206: The Murder of Dolly Rose Grigsby
In July of 1994, 42 year old Dolly Rose Grigsby was reported missing after visiting a shopping mall in Mercer County, West Virginia. Her husband, Dan Grigsby, did everything he could to try to find his missing wife and mother of their two children....
In July of 1994, 42 year old Dolly Rose Grigsby was reported missing after visiting a shopping mall in Mercer County, West Virginia. Her husband, Dan Grigsby, did everything he could to try to find his missing wife and mother of their two children. The more time passed, it appeared what happened to Dolly would remain a mystery forever. But a shocking development three months later blew the case wide open.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Gemma Harris
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Sources: https://southernfriedtruecrime.com/dolly-rose-grigsby
This episode is brought to you by:
- Go to SimpliSafe.com/southernfried and for a limited time, save 20% on your home security system when you sign up for Fast Protect Monitoring. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
- Control Body Odor ANYWHERE with @lumedeodorant and get $5 off off your Starter Pack (that’s over 40% off) with promo code SFTC at LumeDeodorant.com
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:02 Southern fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. On the summer evening of July nineteenth, nineteen ninety four, Dan Grigsby was slightly unsettled. He and his wife of twenty five years, Dolly, had stopped by the Mercer Mall in Bluefield, West Virginia. The couple was on their way home to pilgrimsnob Virginia, after dropping their fifteen year old son, Danny, and his friend off at a football camp in the West Virginia town of Athens, almost eighty miles away. Dolly told Dan she wanted to take a detour on the way back to go to the mall. Eager to get inside and check out the bargains, Dolly and Dan agreed that she would head in first and Dan would meet up with her in the Seares Electronics department. But when Dan made his way into the mall a short time later, he couldn't find Dolly anywhere. He wasn't too concerned, his wife had likely become engrossed looking around, but the longer Dan waited, the more his concerns grew.
1:11 It was unlike Dolly to not keep her word about meeting up with someone. This was a woman who called her loved ones if she unexpectedly left the house in case they needed her and she wasn't at home. Feeling conflicted, Dan got back in the car and drove home to Pilgrim's Nob, where he called the West Virginia Police. But in the coming months, when the truth about what happened to Dolly emerged, it was, depending on who you asked, either entirely predictable or the least likely thing anyone could ever have expected. Welcome to Episode two o six, The Murder of Dolly Rose Grigsby. Pilgrim's Knob in but Cannan County, Virginia is a tiny mining community of less than five hundred people about three hundred and fifty miles west of Richmond. It's in the far western part of the state, just south of the West Virginia border.
2:09 Though originally named for the fifteenth American President, James Buchanan, I am in fact pronouncing Buchanan County like locals do. Settled in eighteen thirty three, It wasn't until over half a century later that Pilgrim's Snob was officially named upon the opening of its very first post office. Situated on the Appalachian Plateau west of the Appalachian Mountains, The area was a major coal mining source, driving the local economy since the early nineteen thirties. It was a cloudy, yet pleasant summer morning on July nineteenth of nineteen ninety four, just seventy four degrees when Dolly Grigsby and her husband Dan, and their teenage son Danny set out on a road trip. The couple drove Danny and a friend to a football camp ninety minutes away at Concord University over the state line in Athens. Forty two year old Dolly was a house proud mom, totally devoted to her two children.
3:12 She was also an active, dedicated member of the Loggy Bottom Pentecostal Holiness Church in nearby Whitewood. Dolly Rose was born on June fourth, nineteen fifty two, in Bartlett, Virginia, to parents Noah and Velva. The Roses were your typical big Southern family, with Dolly being one of thirteen children. Her forty three year old husband, Dan Richard Grigsby was born around nineteen fifty one, one of six children to parents William and Florline. It's not clear exactly where Dan was born, but available records show both his parents were born in nearby Russell County. Dan and Dolly were married on May twenty sixth, nineteen sixty nine, and Clintwood in Dickinson County, Virginia. They really did appear to be childhood sweethearts. When they were pronounced husband and wife, Dan was eighteen years old and Dolly was just sixteen. While this is usually unacceptable by today's standards, it wasn't uncommon in the late sixties. When Dolly was around twenty one years old, she and Dan moved to Buchanan County, where they raised their two children, Diane and Danny. Diane was born in nineteen seventy one and Danny in nineteen seventy nine. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Following Dan's missing persons report, police wasted no time
4:44 launching an investigation. Dan told law enforcement that after dropping Danny and his friend at the football camp, he and Dolly stopped at the state park in Hinton, West Virginia, before having an early dinner at a fast food restaurant. The last stop on their road trip, and the last place Dan would see Dolly was the parking lot of the Mercer Mall in Bluefield at around five point thirty pm. According to Dan, he let Dolly out at the mall's main entrance while he went to find a parking spot. After doing so, he went inside to sears, but Dolly wasn't there. After searching for his wife for a while with no luck, Dan got in the car and drove back to Pilgrim's Knob. He reported his wife's disappearance to West Virginia State Police around two thirty am the next morning. Dan told investigators that there hadn't been any issues out of the ordinary in the Grigsby household. They had weathered the usual ups and downs that come with being married for a quarter of a century, including Dan's chronic pain, which saw the retired coal mine foreman no longer able to work. So Dan was at a loss to explain why his wife would suddenly have run off. The only thing he could think of causing any concern in Dolly's life recently were issues at their church involving one of her closest friends.
6:06 According to Dan, Dolly had told him the church problems made her want to get away, but other than that, she hadn't been upset or distressed about anything in particular, and it was noted that it was completely out of character for Dolly to just take off without saying anything to anyone. Dan didn't contact mall security before he left Bluefield, but it's not clear why, and it wasn't like the mall was around the corner from their house. If Dolly had come outside to find her husband and her only means of transport gone, it was at least a seventy five minute drive home, Yet Dan told police he assumed that she had hitched a ride. Questions remained as to why Dan didn't hang around longer to see if his wife would show up, or at least contact local law enforcement right away. He had waited a full nine hours before reporting Dolly missing. It's understandable Dan may have anticipated being told to wait twenty four hours before raising the alarm, but it did seem unusual because Dolly always let her husband and kids know where she would be. According to the Bristol Harald Courier, Police from Buchannon, Craig and Dickinson Counties, in addition to West Virginia State Police, searched a forestate area for the missing woman.
7:30 Law enforcements. Multi jurisdictional search extended to Kentucky and Tennessee, where Dolly had relatives. A detailed description of Dolly at the time of her disappearance was widely publicized. She was five foot seven, had a fair complexion and sandy graying hair that appeared frosted. She had been wearing a light tan, mid length skirt, matching blouse with three quarter length sleeves and light green and yellow horizontal stripes with white sandals. She also wore blue prescription glasses and had a scar above her right eye, and she was carrying a brown Aigne brand purse. Even though he had waited to report her missing, when he did, Dan immediately jumped into action, publicly doing what he could to try and bring Dolly home safe. He spent thousands of dollars on ads and the Bristol Harold Courier pleading for any information as to Dolly's whereabouts. In one of many stories in the newspaper, Dan begged for anyone to make contact if they had spoken to his wife, saying, quote, if anyone knows anything, we just want them to let us know. That she's okay. If she reads this, we just want her to call her family to let us know she's all right.
8:48 However, as the days and then weeks passed, Dolly made no contact with her family or friends. Her distraught loved ones hoped that something uncharacteristic had have preventing her from calling home. Dan was a regular fixture at church, leaning on his spiritual community for much needed emotional support, but as more time passed, everyone's fears grew. It was increasingly unlikely that Dolly would be found alive. However, with no proof, everything was still up in the air. The disappearance was all anyone in Pilgrim's Knob and the surrounding areas could talk about. In August, Virginia State Police were brought in to assist, under the leadership of Special Agent Jack Davidson. By early September, Dan's ads, published in the Bristol Herald Courier were accompanied by news of a five thousand dollars reward for any information about Dolly's disappearance that would be over ten thousand today.
9:52 Dan continued to cooperate fully with police, even taking a polygraph, but according to Rowanoake Times, his results proved to be cause for concern. Out of ten questions, Dan felt the three most significant, asking specifically about Dolly's whereabouts, and by now law enforcement knew something Dan did not know. They knew. Investigators had learned that Dan and Dolly had not stopped by Mercer Maul at all. Police had suspected from the very start that Dan not only knew more than he had let on, but was directly involved in his wife's disappearance.
10:33 According to The Roanoke Times, discontent bubbled not far from the surface. In the Grigsby marriage detectives learned things were said to be so bad between the couple that in August nineteen eighty seven and again exactly a year later, Dolly had filed for divorce. She suspected Dan of being unfaithful and also claimed he had been physically, emotionally and mentally abusive, But on each occasion, the couple reconciled and Dolly withdrew the filing. Indeed, according to friends of the couple, their relationship had outwardly been back on track by the time Dolly disappeared.
11:13 In cases where there don't seem to be any leads or sufficient evidence to lead to an arrest. Law enforcement relies on the public coming forward with information to crack the case. All it takes is one person, and this is exactly what happened in the case of Dolly Rose Griggsby. In early October, investigators were contacted by a clintwood Man, thirty eight year old Mickey Breeding. Mickey was friends with Dan's thirty nine year old brother, Ken Griggsby, and what he had to say was shocking. If true, it would confirm what police had suspected all along. Mickey revealed that Ken had asked him to help Dan dispose of Dolly's body. On October fifth, Mickey accompanied state police to an area near tub Run Road in the Jefferson National Forest in Craig County, Virginia.
12:09 There, he directed investigators to what he said were Dolly's badly decomposed, dismembered partial remains buried in multiple brown plastic bags underneath rocks in a creek bed. Mickey also directed them to a separate site a couple of miles away, where a partial human jawbone with an intact muller was recovered, along with ten other loose teeth, Dolly's underwear, and a blanket. Micky claimed had been wrapped around Dolly's body. One thing missing, though, was Dolly's head. When investigators contacted Ken, they learned that Mickey wasn't making anything up. The next day, October sixth, eleven weeks after Dolly was reported missing, her husband was charged with first degree murder in using a fire and the commission of a felony. As Dan Grigsby was immediately deemed a flight risk and there were concerns he would attempt to target witnesses, he was held without bond. He refused to talk, only asking for an attorney. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. We've wrapped up twenty twenty three and working on our twenty twenty four resolutions. It's the perfect time to take action to protect your home and loved ones. Simply Safe has been protecting my home for years, from my house in the busy city to my new home in the secluded country. I love the feeling of security, whether I am home
13:43 or not. Simply Safe is comprehensive protection for the whole home, with advanced sensors that not only detect break ins, but fires, floods, and other threats to your home. With new twenty four to seven live guard protection monitoring agents can actually see, speak to, and con front intruders in your home, available only from Simply Safe to actually stop crime in real time. Twenty four seven monitoring is highly affordable, costing less than a dollar a day, half the price of traditional home security. Keep your home and family safer than ever in the new Year. As a listener, you can save twenty percent on your new system with a fast protect plan by visiting simplysafe dot com slash Southern Fried. Customize your system in minutes at simplysafe dot com slash Southern Fried.
14:30 There's no safe like simply Safe. New Year's resolutions are hard to keep, but there's one resolution that's within reach. Smelling better. That's why I'm so excited to tell you about Loomy. It's the first of its kind whole body deodorant. Loomy is seriously safe to use anywhere on your body, pits, under boobs, thighfolds, belly buttons, butt cracks, vulvas, and feet. I have very sensitive skin, and it's hard to find a product to use on my under arms, much us anywhere else. Loomy is awesome. It's aluminum free baking, soda free, parabin free, and pH balanced for safe use below the belt, and it's clinically proven to block odor all day in control odor for up to seventy two hours. Loomy's Starter Pack is perfect for new customers. It comes with a solid stick deodorant, cream tube deodorant, two free products of your choice like mini body wash and deodorant wipes, and free shipping. As a special offer for listeners, new customers get five dollars off a Loomy Starter pack with code SFTC at Loomydeodorant dot com.
15:37 That equates to over forty percent off your starter pack when you visit Loomydeodorant dot com and use code SFTC. That's five dollars off the starter pack when you go to Loomy l u me E Deodorant dot com and use code SFTC. Police publicly acknowledged that there was a motive for this laying, but refused to elaborate. If convicted, Dan was facing twenty years to life in prison for the murder charge and one to five years on the firearm charge. Dan's brother Ken and his friend Micky Breeding were both charged with the misdemeanor of being an accessory. Until their preliminary hearings on November eighth and Craig County General District Court, both men were free on bond. Along with the partial jawbone. Dental records confirmed the remains were those of Dolly Grigsby. At her autopsy, the medical examiner found the wife and mother of two had been shot at least three times in the back and chest with a thirty two caliber handgun. Two bullets were still lodged in Dolly's torso, with a chest wound proving fatal. The level of decomposition indicated her remains had lain where they had been found for at least a month. I cannot imagine how painful this whole ordeal was for Dolly's children, Diane and Danny. By this time, twenty three year old Diane
17:07 was married and living with her husband. They took Danny in without a second thought, later becoming his legal guardians. Remember, Diane was about eight years older than her brother, who would have been about fifteen. At Dan's preliminary hearing in early November in Craig County General District Court, he pleaded not guilty to murdering Dolly. He also denied recruiting Ken and Mickey to dispose of Dolly's remains or accompanying them to the forest to do so. At Ken's preliminary hearing in December, though, he had a very different account. He said Dan told him, his wife and their daughter that he had killed Dolly at Dan's hunting cabin in the forest following an argument, though Ken didn't know what the argument was about. Dan then asked his brother to help hide her body.
18:00 The court also heard that Dan then told Mickey he had killed Dolly. In the end, Ken waved his right to a preliminary hearing. He would be automatically sent to a grand jury in the new year. Later in December, Dan's bond was set at two hundred and fifty thousand. He waived his right to be indicted by a grand jury, opting to proceed straight to a bench trial. In February nineteen ninety five, Kin was indicted by a grand jury. If convicted, he faced up to twenty years in prison. As the date of Dan's trial grew closer, Kin knew that if he gave up further information, this could only help his own case. Just before Dan's trial, began. Ken told police that Dolly's head was buried in his late father's garden.
18:49 At Dan's one day trial in May nineteen ninety five, Commonwealth Attorney Thaddeus Cox told the court that some time before the murder, Dan bought the thirty two caliber revolver from a man in Clintwood, Virginia. Ken Grigsby was the prosecution's star witness, along with his wife and daughter. Ken testified that Dan told him that on July nineteenth, he took Dolly on a walk through the Jefferson National Park near his hunting cabin. After briefly running back to his vehicle to retrieve his gun, but telling Dolly he was fetching a soda, Dan caught up to his wife. After helping her over a fallen tree, he shot her. He wrapped his wife's body in a green blanket before dragging her to a dry creek bed. Dan then dug a shallow grave and covered the site with rocks. Ken told the court that Dan, concerned the body would soon be discovered, approached him, who recruited Mickey to dispose of Dolly's remains.
19:51 Dan paid the men six hundred dollars each about twelve hundred. Today, Dan, Ken, and Mickey drove out to the forest where Ken and Mickey dug up Dolly's body in order to prevent her from being identified. The men decapitated Dolly before burying her head two miles away. The following week, Ken and Mickey returned to the site where Dolly's head had been buried. Upon Dan's request. They dug it up and Ken took it back to Dickinson County. But what he didn't know, either from the level of decomposition or something else, was that Dolly's lower jawbone was left there. This allowed investigators to recover it when Mickey later escorted them to the scene. On a third visit to the forest, Mickey and Ken again dug up Dolly's remains, this time to dismember her. They haphazardly stuffed her body parts into plastic bags before hastily burying them under rocks in a creek bed. In an attempt to divert suspicion away from himself. Dan then went public with his intense focus on searching for his missing wife, hence the ads and the frequent emotional breakdowns at church. But at trial, there was corroborative evidence from other witnesses about Dan confessing to multiple people. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. Dan didn't
21:25 take the stand in his own defense. His attorney, Carl McAfee, did his best to argue for the first degree murder charge to be downgraded to second degree murder, relying on the prosecution's responsibility to prove intent, which seems like it would be an easy feat for the Commonwealth considering Dan's purchase of the gun beforehand. A defense psychiatrist also testified that on the day of the murder, Dan drank beer and was under the influence of ten different medications for chronic pain and severe deppression. As psychiatrist also spoke about Dan's two previous attempts at taking his own life, claiming that prior to the murder, he told a psychologist that if Dolly ended the marriage, he would kill her and then himself.
22:14 For these reasons, the defense claimed Dan was incapable of knowing right from wrong, but Circuit Judge Duncan Bird Junior didn't buy it, finding Dan sane at the time of the murder, as well as guilty on both charges. On August twenty first, nineteen ninety five, Dan was sentenced to fifty years in prison on the first degree murder charge and three years for the firearm charge seven months earlier. In January nineteen ninety five, sentencing reforms in Virginia saw discretionary parole abolished for felonies committed in or after that year. Inmates would be required to serve at least eighty five percent of their sentence, though they could or in credit for g good behavior, which would count toward potential early release.
23:04 But as Dan murdered Dolly before the new law came into effect, he would be eligible for parole in just another fourteen years. And what of Dan's accomplices, his brother Ken and Mickey Breeding In June nineteen ninety five, Ken was convicted of being an accessory after the fact and sentenced to twelve months in prison. That same month, the charge against Mickey was dismissed in return for his cooperation with investigators and his information which directly resulted in Dan's conviction. It's not clear from the available information whether the murder weapon was ever recovered. In subsequent years. Dan has submitted numerous appeals, but all of these have been dismissed.
23:52 Today, seventy two year old Dan is incarcerated at the Deerfield Correctional Center in Caprin, Virginia. He became eligible for parole around two thousand nine and has applied multiple times over the years, his most recent attempt last year in twenty twenty three. These parole attempts have all been denied due to the seriousness of Dolly's murder. Dan's prison records indicate a scheduled release date of April two thousand thirty three, which would mean he would serve only thirty eight years of his fifty three year sentence, but he will be eighty three years old if he lives that long. But given his parole denials to date, it's likely that Dan will die in prison. No real motive other than the possible argument of the hunting cabin has ever been established or publicized. But of course Dolly had already accused her husband a physical and emotional abuse, and since Dolly Grigsby had already falled for divorce twice, perhaps Dan's motive was the same disgusting reason so many abusive men kill their wives control. Maybe there was a fight that awful day and Dolly said she was done for good, but Dan had brought a gun and taken his wife to an isolated area so it would seem he planned to kill his wife of twenty five years, the mother of his children, and then coldly having her body dismembered. Dolly Grigsby was only forty two
25:29 years old. She had her whole life ahead of her. She had children she loved and future grandchildren to cherish, but it was all ripped away from her by her jealous and abusive husband who just would not let her go. He would rather see her dead. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Jimma Harris. As usual, any editorial comments and opinions are my own. Southern Fred's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Kly Horner. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website, Southern Fried True Crime dot com and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. We do, of course, discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shit as is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a or rate and review. I'm also on all large platforms like iTunes,
27:03 iHeart, Spotify, Amazon, Audible and YouTube. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. You'll take care
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed