thought I’d give it a try, I’m so glad I did. I’ve listened to 15 shows today and no telling ow many I’ll get through tomorrow. Thank you ladies.

Hi Ashley and Brit I love your show OMGOSH I am 11 but Yall are amazing moms and I was wondering if you could help me with something my mom was kidnapped when she was around 16 and raped and escaped do you think you could make a episode if not just mention her it would mean a lot to me and her thanks - Livia

I listen to this daily lol

I LOVE IT!!! It’s truly great, it shows how far this podcast has gone! If you’re receiving these, please add it to the next episode!!!

Could you please make a mysterious death of somebody that is interesting and long and could you make it family friendly please. Love your podcast it is so good

These podcasts are exceptional! Their storytelling skills are unmatched. You will be captivated like never before.