205: The Santa Claus Bank Robbery
In the lead-up to Christmas, 1927, the good citizens of Cisco, Texas, were looking forward to celebrating the holiday with their nearest and dearest. But a group of men who rolled into town on the morning of December 23 from Wichita Falls had...
In the lead-up to Christmas, 1927, the good citizens of Cisco, Texas, were looking forward to celebrating the holiday with their nearest and dearest. But a group of men who rolled into town on the morning of December 23 from Wichita Falls had different ideas. Led by an ex-con in a Santa Suit, their actions at the town’s First National Bank went on to spurn one of the state’s biggest manhunts, ultimately leaving six men dead and numerous others wounded. What unfolded not just over the following week but the next couple of years afterward was equal parts a comedy of errors, a gripping tale of Wild West justice, and a tragedy for those who stepped up to protect and serve during one of the most audacious heists in Southern history. This is the story of the Santa Claus Bank Robbery.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Gemma Harris
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Sources: https://southernfriedtruecrime.com/santa-claus-bank-robbery
This episode is brought to you by:
- They say time waits for no one, and neither should payday--See EarnIn.com/TOS for more details.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:03 Southern fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. On December twenty third, nineteen twenty seven, the downtown area of the small north central Texas town of Cisco in Eastland County was busy with last minute shoppers getting ready for Christmas. Situated about one hundred miles west of fort Worth, Cisco was a bustling center that had thrived off the back of the Texas oil boom in the mid to late nineteen tenths. It had begun life as a railroad town and continued to prosper thanks to coal mining. The town of around eight thousand residents was enjoying unseasonably warm weather, according to the fort Worth Weekly, and given the time of year, it didn't seem out of place to see Santa Claus ambling down Cisco's main street, known as Avenue D. For the town youngsters, the unexpected delight of jolly old Saint Nick walking down the street at midday brought great unanticipated delight as the man in the red suit strolled along.
1:11 He greeted excited children, waving anciently patting them on the head as he passed. A six year old girl across the street with her mother was so excited she pleaded with her mom for them to follow Sanna to see where he was going, and her mother agreed. Sanna couldn't pause to chat though, like everyone else, he had things to do that day, and his first stop was at Cisco's First National Bank. Welcome to episode two o five, the Santa Claus Bank Robbery. Underneath the festive attire, dressed in street clothes was twenty four year old Cisco local and unemployed convicted arm robber Marshall Field's Ratliff, and he wasn't filled with Christmas spirit that day. He was intent not on giving, but taking from the First National Bank, and just like Sanna, Marshall had helpers on standby to help him pull it off. Waiting outside in an alley beside the bank in a stolen dark blue buick were thirty one year old Henry Helms, twenty two year old Robert Hill, and thirty two year old Louis Elmore Davis. The men had arrived in town after driving over one hundred and fifty miles from Wichita Falls late the night before, having stolen the buick and made their journey drunk on moonshine. They had an audacious plan.
2:39 Marshall and his brother Lee had initially conspired to rob the bank some months before. They weren't strangers to being on the wrong side of the law. In nineteen twenty six, they were convicted for another armed robbery in Valera and sentenced to eighteen years in prison. But when they were both pardoned by Governor Mariam Ferguson after just a year and were unable to find work in the oil fields, Marshall and Lee made their way to Wichita Falls, where they lived in a rooming house. Things went awry for the brothers when Lee committed another armed robbery in the fall of nineteen twenty seven and returned to prison. Marshall decided to recruit two of his Huntsville Seat penitentiary buddies, Henry Helms and Robert Hill, as well as a safecracker. By mid December, the plan was set to rob the Cisco First National, but a week later the safe cracker came down with the flu, so Marshall roped in his brother in law, Lewis Davis, who, unlike the others, had no criminal record, but the lure of a sizeable cut of the money was too good to resist.
3:45 For the father of three, Marshall knew he couldn't walk into the bank wearing any old disguise hoping to get away with robbery. He was known in Cisco, where his mother formerly ran a cafe. Back in Wichita Falls, Marshall persuaded his landlady to loan him a Santa Claus costume she had made for her husband, reassuring her he would have it back to her in time for Christmas Day. On the morning of December twenty third, after the group arrived in Cisco, Marshall put on the red suit and crouched down on the floor of the buick. His accomplices let him out a few blocks away from the bank to walk the rest of the way. They then continued on into the alleyway alongside the bank building to await their queue. After Marshall let his accomplices in the alley know he had arrived, he strolled into the lobby of the red Brook one story bank. Enthralled children followed him like a festive pied piper.
4:44 Around sixteen people were inside, including customers and staff, with some at the teller's windows. Cashier Alex Spears caught out a friendly hello Santa, but got no response from the bearded man as he made his way to a desk where customers for riding deposit slips. A follow up greeting was also ignored. Without warning, Robert, Henry and Lewis, who had followed Marshall inside but were all undisguised, suddenly pulled out their guns. According to the fort Worth Star Telegram, Robert confronted the cashier and a customer he was speaking with, telling them it was a stick up. Francis Blasingame was the six year old girl who, along with her mother were among those who had followed Santa into the bank, but they had no idea what awaited them and were now trapped thanks to Louis menacingly blocking the front door, or so they thought. Thinking quickly, missus Blausnglen grabbed her daughter, bravely running through the bookkeeper's office and ignoring the shouts of the robbers to stop or be shot, they ran out a side door and down the alley towards the police department nearby. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Upon being alerted to the robbery in progress, police Chief George bit Bedford, Deputy George Carmichael, and Officer Ronald Ready sprang into action. The fifty nine year old Chief Bedford was an imposing
6:16 man, standing six foot four and had twenty five years on the job. Grabbing riot guns, the officer swiftly made their way to the bank, with Chief Bedford taking up position near the top of the alley near the bank's front door. His fellow officers manned an alley running perpendicular to the bank's rear. According to local newspaper editor Boyce House, as word quickly spread outside up and down Avenue D, it was a literal call to arms for the citizens of Cisco. In the nineteen twenties, bank robberies throughout smalltown Texas were occurring at a rate of up to four times a day. In response, just months before, the Texas Bankers Association had announced a five thousand dollars reward for anyone who killed an armed robber. That's over eighty eight thousand today, But there was no reward for a robber who was captured alive. So it's no surprise that Ciscowans determined to either nab themselves the reward. Completely fed up with armed robber's rampant lawlessness, or both, converged upon the bank from a safe distance.
7:27 After all, while people's lives were at risk, the opportunity to score a quick five thousand was too good to resist. Stores carrying firearms were selling out of guns as people on the street wanted in on the action to take down the men terrorizing their community. Inside the bank, Marshall had barged through to the teller's cage, where he took a pistol from a drawer. Inside, Henry shoved customer Oscar Kliat out of the way at the counter, ordering the cashier Jewel Poe to open the bank vault. Pulling a potato sack out from under his Santa suit, Marshall hurriedly stuffed twelve two hundred dollars almost two hundred seventeen thousand today and one hundred and fifty thousand in bonds worth over two point six million today into his bag and emptied cashier drawers while his accomplices herded terrified bank staff and customers into the bookkeeping office. Henry was particularly frightening as he held an automatic weapon in each hand, threatening the hostages not to look at their captors. When Marshall emerged from the vault, the gunfire started.
8:35 Apparently seeing someone peering in through one of the windows, Henry fired a shot. Robert then fired multiple times into the ceiling to show the terrified hostages the gang meant business. Armed citizens waiting outside the bank responded in kind, unleashing a hail of bullets on the building. The robber's new time was running out to make their escape and needed to make a quick exit. As the gang made their way to the side door and out into the alley with the hostages, gunfire erupted in a dramatic shootout with Chief Bedford, officers Carmichael and Reddy's and the public. The robbers returned fire and in the melee, six hostages were wounded. It was hard to say whether they were shot by the robbers, police or the public. The wounded included forty two year old cashier Alex Spears, who was shot in the jaw, customer Oscar Klatt who was struck in the foot, and twenty two year old Harvard student Maryan Cayson who was shot in his leg. Twenty eight year old laborer Pete Rutherford thirty three year old Brady Boggs and cafe owner R. L. Day Chief Bit Bedford was shot five times by Henry Helms as he attempted to prevent the men from passing him at the top of the alley near the street. Deputy George Carmichael was also struck by Henry, sustaining a serious head wound. Robbers knew they couldn't take a whole group of hostages with them and making their escape, so instead they chose two girls, twelve year old Laverne Comer and ten year old m
10:09 M. A. Robertson, using the girls as human shields while the gang ran towards the buick with the lute in hand. The men bundled their hostages into the vehicle, but the robbers didn't escape unscathed. Robert was shot in the arm, while Marshall was struck in the leg and chin, but Louis Davis was also wounded badly and had lapsed into unconsciousness by the time he was laid on the floor in the rear of the buick. Ironically, he had only agreed to the robbery on the condition that there would be no shooting. As the bullet riddled buick took off. Officer Reddies, who had managed to escape uninjured, made a dash back to the police department for a rifle before hitching a ride with a motorist to continue the chase. Hopes of a speedy getaway were thwarted as a comedy of errors seated to play out. It seems it had occurred to none of the men that after their road trip from which Tau Falls, the buick would need more gas. Realizing the tank was dangerously low, they turned right out of the alley and sped south on Avenue D with a flat tire. Thanks to several crack shots by a mailman's forty five colt, they pulled over. Marshall and Henry rushed out into the road, holding up an oldsmobile at gunpoint, driven by fourteen year old Woody Harris, who had driven his parents and grandmother Inn from Rising Star. As the Harrises ran for safety into a nearby house, the robbers man handled their two young
11:41 hostages, Lewis, and the money into the oldsmobile, all the while dodging bullets which whizzed and pinged around them As incensed locals and law enforcement gave chase. Robert was wounded during the relentless gunfire, but to start a car you need keys, and the one for the Oldsmobile were safely still with the quick thinking Woody Harris. The bumbling and frustrated men hurried back to the buick with their hostages, leaving the comatose Lewis, who would slow them down, in the back of the Oldsmobile. He was later taken to a Fort Worth hospital. As the men forced the last drop of gas out of the buick, they fired shots back at a vehicle pursuing them. Even if they hadn't planned on an empty tank, they had brought with them a deterrent in the form of nails, which they tossed out into the road to disable their pursuers tires.
12:35 The men only made it a few miles to the edge of town before they ran out of gas and decided to flee on foot over a fence and into the undergrowth. Laverne and ma May were left cowering in the buick, unharmed with the bloody Santa suit as the men ran for their lives. But by the time they felt free and clear of the angry townsfolk and law enforcement, they realized it wasn't Lewis they had left behind. Thankfully for authorities, the robbers had left behind all the stolen cash and securities too. According to the Waksahatchie Daily Light, the proceeds were returned to the bank, which was damaged by at least two hundred bullet holes. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. In those moments when money isn't moving as fast as your dreams are, earn in provides the financial momentum you need to keep moving forward. Earn In is the app that's helping millions of Americans to feel self sufficient without falling into debt traps. Just download the earn in app and verify your paycheck. Access up to seven hundred and fifty dollars per pay period. It's easy and free to get started. There are no mandatory fees or credit check. Earn In is designed to support you in the short term and long term. If I needed help, I would turn to earn in.
13:58 Earn In provide your own money at your fee tips. It's a safe and fast option when you need it. Download earn in today spelled EA r n I n in the Google Play or Apple App Store. When you download the earn In app. Type in Southern Fried Under Podcast. When you sign up, it'll really help the show. Southern Fried Under Podcast subject to your available earnings daily maxim pay period. See earnin dot com slash cos for details. Earn In is a financial technology company, not a bank. Bank. Products are issued by Evolved Bank and Trust Member FDIC. The biggest manhunt in Texas to date was on led by thirty one year old Ranger Captain Tom Hickman, and authorities in the surrounding areas were about to take up the pursuit, already having been alerted by Cisco law enforcement. Eastland County Sheriff John Hart, his deputies, reporters, and the public were on high alert in the hunt for the fugitives. According to the fort Worth d Record Telegram, search parties, including those on foot and horseback, scoured the unforgiving outskirts of Cisco with tracker dogs for any trace of the missing men. Aside from a suitcase containing first aid supplies and overcoat and bloodstained gloves, there was no sign of the gang. But back in Cisco, the news got worse. That evening Chief Bedford died from his injuries and Lewis the only man in custody was charged with
15:28 murder and armed robbery. On the morning of Christmas Eve, Marshall, Henry and Robert snuck back into Cisco and stole a Ford vehicle. Thirty two year old Lewis Davis would never face justice for Chief Bedford's death, succumbing to his wounds and dying that evening. For all the efforts of law enforcement and the Cisco townspeople, no one received their reward as it couldn't be determined exactly who shot the man. Come Christmas Day, the robbers were still at large. Despite the need for a reliable transportation, The trio wrecked the Ford just thirteen miles west of Cisco, outside the town of Putnam. Needing another vehicle, Around one am on December twenty sixth, they came upon the Wiley home, forcing twenty two year old Carl Wiley to drive them in his Dodge. Carl was shot in the arm as the group forced him at gunpoint to drive them away, not by the bandits but by his own desperate father. For almost another twenty four hours, Karl was kept hostage by the men who didn't even offer him anything to eat, but they were much the worse for wear by now thanks to their gunshot wounds and lack of sleep, not to mention the worsening weather conditions, with sleet and icy plummeting temperatures making staying on the run near impossible. At five a m. On December twenty seventh, the men released Karl in his dodge and stole a roadster, driving fifty five miles north to South Bend in Young County. Carl told police he believed the men planned
17:02 on returning to Wichita Falls, but the gang didn't plan on encountering Sheriff Foster, Deputy Sheriff Sigh Bradford, and other officers in a roadblock at South Bend, thwarting their attempt to cross the Brazos River. A chase ensued, with Marshall, Henry and Robert abandoning the roadster and fleeing on foot across an oil field. They fired back at law enforcement as they ran, with each man being injured in the shootout. Thanks to Deputy Bradford's double barreled shotgun nicknamed Old Betsey, Henry and Robert made their escape into the woods, but Marshall Ratliffe was finally brought down. He was alive, but had six gunshot wounds and was carrying six pistols in addition to a double barreled shotgun, three belts of ammunition, and a bowie knife. Despite an aerial search, there was no sign of Henry and Robert in the woodland, and the number of people wounded during the ongoing search continued to climb ter. Two men, including a sheriff, were injured after their weapons were accidentally discharged. On the morning of December thirtieth, Henry Helms and Robert Hill were finally captured without incident, and the town of Graham authorities were alerted by locals who took note of the fugitive's firearms and bedraggled appearance. By now, the men were so fatigued, dehydrated, and in need of medical attention there was no point continuing to run. Between the two of them, they were carrying seven pistols. According to the Associated
18:33 Press. On January twenty seventh, nineteen twenty eight, ten days after sixty year old Deputy George Carmichael became the second lawman to succumb to his injuries, Marshall was convicted of armed robbery and sentenced to ninety nine years behind bars. Despite how traumatizing the experience of the robbery and shootout had been for young Laverne Comer and Woody Harris, it was their eyewitness evidences that helped convict the man disguised as Sannah. Marshall's trial was the last ever to be held in the Eastland District Court's former courthouse, which was reduced to rubble following the conclusion of the proceedings. Henry meanwhile attempted to plead insanity and the lead up to his trial, but was prosecuted for killing Chief Bradford and Deputy Carmichael in February nineteen twenty eight, and was sentenced to death. At Robert's trial the following month, he pled guilty to armed robbery and begged the court for mercy, claiming his lack of a stable childhood home had led him to become involved with convicted felons. His pleas must have worked, because instead of death, he was sentenced to ninety nine years in prison. By now, Marshall had received a further sentence, despite there being no evidence that he had fired his gun out into the alley. He was convicted of killing Chief Bradford and Deputy Carmichael and was sentenced to death. On September sixth, nineteen twenty nine, thirty two year old Henry Helms was executed in the electric chair and Huntsville. The same
20:07 day, Marshall's mental health seemed to take a turn for the worse. A subsequent appeal against his death sentence had since been unsuccessful. After his attorney and mother applied for a sanity hearing, Marshall was extradited to Eastland County Jail for evaluation after a bench warrant was issued over his theft of the oldsmobile. But the town's patience was wearing thin with the delay. They wanted to see Marshall executed swiftly. On November eighteenth, Marshall's health had supposedly deteriorated so rapidly that it took Deputy Sheriff Thomas Jones and jailer Edward Pack Kilbourne to help the convicted felon with basic tasks like eating and bathing. But Marshall's act was all a ruse. According to the Abilene News Reporter, when Pack and Tom's backs were turned marsh she'll snuck out his open cell door and stole a thirty eight pistol from an office desk drawer. In the resulting tussle with the officers, Marshall shot Deputy Jones multiple times, wounding him badly. Thankfully, Pack managed to overpower Marshall, who was rendered unconscious before being locked back in his cell.
21:19 Pack subdued Marshal by pistol, whipping him. By the following evening, two thousand, agitated Eastland County residents had gathered outside the jail hoping that Deputy Tom Jones would pull through. Fueled by vigilanteism and hell bent on vengeance, a crowd of about two hundred men stormed the jail, overpowering Pack Kilbourne and dragging Marshall from his cell, stripping him naked and binding his hands and feet. Dragging him outside, the angry mob made their way two hundred yards down the road to the rear of the Majestic Theater, which was ironically staging a production entitled The Noose. Someone produced a length of rope and the hostile, jeering crowd proceeded to lynch twenty six year old Marshall Ratliff over a guy wire strung between two telephone poles fifteen feet above the ground. Marshall had a brief reprieve when the rope broke, but another one was quickly found. The second time, there was no escape. After Marshall's corpse hung in the air for several hours, he was pronounced dead at nine to fifty five pm. His body was laid out for all to see in an Eastland furniture store the next day until it was taken to the coroner. Sadly, fifty five year old Deputy Tom Jones didn't make it and died in the hospital the next day. Lynching was punishable by death in Texas, and Marshall's was said to be the last mob lynching in the state, but despite a grand jury being convened, no
22:52 one was prosecuted. Marshall Ratliffe's death brought the death toll from the robbery including the gang, to six, and eleven others had been wounded. The only member of the gang to survive was twenty two year old Robert Hill, who was released from prison in the mid nineteen forties after three unsuccessful escape attempts. There are mixed reports as to whether he changed his name, but it appears he faded into obscurity into quiet life, dying in nineteen ninety six at age ninety. Since nineteen sixty seven, the original First National Bank building has a plaque that was installed by the Texas Historical Commission. These days, while the former bank has moved premises, it features artwork depicting the infamous heist and even has a printed booklet available about the robbery. It's called the First Financial Bank Now and is located on Conrad Hilton Boulevard. If you're interested in reading more about this fascinating chapter in Texas criminal history, you can check out the Santa Claus Ribery by Ac Green and the twenty twenty three novel The Last Man by Thomas Goodman. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly.
24:12 Today's episode was researched and written by Jima Harris. Southern Fred's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio, and the original graphic art is by Coly Horner. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website, Southernfrid True Crime dot com and click on the listeners suggestion tab or email sftcresearch at gmail dot com. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases, y'all. Always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion Group where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shit ice is loud. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoyed today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review. I'm also on all large platforms like iTunes, iHeart, Spotify, Amazon, and Audible. Until next time, Thanks so much for listening, y'all, Take care and Merry Christmas to those who celebrate
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed