197: Memphis Serial Killer: George Howard Putt-part 2 of 2
In August and September of 1969, one man killed five people in the span of 29 days in Memphis, Tennessee. These violent crimes shook the city of Memphis to its very core. Lock sales skyrocketed. Families adopted large dogs. People refused to leave...
In August and September of 1969, one man killed five people in the span of 29 days in Memphis, Tennessee. These violent crimes shook the city of Memphis to its very core. Lock sales skyrocketed. Families adopted large dogs. People refused to leave their house after sunset. It felt like no one was safe. The police searched day and night for this elusive serial killer. They doubled—then tripled—their staff, canceled all vacation time, and poured over $100,000 into paid overtime. But were it not for the brave actions of the killer’s final victim, Mary Christine Pickens, the perpetrator might have walked free for far, far longer. This is part two of a two-part series.
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder & Erica Kelley
Recommended by Kelly and others.
Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/george-howard-putt-2
This episode is brought to you by:
- Treat yourself to the best shapewear on the market and save 20% Off at honeylove.com/SFTC.
- Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey. Download today on iOS or Android.
- Today’s show is sponsored by Newspapers.com - my biggest resource for the show. Use the code "SOUTHERNFRIED” at checkout to get 20% off a Publisher Extra Subscription!
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:10 Southern for a true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. Serial killers are more rare than popular culture would have us believe. Most murderers know their victims. Their deaths are not random. They haven't been unlucky enough to cross paths with a monster. They were unlucky to know a person who wanted to hurt them. But books and movies especially perpetuate the myth of the everyday boogeyman, and the fictional victim is the archetypal beautiful damsel in distress who was stalked and hunted until a final showdown. She will either meet her fate with a serial killer and die, or some criminal probe filler will identify the monster just in time to save our damsel. But life isn't an episode of criminal minds. Real serial killers cannot always be put in a box and figured out, and let's face it, local law enforcement don't want to figure them out, they just want to stop them. So in that brutal Memphis summer of nineteen sixty nine, police were at a loss. They worked with the press and the public and details of the murders were in the papers in a way we no longer see, making the Boogeyman real, in a way that was beginning to feel personal to Memphians. Instead of being scared, they were
1:42 getting angry. Welcome to episode one ninety seven Memphis serial killer George Howard Putt part iiO. From nineteen sixty two to nineteen sixty four, a serial killer had a death grip around the bustling Matre Propolis of Boston, Massachusetts. This killer was accused of sexually assaulting and murdering at least eleven women in the Boston area, and he had several distinct imas. All of his victims were female, most of them were between the ages of sixty five to eighty five. He'd usually convinced them to open their door willingly, so there were no signs of forced entry, and he often strangled them to death with a pair of nylon stockings. Afterward, he would sometimes tie those stockings in a beau around his victim's necks. Youth probably heard of this killer before the media dubbed him the Boston Strangler, and for two long years Massachusetts was plagued by his threatening presence. In nineteen sixty five, thirty four year old Albert DeSalvo confessed to the crimes of the Boston Strangler. He claimed that he had sexually assaulted and killed Anna Slessor's, Mary Mullen, Nina Nichols, Helen Blake, Ida Erga, Jane Sullivan, Sophie Clark, Patricia Bassett, Mary Brown, Beverly Sammons, Evelyne Corbin, Joe Ann Graf, and Mary Sullivan. Only five of
3:14 these women were around twenty years old. The rest of the thirteen victims were ages sixty five to eighty five. It's not clear if Dessalvo actually committed all of these heinous acts. Many believe he was lying about committing at least some of them, but at the time of his confession, DeSalvo was already sentenced to life in prison for being a serial rapist. As a result, he was never formally tried or convicted of any Boston Strangler related crimes. DeSalvo died in prison in nineteen seventy three. Later, in twenty thirteen, his DNA was definitively linked to the rape and murder of the last known victim of the Boston Strangler, nineteen year old Mary Sullivan, who died on January fourth of nineteen sixty four. Five years later, in nineteen sixty nine, another serial killer would walk the streets, but not the streets of Boston. This time it was Memphis, Tennessee. Over a span of twenty nine days, the perpetrator killed five people fifty eight year old Roy Dumas, forty seven year old Berneline Dumas, eighty two year old Laylah Jackson, twenty one year old Glinda Sue Harden, and the focus of today's episode, fifty nine year old Christine Pickens. And this Memphis serial killer had some notable similarities to the Boston Strangler.
4:35 He also primarily targeted older women. He also always convinced his victims to open their door willingly. He also strangled them to death, and he also chose stockings as his weapon of choice for most of his murders. There were so many similarities between the two serial killers that experts on the Boston Strangler helped the Memphis police with their investigation. The Memphis newspapers constantly made comparisons between the two killers, and the author of the nineteen sixty eight book The Boston Strangler, Gerald Frank even wrote a criminal profile on the Tennessee copycat for the Memphis Press Simitar. The police went so far as to investigate any person who had checked out Frank's book on the Boston Strangler from the public library, though a journalist from the Commercial Appeal did point out that the paperback of the same book was available for a mere ninety five cents at any newsstand, not to mention a movie had been created about the Boston Strangler too. It felt like history was repeating itself. And I guess in a way, history was repeating itself, but not in some big grand way, like how newspapers used to frame serial killers. The Boston Strangler, Albert DeSalvo was just an evil man.
5:58 This serial killer from Tennessee was just one more evil man, and like all evil men, he fell flat on his face when a woman was given the smallest chance to fight back. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Mary Christine Pickens was born on September eleventh, nineteen ten, to her parents, William and Mary Pickens, in Tiptonville, Tennessee. Since Little Mary was named after her mother, A Mary Junior, if you will, she primarily went by her middle name Christine. Her friends and family called her Chris. Christine had three half siblings from her father's three previous marriages. Christine's mother, Mary, was William's fourth and last wife. Christine's father, William, was a reverend and a pastor. He worked at a variety of churches, including the Lambeth Memorial United Methodist Church in Jackson, Tennessee, about seventy miles south of Tenptonville, where Christine was born. You won't be shocked to hear that Christine, a pastor's daughter, was also very religious. She attended church every Sunday and was involved in all church activities her entire life. Christine spent most of her childhood and adolescence in Jackson, Tennessee. She graduated from Jackson High School in the nineteen twenties. After that, she attended the University of Memphis Lambeth Campus, which was also in Jackson. But when it came
7:29 time for Christine to find a job, she knew that she needed somewhere different, somewhere with opportunity, so she moved from Jackson to Memphis. The two Tennessee cities aren't terribly far away from each other, about eighty five miles total. An hour and a half's drive with traffic, But I bet to a young woman who had spent her whole life in Jackson, the journey to Memphis felt immns, but Christine was brave, and like all brave women, she figured it out. I'm not sure what Christine's life was like in her twenties. The information just asn't available, but I can tell you that Christine's father passed away in May of nineteen forty one. He was seventy nine years old.
8:11 Christine was thirty, and I'm sure that was a challenging time for her. Two years later, on November twenty eighth of nineteen forty three, thirty three year old Christine Pickens married a man named Thomas Butler in Marion, Arkansas. At the time, Christine was the manager of the book department at Lowenstein's. She had worked there for several years, and Thomas was in the Navy. He was a machinist's mate first class. The young couple honeymoon in New Orleans, Louisiana, and then they moved to San Francisco, California to start their lives together. That's where Thomas was stationed, and then one month later, Thomas died. Based on contact clues and a few mentions of Thomas in the papers, he was probably overseas serving his country in World War II.
9:00 Following her husband's untimely death, Christine reverted to her maiden name. That's why she's Christine Pickens and not Butler. But even though Christine preferred to use the name Pickens, she always maintained her status as a missus and she never married again. In the early to mid nineteen fifties, Christine worked as a receptionist at the Methodist Hospital. Her boss was a radiologist who always remembered how kind and sweet Christine was. She had a sharp sense of style, a quick wit, and a compassionate heart. When Christine's colleagues would bicker, she was quick to step away from the conflict. Around nineteen fifty nine, Christine left her job at Methodist Hospital to become a receptionist for doctor Robert Armstrong. He was a dentist. She would work in his dental office for the next ten years, and I'm sure Armstrong was very appreciative of that Christine was an asset to his team professionally and personally. He told the Commercial Appeal that Christine was incredibly supportive of the people around her. In September of nineteen sixty nine, fifty nine year old Christine lived alone in a one bedroom apartment that she wasn't actually alone. She had friends, good friends. One such friend described Christine as helpful and funny. They told the Commercial Appeal, I remember her sitting up with a friend all night when her friend had surgery. She was just a good Christian girl that everybody loved. And the people who weren't Christine's friends, well, she still treated them like they were her friends anyway. One
10:33 of her neighbors told the Commercial Appeal she was one heck of a nice person. She was the kind of person who would bring you a bowl of soup if she knew you were sick. A man who worked across the hall from Christine said, I used to go get cokes for her. She never let me pay for them. She was a lot of fun, sharp and on the ball. On Thursday, September eleventh, nineteen sixty nine, it was Christine's fifty ninth birthday, but she had taken the day off. That wasn't her nature. Of course, she went into work like always. She walked into armstrong and armstrong dental office at eight thirty that morning and waved at her apartment neighbor, who happened to work in the same building as Christine, sat in her office chair. Everyone wished her a happy birthday, and she graciously but excitedly thanked them for the well wishes before getting straight to work. After all, Christine had a lot of patients that day. They always did on Thursdays. Since the dental office closed at noon and wasn't open on Fridays, Christine didn't have time to grab a proper lunch she was so busy, but that was usually the case at this fast paced job. She would just sneak quick bites in in between patients. At noon, the office closed and Christine left her desk. A colleague asked her if she was headed home, and Christine replied, no, I've got an errand to run. I don't want to be in a hurry. You go on. Apparently Christine was going to get a gift for doctor Armstrong soon to be born grandchild, you know, just doing something nice for the people around her on her own birthday. Typical
12:07 Christine things. Approximately one hour later, Christine was found dead at her home. There was no sign of forced entry, and there were three locks on her doors. One lock on her back door was brand new. She had added it in response to the murders of the Dumases, Laylah Jackson and Glinda Sue Harden. After the news of Christine's death broke, a receptionist who worked in the same building as Christine told the Memphis Press Simitar, she had such a friendly smile. The last time I talked with her, we were talking about the murders. She said she wouldn't let anyone in her apartment that she didn't know. And a longtime friend of Christine's, Claude Jen, lamented to rapporters about how he teased Christine about her caution. He joked, by the time a prowler gets in the front, you can get out the back.
13:00 Funeral service was held two days later at the Griffin Funeral Home in Jackson, Tennessee. She was buried in the Hollywood Cemetery in Jackson, just like her parents, and Christine's gravestone was inscribed with these words she loved God, she loved life. I know what you're thinking, where's the big to do? The police, the investigation, the dusting for fingerprints. The quotes from our repeating guest stars, Fire and Police Director Holloman and police chief Looks. Well, you won't be hearing any of that because they caught the guy. It was twenty three year old George Howard Putt, and his long awaited arrest was all thanks to Christine. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. Today's episode is sponsored by newspapers dot Com, the largest online newspaper archive and your ultimate resource for untangling secrets of the past and Southern Fried listeners. I'm here to tell you this show would not be possible without newspapers dot Com. I've used this online resource since the beginning and would be lost without it. You can delve into more than eight hundred million pages of digitized newspapers and uncover overlook details and forgotten stories. Newspapers dot Com has a vast collection of papers spanning three centuries. Explore pulse pounding news reports, eyewitness accounts, and crime scene photos from the US and beyond. Travel through time with newspapers dot Com and get a front row seat to history. For listeners of
14:31 today's show, newspapers dot Com is offering twenty percent off a publisher extra subscription. Just use the code's Southern Fried at checkout. Unleash your inner detective with Newspapers dot Com Today, Ladies, y'all know there is nothing worse than an uncomfortable bra. Thankfully, Honeylove has revolutionized the bra game. Honeylove's bras feature supportive bonding that eliminates the need for underwire without sacrificing left. When I started working from home, the first thing I did was get rid of all my underwire bras and then set off on a quest for the perfect comfortable bra that still had the support I needed. And then boom, I found Honeylove.
15:13 Honeylove's bestseller crossover bra is so comfortable it's sure to be your new go too. This bra is all the support of traditional bras without using any underwires. But it doesn't stop there. Honeylove has more than just bras. They have incredibly comfortable with shapewear, tanks and leggings for everyday support. Treat yourself to the best bras on the market and save twenty percent off at Honeylove dot com slash SFTC. Use our exclusive link to get twenty percent off at Honeylove dot com slash SFTC. After you purchase, they ask you where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them we sent you. It's time to ditch the underwire for good thanks to Honeylove. Everyone loves a good family mystery, especially one with as many twists and turns as June's journey. This game is about a daring young girl, June, traveling to her sister's estate to uncover scandalous family secrets. Engage your observation skills to quickly uncover key pieces of information that lead to chapters of mystery, danger, and romance. Where will each new chapter take you? Each chapter uncovers a collection of dazzling hidden objects spectacles for you to solve. Set out on a journey through the glamorous Roaring twenties and search for hidden objects from the parlors of New York to the sidewalks of Paris. I slip out after dinner and cozy up on my porch to get lost in June's journey. Right now, I'm in chapter eight, where June goes on a trip to Paris to continue to try and help her niece Virginia. I love to relax and lose myself in this captivating quest of
16:48 mystery, murder, and romance. Are you craving a good mystery or just looking for an escape? Either way, you should immerse yourself in the world of June Parker. Discover your inner detective when you download June's Journey for free today on iOS and Android. George Howard Putt was born on March fifteenth, nineteen forty six, to parents Ruth and Clifford Putt, in New Orleans, Louisiana. His nickname was Buster, and he was the third oldest child out of at least six siblings, including four brothers and one sister. George's childhood was, by all accounts, terrible. It doesn't excuse the monster he would become, but it's definitely a part of his history. In nineteen forty three, three years before George was born, his father, Clifford, was drafted into the military at age twenty four. He was supposed to serve his country in World War II, but we don't know if he did. We do know that, according to the Greensboro Record, Clifford was investigated for being an army deserter, but I guess they found evidence indicating that he had been properly discharged. Later that year, Clifford was convicted of assault. He was fighting with his wife and George's future mother, Ruth. When the situation escalated, a man had stepped in. Clifford pulled a rifle on him and shot twice.
18:11 Luckily the rifle filled both times, and then he tried to flee the scene, but was apprehended by police. In nineteen forty six, the year George was born, his father was charged with cruelty to a juvenile in New Orleans. We're not sure who the juvenile was in that case, but it could have been baby George. According to George's grandfather, Clifford would beat his four month old son with his belt. Clifford was sentenced to one year in jail, but it was suspended so long as he underwent treatment, and it appears that he did undergo treatment at the VA in North Carolina. In July of nineteen forty seven, when George was one year old, Clifford played guilty to fraud. He had knowingly made false statements about payments related to his service in the army and somehow gotten money out of it. A few months later, in November, Clifford was caught forging checks and About thirty days later, in December, he was charged with larceny. By the time Clifford turned forty, he was accused of check fraud in six cities. So, yeah, George's dad was a bad guy, But what about mom? Unfortunately, Ruth was just as bad as Clifford. For a time, they were partners in crime. Clifford would give Ruth money for bus fare, and then Ruth would take all the kids to different cities in the area. In each city, she would pretend she was going to buy an item when the check made out for more than the item cost. For example, she paid eighteen dollars for a watch and handed the clerk a check for over fifty Then she got the
19:42 watch and the remaining balance in cash. According to Ruth, they ran this scammon at least a dozen cities, and when she was caught, she said the whole thing was Clifford's idea. She said he forced her to forge checks day in and day out. I'm not sure I believe. The court certainly didn't. Eventually, Ruth was sentenced to three to five years in prison in Greensboro. After that, she was to serve another sentence of up to ten years for a different forgery conviction. By nineteen sixty four, Clifford and Ruth divorced. They probably couldn't see each other anymore anyway, they were too busy serving prison sentences. Meanwhile, George and his siblings were shuffled between relatives, friends, and foster homes for the majority of their childhood. There are records of him living in New Orleans, Texas, North Carolina, Mississippi, and Virginia. And as you can imagine, that unstable, transient, no parent childhood didn't go well. George started his ripe sheet very early. At age eleven, he was cost stealing an air rifle in Texas. Okay, you might be thinking that's no big deal, no harm, no foul, and normally I agree it was just an air rifle. But this was just the beginning for George. On July twenty sixth, nineteen sixty one, fifteen year old George sexually molested a ten year old girl. On January thirteenth, nineteen sixty two, George, who was still fifteen, was accused of kidnapping a
21:14 woman, holding her at gunpoint, and forcing her to drive to a secondary location. That woman, thank god, purposely wrecked the car and escaped. George was arrested two days later. George crawled through the second story window of a home he had seen two women enter. He woke one of these women up and said, don't scream if you don't want anything to happen to your children. Then he forced her to dress and get in his car. Police caught him when George ran a red light. Luckily they put a stop to him this time. I can't emphasize this enough. George was fifteen years old, and these are just the crimes we know about. If teenage George was stalking women this boldly, these probably weren't his first violent crimes. He was definitely aware he could get away with it. The courts certainly weren't stopping him, not in any meaningful way. It wasn't until George was days away from turning seventeen that the courts finally committed him to the Gatesville School for Boys in Gatesville, Texas. He was released four years later, on March fifteenth, nineteen sixty seven, his twenty first birthday. In a perfect world, George would have spent those four years reflecting and rehabilitating, but he did not.
22:29 Instead, he tried to escape the school and was accused of trying to rob the librarian with three other boys. Sometime during George's teen years, a psychiatrist determined that he was a psychopath. According to the commercial appeal, the psychiatrist said George was capable of committing almost any type of crime. As I was researching this case, I almost lost my damn mind reading articles that framed George as a product of his upbringing. It is difficult to feel sympathy when you know the brutality of his crimes. George made choices, he made decisions, and many people have rough childhoods. We are all products of our upbringing, good or bad. When twenty one year old George was released from the state school, he got a job as a hospital orderly in Houston, Mississippi.
23:19 Then George moved to Tupelau, which was his father's hometown. His paternal grandparents still lived there and George stayed with them for a while until he got on his feet. George was actually hired at the Tupelau Medical Center, but then he was fired. He had stolen the wallet of the director of nurses. He was forced to give the money back and no charges were pressed. When folks at the Tupeleaux spoke to reporters later. One woman recalled that George tried to wear his sunglasses during his interview. They had to ask him to remove them. While in Tupelau, twenty one year old George married an eighteen year old woman he had met through family named Mary Mary Ruth. By nineteen sixty nine, twenty three year old George and twenty year old Mary Ruth had a son together, but they weren't a happy little family. Mary often complained that George was lazy and that he physically abused her, in addition to all that the couple was in dire financial straits. In May of nineteen sixty nine, George was arrested by the Mississippi police. He had robbed someone. He pled guilty, and his charge was reduced to trespassing. They fined him five hundred dollars and sentenced him to six months in the Hines County Penal farm in Jackson, Mississippi. But apparently George didn't think that his reduced sentence that he had literally pled guilty to was fair. So one day, when George was assigned to work detail outside, he just left hopped in a truck and drove off.
24:52 He wouldn't be seen again by the legal system for several months. At this time, Mary Ruth was pregnant with her and George's second son. They made their way to Memphis and stayed with George's brother, Clifford Junior. Then George found a job working at the Hudson Oil Company as a service station attendant. He was also receiving money from the Aid to Dependent Children program in Mississippi. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Cut to August of nineteen sixty nine, the start of twenty three year old George Howard Putt's murder spree. George had escaped from a Mississippi prison three months before and fled the state. Now he was working at a gas station in Memphis, Tennessee.
25:41 And according to George's own confessions to all five murders, court documents, eyewitness statements, and over one hundred newspaper articles, here is what probably happened next. And I say probably because George would later redact his multiple confessions confessions that he had signed. On August thirteenth, nineteen sixty nine, George murdered a fifty eight year old Roy Dumas and sexually assaulted and murdered Roy's wife, forty seven year old Bernelin Dumas. According to George's confession, he had chosen the Dumases by complete chance. That day he had gone to sell a pine of blood, then he had a few beers at the Ok cafe, and after that he found a random apartment building. At least one person saw George sitting outside this building, with the apartment picked at random. George knocked on the Dumas's door. Roy answered, and George pushed small statured Roy back into the apartment and demanded money. Maybe Roy had argued with him or said he didn't have any money, because George tied him up and searched for the money himself, and he found about thirty bucks in total, which would be about two hundred and fifty in twenty twenty three money. At one point, according to George's initial confession, Roy freed him from his bindings, but then George caught him and tied him to his bed once more. In the midst of all this, Roy let it slip that his wife, Bernolynne, would be home at about three pm. So George waited for Bernoline in her bedroom when
27:15 she came home from work, George jumped her with one of Roy's hunting knives and tied her up, and despite what the medical examiner would say in a nineteen seventy three trial, George himself explained that he raped her and then he mutilated her with Roy's knife and strangled her with a stocking. Then he strangled Roy with a stocking. George took a few minutes to wipe the apartment clean of his fingerprints, then he took Roy's knife with him and left. Eleven days later, on August twenty fifth, George killed eighty two year old Laylah Jackson. George never went to trial for Layla's murder, just for the murders of Roy, Bernoline, and Christine. We'll get to that later, but just say, you know, that's why we have fewer details here. But it's likely Layla was also picked at random, especially since it didn't appear that she ever crossed George's path. On the same day that George killed Layla, he went to a used car dealership called Amco Transmission Company. The company owner remembered selling George a nineteen sixty one white Buick station wagon. George told the owner that The buick was for his wife, Mary Ruth. The car didn't actually run, but that was all right with George. He and his brother Clifford Junior could fix it up. George gave the car dealer fifty dollars as a down payment on August twenty fifth. It's not clear if he bought the car before or after he killed Laylah that day, but since Layla always said she didn't keep money in her house, it wouldn't shock me if he had
28:48 bought the car after he murdered Layla. It would make sense that he couldn't buy the car outright since he wasn't able to find too much money in Layla's home. Four days later, on August twenty ninth, George killed twenty one year old Glinda Sue Harden. As I mentioned in Part one, there are suspicions that Glinda Seue had left her car unlocked and that George had used that as an opportunity to get in her back seat. But maybe that's not what happened. Maybe George simply saw Glinda Sue cash her paycheck at the bank around lunchtime that day, and then followed her until she was near her parked car. Like Layla. George would never go to trial for Glendasue's murder, so the details are hazy. After George robbed, raped, murdered, and mutilated Glinda Seue, he was seen driving her car to the parking lot, where it was later discovered at some point he stole Glindasue's money and several of her belongings, including her sunglasses case, which was later found in his home.
29:49 Three days later, on September second, George returned to the used car dealership and paid off the rest of the station wagon, and nine days after that, on September eleventh, George killed fifty nine year old Christine Pickens. According to George's confessions and the testimony of several witnesses, George sold a pine of blood that day, just like he had before the Dumas's murder. Then he drank some Budweisers at a bar from about ten forty five am to twelve thirty pm. This bar was the same one George went to before the Dumas's murders, the Oka Cafe, and it was walking distance from Christine's apartment. The waitress who served George chatted with him about the serial killer running loose, who was killing people with stockings. The waitress had no idea she was talking to the serial killer himself. She told the Commercial Appeals reporters quote, I was teasing him about whether he had a stocking in his pocket. He just smiled.
30:48 People were always kidding about things like that. After George left the Oka Cafe in his car, a woman later saw him walking near Christine's apartment. According to court testimony, George first knocked on the door of the apartment next to Christine's. The resident of that apartment, Grace Oldham, testified that George said I'm here to collect on a bad check from Oldham. When Grace asked for more information, George said it was Johnny Oldham. Grace told George to go away, and she heard him leave. Then she peeked out her door and saw him go into Christine's apartment. According to George's confessions, he had seen Christine walk into her building while carrying some packages at one o five pm.
31:34 He followed Christine inside her apartment. Once inside, he tried to snatch her purse, but Christine wasn't having it. She began screaming bloody murder. Literally, she yelled, murderer, murderer, George stabbed her at least fourteen times and slashed her throat, and despite these gruesome injuries, Christine fought back and screamed as loud as she could she could be heard cleary to her upsur's neighbor, Emma Gross. Emma was fifty seven years old, a grandmother and a nurse. She was getting ready for work that day and making herself a sandwich, but upon hearing Christine's screams, Emma dropped everything and sprinted to the source of the sound. She immediately spotted George holding a bloody knife, the same knife that George had stolen from Roy Dumas. George tried to act calm as Emma approached him as if this was a normal situation, but Emma told the Commercial Appeal, I was so close to him. He showed me the knife and blood fell off the blade onto my uniform. Emma tried to grab George, but he pushed her away and ran, and she followed right behind him. As Emma took off after George, she saw another neighbor, fifty seven year old Wayne Armstrong. Wayne was a liquor store clerk who lived across the hall from Christine. Emma yelled to Wayne, come, Christine's been killed.
32:58 Wayne burst out of his apartment, worrying nothing but his boxers, and whipped out a pistol. According to one eyewitness, George paused and said he won't shoot me in the back, to which Wayne replied, I'll shoot you in the back the same as in the front if you try to run away. But then George ran and Wayne did fire six shots at him, but none of them made contact, so Waine and Emma both ran after George while yelling for onlookers to call the police. Multiple people heard Wayne and Emma's please and joined in their pursuit of George. In a way, it was kind of poetic. George had terrorized the citizens of Memphis, and now Memphis citizens were getting their shot at terrorizing George. But still he nearly got away.
33:43 He was a fast runner, and he managed to hop a fence and go under a construction expressway. I'm sure by that time many people had called the police, but there was no way the authorities were going to make it in time. Through a sheer stroke of luck, George happened to run into two police office R. G. Noblin and P R. Scruggs. They stopped him because they thought something weird was going on. One later admitted that at first he thought George was an artist. Why else would someone have so much red paint on themselves. Quickly the officers realized George was covered in blood, not paint, and finally he was caught. It was over. He was strip searched, arrested, and charged with five counts of murder. At one twenty one pm on September eleventh, nineteen sixty nine, only fifteen minutes after the Son of a Bitch murdered Christine Pickens on her own birthday, Police Chief Henry Lux said of Christine, meantphisows this woman a dead of gratitude. If she had not put up a fight and screamed, sounding the alarm for others to hear, she might not have been discovered until long after her death, and the killer would have had the chance to escape. It may sound trite, but in a sense, she gave her life so that others could escape this terror. Police Chief Looks also publicly thank the efforts of Immigrose, Swayne Armstrong, and the other concerned citizens who had helped chase George down. Shortly
35:13 after capturing George, the police were able to recover the murder weapon, which he had tossed while he was running, and they also found his bloody white shirt, which he had taken off during the chase. Two. When his arrest was announced on the police radios, the officers cheered over their walkies. Later, George would be indicted for five counts of murder in the perpetration of a robbery, two counts of carrying a hunting knife, and he was held without bail. The next day, on September twelfth, the papers announced that the police had charged twenty three year old George Howard Putt, an escaped convict, with the murder of five people. The police highly suspected that this twenty three year old was their notorious, cunning sex killer. George admitted to killing his victims at random when he needed money. Now that police knew George was the killer, finding the evidence to prove as much was easy. According to the FBI, his fingerprints were on Christine's apartment door, his pom print was on her purse, and of course he had been caught in the act.
36:15 It's not clear how much George's wife, Mary Ruth, and his brother Clifford Junior knew about George's serial killing. They both claimed to be extremely shocked, but Mary Ruth had recently paid up their rent for several weeks, and according to witnesses, Clifford Junior had spent time with George every single day for weeks that summer and fall of sixty nine. Naturally, Clifford Junior had claimed that he had rarely seen George during this time, but he did admit that he noticed George had been acting weird about the recent stream of murders. In an interview with the Memphis Press, Simitar, Clifford said, I had a bad feeling. Every time I would see him, he would say there was another murder, and I hadn't heard it on the news report for anything. It seemed that he wanted to tell me what he had done. I knew something was wrong. He'd show me the houses where those deaths occurred. He pointed them out, and another weird thing. Less than a week after George was arrested, Clifford Junior packed up and left for Richmond, Virginia. But in all fairness to Clifford, he said he'd lost his job at the service station due to the case. In October of nineteen seventy twenty four year old George Putt's first jury trial began. He was accused of murdering Mary Christine Pickens in the first degree. The prosecution had chosen Christine's murder because they figured with the eyewitnesses and fingerprints, it would be the easiest to get a conviction, and they were seeking the death penalty, so hopefully they only have to do this
37:49 process once. During the trial itself, the prosecution presented an airtight case against George. After all, the police had literally caught him red handed, and there was so much more evidence against him. George's fingerprints were at Christine's apartment, his palm print was on her stolen purse. He had used Roy Dumas's knife as the murder weapon. The defense's arguments were not so air tight. They said George couldn't have confessed because he was too drunk from his beers at the Ok cafe, but for the record, the waitress that had served George said he seemed fine. The defense also insinuated that the signatures on George's confessions were falsified by the police, but that rationale didn't stick well either, especially since the prosecution read aloud George's very specific, very accurate confessions. By the end of it all, George's defence team realized the only leg they had to stand on was George's mental health. George had pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. Now his attorneys had to convince the jury. Multiple psychiatrists testified to George's distorted views of women, his mental health diagnoses, and violent behavior.
39:07 George's mother in law testified that he once walked in on her while she was having a bath. He put his hands on her shoulders and said, sh I won't hurt you. But even though the defensive psychiatrist said George was legally insane, the prosecution's expert witnesses said otherwise. They argued that George knew right from wrong when he had killed Christine, he just hadn't cared. I bet this entire trial, from opening statements to closing, felt more like a formality than a debate. On October twenty seventh, after two weeks of trial, approximately fifty witnesses, and forty seven minutes of deliberation, the jury found twenty four year old George Howard Pytt guilty of first degree murderer. He was sentenced to death in the electric chair. Less than a week before George's conviction, his wife Mary Ruth, gave birth to his second son. Following the trial, George's lawyers immediately moved for a new trial, that was denied, and then they started the appeals process. Despite the win on Christine's death penalty case, prosecutors decided to try George for the Douma's murders lest his conviction be overturned on some technicality. The second trial began on April twenty third of nineteen seventy three. George was twenty seven years old. The prosecution simply presented George's confessions and rested their case, and the defense once again argued that George was temporarily insane when he committed the murders, but this didn't hold up well. Multiple
40:43 medical experts took the stand saying George was absolutely sane during the murders. Some even indicated that George purposely tried to appear mentally ill so that he could avoid the death penalty. On April twenty seventh, after ninety minutes of deliberation, Howard Putt was convicted of murdering Roy and Bernel and Dumas he was sentenced to four hundred and ninety seven consecutive years in prison, the longest sentence ever given in Memphis, Tennessee. But what about George's death sentence? While In June of nineteen seventy two, the United States Supreme Court determined that the death penalty was unconstitutional. As a result, George's original sentence for the murder of Christine Pickens was changed to ninety nine years in prison, which was included in his total of four hundred and ninety seven years. The United States later restored the death penalty in nineteen eighty eight. By nineteen seventy four, George's appeals had been dismissed and his convictions upheld. He had never shown remorse for killing Roy and Bernel and dumas Leyla Jackson, Linda Sue Harden, or Mary Christine Pickens.
41:52 He told a Memphis magazine around nineteen eighty nine, I think where I'm at now is where I'm supposed to be. To get where I'm at, I'd do it all again. At one point, years after his conviction, George requested a new trial yet again. He claimed that his defense council was ineffective. This appeal was also denied. On October twenty sixth, twenty fifteen, sixty nine year old George Howard Putt died in a prison hospital in Davidson County, Tennessee. To date, his burial details remain unknown, but if you look on his find a grave page. One person left him poison ivy, where folks usually virtual flowers. George Putt killed five people over a period of twenty nine days. He is still a serial killer rather than a spree killer because there were cooling off periods between the murders. During that hot summer of nineteen sixty nine, Putt terrorized Memphis, Tennessee, and a combination of robberies and sexual assaults. He prayed on older, morelvulnerable women, with the exception of one victim, Glinda Sue Harden, and even she seemed to be a murder of convenience. He needed money. He saw Glinda Sue and followed her to her car. Since at least the age of fifteen, George Putt had been brutalizing women. By the summer of nineteen sixty nine, he was
43:22 escalating the mutilations of his victims. Showed a rapist who had graduated in his savagery, while also seemingly pairing his robberies with the sexual assaults for convenience. And who knows how many unsolved rapes and murders could be attributed to such a violent man, A man who was assaulting women before he was even eighteen years old, A man who never showed any remorse, A man who deserved to die in prison. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted in produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank, with additional writing by myself. As usual, all editorial comments are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic art is by Koly Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon schuck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases you'll always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messaging, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share means. We do, of course, discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it
44:53 when we say no shit ass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review. I'm on all large platforms like iTunes, Iheartspotify, Amazon, and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. Y'all, take care
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed