Reviews

Rate Show

You Are So Good
It’s a weekly delight with the trifecta of nice people, intelligent discussion and the movies that (often) made us.

Marvelous
Let me just say that I can hardly get through a week without a Wednesday/Thursday dose of this remarkably lovely show.💜

Gen-X listener connects with a movie podcast, learns to live again
For reasons that don’t concern us here, I have always been a bit disconnected from the popular culture of my people and have always needed a docent to show me the way. In my younger days, my older sister and cooler friends filled this vital role. Now that I’m a man of a certain age, I have turned to to Alex and Sarah, two intrepid millenials brought together through the miracle of The Tumbler (sp?) to share fellowship as they discuss movies that “hit them in the feels”, as I believe the current parlance has it. Whenever I activate the podcast application on my pocket phone, I pass a pleasant hour with Alex and Sarah, who always leave me wanting to experience for myself the flimic artifacts they discuss, and yes, to delve deeper into the messy extra-cinematic world of human emotion. Five Stars!

Can’t Be Without
This podcast has left me with tons of great suggestions for movies to watch, and ways to reconsider movies I’ve already seen. It is such a joy to listen to funny, emotional intelligent individuals talk about how they relate to each film. I’m so impressed that they only give ads for products and services they morally stand behind. Cannot recommend this show enough!! 💖

If jocular Terry Gross and “I just have a lot of feelings” girl from Mean Girls had a movie podcast.
Allergic to strong narrative structures and probably the air we breathe? Connoisseur of character actors? A forever-renter? Would you possibly describe “Titanic” as your emotional-support action movie? Do you often walk into a room and think “why I am here…?” in both an existential *and* literal way, and then shrug and continue eating the one thing you’ve been eating all week while trying to have empathy for yourself? Yeah, me either. (This podcast is for you)

Like drinking spiked coffee with friends
I’ve been a fan of Sarah’s since the beginning of you’re wrong about. Absolutely everything she does is amazing. Her and Alex are a great duo. This podcast is so affirming and reminds me that feeling things is good. It’s like getting to sit down and chat over coffee with Bailey’s- thoughts and topics may jump around, but that’s what makes it even more relaxing and warm. All love to Sarah, Alex, and Caroline and all their guests!!!

This podcast is the hoodie I could wear everyday
Seriously listening to this podcast is like awakening all the the warm, feel-good nostalgia of finding that one hoodie you wore through high school but still questioning why it smells the way it does and why did I leave the house like this for four years. The answer is, of course, it just feels good. This podcast is good. You are good.

one of my all time favorite shows
sarah and alex are great and the podcast is incredibly genuine as well as insightful and funny.

Fabulous
Absolutely love the show. It feels like I’m just chatting with friends (a convo I don’t contribute to 😂) but I love how they go off on random side notes, I really enjoy the casualness of the talking. 10/10, never change.

Why are good?
As far as parasocial relationships go, the one I have with Alex Steed and Sarah Marshall is precious to me. This show might not do it for everyone but, like the music of Daniel Johnston or Jenny Mae, if it does it for you, it does it better than most. Thanks to the team. Much love to you and yours. Keep coming back.

This Podcast is Good
I suppose if you were to come to this podcast after having listened to You’re Wrong About and/or Maintenance Phase, you may be let down by the much looser format of this show. But it’s also one of the nicer things about the podcast I find, because it does just feel like a casual conversation between two very open people who have a solid grasp on understanding how films are made and how to identify strengths and weaknesses in writing. There is a clear genre/subgenre that the hosts seem to like analyzing; typically maturation/coming of age, slice of life, and character driven plots that deal with a central underlying trauma. It’s an interesting way to watch a movie and this podcast often makes me want to rewatch films from childhood, which is always fun. I do wish they’d throw in the occasional random film neither has ever seen so as not to rely on nostalgic memories too often. Overall the calm, good vibes from Sarah and Alex make this a nice, cozy nook of a podcast to get to listen to each week. Also the artwork for the cover is very cute and always makes me happy.

This is Good
Sarah and Alex are having the conversations about movies I wish we all would. The format and focus of this show are unexpected in all of the right ways. In a podcast world full of gatekeeping by people who like the “right” movies or a specific perspective, this podcast makes the listener feel like their experience and feelings about a movie are valid and worth sharing (which I often do aloud in my car along with them). Highly recommend.

Unbelievably sexy
This podcast has given me two life altering revelations. I am good. And I would like to be the Daddy. Bonus point for Sarah singing Jiggle Jiggle like Cowboy selling the news on a street corner.

Squishy and FUN-getable
Truly one of my favorite podcasts. I listen to every episode, end if it’s a film I’ve never seen or even thought to watch before. I have to hear why they chose the film because it means something to somebody. I’m in my feelings when I’m watching movies, so why not be in them when we talk about them? Alex and Sarah always get guests with similar vibes and everyone just has such an emotionally insightful discussion in a safe space. I had a real “why are dads” dad, which is what drew me to this podcast in the first place. I realize now, I was always looking for life guidance through movies as a kid. Alex and Sarah feel like kindred spirits. Every episode guarantees laughs, tears, and revelations.

A joy
Came for Sarah, stayed for Alex’s delightful laugh

Love this pod
So happy to have found this recently. Thanks Sarah and Alex.

I mean…
If I loved this podcast anymore, I think I’d be pressured to marry it.

The best company
I love scrolling through episodes to find a movie that matches the vibe I’m looking for to accomplish a mundane that. Sarah and Alex feel like smart kind friends and the guests always bring something fun to the show ☀️🌴

Love this
I adore these conversations and perspectives

Great show
This is a great show. Don’t be misled: of course it’s self indulgent, all media discussion and criticism podcasts are by definition. But that doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy it while thinking critically. One weird thing that happened recently. They criticized Ben Kingsley for playing Gandhi. Super weird. Just because he was born in England?

IT’S AMAZING
No notes 👋🏻

The perfect show
I listen to You Are Good any time I am stressed. I saved the Goodfellas episode for when I was in labor. I ended up having a difficult time and I truly credit Sarah and Alex for helping things go smoothly because their voices keep me so relaxed.

IT’S AMAZING
But since I’ve subscribed there haven’t been any new bonus episodes ☹️ the nerds need ‘em!

Love this show
Alex and Sarah have great chemistry and are so thoughtful and sensitive in their commentary. 10/10

Stand By Me
Very entertaining! I love your visits to the Stephen Kingdom. Can Dolores Claiborne be far behind?!?!? When I read The Body in my chubby youth, I never considered that King was being particularly unkind to fat people, more that he was showing what fat kids had to experience, not necessarily with compassion, per se, but at least not avoiding it. Your discussion will make me examine his stuff more closely on re-reads to see if I agree. I alway appreciate a new perspective from the feelings reviews! Thank you! Alex, you are our Chris.

You are good superman episode
Superfun superman podcast. Fangirl jeane is one of my faves!

SO FREAKING DELIGHTFUL!!!
A “feelings podcast about movie“” sounds like it might be, I don’t know, self indulgent? Squirmy? THIS AIN’T THAT, FOLKS This is two smart, perspicacious, thoughtful, generous, sharp eyed and huge hearted folks, who are frequently joined by guests who are all that plus bring their own expertise and wisdom and joy to table. They talk about movies and use them as a lens to talk about everything. The episode that won my fealty forever was the one on Thor: Ragnarok with Fangirl Jeanne. I clicked on it because I like that movie and I already knew I loved Sarah Marshall (from the also excellent and unmi’sable You’re Wrong About). Well, let me tell you, Jeanne’s read on Thor, a super hero movie with two, cis-het, white male leads, from her perspective as an indigenous, bi-racial, queer woman about a movie made by a bi-racial, indigenous, half Jewish film maker as a mediation on diaspora and otherness BLEW MY MIND!! Check it out, you won’t be sorry!

Super good podcast! With one caveat.
Love Sarah Marshall and Alex Steed, they regularly have great guests who I haven’t necessarily heard of and they are all passionate about the films they have come to talk about and I love that. However Alex Steeds preamble before the episode begins is horrifically long. This weeks episode (George of the Jungle) took 10full minutes before it got started and that is not very engaging and I usually just skip that part anyway.

Pretty poggers
I think the podcast is good, just not something I’m into. I found that the intro was a little long, but that’s just my opinion. Love the movie selection, keep it up.

tbh my favorite podcast
the best podcast out there, so so so so so so so so so so so good thank you for doing an ep on “that thing you do!” love ya’ll