Listener Reviews

This is Jimmy spread him on podcasts and tell people to do that 🤠 / | \ / \

I is soooooo good

Crime Junkie being the number 1 Podcast gives me hope in people 🩷. These ladies really do great work, with empathy, focusing on the marginalized and shedding light on stories that need it.

I love this podcast I listen every week. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

My favorite podcast! I started listening a few months ago. I started from the first episode currently on 2021 and I am obsessed. Love these ladies and the spotlight they put on these cases.

This is my favorite podcast of all time!

I think I’ve listened to just about every single episode you guys have you guys do a good job and relying the information and raising questions and it’s enjoyable to listen to you. However, you have a distain for God that you expose through the mockery of Christianity and faith. John Paul, and Wayne and a lot of pastors within the evangelical charismatic movement within Catholicism within Protestantism within Judaism have taken that power and authority that they have us pastors to destroy the image of God and his Messiah. A show explaining your current stance on faith.

I listen to this podcast because it’s entertaining and the cases are interesting. People are bashing on Britt, but I really like her. She seems like the tender-hearted one who brings the maternal instincts to the table. Honestly, I would like it more, and wince less while listening, if they would stop hating on Christianity. Or maybe if they would explain why they chose to leave their faith, I could have more empathy for them? I don’t know, it just hurts my heart to know that in such a hopeless sector of entertainment (murder/true crime), these women are discounting where my hope comes from, and using their influence to persuade others to quit on their faith. That being said, hey seem like sweethearts, and I love what they do. I have listened to all the episodes, and I will continue to support their show because I think the behind-the-scenes work they are doing is important, and I love hearing updates of crimes solved.

I’m a crime doc junkie. And I started watching them all. But what made me start listening was I got my annual review at work. And I listened to shows and it was brought up saying no more. So I started podcasts. I literally typed crime and you guys popped up. I’ve binged since January of this year. I’m obsessed. And will forever be a crime junkie now because of you two!

You two are amazing. Thank you for bringing light to so many cases

The best true crime podcast!!! I listen to you guys daily while working. Makes work bearable LOL

I’ve enjoyed many episodes, but the clear distain for Christianity makes it hard to listen if you consider yourself in that camp. The valley girl mocking of the church and people in it, is gross. I can tolerate other worldviews or disagreement, but when the show has to incorporate a clear bias or chip on your shoulder towards religion, it gets old. I enjoy the episodes that they don’t bring that into it.

I started listing to you guys thinking it would be boring but my sister forced me to listen and now I’m obsessed and can’t stop listening.

So happy to see attention on Mica Miller!! I heard of her from Serialously and she deserves it!! Love all the content!

You are in my top 5 of go-to crime podcasts. I love you both and your thorough case coverage. BUT you both sounded manic during your Aug ‘26 episode about Mica Miller. I almost stopped listening because you were talking over each other and laughing so much—you sounded like high-pitched squealing teen-age girls. I am a long-time listener. I hope you can see this feedback as constructive.

All of questions you’ve asked, Mandy Matney, et al/True Sunlight podcast goes into detail about and can answer these questions. Like fact y’all’s viewpoints as raised as members of that “kind of church” is so valuable.

I want to first say I appreciated the coverage and information given on the Mica Miller case, however, I do want to add that not all evangelical churches operate the way JP’s church operated and overall above everything else, Jesus in NO WAY condones anything JP preached or vowed was Bible based teaching. Everything about him was evil and nothing of God and I pray people realize that because he did despicable things in Gods name. Praying for Micas family and justice.

Been listening since around 2020, and have listened to every episode. This is the only true crime show I trust because of how respectful they are of victims/victims families. Their advocacy work is also amazing and I’ve learned a lot to keep myself safe since listening.

I used to listen ALL THE TIME, until I had to switch to the Crime Junkie app to listen ad free. Then I just stopped. But I’m still a subscriber so I decided to open the app and listen to an episode last week. I admit, it had probably been over a year since I had heard an episode. I thought that Ashley got a new host. Britt’s voice is completely different! Between how high-pitched Britt’s voice was and how fast Ashley was talking, I thought I had accidentally turned my speed up.

My fav podcast but I need a warning when there are 2 part episodes!! My pregnant/toddler mama brain cannot remember what happened a week ago 🤣🫶🏻

My go-to true crime podcast, hands down!

Love you Ashley, but slow down, sometimes you talk so fast I have to rewind to get the conversation! 🫶

The final verdict is never settled for these women. No such thing as an open and closed case. They’ll tell you why that woman didn’t really commit suicide; it was in fact the husband that did it and the police helped cover it up. Just ignore logic and reason and you’ll love this podcast :)

Can you make an episode about the Lindsay Clancy.