🎙️ When the Mic Meets a Moment of Tragedy

👋Hey there Podcaster!

As creators, we face moments that test our instincts behind the mic, last week’s Podcasting Morning Chat dug into the tough question of whether to break format on days of tragedy like the September 11 attacks, we explored how interview hosts can strike the perfect balance between amplifying their guests and showcasing their own voice, and we shared powerful takeaways from our latest episodes to keep your content sharp, engaging, and full of heart.

------------------------------

🎙️ When the Mic Meets a Moment of Tragedy

When the calendar brings us back to days of tragedy like September 11 attacks, should creators break format or stay the course?

That question anchored the Podcasting Morning Chat, where the room paused its usual flow to explore how podcasters can navigate the tension between consistency and compassion.

Twenty-four years later, the memory of 9/11 still stops us in our tracks. For some, it’s a scar they lived through. For others, it’s history they only know through stories. Either way, the question lingers: how do we as creators show up on days like this?

Here’s some of the wisdom the community shared:

Acknowledge with intention. Even if your show isn’t about current events, silence can feel dismissive. A moment of reflection can speak volumes.

Balance emotion with responsibility. Pausing before reacting creates space for thoughtfulness instead of noise. As Sid Meadows said, “Respond thoughtfully rather than react.”

Use your voice for good. After 9/11, what stood out wasn’t only the loss, it was the unity that followed. Our platforms can amplify hope, gratitude, and kindness in the same way.

Preserve history. Podcasts can hold not just the facts, but the feelings of moments in time, becoming living archives for future generations. Ashley shared how her own show was born from documenting her town’s recovery after Hurricane Michael, showing how storytelling helps communities heal.

Plan or pivot. It’s okay to go off-script if you feel called to. As I reminded newer podcasters, your show is yours, you can do what feels right for your audience and your heart.

Lead with gratitude. My friend and co-host, Sid Meadows encouraged us to balance the inevitable grief with messages of love, kindness, and connection. Because hope is what unites us.

Because our platforms don’t just inform or entertain.
They preserve.
They heal.
They unite.

So, what do you think? On days like this, should creators step outside their usual format to reflect, or stay the course? Reply and share your thoughts.

----------------------------

🎙️ Should Interview Hosts Stay Quiet…or Steal the Show?

Is the host of an interview show supposed to pipe down…or stand out?

Some say the host’s only job is to shine a light on the guest. Others argue that audiences come for the host, their perspective, stories, and energy are what make the show memorable.

During a recent Podcasting Morning Chat, the conversation got lively. I posed the question, and the community delivered powerful insights:

The host is the guide. We called the host a “dynamic guide of the story,” steering the conversation and drawing out compelling insights that guests might not share on their own

Content still comes first. Another podcaster reminded everyone that listeners seek value. The host’s job is to ensure that value is delivered, no matter who’s speaking

Stories build connection. Others shared how sprinkling in his own experiences can help guests open up, especially newer guests who might need guidance to tell their stories in a relatable way

Authority matters. Some emphasized that sharing your own insights occasionally helps establish credibility and influence as a host — as long as you don’t overshadow your guest

Find the balance. We talked about editing with intention, cutting her own anecdotes when they don’t add value, and giving more space to experts while using her own voice to keep the conversation grounded.

Master your craft. Others encouraged hosts to keep honing their skills, guiding conversation, asking better questions, and continuously practicing the art of interviewing

So maybe it’s less about choosing sides and more about mastering the dance…enough space for the guest to shine, with just the right dose of host presence to make it all click.

👉 What do you think? Should an interview podcast be guest-driven, host-driven, or a true back-and-forth conversation?

-----------------------------------

🎙️Podcasting Morning Chat Highlights🌅

Welcome to your essential morning brew of ideas and insights, the "Podcasting Morning Chat" is a daily show that's by creators, for creators. A dynamic team of experienced podcasters, entrepreneurs, and producers hosts the PMC. Each episode peels back the curtain on the art of podcasting and content creation. The conversation is a mix of insights, stories, and strategies, tailor-made to keep your content fresh, your audience engaged, and your creative spark alive. 

Recorded live every Tuesday-Friday (temporary summer schedule) at 7 AM EST on Clubhouse and available via podcast at 7 AM PST, our show has become a cornerstone for podcasters worldwide, offering a unique blend of expert advice, real-world success stories, and innovative ideas. Whether you're here to enhance your content, expand your audience, or just soak in the collective wisdom of fellow content creators, the PMC is your source for inspiration, empowerment and connection in the podcasting world. 

Catch up with the latest episodes and join our global community of creators to kick-start your day with creativity, strategy, and insight.

• September 9, 2025: Episode #366: The Secret To Balancing Great Guest Interviews
• September 10, 2025: Episode #367: Declining YouTube Views and Remembering Todd Cochrane, CEO of Blubrry
• September 11, 2025: Episode #368: Remembering 9/11: What Podcasters Can Say When the World Pauses
• September 12, 2025: Episode #369: When Does the Podcast Money Start Rolling In?

----------------------------

I’m so grateful to be connected with you and a part of your podcast journey. 

All My Best,

👋Marc Ronick

This content was composed with assistance from OpenAI

Some of the links in this newsletter may be affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them at no extra cost to you.