Sept. 4, 2023

Annalisa Netherly & the History of The Read House

Annalisa Netherly & the History of The Read House
Annalisa Netherly & the History of The Read House
Southern Fried True Crime
Annalisa Netherly & the History of The Read House

In 1927, a young woman met a violent end in a Chattanooga hotel. Reports on how she came to her death are mixed, but the legend of her gruesome story persists almost 100 years later, and for good reason. The tragic young woman’s spirit is said, along...

In 1927, a young woman met a violent end in a Chattanooga hotel. Reports on how she came to her death are mixed, but the legend of her gruesome story persists almost 100 years later, and for good reason. The tragic young woman’s spirit is said, along with the ghosts of many others, some from the Civil War era, to haunt not only the room where she died but the entire establishment where she spent her final days. Fire, flood, a near-duel, and an infamous mobster are all part of the colorful, yet macabre and paranormal legend of the south’s longest continuously running - though still magnificent - hotel. This is the history of Annalisa Netherly and the Read House in Chattanooga, Tennessee.

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Gemma Harris
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley

To enter the lottery for a night in room 311:
https://www.thereadhousehotel.com/311-package/

This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:15 Southern fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. In nineteen twenty seven, the city of Chattanooga, Tennessee, was thriving off the back of the early twentieth century industrial boom. The hospitality sector, in particular was enjoying a renaissance, largely due to the relaunch of a well known local establishment called the Red House a year earlier. Following extensive renovations. The Chattanooga institution, which played a seminal role in the city's development and identity, was a popular destination for city residents and tourists alike. At the time, Extended hotels days for out of towners like Annelisa Netherley weren't unusual. After arriving in Chattanooga from San Francisco, the young woman checked into room three eleven of the Red House one morning during Annalysee's stay. Housekeeping staff received a gruesome shock.

1:23 Lying in the bathtub of the three bedroom suite was Annelisa's lifeless body, her head almost severed and her corpse largely submerged beneath the bloody water. How could a young woman so far from home have come to such a brutal end. Welcome to Episode one ninety two, Annelisa Netherley and the History of the Red House. Nestled in the southeast of Tennessee, at the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains and alongside the Tennessee River, the city of Chattanooga lies just north of the border with the State of Georgia, immortalized in the Glen Miller version of the nineteen forty one jazz standard Chattanooga choo Chow. The city came into its own in the mid nineteenth century with the arrival of the railroad. According to author Allan Brown and his book Haunted Tennessee Ghosts and Strange Phenomena of the Volunteer State, local businessman Thomas Crutchfield Senior promised officials from the State of Georgia, which owned the Western and Atlantic Railroad, that if Chattanooga was placed on the route, he would construct a hotel to accommodate passengers. Thomas Senior secured the perfect spot in the downtown area on what was then Ninth Street, straight across from Union Station. He later became Mayor of Chattanooga in eighteen forty seven, Crutchfield House opened with a three story hotel, eagerly awaiting its first guests arriving

2:57 by rail from Atlanta in May of eighteen fifty. When Thomas Senior died that same year, the running of the hotel was passed to his son, Thomas Jr. As the local economy boomed over the next decade, crutchvill House prospered as one of Chattanooga's biggest, finest, and first hotels. It became a buzzing social hub where both locals and guests met to discuss pressing matters like politics, business, and development deals. But in the background, political instability was rumbling. With the American Civil War looming on the horizon. Tensions rose in Chattanooga on January twenty first, eighteen sixty one, when former Senator Jefferson Davis was on his way back to Mississippi after tendering his resignation to the US Senate.

3:49 During a stopover at the Crutchfield House, Davis gave an impromptu speech in the lobby urging the importance of Tennessee seceding from the Union and joining the Confederacy. Thomas Junior's younger brother, William, who was a staunch Union supporter loudly denounced Davis as a renegade and trader. The heated argument escalated, almost culminating in a duel. As the click of cocked pistols could be heard. Just in Tom Thomas Junior spirited his brother out of the room, narrowly avoiding violence. Seeing the riding on the wall, Thomas Junior made the decision to sell Crutchfield House. He continued to enjoy financial success after the war, opening a general merchandise store on Market Street. Chattanooga itself played a pivotal role in the Civil War as a Confederate rail hub for transporting soldiers, essential supplies, and raw materials, with Crutchfield House designated as local Confederate headquarters. But early in September eighteen sixty three, after Union soldiers occupied the city, the hotel was converted to a military hospital for wounded Union soldiers during the Battle of Chickamauga.

5:01 In one day alone, on the last of the brutal and bloody conflict, around five hundred men were taken in for treatment. Almost four thousand Union and Confederate soldiers died at Chickamauga, including those who died both armies combined had losses of thirty four thousand. Sadly, many men lost their lives at Crutchfeld House during the war, succumbing to their injuries sustained in battle. Their bodies were stored in the basement, which served as a temporary morgue, but the spirits of some never left, leaving an eerie paranormal imprint on the grounds which pervades to this day. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break.

5:47 It wasn't just soldiers who died at the makeshift hospital during this time. According to one account, a Union soldier got into an argument with a sex worker in his room over payment and ended up killing the woman. Even after one hundred and sixty years, her ghost is still said to haunt the historic building. Just three years after the war had ended, the Tennessee River flooded Chattanooga in March of eighteen sixty seven, the largest flood in recorded city history. After a four day storm, the river rose fifty seven feet, inflicting severe structural damage to many of the city's buildings. Streets were at least four feet under water, and the lobby of the crutch Filled House was flooded. This flood was the catalyst for the city raising street level by one story to minimize the impact of future flooding. The hotel's fortunes continued looking bleak when it was destroyed by fire just six months later, after ablaze broke out in the oil room. Could it be that the lost and lonely spirits of the soldiers who had died on the site during the Civil War had somehow cursed the building?

6:57 If they had, it did not deter Surgeant John Reid and his wife Caroline from buying the former hotel in eighteen seventy one, which was now an office building on the corner of Broad and Ninth Streets. Read envisioned turning the premises back into Chattanooga's grandest hotel, dedicated to providing the finest in Southern hospitality. The Reds had a hotel in their hometown on Mcmanville, Tennessee, which burned down before they moved to Chattanooga in eighteen seventy one. On New Year's Day eighteen seventy two, the new forty five room hotel was ready and now renamed the Red House. Seven years later, in eighteen seventy nine, John sold the business to his nineteen year old son, Samuel Robertson read. During this period, the hotel was again temporarily used as a hospital, this time treating those afflicted by the eighteen seventy three cholera outbreak, which killed one hundred and two people, followed by the eighteen seventy eight yellow fever epidemic, which claimed one hundred and forty lives. From the late nineteenth century onwards, more improvements were made, including electric lighting, a fourth story, telephones in every room, a billiard's room, Turkish baths, a rail ticket office, expansion to two hundred and fifty guest rooms, and a dedicated retail space on the ground floor. But despite all the upgrades and progress, accidents at the hotel continued to claim lives. In nineteen sixteen, thirty year old traveling Nashville salesman Lane

8:31 mcquittie was sitting writing a letter to his mother died after a hydraulic pressure tank burst, ripping through the hotel walls in a massive explosion. In a separate incident, another man died after falling down an elevator shaft. Despite these tragic accidents, like his father, Samuel Reid was a constant innovator and had bigger dreams for the Red House. In nineteen twenty five, much of the existing hotel was demolished, apart from one twenty rooms, in preparation for Samuel's ambitious revitalization plan. The following year, construction was complete on the ten story, four hundred room Georgian Revival style building, costing a whopping two point five million or just over forty three million today. On July fifth, nineteen twenty six, the fully renovated Reedhouse was officially launched. Appointed with all the latest modern facilities combined with luxury, the lobby instantly conveyed a feeling of grandeur. Its soaring arches and magnificent columns beneath vaulted ceilings with bronze light fixtures, two large chandeliers, marble Toronto floors, richly upholstered furniture, and exquisitely carved Russian walnut paneling exuded opulence. The newest wing consisted of two hundred and eighty rooms, decked out with walnut furniture. Amenities available included a drug store, floor, travel bureau, barber shop, coffee shop, riding room, beauty shop,

10:05 tea room, and two private dining rooms. Twenty five foot ceilings were a feature of the elaborate silver Ball Room, along with Waterford crystal chandeliers, silver leaf ornamental cornices, solid silver sconces, and an oak floor, while the two hundred and twenty seat public dining room delighted patrons with crystal light fixtures, gold damask drapes, and soft blue china. The large scale improvements were even featured in an impressive eighteen page spread of the July nineteen twenty six edition of the Hotel monthly magazine, including full page photos and floor plans. But even after the hotel's spectacular face lived, the restless spirits of those who spent their last days on the premises continued to make themselves known. Civil War soldiers who died in the former military hospital began appearing in the mirror of the Silver Ball Room when no one else was around, as well as roaming the fourth floor.

11:05 The presence of a very young spirit, perhaps a child, had also been reported on the second floor. Not every guest who checked into the revamped Redhouse would check out. When Annelisa Netherley arrived in nineteen twenty seven from San Francisco for an extended stay, no one could have guessed what would happen. Unfortunately, not much is known about Annelisa. Reports vary as to whether she arrived in Chattanooga with her husband or on her own. Nevertheless, she checked into room three eleven on unknown business. There are several accounts of how Annelisa met a sorry and gruesome end. The most off repeated version has it that when her husband returned to their room one day following a meeting, he found her with another man. Enraged with jealousy, he slit Anelisa's throat with a razor in the bathtub where she was, almost decapitating her. This is where her body was later discovered, her head hanging over the side of the tub.

12:07 A different version claims Annelisa was a sex worker who was killed by a client she checked into the hotel with after he found she was entertaining other men. Other stories say Annelisa took her own life after a man she had taken a fancy too took up with another woman, or simply that her husband abandoned her for someone else. Overwhelmed with heartbreak following their rejection, she died by suicide. I have no idea how it'd be possible to die by almost cutting your own head off, but the details in this instance are lost to history. To add to the mystery, there's nothing from this time formally documenting Annelisa's death. If indeed her manner of death was a homicide, it's not even clear whether her murderer was brought to justice. Following Annelisa's death, guests staying in room three eleven began reporting all manner of unexplained occurrences. Unusual noises, objects, moving flickering lights, a heavy and despondent presence, a feeling of being watched, touched while in bed, and sudden running water are common as our shadowy figures in the room. Guests often experienced someone knocking on the door, but no one in sight when the door is opened. On one occasion, the phone in room three eleven repeatedly rang for a male guest staying there, but every time he picked up, no one was on the line.

13:35 According to author Alan Brown, in August of two thousand and seven, a couple staying in the room each had chilling experiences. Around three thirty am one morning, the woman awoke to the sound of something like a marble rolling across the bathroom floor before the open bathroom door closed on its own. The following night, her husband had just come to bed after finishing some work on his laptop around three am. Just as he was drifting off to sleep, he saw the shadow of someone next to the bed, followed by the sense that the shadow was pressing its face close to the man's own. The shadow suddenly disappeared before moving to the dresser, waking the man's wife. To this day, Anna Lisa's restless spirit is believed to haunt not just from three eleven, but other parts of the hotel, especially the third floor. She has also said to have been spotted inside the mezzanine level restroom. Anna Lisa takes an intense dislike to mail guests, especially those who smoke, with many men at the hotel reporting their cigarettes and cigars being extinguished by an unknown force. According to author Susan Sawyer in her book Myths and Mysteries of Tennessee, one hotel employee of thirty years had always dismissed the stories about Anna Lisa until one day he saw a confused looking woman in a nightgown at the open door to room three eleven. When the employee returned with another staff member to help the woman,

15:05 she was gone. The door was now shut and locked from the inside and could not be unlocked for love or money. Not everyone who stays in Room three eleven reports unexplained events or paranormal activity, but others have found their experience so frightening. It's not uncommon for terrified guests to present at the front desk in the middle of the night requesting a new room. As recently as Halloween twenty twenty, a woman staying in Room three eleven with her husband sought assistance just before midnight. She had found him lying on the floor, shaking and cursing people in a deep, uncharacteristic voice. Staff described the man's behavior as something like a possession. Despite its grisly morbid history, the Reed House was still the place to see and be seen, even if you were an infamous mobster. In nineteen thirty one, the hotel played host to Al Capone as he awaited trial in Chicago on federal tax of Asian charges. The notorious mob boss stayed under police garden room three eleven, where Annelisa Netherley died just four years earlier, in which the hotel was having trouble renting out for obvious reasons, but now custom iron bars were installed on the windows to prevent Capone from escaping. For the record, he didn't report any unusual happenings in his room. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. Following Samuel

16:37 Reid's death eleven years after al Capone stayed there in nineteen forty two. The hotel changed hands multiple times, and as the face of travel started changing in the nineteen sixties, with motor ends taking off across the country, the Reid House expanded its accommodations in nineteen sixty two. This cost one point six million or sixteen point five million today. A one hundred and six room, six story motel was added in a rear wing, complete with outdoor pool and parking garage, catering to tourists traveling on the interstate. Today, the former motel is known as the Manor Wing. The Reed House's significance as part of the historical and architectural fabric of Chattanooga was then cemented in nineteen seventy six, when it was added to the National Register of Historic Places. After flying under the flag of Best Western, Radisson and then Starwood Hotels, which runs Sheraton, the Reed House was sold in twenty sixteen to Aveasett Hospitality Group founded by Charleston attorney, developer and hotel manager John Whites from South Carolina, specializing in restoring historic properties. They also run the Todds Hotel in Charleston, South Carolina, and a boutique art hotel in Charleston known as The Vendue. In two thousand four, Starwood Sheraton conducted a twelve million dollar Florida ceiling renovation, opening Porter Steakhouse inside the hotel. A twenty seven million dollar renovation project worth thirty four

18:08 million today commenced, including a complete overhaul and modernization of all guest rooms. The hotel's main entrance was also relocated from Broad Street back to the front of the hotel, where it originally was on what is now Martin Luther King Junior Boulevard. Ninth Street was renamed around nineteen eighty one, the hotel was returned to its former glory, providing guests with a nostalgic yet tastefully elegant step back in time to the jazz era of the Roaring twenties. The iron bars on the windows of Room three eleven were reinstalled to give guests an authentic experience of what al Capone's stay was like, but things didn't always go as smoothly as contractors hoped. In renovating Room three eleven, for a start, they couldn't even open the door, which was the only one in the hotel that wouldn't budge. Even attempts to remove the handle were feudal, resulting in workers having to cut a hole through the door with a saw. Three eleven was also the only room where pipes burst during renovations in the middle of the night when all was quiet. One tiler reported online that while working in the room, there was an uneasy feeling in the fire alarm kept going off, only ceasing when the contractors finished their work. In twenty eighteen, the Reed House was officially relaunched to great fanfare. Two hundred and forty one guest rooms now had modern bathrooms, new furnishings, and of course the latest TV's and Wi Fi access. But one room is styled differently from all the rest, remaining truly

19:44 faithful to yesteryear with no modern electronics like a hair dryer, coffee maker, many refrigerator, or TV. And it's entirely intentional. The scuffed gray door to Room three eleven can only be accessed with a physical key as opposed to a typical access card. The room was restored as authentically as possible, looking much the same as it would have during annalysa Netherly stay back in nineteen twenty seven. There's distressed hardwood floors, ornately card Victorian era furniture, including a velvet sofa, a marble topped coffee table, antique rotary phone, a vintage claw foot tub, pool chain toilet, and an AM radio for display purposes.

20:26 The goal was to make Anna Lisa's spirit fill at home as opposed to future guests. The first people to stay in Room three eleven following the revamp had a somewhat eventful visit. The hotel chose these guests by emailing all past guests asking if they would like to stay in the room. According to the Hamilton County Herald, the couple were healthy skeptics and even set up a video camera. Apparently, shadows moving at night were detected. The woman felt something grab her wrist in the bedroom, later developing a large fresh bruise. Later that night, trying to make sense of the unexplained noises in the room, the woman felt the bed move, shaking her husband awake. The woman felt something brush the back of her neck. The next morning, as the couple prepared to leave, the man closed the door on the living room cabinet, which he noticed was open when he looked again. A few minutes later.

21:22 The cabinet drawer above was fully open too. But it's not just guests who have experienced odd things. In Room three eleven, staff has seen the pull chain on the toilet swing back and forth with no breeze, and the door on the living room cabinet slowly open. Other spirits in the hotel continued to show up in photographs following the hotel's relaunch, According to the Chattanooga Times Free Press, and one picture of a woman taken inside the new lobby, the face of John T. Reid is said to be seen on the wall behind her. On a different occasion, an employe took a selfie in the hotel's offices, now on the base. Only afterward did she realize that a detailed, yet disembodied hand was resting on her left shoulder in the picture. The Readhouse celebrated its one hundred and fiftieth anniversary last year. In twenty twenty two, There's no doubt that as the longest continuously operating hotel in the Southeast, it has remained a prominent stalwart of downtown Chattanooga, its rich social and cultural significance spanning the generations. The hotel doesn't shy away from its spine tingling paranormal history, but instead embraces it as a living, breathing part of its identity.

22:41 If you're interested in reading more about the story of Analysa Netherley and paranormal phenomena at the Readhouse, you might like the books Myths and Mysteries of Tennessee by Susan Sawyer, Haunted Tennessee, Ghosts and Strange Phenomena of the Volunteer State by Alan Brown, and Ghosts of the Southern Tennessee Valley by George na Katarski. The Redhouse will actually be booking Room three eleven in October. Reservations will be based on a lottery. The hotel will have a dedicated landing page featuring a form for interested guests to enter. The web page will be available to sign up for until September thirteenth. On September fourteenth, management will conduct random drawings to select the six winners go to the Redhousehotel dot com slash three eleven dash package. It can be found under the offer's tab. Included in the package are overnight accommodations in Room three eleven, complementary valet parking in room, decanter of bathtub, Gin two Na Lisa, Cocktails at the Bar and Billiard's Room, Martini and Pearls, pre dinner amenity, one hundred and fifty dollars dining credit at Bridgman's Chop House, and a twenty five dollars Starbucks gift card for breakfast. I will be staying in Room three to eleven next weekend.

24:03 Follow me on Instagram for photos of my stay. I'm very excited to be a part of living history and even more excited for a visit from Analyisa. Southern Fried Truecrime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Jemma Harris. Southern Fred's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Colie Horner. If you have any case suggestions, please go to our website, Southern Fried Truecrime dot com and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com.

24:44 This is the best way for me to get those little known cases, y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages, but please come join our Facebook group Southern Friedtrucrime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, ship Dolly Parton, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discussed true crime, not just Southern Fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a saving funk corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no should ass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. Southern Fraud is available on all large platforms like iTunes, I Hearts, Spotify, Amazon, Audible and now YouTube. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care