198: Karla Faye Tucker
On June 12th of 1983, 27-year-old Jerry Lynn Dean and 32-year-old Deborah Ruth Thornton met at a pool party. Right away, their chemistry was apparent—even though their budding relationship was doomed from the start. Jerry had recently separated from...
On June 12th of 1983, 27-year-old Jerry Lynn Dean and 32-year-old Deborah Ruth Thornton met at a pool party. Right away, their chemistry was apparent—even though their budding relationship was doomed from the start. Jerry had recently separated from his wife, and Deborah was still married. Regardless, Jerry and Deborah decided to have a harmless one-night stand. But that night would turn out to be anything but harmless. By morning, both Jerry and Deborah were brutally killed. The murder weapon? A pickaxe and a hammer. And the murderers? Jerry’s estranged wife’s friends: 23-year-old Karla Faye Tucker and 37-year-old Danny Ryan Garrett. Sixteen years later, in 1998, Karla Faye Tucker would be the first woman executed in Texas in 135 years.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Recommended by Eileen and others
Sources: https://southernfriedtruecrime.com/karla-faye-tucker
This episode is sponsored by EarnIn: They say time waits for no one, and neither should payday--See EarnIn.com/TOS for more details.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:05 Southern Fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. When I was young, I remember a lot of talk about Carla fey Tucker. But even though I knew her name, I only knew it in the sense that she was controversial. Like Linda Kasabian of the Manson family, she had only acted as a lookout at the Tait and LaBianca murders, and afterwards she turned state's evidence for immunity, but there were plenty of people who disagreed with her deal. It was very controversial. She was an accomplice after all. So I had assumed that Carla fey Tucker had been some kind of accomplice, and that's why people were so divided about her case. Well, I wasn't only wrong about Carla's participation in a vicious double homicide. I was wrong about why people felt her sentence was controversial. Like many convicted murderers, she converted to Christianity while in prison, which shouldn't be surprising much less controversial. But Carla was an attractive woman and many people felt she was sincere in her conversion.
1:18 So she became a sort of folk hero for the anti death penalty movement, whether she deserved it or not. Welcome to episode one ninety eight, Carla fey Tucker. Deborah Ruth Carlson was born in May of nineteen fifty one in Columbus, Ohio, to parents Bill and Harriet List. After her parents divorced, Deborah wasn't very close to her biological father, especially not after her mother remarried. Deborah's stepfather was US Air Force staff Sergeant Homer D. Carlson, and he became the prominent father figure in Deborah's life. She went by Deborah Carlson after he married her mom little May twelfth of nineteen eighty one, thirty year old Deborah Carlson married thirty one year old Richard Thornton of New York.
2:07 It was two days after her birthday. By nineteen eighty three, the married couple lived in the Houston area. They made their way to Houston for a few reasons. First, Deborah's biological father, Bill List, owned a trailer manufacturing company down there, and he hired Deborah. Plus Deborah's brother, Ron, was also in the Houston area. At some point, she left that job and According to Mark Beaver's book The Ballad of Carla fey Tucker, she became a bookkeeper at a mortgage company and she and Richard had two children together. But things were not all peaches and cream for Deborah and Richard. They were having some trouble and on Sunday, June twelfth, nineteen eighty three, Deborah and Richard had a really big fight. Afterwards, she went to a pool party. At the party was a twenty seven year old guy named Jerry lyn Dean. He hit on Deborah and she was flattered. Jerry was a cute relic of the seventies. He had a mustache and long brown hair.
3:07 At five seven and one hundred and fifty pounds, he was a small but fit guy, and he had a lot of personality. And I'm sure he told Deborah all about the Harley Davidson he was working on. So when Jerry propositioned Deborah, she said yes. She arranged for someone to take care of her two children. She made sure she had clothes for work on Monday, and she went with Jerry to his apartment. And as far as my research indicates, Deborah didn't know Jerry well, if at all, before this evening. It was, for all intents and purposes, a one night stand for Deborah. Between two thirty am and four thirty am on Monday, June thirteenth, Deborah awoke she heard some strange noises in Jerry's apartment. Someone was there two someone's actually a man and a woman. Deborah kept her head hucked under the covers. She and Jerry were on a mattress on the floor of his guest room, and Jerry yelled out what's going on. Suddenly, debraa could tell another person was on the bed where she and Jerry lay. She could feel their weight on the mattress. A woman said, don't move, motherfucker, or you're dead. Debora stayed very still, the sheets and blankets still covering her head. It didn't appear like anyone had noticed her presence, not yet anyway. Outside of the covers, there was a mad scramble.
4:32 The two strangers were beating up Jerry, and Jerry was not faring well. After a while, Jerry began making gurgling noises. Then there was a loud thud, and then Jerry didn't make any noise at all. One of the two intruders left the bedroom, but the second intruder. The woman stayed and that's when Deborah started to panic. When a hard object pierced her shoulder. She knew she'd been spotted and there was no way they were going to let Deborah leave this room alive. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Carla Faytucker was born on November eighteenth, nineteen fifty nine, to her parents, Carolyn and Larry in Houston, Texas. Carla was the youngest of three sisters, Kathy and Carrie, and her childhood, as told by Carla herself, was incredibly difficult. She always considered herself very close to her mother, but, as she explained in an interview with Larry King, her mother, Carolyn, had a horrible drug problem, and she followed in her mother's footsteps at a very young age. Carla began smoking cigarettes and pot at the age of eight. When she was ten years old, her parents were going through a divorce. During the divorce proceedings, Carla learned that she was born after her mother, Carolyne, had had an an extramarital affair. Carla was not her father's biological daughter. That's the year ten year old Carla began
6:06 using heroin intravenously. She became addicted to heroin and other drugs almost immediately. By the age of thirteen, Carla dropped out of school. She filled the seventh grade and never went back. Instead, she became a groupie for rock bands like the Alman Brothers and The Eagles, and by the age of fourteen, Carla had begun engaging in sex work to help pay for her ongoing drug addiction. Around that same time, Carla became violent, usually beating up other kids her age, once giving another teen two black eyes. By the time she was fifteen, she was fighting adults too. She would even take on two at once. At age sixteen, Carla married a man named Stephen Griffith.
6:53 He was a mechanic, and the two were together for about five years. During that time, Stephen said that Carla always said that someday was she would be famous, but it was never clear how Carla thought she would accomplish fame. Carla and Steven fought like cats and dogs. They divorced by the time she was twenty one. By then, Carla was deeply into the Houston motorcycle scene. All of Carla's friends were bikers, including the new man she was seeing. His name was Danny Garrett and he was thirty five years old. Her best friend Shaan and Shawn's husband, Jerry Lynn Dean had introduced the new couple. Daniel Ryan Garrett was born April twenty fifth, nineteen forty six, to Hazel and Sandford Garrett. He was the second oldest of four kids, all boys, except one younger sister. We don't know much about Daniel's younger years, except that he went by Danny and was a boy scout at around age eleven. Around nineteen sixty four, eighteen year old Danny graduated from Angleton High School in Ingleton, Texas. Three years later, twenty one year old Danny married eighteen year old Cecilia Moody in Freeport, Texas, and then Danny began attending the Naval Pharmacy School in San Diego. Between nineteen sixty seven and nineteen seventy five, Danny joined the Army. As part of his service, he was deployed to Vietnam, and his experience in Vietnam during the height of the Vietnam War was terrible. After he returned to the States, Danny
8:26 suffered from debilitating PTSD. His friends reported that Danny had flashbacks and became violent. One man said that Danny had even beaten the side of his home with a tire iron. Danny also often wore a necklace with a tiger's tooth as the pendant. He would tell people that he'd killed the tiger himself. While in Vietnam. In nineteen seventy five, Danny was arrested for possessing drugs in his home. He pled guilty and was sentenced to ten years probation, though that was reduced over time. Between the turmoil of Danny's PTSD and drug usage, his first marriage did not work out. Then, on December twenty fourth, nineteen seventy five, twenty nine year old Danny Garrett married again, but that marriage fell too, and by nineteen eighty three he was dating twenty three year old Carla fey Tucker. At the time, Danny was a bartender at a swingers club in Houston, Texas, and according to his friends, Danny didn't seem okay. Starting in that February, Danny had been really down in the dumps. His coworkers noticed that he was much angrier and more irritable than usual. People commented that he was always moody and argumentative. One person told the Associated Press he did not seem like himself. Danny had always been easy to get along with, and then suddenly he wasn't. We're not sure why Danny was having such a challenging time in February, but by June of that same year, he hadn't gotten any better, and his new girlfriend, Carla wasn't helping. She kept ranting on and on about her ongoing feud with the
10:00 their friend, Shawn's now estranged husband, Jerry Dean. Jerry Lynn Dean was born in May of nineteen fifty six to Emily and Alvin Dean and Smith, Texas, and in nineteen seventy four, eighteen year old Jerry joined the US Coast Guard. In February nineteen eighty three, twenty six year old Jerry Dean married a twenty something woman named Sean, who also happened to be Carla's best friend. As I mentioned before, Shawn and Jerry had actually introduced Carla to her current boyfriend, Danny. Have we got that straight? Carla and Sean were BFFs, Shawn was married to Jerry, and Carla and Danny were boyfriend and girlfriend. Anyway, After Jerry and Shawn's February nuptials, their honeymoon period was very short lived. Only a few months into their marriage, the couple had decided to call it quits, and even though Jerry and Shawn were legally married on paper, they didn't consider themselves husband and wife any longer. And that was quite all right with Seann's best friend Carla, because Carla despised Jerry.
11:03 Apparently, Jerry had destroyed a photo album of Carla's and in that album were the last remaining pictures of Carla and her mother, who had died some years earlier. After learning what Jerry had done, Carla attacked him. In doing so, she broke Jerry's glasses and Jerry had to go to the hospital to have glass removed from his eyes. But that wasn't enough for Carla. She was still furious with Jerry for callously destroying the last memory she had with her mother. In early June of nineteen eighty three, twenty three year old Carla and her boyfriend, thirty seven year old Danny were on a bender for three sleepless days. They had been drinking heavily and taking drugs every two to three hours. They smoked pot and popped all kinds of pills, some you've probably heard of, like valium and Soma, and then several I had to look up that are in the opioid family. Then to top it off, they were injecting methamphetamy. Basically, they were mixing uppers and downers. Later, Carla would say she felt wired, but this feeling wasn't new to Carla.
12:09 She had been doing drugs since she was eight years old, and she estimated that she had not been cleaned for more than a few days since then. In Carla's adult years, she was high most of the time. In fact, for the entire month of June, Carla had been injecting speed into her body NonStop. So on June twelfth, Carla and Danny were high, and not like buzz, they were really really high, and they weren't alone. Carla, her boyfriend Danny, and her sister Carrie all lived in this house, so they were all there, along with Carrie's ex husband, Ronnie, and another friend of Carla's named Jimmy Lebrant. When the sun went down, Carrie and Ronnie left the house and they didn't come back until the next day. But Carla, Danny and Jimmy were still going strong and they were discussing a topic that Carla loved to talk about, her hatred for Jerry Dean.
13:03 Together, the trio molled over Jerry's many flaws, and, as Carla often did, she said she wanted to off Jerry and take his motorcycle. He was fixing up a Harley Davidson in his apartment, and Carla didn't feel that Jerry deserved that luxury. Eventually, Carla, Danny, and Jimmy decided they were going to Jerry's apartment to intimidate him. They wanted to take money that Jerry supposedly owed them, and they were going to steal his beloved Harley Davidson. In preparation, Danny grabbed the shotgun. He would later claim he had no intention of killing Jerry with the gun. He just thought Jerry might be more cooperative if he saw Danny had it. At trial, there was testimony that indicated that Danny also brought rubber gloves to Jerry's apartment, which would really discredit Danny's hull I never meant to kill him claim, but it's unclear if Danny even wore the gloves. Later, Carla would, explaining that she didn't mean for this next part to happen, that she only wanted to confront Jerry toe to toe. Regardless, the group of three gotten to Danny's ranchero.
14:09 They drove to Jerry's apartment sometime between two thirty am and four thirty am on Monday, June thirteenth. When they arrived, Jimmy decided to stay in the car, Carla and Danny walked right through Jerry's front door. She had unlocked the door with the key she had stolen from Sean. Next, Carla and Danny entered Jerry's guest room, where he and Deborah Thornton were sleeping. Okay, so from here on out, the details of the crime get a little hazy, And when you think about that, it makes sense. The only people who left this room alive weren't exactly motivated to tell the truth, and who knows how much they really remembered with that amount of drugs in their system. But here's probably what happened, according to court testimony from Carla's sister Carrie, Carla's own testimony, local newspaper coverage, and Mark Beaver's book, The Ballad of Carla Fey Tucker. Carla jumped on Jerry's prone form. She pinned him down to the bed, saying, don't move, motherfucker, or you're dead. But of course Jerry did move. It's instinct. Jerry went to grab Carla's hands, and with that moment, Danny pushed Carla out of the way and began beating Jerry with a hammer. It's unclear where Danny got this hammer. Did he bring it along from home along with a shotgun, or, as is probably more likely, did he pick it up off the floor of Jerry's messy apartment. Jerry worked in manual labor and had for a long time. He had accumulated boxes and boxes of tools that were strown about his apartment's guest room. I'm sure there was a hammer in there somewhere,
15:43 and I know for certain there was a pickaxe leaning against a door. After Danny was done beating Jerry with the hammer, he left the room. He was getting started on stealing Jerry's stuff, and Jerry, who wasn't dead yet, was lying face down on the mattress, and his breathing sounded like gurgling. This gurgling sound supposedly bothered Carla during her trial she would explain that sound. All I wanted to do was stop him from making that noise. So she grabbed the four foot long pickaxe that was sitting against Jerry's door, and she hit him in the back with it four or five times, and still Jerry was alive, still gurgling. At this point, Jimmy, who had been napping in the car, came into Jerry's apartment. He intended to help rob the place, but then Jimmy took in the scene before him. Danny collecting the parts from Jerry's half completed Harley Davidson and loading them into the car, Carla smiling while actively hitting a sheet covered Jerry, whose breathing sounded to him like a broken aquarium pump, and a woman no one seemed to have noticed, hiding under Jerry's bed covers, and at the sight of all this, Jimmy ran. When Danny realized that Carlo was having a hard time finishing Jerry off, he came back to help. He rolled Jerry onto his back and grabbed the pickaxe from Carla and dealt Jerry one final blow to his chest.
17:07 Then Danny left the room to continue hauling things to his vehicle. Carla was alone with Jerry's corpse and thirty two year old Deborah Thornton. When Deborah shifted under the bed sheets, Carla realized she was there, so Carla brought the pickaxe down on Debora's shoulder hard, and then Deborah began to fight for her life. During the fight, Danny reappeared and wrangled the pickaxe away from both women. Then he began beating Deborah with the pickaxe. Soon Deborah begged for death. Carla claimed Debora's last words were, oh God, it hurts. If you're going to kill me, please do it now. At that, Danny kicked Deburah in the chin so hard that she landed on her back, and then Danny slammed the pick axe into her chest. He left the axe there, buried seven inches into Deborah's heart, and then they left.
18:02 On the morning of Monday, June thirteenth, a guy named Gregory Trevor was waiting for his friend and coworker, Jerry Dean to pick him up. They were going to their jobs at the cable company together. When Jerry didn't show up at his usual time, Greg walked to Jerry's apartment. It was just a short distance away. Greg knocked on the door. When he saw that the door was slightly ajar, he became suspicious. He called out his friend's name at the front of the apartment, but there was no response, so Greg pushed open the door and walked in. Upon reaching Jerry's spare bedroom, he saw Jerry lying on the floor with blood on his head, and a woman lay beside him on a mattress. She had a pickaxe sticking out of her chest. Greg immediately called the police. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsor. In those moments when money isn't moving as fast his life, earn in provides the financial momentum you need to keep moving forward. Earn In is an app that gives you access to your pay as you work, up to one hundred dollars per day or up to seven hundred and fifty dollars per pay period. I really could have used earn in when I was younger and constantly struggling. Earn In is at the speed of you get up to one hundred dollars a day of your pay within minutes of earning it, no mandatory fees and no credit check. Download earn in today spelled ea r n i in in the Google Play or Apple App Store. When
19:37 you download the earn In app, type in Southern Fried Under podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show Southern Fried Under podcast subject to your available earnings daily max and pay period max. See earnin dot com slash ts for details. Earn In is a financial technology company, not a bank. Bank products are issued by Evolved Bank and Trust member. See Jerry Lynden's funeral services were held on Friday, June seventeenth, nineteen eighty three, at the Memorial Funeral Home Chapel. He was buried in the cemetery at Tyler Memorial Park in Tyler, Texas. His brother Bobby is buried in the same cemetery.
20:22 Deborah Ruth Thornton was buried in the Mifflin Cemetery in Gehanna, Ohio. She was buried next to her mother, Harriet, who had passed away years before in nineteen sixty three when she was only thirty one. While the victim's families were mourning their loved ones losses, Carla and Danny were celebrating their murderous victory on Monday, June thirteenth, the same day that they had killed Jerry and Deborah. Carla told her sister Carry how it all went down. She described the scene with gleeful detail, from the hammer to the pickaxe to the robbery. In total, Carla, Danny, and by proxy, Jimmy had stolen Jerry's motorcycle, some of his motorcycle parts, his wallet, his El Camino, and Deborah's wallet. Carla gave Debora's wallet to her sister Carry as a birthday present, but Carrie threw the wallet away in disgust. Carla also tried to give Danny's brother, Doug, Jerry's wallet, but Doug threw it away after burning the contents. On the same day as the murders, Jerry stolen El Camino was abandoned in a parking lot near the Astrodome, and Jerry's motorcycle and motorcycle parts were hidden in Danny's garage, eventually dug through the motorcycle parts in the Brazos River. When the Monday Evening News reported that Greg had discovered the bodies of Jerry Dean and Deborah Thornton, Carla and Danny laughed. They bragged that they were famous and proud to be known as the Pickaxe murderers.
21:49 Carla's sister, Carrey, recognized that her sister had become unhinged dangerous, and she moved out of their communal home. The next day. She went to live with Danny's brother, Doug, and then those two Carrie and Doug, would later marry. Back at the crime scene, the police were doing everything they could to identify the murderers, but they didn't have much to go on. They could tell several items had been stolen, and Jerry's TV and stereo were stacked next to his entertainment center as if someone had tried to steal them but accidentally left them behind, and the authorities could see there was no sign of forced entry. But that was about it, and for five weeks it really appeared that the case might have gone cold. But then thirty six year old Doug Garrett, Danny's brother, decided enough was enough, and on July nineteenth of nineteen eighty three, Doug called his longtime friend, who just so happened to be a homicide detective, Lieutenant J. C. Moser of the Houston Police Department. By this time, Doug and Kerry were officially dating, and the day after Doug called, they met with Lieutenant Moser to explain everything in person, what happened to Jerry Dean and Deborah Thornton Wyatt had happened, and most importantly, who was responsible. But Doug and Carrey's words weren't going to be enough. The Houston PD needed cold, hard evidence, so they strapped a microphone to Doug's chest and sent him off. They needed him to get Carla and Danny to admit to everything on tape, So a few days
23:23 later, Doug rode his motorcycle to Carl and Danny's house on McKain Street. I'm sure his heart was racing. To hide the wire properly. Doug had to wear a long sleeved shirt in Texas in July. When Carl and Danny questioned Doug about his shirt, he simply said he needed to do laundry. Then he spent the next ninety minutes prompting Carla and Danny to talk about the murders, and they were happy to. They had thought they'd gotten away with everything, and they were overjoyed to share the tale once more. You know how the murders went down, so there isn't much new information to reveal for you here. But Carla did say something on these recorded tapes that would go down in history, and that's that. As Carla swung the pickaxe into Jerry Dene's body, shoe orgasmed with each and every blow. When Doug asked if that was true, Carla responded, hell yes. During the conversation, Doug informed Carla and Danny that the authorities told him they were prime suspects. In response, Carla said, they're just digging. Doug also commented that it could have been done neither, to which Danny responded, that was the way it came down. It was a freak thing. At one point during this wired conversation, Carla left the room. During that time, Doug told his brother, you never would have done something like that on your own, and the two men cried. With this conversation in hand, the police had them over
24:53 the course of several days. In late July of eighty three, the police arrested Carla fey Tucker, Danny Garrett, and Jimmy Leebrant, as well as Carrie's ex husband, Ronnie Burrell. Ronnie had helped Jimmy flee the scene, but I don't think any charges stuck against him. Carla and Danny faced capital murder. They were held without bond. Jimmy faced burglary charges and was also held without bond. Days later, on July thirtieth, Carla wrote a letter to Danny. The two criminals weren't supposed to be communicating, so Carla sent the letter in secret. It began to my only man and true love.
25:33 In the letter, Carla wrote, I am ready to say anything just to get out of here and come break you out. I just want to see and hold you again. Please be strong and don't let them give you the death sentence, for we will be together again always in our minds and hearts. She goes on, even if I have to say you did it and get out of here and then get you out somewhere or another, I know there is a way. And then she sonned off by saying yours forever and always. Wow. What a sweet way of saying. I'm gonna lie and say that you did it all, but I promise I'll break you out of prison somehow. This letter would not be revealed to the public until Danny's trial, which wouldn't happen for a while. Danny's trial happened after Carla's. But I'm telling you about the letter now, because at the same time Carla was writing this letter and promising Danny that she'd say anything on his behalf. She also claimed to have become a born again Christian and hey, maybe she truly found Jesus. I don't know. The timing just seemed interesting. Years later, when Carla was on Larry King Live, she described how she found Jesus.
26:42 Apparently, there was a religious group that would come to the Harris County Jail every so often. They would perform a puppet show for the inmates. One night, everyone Carla knew in the jail was going to the puppet show. Not wanting to be alone, she joined them. Afterward, Carla grabbed Bible. They were giving them away for free, but she thought she had stolen it. And Carla said, that night I started reading the Bible. I didn't know what I was reading, and before I knew it, I was just in the middle of the floor on my knees and I was just asking God to forgive me. Now, jailhouse conversions are not the stuff of wonders. When people are forced into a cement room with literally nothing to do besides reflect on their wrongdoings. Well, yeah, religion is a comfort, a way to soothe one's self when those nights get long. But Carla fay Tucker's conversion story would become legendary. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Carla fay Tucker's trial took place in April of nineteen eighty four.
27:51 She was charged with the murder of Jerry Lyn Dean. The prosecution was seeking the death penalty, so they figured they would start with the murder of Jerry Dean and if for some reason it didn't stick, they could try Carla for Deborah Thornton's murder. But they didn't need to because this trial was the most open and shut court case you've ever seen. After all, the prosecution had a taped conversation in which Carla admitted to killing Jerry, and Carla's behavior in that conversation indicated she clearly was not remorseful at all. And if that somehow wasn't enough, the prosecution had convinced Jimmy Leebrint to flip, and so Jimmy, an eye witness to the murders, was testifying against Carla. Carla's trial was big news, highly attended and extensively reported, and there were some very dramatic moments, like when the medical examiner testified that Jerry had received over twenty wounds from the pickaxe, many of which occurred while he was still alive, and how Doug Garrett testified that Carla and his brother Danny were satanically possessed.
28:56 Doug said the devil had taken over their minds and bodies. I can't say whether they knew right from wrong. I can say I do believe the devil was in it. According to the Associated Press, the defense rested on Wednesday, April eighteenth, without presenting any testimony to the jury, and on Thursday, April nineteenth, after deliberating for seventy minutes, the jury found twenty four year old Carla Faytucker guilty for one count of capital murder. Carla's court appointed defense attorney, Mac Arnold, told the Longview News Journal that he brought no witnesses for quote many legal reasons it would take hours to discuss. Let me just say this, This case is not over yet, and he was right. There was still Carla's sentencing, or as they call it in Texas, the punishment phase. There was only one question left. Would Carla be sentenced to death by legal injection, or would she squeak by with life in prison. Mac Arnold was quoted by the United Press International as saying that he never planned to prove that Carla was innocent. He could only help her avoid the death penalty. He said, if I had argued innocence in the face of that evidence, I would have lost all credibility with the jury. They never would have believed me again. So this is where the river hit the road for Carla. Her defense counsel claimed that on the night of the murders, she was temporarily insane due to intoxication and drug use. The argument was that Carla was not in control of her actions because she was in a manic, frenzied state. The defense's expert witness for the temporary insanity claim was doctor
30:33 Barbara Falcons, and doctor Falcons also testified that she doubted the truth of Carla orgasming while she killed Jerry, after she conducted an hour's long interview with Carla the month before. She had learned that Carla said she never had a pleasant sexual experience in her life, so maybe Carla was mistaking what an orgasm was. And Carla testified for her own defense. She spoke for five hours, and I'm not sure if it helped were hurt her case. On the one hand, Carla did express regret for killing Jerry. She said, quote, sometimes I think that if someone were to come up to me and do the very same thing I did, or worse, it still would not be justice for me. I don't see how anyone could ever be forgiven for something like I've done. And according to Mark Beaver's The Ballad of Carla fey Tucker, she also said it was actually Danny who dealt Jerry and Deborah's killing blows.
31:29 But on the other hand, Carla admitted to planning more acts of violence. She spoke about how recently she and Danny were considering killing Jimmy Liebrant and Ronnie Burrell. They were worried the two men would snitch, and Carla even testified that she, Danny and his friends had plans to raid drug labs. They would kill the people who worked there and then steal the drugs. On Wednesday, April twenty fifth, nineteen eighty four, after deliberating for about three hours, the jury sentenced twenty four year old Carla fay Tucker to death at the News Carla bowed her head but was otherwise expressionless. Now, Carla was one of just sixteen women on death row in the United States, and she was the only woman on Texas's death row. For reference, during the year of Carla's trial, Texas had nearly one hundred and eighty men on death row, and two men had already been executed that year. But if Carla was successfully executed well, then she would be the first woman executed by the state of Texas since the Civil War. As with all death sentences in Texas, Carla's case was automatically appealed, but that appeal and all the following ones, would fail. Since Carla had already received the death penalty for Jerry's murder, a judge dismissed her second capital murder charge for Deborah's death. Six months later, in October of eighty four, thirty eight year old Daniel Ryan Garrett faced his own trial for the murder of thirty two year old Deborah Thornton, and again
33:00 this was a fairly straightforward trial. The prosecution still had the recorded confession, and this time they also had Carla's testimony. Carla took the stand for five days during Danny's trial. During that time, she said she was compelled to testify against Danny because quote people deserve to know the truth. This was directly opposed to the letters she had written to Danny about a year earlier, which were also presented in court, and honestly it must have stung for Danny. He had gallantly refused to testify at Carla's trial. During Carla's testimony, she affirmed the events during the night of the murderers. When Danny's defense attorney requested that she hold the murder weapon to demonstrate how she had swung it at Debora, Carla began crying. The attorney adjusted and asked Carla to tell him how she had held the weapon. Later in her testimony, Carla asserted that she loved Dane very much and cared for him quite a bit. She said she didn't want him to be convicted for these murders. In response to all this, Danny's defense team argued that he was merely another victim of Carla's, that Carla had manipulated him into doing these horrible acts. But the jury wasn't buying it, and on Tuesday, November twentieth, nineteen eighty four, after about four hours of deliberation, the jury found Daniel Ryan Garrett guilty of killing Deborah
34:30 Thornton. During his punishment phase, his older brother, forty year old Joe Garrett, testified on his behalf. Joe said, Dan was always a popular sort of person and had a lot of friends. I have never known Dan to be involved in any acts of violence other than this one he is alleged to have done. I can't imagine he did it. It is totally out of character Dan, as a child and through his adult life was a blonde headed, round faced, bubbly person who never upset anyone. But when pressed by the prosecution, Joe did admit that he hadn't seen his brother much in his adult years, and the prosecution asserted that Danny wasn't the kind of man his brothers and other witnesses brought by the defense made him out to be.
35:17 Danny was a drug addict who had murdered someone and had no qualms about doing it again. By the end of it all, the jury believed the prosecution, and Danny was sentenced to death. Nearly a decade later, on January fourteenth, nineteen ninety three, Danny was awarded a new trial on a technicality one of his jurors had been improperly dismissed by prosecutors. But before this new trial could happen, Danny died of natural causes. On June fourteenth, nineteen ninety three, Danny Garrett succumbed to deliver disease in Houston's Lyndon B. Johnson Hospital. In a shocking turn of events, on June sixteenth, nineteen ninety two, Jimmy Liebrant told the Houston Chronicle that he had lied on the stand during Carla's trial. During the trial, there was a whole argument about whether or not Jimmy had struck a deal with the prosecution in exchange for his testimony on the stand. Jimmy denied any deal, but as it turns out, he had made one. He was told that he would receive a single digit number of years in prison if he could help put Carlo away for good.
36:29 Had the jury known that, they might have considered Jimmy's testimony differently. After all, people are compelled to lie when their own neck is on the line. After Carla's trial, Jimmy was sentenced to twenty years in prison, a two digit number, but he only served three years. And four months, so perhaps his single digit deal was still in place. Enjoying his own freedom, Jimmy told the chronicle, I don't want to see that girl die. She was young enough and impressionable, and we were crazy people s she was running with. She's been locked down for long enough. God give her another chance. There's turned out not to have any real impact on Carla's case other than moving back her execution date from June of nineteen ninety two. They didn't want to execute her until they had reconsidered Jimmy's part in the trial, but ultimately the courts determined that even if Jimmy had not testified, the jury would have still convicted Carla. And they are one hundred percent right. I can't say it enough. They had her recorded remorseless confession. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. By March of nineteen eighty six, two years after her conviction and death sentence, Harla claimed that she had been fully reformed in her eyes, since she was off drugs and no longer immature.
37:58 As she put it, she was no longer a danger to society, and she said she was excited to continue her education from prison. So far she had already earned her ged. Over the next few years, she would complete thirty hours of college credit and teach herself sign language. When reporters asked Carla Hey, why sign language, she responded that she wanted to see her hands do good in the world. In an exclusive interview with the Houston Chronicle, Carla said, I think everything about was bad, the way I was living, the way I was thinking. She attributed much of her self reflection to her relatively newfound relationship with God. During that same interview, Carla expressed that she had hoped to donate her organs to those in need, but she was recently informed that the lethal injection medications would make her organs unusable. She said, quote, I had really hoped to be able to give my body to help others. That way, I could give life back for the life I took. And it seems that Carla's new religious nature might have been authentic.
39:07 Her jailers certainly seemed to think so. One said, everybody sees Jesus at the jailhouse, but this woman isn't just talking. She is genuine. She shouldn't die, and many others felt the same about Carla's faith. An organization called the Family Life Training Center met with Carla in October of nineteen eighty three. They were taken by her story and devoutness, so the Family Life Training Center urged their followers and readers to write to the Texas Governor. They wanted Carla's sentence to be commuted to life in prison. And this wouldn't be the last Christian organization who took a liking to Carla. The Life Way Covenant Fellowship of Hungerford also became passionate about Carla's sentence commutation, and they weren't even against the death penalty from an ideological standpoint. He just liked Carla. Honestly, it seemed like everyone who met Carla liked her. In nineteen ninety two, Beverly Lowry wrote a book entitled Crossed Over a Murder, a memoir that was based on Carla's story. After meetings several times, Beverly and Carla had become good friends. Even Ron Carlson, Deborah Thornton's brother, was swayed by Carla's transformation. The Corpus Christi Caller Times reported that Ron said, quote, what I saw when I spoke to her was something totally different from what I saw eight or nine years ago when the trial was going on. Meanwhile, Carla
40:38 also did a series of interviews discussing her Christianity and God's forgiveness, and in June of nineteen ninety five, thirty five year old Carla married a pastor named Dana Brown. She had met Dana through his prison ministry work. Marriages weren't allowed on prison grounds, so Carla and Dana were married by proxy and t two separate locations. After the ceremony, Dana traveled to the prison in a decorated car, but the newlyweds weren't allowed to speak on their wedding day. In fact, they never touched at all. According to the Associated Press, Carla said, since we didn't let the physical relationship get in the way, we have a totally spiritual relationship that's so deep a lot of people wouldn't understand.
41:25 Then, in nineteen ninety seven, Darley Routier joined the growing number of women on Texas's death Row. As a result, the media picked up coverage on Carla's case. Again. This was further spurred because by August of nineteen ninety seven, Carla had exhausted all of her appeals and because on Sunday, December seventh of nineteen ninety seven, Carla appeared on CBS's Sixty Minutes. She said, I'm so far removed from the person that I used to be out there for me, what's weird is thinking back on some of the things I used to do. As a result of this widely televised interview, Pat Robertson, whom you may know from his work on the seven hundred Club, also began advocating for Carla's sentence to be commuted, and then, according to the Austin American Statesman, there was quote an outpouring of support for Carla. More than six thousand letters and cards were sent to the Texas capital on her behalf.
42:23 Considering that there were nearly twenty million people living in Texas at the time and two hundred and seventy three million in the entire US, I'm not sure I would call six thousand letters an outpouring of support, but it did capture the public's attention. All of the mail requested that Carla's sentence be commuted to life in prison, but it fell on deaf ears because the law doesn't care if you're a beautiful, articulate woman who found God. If a jury finds you guilty and worthy of the death penalty, then that was that you were guilty and sentenced to death. And I don't mean to be crass, but there are a lot of men who are on death row who also find God.
43:06 There's something to be said here about Americans wanting to give grace to women where we wouldn't for men. Eventually, Carla's execution was scheduled for February third, nineteen ninety eight, and this caused even more of an uproar by the media and the public. Mick Jagger's ex wife, Bianca Jagger, began singing Carla's praises through Amnesty International. Hell The prosecutor who had worked to put Carla away, Charlie Davidson, was switching sides. Originally he had called Carla the embodiment of evil. Now he was convinced that Carla was a changed woman who shouldn't die. Even Pope John Paul the Second publicly showed his support for Carla.
43:51 But there were some voices that publicly supported Carla's death sentence. For one, you had Diane Clements, President of Justice for All, she said, if she had converted to the Buddhist or Muslim or Jewish faith rather than Christianity. Would so many people think it was so relevant? No, and there was also Deborah Thornton's widowed husband, Richard. In an interview with the Longview News Journal, Richard explained that he was looking forward to her execution date. He said, I will look straight into the face of Carla fey Tucker and hope that she sees my face last, because I feel like the first face she'll see in whatever life beyond this life will be my wife. Right before Carla's execution, then Texas Governor George W. Bush refused to commute her sentence.
44:39 He released the following statement to explain his reasoning. Carla fey Tucker has acknowledged she is guilty of a horrible crime. She was convicted and sentenced by a jury of her peers. The role of the state is to enforce our laws and to make sure all individuals are treated fairly under those laws. May God bless Carla fey Tucker and God bless her victims and their families. At the end of the day, despite the public hysteria, anyone with experience in law knew that Carla was going to die. James Markhart, a criminal justice professor at sam Houston State University and an expert on the Texas death penalty, said to commute Carla would open the doors for a multitude of light claims from the boys, and frankly, America just didn't care about those boys on death row in the same way that they had come to care about Carla. So on the evening of February third, nineteen ninety eight, after fifteen years on death row, thirty eight year old Carla fey Tucker was executed by lethal injection in Huntsville, Texas. Her last meal was a banana, peaches and a tass salad with dressing. Her final words were, I would like to say to all of you, the Thornton family and Jerry Deane's family, that I am so sorry. Hope God will give you peace with this. Yes.
46:00 To Carla's husband Dana, she said, baby, I love you. Then she addressed a few folks individually. Next she said, everybody has been so good to me. I love you all very much. I'm going to be face to face with Jesus. Then she thanked the warden and said I will see you when you get there. I will wait for you, But there are plenty of people who doubts she'll be waiting at the pearly gates, who feel her folk hero status was ridiculous, who remember her cold, remorseless, taped confession, who believe she was a cold blooded killer, and it doesn't matter whether or not she found God, And they especially don't believe her gender should make any difference in the eyes of the law. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank, with additional writing by me. As usual, all editorial comments are my own special thanks to Mark Beaver, who sent us his book The Ballad of Carla fey Tucker to use as a resource for this episode.
47:08 Southern Fred's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic art is by Koly Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon Schuck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tap. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swyp recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shud as is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe, and please tell a friend or rate and review. I'm on all large platforms like iTunes, Iheartspotify, Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. Y'all take care,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed