*Remastered: 91: The Sherry Murders, The Dixie Mafia & Corruption in Biloxi
In 1987, a circuit court judge and his wife, a former city council woman, who wanted to be mayor, were murdered in their home in Biloxi, Mississippi. It was obviously a professional hit. Vincent Sherry was a former criminal defense attorney who had...
Who was the real target? It was a conspiracy that would take four years and the determination of their oldest daughter to unravel.
Written, hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched by Haley Gray & Erica Kelley
Edited by Chaes Gray
Case Suggestion by listeners: Casey Porter, Eileen Mace & Drew Stuart
Suggested Reading: Mississippi Mud: Southern Justice & The Dixie Mafia by Edward
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:00 Southern fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. In the late nineteen eighties, Biloxi, Mississippi, was teaming with corruption run unofficially by the Dixie Mafia. It wasn't exactly a secret. By nineteen eighty three, the FBI was investigating Biloxi and Harrison County, where it's located. Vincent and Margaret Sherry were pillars of Biloxi. One local commented that if you just said Vincent Margaret, everyone knew who you met. Vince, a conservative Democrat, was a circuit court judge and a criminal defense attorney. Some of his former clients were in the Dixie Mafia. His wife, Margaret, an old school Republican, was a former city councilwoman with ambitions to be mayor. She wanted to clean up crime and corruption in Biloxi. They might have seemed like an odd couple. Vince had defended the very criminals, Margaret wanted put away.
1:08 But they were like bookends, perfectly complimenting each other. Both were natural born politicians, gregarious, and well respected in their community. When they were murdered in their home in September of nineteen eighty seven. It immediately looked like a professional hit. This was no bar glory, but who was the real target? The judge, with former connections to the Dixie Mafia or his wife determined to become mayor and exposed the corruption in Biloxi, as well as shut down illegal brothels and gambling run by the Dixie Mafia. It would take years to unravel the conspiracy and the steely determination of their oldest daughter to see it through. Welcome to Episode ninety one, The Sherry Murders, Dixie Mafia, and corruption in Biloxi. Sitting on the Gulf of Mexico, Biloxi, Mississippi today is well known for its beaches and casinos, but legal gambling didn't come to Mississippi until the nineteen nineties. First settled by the French in sixteen ninety nine, it went from French rule to British rule in seventeen sixty three, to Spanish rule from seventeen seventy nine to eighteen ten. Then in eighteen eleven, Biloxi came under control of the United States of America as part of the Mississippi territory. Mississippi was admitted to the Union in eighteen seventeen. Despite this,
2:43 Biloxi remained largely French in character. It became a summer resort with the advantages of close proximity to New Orleans and ease of travel by water. The beachfront of Biloxi lies directly on the Mississippi Sound, with barrier islands scattered off the coast and into the Gulf of Mexico. Rich farmers and businessmen built summer homes there, and soon hotels and rental cottages started dotting the beaches. Biloxi's casino history dates back to a period in the nineteen forties when open, if technically illegal, gambling took place in a casino within the Broadwater Beach Resort.
3:27 Open gambling ended in the nineteen fifties. It became known as the poor Man's riviera for the tourist industry, but otherwise commercially, Biloxi was dominated by the shrimp and oyster industry. In the early nineteen sixties, the Gulf Coast became a new Southern vacation destination for Northerners as an alternative to Florida, with Biloxi at the center hotels hired French chefs and upgraded their amenities and offered some of the best seafood in the country. In the late sixties and early seventies, the Dixie Mafia began and Biloxi was soon their home base. The FBI defines the Dixie Mafia as a loose confederation of thugs and crooks who conducted their criminal activity in the southeastern United States. One word got out the Biloxi, with its history of strip clubs and illicit gambling, was a safe haven. The criminals settled in The poor Man's Riviera had become a ced strip of nightclubs and motels which also served as strip clubs and gambling dens. Mike Gillett, Jr.
4:42 Was known as the godfather of Biloxi. He owned many of the motels and clubs. His strip clubs often had brothels running in the back rooms, and he ran a tight ship known as Mister Mike. He was the most well known and trusted member of the Dixie Mafia. There wasn't much structure to their organization of everything from petty crimes to armed robbery and murders, but they had one motto, thou shalt not snitch to the cops. Also known as the Cornbread Cosa Nostra, the Dixie Mafia ran prostitution and pornography rings. They were drug smugglers and distributors, and of course, contract killers. In nineteen eighty three, the FBI started investigating Biloxi and Harrison County. They found that the entire Harrison County Sheriff's office was a criminal enterprise. Special Agent Keith Bell said they were doing anything and everything illegal down there for money. Sheriff Hobbs and officers loyal to him would release prisoners from the county jail, safeguard drug shipments, and hide fugitives. Anything you can think of they were involved in.
5:59 There were a few non corrupt police officers and they helped the FBI end the corruption. In nineteen eighty four, Sheriff Leroy Hobbs was convicted of racketeering and was sentenced to twenty years in prison. Vincent and Margaret Sherry had settled in Biloxi in nineteen seventy one after traveling the world. Vince had enlisted in the Air Force in nineteen fifty one, where he spent seven years as an intelligence officer and served as a judge advocate for thirteen years. He retired at the rank of colonel. Born in February nineteen twenty nine in King's, New York, Vincent Sherry grew up in Paducah, Kentucky. He attended Western Kentucky University, where he received a Bachelor of Arts degree, Middle Tennessee State University where he received a Master of Arts degree, the University of Southern Mississippi where he received a PhD, And George Washington University where he received a Bachelor of Law's degree. He had earned what they used to call a juris doctor.
7:08 Vince was licensed to practice law in Virginia, Kentucky, and Mississippi. He was also able to practice in the Court of Customs and Patent Appills, the US Tax Court, and the Court of Military Appills. He also taught at the University of Southern Mississippi for eight years. He taught upper division and graduate political science and criminal justice classes. If it isn't already apparent, Vincent Sherry was a brilliant man. He spoke five languages and did his doctoral thesis on the judicial system of South Vietnam. He was like a walking encyclopedia, and he loved using obscure words to keep his family on their toes. His daughter Lynd said that her father fervently believed ignorance, not evil, to be humanities worst sin. In nineteen eighty one, he began a criminal law practice in Biloxi with his partner Pete Hallett. They defended many Dixie Mafia members, including the Godfather Mister Mike, and Hallett's big client was another big gun named Kirksey Nix in prison for life. Nicks ran all illegal activity inside the prison and a lot on the outside. Pete Hallett defended him from nineteen seventy nine to nineteen eighty eight. By July of nineteen eighty six, when Vince was appointed as a Circuit court judge, he and Pete Hallett had built a lucrative practice.
8:41 His skills as a defense attorney really helped him as a judge. He was considered very fair, not partial to either side, and so kind to defendants that they actually sent him thank you cards and Christmas cards after he sent them to prison. Pete Hallett later said it was because he talked to defend, explaining carefully why he was sending them to prison, but Vince Sherry wasn't without his faults. He had a mercurial temper that wasn't helped by his high blood pressure and frequent headaches. He and Margaret could fight viciously, and he had very high standards for his children and could often seem distant. He also had a sharp sense of humor, almost biting at times, with a gift for choosing spot on nicknames for people whether they liked it or not, but his family still adored and revered him. He was well known and beloved in the community as a very generous man, kind to strangers and a friend to all. And though he wasn't necessarily handsome in a classic sense, he was magnetic, much to his wife's annoyance, as many women were drawn to him.
9:54 Margaret Joyce Smith was born in July of nineteen twenty nine in Mooring Sport, Louisiana, but grew up in Kentucky in Bowling Green. She attended Western Kentucky University and was a schoolteacher for a while. She and Vince met at Western, and they married in nineteen fifty, both at age twenty one, before Vince joined the Air Force. Margaret was a force to be reckoned with as well. She was a Biloxi City councilwoman from nineteen eighty one to nineteen eighty five, and she ran for mayor as a Republican in nineteen eighty five, but lost to incumbent Mayor Gerald Blessie, who was her sworn nemesis.
10:37 She outwardly hated him and made no bones about it. Margaret was an old style Republican and bless He was a Liberal Democrat and a decorated Vietnam War veteran. He described himself as a reformer and he was popular in Biloxi's poor black community. Biloxi's economy at the time was in the shedder. The fancy old hotels on the waterfront were practically bankrupt due to a huge slump and tourism. Mayor Gerald Blessie had a plan for a new waterfront with a new two hundred room hotel and a French style marketplace. Naturally, the old hotel owners opposed this, knowing they would definitely be thrown out of business, and well to do Biloxians off West Beach and North would rather see municipal funds used to pay streets and fill potholes, but Blessi's plan proposed fourteen hundred new jobs while promising to preserve the history and culture of Biloxi. It was definitely a city divided, with a margin of only five hundred votes, letting Blessie keep his job.
11:48 But Margaret wasn't going anywhere. She planned to run again for mayor in nineteen eighty nine. In the meantime, she showed up to every city council meeting to oppose Mayor Blessi and his policies, and she used the voter referendum process to accomplish blocking his proposals and goals. She often accused him of associating with crime and vice leaders of the underworld and backroom deals. She accused him of misspending government funds, something the FBI did look into because Biloxi officials had released one hundred and sixty thousand dollars of HUD grant funds to start development costs without federal approval. The mayor and company basically claimed that they had verbal authorization and they just didn't have it in writing. Despite this and an IRS audit, Blessi mostly came out clean, but many people believed that after Vince had been appointed to the bench, Margaret had a damn good chance of winning in nineteen eighty nine. Gerald Blessie, in turn, also made no secret of his hate for Margaret Sherry. He called her a racist and pointed out to the press that her husband was the one who profited from crime as a criminal defense attorney. It was ugly and it was very public. When the Sherry's were found murdered. Their granddaughter, Kathy was devastated. She was especially close
13:20 to her grandmother and had even helped with her first mayoral campaign. She talked on the phone to Margaret all the time about Biloxi corruptions and scandals. When her mother, Lynne broke the news to her, Kathy remarked, where the hell was Gerald Blessie. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. On Monday, September fourteenth, nineteen eighty seven, Vince and Margaret had a fairly normal day. Vince went to court that morning for his normal docket, and then got a haircut, and then he filled up his car with gas because he and Margaret were going to bat and Rouge the next day to visit their youngest daughter, Leslie at college. He chatted for a while with his law partner Pete Hallett. Before he got home and went for a jog.
14:20 Margaret did some work herself. She was constantly telling friends and family that she was about to expose major corruption in city hall. She did some work on her upcoming mayoral campaign, and then she went shopping for a few new dresses and electric calculators for her office. She spoke to three different friends later that day about how she was working with the FBI and planned to help put Mayor Gerald Blessie in jail. One of her friends warned her she shouldn't talk like that without proof. Margaret answered, don't you understand I have the goods. I have documentation. She told her friends she intended to make her claim public at the city council meeting the next day, when the city's new budget was set to be adopted. According to author Edward Humes and his book Mississippi Mud, her last call was cut off abruptly. The friend had heard Vince in the background complaining about being hungry and wanting to go to dinner, so she assumed Margaret just hung up to deal with him. The next day.
15:24 No one missed them. Everyone knew they were supposed to be in Baton Rouge. Leslie didn't raise the alarm, so maybe she thought they had changed their minds. One of their dogs was scheduled to have a cataract removed, so maybe that had delayed them. By Wednesday morning, though Vince was due in court, the court's staff called his law partner, Pete Hallett a little before nine am. When Vince Hutton shown up. Pete tried to call the Sherry house, but he didn't get an answer. At eleven am, he went over to the house with his law firm associate, Charles Leaguer. He stepped in the house briefly and then shouted for the neighbor to call the police.
16:07 He told Charles Leaguer that Vince and Margaret were both dead. Police went in the house and found the Sherry's docks and Moe barking and growling next to Vince's body, protecting him. When they walked to the bedroom, Mo raced in there and stood over Margaret, barking and burying his fans. Later this detail was hard for police and the Sherry kids. Vince and Margaret had two docsins Mo and Fritz, who they doated on. They called them the boys. Lynn and her siblings felt like the boys never would have led a stranger in the house without barking or biting them, even they ferociously protected their masters.
16:51 They thought it had to be someone the Sherry's knew. They pointed out to the cops that the dogs had not attacked Pete Hallett. Later investigators would come to believe that Vince opened the door to the killer who put a gun in his face, so he showed the dogs into his bedroom where Margaret was and quickly shut the door. Margaret probably just thought someone was at the door Vince needed to talk to, so we got the dogs out of the way. There's no indication she was alarmed. And then Vince came back to face the man who shot him from two feet away, sending him flailing backwards, sprang blood on the walls and ceiling. He was shot in the mouth, shattering his teeth. Margaret had been undressing for the evening. She was clad only in her bra and underwear, and she had one earring in her hand, as if she had been removing her jewelry. There was no blood spray.
17:48 She was shot four times point blank in the head, and just one stream of blood flowed from her temple onto her body. She was slumped against the bed with her feet under the dresser, like she had just slid down. There were two bullets in the wall, so if she heard those, she may have had a moment to turn and see her killer, but she may not have heard them at all. Police found a rubber foam around their wounds and the floor around their bodies. It looked as though someone had shot through a pillow or used a homemade silencer, which made sense as Margaret was clearly caught off guard. She hadn't heard the shots her husband had suffered, and probably not the two that went in the wall near where she was standing.
18:33 With one bullet left in the gun, the assassin went back to where Vince lay. From the amount of blood around his body, detectives believed he had been alive when the killer went for Margaret. The killer then shot Vince in the face again, hitting just below his right eye, finishing him off. The dogs had not been harmed as the killer fled, and they had been in the house for a day guarding their dead master's Multiple departments helped search the crime scene. The FBI, Mississippi Highway Patrol, Harrison County Sheriff's Department and the Biloxi Police Department, but it was the Biloxi Police who took the lead on the investigation. Pete Hallett's official story to police and the Sherry kids was that he looked in through the sliding glass store and saw the dogs, and he also saw that there was dog excrement on the rug. He said that alarmed him, so he tried the handle and it opened. He said he walked in far enough to see Vince's body before coming outside and telling a neighbor to call the police. When Lynn's Posito, the oldest Sherry daughter, pressed Pete, insisting her imagination was worse than not knowing, he just said he only saw her father, that he had clearly been shot, and he had not gone in because he didn't want to see her. Moll, the oldest Sherry child, Eric Sherry, had called Lynn from his home in Florida.
20:02 One of his Biloxi friends had called to all for condolences after he heard the news on the radio. This makes me crazy, Biloxi police, if not Pete Hallett, should have immediately made calls to the Sherry kids so they didn't find out this way. Eric said, he would call the youngest Leslie if Lynn would call vin Vincent Sherry, the third had the worst temper, and they definitely did not want him finding out from the news. When Lynn hung up with him, he was already planning on buying a gun. Lynn then had the horrific responsibility of not only telling her brother, but calling other family members to spread the word. After one aunt dropped the receiver screaming, Lynn hung up and couldn't do it anymore. She was waiting for her husband to get home. Dick Sposito was her rock, but he traveled a lot, so she hadn't even been able to get on the phone with him right away.
21:00 When he called back and she told him, he immediately said he would get home as soon as possible, but he was in Paris and couldn't get a flight until the next day, so Lynne had a full day to wait for the comfort of her husband's arms, and she still had to tell her children, who adored their grandparents. Lynn and her family lived in North Carolina, and so did her brother, Vin. Eric was in Florida and Leslie was in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. The message they gave each other was get home. Now as fast as you can. Lynne went and picked up her sixteen year old daughter Kathy first, who immediately made the remark about Margaret's nemesis, Mayor Gerald Blessy. A neighbor who had come to sit with Lynn, offered to go pick up her youngest seven year old Beth at the bus stop and keep her at her house for a while until Lynn could tell the older kids and make more phone calls. After picking up Kathie and breaking the news, Lynn picked up her thirteen year old son Tommy from Junior High and told him as well, and then she waited for her siblings. Leslie and Eric were driving into Biloxi while Lynne caught the next flight to Biloxi with her kids.
22:18 Vinn was waiting to fly on the next day so he could bring his wife. Once they were all together, they headed straight to the Hallett and Sherry law office to meet with Pete Hallett. He had told them to come to see him first, and they trusted him. He had told Eric he would use his contacts to find out as much as he could. Lynn left her two youngest children with a friend, but sixteen year old Kathi insisted on coming to Pete Hallett greeted them warmly, hugging Lynn. He promised he would help them in any way he could, But just as Eric was about to ask the first question, Pete cut him off. He said, listen, there's something you need to understand. There is nothing you can do to bring your parents back to life. Nothing. The best thing you can do is drop it. Shocked Eric and Lynn asked, was it BLESSI? Is that why you want us to drop it? But Pete Hallett would not elaborate.
23:18 As they were leaving, Kathi Spozito, Margaret's fiery granddaughter, said I don't trust him. Lynn tried to give Pete the benefit of the doubt. He was her father's best friend, and though he was well known and loved in Biloxi, Vince didn't have many close friends. A joint funeral for the Sherry's was held on September nineteenth, nineteen eighty seven, at Nativity Cathedral. Pete Hallett gave the eulogy. He reportedly said he was so close to the couple that he considered them family. The Clarion Ledger described the stories Hallett told in his eulogy as giving attendees both pause and levity. Why has God deemed to take Vincent and Margaret away from us and allow a wild animal to remain among us? He intoned from the podium. Hallett later passed out copies of his eulogy to members of the media. He had his own political ambitions and didn't waste this moment for publicity. Despite how tasteless it was. Pete Hallett had been dismissed almost immediately as a suspect. Even though he was the last to see Vince and the person to find the bodies. They found his story credible.
24:37 After some digging, they found that Vince had been turned down on a life insurance policy for the law practice due to his high blood pressure, so Pete didn't have a financial motive, and besides, Vince was his best friend. As the investigation continued, some people told the police that Vince had received threats since he had started practic sing law in Biloxi, but Pete Hallett said Vince never told him about any threats. He said, if there had been threats, I am positive he would have told me. But starting in nineteen eighty one, the Sherry couple received letters from someone named Bryce Hundeman, who opposed some of the couple's political opinions. In nineteen eighty six, Vince put an ad in the paper that said, in all caps, invitation to Bryce Hundeman. As you probably know, I have been appointed to the Circuit Judges bench to replace Judge Griffin. In view of your long interest in my professional activities, I certainly hope to see you at my installation reception. When townspeople were getting frustrated that the murders weren't solved within a few days, the Biloxi Public Safety director said, it will take time. It was a professional job.
25:51 It'll be very difficult for us to solve. Only a few days after the murders, Gulf Coast businessmen put their money together to make a fifty thousand dollars reward for information that would be around one hundred and eleven thousand today. The Sherrys lived across the street from a golf course. In hopes of finding evidence, the police searched the golf course and a pawd on the course, but found nothing. The police immediately said that Mayor Gerald Blessy had been out of town during the murders, and also the next night uncharacteristically missing a council meeting. As far as they were concerned, Blessy was dropped as a suspect.
26:34 The Sherry kids were angry about this. Blessy was the prime suspect in their minds, not that he murdered their parents himself, but that he had set it up and now it was his police station and his detectives investigating the murders. From the start, police believed the murders were the work of a professional because there was nothing missing from the house. There was no sign of fourced century Police wondered if maybe a criminal judge Sherry had sentenced was getting revenge on the judge. But after talking to Lynn, they found out that Vince's black appointment book was missing. They held this back in the media, hoping to find a suspect, even though common sense would tell you the killer probably already disposed of it. Police took Vince's files from his time as a defense attorney and also from when he was a judge. They wanted to look through them to see if they could find anyone who had motive to kill the Sherris.
27:33 A neighbor came nervously to Lynn because he had seen a car the night the Sherrys were murdered. He was nervous because it looked like an unmarked police car. The yellow car was found two days later. It had been stolen and the tags replaced, but Biloxi police immediately dismissed it as pertinent to the case, again angering Lynn. She felt it was a good lead. In March of night eighty eight, a new task force took over and reviewed everything the previous task force had done to see if they had missed anything. In September of nineteen eighty eight, it was announced by Biloxi's public safety director that the Sherry's son, Eric, was a suspect in the murders. He said that Eric's friends told them he would be in Biloxi that weekend before his parents were murdered. He also said that Eric did not register sufficient emotion after his parents were killed, and he refused to take a lie detector test. Many people handled grief differently, some growing numb, especially when among strangers. Also, it had already been proven that Eric was in Florida when his parents were murdered. This was all bullshit and a cruel reason to go after Eric.
28:49 Eric said that he and other families did refuse to take a polygraph the week of the murders, but he went back later to take one and was told by the Harrison County sheriff that it wouldn't be necessary. This is because while questioning Lynn, they told her they suspected one of her siblings because they found out he was adopted. It was a huge family secret. Eric was actually Vince's nephew. He and Margaret took aim when he was a baby. He had never guessed why he looked so different from his siblings. His father had been of Asian descent, and while Eric didn't look Asian, he did have very dark hair and was dark complected, unlike the rest of his family.
29:33 Lynn begged the police not to tell him. She and all the siblings would comply to polygraphs if they promised not to tell Eric. She didn't want him to find out this way. Lynn also claimed that she had initially agreed to the polygraph but only if other Bilocks the officials were tested. The police denied. She said that to them, Lynn had to tell her brother he was adopted. That's why the police were looking at him so hard. He said. It was one of the worst moments of his life, like when he heard his parents were dead, he felt alone and empty. Later in that September of nineteen eighty eight, police held a press's conference to give an update.
30:18 They said they had no concrete motive, no concrete suspects, and no plan to drop the investigation. In response, Lynd told the press quote, A year without results is long enough. You don't know whether it's genuine ignorance or a very sloppy cover up. By mid nineteen eighty nine, there were rumors that Vince had been involved in a money scam involving angle of prison inmates. There were also rumors that Pete Hallett met with two inmates to plan the Sherry murders. Of course, Pete Hallett said he wasn't involved. He said, quote, let me once again state that any suggestion I was involved in the ending of the murder of Vincent and Margaret Sherry as an outright lie.
31:04 The local police investigated the murders for two years, but didn't get anywhere, So the FBI came back in in nineteen eighty nine and Special Agent Keith Bell started investigating the murders alongside the new Biloxi Police Captain Randy Cook, they found three hundred and forty five phone calls between Pete Hallett's office and the Angola prison in Louisiana. The calls ranged from December nineteen eighty six until September fifteenth, nineteen eighty seven, the day after the Sherry's were murdered. When they asked Pete Hallett who the calls were with, he said they were between a law office aide and his client, Kirksey Knicks. Kirksy Knicks was a former leader in the Dixie Mafia, now imprisoned for life in Angola for murdering a grocer in New Orleans in nineteen seventy two, But in Angola business hadn't stopped for Kirksy Knicks. The team then found prison records that showed Howett had been meeting with Nicks in prison around the same time the phone calls began. Also in nineteen eighty nine, Lynn hired private investigator Rex Armistead to investigate her parents murders.
32:22 She couldn't have chosen better. Armistead had been investigating the Dixie Mafia since nineteen seventy six. I'm going to pause here for a word from our sponsors. Kirksey Nicks Junior was a strange character. He had tested with an IQ of one eighty and he was the son of a criminal appeals court judge, Kirksy Nicks Senior, and his mother had also been an attorney. He didn't grow up poor or neglected, and he didn't grow up in a life of crime. He chose it. When Rex Armistead came on board as the family's private investigator, he developed an immediate rapport with the FBI agent on the case, Keith Bell, and the new police captain Randy Cook. These men had also gained the trust of Lynn's posito, not an easy thing to do, after all she had been through throughout the investigations and later trials. She was constantly frustrated that she seemed to know more about the case than officials or the prosecutors. Bell and Cook told rex Armistead that Kirksey Nicks was in charge of a cash scam from inside prison. At the direction of Nicks, the scammers paid off guards in order to use the prison telephones. They would place ads in gay publications like The Advocate, saying they were looking for love or just
33:53 some summer fun, and asking for a phone number men would reply to the po box provided in the ad. Then the scammers would start one of their many ploys to get money out of the gay men. And all the ploys the scammers would send racy photographs to keep the game in interested. Of course, the photos weren't of themselves. They were usually beefcake pin ups. Kirksey Nick said he used the name Eddie Johnson and would send a fake photos showing himself as buff and young. He also had a gift of changing his voice to sound younger and even like a woman. Sometimes. As the scams moved on to straight men, the scammers would usually say something like they were in gel on false charges and just needed a little money to get out, and once they were out, they would be free to come to their benefactors, either for a relationship or just for a hookup. And if that didn't work, they would blackmail closeted gay men by threatening to out them. Dozens of men wired money to Knicks through U Stern Union. One man took a second mortgage out on his house and sent next one hundred thousand dollars that's about two hundred and thirty thousand dollars today. Another man sent around twenty thousand, which is about forty thousand today. And since so many of the men were closeted, once they realized they were being scammed, they were hesitant to press charges
35:23 for fear of losing their jobs and other social ruin. But some did report the scams, only to be laughed off by homophobic and corrupt police. The scam lasted from nineteen eighty six to nineteen eighty nine. If you're wondering what a man who is spending life in prison needed that money for, well, it was to bribe his way out of prison. He planned to pay for a pardon either from the parole board or from then Governor Edwin Edwards. It wasn't much of a stretch. With a corruption and local and state government. In two thousand and one, former Governor Edwards was convicted of racketeering and sentenced to ten years in prison. And though he was a popular governor in his time in office from nineteen seventy two to nineteen ninety six, he was plagued with accusations of corruption. After finding out about the Lonely Hearts scam, Rex Armistead went to Angel of Prison and met with Dixie Mafia member Bobby Joe Fabian.
36:27 He knew him well after investigating the Dixie mafia for so long. Bobby Joe was also a lifer serving time for murder and kidnapping, and he sang like a canary to Rex Armistead. He revealed that Kirksey Knicks had planted a full time associate at the Hallett and Sherry law firm to help run the scam. She was his girlfriend, Sherry La Ras Sharp. She went by La Raw a nickname. Sherry Sharp had been born in an Arkansas brothel. Her mother was a madam, and she was exploited turned out hooking for her mother. By the time she was a teen, her nickname had been Punkin for a long time, and that's what Kirksey called her. She claimed to have fallen in love with him at the age of ten when he visited her mother's bordello, but she preferred the nickname Laura and went by that, though Kirksey would often make fun of her behind her back, calling her La La.
37:25 She would go to the p O boxes for Nicks, collect the scam cash and deposit it into the law firm's trust account. But in December of nineteen eighty six, Nis found out that one hundred thousand dollars was missing from the account, though some sources put that figure around two hundred thousand. He called Pete Hallett for a face to face meeting at Angola. When Nick confronted Hallett about the missing money, he blamed it on his law partner, Vincent Sherry. Mike Gillich, known as Mister Mike, the god Father of Biloxi, was not in jail and also called for a meeting with Pete. He also profited from the Lonely Hearts scam and wanted answers. Pete Hallett again blamed his supposed best friend and partner, Vince Sherry. Bobby Joe Fabian said later in a TV interview in which he hit his face quote Howett knew that somebody was going to die, and better Sherry than him. Bobby Joe estimated that the scam had brought in around five million dollars, though again other sources say it was closer to a few hundred thousand dollars. Still no small scheme. Bobby Joe knew all of this because he had once been part of the scam.
38:44 He signed his last name in the female way b O B B I e JO. Ironically like the victim in my last episode, he also was adept at changing his voice on the phone. But he had stopped participate painting because he thought Kirksy Knicks was taking too many risks. His ego had gotten ahead of him. He thought he was untouchable. He had mister Mike on the outside, the support of not only La Raw but of course a legit law firm helping to launder the money. And Kirksey actually had a wife, a woman named Kelly k Newsome Knicks. She had been the daughter of another girlfriend of his, who he had actually adopted as his stepdaughter when she came of age and he tired of her mother. He got involved with Kelly when she was twenty two. Kirksey announced he was in love with her and wanted to marry her. She was reluctant, but Kirksey promised her that Pete Hallett, his attorney, would help with her legal issues, and he did. In nineteen eighty three, she and Kirksey were married over the phone. It was done in front of a lone judge with phony licenses, with Pete Hallett as the only witness. Kelly wouldn't find out until later that Hallett had never filed the marriage certificate. He did so in March of nineteen eighty seven at Nick's request, around the time he found out about his missing money. A wife
40:15 could not be compelled to testify against her husband, and Kelly did have a lot of drug and alcohol problems. She was arrested for a dui and they found cocaine on her and Pete. Hallett always belled her out, and she also worked some at the law firm, though she was mainly an outside runner for Kirksey. In nineteen eighty six, Pete had Kelly called Kirksey with a warning. He had told her quote, you'd better tell Kirksey he better leave those fags alone. The FBI was already looking into the scam. Over the years, as Kelly struggled with her addictions, Nicks would have to go back to La Raw Then she would get back in his good graces and show up at a beach house he owned, only to find Laura living there. It was a constant source of drama. Bobby Joe said that Laura often visited Nick in prison and got busted bringing him marijuana. That's when Bobby Joe dropped out of the scam. All the while Pete Hallett was signing legal affidavits claiming that Sherry Lauras Sharpe was a paralegal with his firm. No one knows what really happened to the money. Obviously, the family of Vincent Sherry were offended at the implication that their father had taken the money. The obvious suspect is Pete Hallett. He was already a liar and a cheat. Vince just didn't know it. But whatever Hallett did with the money, he hid it well.
41:45 Bobby Joe also told Rex Armistead that Kirksey and mister Mike had hired a legendary assassin in the Dixie Mafia named John Ransom. He was a one legged man who worked quietly out of Georgia. He had been arrested numerous times since the seventies for burglary, assault, rape, and bootlegging. He was suspected in many murders, usually men or women set to testify against someone in the Dixie Mafia. In nineteen eighty nine, as was suspected, Pete Hallett ran for mayor of Biloxi and he won. He basically ran on Margaret Sherry's back. He was the first Republican elected in Biloxi since reconstruction after the Civil War.
42:31 As Hallett continued to battle allegations public and private, the DA's office was grappling with whether or not to take the conspiracy case to trial. Agent Bell and Captain Cook, and obviously Lynn were pressuring them hard to try it, so they took it to a grand jury after weeks of studying the luminous files and deciding on the right charges for indictment. At this point it was a bitter pill to swallow but believe the accounts of people who had agreed to speak to investigators. Gerald Blessy, her mother's nemesis, was not involved. However, a federal grand jury and died of Blessy and associates for fraud, conspiracy, and extortion, and it was the investigation that Margaret Sherry was involved with that brought it all out. He went to trial, but it ended in a mistrial when the jury failed to reach a verdict. In nineteen ninety two, a judge from the second Judicial Jurisdiction of Harrison County dismissed the charges. Ironically, the same bench that Vincent Sherry had sat on. Gerald Blessey was nominated a city attorney in twenty sixteen by then Mayor Andrew Gillitch, no relation apparently to mister Mike Gilitch. Mississippi takes care of his own. Blessi eventually resigned the position later in the year, stating that at age seventy four, he was ready to retire. In nineteen eighty seven, investigators had gotten a real
44:05 break in the case. Charles Leeger came forward. He was the law firm associate with Pete Hallett the day of the murders, and later testified that Hallett said Vince and Margaret were both dead, though Pete had always claimed he didn't go into the house far enough to see Margaret. Hallett tried to explain this away, that he just assumed Margaret was dead, but Charles had been hired to take up the slack after Vince was nominated to the bench. He knew things, and he knew he had seen John Ransom before seeing his face on TV proved it. He had met up with Pete Hallett. By nineteen ninety, Kelly Nicks had come around. She had cleaned up her life, had a daughter and wanted to do the right thing. She would make an excellent witness at trial, no matter how much Nicks and his associates tried to intimidate her. John Ransom seemed to be another good witness. By then, he was a sick old man and a Mississippi prison, missing his family. He swore he hadn't killed the Sherris, but had knowledge of the murders and would give detail with immunity. He told investigators that he had refused to kill a woman, so he passed it off to another hitman, but he did provide the murder weapon with the homemade silencer. But when the DA was ready to move on indictments, Ransom had been moved to a Georgia prison closer to his family, and he refused to cooperate any longer. The prosecution was hesitant to
45:37 take it to trial, but they took it before a grand jury anyway. The indictments they asked for were for the intricate lonely Heart scam, murder, conspiracy, wire fraud, and two counts of traveling in interstate commerce from murder to hire. To everyone's surprise, the grand jury agreed, and in nineteen ninety one. Kirksey Knicks, mister Mike Gillich, John Ransom, and Sherry la Ross Sharpe were all indicted on fifteen collective counts. Pete Hallett was often mentioned in the press as an unindicted co conspirator, much to his expressive anger. He loved shouting to the press about this persecution of his character. Knicks, Gillitch, Sharp, and Ransom were indicted with conspiracy, murder, and wirefraud. Nick's, Gillich, and Ransom were indicted for murder for hire, including aiding and abetting by traveling from Louisiana to Mississippi to arrange the murder, and murder for hire for traveling between Georgia and Mississippi. The trial started in Hattiesburg, Mississippi, on September thirtieth, nineteen ninety one, four years after the Sherry murders and sliding in right before the statute of limitations would have run out on any conspiracy charges. The headlines screamed Sherry at her trial, but in reality no one was charged with their murders. The first witness up was James Dickey, a man who had come out of the closet nine years earlier
47:10 and had reported being scammed, only to be ignored by Louisiana officials uninterested in pursuing charges for a gullible gay man. But mister Dickey was an educated man, an activist, and a journalist. He had even heard of the scams and con games praying on the elderly and lonely and yes, homosexual men. He had even written about it. He was the last one to believe he could voll victim to the scam, but he had, and he made an excellent witness. Homophobia be damned. Smart and well spoken, James Dickey came across as an honest, professional man, embarrassed by what had happened to him, but not afraid to testify about it. Now. One of John Ransom's associates testified the Mike Gillisch talked to him and Ransom about a hit. The associates said he was out of town for the murders, but he claimed Ransom later admitted to him that he killed the Sherry's. The courtroom antics in this case are astounding. At one point, a fuse blue and the electricity went out in the courtroom. When the lights came back on, four bailiffs were standing around Ransom, protecting the judge, jury, and the rest of the courtroom from the legendary hit man. He had made quite the spectacle of himself at trial, and so did Kirksey Knicks. Mike Gillich went so far as to flipping the bird at reporters outside the courtroom. Sherry Lauras Sharp attacked a
48:43 reporter with her purse one day. You cannot make the shit up. I recommend reading Edward Hume's book Mississippi Mud, Southern Justice, and the Dixie Mafia for a full rundown. In fact, there is no way I could have fit even half of this Southern Gothic tale into one episode. I cannot recommend his book enough. The jury was allowed to rule in the conspiracy chart without specifying whether a defendant conspired to murder or to fraud, or both. But after six weeks of trial testimony, everyone but Sherry Larras was found guilty of conspiracy, murder, and wire fraud. Kirksey Knicks, Mike Gillich, and John Ransom were all found guilty of murder for hire for traveling between Georgia and Mississippi. Nis was sentenced to fifteen years in prison, but Of course, he was already serving a life sentence, so this was tacked onto his time, ensuring he would probably never get parole. Mister Mike also got fifteen years in prison. When he was eligible for release, he'd have to spend three years on probation. John Ransom was sentenced to ten years. When he was eligible for release, he'd also have to spend three years probation. Sherry Larras Sharpe was sentenced to one year and one week in prison for her part in the Lonely Hearts scam and wire fraud. She got a better deal for testifying against Nicks and Gillisch. When she was eligible for release, she'd have to
50:15 spend three years on probation. Then, in nineteen ninety four, mister Mike Gillich finally agreed to talk to the FBI in exchange for a shorter sentence. Gilich told the FBI exactly what Bobby Joe Fabian had said. Pete Hallett told Kirksey Nicks that Vincent Sherry stold the money in order to save his own life. He knew he was in the crosshairs up to his neck in this mess, so he threw his best friend and law partner under the bus. That's when Nicks and Gillich ordered a hit on Vincent Sherry. Nix and Gillich said they would split the cost of the hit man. They were going to hire John Ransom, but decided on a man named Thomas Hull. They hired Holcombe to kill Vincent for twenty thousand dollars around forty five thousand today. Later, they said Pete Hallett did offer to help pay, but Gillitch supposedly told him it was taken care of. Margaret Sherry's murder was just a bonus and a precaution. Mike Gillett knew that Pete Hallett wanted to run for mayor, and besides, they didn't need a do gooder Republican snooping into her husband's murder investigation.
51:30 It was a win win for all of these creeps. After all of these years, investigators finally had Pete Hallett. In nineteen ninety six, the government indicted Nick's, Sharp, Hallett, and Holcombe on fifty two charges, including racketeering, conspiracy to violate the racket Statute, fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, money laundering, and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Sherry Lauras Sharpe was charged with obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice for her false testimony that she gave in the nineteen ninety one trial. Pete Hallett was charged with conspiracy to obstruct justice based on false statements he made during the nineteen ninety one investigation and trial testimony. He was also charged with obstruction of justice, conspiracy to violate the Racketeering Statute, racketeering, and conspiracy to commit wire fraud.
52:30 And Thomas Holcombe, the trigger man, was charged with conspiracy to violate the racketeering Statute and conspiracy to obstruct justice, but not for murder. It's interesting that no one was charged with conspiracy to murder in this indictment. People always want Pete Hallett in as being a co conspirator and the murders, which she was, and yet he was never even charged with conspiracy murder. During the trial, Mike Gillich testified that Thomas Hallcombe put superglue on his fingers so that he wouldn't leave any fingerprints on the gun he used to kill the Sherry's. Gillich said he watched Holcombe put the glue on before he went over to the Sherry's house. The plan was for him to knock on the Sherry's door and then kill them. Vince Sherry did answer the door, just like the police had suspected, and Holcombe had used the yellow, unmarked car that had been stolen and then put in another lot. That was a good lead. Lynn was right. All John Ransom had done was supply the weapon with a silencer.
53:36 If that fool had turned state's evidence in the first trial, he would have gotten his immunity. He wasn't the trigger man. On July sixteenth, the jury found Nick's Sharp and Hulcombe guilty of all charges. They found Pete Hallett only guilty of obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice. The judge asked the jury to try and deliberate again on the remaining charges against Tallet. On July seventeenth, the jury found Hallett also guilty of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to violate the racketeering Statute. On September twenty second, nineteen ninety seven, Hallett was sentenced to two hundred and sixteen months for a Rico conspiracy one hundred and twenty months for obstruction of justice, sixty months for conspiracy to obstruct justice, and sixty months for conspiracy to commit mail fraud for his part in the Lonely Hearts scam. The sentences were to be served concurrently for a total of eighteen years in prison. While sentencing Pete Hallett, the judge said if mister Hallett had been truthful about the missing money in the beginning, the Sherry's would not be dead. Kirksey Nicks got another life sentence in prison.
54:52 He will most certainly die there. Thomas Holcombe also got life in prison. Sherry laur Sharp was sentenced to five years after Pete Hallett was found guilty. Lynn Sherry shook mister Mike's hand and thanked him. I want to say thank you, thank you for telling the truth. You're the only one who would and I just wanted to say thank you, she said, sobbing. Mister Mike just kept saying I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Mister Mike, after spending time in prison away from his family, had a total change of heart. After court he caught up to Lynn and said, I'm so sorry.
55:35 I only thought of what I was doing for my family. I never thought of what I was doing to anybody else's. I'm so sorry for what I did to your family. Lynn later said he really, honestly was as repentant as you can get. It wasn't an act. Mike Gillet received an early release because he helped with the investigation, and he was led out in two thousand. He died of cancer in April twenty twelve at the age of eighty two. Kirksey Knicks is currently incarcerated in the El Reno Federal Correctional Institution in el Reno, Oklahoma. He is seventy seven years old. Thomas Holcombe died in prison on April eighth, two thousand and five. He was fifty two years old. John Ransom was released on November seventh, two thousand and three, whereabouts unknown, but he would be ninety three years old. Neither Hayley, my research assistant, nor I could find an obituary for Ransom, so he could still be alive. Pete Hallett was released from a Montgomery, Alabama, federal prison in March two twelve. Then he went to a halfway house in Hattiesburg. He worked as a handyman at Saint Thomas Catholic Church on the University of Southern Mississippi Campus. Seventy year old Hallett was released from the Halfway House in April of twenty thirteen. As of two seventeen, how it, was living in Ocean Springs with his wife, Sandra Haley, and I could
57:05 not find an obituary on him either, so we assume he is still alive. He would be seventy seven years old by now. Ironically, the Sherry murders are technically still open cases. No one was ever charged with their murders, but mister Mike, the godfather of Biloxi and leader of the Dixie Mafia, had broken their one code, thou shalt not snitch to the copse. He had never served time before, and after a few years in prison, old and away from his family, he broke. He finally saw the pain of Lynn's posito and her family. As she and her family did feel he was truly repentant, they forgave him. I've spoken before about the power of forgiveness. Somehow, Lynne and her family found peace with Mike Gilich's confession.
58:00 The people that killed their parents were finally punished, and Lynn and her family were finally able to move on with their lives. Lynn and her siblings obviously still miss their parents. Today, she watches her grandchildren and fills an ache that they will never know her mother and father. That's a loss that never goes away, and she still chooses forgiveness. Southern Fried's True Crime is written and produced by me Erica Kelly. The original graphic art is by Coley Horner, and Southern Fried's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio. Thank you so much to Haley Gray for her diligent research assistance in this complicated case, and thank you to author Edward Humes for his amazing book, Mississippi Mud.
58:50 He opens his book with an explanation of what Mississippi Mud meant. It's a poker game. It's a game where the cards are irrelevant. The point is to bluff and try a fellow players. It's a fantastic metaphor for the shary murders. I have a few listeners to thank for suggesting this case Casey Porter, Eileen Mace, Andrew Stewart. Thanks guys, you picked a good one. Please remember to practice social distancing, wash your hands, and think of your friends, family and neighbors. We all need to do our part. Stay home and stay safe. If you need to go out, wear a mask. It's not full proof, so keep your distance from others, but it's better than nothing. Look on YouTube for videos on how to make masks out of bandanas or leggings. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on most large platforms like Stitcher and Spotify, as well as Stitcher Premium, where you can listen ad free. If you have any case suggestions, please email Southern Fried Truecrime at gmail dot com. I'm sorry, but I no longer answer private messages of social media. I managed three platforms and it's just too overwhelming, but please feel free to reach out by email. Not only do I get my most interesting and little known cases from listener suggestions, I love hearing from you guys, So until next time, thanks so much for listening. Wash your hands, stop touching your face, and y'all take care.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed