190: The Murder of Liz Sennett
In the spring of 1988, Liz and Charles Sennett were pillars of the Colbert County, Alabama, community. 45-year-old Liz was a mother, grandmother, and homemaker. Charles was a local pastor. They were beloved and respected. On March 18th, Charles...
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional Writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Sources: southernfriedtruecrime.com/liz-sennett
Sponsors for this episode:
- Today’s episode is brought to you from The Vanished. The Vanished covers unsolved missing persons cases that have been overlooked or forgotten by the mainstream media. Listen early and ad-free on Wondery Plus.
- Today’s show is sponsored by Newspapers.com - my biggest resource for the show. Use the code "SOUTHERNFRIED” at checkout to get 20% off a Publisher Extra Subscription!
- Play a murder mystery game for the internet age with Who Killed Mia? Use promo code SFTC for 20% off at Relatable.com/whokilledmia. Citizen detectives, it’s your time to shine!
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:13 Southern for a true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used listener discretion as advised. You hear the phrase happy wife, happy life a lot. It seems to put the onus on the woman to keep the marriage and calm waters, but that's not always how it's meant. Sometimes it just means that the wife is the rock of the family. She keeps everyone centered. Liz Sinnate was very much the rock of her family. Her husband, Charles, was a preacher and the center of their church, but together they were the center of their community, and Liz was very much the heart of her family. As one of her sons put it, it's not easy being a preacher's wife, but she performed the role with the same grace and love that she did being a wife and mother. When she was murdered, naturally, Charles was the first suspect.
1:18 The husband always is, But Charles had a solid alibi. Who would want to hurt this lovely and loving woman. Liz Senate had no enemies. The brutality shook their small Alabama town and especially congregance of their church, and the truth would destroy the Senate Family. Welcome to Episode one ninety the Murder of Liz Senate. In the nineteen eighties, Ronnie May was an investigator with the Colbert County Sheriff's Department in Alabama, and he wasn't new to this job.
1:59 Far from it. He had started his law enforcement career over a decade earlier, in nineteen seventy three, and he enjoyed the work because Ronnie would continue to be an officer of the law for over forty years, only retiring in twenty fifteen. But back in the eighties, Ronnie wasn't anywhere near retiring. On March eighteenth of nineteen eighty eight, it was a cool spring day. The high was in the forties. The rolling hills of Culbert County were bright green with new life. The breeze was light and airy. It was the perfect kind of day for a morning coffee and a big breath of fresh air. As Ronnie opened the door to the Sheriff's department that morning, he might have thought the same, but not for long. At eleven forty four am that day, a local pastor, forty five year old Charles Sennett, called the Culbert County Sheriff's department and a secretary answered, but the preacher, Charles, was unintelligible, screaming. The secretary couldn't make out what he was trying to say, and at that point the call was transferred to Officer Ronnie May. Ronnie waited for Charles to gather himself. Only then could Charles explain to Ronnie what had happened, and it was horrible. Charles's wife, forty five year old Elizabeth Liz dor Len's Senate, was dead. Charles didn't know how, he didn't know who, but his and Lizz's home had been ransacked,
3:30 and Liz was covered in blood lying on the floor of their den. Years later, Ronnie May told al dot com all we knew was a pastor's wife had been killed and what had been a home invasion. Ronnie rushed to the senate home near Tuscumbia, Alabama, along with other first responders. When they arrived, Liz still had a pulse, but it was faint. In the hopes that she would wake up and say something anything about her killer's identity, Ronnie rode with her in the ambulance to the hospital, but Lizza's eyes never opened. She died in surgery two hours later. Thus, the investigation into her murder began, and some time later, after the dust had settled and the case was solved, Ronnie realized something strange. He had seen Lizza's killer before, and it was only a few weeks before her murder. Ronnie had been at a gas station in Cherokee, an Alabama town about fifteen miles away from the senate's home. This too had been a crime scene. The owner of the gas station had been shot and killed. Ronnie and other officers were investigating the gas station when he noticed a strange man following him around.
4:46 The man appeared to be part of the rescue squad, according to Ronnie, but the man was in the way. He asked him to leave multiple times, but for whatever reason, the man kept returning. Ronnie would speculate that this man was trying to understand how law enforcement investigated a crime scene. He was doing reconnaissance, but at the time there was no way for officer Ronnie made to know that. So when the man left, Ronnie led him and he didn't think much of it. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Elizabeth Dorlen Thorne was born on December tenth, nineteen forty two to parents Howard and Dosha in Franklin County, Alabama. Throughout her life, her friends and family referred to her as Liz, so that's what we'll call her too. Growing up, Liz was the oldest of her two brothers and one sister, and of the four Thorn children. Liz was especially soft spoken.
5:53 She was a quiet young woman with a typical type a personality. Liz liked things to be neat and organized. She was a person who had a place for everything, and everything was always in its place. Liz also enjoyed being a particularly feminine woman. Her family would later describe her as a girly girl. The Thorn family was born and bred in Alabama for generations, and I'm not just saying that. Lizz's parents, her parents parents, and their parents parents were all born in the northwest corner of Alabama. Liz two, of course, but her family moved to Ohio sometime between nineteen forty eight and nineteen sixty one, during the time Lizz's father spent in the military. The family moved to a home near Cleveland when Liz was in her teens, and there she met a young man named Charles. Charles Edwards Sennett was born on October twenty third, nineteen forty two, and hen Lawson, West Virginia, to parents Ed and Beava. Ed was a preacher and Liz and Charles had a great deal in common. They both lived in Ohio, but were Southerners at heart. They were both the same age, and they were both Christian folk, and so were their families. But most importantly, the young couple fell deeply in love with each other. So on June second, nineteen sixty two, twenty year old Liz and twenty year old Charles were married in Ohio, and literally nine months exactly after their wedding date, on February third,
7:26 nineteen sixty three, Liz and Charles welcomed their first child into the world, a baby boy named Charles Junior. They called him Chuck, and two years after that, in May of nineteen sixty five, Liz and Charles had yet another baby boy. His name was Michael and he would go by Mike. Chuck and Mike remember their parents' relationship as idyllic. In an interview with American Monster, Chuck said, Dad love and adored mother. She was the best thing that ever happened to him, and Mike affirmed, saying everyone thought of them as the perfect couple. Liz and Charles weren't just picture perfect spouses, they were good parents too. According to Mike, Liz was like a big mama hen, keeping everybody in check. It was clear that she cared about her sons and she wasn't afraid to show it. She went above and beyond to make sure both Chuck and Mike knew that she loved them through joyful birthday parties, meaningful Christmas gifts, and a ton of special family traditions. Chuck explained that their family was always rich in faith and health. We had what we needed and some of what we wanted, and Charles did his part too.
8:41 Chuck explained that his father was always a hard worker and a great provider, but more than that, he remembered his dad as an all around nice guy. When baby Mike was born, Charles and Liz were about twenty three years old. Around this time, Charles worked at a Seers department store in Ohio, but that wasn't what he wanted to do. He wanted to be a preacher. Remember, Charles's father had been a preacher, and Charles knew that it was his life's calling to follow in his father's footsteps. This probably didn't surprise anyone who knew Charles. After all, he was an excellent speaker and a strong leader. Chuck told American Monster, a preacher has to know what they're talking about. People have to believe in what they're saying, and that came natural to him. But in order to fulfill his dream of sharing God's word, Charles felt he couldn't stay in Ohio. So the young senate family left behind one life and began another, this time in Nashville, Tennessee.
9:43 Mike recalled that this big move felt like a leap of faith, but in the end it appeared to be worth it. In Nashville, Charles began attending evening classes for up and coming preachers under the Church of Christ, and three years later he graduated. He and Liz were about twenty six years old. Almost immediately he was offered a full time position at the Hatton Church of Christ and Hatton, Alabama. I'm sure Charles and Liz were both relieved and excited by this news. For one, a job as a job, there's nothing like financial security, but for two, Liz's parents now lived in Alabama, I'm sure it was nice to be closer to them and their extended families.
10:26 And Charles thrived in Alabama. Before he arrived at the Hatton Church of Christ, it was a small church community. The tiny town of Hatton only has about sixty people in it today. While there isn't data available on what Hatton's population was at this time, we know that it hasn't had over two hundred people in it for over ten years. But after Charles became the pastor, people flocked from miles away to hear him speak. According to Chuck, they had to build a bigger church, one that could hold up to three or four hundred people. Needless to say, Charles was doing very well as a pastor, and both Liz and Charles became central pillars of the Hatton community.
11:09 Mike told American Monster, whether it be the elderly ladies of the church, the Boy Scouts, cub Scouts, teaching graduation, ged classes, you name it, they were involved in the community and everybody knew them, and church was central to the Senate family. Liz and the two boys always attended Charles's services. Chuck recalled that Sunday morning, you knew where you were going Sunday's probably felt like a weekly celebration for the Senates because after Charles led the Sunday service, he and Liz would invite guests over. They hosted parties, dinners, and other events, and actual holidays like Christmases and birthdays were happy times in the Senate House too. American Monster showed some old home movies from one Christmas as Chuck explained that both sets of grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins all came together. Chuck and Mike remember these gatherings fondly. In fact, they remember most of their childhood fondly. Mike said, you couldn't ask for better times. And, believe it or not, Charles wasn't just known as a powerful preacher, a welcoming host, and a beloved father, He was also known for his golden singing voice. Mike said he had a deep voice. He could sing deeper than he could talk. In Charles's childhood, his family sang regularly. At one point, they even formed a singing quartet. Charles loved singing in this quartet with his family. Throughout his adult
12:41 life, Charles was always in one a cappella group or another. On top of preaching, and singing. Charles also started his own side venture. He sold burial vaults. These are the outer containers that hold a casket. Most cemeteries require them. Said that man is pretty high and that made Charles's business pretty successful. Plus it was another way for him to provide for his wife and sons. But between his full time job as a preacher, his hobbies, and his side business, Charles was overwhelmed. In nineteen seventy six, thirty four year old Charles was really starting to feel the pressure. Mike said, I could tell there was a tiredness to him. One night, Liz called Charles at his burial vault business, but he didn't pick up. She called again and again, but still no Charles. Concerned, Liz went to the business to check on him, and she found him in the midst of a nervous breakdown. Fortunately, Charles was able to get the medical attention he needed. His doctors diagnosed him with depression and prescribed him lithium, But unfortunately, his doctors also recommended that he give up preaching for good. At this Charles was heartbroken. Mike recalled, it was like he was empty, an empty, broken down man, and Mom had to step in and be the rock, and she did a very good job of it. In light of Charles's mental health struggles, he quit his job as a pastor and Liz became
14:16 a secretary. She had to pay the bills, but after about two years, Charles was feeling up to preaching again, and in nineteen seventy eight he returned to the pulpit and he traveled some. In nineteen seventy eight, Montgomery Advertiser reported that Charles officiated about one wedding or funeral a month at the East Tulassee Church of Christ, which is over two hundred and forty miles away from Hatton and Colbert County, where Liz and Charles lived. Like many who battle mental health issues, Charles wasn't fully cured during his time off from preaching. It just doesn't work that way. And several years later, around nineteen eighty three, Charles's psychologist wrote a letter to a neurosurgeon. In that letter, the psychologists discussed Charles's irregular mood swings, how he could go from exhilarated to depressed and no time at all. It's unclear what became of this letter.
15:15 Perhaps Charles was looking for some sort of surgery to help with his emotional balances. The court documents that mentioned the letter didn't say meanwhile, Charles and Lizz's little boys were growing up. Until Lizz's delight, they were starting to have children of their own, and Liz, more than almost anything else, loved being a grandmother. Chuck said his parents were giddy when their first grandchild was born, especially Mamma. He added, when you hear grandmother, you probably picture a little old ladies with gray hair. But in nineteen eighty eight, Charles and Liz were both forty five years old. They had been young parents, and now they were young grandparents. They lived on Coon Dogs Cemetery Road in Culbert County, near Tuscumbia, Alabama. At this time, Charles was one of the pastors at the local Church of Christ in Sheffield, Alabama, about ten minutes from small town Tuscumbia, a beautiful little city with less than ten thousand residents at the time. On the morning of Friday, March eighteenth, Charles left his home at about seven thirty in the morning to do some work at the church. He grabbed some fast food before and visited some Sheffield area residence after. Then, around eleven thirty am, he headed home, and by eleven forty four am, Charles called the Colbert County Sheriff's Department and spoke to investigator Ronnie May. As I mentioned earlier, a very upset Charles explained to Ronnie that he had arrived home to find Liz dead. She was
16:48 partially wrapped in an Afghan rug and had been badly beaten and stabbed, and Charles said he believed the murder weapon to be a fireplace implement. Shortly after his emergency responders came to help Liz. She was actually still alive, but barely breathing. They transported her to the Helen Keller Memorial Hospital in Sheffield, but two hours later Liz passed away during surgery. Later medical experts would determine that in addition to being brutally beaten, Liz had suffered ten stab wounds ate to her chest and one to either side of her neck. She also had defensive wounds as well as slashes across her head. Investigator Ronnie May later said she fought it, and she fought hard. By several eyewitness accounts, Lizz's body was badly mangled following this attack. I won't go into too much detail.
17:45 But in almost every appeals document I read, one lawyer or another argued that the photos of Lizz's body shouldn't have been allowed in court. That's how gruesome they were. Forty five year old Elizabeth Dorlen Senate was buried in the Dempsey Cemetery in Red Bay, Franklin County, Alabama. She is buried in the same cemetery as her parents, Dosha and Howard Thorne. Lizza's mother had passed away seven years earlier, in nineteen eighty one. She'd only been fifty nine years old. Howard outlived them, both, dying at the age of eighty seven and two thousand and nine. In the wake of his mother's death, Mike Senate told the Montgomery Advertiser that he regretted she didn't have more time to spoil her grandchildren right away, the authorities suspected that Lizza's murder was the result of a burglary gone wrong, but as they inspected the crime scene more closely, the detectives started to realize things weren't adding up. Officer Buddy Aldridge told the Birmingham Post Harold it just looked strange from the very beginning. No one had seen Lizza's killer. After all, Liz and Charles lived in a rural area. The nearest neighbor was at work when the attack happened, so all the detectives had was the crime scene, and they meticulously cataloged it for several days. That's how they determined that the crime scene had been staged.
19:15 I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. It's hard to imagine losing a loved one, a wife, a husband, a child. For many of us, it's our biggest fear. I want to tell you about a podcast from Wondery called The Vanished. The Vanished covers unsolved missing persons cases that have been overlooked or forgotten by the mainstream media. Every week, host Marissa Jones dives into a new case, sharing the details of their mysterious disappearance from interviews with family, friends, law enforcement, and even suspects in an effort to reveal the truth. The Vanished has even aided in getting long overdue arrests. Through their in depth interviews, Marissa reminds listeners of the human behind the headline and aims to help family members find their vanished loved one or at least a sense of peace. Enjoy The Vanished on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to The Vanished early and add free on Wondery Plus, Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Today's episode is sponsored by newspapers dot Com, the largest online newspaper archive and your ultimate resource for untangling secrets of the past and Southern Fried listeners, I'm here to tell you the show would not be possible without newspapers dot Com. I've used this online resource since the beginning and would be lost without it. You can delve into more than eight hundred million pages of digitized
20:47 newspapers and uncover overlooked details and forgotten stories. Newspapers dot Com has a vast collection of papers spanning three centuries. Explore pulse pounding news reports, eyewitness accounts, and crime scene photos from the US and beyond. Travel through time with newspapers dot Com and get a front row seat to history. For listeners of today's show, newspapers dot com is offering twenty person off a publisher extra subscription. Just use the codes Southern Fried at checkout. Unleash your inner detective with Newspapers dot Com Today. If you love nothing more than a juicy mystery or an unsolved case, you will love Relatable's newest game, Who Killed Mia?
21:30 Who Killed Mia? Is a murder mystery story for the Internet age centered around the fictional but incredibly realistic influencer Mia Starr and her untimely death at the Replay Awards. Players work to solve the case using a mix of physical and immersive digital evidence like hacking into MIA's phone, as well as gripping live action videos to uncover the killer. This sensational game is available on the Relatable website as well as Target, Walmart, and Amazon. My family and I love to play murder mystery games together. My grown kids about snatched that box away from me before I could open it. It was really cool opening all the evidence and then following along on our phones with it eliminating suspects, calling all crime junkies. Who Killed Mia is for all my game lovers and detectives. Get this game for your next game night and find out who killed the world's favorite influencer and who killed Mia. A new kind of murder mystery game from Relatable, The creators of the hit game what do you mean and get twenty percent off with promo code SFTC at relatable dot com slash who killed Mia. Citizen detectives, it's your time to shine. That's relatable dot com slash who killed Mia promo code SFTC for twenty percent off. As the authorities investigated the crime scene where list Senate was killed, they realized that this couldn't have been a burglary gone wrong. Hardly anything was missing from the senate house, just a stereo and a VCR. Numerous valuable items were left behind, and hundreds of
23:03 dollars and Lizz's purse remained untouched. Plus, there was no sign of forced entry, which meant Liz might have let the killer inside her house willingly, as if she knew them or was at least comfortable enough to open the door for them. Now, authorities were even more suspicious. During their investigation, One officer saw something odd floating in the pond located about fifty yards from Charles and Lizz's house. It was a broken piece of a walking cane. Another portion of that same cane was found in the Senate's den near Lizz's body. Authorities quickly deduced that the cane had been one of the many items used to brutally beat Liz, so they drained the pond to see if more weapons were there, and there were, According to the Birmingham Post, Harold law enforcement agents discovered more pieces of the walking cane, a fire poker, and a black handled hunting knife. Back inside the sentence home, investigating officials also found several hairstrands near Lizz's body. These hair strands were discovered in two places, the rug that had been draped across Lizz's body and a baseball capp the attacker had presumably left behind. Today, hair strands are a great find at a crime scene. It's DNA evidence right well, as long as you find one with a hair follicle. Even without the follicle, it can be powerful circumstantial
24:33 evidence. But back in nineteen eighty eight, the technology to compare DNA and forensic science had only just been invented. It wouldn't be mainstream until the nineties, and even then there would be a long wait before databases like cotis what help solve cases consistently. Still, the labs could easily conclude that these hairs did not belong to Liz, and they didn't belong to Charles either. There were also fibers found on the hunting knife that appeared to match the rug on Lizz's body. Now, detectives were at an impasse. They had the murder weapons, but no murderer, and they had zero suspects, so they couldn't compare these mysterious hair strands to anyone else's hair. Not to mention, Charles's tom was easily accounted for during the time Liz was killed, so he couldn't have done it, and most of the people Liz knew had strong alibis too.
25:30 Investigators were baffled. Who could have killed Liz senate who would have wanted to? She didn't have any enemies, She was an active member of the community, a caring mother and grandmother, the pastor's wife, and whoever had murdered Liz did it for almost nothing. They didn't even take the remote that went with a VCR. The Alabama Bureau of Investigation became involved in Liz's case early on, but still days passed with no new leads. The people of Sheffield, Tuscumbia, and other surrounding Culbert County cities were terrified a killer was on the loose, and it probably felt like if Liz's Senate could be killed, then no one was safe. But by a stroke of sheer luck, the Culbert County Sheriff's Department received a lead. A member of Charles's congregation contacted the authorities. They had somehow come across a Valentine's Day card that was addressed to Charles, but it wasn't from Liz. It was from a different woman.
26:36 This woman was a member of Charles's church too, and was also a close friend of the Senate family. Immediately, the investigators brought the woman in for questioning, and she confirmed what the Valentine's Day card had implied. According to author Tim Kent, who wrote Murder from the Pulpit, the woman lawyered up, presumably after confirming the affair and admitting that Charles had borrowed money from her. Detectives could also have gotten a warrant for bank records, though, But now they knew for sure that Charles was cheating on Liz with this woman. Detective Ronnie May could now view his interactions with Charles on the day of Liz's murder in a different light. He could see clearly how Charles had seemed especially shocked when they realized that Liz still had a heartbeat. According to May, Charles almost fell at the news. In total, the authorities brought Charles in for questioning three times. The first two times he denied any involvement in his wife's death, but according to the authorities, Charles's story kept changing.
27:42 But that's pretty typical. It's hard to remember specific details at specific times. I'm not sure the deputies or sheriffs really thought Charles was involved until this third questioning, because this time when the officers spoke to Charles, they weren't messing around. They told Charles they knew about his affair, and they knew that he had borrowed three thousand dollars from his girlfriend in the weeks leading up to Liza's death. Charles agreed, yes he had an affair, and yes he had borrowed that money, but he wouldn't tell the officers what he had spent it on, and he denied that he had been involved in Lizza's murder.
28:22 But the detectives were not having it. By the end of it, they told Charles that he was a suspect, and they arranged for him to undergo a polygraph test the following week. Still, Charles was adamant that he didn't do it, He didn't kill his wife. But as he stood up to leave, one of the interrogating officers made one final comment. The officer said something along the lines of I wonder if Charles knows Kenney Smith, and according to officer Ronnie May, Charles's face turned beat red. Kenny Smith, who will get too momentarily, was known as a bad actor in the Colbert Howny area, and Kenny wasn't above taking money in exchange for murder. It was Friday, March twenty fifth, nineteen eighty eight that Charles spoke with the authorities for the third and final time. He didn't take the news well that he was now a suspect. Afterwards, he got in his pickup truck and drove to a family member's house. There, his sons, Chuck and Mike, and their families were gathered. After Charles arrived, he told his two sons that he had cheated on their mother with this woman from the church. Right away, Chuck and Mike were met with a whirlwind of feelings. Mike told American Monster, I'm mad. My emotions were running You just lost your wife and now you're having an affair. You're a preacher, man of the cloth.
29:48 You're not supposed to be doing that. But Charles wasn't done yet. He had more to tell his two sons. He told them that he was to blame for their mother's death, and he walked out of the house. He climbed into the front seat of his truck and picked up his twenty two caliber gun and shot himself in the head. Chuck and Mike heard the blast, and then they watched as their father closed his eyes for the very last time, only one week after they lost their mother. Later, the authorities found a note in Charles's pocket. While the contents of this note have not been released verbatim, Officer Buddy Aldridge told reporters that the note indicated the following that Charles had never hurt his wife and that he had gotten in with some bad guys and he did not want to cause the family any more embarrassment.
30:42 Just like after Liz's death, Officer Ronnie May was one of the first people to arrive at the scene of Charles's death, and also just like with Liz, Ronnie rode with Charles and the ambulance on the way to the Helen Keller Memorial Hospital. Again, he was hoping that Charles would say something that in Charles's final words, he might explain when he meant when he said he was to blame for Liz's murder. But he didn't say anything, and the doctors at the hospital declared Charles dead at six forty pm. Liz Sennett's murder case was already high profile in this area of Alabama. A pastor's wife being horribly bludgent and stabbed at death was scandalous enough on its own, but after Charles's suicide, this case's publicity shot into the stratosphere. There was a sense of disbelief, like this was all a TV show, not real life, and the two hundred members of Charles's congregation were devastated. They had known Charles, they had known Liz. How could any of this have happened. Charles's associate pastor, Cherald Sockwell, told the Alabama Journal that the whole situation has got us all torn up. But even though it seemed like Charles's suicide meant that he was involved in Lizza's murder, it still wasn't clear who had actually killed Liz. Charles couldn't have. He was with other people at different locations, and of course, someone else's hair strands were found at the crime scene.
32:15 So, due in part to the massive publicity this case was getting, Alabama Governor Guy Hunt advertised a ten thousand dollars reward for any information about Lizza's murder. That's about twenty six thousand in today's money. On March twenty ninth, nineteen eighty eight, an anonymous female called the Colbert County Sheriff's Department. She asked about the reward, and Officer Ronnie May directed her to make the call through crime stoppers to receive the money. So she did, and then the anonymous tipster told Ronnie May and other relevant officers exactly who was responsible for Lizz's death. And it wasn't just one person, it was three, none of whom were Charles Sennett, though his hands aren't clean either. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Now I'm going to tell you the series of events that led to the heart wrenching murder of forty five year old Liz Senate. Most of this information was gained from the anonymous tipster, but for clarity. I've supplemented the details the tipster left out with court documents, the perpetrator's confessions, and newspaper articles relating to this case. About a month before Liz's murder, sometime in February of nineteen eighty eight, Charles Sennate was feeling trapped somehow. He had accrued massive financial debt Andy was cheating on his
33:45 wife. So, figuring he could kill two birds with one stone, Charles took out a life insurance policy for Liz, and then he orchestrated her murder. Author Tim Kent pointed out what he thought was the main motive. As a preacher in the Church of Christ, Charles would believe marriage was sacred and he couldn't divorce Liz unless she had committed adultery. The only other way out is for her to die. He said, that may be true, but it seems to me that murder is a much bigger sin than divorce. I would think Charles was motivated not only by his feelings for his mistress, but also money. Those are the two biggest reasons people kill in this world.
34:27 As Charles schemed, he made sure to do his research and at least once he followed the unsuspecting officer Ronnie May around the gas station crime scene that we discussed at the top of the episode. Once Charles had a plan, he reached out to twenty one year old Billy Gray Williams. Billy rented an apartment from Charles and Florence, Alabama. For reference, Florence is less than ten miles away from where Charles and Liz lived near Tuscumbia. Charles explained to Billie that he he needed to hire someone to kill his wife. It's not clear why Charles entrusted Billy with that information, but he did. Maybe Billy was the only criminal type person Charles knew. Charles said he could get three thousand dollars to pay for the assassination. That's less than eight thousand dollars in two twenty three money. From there, Billy reached out to his close friend, twenty two year old Kenneth Eugene Smith, who went by Kenny. Billy and Kenny had known each other for a long time. They had gone to high school together, so when Billy called up Kenny and asked him to come to his apartment for a chat, Kenny probably didn't think anything of it, but as they sat on Billy's front porch in the late afternoon. Billy told Kenny about the murder for hire plot, and then he asked Kenny if he would kill Charles's wife. Billy explained how they could split Charles's money fifty fifty each getting fifteen hundred, which is about thirty eight hundred and today's money. At
36:00 first, Kenny wasn't sure. He told Billy he would think about it. Kenny and Billy revisited the topic a few more times as Kenny pondered. Two weeks before the murder was scheduled, Kenny met Charles through a meeting that Billy arranged. Charles had never met Kinny before, and the two men did not exchange names. Charles said that he wanted somebody taken care of, and then he proceeded to pitch to Kenny why he should murder his wife, though he didn't say wife yet. Charles just reassured Kenny that the target would be at home alone during the time of the murder. He also said there would be no visitors at the house because this person never had any visitors, and he explained that the house was in a rural area, so no one would be nearby. Kenny listened to Charles's proposal and told him he would get back to him. He gave Charles his phone number, which Charles used to call Kenny multiple times. He wanted to know if Kenny had decided what he do it or not. About a week before the murder was to occur in early March of nineteen eighty eight, Charles hurd back Kenny would do it, and Kenny had also enlisted another young man and the murder for higher plot. This was nineteen year old John Forrest Parker. He had gone to school with Billy and Kenny. Also. They were all three friends from Florence, Alabama, and as a brief sidebar, Kenny had actually asked another friend of his to join him in murdering Liz before John, but that friend said no. With John
37:32 in the picture, he Billy, and Kenny would now receive one thousand dollars each about twenty five hundred in today's money. Neither Kenny nor John ever knew Charles or Lizz's names. On Tuesday, March fifteenth, Charles and Kenny met at a coffee house. There, Charles drew a diagram of his and Lizza's home. He explained to Kenny that the target was his wife. Originally, Lizza's murder was to happen the next day, on Wednesday, March sixteenth. Charles was going to Birmingham for a doctor's appointment, but Liz unexpectedly decided to go with him that Wednesday, so Charles rescheduled the murder to that Friday, March eighteenth. Billy, Kenny, and Charles met one more time before the murder. On that Thursday. They met outside of Billy's apartment in Charles's silver car. John wasn't there. Earlier that day, Charles had cashed to check for three thousand dollars. He had borrowed the money from his girlfriend. She'd had no idea what it was for. Charles only told her he needed to pay some debts now. Charles gave Kenny two hundred dollars. He told him that this was to front the cost for any supplies needed to kill Liz, and Charles also showed Kenny that he had the remaining cash in a hand.
38:51 Charles also explained that he wanted Lizz's death to appear like a burglary gone wrong. He told Kenny to still whatever he wanted from his and Lizz's house. They all agreed that Kenny and John would do the murder and Billy would hold the money. After they murdered Liz, they would go to Billy's apartment and he would give them their remaining shares of the cash. Charles told Kinney that he would be out of the house from eight am to noon the next day, so that's how long Kenny and Johnny had to kill Liz. Later, Billy gave John one hundred dollars of the two hundred that Charles had given to Kenny. John was supposed to use that hundred dollars to buy a handgun to kill Liz, but John, who was a self admitted drug addict, did not do that. Instead, he bought drugs. At about nine thirty am on Friday, March eighteenth, Kenney and John loaded themselves into John's gold nineteen seventy eight Pontiac Grand Prix. First, they drove to Muscle Shoals, Alabama, a city very close to Florence, Tuscumbia and Sheffield, though I'm not sure why. Then they made their way to Charles and Liz's house. Sometime during this drive, John shot up three ccs of talwan, which is an opioid, so he was high. It's a narcotic that's been discontinued because of the high risk of addiction. And as John drove to the Senate House, Kenney sharpened a six inch hunting knife. John had brought the knife since he had used the money for the gun on drugs. Once the two men arrived
40:21 at Liz's house, they parked near her patio then knocked on the door. When Liz answered, Kenny and John explained that they wanted to explore her land for a potential hunting area. They said that her husband, who they didn't know as Charles, had told them they could do this. Liz was understandably a little weirded out. She asked them for their names and then called Charles to make sure what they were saying was true. Charles apparently confirmed Kenney and John's information. He told Liz to let the two guys walk around their property. As Kenny and John walked around outside, she stayed inside. John would admit to the authorities that he didn't know why he and Kenny didn't jump Liz when she first opened the door. Perhaps they got cold feet. Regardless, after Kenny and John made a show of exploring the property. They came back to the door. They knocked again and Liz answered. This time, the men asked if they could use her bathroom and get a drink of water.
41:21 Liz agreed and let them into her house. First Kenny used the bathroom, then John went. As John was in the bathroom, Kenny made conversation with Liz. When John came out, he had placed cotton socks on his hands, presumably to hide his fingerprints, but maybe not. One court document stated that both Kenny and John were wearing gloves due to the cool weather. This is when the two men attacked. It's unclear who did exactly what. Kenny would later claim that he never laid a hand on Liz, that it was only John who attacked her. Kenny described John's actions as frenzied, but John said the opposite, that it was Kinny who had actually killed Liz. It doesn't matter. What does matter is that these two evil men beat Liz Senate so viciously that she was, according to court documents, struggling for her life.
42:16 Officials believed that any item within reach of the two men was used against Liz, including a galvanized pipe, a walking cane, multiple fireplace tools and a chair. All the while Liz was begging them not to hurt her. And then one of them, We're not sure who, stabbed Liz ten times. Then Kenny and John overturned the house. They grabbed the stereo and the VCR, and they broke the medicine cabinet. A china hutch was also overturned. Afterward, John through the stereo in a nearby river. Kenny took the VCR home. The men said at the time that they left Liz was still alive. They could hear her gurgle breathing as blood entered her lungs. Then John and Kenney went to Billy's apartment where they got the rest of their money, and then they disposed of their bloody clothing. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. The authorities wanted to believe that this anonymous tipster was telling the truth. She knew so many details it would be crazy if this was just some random person sending them on a wild goose chase. For example, the tipster knew that on the day of Lizze's murder, Billy used his share of the money to buy a water bed from water World and the tipster knew all about the stolen VCR now at Kenney's house, that it did not have a remote because that was left behind at the sentence house, its
43:50 make, its model, its serial number, that Lizza's blood was still spattered on it. But the local authorities of Colbert County still had to verify this information. So the stolen VCR became very important. It tied Kenny to Liz's murder. Authorities hoped that once they had Kenny in hand, he would fold, then Billy and John would come shortly after. So the officers found the box that the VCR came in. Mike's wife, Kim, had gifted the VCR to her in laws and presumably knew where the box was. Now they could match the serial number of Lizza's stolen VCR to the VCR allegedly sitting in Kenny's house, So at about three pm on March thirty first, about two weeks following Lizza's murder, the police obtained a search warrant for Kenny's home.
44:44 Within ten minutes, they found the VCR and confirmed the matching serial number and yes, Lizza's blood was still on the VCR. On the same day that the officers rated Kenny's home. Kenny, Billy, and John were arrested. John and and he were charged with capital murder, and Billy was charged with conspiracy to commit murder. The legality of whether or not the authorities had enough grounds to arrest these men at the time they did was questioned at length. Ultimately, Kenny confessed to everything immediately and John did too. Based on those two confessions, the officers definitely had the legal right to arrest Billy. But the timeline of when these young men were all taken into police custody versus when they were arrested versus the confessions that would allow them to be arrested is shaky, but ultimately the courts would let that slide in the appills process. I imagine there was a fair amount of grace given considering that these three men had killed an innocent woman in cold blood. Each of the three men were tried separately. First up was Billy Gray Williams's trial. It happened in January of nineteen eighty nine. According to the Birmingham Post Harold he was convicted of capital murder. Sometime throughout the legal proceedings, Billy must have been upgraded from his initial charge of conspiracy to commit murder. Almost no details about Billy's trial are available in the public record, but we do know that a month later,
46:15 in February of nineteen eighty nine, Billy was sentenced to life in prison without parole. All of his appeals were denied. On November twenty second of twenty twenty, Billy Gray Williams died in prison. He was about fifty three years old and he had spent thirty one years in prison. The next trial was that of John Forrest Parker. It began on May thirtieth, nineteen eighty nine. According to court documents, both the prosecution and defense agreed that John was guilty of assault and conspiracy to commit assault, but the defense claimed that John had no intent to kill Liz, just badly hurt her. John's defense attorneys went on to say that John actually left Liz in ok health, as in she was beaten but not near death, and that it was Charles, not John, who returned to the home, pulled out his own knife, and stabbed Liz to death. That is, in my opinion, bullshit. Where was the second knife, then? Where was Charles's bloody clothing? How did John know? He left her closer to life than death. Did John take her vitals as he walked out the door pull out of blood pressure cuff?
47:23 I don't buy it, and neither did the jury, especially because one witness testified that John had explicitly told him he was going to kill somebody with Kenney Smith. John did not testify, and after deliberating for about one hour, the jury found him guilty of capital murder. They recommended that he'd be sentenced to life in prison without parole, but the judge disagreed. He sentenced John to death, and after he exhausted all of his appeals in the state and federal courts, forty two year old John Parker was executed at six forty one pm on June tenth, twenty. He died by lethal injection. His last mill was fried fish, french FROs and iced tea. He had spent twenty one years in prison. In the time leading up to John's death, Lizza's son Mike told the Montgomery Advertiser his family has had twenty years to say goodbye, and I never had that. All I wanted was an apology, and he's had twenty years to give me one, and he still hasn't given me one to this day. Moments before John's execution, he was asked if he had any last words. At this he turned to Lizza's sons, Chuck and Mike, who were both present, and said, I'm sorry. I don't ever expect you to forgive me. I really am sorry. Then he told his friends that he appreciated everything and he loved them, and then he died.
48:51 The last trial was for Kenneth Eugene Smith. It took place in October nineteen eighty nine. This was the only trial of the three men that was grand a change of venue. By this point, Liz's case was incredibly well known, so they moved Kenny's trial from Colbert County, Alabama, to Jackson County, and the judge also placed a gag order. Kenney's defense was based wholly on blaming John. John was the one who killed Liz, not Kenny. Kenny claimed that he never touched her, and his lawyers also argued that he too, never thought he was supposed to kill Liz, just to beat her up, but this, of course was not true. It was a desperate man facing the consequences of his own actions. The jury deliberated for twenty minutes before convicting Kenny of capital murder, and then they recommended that he'd be sentenced to death. Kenny, like John, and Billy, uppealed his case at length, but Kenny, unliked John and Billy, was the only one to be granted a new trial. It was on a technicality the trial court judge did not enter a detailed explanation about the aggravating and mitigating circumstances required to sentence someone to death. Kinny's second trial took place in nineteen ninety six.
50:09 He was reconvicted. This time, the jury recommended a sentence of life in prison without parole, but the judge disagreed and sentenced Kenny to death. Today, Kenny is in the home in prison and at Moore, Alabama. He is about fifty seven years old. He was originally scheduled to be executed at six pm on November seventeen, twenty twenty two, but Kinney was able to pull some last minute legal shenanigans. Long story short, the U. S. Supreme Court was forced to review Kenny's case on the literal day of his execution. The medical staff in charge of his execution was given the go ahead at about ten twenty two PM, but the warrant for Kinny's death penalty expired at midnight. They had ninety minutes to do a process that was originally given six hours. When the medical team struggled to place Kenny's second IV line, they called off the execution at eleven twenty PM. At that point, there wouldn't have been enough time for the lethal injection to kill Kenny before the warrant ran out. This was a very big deal in Alabama, and that's because it happened in the wake of criticism over Alabama's lethal injection process. In July of twenty twenty two, convicted murderer Joe Nathan James Junior was executed following a three hour long delay after they struggled to successfully set up his IV line.
51:36 In September of twenty twenty two, the execution of convicted murderer Alan Eugene Miller failed after the execution team couldn't find a suitable vein. There were and are rampant allegations that Alabama's lethal injection process is at best flawed and at worst in humane. After Kenny's failed execution in November of twenty twenty two, Alabama paused all executions they were internally reviewing their procedures. They resumed in the summer of twenty twenty three. Kinney was able to use this bungled execution as an opportunity to lobby for his right to die by a new method in Alabama. It's called nitrogen hypoxia. Basically, an inmate is forced to breathe in nitrogen until they die from the lack of oxygen. Meanwhile, his lawyers are also trying to stop the second execution attempt. They wrote in a court filing to subject mister Smith to a second execution by lethal injection would subject him to the tortuous experience of unnecessary physical and psychological pain, as has been established through Alabama's last three execution attempts. I know these lawyers are doing their job, and I know Kenney just wants another day on this earth. But it's hard not to compare words like torturous experience and unnecessary physical and psychology logical pain without thinking of what Liz must have gone through. When I first read about this case,
53:07 I thought it was incredibly sad, but basically another spousal murder for higher case. But the devil is truly in the details here. How could a preacher, a loving father and husband do this? How could three men agree to murder Liz Senate for just a thousand dollars each. That's still only about twenty five hundred dollars today. I suppose the answer to the killers is drugs. That's why they would kill Liz for so little money. Addiction is a terrible disease, but murder is an unspeakable choice. But Charles is even harder to understand. From all sources, he was a devoted preacher and family man.
53:49 There had never been one hint that he was capable of something like this. An affair was inconceivable to his sons, but to orchestrate their mother's murder a suicide was sadly not as shocking. Charles had long suffered with mental health issues, and I suppose the guilt of what he had done was too much for him to live with. Liz Sennate was only forty five years old when she was viciously murdered. She had so much of her life ahead of her. She had grand babies to cherish, sons to watch grow older. Her hopes and dreams were smashed to pieces. Her sons were devastated, and the moment they had to process what their father had done, he killed himself basically in front of them. I cannot even imagine the sort of pain and grief they have had thirty five years to live with this horror. Perhaps Kenny's execution will give them closure. Perhaps not. Many people believe that there is no such thing as closure, and with a crime this monstrous, I'm inclined to agree.
55:00 Southern Fried Truecrime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank, with additional research and writing by myself, and of course, all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Fried's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio, and the original graphic art is by Coley Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandan Scheck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. The research tab on Southern Friedtruecrime dot Com is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried Truecrime Fans Discussion Group where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do have wors discussed true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shit ass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate interview on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like our Hearts, Spotify, Amazon, Audible, end YouTube. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed