201: The Murder of Carrie Daugherty
Everyone who frequented Barley’s Taproom & Pizzeria in Knoxville, Tennessee, knew bartender and waitress Carrie Daugherty. She was a friendly 24-year-old woman who had a quick wit and a sweet smile. But, on March 19, 2008, Carrie’s body was...
Everyone who frequented Barley’s Taproom & Pizzeria in Knoxville, Tennessee, knew bartender and waitress Carrie Daugherty. She was a friendly 24-year-old woman who had a quick wit and a sweet smile. But, on March 19, 2008, Carrie’s body was discovered on her own front lawn. She’d been brutally murdered. Those who knew Carrie were shocked. This was a woman with no enemies. When the murderer was apprehended, that sentiment was verified—Carrie had no enemies. Because the man who killed her claimed that he’d made a mistake during a bout of insanity.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Erica Kelley and Andrea Marshbank
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Recommended by Sarah, Lauren, and others.
Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/carrie-daugherty
This episode is brought to you by:
- Go to SimpliSafe.com/southernfried and for a limited time save 50% on your home security system when you sign up for a Fast Protect Plan. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
- Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey. Download today on iOS or Android.
- They say time waits for no one, and neither should payday--See EarnIn.com/TOS for more details.
- Go to UncommonGoods.com/southernfried for 15% off. We’re all out of ordinary
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:01 Southern Fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Today's episode is more graphic than usual. Listener discretion as strongly advised. In the city of Knoxville, Tennessee, Tuesday, March eighteenth, two thousand and eight was a beautiful, cool spring day with highs in the sixties. Twenty four year old Carrie Dougherty had to work that night. She was a server and sometimes bartender at a local watering hole. Her roommate, twenty six year old Amanda Close, didn't wait up for her. Carrie was a closer that night and wouldn't be home until after one am. After a turbulent period, Amanda and her boyfriend were back together. She spoke with him on the phone before she went to sleep, and she didn't think she had anything to worry about. Micah Johnson, her twenty one year old boyfriend, had gotten help after struggling with major mental health issues. He had checked into a psychiatric ward for a week. He was prescribed antipsychotic medications and he appeared to be doing better. So as Amanda drifted off to sleep that night, she might have thought everything was fine. That's probably why when she woke up briefly to the sound of a loud bang in her front yard, she didn't think anything of it. She rolled over and went back to sleep, But then Amanda woke again. This time it was to police officers, a swat team, and a hostage negotiator pounding on her front door, and that's when Amanda realized that things weren't fine. Her boyfriend
1:36 Mikah certainly wasn't fine, even though he had led her to believe that he was, and her friend and roommate Carrie would never be fine again. Welcome to episode two oh one, The Murder of Carrie Doherty. Carrie Amanda Doherty was born on May eighth, nineteen eighty three, and Chattanooga, Tennessee, to parents Carol and Steve. The Dougherties were a big family. Carrie was one of eight siblings. She had five brothers and two sisters, and she had more aunts, uncles, and cousins than you could count. Carrie attended Saint Jude Catholic School from kindergarten through eighth grade, then Notre Dame High School, where she graduated in two thousand and one. She had grown into a beloved young woman. She was bubbly and kind. Her high school classmates voted her most spirited, and they chose her for Homecoming Queen. Carrie was the epitome of the girl next door, wholesome, sweet and involved in everything.
2:38 She was on the cheerleading squad, in the student council, and was a leader for her church's youth ministry. Needless to say, everyone knew that Carrie was going places, and the first place she went after high school was spring Hill College, a private Catholic university in Mobile, Alabama. But for whatever reason, Carrie decided spring Hill wasn't for her, so in the fall of two thousand and three, Carrie enrolled at the University of Tennessee in Knoxville, maybe because ut was only one hundred miles from her hometown and family versus spring Hill College, which had been a whopping four hundred miles away. At the University of Tennessee, Carrie majored in journalism and electronic media. But near the summer of two thousand and six, twenty three year old Carrey took a break from her studies. She got a job at a popular Knoxville bar in eatery Barley's tap Room in Pizzeria. Barley's is located in Knoxville's historic Old City.
3:35 There's live music, and they boast the best draft beer selection in Knoxville. Carrie loved working for Barley's. She was good friends with the staff, and customers loved her. She was one of the most popular servers there. Carrie's manager told the Knoxville News Sentinel, she was part of our family here. She was a great person. She always tried to make everybody smile. She just brought life into a room. When Carrie wasn't working at Barley's in the spring of two thousand and eight, it's likely she was running. She was training for the Music City Half Marathon on April twenty sixth, two thousand and eight. She was participating in this race to fundraise for an organization that fights against childhood cancer. It's known as Emily's Power for a Cure. This organization held a special place in Carrie's heart because it was founded in honor of her two year old niece, Emily Ransom. In February of two thousand and six, Emily died of stage four narrow blastoma cancer. As a result of her passing her parents started this foundation, and of course, Carrie, who was described by family members as Emily's favorite aunt, was very involved. At the same time that Carrie was training for her half marathon and working at Barley's, she lived with her friend Amanda Close. Amanda spend a lot of time with her boyfriend, Micah Johnson, and as amanda'sroomate, Carrie hung out with Micah and Amanda often. Micah Ross Johnson was born on March sixth, nineteen eighty
5:06 seven, to parents Francis and Gary, and grew up in East Tennessee. In two thousand and three, Micah was attending Knoxville South Doyle High School. There, he was an officer in the technology club and a tight end for the school's football team. But it seemed like the tech side of things upheld to Michaeh more than the sports side of things, and though Micah was exceptionally bright, later testing put his IQ at one thirty three, he had problems with drugs and alcohol starting in high school. He was expelled for these issues, but he cleaned up his act, went back to high school and graduated with a scholarship to UT In two thousand and six, Micah began studying aerospace engineering at the University of Tennessee. He met his girlfriend Amanda close in early spring of two thousand and seven. But things came crashing down again for Micah when in his set ear at ET he was expelled for brutally assaulting a fellow classmate. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. In September of two thousand and seven, twenty year old Micah Johnson was headed to a math class in UT's airs hall. Micah's classmate, who will call George, was walking behind him. They had the same math class together. Suddenly, Micah turned around and punched George in the face. He fell down, completely knocked out, and then Micah continued punching him. Police report stated that Micah
6:40 punched an unconscious George four to five more times. For reference, Micah was six foot three inches tall and weighed nearly two hundred pounds, not a small man, even if he had left his football days behind in high school. Getting hit by him just one time was a knockout. As a result of Micah's ruthless haad attack, George suffered a broken jaw and numerous other injuries. He even had to have reconstructive surgery. Why had Michah suddenly attacked George? Was he overreacting to something George said, something George did. How could we possibly make sense of this unexplainable assault. Well, it turns out it's difficult to make sense of anything here because, according to other UT students in the same math class, Micah and George had never even spoken yet. Micah said he was reacting from George and his friends calling him names. It's unclear if George was even actually walking with his friends. From witness reports, the attack was sudden and unprovoked, but Micah insisted that George and his group were calling him pretty boy and other derogatory names. Then he said he saw George make a fist and suddenly believed he held a knife. Micah was expelled from the University of Tennessee, and a clinical psychologist who evaluated him following this assault said he suffered from quote a severe mental disease or defect, and that this mental disease or defect stopped him from acknowledging the wrongfulness of his actions, which is
8:13 why, even though he was arrested, he never went to trial for the assault. After Micah attacked George. He became extremely paranoid. He was convinced that the police were tracking him. His behavior was so strange that friends and family noticed it. Even Carrie, his girlfriend's roommate, noticed it. She wrote about Micah and her diary. Carrie described Micah as crazy and suggested that he might be schizophrenic. She had experience with mental illness and her immediate family. Her diary entry reads like a letter to Amanda. Maybe she was going to hand it to her friend and roommate to avoid confrontation. It's unclear, but what she wrote was chilling. Dear Amanda, in regard to Micah, ad don't feel comfortable around him. My brother Steve is schizophrenic. Sometimes he became convinced we me, Will and Pat are the devil. He especially hated Will. One day, Mom found Steve sitting on Will's chest. Will was three and unconscious. I haven't seen him since he put a plastic bag on my head fifteen years ago. Anyways, Micah is schizo as well, and frankly he terrifies me. Flashbacks, scary, not ready to die. Will and Pat are also Carrie's brothers. Despite feeling more than uncomfortable around Micah, Carrie had spent a lot of time with him since he was dating her roommate.
9:43 He was over at their North Knoxville house all the time, and the three of them hung out a lot, So even though Micah didn't actually live with Amanda and Carrie, it probably felt like it sometimes. Some court documents even report that they did live together. That's how often Micah was over. He also mowed the yard and helped take care of the house. Micah's actual home was in Maryville, Tennessee, which is about seventeen miles from Knoxville. He lived with his father and stepmother. Amanda called his dad when she thought Micah's behavior was getting out of hand to back up just a little, as I said. Micah and Amanda met an early spring of two thousand and seven. He did not exhibit any mental health issues at the time. He was twenty years old in studying aerospace engineering. He also held down a job.
10:33 But in September of that year, after about seven months of dating, Amanda would later testify that Micah began acting bizarrely. He was not eating or sleeping well, and he was saying unusual things. He also began abusing drugs and alcohol again. Specifically Benzo's like xanax or adavan, and he was a heavy marijuana smoker. That same month, in September, he attacked his classmate George and was expelled from Utia and this is when he received his first kind of vague diagnosis of mental disease or defect and avoided prison. But not long after this, Mica complained to Amanda that he had symptoms of a heart attack.
11:13 She was also alarmed by his anxiety and paranoia. At this time, she called Micah's father to pick him up, and Gary Johnson took his son to Baptist Hospital. He remained in the psychiatric unit for eight days. They medicated Micah heavily and he was improving, but he left the facility against medical advice because as doctor needed to quote rule out bipolar mania with psychosis versus first onset of schizophrenia. Amanda then distanced herself from Micah for a couple of months until he began acting like his old self again. In November, they reunited and Micah began spending a lot of time at Amanda and Carrey's house again. For months, it seemed like he was recovering well. He was working the late shift at the Coca Cola warehouse and had no problems there. On March sixth of two thousand and eight, Micah turned twenty one years old. He, Amanda, and Carrie celebrated his birthday at Barley's on the weekend before Carrie was murdered. On Tuesday, March eighteenth, Micah, Amanda, and Carry hung out yet again. They spent some time together during the day before Mica had to leave he needed to get ready for his shift at work later in the day. Carrie went to her job at Barley's. According to Amanda, all of these interactions seemed completely normal. That night, after work, around midnight, Micah called Amanda. They spoke on the phone for a while, but
12:45 at no point during their conversation did he mention one crucial detail that he was parked one block away from her house, watching and waiting, and he hadn't told Amanda yet another crucial detail that he has stopped taking his antipsychotic medications. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. There's never a wrong time to protect your home, but this fall happens to be an especially good time because you can get up to fifty percent off a brand new simply Safe home security system. Recently, I read that most burglaries occur during the day in normal working hours. I work from home, so I'm alone a lot, and I feel so much safer with simply Safe looking out for me. Simply Safe is comprehensive protection for the whole home with advanced sensors that detect break ins, fires, floods, and more, plus HD cameras for both inside and out. It's powered by twenty four to seven professional monitoring for less than one dollar a day, half the cost of traditional home security.
13:48 With new twenty four to seven live guard protection and the smart Alarm, wireless indoor camera monitoring, agents can see and speak to intruders, helping stop crime in real time. A powerful technology exclusively from simply Safe. Satisfaction is backed by simply Safe's money back guarantee. Try simply Safe for sixty days risk free. If you don't love it, return your system for a full refund for a limited time. Listeners can get a special fifty percent off any simply Safe system with a fast protect plan. Visit simplysafe dot com slash Southern Fried That's simplysafe dot com slash Southern Fried. There's no safe like simply safe. Everyone loves a good family mystery, especially one with as many twists and turns as June's Journey. June's Journey is the number one hidden object game in the world, but they're captivating to detective story taking you back to the glamour of the nineteen twenties with a diverse cast of characters. Each new scene takes you further through a thrilling murder mystery story that sets the main protagonist, June Parker, on a quest to uncover her family's mini secrets. Engage your sense of observation to find hidden clues. Search for hidden objects from the arlers of New York to the sidewalks of Paris. Escape to a bygone age of mystery, danger and romance, and build your very own island estate with expansive gardens and beautiful buildings. I am now in chapter nine, on a new adventure on the dark streets of Paris. With the holidays ramping up, life has gotten busier,
15:18 so I especially enjoy my breaks when I slip away to play my favorite game. Can You Crack the Case? Download June's Journey for free today on iOS and Android The following information is from court documents, eyewitness testimony, and Mike's multiple confessions. While no one will ever know for certain what exactly happened on this fateful night, this is about as close as we can get. Around one am, Wednesday, March nineteenth, two thousand and eight, twenty four year old Carrie Dougherty finished her shift at Barley's tap Room in Pizzeria. Bidding her coworker's farewell, she hopped on her Ford Explorer and drove home.
15:58 She had no idea Mike was waiting for her. He had parked a block away from Carrie and Amanda's house. Carrie parked on the street in front of the house. As Carrie got out of her SUV and was walking to the door, Micah approached her. At this point they may have exchanged a few words, but that is unclear and I will get into it more later. Micah had a brick he had gotten from the backyard. He suddenly hit Carry in the head with it. He used so much force that the brick broke in half. A neighbor who witnessed part of the attack and then called nine one one, said that he continued to beat Carrie in the head with the brick. As he dragged her across the front yard. He suddenly stopped, and as Carrie lay on the ground stunned, Micah went over to the car port. He grabbed a dull bladed shovel. Then he used that shovel to stab Carrie multiple times, mostly in her neck region. The Emmy would later say it appeared that Micah was trying to decapitate her. Then he grabbed some nylon rope from the car port. He wrapped the rope around Carrie's neck and tried to strangle her with it. He dragged her back and forth across the front yard. In total, Micah attacked Carrie for more than ten minutes, and he had grabbed her cell phone. Says she couldn't call for help, but as I said, a neighbor did call for help. They only saw the beginning of the attack before running for the phone to call nine one one, and at one forty six am, Knoxville Police Department officers were dispatched to investigate a domestic disturbance at Carrie's home. The police arrived at one fifty seven
17:33 am, and they discovered Carrie's body in the front yard. The nylon rope was still tied around her neck, and both the shovel and brick pieces lay nearby. She lay partially under her own vehicle. Later, Carrie's autopsy would show that she had deep lacerations from Micah chopping at her neck with a shovel. Her jugular vein had been severed. She had also suffered skull fractures and had abrasions on her back from being dragged. Her arms and hands were covered in defensive wounds. The medical examiner would later testify that Carrie had lived for several minutes of the horrific attack. Carrie's main cause of death was blunt for's injuries to the head, with the chopping, injuries to the neck and the strangulation being contributing factors. At the crime scene, authorities located Carrie's purse, jacket, shoes, and keys. They were strewn across the lawn. The scene was terribly gruesome. Carrie's blood was everywhere, especially on her vehicle where she was found. There was a blood trail from the side door of the house across the yard to Carrie's suv. After trying and failing to put Carrie's body in her own suv, presumably in an attempt to hide her body to buy time. Micah had fled the scene, but the police didn't know that.
18:52 They thought he might have gone inside the house. As a result, a swat team and hostage negotiator were called to the scene. The police knocked on the door and a surprised Amanda answered it. Meanwhile, Micah went to his father's home in Maryville, took a shower and changed clothes. He stashed his bloody clothes in a bag before going to an ATM and withdrawing five hundred dollars. Then he began to head toward Georgia. Cell Phone records put him in the Atlanta, Georgia area. When his father called him, Gary Johnson talked his son into coming back to turn himself in. Micah did drive back to Knoxville, but he didn't turn himself into authorities right away. Law enforcement officers had zeroed in on Micah Johnson as the primary suspect because Amanda told investigators about his mental health issues in her first interview, so they suspected strongly it was Mica from the jump. They just needed to find him. Meanwhile, Amanda fled to her parents' home in Loudney County. Because she was understandably distraught, She gave her dad her phone to answer and tried to get some sleep.
20:00 Micah called her phone that afternoon, but when Amanda's dad answered, court documents say there was a brief silence before he asked to speak with her. Mister Close refused and repeatedly told him he should turn himself into the police. He later testified then, in the approximate five minute call, Micah was vague but answering repetitively with quote little snippets of words that amounted to remorse, For example, while I've screwed up, I've messed up. When Amanda left to return home, she went out to her car and saw that someone had placed gravel in the shape of a heart with the words I am dead on the hood of her car. Someone had also rifled through her car and left a half empty beer can and cigarette butts. No one witnessed Mica do this, but the Close family confirmed that he had visited her family home several times, so he knew where to find Amanda. It had to be him. On Wednesday, March nineteenth, at eleven thirty pm, about ten hours after carry was murdered. A police officer spotted Micah. He was in his red nineteen eighty eight Ford F one to fifty pickup truck and he was near Carry and Amanda's home When the police officer spotted Micah. They tried to pull him over for a traffic stop, but Micah led the officer on a short chase, running multiple red lights. Finally, he slammed on his brakes on Henley Bridge.
21:23 He exited his car, ran to the side rail of the bridge and looked like he was going to jump, but he didn't. According to the police spokesperson who spoke with the Knoxville News Sentinel, there is no doubt he thought about it, and he had an opportunity before the officers got to him, but he never actually climbed up onto the railing, and then he started struggling with the officers. Michah struggled so hard that one officer even tried to taze him, but the wire projectile didn't go through his heavy jacket, so the shock was ineffective. Before transporting Micah to jail, the authority stopped at the Universe to the of Tennessee Medical Center to get him evaluated. He was found competent enough to transfer to jail. Then twenty one year old Michael Ross Johnson was arrested for the charges of first degree murder and evading arrest. He was held on a nine hundred thousand dollars bond. Around this time, investigators found Carrey's cell phone in Micah's truck, along with eighty seven dollars that she had made in tips that night. Micah's bloody fingerprints were on Carree's blood splattered SUV, and his clothes and shoes were covered in Carrie's DNA, not to mention his father's shower, which tested positive for blood. Everyone was shocked by Micah's horrific actions. Why would he kill Carrie? They were not hooking up or even flirtatious. They were barely even real friends. Carry's brother, Scott told the Knoxville News Sentinel, I don't have any idea why he would have done this. On Monday, March twenty fourth, Carrie's family held a Mass
22:57 of celebration at the Saint Jude Catholic Church. Afterward, Carrie was laid to rest in Hamilton Memorial Gardens in Hickson, Tennessee. Her family requested that any memorial contributions be donated to Emily's Power for a cure. The entrance to Barley's, where Carrie worked, was covered in cards, flowers, and prayer kindles from her friends, co workers, and an outpouring of the shocked community. Several months later, on May eighth, two thousand and eight, Carrie's friends celebrated what would have been her twenty fifth birthday. They raised a glass in Carrie's honor at her favorite restaurant, Signor Taco. One friend told the Knoxville News Sentinel every day was a better day because she was there, and for years, multiple organizations, including the University of Tennessee and Barley's Taproom in Pizzeria, would continue to hold events in Carrie's name. I'm going to pause now for a word from today's sponsors. If you want to hear where'd you get that? This holiday season? Uncommon Goods is your secret weapon. Uncommon Goods is here to make your holiday shopping stress free by scouring the globe for truly unique gifts for everyone on your list. I found a Murder Mystery jigsaw puzzle for my secret Santa gift. The box is in the shape of a book to put on your shelves. It is so cool, I bought two so that I could have one for myself. When you shop at Uncommon Goods, you're supporting artists and small independent businesses. These fine products are often made in
24:32 small batches, so shop now before they sell out this holiday season. From art and jewelry to kitchen, home and bar, Uncommon Goods has something for everyone, and with every purchase you make at Uncommon Goods, they give back one dollar to a nonprofit partner of your choice. They've donated more than two and a half million dollars to date. To get fifteen percent off your next gift, go to uncommon Goods dot com slash Southern Fried. That's Uncommon Goods dot com slash Southern Fried for fifteen percent off. Don't miss out on this limited time offer uncommon Goods. We're all out of ordinary. Unexpected expenses like car trouble can really throw off your budget. Worrying about it doesn't help. Earn In does. Earn In is the app that provides up to one hundred dollars a day of your paycheck within minutes of earning it. No mandatory fees, no credit check, and no debt traps. Watch your earnings tick up as you work and access up to seven hundred and fifty dollars per pay period.
25:27 It's easy and free to get started. Add your bank and employment info and they'll verify your paycheck. Like many people, I've been forced into payday loans in emergencies, and it's a vicious cycle. Looking back, I would have killed to have an app like earn In. Make earn in a part of your financial routine and join earn In's over three and a half million customers who rely on the peace of mind earn In gives them. Download earn in today spelled ea r n i in in the Google Play or Apple App Store. When you download the earn in app, type in Southern fry Under podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show Southern fried Under podcast subject to your available earnings daily max and pay period max. See urnin dot com slash cos for details. Arnin is a financial technology company, not a bank.
26:14 Bank. Products are issued by Evolved Bank and Trust Member FDIC. Although Micah was indicted for Carrie's murder in early May of two thousand and eight, his trial didn't take place for three more years, and that's in part because Micah was pleading not guilty by reason of insanity. His defense team was going to argue that Micah was so mentally disturbed when he viciously attacked Carrie that he didn't know what he was doing. They would argue that Micah was legally insane at the time he bludgeoned, stabbed, and strangled her, even though he was stopping and taking time to get each new weapon. The defense team would argue that he couldn't have stopped what he was doing even if he had wanted to. Since both the prosecution and defense needed to boroughly understand Micah's mental state to make their arguments, there are a lot of delays. He spent at least a month in the Middle Tennessee Mental Health Institute in a maximum security ward undergoing evaluations just for the prosecution, and there were more evaluations both before and after that. Plus when you add in all the regular court backlog, the time just added up. While all these delays were happening, Micah remained in police custody, be it in jail or a mental institution. While incarcerated, Micah wrote letters to people, including his then ex girlfriend Amanda, and he made over one hundred phone calls. Some of these letters and phone calls contained incriminating information that the prosecution wanted to use in court, which isn't uncommon,
27:48 but this time it was a big issue. Basically, when a person is incarcerated, their letters and phone calls are usually not private unless they are consulting with their lawyers. So the prosecution was reading all of Micah's letters and transcribing his phone calls, but they purposely didn't turn over the letters or phone calls to Micah's defense counsel. That's a violation of the Brady Rule, which requires that the prosecution disclose evidence that could be favorable to the defendant. And who's to say that some of the things Micah was writing in these letters or saying in these phone calls couldn't be favorable to him, and Micah did express remorse and at least one letter. Legally, the defense should have been given this information. In one letter to Amanda, Micah begged please acknowledge my life as still worth something. But the prosecution knew if they turned over this promising evidence to the defense, then Micah would stop writing letters and making phone calls because his lawyers would literally tell him to stop and then the prosecution's steady stream of incriminating evidence would dry up. But as an aside, why defendants aren't warned about them monitoring of their calls and letters by their defense council is always a mystery to me. The assistant District Attorney, Takeisha Fitzgerald, later received a censure from the High Courts for withholding this evidence, but a censure is more of a slap on the wrist than anything else. On November seventh, twenty eleven, Micah's trial finally began, and they had a tough time finding jurors
29:23 for the trial. Since his defense was relying entirely on his alleged insanity. It was hard for some people to handle that if Micah was deemed insane, he might not receive a prison sentence even though he had brutally killed someone. One potential juror said, I don't believe in psychiatrists. I believe if you do the crime, you need to do the time. This juror was rejected, but others with more middle of the road opinions on mental health were accepted. It is difficult to find a totally impartial jury in these cases, and probably particularly harder because Carrie's murder had ex stintsive press coverage, the defense counsel's motion for a change of venue had been denied. Finally, opening arguments began.
30:08 According to the prosecution, Micah was mentally ill, but not legally insane at the time of Carrie's murder. To prove this, they brought to the stand witnesses who could testify to how normal Micah seemed right before he killed Carrie. Micah's Coca Cola warehouse supervisor said he seemed fine at work that day, Amanda testified that he acted perfectly fine hours before she Carrie and Micah had hung out that day, and Micah's own parents testified that he was known to abuse alcohol and drugs regularly, especially marijuana. The state was trying to show jurors that Micah wasn't out of his own control. From the state's perspective, Micah was a dangerous person. He just also happened to have a mental health problem, one that sometimes caused him to have paranoid delusions and hallucinations, and that had both sides agreed, caused Micah to be legally insane when he attacked his classmate George out of the Blue in September of two thousand and seven, but not when he murdered Carrie Doherty. One of the prosecution's most compelling witnesses was forensic psychiatrist doctor ROKEA. Ferouke. She argued that if Michah was truly insane when he attacked Carrie, then why did he park a block away from carrying Amanda's house? Why did he shower after the murder? Why did he flee the state? Why did he allegedly write I'm dead and gravel on Amanda's car?
31:34 The answer because Micah knew that killing carry was wrong, which means he wasn't legally insane. Throughout the state's case, Micah's defense did not pose a single question to any of the prosecution's witnesses. They waited patiently until it was their turn to present MICA's side of the story, and then chaos ensued. The defense brought to the stand their own forensic psychiatrist, doctor Keith Carusoe. He testified that Micah suffered from schizo effective disorder bipolar type. Doctor Carusoe believed that Micah had killed Carrie during a period of paranoid psychosis, meaning he was legally insane when he murdered her. In sessions with doctor Carusoe and other professionals, Micah told two main versions of what had happened on the night he killed Carrie. One version of events was that Mica believed that the person driving up to carry in Amanda's house was Amanda's ex boyfriend. Micah allegedly had reason to believe that this ex boyfriend had once raved Amanda. Micah was insane, so he couldn't recognize Carrie. He truly thought she was this different, dangerous man who had come to hurt his girlfriend. The second version of events is this Mica didn't know who Carrie was at all. He only recognized her as quote a scary dark figure or shape that was coming toward him for the purpose of killing him. Doctor Carusoe testified that, in his opinion, Micah should be
33:04 hospitalized in a forensic psychiatric hospital indefinitely and would need lifelong medication given by monthly injections. He also said, quote, this is a guy who was not real forthcoming about how mentally ill he is. He's going to need to be monitored very very closely. I think those are the things that you know are the best options. If he winds up in prison, He's going to need the same kind of treatment, the access to it is not going to be as good. I kind of worry about medication non compliance because I've already seen a case where a corrections officer was murdered by an inmate with psychiatric illness that was not on medication. But after cross examination by the state, some of doctor Carusoe's notes were entered into evidence. As I said, Michaeh talked to Crusoe and Ferruk and other psychiatrists many times over the months and years leading up to trial. His stories changed all the time, but doctor Crusoe was his expert witness and ultimately provided a formal report for Micah's defense, and this final report did not include one version of his confession that Micah had actually told Carusoe first. Upon cross examination, doctor Carusoe admitted he left out the first confession because he believed Micah was lying. So the prosecution subpoened his original notes from interviews with Micah rather than just rely on the formal report, And in these notes, the third version of events came to light, one that the prosecution
34:38 had never heard before, and this version supported that Michah wasn't insane. It actually made it seem like Micah had a pretty clear rationale for everything. In May of two thousand and nine, Micah told doctor Carusoe that he had had a sexual fantasy about Carrie about a day before the murder, and as a result of this fantasy, he went to her in Amanda's house in the early morning hours of March nineteenth. He waited for Carrie to come home from work. When she arrived, Micah demanded some money that she supposedly owed him. He allegedly gave her some money to buy marijuana, but she never did, and when she refused to pay, Micah asked her for sex in exchange for the money. He said. At this Carrie angrily slapped him. When Carrie's hand hid his face, he claimed that he blacked out and attacked her.
35:30 Remember, even though this was the third version of events the court was hearing, it was actually the very first version that Micah told doctor Crusoe. To some that makes it seem like Michah was probably telling the truth, but to doctor Crusoe it was evidence that Micah was fabricating this version. He recanted this story and repeatedly told the two other narratives to Crusoe. Doctor Carusoe determined that Micah made up the hole I wanted to have sex with Carrie and she rejected me story because he was worried. Micah thought that if he told the truth that he was insane, his chances for a lighter prison sentence were slim. Micah said he knew from talking to his fellow jail inmates that Tennessee jurors are not statistically likely to accept I was insane as a valid excuse for someone committing murder, and that is true. Out of a hypothetical one thousand criminal cases in Tennessee, only ten of them would ever use insanity as a defense, and of those ten, no more than three would win their case. But it wasn't just his fellow inmates. The prosecution also brought up that Micah had visited the law library in jail nineteen times. Doctor Cruzo testified that Micah was trying to present himself as quote less crazy so he wouldn't be locked away forever.
36:52 Micah also admitted that he just didn't want to be labeled as crazy or a monster. His Upella attorney later argued that this is really common with patients suffering with schizophrenia, even if it's in their own best interest to admit their actual delusions and hallucinations, they cannot bear the labels that go with the insanity defense. But what gets me is that Micah could have made up anything, any reason at all, for why he murdered Carrie, That she attacked him, that she was threatening him. Did Mica tell doctor Carusoe this version of events because it was the truth and then realized his mistake after the prosecution was just as baffled as I am. It's a version of events from the defense that shows Micah was fully aware of his actions. His defense attorney Mark Stevens claimed he had never heard this version of events before, that it was only in doctor Carusoe's notes and the earliest draft of the report, which Stephens claimed he had never seen, and doctor Carusoe claimed that he thought everyone already knew about it because it was in his notes, But Stephen said he only relied on the final report that doctor Crusoe submitted, saying he didn't have time to go through all the materials and believed the final report would be fully complete.
38:12 Likewise, doctor Carusoe also claimed he didn't have time to create a full final report, and the one submitted was only supposed to be the latest draft. Did the dog also eat their homework? The negligence of these two professionals is astounding, no matter how you feel about Micah's claim of insanity. They fully had to stop court for one day and send duerrs home to get this mess sorted out. The next day, doctor Crusoe took the stand again, and in the words of MICA's own lawyer, he was eviscerated during cross examination. It was, to put it, lightly, a shit show. And I haven't even told you about how Crusoe was called out for committing an academic misdeed during medical school. He had falsified some data for a research project, but the incident happened over twenty years ago and the research was never published for the record. Up until this incident came out in Micah's trial, doctor Crusoe was a respected forensic psychiatrist who was not only an approved expert witness for this court district, but had testified a few other times for Micah's attorneys in other cases.
39:20 Still, this revelation about falsifying data was extremely damaging to his credibility. The defense rested its case shortly after this debacle, and in late November of twenty eleven, the jury deliberated for six hours before rejecting twenty four year old Micah Johnson's insanity defense for the brutal murder of Carrie Doherty. The jury convicted Micah of one count of premeditated murder, two counts of felony murder, two counts of especially aggravated kidnapping, and one count of especially aggravated robbery. The three murder convictions were merged into a single count, and the two especially aggravated kidnapping convictions were likewise merged. The trial court sentenced Micah Johnson to life for the murder convictions and to twenty five years each for the kidnapping and robbery convictions, which resulted in an effective sentence of life plus fifty years. The court later held additional hearings to further sentence Micah for his smaller crimes like evading the police. During sentencing, Micah spoke out and asked Carrie's friends and family to forgive him. They shouted no in the court room. During her impact statement, Carrie's mother, Carol said, we have been sentenced to a lifetime of heartache because of that horrible monster. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. Following his trial, Micah appealed his conviction and won. Honestly,
40:53 this is a rare occasion that I'm not surprised someone won an appeal. As with all appeals, Micah's defense had provided the court a huge list of all the things his new lawyers believed went wrong in his trial, but only once stuck and that was in effective counsel. Micah's lawyer relied heavily on doctor Crusoe's expert testimony, and as you know, doctor Crusoe's testimony may very well have been the nail in Micah's proverbial coffin the state argued that lead counsel Mark Stevens did know of earlier reports on his client and therefore knew the original narrative that Micah confessed to. Whether Stevens forgot about it or intentionally hid it, he was neglectful because he quote did nothing in advance of trial to mitigate the damage. He also did nothing to mitigate the damage to doctor Crusoe's credibility, since the doctor omitted the first narrative in later drafts. And the final report.
41:53 I've read a lot of appeals over the years, but I don't think I've ever seen the trial lawyers fall on their sword so much and so hard. One part that was especially interesting was that the team failed to object when doctor Ferruk, the expert psychiatrist for the state, testified before the jury that if Micah was found not guilty by reason of insanity, there was a chance he would be released back into the community, and she said, in her opinion, Micah was not commitable to a mental health facility. This was not doctor Feruke's direct testimony, but came out on cross examination by Stevens's co council. Stevens told the appellate court that he knew what doctor Feruke said was true and didn't think it was an objectionable issue. He also pointed out that he didn't want to object during his own co council's cross examination, which makes sense, but still think about this from a juror's perspective. You hear that the man who viciously murdered a young woman will just be released into the community.
42:53 If you vote not guilty by reason of insanity, how would you vote? But this argument failed on appeal because the trial judge instructed the jury during the sentencing phase quote, a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity shall result in the automatic detention of the defendant in a mental hospital or treatment center, pending further medical and legal findings. So basically, even though doctor Feruke's inappropriate statement was not objected to or struck from the record, the judge told the jury anyway, just in a more formal statement than doctor Fruke saying he could be immediately released into the community, but she did clarify that he would be held for evaluation by two mental health professionals who would decide whether or not he was committable. First, these are doctor Fruke's exact words. What happens when the court declares anybody not guilty by reason of insanity, the person doesn't have any more charges, so the person is ready to go to the community, go back to the community, have to be released to the community. So at that point the court should write a called two mental health professionals to do that determine the committability and if they determined that the patient is committable, then the patient gets into the hospital. If they determined that the patient is not committable, then the patient gets released into the community. End quote. She did say the word community four times. Whether that was strategic or not as a matter of opinion, but I would imagine that it would stick in a
44:24 juror's mind. But it is true that by law he could be held from thirty to ninety days for evaluation and then be released if he was found not committable. That was a bitter pill to swallow for people who have heard and seen what Micah had done to carry Doherty. There had been the usual objection to crime scene and autopsy photos being too graphic, but the jury saw almost everything, including a video made at the crime scene. But as a result of the mistakes made by his defense counsel. In June of twenty twenty two, thirty five year old mid Mika Johnson was released from prison on a one million dollar bond. So far, he had spent about eleven years in prison.
45:07 In late April of two thousand and three, thirty six year old Micah was retried for the murder of Carrie Doherty. The prosecutor was once again assistant da Takeisha Fitzgerald, even though she had been censured in his first trial for withholding evidence. Micah's new defense counsel was Gregory Isaac's. This trial took about two weeks and was far less explosive than his first trial, and on May sixth, twenty twenty three, two days before what would have been Carried Doherty's fortieth birthday, the jury deliberated for a few hours before convicting Micah a first degree premeditated and intentional murder, first degree felony murder, especially aggravated kidnapping, and especially aggravated robbery. He was re sentenced to life in prison. Currently, Micah Johnson is incarcerated in the medium security Hartiman County Career Action Facility.
46:02 This was an extremely difficult case to research and write about. I always try to be very careful when discussing mental illness and explaining the fine line of legal insanity, and I also try to be sensitive about the graphic nature of a murder, but I felt that the details were so important to try and understand whether or not Micah Johnson was legally insane. There's no question that he was suffering from psychosis and other types of serious psychiatric diagnoses. It made sense regarding his attack on his classmate George, who was grievously injured from Micah punching him. Maybe if he had snapped and attacked Carry in the same way, his case would be more believable. He was off his medication, after all, but he lay in wait for Carrie. He already had a weapon in hand, and then stopped twice to get a shovel and rope. He snatched her cell phone immediately so she couldn't call for help. And remember, he did the yard work for Amanda. He didn't just grab the closest object to hit Carry. He retrieved these items from the backyard and carport where he knew he would find them. The attack was very prolonged and particularly cruel, which are elements of first degree in premeditated murder charges, and it would seem he was also trying to hide Carrie's body in her car to give him time to get away from the scene. And then, of course, he did flee to
47:32 his father's house, where he cleaned up before withdrawing five hundred dollars and going on the run to Georgia. The culmination of these facts are just too much for most people to believe that Micah snapped during a paranoid psychotic episode. Would this horrific murder have happened if Micah had stayed on his medication. That's impossible for me to say. He may have had delusions about Carrie earlier, but again, this murder was just too planned for me to believe he did not know the wrongfulness of his actions at the time. I would have voted guilty to I cannot fathom the devastation that Carrie's family went through. An entire community grieved for this beloved young woman. She was cruelly ripped from the lives of so many people, and the viciousness of her murder is the stuff of nightmares.
48:27 My heart aches for Carrie's family and friends. We can only hope and pray that they believe justice was served and that the passing years have given them some measure of peace. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Erica Kelly and Andrea Marshbank. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio, and the original graphic art is by Kuley Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon Schack Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener's suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me. Please remember that I don't accept suggestions on social media private messaging, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Freed True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes.
49:24 We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern Friued, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shit ass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review. I'm on all large platforms like iTunes, iHeart, Spotify, Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed