203: The Hicks Babies
More than 200 babies, known as the “Hicks Babies,” were sold by Dr. Thomas Hicks from the back of the Hicks Community Clinic in McCaysville, Georgia during the 1950s and 1960s. Until his actions came to light, he was a respected and beloved doctor in...
More than 200 babies, known as the “Hicks Babies,” were sold by Dr. Thomas Hicks from the back of the Hicks Community Clinic in McCaysville, Georgia during the 1950s and 1960s. Until his actions came to light, he was a respected and beloved doctor in McCaysville, known for helping everyone…often taking things like a sack of potatoes in return for payment. Some town residents defend his actions to this day, but the “Hicks Babies,” as they became known, are still struggling to find their birth mothers and come to terms with their origins and the damage Hicks did by keeping his practice shrouded in mystery.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Gemma Harris
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Sources:southernfriedtruecrime.com/thomas-hicks
This episode is brought to you by:
- Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey. Download today on iOS or Android.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:01 Southern fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion as advised. On March fifth, nineteen seventy two, the residents of Mccaysville, Georgia, were in mourning their beloved former town doctor had lost his battle with leukemia and passed away at age eighty three, leaving behind a wife's son and daughter. Doc Hicks had a reputation as being the kind of doctor everyone needs. He do anything for anyone. In the poor, remote copper mining town straddling the Georgia Tennessee border in the Blue Ridge Mountains, people didn't always have money for medical services, and if they did, it often wasn't enough. But doctor Hicks provided a level of care and various services without judgment or demanding payment from those who truly couldn't afford life saving treatment. It wasn't unusual for him to be paid in a sack of potatoes. He was part of the fabric of mccayswell and was said by many to be not only one of the best physicians, but one of the best men they knew. However, others took a different view. The same man who had donated an organ to the local church and gave medicine away for free, had once stolen a watch from the arm of a dying patient. So not everyone was a fan of doctor Hicks, But twenty five years after his death, a much greater scandal would emerge. It
1:32 rocked not just the small town, but the entire country. The hippocratic oath all physicians must uphold throughout their career as above all else, do no harm. The people of Mcayswell were about to discover that someone they had trusted with their lives and who they felt been nothing but professional, was accused of something so harmful and so contrary to the nature of the man they knew, it was hard to believe. Welcome to episode two oh three, The Hicks Babies. Thomas Juggarthy Hicks was born on October eighteenth, eighteen eighty eight, in Bloomington, Tennessee, to parents David and Mary, one of six children.
2:15 He graduated from Emmery University Medical School in nineteen seventeen and that summer married twenty four year old Sullivan County woman Chas Copeland. The couple settled in Copper Hill, Tennessee, and had three children. Their son also became a doctor, but died suddenly in nineteen sixty seven at age forty four. While Chass became a Sunday school teacher. Her husband took a job with the Tennessee Copper Company treating minors he diagnosed with fatal lung conditions, but in nineteen thirty two, when the doctor was discovered submitting an excessive amount of claims compared to the size of the company's workforce, he was fired. Doctor Hicks ran into trouble again in nineteen forty three, having time in jail for illegally selling narcotics, and was subsequently struck off in Tennessee. Despite this setback, just ten months later, following his release, the doctor opened a clinic several blocks away from his home. It was just across the border in the tiny North Georgian town of Mccaysvielle and Fannin County, home to just over two thousand people. The unassuming blond brick one story building had distinctive green and white striped awnings. Mccaysville is the twin city of Copperhill, Tennessee. Both Appalachian towns are situated along one river, whose name varies depending on where you are in relation to the state line. In Tennessee, it's the Ocoee River, while in Georgia it's the Tacoa River. The state line itself runs right through downtown mccaysville through the grocery
3:49 store parking lot. Doctor Hicks was well respected and warmly embraced by the community. He was personable, charming, and made house calls regardless of the hour. Patients felt at ease in his presence and trusted him without a question. He became a charter member of the Adams Bible Class of the town's first Baptist church, president of the Kowanas Club, and a member of Copper Hill Lodge. But doctor Hicks was working at a time when reproductive rights for women in Georgia were non existent. In the nineteen forties and fifties, conservative Southern America, birth control wasn't readily available, and unmarried mothers were much aligned. Anyone finding themselves unexpectantly pregnant and not wanting to be was thrust into a terrifying world of fear and uncertainty. It was the same for married women who couldn't afford another mouth to feed. Many women died as a result of a lack of access to safe and affordable abortions, either through trying to perform one themselves, having one at the hands of an unqualified back yard operator, or by suicide.
4:55 According to the Akron Beacon Journal, doctor Hicks advertised what he called pregnancy care services on phone booths, overpasses and at bus stations for one hundred dollars about twelve hundred dollars in today's money. He performed safe abortions when many other physicians wouldn't. Of course, adoption was an option, but this process had recently been the subject of much scandal at a national level, when the crimes of Tennessee women Georgia Tann were exposed just before her death in nineteen fifty. Back in twenty twenty, I released episode ninety five on Georgia Town, entitled Pedophile, Kidnapper and Inventor of Modern Adoption. From the nineteen twenties, Tan trafficked over five thousand children, selling them to wealthy families. Other children, including nineteen unidentified victims, died of extreme abuse and neglect at the Memphis branch of the Tennessee Children's Home Society. Southerners were horrified that something like this could happen in their own backyard. Surely, they thought, with Tan's death and the sordid nature of her actions exposed societies most vulnerable would never again be exploded on such a scale. But they were wrong. Over in Georgia, word was now getting around that doctor Hicks could arrange a discreet way for his pregnant patients to adopt their babies out to loving families. He had lined up himself with privacy guaranteed and minimal fuss. He was already performing abortions, so this
6:28 seemed to many women a legitimate way to solve the embarrassing or financially stressful problem of an unplanned pregnancy, and it was an option for those women who didn't want a baby but were personally opposed to abortion. Doctor Hicks arranged temporary housing for some of the expectant mothers for several months. He also covered their medical costs and care during their stay at either his farm, the New York Hotel on Copper Hill, Tennessee, or in his apartments in the Telephone Company building. Time came for women to deliver. Doctor Hicks got on the phone to prospective parents, but none of them were vetted the way they are today. After giving the new parents only twenty four hours to get to Mccaysviell, doctor Hicks sold the newborns for anywhere from eight hundred dollars to up to ten thousand dollars ten thousand to one hundred and twenty thousand today. The usual amount was said to be around one thousand, which is about twelve thousand, six hundred today, according to the Atlanta Journal Constitution. Some babies even went for as low as one hundred dollars twelve hundred today. It's not known how much, if anything, was paid directly to the birth mothers. Parents couldn't choose the gender, but if you could pay, you could get yourself a baby.
7:44 Doctor Hicks arranged a falsified birth certificate which would be forwarded several weeks later, naming the adoptive parents as the birth parents, with the birth occurring in Mccaysviell. No questions asked. Doctor Hicks knew he had to minimize any paper trail, so he didn't keep any records of the birth mothers or families linking them to their adoptive families out of state, no medical records, and no accurate county court records of the births would ensure the entire operations was kept under wraps. The doctor's mo also prevented any birth mothers from changing their minds about giving up their babies. With no documents filed through a court to prove the adoption had occurred, they had no rights. Despite how traumatizing this must have been for many of doctor Hicks's patients. Some women gave birth multiple times at the clinic. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. While many of the women knew they were giving up their babies for adoption once they had delivered, it wasn't always this way. In a situation where it's hard to see that altruism was the sole motivator and not money, doctor Hicks began taking infants from mothers who didn't want to give up their babies at all. After these newborns were delivered, they were whisked away and the dazed mother was told her child was stillborn. Meanwhile, a couple who assumed the baby wasn't wanted was waiting out back of the clinic to take their new baby home. Expectant
9:18 mothers who very much wanted their children and trusted Doctor Hicks were lied to Doctor Hicks didn't flaunt what was happening behind closed doors. Locals put two and two together, but didn't ask questions about what seemed to be an open secret. Women arrived from out of town in cabs and even by plane. Pregnant teens and young women from wealthy Southern families arrived in mccayswell at all hours of the day and night to see the doctor. It wasn't unusual to see limousines parked in the clinic's back alley. But in December nineteen sixty four, operations at the Hicks clinics started to wind down. This wasn't due to the illegal adoptions, which were really more transactions being conducted literally out of the back door.
10:03 Doctor Hicks was instead arrested for performing an abortion on a young woman from Cobb County. In return for the charges being dropped, the doctor agreed to surrender his Georgia medical license. According to the AJAC, some believed the arrest was orchestrated by other doctors who were jealous of how well off doctor Hicks was. By this time, the years passed, and by the early nineteen nineties, a woman in Akron, Ohio named Jane Blasio was on a mission. Since the age of six, Jane had known she was adopted. As a teen, she didn't ask too many questions, but she knew that one day she had to find out more about where she came from and hopefully her birth family.
10:46 As a teenager, Jane had found an imbordered baby pillow in her attic. It had her name and her birth date as January fifteenth, nineteen sixty five, but Jane had always been told her birthday was December sixth, nineteen sixty four. Her birth date was backdated to December nineteen sixty four to avoid any repercussions for doctor Hicks, who had continued to practice even though he had surrendered his medical license in nineteen eighty eight. Following the death of her mother, Jane's father told her the story of how she came to join the family. After losing a child at birth and being turned down by local adoption agencies, her parents bought Jane's older sister, Michelle, from the Hicks clinic in nineteen sixty one. Michelle was sold for eight hundred dollars plus the cost of a new outfit for her birth mother. Jane followed a few years later, she was sold for one thousand, but with her original birth certificate falsified, there was no way for Jane or any other Hicks Babies, as they came to be known, to trace birth families the usual way. Legitimate adoption agencies turned down Jane's parents because her mother had been previously divorced. Then they heard about the Hicks Clinic from a relative who had purchased a baby. To get help with her birth records, Jane sought the assistance of Fannin County Probate Judge Linda Davis. Together they uncovered around fifty birth records between nineteen fifty five and nineteen sixty four, where the registered birth of place was mccayswell, but the
12:18 parent's usual address was Akron, a twelve hour drive away. This made no sense and suggested that something illegal had definitely occurred. In nineteen sixty alone, six of the fifty babies born in Fannin County, just over ten percent were sold through the clinic to out of state families. Judge Davis eventually uncovered records of at least two hundred infants born at the clinic and handed out the rear of the premises into the waiting arms of their new families that averages out to just over one baby a month. They often wore little more than a diaper, came with no supplies, and were still covered in Vernex, the waxy white substance found coding the skin of newborn babies. Georgia Superior Court records confirmed that none of the babies had been adopted through the appropriate legal channels. But how did so many babies end up in Ohio and how did their adoptive families find out about doctor Hicks. Forty nine of the two hundred babies were sold to couples from Summit County, Ohio, through a woman only known as Ruth.
13:24 Ruth had grown up in Mcaysville and her family knew doctor Hicks. She later moved to Ohio, where she worked for west Akron Goodrich and bought four babies of her own through the clinic. As words spread around Akron that people wanting a baby could get one from Georgia for the right price, Ruth became the facilitator. Prospective parents contacted the clinic, putting their names on a waiting list and waiting by the phone for doctor Hicks's call. Forty seven of the Summit County babies went to homes where the father worked for the Akron Tire company. The remaining two newborns were sold to a doctor in the Ohio city of Cayuga Falls. As words spread to prospective parents, couples from eleven states, including Arkansas, New Jersey, Oregon, Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, and Pennsylvania contacted doctor Hicks to arrange the purchase of a newborn. According to The New York Times, Judge Davis believes most of the adoptive families were not rich, but working class. Ruth later refused to discuss her involvement in what happened.
14:30 If she was alive today, she'd be one hundred and four, so she's likely passed away given how often the adoptions were happening in such a small town. Some later wondered whether doctor Hicks himself had fathered some of the children, but there's no evidence to suggest this occurred. And don't forget it was common for doctor Hicks's obstetric's patients to come from out of state and interstate. Jane Blasio made multiple trips to mcaswell and search for answers. She suspected it would be difficult to get information and was met with complete stonewalling. People didn't want to talk, much less entertained the thought of their beloved former doctor's reputation being besmirched when he wasn't even alive to defend himself. It became clear that doctor Hicks was a man of contradictions who wore different masks depending on who Jane talked to. Some claimed the doctor couldn't have possibly made a profit, even he was covering medical and accommodation costs for his patients and their babies. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsor. There's nothing like a good family mystery, especially one with as many twists and turns as June's Journey. June's Journey is the number one hidden object game in the world, with a captivating detective story taking you back to the glamour of the nineteen twenties.
15:54 With a diverse cast of characters, Each new scene takes you further through a thing thrilling murder mystery story that sets the main protagonist, June Parker, on a quest to solve the murder of her sister and uncover her family's many secrets. Engage your sense of observation to find hidden clues, search for hidden objects from the parlors of New York to the sidewalks of Paris. Escape to a bygone age of mystery, danger and romance, and build your very own island estate with expansive gardens and beautiful buildings. I am now in chapter ten, where we boarded a train to Italy on the trail of a killer. I can't wait to see where this leads me. Can you crack the case? Download June's Journey for free today on iOS and Android. In nineteen ninety seven, twenty five years after doctor Hicks's death, the ugly truth was about to get extremely uncomfortable for those who had held him in such high esteem.
16:52 News of Jane's investigative work went public in the Atlanta Journal Constitution, Akron Beacon Journal, and the New York Times. Times. Calls started flooding into Judge Davis from those who thought they could be one of the Hicks babies. Many of the stunned townsfolk felt that doctor Hicks's actions had not only saved lives, but helped prospective parents who did give their adoptive babies good homes realize a dream they thought would never come true. Obviously, doctor Hicks was dead by this time, but so were many who could have provided answers about what went on, including former nurses, his secretary, lawyer, and much of his family.
17:33 His surviving granddaughter, Sally Sumpyrac, claims to not know anything specific about what occurred and rejects the assertion that it was a black market adoption operation, but she's supportive of Jane Blazio's quest to help others find their birth families. With no records left behind at the clinic, there was little to go on, but this didn't stop the genetic testing phase of Jane's work from kicking off. Jane became a professional investigator and expert and black market adoption. With the help of Judge Davis, she established mccaswell's Lost and found a confidential registry and support group for those connected to the former Hicks clinic. She continues to dedicate much of her life to facilitating the connection of other Hicks babies with their birth families where possible. In twenty seventeen, Jane identified her own birth father.
18:25 His name is Herbert Kruse, and he had died in twenty ten. However, her birth mother's identity remains elusive. It was believed her mother could have been Kitty Goss, who died in nineteen eighty seven at age thirty eight. Kitty was the oldest of nine children and lived in poverty. In the mid nineteen sixties, she gave up two babies for adoption. DNA testing involving her son Jamie revealed an inconclusive link to Jane. Jane's advocacy work as not about seeking financial restitution, disrupting anyone's life, or said out to violate anyone's privacy. It's simply giving people back the right to connect the dots about their medical history, a right taken away by someone who many believe benefited financially from the circumstances. In twenty nineteen, a six part documentary about the Hicks babies and Jane's search for answers, entitled Taken at Birth, aired on TLC. Two years later, Jane released her memoir of the same name. Many people in mccaysville and the adoptive parents are still alive and staunch in their support of doctor Hicks. In twenty fourteen, then Mayor Thomas Sebolt told the AJC quote, everyone accepted that it happened in this town and they just rather let it go on. They maintain he provided a much needed service during a time when reproductive rights and healthcare were largely underground. They argued that the babies born and sold
19:56 through the clinic went on to grow up in loving homes with family who wanted nothing but the best for their children. And this last part is undoubtedly true. Many of the women who gave birth at the clinic, truly wanting to give their child a chance at a better life, felt they made the right decision at that moment in time. But there's no getting away from the fact that doctor Hicks also coerced, confused, and scared vulnerable young women who were on the fence about adoption into surrendering their babies. These women may very well have wanted to make it work, despite the stigma of being a single mother or the financial challenges of expanding an existing family. We can't forget that doctor Hicks also lied and stole from other mothers, mothers who were told that their babies, who were very much alive were still born. This completely contradicts the narrative by some locals that the doctor didn't perform any services that weren't requested by a patient. Doctor Hicks went to great links to prevent people from ever being able to trace their birth families for something as straightforward as medical history was he motivated by profit or charity while hoping to break even in the fees he charged.
21:15 We'll probably never know. The pain and trauma doctor Hicks cause to generations of families are undeniable, and many argue this is not negated by the overall level of care he provided to the broader community. It's doubtful he was the only physician in the South risking being stripped of their medical license for providing access to safe abortions, but it's unlikely these other doctors went to the links he did in deceiving and exploiting patients. Jane Blasio continues to advocate for open adoption and increased safeguards for all parties involved. To date, about fifteen of the Hicks babies have found their birth parents thanks to DNA testing and Jane's help.
22:00 Along with the other Hicks babies, seven birth mothers have also come forward, but time is running out for those who are still desperate for answers. The DNA testing occurred in twenty fourteen and Tennessee and thirty people turned up from all across the country. Ancestry dot Com agreed to analyze their DNA for free. Previous testing was conducted in nineteen ninety seven, but potential matches were limited due to technology at the time. Jane originally said in nineteen ninety seven of Hick's actions, the villain is the circumstance. Today, on her website it appears she takes a stronger position by saying Doc Hicks was no saint, and we recognize his dysfunction, the pain he caused many and have learned to bear it.
22:51 Will probably never know how many babies were sold by doctor Hicks. The complexities and complications of his legacy continued to affect hundreds of people today, not just the Hicks babies themselves, but their adoptive families and those supporting them in their journey toward restoration. Indeed, many may still not know they were ever adopted through the clinic, if at all. And then, of course, there are those who discovered the circumstances of their adoption but have since passed away without ever knowing the real story behind taking their first breath in Mccaysville. If you or someone you know may be connected to the Hicks Clinic and is looking for assistance and support in their search. You can reach out to Jane Blazio at Janeblazio dot com. Southern frid True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Jima Harris. Southern Fred's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic art is by Coley Horner. Today's episode was edited and made by Brandon schock Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener's suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases, y'all always send me.
24:12 Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fred True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern Fried, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God we mean it when we say no shit ass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review. I'm also on all large platforms like iTunes, iHeart, Stitcher and now Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. Y'all, take care,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed