202: The Fugitive Lee Barnett
In April of 1994, Lee Barnett picked up her 11-month-old daughter, Savanna, from her ex-husband Harris Todd’s house in Charleston, South Carolina. They were supposed to return at around six o’clock that evening. But they never showed up. Over the next...
In April of 1994, Lee Barnett picked up her 11-month-old daughter, Savanna, from her ex-husband Harris Todd’s house in Charleston, South Carolina. They were supposed to return at around six o’clock that evening. But they never showed up. Over the next 20 years, they’d travel the world together, as Lee fled from her child’s father, the FBI, and numerous international agencies. She claimed she was saving her daughter from an abusive father. But Harris claimed that Dorothy was the actual abuser.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Erica Kelley and Andrea Marshbank
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Recommended by Nate and others
This episode is brought to you by:
- Give your loved ones the precious gift of memories, bound in a beautiful keepsake book. Go to StoryWorth.com/southernfried to save $10 on your purchase.
- This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try and get a break from your thoughts at BetterHelp.com/SOUTHERN
- Treat yourself to the best shapewear on the market and save 20% Off at honeylove.com/SFTC.
- Go to UncommonGoods.com/southernfried for 15% holiday gifts. We’re all out of the ordinary.
- They say time waits for no one, and neither should payday--See EarnIn.com/TOS for more details.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:10 Southern Fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. Everyone knows that saying there are two sides to every story, and today's case is the perfect example of that. In fact, everything about this case could be completely turned on its head, just depending on who you believe. On the one hand, this could be a case of a mentally unstable, abusive woman, a woman who tormented her husband behind closed doors, who berated, threatened, and became violent with him. But on the other hand, this case could be the exact opposite. It could be a case of an uncaring man who married an unsuspecting woman, a man who, after their divorce, put their newborn little girl in danger, a man who wanted to take his daughter away from her mother forever for the simple sake that he could. But it was the woman Lee Barnett, who abducted her own newborn daughter and successfully fled her ex husband, international authorities, and FBI for nearly twenty years. Welcome to Episode two O two, The Fugitive Lee Barnett. Dorothy Lee Barnett was born on May twenty seventh, nineteen sixty. Her mother's name was Dottie.
1:38 Of course, Dottie was probably a nickname for Dorothy, and Dorothy Lee went by her middle name Lee. Lee's father had died during her early childhood, so Dottie became a single parent. Despite the tragedy of her husband's death, she maintained a passion for life. She was known to be free spirited, fun and it showed. Dottie and her children moved to all sorts of different places during their childhood. South Carolina, Florida Belize. When Lee's friend Susan first laid eyes on the Barnett family, she saw evidence of that. Susan told journalist Marine mayher when I first met Lee, she was five and I was seven, and she had a big black snake around her neck, and so I took one look at her, and I said, Oh, that looks like an interesting family. I want to be friends with her. Susan recalled that Lee appeared to have this fantastical life, like something straight out of in Indiana Jones movie, but appearances can be deceiving. Dottie Lee and the rest of the Barnett family had to navigate their own challenges as a single mother Dottie had a difficult time providing for her children. They lived mostly off of the father's Social Security payments. Lee's brother, Cliff Barnett said, we had to learn how to do things with no money and no resources, and they did, but that didn't mean it was fun were comfortable. In fact, Lee would later be described as an FBI profiller, as someone who liked the finer things in life. Maybe her desire for an expensive lifestyle was a reaction
3:10 to her childhood. As Lee became an adult, she also became a beautiful woman. She had blonde hair, blue eyes, and she was a tiny thing, only five foot two inches tall and about one hundred pounds. She was known for her outgoing personality and her ability to make friends easily. Everyone wanted to be friends with Lee. She was vivacious, charming, a talker, all great qualities for her job in her early thirties, a flight attendant. That's where thirty one year old Lee Barnett met thirty eight year old Benjamin Harris Todd the Third. He was a well to do Southern gentleman who opened doors and wrote poetry, and he, just like Lee, went by his middle name Harris. Harris was born in nineteen fifty three to parents, Margie and Benjamin Harris Todd, the second benjam Men and Margie married in September of nineteen fifty They had four children, three boys and one girl. Harris's family moved to Bowling Green, Kentucky in nineteen fifty five when he was two years old. His mother and father both worked in the health care industry. His father was an internist and his mother a registered nurse. The Todd family probably looked like they were living the dream until nineteen sixty one, when tragedy struck.
4:27 Doctor Benjamin Todd died unexpectedly at the age of thirty seven from a penicillin allergy. He was buried in the Fairview Cemetery in Bowling Green, and that's where Harris's mother would also be buried later in twenty eleven. At the time of his father's death, Harris would have been about eight years old, but his dad had still left quite an impression. For years, Harris would aspire to be a medical doctor. He wanted to follow in his dad's footsteps. During his high school years, Harris won a Fuloride scholarship to an exclusive prep school called the Phillips Academy, located in Andover, Massachusetts. Phillips Academy is one of the oldest prep schools in the East. While there, Harris excelled.
5:12 He was the president of the pre Med Society. He was on the varsity track team. Even at age thirty four, Harris could still finish a mile in less than six minutes on race day. After Harris graduated from Phillips Academy at the age of eighteen, he received a scholarship to study at the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill. The scholarship was called the Moorhead Award and it was for eleven nine hundred dollars, which is more than ninety thousand today. But Harris did not become a doctor. Instead, he went into finance. As an adult. He would make his name as a financial advisor for Merrill Lynch. This is who thirty eight year old Harris was when he met Lee, the beautiful thirty one year old flight attendant. An established man with a good paying job, he already owned his own home on John's Island in Charles County, South Carolina. Harris was also notoriously well spoken. He could discuss Beethoven and American novelists and everything in between. Plus Harris seemed like a nice guy put together, it's no wonder why he and Lee fell for each other. But not long after they did, everything started to fall apart.
6:25 I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. According to Lee, she and Harris's relationship began as a friendship, not as a courtship. But after about five years of knowing one another, Harris confessed his love for her, and it changed everything. Lee told CBS's Forty eight Hours. He just professed to me that I made him feel different than anybody else ever made him feel. And then one thing led to another right away. Some of Lee's friends were not fans of this new pairing. Lee's friend Patty told Maureen maher they onted different things out of life. She was very outgoing and he kind of kept to himself, not to mention. Lee wanted children, and as Lee tells it, Harris did not. But Lee wasn't phased by Harris's lack of desire to have kids. She thought she could change his mind. She was already pushing Harris, who she thought was a rather serious man, out of his shell. Lee encouraged him to live as she herself put it a more normal, fun loving life, But according to Harris's interviews with the Pittsburgh Post Gazette, Harris wasn't sure that Lee made his life normal or fun loving.
7:35 In fact, Harris said that when Lee was ready for marriage, he wasn't, and that's because, according to Harris, Lee was prone to angry outbursts. Harris said that she was extremely volatile and prone to dramatic mood swings, and these mood swings were bad, so bad that Harris wasn't sure he could commit to Lee. But just as Lee had thought she could fix Harris's view on children, Harris told Dateline that he he felt the same way. He thought he could fix Lee's temper. Then, despite Harris's misgivings, the couple did marry. As reported by the Pittsburgh Post Gazette, Lee surprised Harris with a marriage license. She suggested to Harris that they used their already planned vacation to the Bahamas as a honeymoon, and bam, that was it.
8:20 They would be married. Thirty nine year old Harris accepted thirty two year old Lee's proposal, and in nineteen ninety two, they were officially man and wife. Reports of Lee and Harris's marriage differ greatly depending on whether you're talking to Lee or Harris. Harris recalled that Lee's mental health issues began right after their nuptials. She wouldn't sleep for days at a time, and he said Lee would beat her head against the walls for hours. One time, Harris remembered waking in the middle of the night when he looked across the bed, he saw his wife, Lee staring at nothing and rocking back and forth. On a different occasion, Harris said he woke up in the night to find Lee on time of his chest. By his account, Lee was preparing to strangle him, and during a TV interview, Harris alleged that Lee nearly killed their family dog, apparently the young Great Dane hadn't followed one of her commands.
9:13 Harris also alleged that Lee became violent toward him. She would throw flower pots at him as he entered their home. During an argument, Lee hit Harris in the head while he was driving. Harris told the Pittsburgh Post Gazette, I've never hit a woman in my life, and I can't explain why I let myself be hit. It's important to note here Lee denied most of Harris's claims. She told journalists that she didn't beat her head against the walls and she never hit Harris, though she did admit to slapping him once, and she also admitted to throwing the flower pots, but she claimed that it was because Harris gas lit her. He called her crazy and insane, Lee explained to Forty eight Hours. He would say to me all the time, you're sick, you're insane. Lee's friend pat said she heard Harris say things like this to Lee over the phone. Patty was shocked by Harris's hateful demeanor toward Lee. Patty felt Harris had changed drastically from the southern gentleman she had thought he was before. About seven months into the marriage, two things happened at Damn Neare the same time. First, Harris was pretty sure he wanted a divorce too, Lee was pretty sure she was pregnant. Still, their accounts of these events continued to differ greatly. When Lee told Harris about the potential pregnancy, she said he was opposed and that he suggested she'd get an abortion, And then two days later Lee confirmed her suspicions she was pregnant. Lee told forty eight hours that Harris became cold and indifferent and remained that way.
10:45 She also claimed that Harris frequently denied the existence of the baby, even when she was in her final trimester. Lee alleged that Harris would repeat, there is no baby. However, Harris disagreed with this version of events. He claimed that he never ever asked Lee to get an abortion, and if he had any trepidations about a child, it was because Lee's hot temper loomed over their relationship. How could they happily bring a child into such a volatile environment. Soon, Harris asked Lee for a divorce, but they were still living together. After all, the house belonged to Harris before their marriage, so he wasn't going anywhere, and Lee wanted their marriage to work, so she wasn't going anywhere either. But one day, about two and a half months into Lee's pregnancy, she became incredibly angry. According to both Lee and Harris, she flipped over a coffee table for Harris, this was the last straw.
11:39 He was upset, and he feared for his own safety, so he left. Lee was shocked to find that her soon to be ex husband wasn't there. The next morning, she told reporter Maureen Mayhear that she felt abandoned. Lee said, I couldn't figure out how somebody I'd loved and known for so long could be this cruel. Following this, Harris asked Lee to move out of his home, but she wouldn't leave. Lee told CBS, I thought if I left his house, I would never ever come back. Lee's friend Patty, said she really wanted the marriage to work. She did everything within her power to get Harris to come back. Meanwhile, Harris went into hiding. Lee continuously contacted him. According to Harris, she would rage and threaten him. He told one TV host quote, I was on the run from her, hiding out at friends houses. She'd drive around all night looking for me, and sometimes she'd find me. She'd stand outside the house and scream that she was going to kill herself. Sometimes Harris was forced to sleep in his own car just to avoid Lee's wrath. These wildly different interpretations of the exact same events really matter. In this case. You could be picturing this expecting mother and dedicated wife, a woman who is desperate to make her family work despite a reluctant partner's hesitancies, but you could also picture a woman who was stalking her estranged husband, a woman who won't leave his house, who won't respect his request for space, and who allegedly abused him. Actually
13:09 it's not really allegedly. Later Lee would admit she did slap him, throw flower pots at him, and flip over a coffee table, but she didn't see that as abuse. Around this time, Harris became concerned for the fate of his unborn child. He wanted Lee to receive treatment for her mental health before she gave birth, and of course Lee wanted to fix things too, so she and Harris went to a marriage counselor. She made the appointment. They saw a psychiatrist name doctor Oliver Byorgston, and Doctor Borgston Diagnosedly as being on the bipolar spectrum. Her specific condition was called hyperthiamic temperament. It was characterized by dwelling, blaming, and temper outbursts. Doctor Borgston was prepared to help treat Lee with medication, and Harris was in agreement with that. He wanted to see Lee get better. He wanted her to be treated, so Lee began taking a new prescription, but she was wary. She had never had a mental illness diagnosis before, and mental illness did not run in her family. Actually, she felt that her outbursts were reasonable, not the result of bipolar disorder. Lee was going through, as she described it, a difficult pregnancy, and for unknown reasons, she feared that her baby might have Down syndrome. But Lee was playing ball. She picked up her prescription for a drug called navane from the pharmacy and she took three doses as prescribed, but then her friend with the medical background advised Lee to stop taking the medication, presumably because navane is a strong antipsychotic and this friend didn't understand why Lee
14:41 would need it, so she stopped. Then Lee also found out that her mother and Harris had spoken to doctor Bjorgston before their first appointment for counseling. Lee felt this was a betrayal and by doing that, Harris had tainted doctor Borgston's perception of her, and Lee was certain that Harris had done the same thing with her mother too. Harris refuted these claims, saying that he was simply trying to get Lee help, but Lee thought his intentions were more nefarious, that he was trying to establish that she was mentally ill and done stable to her family and medical professionals. She thought that he was trying to save face for walking out on his pregnant wife. After Lee stopped taking her meds, Harris knew he wanted custody of their unborn child. According to Harris, he felt a responsibility towards this child. He couldn't let them face the world with only Lee at their side. Harris told CBS, the physical violence is one thing, the mental instability is another. In February of nineteen ninety three, barely a year after they were married, a pregnant Lee filed for divorce.
15:46 In response, Harris countersued. He alleged that due to Lee's abuse, he suffered from post traumatic stress disorder, and then their daughter was born. After that came the custody battle of a lifetime. Honestly, it was more a war than a battle, and only one parent will come out victorious. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. I love giving special and thoughtful gifts, especially during the holiday season. That's why I'm giving loved ones story Worth. Story Worth is an online service that helps you and your loved ones preserve precious memories and stories for years to come. Every week, story Worth emails your relative or friend a thought provoking question of your choice from tons of options, like what's the bravest thing You've ever done in your life? After one year, story Worth will compile all your loved one's stories, including photos, into a beautiful keepsake book that you'll be able to share and revisit for generations to come. It's been a remarkable way for my family to keep memories alive. I lost my grandmother when I was young, but I remember her biscuits. Getting her recipe and some funny stories about making biscuits with her is a priceless gift I cherish. With story Worth, I am giving those I love most a thoughtful, personal gift from the heart and preserving their memories and stories for years to come. Go to storyworth dot com slash Southern Fried and save ten dollars on your first purchase. That's storyworth dot com slash Southern Fried to save ten dollars on your first purchase. This show
17:22 is sponsored by Betterhelp For the holidays, our family focuses on a gift for each kiddo, while the adults just enjoy our time spent together, whether or not your family gives gifts during the holidays, you get to define how you give to yourself, and the holidays are a great time to do that. So, whether it's by starting therapy, going easier on yourself during the tough moments, or treating yourself to a day of complete rest, remember to give yourself some love this holiday season. I have used therapy a lot in my adult life to deal with major traumas and also to learn coping skills that have been invaluable to me, like say boundaries with people who upset me or stress me out. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give Better Help a try.
18:07 It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. In the season of giving, give yourself what you need with Better Help. Visit Betterhelp dot com slash Southern today to get ten percent off your first month. That's Better Help h e lp dot com slash Southern. Savannah Catherine Todd was born on May sixth, nineteen ninety three, in Charleston, South Carolina. On future documents, Savannah's name would be listed as Savannah Lee Barnett. Later, Lee would write in a diary about why she chose the name Savannah. She explained, I've always loved the name Savannah. It reminds me of great beauty. It also reminds me of my home, The Endless reads, the Shrimp, the Blue Herons. On the day of Savannah's birth, Lee was overjoyed her baby was a healthy, beautiful girl. But that joy didn't last because when Savannah was two and a half months old, Harris sued for custody and it was a terrible process, hateful, vitriolic, with mud slinging on both sides. Over the course of the twelve day custody trial, here's what happened. Lee claimed that Harris was gay and that the only reason he wanted their daughter was to punish her. She said he was an evil man, and she even pointed to some artwork Harris owned that she felt was particularly satanic. The Peace depicted a bearded pianist surrounded by cherubs.
19:34 Sure it's kind of weird, but I don't know about satanic. Harris, of course, disagreed with all of this. He said he loved his newborn daughter and didn't want custody out of revenge. He also denied being gay. I'm sure he denied that he was evil too, after all, the artwork had been created by a friend. During the custody proceedings, Harris got his shots in too. He claimed that Lee was too promiscuous to be a good mother. He had hired private detectives. They had evidence that revealed that Lee had six lovers since their divorce. Harris thought this showed Lee's lack of parental responsibility. He also had evidence that Lee was drinking alcohol during a period when she was also breastfeeding. But some of Harris's claims during the custody suit were more serious than mudslingy. He told the court about how Lee had stalked him, and Harris brought in doctor Byorkston, the marriage counselor, for his expert testimony. Doctor Bjorkston told the family court about Lee's mental health diagnosis. The psychiatrist said her condition was associated with violence to Lee. Doctor Byorgston's testimony felt life destroying because despite the fact that Lee provided two other psychiatrists who denied any mental health issues, Doctor Borgston's testimony appeared compelling to the court. It made it nearly impossible for Lee to win, or at least that's how she saw it. She said, the more you claim you're not mentally ill, the crazier you sound. To gain more clarity, a final psychiatrist was brought in and this one confirmed Doctor Brewergston's diagnosis. Lee had a hyperthymic temperament. They
21:07 said that Harris was the more predictable parent and they recommended that Harris have custody and also baby Savannah's child advocate testified and agreed, which isn't shocking. Lee kept claiming the child advocate was biased toward Harris, which is a big deal. A huge part of the child advocate's job is to be impartial and only act in the interest of the child. Savannah's child advocate was forced to hire their own lawyer for legal protection against Lee's allegations. Lee also struggled to make a good impression on the judge. She frequently had angry outbursts during the court proceedings. She had so many of these outbursts that the judge ordered a bailiff to stand behind her. The bailiff kept his hands on Lee's shoulders that way, Lee would remain seated in court. Lee's friends claimed that she just couldn't handle the stress of the trial. They believed this was a sensible reaction to a mother facing the loss of her child. I disagree with her friends.
22:03 Most parents in a custody fight do their best to remain calm and project reason and responsibility to the judge. You cannot have temper tantrums in court, unless, of course, her mental health diagnosis was true and she could not control herself. Either way, she is making the case for the experts who testified against her. By the end of it, the judge chose to grant custody to Harris. To explain his decision, the judge cited Harris's better paying job, Lee's inability to control her impulses, and the fact that Harris was willing to share custody while Lee was not. In fact, when Harris's joint custody proposition was offered to Lee, she rejected it. According to the Herald, the court found that Lee steadfastly rejected that the father had any role of value to the child, and that she and the child would be better off if he were not in the picture at all. See completely unreasonable. Savannah was hers alone in her mind. Also, the judge did agree that Lee had been abusive toward Harris. The judge expressed concern that Lee's mental illness might lead to actions like homicide or suicide. And remember, Lee did not deny those three incidents of violence. So on February eighteenth of nineteen ninety four, the judge awarded full custody of nine and a half month old Savannah to forty one year old Harris Todd. Thirty four year old Lee Barnett would see her daughter during supervised visits two weekends a month. On the same day this custody decision was made, Harris took Savannah home without Lee. Now that Harris had custody of little Savannah, he was overjoyed. He told MBC's Date Line that he
23:37 felt an overwhelming sense to protect and care for her. Savannah had her own bedroom with a crib and pastel pink walls. She had clothes and toys and a loving family. Harris was the happiest he had ever been while taking care of his baby daughter, but at the same time, Lee was the unhappiest she had ever been. She did not like that a judge said she was a danger to her own child, especially since she felt that her child was in significantly more danger with her father. During the custody proceedings, Harris had indicated that should Savannah show signs of mental illness as Lee had, he would take Savannah to a mental health professional. He said that he would feel comfortable doing that when Savannah was young, as young as three years old. Lee felt this was outrageous in proof that Harris was going to discredit her daughter through mental illness. I assume in Lee's mind, she thought Harris would take Savannah to a psychiatrist, claimed she was crazy and not let her control her own life. After all, that's what Lee felt Harris had done to her.
24:37 But one could also rationally argue that Harris was promising to watch Savannah closely for any signs of mental health issues and promising the judge he would get the child help if she needed it. So often these disorders are genetic. Two weeks after the verdict, Lee went to pick up her daughter, with her friend and babysitter accompanying her. Savannah had a couple of bruises on her head and a bloody knows. Lee believed that Harris had hurt their daughter. Harris said that Savannah had fallen while spending time with her grandmother. He took her to the er and They found the injuries to be the result of a minor fall, and the doctors at the er found no signs that Savannah was abused. Not satisfied, Lee took Savannah to her pediatrician, who agreed with the ER's staff that Savannah's injuries were from a minor fall and there was no indication of abuse. Lee was infuriated. Ultimately, she just couldn't stand to see her daughter with Harris, so she took action, and her first action, as she tells it, was to try to appeal the custody decision. But Lee claimed she couldn't appeal the decision. Supposedly, the judge hadn't finished the correct paperwork in time, so the thirty day deadline for appeals came and went.
25:47 It's a little hard for me to believe that this judge didn't follow the paperwork on time. Lee said this in a Dateline interview. But it's not like the judge came on the show to dispute it. Honestly, I don't know what happened. What I do know is that Lee was desperate. She wholeheartedly believed she needed to keep her child safe. So when she saw a sixty minute segment about where to get fake birth certificates. In Los Angeles, she went. She made her way across the country and purchased two birth certificates, one for herself using the pseudonym Alexandria Maria Canton, and one for Savannah using the pseudonym Nick. Lee figured that Savannah could pass for a boy, at least for a while. Later, Lee would change Savannah's alias from Nick to Samantha, and Samantha would stick. After getting the fake birth certificates, Lee went to Houston, Texas. There she popped on a black wig and walked into a DMV and got a Texas driver's license. After that, it was simple to obtain two passports. On Saturday, April twenty third, nineteen ninety four, Lee arrived at Harris's Charleston home. She picked up Savannah for her scheduled visit. The mother and daughter were going to a birthday party together.
26:59 Although there were supposed to be a court ordered chaperone with Lee, there wasn't. Maybe Harris figured the other parents of the birthday party would count a supervision, or maybe he was trying to extend an olive branch by not pestering Lee about a chaperone. Lee was supposed to bring Savannah back to Harris by six o'clock that evening, but she didn't. This wasn't the first time Lee hadn't brought Savannah back. He had to get an emergency court order once to go get his daughter. So he drove over to Lee's house, but the house was empty. He began calling people, but no one had any clue where Lee was, where Savannah was, and honestly, no one could have even guessed. Later, Harris said, I didn't even imagine anything that horrible.
27:41 I'm going to pause now for a word from today's sponsors. This year, I am thankful for Honeylove because there is nothing worse than suffering from an uncomfortable bra or shapewear. Say goodbye to uncomfortable underwire and bulky fabrics that trap heat. Honeylove's bras feature supportive bonding that eliminates the need for underwire without sacrificing lift. I've always struggled finding comfortable bras without underwire, so Honeylove is a godsend for me. I feel confident and comfortable without sacrificing style. Honeylove's best selling crossover bra is so comfortable it's sure to be your new go too. This bra gives all the support of traditional bras without the underwire. Honeylove is just as easy to put on as it is to take off. Shapewear shouldn't be hard. Their products make you look good and feel good. Give the gift of comfort and style to yourself this holiday season. You deserve it. Treat yourself to the best bras and shapewear on the market and save up to twenty percent off site wide at Honeylove dot com slash SFTC this month. Only after you purchase, they'll ask where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them we sent you. It's time to ditch the underwire for good thanks to Honeylove. Still looking for that perfect gift this holiday season, there is still time to find incredible, original gifts with the help of Uncommon Goods.
29:04 Uncommon Goods dot com has the absolute best gifts for everyone in your life. My friend loves plants and I found a lovely heart shaped watering steak perched on a terra cotta steak. This sweet hand blown glass work of art will keep indoor plants hydrated for up to a week. Uncommon Goods looks for products that are high quality, unique and often handmade. They have the most meaningful out of the ordinary gifts anywhere, and uncommon experiences are more than virtual classes. Their opportunities to have fun and connect in new ways. From cooking and mixology classes to gardening, and so much more. From art and jewelry to kitchen, home and bar. Uncommon Goods has something for everyone, truly unique gifts that you can't find just anywhere. To get fifteen percent off your next gift, go to Uncommon Goods dot com slash Southern Friud. That's Uncommon Goods dot com slash Southern Friud for fifteen percent off. Don't miss out on this limited time off for Uncommon Goods. We're all out of ordinary. When you're living on a tight budget, unexpected expenses just seem impossible. Earn in can really help. Earn In is an app that gives you access to your pay as you work up to one hundred dollars per day or up to seven hundred and fifty dollars per pay period. Just download the earn in app and verify your paycheck. Any money you access is automatically repaid from your next paycheck.
30:27 I wish an app like earn in had been around in my younger years. Living paycheck to paycheck, there weren't many options if I was struggling any given week. Earn In is designed to support you in the short term and long term with no mandatory fees and no credit check. Download earn in today spelled EA r ni in in the Google Play or Apple App Store. When you download the earn in app, type in Southern Fried under podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show under podcast subject to your available earnings daily max and pay period max. See earnin dot com slash cos for details. Earn In is a financial technology company, not a bank. Bank. Products are issued by Evolved Bank in Trust Member FDIC. Sixty four days after losing the custody battle, Lee had acquired every false document she needed. Now she and her daughter could become entirely new people. And that's exactly what they did.
31:32 On that fateful Saturday in April of nineteen ninety four, Lee, Savannah, and Lee's older brother got into a rental car. They left Charleston and headed south. Lee had ten thousand dollars with her that's more than twenty thousand today. On the way, they stopped at a gas station. There, Lee cut her hair and died at brown. Then they traveled to the Atlanta Airport. Lee showed her and Savannah's fake documents and then they got on a plane. From here on out, Lee would become Alex and Savannah would become Nick. Alex and Savannah traveled from the US to Malaysia. Seven months later, they went to South Africa. That's where Alex met an engineering geologist.
32:15 His name was Juwan gelden Heis. Alex told Juan everything, and Juan kept her secret. He adored baby Savannah, who was now going by the name Samantha, and would keep that name permanently. Lee said she fell in love with a man who fell in love with her daughter. Alex married Juan several months later in nineteen ninety five. Now Lee became Alex gelden Heiss, Savannah became Samantha gelden Heiss, and Juwan would raise her as his own biological daughter. Samantha did not find out the truth for years. Shortly after, Juan and Alex had a son together named Reyes. After some time in South Africa, the gelden Heist family moved to Botswais for Juwan's career. In two thousand and three, they would again move for Juwan's career, this time to New Zealand, and then their last move was to Australia. They became Australian citizens in two thousand and seven. By this point, Lee had successfully been on the run for thirteen years. She'd remain on the run for nearly seven more years, even though numerous law enforcement agencies were looking for her. Back in nineteen ninety four, on the day Lee abducted Savannah, Harris called Lee's younger brother, Cliff. Harris wanted to know where his ex wife and daughter were.
33:36 Cliff told the story to journalist Maureen Mayher. He goes, where's your sister? I said, I have no idea, and he goes, your sister is not a fit mother. She can't take care of a child by herself, she doesn't have the sense for it. And I finally just eventually said, well, apparently she has the sense to disappear from you. Soon, it became clear to Harris that Lee and Savannah were not coming back. Harris was certain that Lee had taken Savannah to hurt him, not to save Savannah. He told forty eight hours I just can't believe it. How could something like this happen, How could it possibly happen? How could she be here and then be gone right away? Harris notified the appropriate law enforcement agencies that his daughter had been kidnapped. Lee's arrest horant was out by the end of that month, and the FBI assigned Agent Chris Quick to the case.
34:29 The FBI took this man hunt for Lee and Savannah very seriously. They were concerned that Lee might hurt Savannah, but honestly, Agent Quick thought this would be a two week situation tops, And at first I can see why it felt like that. For example, Lee had a large map of South America in her home, and she had spent some time growing up in Belize, so maybe she had connections there. Maybe that's where she went. It might have seemed like a strong lead, but it turned out to be a red herring. Also, less than a week before the kidnapping, Li sent out a letter and videotape to her friends and family. Here's an excerpt from the letter. To whom it may concern, I recently lost custody to my beautiful nine and a half month old nursing baby. This happened because of a truly evil person b Harris Todd, and a totally corrupt family court system. The recorded video was similar in tone. Lee spoke to the camera saying that her ex husband, Harris Todd, had misrepresented her as a villain. Lee claimed that he made false allegations about her out of a need for revenge. He apparently was only worried about hurting Lee, and he didn't care if you hurt little baby Savannah too. Here's a direct quote from the video. Savannah and I belong together, and nobody besides God has the right to destroy that.
35:51 I promise and swear on my life that I will continue to take care of my daughter. I will keep her safe and I will never allow any one to harm her again. Lee called these letters and video messages an attempt to embarrass and discredit him, but to the FBI, they felt promising. Lee was emotional, hot headed, She had a lot of feelings she wanted to say. Surely she would reach out to people in the United States to say those feelings, and in doing so they would catch her. Agent quick promptly put traces on all of Lee's friends and family members phones, but Lee didn't call any of them. Agent quick monitored the flights to South Africa and Belize, where Lee had international contacts where her family owned property. But Lee didn't reach out to those contacts either, and she didn't visit those properties. He later told forty eight Hours. Most fugitives mess up make mistakes because they can't leave the life they came from. This didn't occur in this case. She totally cut ties from everyone. Lee later said, I feel the FBI and every other law enforcement agency underestimated me. The FBI developed a profile for Lee.
37:04 It determined that she was used to nice things and enjoyed traveling, so the experts indicated that Lee was probably going to find a nice location she would make connections with rich people. In the end, this profile turned out to be fairly accurate, but the FBI wouldn't know that for decades because they didn't have one crucial piece of information, Dorothy Lee Barnett's new name. Three years passed, then four now. According to the FBI, the case was officially cold. It wasn't out of their mind. They had age progressions of Savannah don often and followed up on hundreds of leeds, but they also weren't having much luck without Lee's alias. Their hands were tied. Harris became fed up with this lack of progress. He probably felt like he was going mad.
37:54 His daughter, his flesh and blood, was missing. Harris made videos for Savannah, and one of those videos, he said the following Losing you took most of the life out of me. Sometimes I feel like I'm already dead and just haven't fallen over yet. He wrote poems about her. He couldn't just forget that his child was out there somewhere without him, So a few years after the investigation began, Harris took matters into his own hands. He began a national media campaign. He wanted to raise awareness about his missing daughter anywhere and everywhere that he could, because he knew that with every passing year he was missing out on her life. Throughout the mid to late nineties, Harris was featured or interviewed on almost every show you can think of. He wrote to John Walsh's America's Most Wanted. He appeared on Unsolved Mysteries, He spoke to Forty eight Hours Dateline, the Montell Williams Show, The Sally Jesse Raphael Show, and more. He hired private detective after private detective. He sent out Savannah's picture on two different eighty vo card mailings where they sent out missing children on cards via the mail. He even wrote to President Bill Clinton.
39:05 Harris was determined. He knew it would only take one person to recognize Lee or Savannah, then he could be reunited with his daughter. But the process was grueling. Harris spent hundreds of thousands of dollars trying to find Savannah. Besides expensive private detectives, he would get calls from TV producers instructing him to travel across the country to do a show than the day before. They would bump Harris for a better story. Still, Harris did get quite a few appearances, and the FBI received hundreds of tips due to his efforts, and Harris himself would follow up on some of them. He figured that he would recognize his ex wife faster than anyone else, and he knew better than anyone that the FBI's bureaucracy could really slow down their ability to follow up on a good lead. So Harris would travel across the world. Took places like Mexico and Costa Rica just because one person had seen a blond woman with a young daughter, and none of these leads panned out, but Harris didn't give up. He said to reporters, if I have to spend the rest of my life doing this, so be it. Harris also filed lawsuits against members of Lee's family. He believed that Lee's mother, her brother Cliff, and her friend Susan had helped her kidnap Savannah. Susan told Forty eight Hours that none of Harris's allegations were true, but the lawsuit was financially devastating to her.
40:31 She also alleged that Harris's hired pe Eyes would threaten to destroy her life and family, but despite all of his efforts, nothing happened. Ten years passed and then fifteen, and Harris began to feel like it was over. If his daughter was alive, she was fully grown. Now she was a whole person who did not know him. Plus, the cycle of hope and despair was exhausting. He would chase a lead, let himself think maybe this is it, and have nothing to show for it. Harris began to ask, do I want to put myself through this again? In two thousand and three, the FBI found evidence that Lee had tried to obtain an American passport using an alias but they still couldn't find her, not until the year twenty eleven, when one email turned Harris Lee and Savannah's worlds upside down. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. In the early morning hours of Sunday, November twenty seventh, twenty eleven, Harris Todd received an email.
41:39 It read I'd like to speak to you in regards to your daughter. Now. This type of email wasn't foreign to Harris. He had received a lot of them over the years, so he knew better than to get excited. The email senders were a married couple. They said they had been friends with Lee and Savannah's family for more than a decade. Thet I thought something was weird about Alex's backstory, and after Alex and this couple had a falling out, the couple decided to do a deeper investigation. That's when they realized Alex wasn't Alex at all, she was Lee. Harris sent them trial documents to help them make their decision, and then the couple provided photographic evidence to verify that they had the right people. The email senders told Harris that Lee and Savannah were known as Alex and Samantha gelden Heis and lived in Queensland, Australia. Harris was blown away. There in this photo of a Christmas celebration was his ex wife, fifty one year old Lee Barnett, and there also was his grown daughter, eighteen year old Savannah Catherine Todd. It had been seventeen years since Harris had last seen Savannah, and he didn't recognize his own daughter, but he recognized Lee immediately. Harris notified the FBI, and equipped with the correct alias, they found Alex and Samantha gelden Heis EA, but it took them two years to negotiate a deal for Lee's arrest with Australian law enforcement. They had to get other government agencies involved, and you know how
43:09 paperwork goes, It just takes time. Plus, as US Attorney Bill Nettles said, Savannah was living a safe, healthy and otherwise normal life, so the FBI wasn't in a rush, but Harris felt like he was out of time. In twenty thirteen, he suggested that he would go to Australia himself, just approached Lee and introduce himself to his daughter, but the FBI asked him not to. They thought there was a high chance that Lee would flee again, and suddenly the two decades long case of missing baby Savannah went to the top of the stack. On the morning of Monday, November fourth, twenty thirteen, after nearly twenty years of being on the run, fifty three year old Dorothy Lee Barnett was arrested in Malubla, Queensland, Australia. She was charged with the international parental kidnaps and two counts of passport fraud. Lee faced twenty three years in prison, three years for the kidnapping and ten each for the fraud. She sat on her living room couch flanked by FBI agents and that's where she explained what was going on to her son Reese. On the whole, Lee seemed rather unsurprised by the whole ordeal, calm, even perhaps she had always known that this was coming. She was taken to a Brisbane jail and denied bell and then she was given an opportunity to call her daughter, twenty year old Samantha. That's when Lee started to cry. At the time, Samantha was away at university studying to become a nurse. When
44:39 her mom phoned at about seven thirty am, Samantha's boyfriend picked up he heard that Lee was upset and immediately handed the phone to Samantha. That's when Lee explained everything to her. Well, Lee told Samantha her own version of everything. According to Lee's interviews with Forty eight Hours, she said, Sammy, you know how we've never had communication with the family and friends in the US, And Samantha said yeah, and then Lee told her, well, I was married before, and I'm going to jail now because I've been accused of kidnapping you, and I said I had to keep you safe. Upon learning about her mother's dual life, Samantha had a ton of questions, and the first one was this, wait, does that mean that dad wasn't my dad?
45:24 Because Samantha had always believed that Juwan Geldenheis was her real father, and even though Juwan and Lee had divorced in two thousand and eight after Juwan had an affair, Juwan and Samantha remained close. As it turns out, Juan had died just a week before Lee's arrest, a week before this incredibly life altering arrest of her mom. It was bone cancer, and Samantha said her last words to him where I Love you. The day after Lee was arrested, the FBI sat down with Samantha. They explained to her exactly what it happened over the past nineteen years. Samantha was shocked. She couldn't believe that her mother was ever accused of abuse or violence, and Samantha laughed in the FBI agent's faces when they indicated that Lee might be mentally ill. Samantha told NBC that's not who she is. She supported her mother. She described her to news outlets as resilient, compassionate, selfless, and encouraging. She told forty eight Hours she did everything she could and more just to keep me safe.
46:29 And she said, if you think about every single little thing that she has gone through, I've lived this wonderful life. And according to Samantha and her half brother, Reese, they did have a wonderful life. Their childhood, which was largely spent in South Africa, was especially amazing, full of adventure. Reese told CBS, we had drives walking outside our house and on the streets, and buffalo and all sorts of stuff around the river. It was fun all the time. Then the family moved to the Sunshine Coast of Australia, where Samantha recalled that her family visited the beach often. They went to wildlife reserves. She competed in swim races. She learned how to dance and play piano. Samantha wasn't the only one who supported Lee. Most of their Australian friends came to Lee's aid as well, and the days following her arrest, nearly twenty people flooded the Galden Highs home. They were all working with Samantha and Reese to get her out of jail. At the same time, Harris traveled across the world to Australia. He wanted to meet his daughter, but the timing wasn't right. Samantha was taking a lot in and after about a month there, Harris returned home to South Carolina without having met his daughter. He took it well. He understood that Samantha was coping with a lot, grieving for the man she knew his dad, and worrying for her mother. Based on her conversations with her mother, Samantha had always suspected that Lee's years in the US were associated with sadness, but Samantha had no idea
48:00 that any of this had ever happened. Her brother Reese, was also kept in the dark. The only person to have ever known the truth was her father, Juan, and since he died a week before Lee was arrested, all of his memories were gone. For almost a year, Lee and her supporters tried to stop the US officials from extraditing her out of Australia. They even started to go fundme campaign. It raised about thirty one hundred dollars. During court proceedings, Samantha and her family held signs that read we love you Mom. But ultimately all these efforts failed. They just didn't have a legal leg to stand on, and in September of twenty fourteen, Lee returned to Charleston, South Carolina. Twenty years had passed since she had last stepped foot in the city. At first, Lee considered going to trial. She entered a plea of not guilty on Monday, September twenty ninth, twenty fourteen.
48:53 She claimed that she had been in an impossible situation, a young mother fighting a corrupt court system that tried to take her child away. In Lee's mind, she did not kidnap her daughter. She saved her, but legal experts like prosecutor Nathan Williams contended that you can't take the law into your hands and flee the country with a child because you don't like the result from a divorce. Hearing, on Monday, November twenty fourth, twenty fourteen, a judge denied Lee's bond. They said that Lee's connections to people overseas was concerning, and her track record of fleeing the country also proved she couldn't be trusted. After months and months in jail, Lee realized that she couldn't take on the US government, not in a legal battle like this one, so she pled guilty to all three charges. On Tuesday, September tenth, twenty fifteen, fifty four year old Dorothy Lee Barnett had her sentencing hearing. Her daughter, twenty one year old Samantha, spoke on her behalf. According to The Herald, Samantha said, I was raised very fortunately. I was loved beyond belief.
50:00 In the end, Lee was sentenced to twenty one months in jail. She received credit for a time served in Australia and the US, and was released in May of twenty fifteen. She then was on probation in South Carolina for two years. She has been a free woman ever since. Harris, who was now around sixty two, was obviously disappointed by this sentencing. He felt that over a third of his life was dedicated to finding his missing daughter, and now his daughter's kidnapper would be released immediately. It didn't seem fair, but he conceded that no sentencing would make up for the pain of those lost years. Harris did get to meet his adult daughter. It happened in the winter of twenty fourteen. Samantha had written Harris an eight page letter where she said she was open to having a relationship with him as long as he didn't speak poorly of her mother. So Harris and Samantha met. They explored his Charleston home together. They spoke about their family history and in NATS Samantha described this meeting as pleasant and normal, and Harris described it similarly. He acknowledged to NBC that it was hard. There was a huge gap between this father and daughter, one that would probably never be fully bridged. A friend of Lee's, who was a judge, accompanied Samantha to her dad's house and said in the two and a half hours there, Harris just showed her around the house and showed off his prized possessions, but sam defended Harris, saying
51:30 that it was awkward for both of them. Harris continues to reside in Charleston, South Carolina. As of twenty sixteen, Harris and Samantha don't stay in touch, but Harris has made peace with this, he told Dateline. She is her own person now, she can make her own decisions. She knows where I am, and she knows that I'll want to hear from her whatever happens. Samantha graduated and became a nurse. That same year, her half brother, Reese graduated from Auburn University in Alabama. He had stayed in the US to stay close to his mom, while Samantha returned to Australia to her fiance and her schooling. Samantha married her fiance, Bradley Stevens, in Fiji so her mother could attend her wedding since Australia denied Lee entry. Today, Samantha is in her early thirties and continues to live near the Sunshine Coast.
52:23 In June of twenty nineteen, Lee Barnett released a memoir. It's called A Mother's Promise. The subtitle is how Far Would You Go? To protect your child. I haven't read it. I don't plan to. I'm sure. Lie spends her memoir continuing to argue that her actions were justified. She has no remorse for what she did to Harris. When asked if she didn't think he had a legal right to see Samantha, she smiled and said legal right be damned. Lee is even quoted as saying, there's nothing wrong with me. I've never done anything violent. I've raised two amazingly healthy, intelligent children who are happy. So who's telling the truth and who's lying? The case is often described as he said, she said, And on the surface that's true. The vitriolic, hateful divorce proceedings show that, But if you look between the lines, you can see that one person is more manipulative. If you watch interviews, Lee comes off as this energetic, charismatic, youthful, and attractive woman. She also sounds mostly reasonable. She did, in fact, raise two normal, healthy and happy children who are devoted to her.
53:32 In one interview, Samantha, when addressing her mother's mental health diagnosis, was disbelieving of it. Quote unless she had done a whole one eighty, then that's not who she is. Well, what if she had done on one eighty. The hyperthymic temperament also has positive aspects that weren't mentioned in court. In court, doctor said her illness was associated with violence and quote dwelling, blaming, and temper outbursts. When I looked up hyperthymia, the first description said it was a constant state of mild mania, meaning you have a high energy, enthusiastic, and overactive personality, which is basically how her friend's family and children described Lee. Vivacious and full of energy, always on the go, very friendly and talkative to me. She seemed to show both sides of one coin, and her behavior in court, as I've already pointed out, basically proved Harris's case. If you need a Bayliff standing over you, you might not be able to control yourself. And then after she fled the country, she turned back into the positive side. She had gotten what she wanted, a daughter, and as she said, she felt only God had the right to separate her from her daughter. She was completely unreasonable toward Harris having any relationship with his daughter. She acted as though she was protecting Samantha, but really she wanted to keep her to herself, refusing to sh share custody, which was a factor in the judge's decision. And later she claimed Harris's
55:06 abuse made her run, meaning the incident when she picked up her daughter and she had mild injuries from a fall. She said that was what made her run. Specifically, the DA who would have tried her when she was caught, reinvestigated this argument. In preparation. He got the records from the er and her pediatrician that both concluded Samantha was not abused, and he found proof that Lee was already working on her fake documents so that she could run before Samantha fell. It was a lie. Lee showed absolutely no remorse for what she did to Harris. She seemed proud of it, bragging that law enforcement had underestimated her, saying legal rights be damned, with a smile on her face. She clearly felt entitled and above the law. And then, on the other hand, you have Harris almost eight years older than his youthful ex wife, and he looked even older than that. He didn't have Lee's natural charisma. He was a slow, talking, reserved man. He was reasonable.
56:06 As much as he wanted to find his daughter, he understood and respected her feelings once she was found, and backed off until Samantha was ready to come to him. None of the things Lee accused Harris of were proved true. He was not abusive and unstable. He fiercely denied telling Lee to get an abortion. He said he felt an overwhelming sense of responsibility when he found out she was pregnant. He may not have wanted children, but he wasn't walking away once it happened. He even agreed to marriage counseling after he asked for a divorce. When that didn't work, he begged Lee to move out of his house, and he wound up walking away from his own home when she refused to leave and he felt unsafe with her. Lee did say he was cold to her, but that's not violence. She admitted slapping him and throwing things. She had a terrible temper that she couldn't even control in court, she had manipulated him into marriage and forced him into fatherhood, and yet Harris seemed to try over and over to be fair with Lee. In the end, Harris seemed tired and resigned. He searched for years, spending thousands and thousands of dollars. He traveled around the world, searching himself he lost almost twenty years with his daughter. He continuously talked about how much he loved her. She was his world, even though their time alone together had been brief, and now she is a stranger to him. As the judge and their custody dispute said, there are no winners here. Lee may have thought
57:37 she won, but after she was convicted and couldn't return to Australia, her beloved and devoted daughter still chose to stay there and make a life for herself in Australia rather than picking up and following her mother to the US. Her brother moved to the States, but Samantha refused to give up her own personal life that she had been building. Now it was Lee's turn to be devas and lives separately from her daughter. Samantha seems to be the most well adjusted and sweet young woman that you could imagine. After all this, don't forget she had also lost the man who she believed to be her father just a week before her mother's arrest. Yet she never seems to feel sorry for herself when you watch her interviews. She just seems strong and positive and forgiving Samantha geldenhis Stevens is a remarkable young woman. She built her own life after two other kinds of lives were stolen from her. She is the victim in this case, and yet she seems to have come out the strongest and happiest, which I would imagine be the one thing her parents could agree on that Samantha deserves to be happy. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Erica Kelly and Andrea Marshbak.
59:00 Southern Fred's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio, and the original graphic art is by Kully Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon Chuck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener's suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases you'll always send me. Please remember that I don't accept suggestions on social media private messaging, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fred True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and front corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shit ass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review. I'm on all large platforms like iTunes, iHeart, Spotify and Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed