193: Police Corruption & The Murder of Kim Groves
Thursday, October 13th of 1994 was a big day for New Orleans. On one side of town, their new police superintendent, Richard Pennington, was being sworn into office. On the other side of town, a beloved mother of three was being murdered. This mother...
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional Writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/kim-groves
Sponsors for this episode:
- This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp online therapy. Give online therapy a try at BetterHelp.com/southern and get on your way to being your best self.
- Go to SimpliSafe.com/southernfried and save 20% on your home security system when you sign up for Fast Protect Monitoring. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
- Go to Proactiv.com now and use the exclusive promo code southernfried to get 20% off your first order! Proactiv, Taking the guesswork out of clearing skin since 1995.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:01 Southern for a true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. When we call nine one one, we expect first responders to get there as soon as possible. The torment of waiting can make it seem like it takes forever for help to arrive, even if it's only a matter of minutes. But what if it's not Your panic can fear? What if it takes a large metropolitan police force almost an hour to get to you. In a medical emergency, every second counts, and even if it's clear that there is no hope for the injured person, the despair of waiting that long next to their body is agony. Thursday, October thirteenth, nineteen ninety four was a big day for New Orleans. On one side of town, their new police Superintendent, Richard Pennington, was being worn into office. On the other side of town, a beloved mother of three was being murdered. This mother was thirty two year old Kim Marie Groves. As a result of Kim's death at the hands of dirty police officers, the New Orleans Police Department's rampant corruption would be exposed, and Superintendent Pennington's reign as the head of THENPD would be forever changed.
1:27 Welcome to Episode one ninety three, Police Corruption and the Murder of Kim Groves. On that Thursday, October thirteenth of nineteen ninety four, forty eight year old Richard Pennington was sworn in as the City of New orleans newest police chief. It was an exciting ceremony, one of pomp and circumstance. The air probably smelled fresh like new beginnings, and why shouldn't it. He was a great candidate for police superintendent was certainly qualified for the role. At age eighteen, Richard had enlisted in the US Air Force and served in the Vietnam War. After that, he became a law enforcement officer with the Metropolitan Police Department in Washington, DC. He stayed there for twenty six years and was even promoted to assistant chief. Now Richard was in the big leagues. This was his first stint at the top of the food chain, the superintendent of the New Orleans Police Department, and he was ready, or at least he thought he was. Minutes after he became superintendent, an FBI agent pulled him aside. This agent explained to the newly appointed police chief that the corruption within the New Orleans Police Department was bad, very bad, far worse than anybody could have ever imagined. As time went on, the FBI agents explained to Richard the nuances of thenpd's corruption. There were rogue officers, a drug ring,
2:58 and an elaborate FBI sting operation meant to take down dozens of dirty cops. Years later, Richard told The Times Pickie in newspaper, I thought, my lord, what am I getting myself into? And it just so happens in an act of pure coincidence. On October thirteenth, nineteen ninety four, the same day that Richard Pennington was shaking hands and being congratulated for his new position as the superintendent of the NPD, a woman was being murdered. Her name was Kim Groves, and her death would become the unexpected catalyst that revealed what the FBI had suspected all along, years and years of corruption within the New Orleans Police Department. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break.
3:52 Kim Marie Groves was born on January tenth, nineteen sixty two, in New Orleans to parents, Nathaniel and Gwendolyn. We don't know much about Kim's childhood, but through Kim's family, we do know that she became an important woman who impacted the lives of many. In an interview with Rare Reports, Kim's nephew, Pops and her youngest daughter, Jasmine, described Kim as above all else, a mother. She was a literal mother to her three children, Jasmine, her son, and her eldest daughter. That Kim wasn't just a biological mother. She was a spiritual one, a protector by nature, a warrior, a queen. In Kim's neighborhood, the fifth District of New Orleans, she was recognized as a mother to all, as in, if you were a kid in the thirteen hundred block of Alabo Street, you knew Kim wass family. You knew she cared about you, loved you, wanted what was best for you, and she would fight tooth and nail to make sure you were safe, happy, and healthy. Kim watched over everyone.
4:59 She wasn't going to let anyone slip through the cracks, and she regularly went above and beyond to ensure the well being of others. She was known for celebrating the successes of the neighborhood kids get an A on a test. Kim was ready to senior praises, get hired for a part time job. She was going to be the first to congratulate you. But she was also known for reminding those same neighborhood kids to be better people when they made poor choices. And that's because Kim was a believer of justice. If you did something wrong, you needed to take responsibility for your actions. You had to. We all did, otherwise, what would the world come to. So in the fall of nineteen ninety four, when Kim heard that a high school acquaintance turned police officer and as partner, had pistol whipped a neighborhood kid, she was not going to let it slide, especially because the kid in question, a teenager named to Nathan, hadn't done anything wrong. According to Kim, the officers had mistaken and Nathan for a person involved in the shooting of an officer. About a day after this pistol whipping incident happened, on or near October eleventh, Kim went to the New Orleans Police Department Office of Internal Affairs.
6:14 There, she failed a complaint against that officer who she knew from high school, and his partner in the complaint. Kim reported both officers for alleged police brutality. On the evening of Thursday, October thirteenth, Kim was at home planning a party. Her youngest daughter, Jasmine's thirteenth birthday, was the next day, on Friday, October fourteenth. Everyone was excited. Thirteen years old is such a big deal. Little Jasmine wasn't so little anymore. She would be a teenager, just one step closer to adulthood. That Thursday night, Jasmine had her cousin Ever for a sleepover. They were playing card games when Kim burst into the room, serenading Jasmine with her own silly rendition of the Happy Birthday song. And it was such a happy moment, one that, according to Jasmine, she would never forget. Not long after this mini birthday celebration, Kim stepped out of the house. It was about eleven pm.
7:15 We're not sure where she was going, and honestly, it doesn't matter, because minutes later, the phone started ringing in the Grove's household. After a few rings, Jasmine picked up the phone. The person on the other end of the line a woman was screaming frantically. She told Jasmine, Kim has just been shot, and I think she's dead. Jasmine ran out of the house, down the block and around the corner, and that's when she saw her mother, thirty two year old Kim Marie Groves, lying on the cement. She was dead and the cause was clear, a single gunshot wound delivered straight to Kim's head in what reporters would later call execution style. As twelve year old Jasmine took the sea in, she was immediately in shock, but soon she realized somebody needed to call nine one one, and that somebody was her. But according to Jasmine, after she explained the tragic situation to a nine one one operator, it still took emergency responders forty five minutes to arrive. And even though Jasmine recalled that her mother was clearly dead far beyond the help of any medical professional, that long of a response time was still upsetting. It was yet another clue that the New Orleans Police Department was not concerned about Kim, or Jasmine or anyone else in the New Orleans fifth District.
8:37 As Jasmine and her family waited for the police, they sat alongside Kim's lifeless body. Jasmine told rare reports that her grandfather picked up Kim's spilled brain matter and washed it in a nearby a levee. Jasmine explained that this was a ritual, a cleansing that would allow Kim to be fully released from this world and sent peacefully onward to the next. After the police came and went, they left remnants of Kim's murder on the sidewalk for over twenty four hours. Jasmine remembered seeing her mother's bloodstains on the sidewalk after school the next day, and later Jasmine would say it felt like a dream. Almost a month passed after Kim's murder, and it appeared that there was little to no progress on her investigation. An eyewitness had said the killer looked similar to Kim's boyfriend, but when it turned out the perpetrator wasn't Kim's boyfriend, that was it.
9:37 The investigation slowed to a full, heart wrenching stop. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. This show is sponsored by Better Help. I sometimes suffer from insomnia, usually brought on by racing thoughts keeping me up at night. Do you ever find that just as you're trying to fall asleep, you just can't shut your brain off. It turns out one great way to make those racing thoughts go away is to talk them through. Therapy gives you a place to do that, so you can get out of your negative thought cycles and find some mental and emotional peace. I've used therapy for the hardest times of my life. It's helpful for learning positive coping skills and setting boundaries, and it empowers you to be the best version of yourself. It isn't just for those who've experienced major trauma. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give Better Help a try. It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. Get a break from your thoughts with Better Help. Visit better help dot com slash Southern today to get ten percent off your first month. That's Better Help Help dot com slash Southern. Fall is here, my friends, and we're all settling back into busier routines filled with our kids soccer practices and seasonal activities, leaving our homes empty and vulnerable. That's why I recommend Safe Home Security and their revolutionary home monitoring innovation. Twenty four seven Live Guard Protection Simply Safe has been protecting my home for over two years now. I love that I feel safe when
11:11 I'm at home and worry free you when I'm not. Twenty four seven Live Guard Protection is made possible by the new Smart Alarm wireless indoor camera, available with a fast Protect monitoring plan. The new Smart Alarm Indoor Camera is the only indoor security camera that can trigger the alarm and instantly deter intruders with a built in siren. It also has a physical privacy shutter to provide protection when you need it and privacy when you want it. Twenty four seven Live Guard Protection and the new Smart Alarm Indoor Camera works seamlessly as part of the simply Safe system to get your whole home safe from break INDs, fires, floods, and more. For a limited time, get twenty percent off your new system when you sign up for Fast Protect monitoring. Visit simply safe dot com slash Southern Fried. That's simply safe, dot com slash Southern Fried. There's no safel Simply Safe, Thank you too. Proactive America's number one clear skin routine for sponsoring today's episode. Exciting news Proactive has just launched their newest skincare innovation, Proactive Clean. Proactive Clean is a gentle skincare routine formulated to clear mild acne to occasional breakouts for sensitive skin. Proactive is dermatologists developed and tested with clinically proven ingredients. It's formulated without parabins, daylates, sulfates, cyclic silicones, and one hundred more bad ingredients. Proactives three step skincare routines help break the acne cycle and give you great looking skin. Get that clean skin feeling with Protective Clean. I'm lucky enough to have very few wrinkles at my
12:43 age, but I do have sensitive skin and I have to deal with the occasional breakout, and Proactive Clean has done wonders to keep my skin clear and leave me without wonderful clean feeling. Proactive has helped over twenty million people on their clear skin journey. Go to proactive dot com now and use the exclusion of promo code Southern Fried to get twenty percent off your first order. That's proactive dot Com promo code Southern Fried to get twenty percent off your first order. Proactive taking the guesswork out of clearing skin since nineteen ninety five. For all intents and purposes, it seemed like the New Orleans authorities could care less about Kim, and since Kim's murder didn't make the news, there wasn't any public pressure to force the NPD to care either. But suddenly, on November two of nineteen ninety four, the FBI came out of the woodwork. They received eight search warrants, one of which was for the home of twenty four year old Damon Causey, a known drug trafficker with a reputation for violence.
13:48 During the raid, the FBI found a gun in Damon's home. They knew they would, after all, the FBI had rated Damon's home specifically to look for this specific gun, And then ballistics testing proved what the FBI had already suspected that Damon's nine millimeter handgun was the murder weapon used in Kim Groves's death. It matched a bullet casing found at the scene of the crime and everything. But how had the FBI known to look for the murder weapon used to kill Kim in Damon's home? In fact, why were the FBI involved in Kim's case at all? Kim a beloved woman had been betrayed by her local police and her local media, both of whom hadn't taken hardly any notice of her absence. So why had the FBI, the United States top investigative force, take notice. Well, it's a hell of a story. To explain it, I'll have to go back to the beginning. In nineteen eighty eight, a twenty four year old man named Lynn Davis joined the New Orleans Police Department, and right from the beginning, Lynn was not the perfect cop.
14:56 In fact, he was far from perfect. Over the course of seven years the NPD, Lynn would gain a reputation for poor performance. In nineteen ninety, he was suspended for fifteen days after crashing his police vehicle, and on another occasion, he was found guilty of a battery arrest and was suspended for fifty one days. And Lynn didn't handle his ever growing list of disciplinary fractions well. He started drinking more, he became increasingly violent while on duty, and the number of internal affairs complaints filed against Lynn's behavior went up and up. Later, one of his own lawyers would indicate that Lynn never had any business being on a police force. So why was Lynn still on the New Orleans Police Force. Why didn't they just fire him? You know the old saying, how one bad apple spoils the bunch. Well, if ever there had been a bad apple, it was probably Lynn Davis. If THENPD could just throw Lynn out, they would save the rest of them from being equally rotten. But the department couldn't fire Lynn. They couldn't fire anybody. And that's because the NONPD was drowning in violence. In the mid nineties, New Orleans experienced more criminal activity than ever before, and the year Kim Groves was murdered nineteen ninety four, there had been a record breaking amount of homicide victims four hundred and twenty four to be exact. A former commander of the innopd's homicide division, Jimmy Keene, told The Times Pickyune, we were really knee
16:26 deep in murders. We just chased our tales, going from one murder to the next. New Orleans was overwhelmed by crime and underwhelmed by qualified applicants for police officer positions. And since the NPD was forced to accept anybody and everybody into their ranks, they became horribly corrupt. New Orleans police officers knew their jobs were secure and with an annual salary of less than eighteen thousand a year, which is thirty seven thousand in today's money, these officers were looking for side gigs, and some of them didn't much care whether or not these side gigs were legal. Now, thirty seven thousand may sound like an okay salary depending on where you live, but New Orleans has always been known for its staggeringly high cost of living. Today, New Orleans is forty four percent more expensive to live than the average US city. Because of all these contributing factors, the NPD became notorious for accepting cash in exchange for favors, committing crimes, and hurting civilians, all without facing any consequences. At first, the people of New Orleans were outraged by this illegal police activity. They filed complaint after complaint against the NOPD. The Justice Department reported that in the nineties, New Orleans sometimes led the country and police brutality complaints, But after a while, when nothing seemed to be changing, the people of New Orleans stopped speaking out against the police. Is often, why would you if nothing was going to change and now you would have a target on your back. It simply
17:57 wasn't worth it. The Mayor of New Orleans, Mark Moriel, who was elected the same year Kim was killed, said the New Orleans Police Department was the worst police department in the nation, Riddled with corruption, leading the nation in civil rights complaints, and populated by criminals and uniforms. It was a tremendous stain on the police department's history. Needless to say, the department didn't have any credibility within its community, especially not in its more affordable neighborhoods like the Fifth District, where most of the crime was happening. In nineteen ninety four, the Fifth District was where one third of all New Orleans homicides happened.
18:37 For the record, there are eight districts recognized by the NOPD, so one of them being home to one third of all murders. That's a big deal, a statistical anomaly. This is the location where you want your best and brightest officers, the cream of the crop. But of course the NPD wasn't equipped to assign the best and brightest anywhere. So in night teen eighty nine, the Fifth District is where the young officer Lynn Davis made a name for himself. Locals called Lynn the Desire Terrorist, and that's because he frequently patrolled a public housing complex called Desire, and as his nickname suggests, Lynn wasn't above using terror to get his way. Before Lynn ever became a police officer, he and Kim Groves actually knew each other. They had attended the same New Orleans High school sometime in the eighties. Lynne was a few years behind Kim, but Kim had interacted with him on several occasions enough times to know that she was not a fan. From the way Kim's daughter, Jasmine tells it, not many were a fan of Lynn Davis even as a teenager.
19:41 According to Jasmine, Kim thought he was weak, maybe even mean, and Lynn wasn't above picking on other kids. According to Jasmine, Kim once saw Lynne try to convince some other, probably younger boys, to put their heads under the tires of parked vehicles, and Kim, always a protector, always a mother, immediately put a stop to that bullshit. She told Lynne exactly what he should be doing instead of harassing other kids. Jasmine speculated in her interview with Rare Reports that perhaps Lynne liked be in a cop because of his friendless childhood experiences. For so long, he was probably the butt of a lot of jokes, maybe even bullied before he became a bully himself.
20:23 Now, as a police officer, Lynn had power. If someone acted in a way he didn't like, he could arrest them or worse. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Over time, Lynn Davis became one of the more corrupt inn OPD officers. His big thing was protecting drug dealers and traffickers in exchange for money. Through this operation, Lynn made friends with many seedy people in the dark underbelly of New Orleans, including a narcotics dealer and hitman and named Paul Hardy. His friends called him cool. When Lyne's colleague, officer Leon Duncan, realized he was getting closer to this guy, he was concerned. And it wasn't even like Leon was a squeaky clean officer. He just knew that Paul was a really, really bad guy.
21:17 In fact, according to Leon, Paul was the suspect in quite a few murder cases he had worked on. So when Leon saw Lynn take a call from Paul during a backyard cookout, he asked Lynne what was going on. Here's what Leon testified in court. Lynn Davis got on the phone and he told the individual on the phone, yeah, yeah, I'm home, just come on over. When I asked him who that was, thinking it was a policeman that he was inviting over since he was having a cookout, and Lynne said, oh, that's Paul. I said, Paul, Paul Hardy and he said yeah. And I said, what the fuck are you doing hanging out with a cold blooded killer like Paul Hardy? And he said, man, Paul Hardy, eate never killed nobody that didn't deserve to die.
22:03 I said, who the fuck are you or Paul Hardy to decide who lives or dies? And he made the statement, well, Dunk, you just don't understand the game. I said, fuck the game. We're talking about people's lives. And he said, see, that's your problem now. In addition to all this, Lynn also helped a group of law enforcement officers sell cocaine on the streets of New Orleans. Together, these police officers covered each other's tracks through violence, intimidation, and falsified evidence. All this is to say, if NPD police officers in the nineties were bad, Lynn Davis might have been the worst, But the universe had something waiting for Lynn, an act of karma that was going to help balance the scales of justice. Because one day Lynn tried to pressure a cocaine dealer into paying him for his protection services, and that cocaine dealer just so happened to be an FBI informant.
23:00 And when the FBI learned of Lynn's drug racket, they knew that he was only the tip of the iceberg. So the FBI orchestrated a complex sting operation to take down every corrupt officer in the New Orleans Police Department. It was called Operations Shattered Shield, and it began in December of nineteen ninety three. The FBI knew that Lynn Davis and his partner Sammy Williams were eager to make money through illegal drugs, so undercover FBI agents posed as a large scale cocaine operation and they hired Lynn and Sammy to assist their business. Lynn and Sammy helped safeguard drug shipments and stood watch at a warehouse filled to the brim with cocaine. After only a few months, Lynn and Sammy recruited seven other police officers to join them. The undercover FBI agents running the whole thing were stunned at how smoothly this entire process was going. They had enough evidence to charge Lynn pretty early on, but as long as Lynn kept bringing in more and more corrupt cops, the FBI was happy to let the operation continue. And these police officers were bowld too. Sometimes they would engage in a legal activity while on duty and in uniform, and no time at all. The FBI had plenty of recorded evidence they could use to put these officers away, But of course, operations Shattered Shield had some bumps. According to the then New Orleans FBI commander Neil Gallagher, one undercover FBI agent was almost outed in the
24:30 early stages. Somehow a rumor got around that one guy was an undercover FBI agent. A showdown occurred and this FBI agent had to strip naked to show everyone he wasn't wearing a wire, And luckily, that agent just happened to not being a wire at that specific time, And even more luckily, the entire ordeal was captured on videotape. But as far as extremely dangerous FBI missions go, this one was fairly smooth, and the FBI had a lot writing on it. A year into the sting, the FBI had employed the efforts of over sixty agents. They used more than one hundred and thirty kilos of real cocaine, and they paid about ninety seven thousand in cash to Lynn and his guise. The FBI needed their investments here to pay out, and they suspected that besides the nine NPD officers they already caught red handed, they could probably get two more with just a little time. In case you're counting, that's about thirty corrupt New Orleans Police officers. At this time, the entire NPD had about two hundred officers, so that means fifteen percent of the New Orleans Police Department could have gone down for corruption. But unfortunately they didn't, and that's because the FBI ran out of the one thing they needed. Time.
25:48 Now, let's return to October of nineteen ninety four. Kim Groves bravely made a complaint against both Lynn and his partner Sammy for police brutality. And this complaint should have been confidential, but at around one am on October twelfth, Lynn found out about it. One of his fellow officers called him and explained the situation in detail. Kim Groves, an acquaintance Lynn already didn't like, had had some bad things to say about Lynn's policing, and Lynn was outraged. He insisted Kim was lying that his partner Sammy, had pistol whipped the kid, not him. For the record, even if that's true, who cares. You can't just watch your police partner beat up a kid and not do anything. Right After learning of Kim's complaint against him, Lynne paged his good buddy, twenty seven year old Paul Hardy, and Paul called back.
26:40 The two men discussed and vague terminology their plan to kill Kim Groves. Paul was to shoot her, then Lynn and his partner Sammy would falsify evidence at the crime scene to cover Paul's tracks. Lynn and Sammy drove Paul to Kim's neighborhood and their police car. The three men tried to track her down, but couldn't find her. At about seven thirty pm, Paul got out of the car to walk around the neighborhood, but Kim was nowhere to be found. Lynne was frustrated. He wanted to take care of Kim now. Lynn and Sammy drove Paul home. They were to call Paul. Once they found Kim, Lynn and Sammy went back to the Fifth District where Kim lived and continued searching. Lynn became angrier and angrier as the evening went on, and Kim remained alive. At about ten p m. Lynn and Sammy found her. She was near her home on the thirteen hundred block of Alaba Street.
27:32 Lynne paged Paul and Paul called back. Then. Lynne described Kim's appearance to Paul, and Paul said that he was on his way. At this time, Sammy shift had ended, so he went home, leaving Lynde to stew in his own negativity. Forty five minutes later, Lynne was upset because Paul hadn't shown up, so Lynne called Paul again and described Kim again in excruciating detail, down to her light brown eyes. And after this call, Paul finally arrived, but he wasn't alone. Two men were with him. One was twenty four year old Damon Cauzey. Damon was in charge of getting rid of the murder weapon, and the second man was Steve Jackson. He was the getaway driver. At eleven PM on October thirteenth, Paul found Kim around the corner from her home and killed her with a single shot to the head. He fled the scene with Damon and Steve. Then he called Lynne.
28:26 Paul laughed as he confirmed that Kim was dead, and Lynn audibly celebrated, cheering at the death of the highly beloved and irreplaceable Kim. Marie Groves and the FBI, well, they heard all of this, every single word exchanged between Lynn and Paul leading up to and after Kim's murder. So I know your first question, and it's a good one. How did they know all of this? Well, Lynn's cell phone was wire tapped by the FBI. In fact, Lynne had actually gotten the cell phone from the FBI. He told his new cocaine business associates, you know, the ones that were undercover FBI agents, that he needed a cell phone to help conduct their business, and the undercover FBI agents posing as cocaine traffickers were happy to give lenn a new cell phone with a few modifications so they could record his every move.
29:18 Now you probably have a second question. I know that Kim's family definitely did, and that was if the FBI was listening to all of Lyne's phone calls and heard him and Paul colluding to assassinate Kim, why didn't they stop it? According to the FBI, their agents didn't know what to make of Lyne's strange phone conversations with Paul near the time of Kim's murder. They attributed the misunderstanding to lennon Paul's vague coded language about Kim. Keep in mind, lenn and Paul weren't speaking this way because they thought Lynne's phone was bugged, because they had no idea about that. They were using coded language, probably because they didn't want eavesdroppers to get any ideas, or at least that's how the FBI spun this part of the story. In court, the contents of these phone call recordings would be revealed, and as it turns out, Lynn and Paul weren't speaking and hardly any code at all. Lynn can be heard telling an unknown person, I can get p to come and do that horn now, and then we can handle the thirty. In this context, thirty is police code for homicide, as in, my partner Sammy and I will clean up the homicide crime scene. And Lynn also told Paul come do that horn now and later after it's done, goes straight uptown and call me.
30:34 Many people have criticized the FBI for not stopping the murder of Kim Groves, and they may be right. It wouldn't be the first time the FBI has been accused of letting someone they deem unnecessary die in order to further their larger mission. But the FBI publicly maintained that they did not know Kim was going to be shot. Gallagher, the leader of operations Shattered Shield, was reported by The Times Pickyune to have said, Unfortunately, we were not provided with enough information to allow us to prevent it. The pertinent conversations were spread out over a ten hour period and were intermingled with many other discussions concerning their protection activity at the warehouse. The conversations simply did not alert us to what would occur. They were cryptic and they did not take on significance until compared with other events. But once it became clear to the FBI that Lynn had masterminded the murder of Kim Groves, they still didn't act. It wasn't until Lynn started planning violence against even more people still using his bugged cell phone, that the FBI decided to pull the plug on operations shattered shield so as I said before. In November, one month after Kim's murder, the FBI rated Damon Causey's home. There they found the murder weapon used to kill Kim, and a month after that, on December fifth, Lynn, Davis, Paul Hardy, and Damon Causey were arrested. All three were charged with one conspira he to injure a press, threaten, and intimidate Kim Groves and another individual in
32:04 the right to be free from use of unreasonable force. We're not sure who that other individual is, and two violating Kim Grove's civil rights, and three killing Kim Groves with the intent to prevent her from communicating information to a federal law enforcement officer relating to the commission of a federal offense. They faced life in prison with a possibility of a death sentence. Two days later, on December seventh, Lynn and eight additional officers in the NPD were arrested. They faced charges of conspiracy to distribute cocaine and use of firearms while drug trafficking among those eight, whereas a sergeant and Lynn's own partner, Sammy Williams. All nine officers faced life in prison, but it was public knowledge that even more New Orleans officers probably would have been arrested had the FBI been able to continue their investigation. In fact, twelve officers had been placed on desk duty while awaiting the results of the FBI operation. Three of those officers walked free.
33:05 Attorney Frank Disavo, a representative of the Police Association of New Orleans, set on Wednesday, December seventh, I just left three happy officers who didn't get indicted. Maybe there wasn't enough evidence, or maybe they didn't do anything. While Kim Groves's murder hadn't made hardly any newspapers only a few months before, now it was the talk of the town. Actually, this entire debacle was a huge scandal for New Orleans. Headline's focused on innopd's widespread corruption, on how officer Lyne Davis hired a trigger man to kill an unsuspecting mother, on the FBI's somewhat successful steeing operation, and of course, on the remaining unknown police officers who were a single hair's breadth away from being arrested by the FBI.
33:49 If community feelings towards the NPD were bad before, now they were abysmal. New Orleans residence had no way of knowing if the police offer who was supposed to be helping them was only one lucky take away from being indicted for corruption. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. The operations shattered shill scandal was so big it shaped the New Orleans political landscape. The city mayor at the time, Mark Morial said Lynn Davis was quote one of the worst examples of what the department had come to. Morial asserted that he would not tolerate cavalier cops by saying, we're on a crusade. We're going to be in a holy war. We're going to clean this department up.
34:34 And on the same exact day that Kim Groves was murdered, the New Orleans Police Department was swearing in their new leader, Superintendent Richard Pennington, and Pennington famously learned of Kim's death, Lynn's corruption, and the secret FBI steeing operation only a few days into his new job. Pennington had come to the NPD knowing corruption was an issue that was part of the reason he got the job, but he probably never imagined just how far the weeds of corruption had grown in the NPD. There's even some suggestion that the previous superintendent was in on it. After all, the FBI hadn't told him about operations Shattered Shield. As prosecutors Constantine George's and Mike McMahon prepared for the trial against Lynn, Davis, Paul Hardy, and Damon Causey, they decided to seek the death penalty for Lynn and Paul, not Damon, and on April eighth of nineteen ninety six, two years after Kim's murder, the trial began. Lynn, Paul, and Damon were co defendants. Steve Jackson, the getaway driver, testified for the prosecution, so if he faced any charges, which he might not have, it wasn't during this specific trial. Throughout the course of the trial, the state painted Lynn as the mastermind behind Kim's murder. He wanted Kim dead because she had fought a complaint against him with the NPD's Internal Affairs office, and this argument didn't take much convincing as Lynne was the mastermind. The many many hours of recorded phone calls proved it. Honestly, the phone calls
36:07 kind of made this case open and shut. There really was no question as to who had done what or why. But the States still covered all their bases. Lynn's partner, Sammy Williams, testified for the prosecution. Sammy played guilty to those conspiracy and drug trafficking charges and was cooperating to get a lighter sentence. So In his testimony, Sammy corroborated the phone calls recorded by the FBI, and Sammy also explained that Lynn gave Paul three hundred dollars as a token of appreciation for the murder of Kim Groves. During closing arguments, prosecutor McMahon said life in prison is too good for Lynn Davis. He deserves to die for what he did, and Prosecutor Georges agreed, calling attention to the fact that Lynn had never expressed any remorse for his crimes. Georges asked the jury, what more does someone have to do to deserve the highest penalty the law provides. The only defense presented was that Kim's boyfriend was the killer because of the two eyewitnesses who said the assailant who shot Kim looked similar to Kim's boyfriend. Lynn did not testify. On Wednesday, April twenty fourth, nineteen ninety six, after two days of deliberations, the jury found thirty one year old Lynn Davis and twenty eight year old Paul Hardy were guilty of all three charges. Twenty five year old Damon Causey was found guilty of two. The jury couldn't decide if Damon was guilty of actually killing Kim, which was the third charge, so that ended in a mistrial. Upon hearing his guilty verdict,
37:39 Lynne visibly sagged in his chair. He was sentenced to death. Next was Paul. He also received the death penalty, but after years of legal footwork, he was determined to be intellectually disabled, meaning he wasn't eligible for the death penalty. But many people, including some of Kim's family and experts on IQ test, believed that Paul was not intellectually disabled, rather he had faked poor test scores to get out of the death penalty. Regardless, Paul won that legal fight, and although he's not facing the lethal injection, he will spend the rest of his life in prison. Damon was sentenced to life in prison. At this sentencing, his family became extraordinarily upset. Apparently, Damon had rejected a deal from the federal government just hours before his guilty verdict was announced. In that deal, Damon would have played guilty to accessory to murder and he only would have served a maximum of nine years in prison.
38:35 But according to Damon's lawyer, Damon had rejected the deal out of loyal to his friend Paul. By accepting a deal, Damon worried he would make Paul look guilty. And I mean Paul was guilty. But those are just the details. I suppose. All three convicted criminals, Len, Paul, and Damon have appealed multiple times. One time, Lenn even represented himself in the appeal. It went as poorly as you can imagine. When Lynn became upset at the way the court proceedings were going, he just stopped showing up to court at all. Ultimately, they're all still in prison. Paul and Damon are incarcerated in a federal facility in Paula, Louisiana, and fifty eight year old Lynn Davis sen the terahte Us Penitentiary in Indiana. He avoided the death penalty through his repeated appeals years ago. Kim's family actually wrote a letter to the George W. Bush administration asking that Lynn's sentence be reduced from the death penalty to life in prison. According to the letter, Kim's family was sick of coming back to court and reliving their trauma for every one of Lynde's appeals.
39:37 It was exhausting. But nothing ever came from that letter. Technically, Lynn is still on death row, but he has some court proceedings in the works right now. Lynn's corruption during his seven years as a New Orleans police officer negatively impacted the lives of many many people, perhaps thousands people were wrongly incarcerated and even murder as a result of Lyne's decisions. The City of New Orleans had to go back through each case that Lynn was even remotely involved in and try to determine if he screwed the whole thing up, or at least the City of New Orleans should be doing that. They've received heavy criticism for how long that process has taken them. For example, it wasn't until twenty twenty two that New Orleans released three wrongfully incarcerated men from prison. The men, Bernald Juluke, Kunta Gable and Leroy Nelson, were arrested and charged after Lynn accused them of murdering nineteen year old Rondelle Santiac. This happened in August of nineteen ninety four, two months before Lynn ordered the death of Kim Groves.
40:40 As it turns out, Rondelle's case might have been a first rone of Lynn's assassination process, maybe even the same one that Kim endured. It's likely that Lynn ordered the head against Rondelle himself. He was concerned that Rondelle's family was coming after his drug business, and so Lynn orchestrator Rondel's death and France eighteen year old Burnell, seventeen year old Kunta, and seventeen year old Leroy for it. These three men spent twenty eight years in Louisiana's harshest state penitentiary, known as Angola Prison. They walked in teenagers and left grown men. Their lives were irreparably damaged for a crime that none of them had committed. Upon his release, Kunta Gabel told the court that he had never even seen the man he was supposed to have killed. If you're a true crima fictionado, you know that Lynn could not have successfully operated the way he did all alone for so many years. The legal system is built with safeguards. If the cops are dirty, good lawyers can figure it out and if the lawyers are dirty, then maybe a judge will catch it, and if not, the judge will Hopefully the district attorney's moral compass can help guide everyone toward morality.
41:47 Recently, The Times, picking a newspaper, approached Julian Parker, the prosecuting lawyer for Rondelle's case. Reporters asked Julian about the business of wrongfully convicting three teens on almost zero evidence, but Julian said he couldn't remember a single detail about the case. That was a thousand cases ago, he reasoned. Following this questionable case in nineteen ninety four, Julian became a chief judge for the district Court. He retired in twenty fourteen, and the district attorney from nineteen seventy three to two thousand three, Harry Connick Senior, never seemed to catch on to Lyne Davis or anyone else's corruption within the New Orleans Police department.
42:29 It's crazy how that happens. I guess, just pure chance happenstance, if you will. Perhaps it was best said by Peter Sharf, a criminologist at Louisiana State University, quote, the Lynn Davis case needs to be understood among systemic corruption. This was an era, not an individual. Today, the City of New Orleans appears to be working on solving their police corruption problem. Former Superintendent Richard Pittington was widely lauded for his work in eradicating corruption from the NPD before he stepped down in two thousand and two, and more recently, from twenty thirteen to twenty eighteen, New Orleans spent more than fifty million dollars on reforms intended to eradicate police corruption. Sure, these reforms were ordered by a federal institution, but we'll take what we can get. When the reforms were signed at City Hall in two thousand ten, Kim Groves's daughter, Jasmine attended the event. Since the tragic death of her mother, Jasmine and other members of Kim's family have been active advocates for justice. In April twenty fifteen, over twenty years after Kim was murdered, the City of New Orleans finally agreed to pay Kim's three children one point five million in a lawsuit settlement, and today Jasmine is the president of an organization entitled Family's Overcoming Injustice.
43:54 It's a group for loved ones who've had a loss at the hands of the NOPD. You can find and support them on Facebook. Each year, Jasmine holds an event on her own birthday, October fourteenth, to memorialize her mother and other victims of civil rights abuses. In twenty fourteen, Jasmine wrote a poem for this gathering. It was entitled Dear Mamma. Here's an excerpt. I remember as a child being so happy and safe seeing the police because the car said to protect and serve. It was nine to one one. I called to help and save you, Yet they know it was their own kind killed you. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly.
44:38 Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank, with additional writing by myself, and of course, all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Coley Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon shack Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. The research tab on Southern Friedtrucrime dot com is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Friedtrucrime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton and share means. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discussed truecrime, not just Southern Fried, but all cons but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shutous is allowed.
45:39 It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like a Heart, Spotify, Amazon, Audible and YouTube. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care. Four
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed