July 17, 2023

185: The Murder of Lindsey Lee

185: The Murder of Lindsey Lee
185: The Murder of Lindsey Lee
Southern Fried True Crime
185: The Murder of Lindsey Lee

When 31-year-old Lindsey Lee didn’t show up for work bright and early one Tuesday morning, her coworkers at the Lexington County Sheriff’s Department were immediately worried. Their fears were confirmed when the deputy who performed a wellness check...

When 31-year-old Lindsey Lee didn’t show up for work bright and early one Tuesday morning, her coworkers at the Lexington County Sheriff’s Department were immediately worried. Their fears were confirmed when the deputy who performed a wellness check at Lindsey’s home discovered her body. At first, investigators didn’t have any suspects for Lindsey’s murderer. Everyone liked her. Lindsey was so incredibly kind and friendly that she’d even maintained a good relationship with her soon-to-be ex-husband.

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional Writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Case recommended by Jennefer, an anonymous sender, and others

Sources: https://southernfriedtruecrime.com/lindsey-lee

Sponsors for this episode:
  • This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp online therapy. Give online therapy a try at BetterHelp.com/southern and get on your way to being your best self.
  • Treat yourself to the best shapewear on the market and save 20% Off at honeylove.com/SFTC.


This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:05 Southern fraud true crime covers cases they're not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion as advised, a marriage is a promise to have and to hold, to honor, and to cherish. It's a commitment made in front of your family, your friends, and maybe your God, to support your spouse no matter what trials may come your way. And this was true on the day that twenty five year old Lindsey Nichole Pilkington married thirty one year old Jason Dawn Lee. They held each other's hands meaningfully as their wedding efficiant spoke these words, these are the hands of your best friend, young and strong and full of love for you. These are the hands that will hold you when fear and grief temporarily comes your way.

0:56 But sometimes promises must be broken. Tis our relationship suffers under the unbearable weight of a fear or grief, or of course a betrayal. But sometimes we just drift apart. It's no one's fault. We just aren't in love anymore, at least one of us isn't. And when a promise must be broken, when divorce has to happen. It can be joyful in a way a rebirth. Usually all parties can recover. Usually with the help of time and clarity, we can mend our broken hearts and move on with our lives. Usually, but not always. Welcome to Episode one eight four, The Murder of Lindsay Lee. Nights in the beautiful midlands of South Carolina are cool during the spring months. You'll get beautiful days in the seventies, but the temperature won't get much further than in the mid forties. After dark. On Monday, March thirteenth, twenty seventeen, thirty one year old Lindsay Nicole Lee was headed to her home in West Columbia, South Carolina, a small city that is a suburb of Lexington County next door to the state capital of Columbia.

2:19 She had had a long day as she headed home in the darkness at around eight thirty pm. That morning, Lindsay had gone to her job as an it specialist at the Lexington County Sheriff's Department. After that, she had hit the gym for her regular martial arts class, and then she had stopped by Walmart to pick up some groceries. As she pulled into the driveway of her quaint, three bedroom, two bathroom home on Haileywood Lane. I'm sure she was relieved to be winding down. Finally she could kick off her shoes and relax, maybe throws something on TV or read a book. But just as she opened her front door with her plastic grocery bags in hand, Lindsay was a bushed and brutally attacked. The next day, on Tuesday, March fourteenth, the other employees of the Lexington County Sheriff's Department rolled in one by one. They all knew Lindsay and liked her a lot. She was a talkative, pleasant woman, and so most of her co workers noticed that Lindsay, a cheerful presence in a typical humdrum office, was absent. This was out of character for Lindsay. She was their resident fitness enthusiast and an early bird. She always worked out in the morning and she was always one of the first people in the building, but not that day. Concerned Lindsay's co workers, who were also her friends, texted her cell phone. No response.

3:46 Next, they called, but she didn't pick up. Slowly but surely, the LCSD staff members were upgrading their status as generally concerned to really really worried. Where was Lindsay? Was hey? Had something happened. They soon called a deputy who was patrolling near Lindsay's house and asked him to do a welfare check, telling themselves it was probably nothing, but wanting to be sure. The deputy in question was named Shannon Lovell. He was a friend of Lindsay's. He also knew lindsay soon to be ex husband Jason, so Deputy Level made his way to Lindsay's house. By this time it was about ten in the morning. He knocked on the front door, but no one answered.

4:30 Then he went around back to Lindsay's rear entrance, and that's when he saw something suspicious. The back door was damaged. The wood was badly splintered, as if someone had forced their way into Lindsay's home. Right away, Deputy Level called for backup. When his partner arrived, the two officers carefully entered Lindsay's house. Later, Deputy Level would tell Discovery Id's American Monster. I had no idea what I was gonna find. Shortly after walking into Lindsay's house, Deputy Level heard water running coming from upstairs. He and his partner took the stairs to Lindsay's bathroom, where the shower curtain was pulled shut across the tub. Dreading what they would find, they were still shocked when they pulled the shower curtain back, they found their friend and colleague, Lindsay Lee.

5:20 She was lying in the bathtub, posed and what the police would later report was a coffin like manner. She had a six inch incision across her throat and she was dead. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Lindsay Nicole Pilkington was born in September of nineteen eighty five to her mother, Debbie Catherine and her father, Steve Pilkington and Arkansas. When Lindsay was born, it was a big event. According to her mom, Debbie, she was the first grand child and the first great grandchild for the family, so the entire Pilkington clan showed up to welcome little seven pound eight ounce Lindsay into the world. Her father Steve told Discovery I d it was a family affair for sure. Everybody was there, everybody was happy. Lindsay's paternal grandpa video the delighted family members who were present for her birth. In the recordings, you can see the hospital where smiling family members hold baby Lindsay.

6:30 Her mother Debbie gazes at her lovingly. Her father Steve is glowing with pride. At one point, Grandpa sumes in on baby Lindsay's adorable face and he says, with pride, Ah, she's going to be quite cute. In nineteen ninety, when Lindsay was five years old, she gained a new family member, Carrista, and Caista is the first to say that Lindsey struggled to accept her as a little sister. After all, Lindsay was used to being the center of attention. She was a charmer, a performer. Even She loved smiling for the camera, showing off her dance moves, and making her family laugh. She was such a cute little girl, with a bouncy brown ponytail swinging in every video, and her large blue eyes framed by smattering of freckles. She would keep that characteristic ponytail most of her life. Like many firstborns, it was hard at first for Lindsay to share the spotlight with her new baby sister, but she soon came around and the two sisters became very close Lindsay was always there to help Caristo whenever she needed her, and Carista followed her big sister around like a puppy dog, whether Lindsay wanted her to or not, but that's how siblings are. Carista wanted to be just like her well spoken, magnetic big sister. She told Discovery, I D I always wanted to play with her. She took up rollerblading, so I wanted to rollerblade. She learned how to ride a bike, so I wanted to learn how to ride a bike. As a dull, Chorista's admiration for her

8:01 charismatic older sister never wavered. Lindsay and Chorista spent their earliest years in Hebrew Springs, Arkansas, but when Steve realized that job prospects were slim in the rural town, he joined the military. He completed his basic training in nineteen eighty seven, when Lindsay was two, and after that the Pilkington family moved around a lot for Steve's military career. First, they went to California. That was a big change from the teeny tiny town of Hebrew Springs. Steve told Discovery, I D you couldn't get any further away from home, which would become an understatement because in nineteen ninety four, nine year old Lindsay and her family moved to Wiesbaden, Germany. Next was Odinton, Maryland, and following that the family finally settled in South Carolina. Moving around so much forced Lindsay to mature quickly. She had to understand big picture problems fast, and moving around so much also made Lindsay, who was friendly to begin with, an especially talented conversationalist. She knew that no matter where she was in the world, being able to chat so easily would help her fit in quickly.

9:13 Lindsay was also a great student. She got straight a's without much fuss and never had any behavioral struggles that her parents worried about. Among her friends and family, Lindsay was known for her quick wit, love for numbers, and sparkling personality. Her only struggle during high school was one that many of us know and empathize with, her weight. Lindsay had a complicated relationship with food, and in high schools specifically, she often expressed to her mother, Debbie, that she was dissatisfied with her body. Throughout the process of researching this episode, I've looked at a lot of photos of Lindsay. She was, of course beautiful at all sizes, but the reality of the world is on occasion many of us don't like how we look, and that's how Lindsay felt.

10:03 Sometimes it's normal, it's human And I'm not bringing this up just to give you a mental picture of Lindsay's looks. It's relevant you'll see. In the early two thousands, Lindsay attended Midlands Technical College in Columbia, South Carolina. She made the scholars list for her outstanding GPA in two thousand and four. About two thousand and eight, she was working at a bank in Lexington County. One afternoon, twenty three year old Lindsay was at her job at the bank when a tall, blonde haired, and blue outlock smith came in to fix a broken vault. This was twenty nine year old Jason don Lee, and he, like Lindsay, was also a charmer. The moment Lindsay and Jason spoke to each other, there was a connection. Almost immediately, he asked Lindsay out on a date and the two soon became inseparable. After dating for a while, Jason took Lindsay out on a boat during sunset one night, Zalia watched the dolphins, but soon he got down on one knee and popped the question. Lindsay elated said yes, and her family was so happy for her. Her sister Chorista told Discovery, ID, I really liked him, very nice, very funny guy, and Lindsay's mother, Debbie felt the same. She appreciated how handy Jason was. If Davy's car was acting up, she could call Jason to take a look under the hood. He was stable, sweet, and he only had eyes for Lindsay. They seemed to be perfect for each other. They had the same interests and a go

11:35 go go mentality. Lindsay and Jason married in twenty ten. Their wedding was beautiful. As she walked down the aisle in her stunning white dress, Jason cried big Bessie tears. Lindsey's family would tease him about it for ages. Lindsay's father, Steve told Discovery, ID it meant a lot to see that he really cared for her and things were going to be good. It really did seem like a strong match. Lindsay and Jason were both fun, joyful people. During their wedding, Jason's best man spoke about how notoriously clumsy Jason was. Lindsay grinned from ear to ear when the best man handed her a first aid kit as a lighthearted joke gift. Lindsay's sister Carrista recalled that both Lindsay and Jason were doers. They liked to be out and about, experiencing everything the world had to offer, and they loved doing it together. But sometimes all of Lindsay and Jason's doing didn't leave much time for the boring parts of life, like cleaning, exercising, and eating healthy. For a long time, Lindsay and Jason weren't motivated to do those things. They were doing what made them happy and didn't worry about the boring stuff. But at some point this lifestyle became a point of contention between Lindsay and Jason. They would accuse each other of being lazy. They were spending a lot of money on eating out, and both of their weights were increasing to a point which made them uncomfortable. Four years after Lindsay and Jason were married in twenty fourteen,

13:09 Jason joined a jim. He was ready to change his ways, get in shape and feel better. He started working out with a trainer named Graham Hockley. Jason tried to get Lindsay to go see Graham too. According to Graham, Jason was worried about Lindsay's weight. He wanted her to feel better for her, but also, according to Graham, Jason wanted Lindsay to be skinnier. Despite what he often said, it seems like Jason might have wanted Lindsay to start working out for him, not for her, regardless. In twenty fifteen, about a year after Jason started working out, Lindsay agreed to try a session. She had seen all the progress Jason had made and she wanted that for herself too. So she met Jason's trainer, Graham, and initially she wasn't a fan. Graham was British, straightforward, and very pushy.

14:05 He forced Lindsay to work hard, and Lindsay, who was a newbie to fitness, didn't appreciate Graham's tough love. But over time she began getting stronger, the workouts weren't quite so hard anymore, and one day she discovered she didn't dislike Graham anymore either. During their training sessions, they would talk about more than just working out. They discussed their lives, their goals. Somewhere along the way, Graham became more than Lindsay's trainer, he became her close friend. Eventually, Graham convinced Lindsay and Jason to try martial arts, specifically judo, which focuses on grappling and throwing tactics to keep your opponent off balance.

14:50 Lindsay and Jason began training heavily in judo, and for Lindsay, judo felt like the answer to all of her fitness goals. The sport really accessed her drive and determination. The cause and effect became so clear to her. Work hard at judo, follow a healthy diet, and the results would happen. And results did happen for Lindsay. In about a year, she lost over one hundred pounds. She looked completely different, and I'm sure she felt completely different. Lindsay was no longer reluctant to go to the gym, fitness classes and judo training with Graham. Now she loved it and nothing was going to stop her from continuing on this new, exciting fitness journey. Lindsay's gym even featured her weight loss story in their advertisements. They proudly showed her before and after photos. Her mother, Debbie told Discovery ID you could see her self esteem just getting higher and higher. She was coming into her own and Lindsay's father, Steve said, you couldn't convince her to eat or drink anything that wasn't on her diet. She was focused. If you're listening to this and tempted to think, wow, I should get into judo and change my life, or if you're feeling bad because this sounds awful to you, I gently encourage you not to think that way. This journey worked for Lindsay, and maybe a martial arts class would interest you too. I don't know.

16:17 I'm not you, and I'm not your doctor, but this is just a friendly reminder that Lindsay's fitness journey doesn't have to be yours, and more importantly, you can be happy in your body just the way it is. After training with Graham, Lindsay entered several local judo competitions and she did really well. She won a high ranking award in one tournament called the Kin to My Memorial Judo Championship. All of this success in judo and her health made Lindsey feel amazing. She was confident and more assured in her decision making, even beyond fitness and health. Suddenly Lindsey knew what she wanted from her life and she wasn't going to compromise. I'm going to pause now tear a word from today's sponsors. This show is sponsored by Better Help. Sometimes the path forward in life isn't always lit with the answers to tough choices. Making the decision to change careers and my forties was terrifying, even though in my heart I knew it was right. Therapy really helped me manage my anxiety and fears, and Better Help can help you whether you're dealing with decisions around career, relationships, or anything else. It's not just for those experiencing trauma. It can be the roadmap you've been looking for. Therapy helps you stay connected to what you really want while you navigate life, so you can move forward with confidence and excitement. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give Better Help a try.

17:44 It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch therapists at any time for no additional charge. Let therapy be your map with better Help Betterhelp dot com slash Southern today to get ten percent off your first month. That's Better Help Help dot com slash Southern. We are in the midst of wedding season, y'all, and you know what that means. Shapewear so you can look and feel your best, whether you were the bride or a guest. Honeylove is your answer for all things shapewear. I wish I'd had Honeylove when I got married almost a decade ago, not just to feel better in my dress, but also because it doesn't look like shapewear. It looks like beautiful lingerie. Lingerie that's so comfortable I don't wind up ditching it in the ladies room. No one wants to worry about that on your big day. You just want to look your best and still feel comfortable. Honeylove has revolutionized compression technology, so you no longer have to feel like you're suffocating while wearing effective shapewear, and Honeylove Shapewear has a convenient opening in the panty area for super easy bathroom trips, no costume change required.

18:52 Try Honeylove and you'll immediately feel and see the difference. We have an exclusive offer for my listeners. Get twenty off your entire order with our exclusive link Honeylove dot com slash SFTC. Treat yourself to the best shapewear on the market and save twenty percent off at Honeylove dot com slash sftc. Again, that's Honeylove dot com slash sftc to get twenty percent off. As Lindsay was becoming more secure in who she was both physically and emotionally, Jason seemed to be going in the opposite direction. He had stopped working out and he wanted Lindsay to stop too, and that was in part because Jason started feeling threatened by Lindsay and her trainer, Graham. According to Lindsay's sister, Jason believed Lindsay and Graham were having an affair, and for clarity, we'll knit that in the bud right now. There was no evidence that Lindsay cheated on Jason, but that's what Jason thought, and once he started thinking it, it was probably hard for him to stop. Lindsay was still going to Graham's fitness classes and training sessions, and she wasn't going to stop. And it is true that Lindsay and Graham were very good friends. Graham was practically a part of Lindsay's family. He would come to holiday gatherings and her house parties. Her mom met Graham, they were two peas in a pot. But Jason couldn't understand that that was all. They were just friends. And to add just

20:23 one more stressor into Lindsay and Jason's straining relationship, Jason had changed his mind on a big relationship decision children. When Lindsay and Jason were first married, they both agreed that they didn't want children. They both felt that kids were not for them, and there's nothing wrong with that unless one partner changes their mind. Lindsay still didn't want kids, but for unknown reasons, Jason now did. Their inability to see eye to eye on having children became a point of contention for the married couple. So, with all of these factors weighing on Lindsay's mind, she made the difficult decision to ask Jason for a divorce.

21:04 They had been married for six years. Lindsay was now ready to move on, but Jason wasn't. He was very upset by Lindsay's decision. According to his friend, Deputy Shannon Lovell, the one who would find Lindsay's body. Jason said he didn't understand where the divorce was coming from, and honestly, Jason's inability to understand that Lindsay was unhappy, given all we know about their relationship, was probably part of the problem, but that's just speculation on my part. Lindsay and Jason were officially separated in April of twenty sixteen, and she moved in with her mom. Jason moved two hours away to an apartment in Simpsonville, South Carolina. He had found a new locksmith job in Greenville, South Carolina, which was only a short drive from his new apartment.

21:55 Greenville was supposed to be a new beginning for Jason, put some space between him and Lindsay and the memories of their old town. According to Lindsay's family and friends, she'd given them all the impression that she and Jason were on good terms, that the breakup was amicable, and it seemed like their actions showed that. For example, Jason said he didn't want to deal with the hassle of his and Lindsay's maritle home. He told Lindsay she could have it. Then Lindsay decided she was going to fix the place up and sell it. That was a great financial decision for her. She was going to make somewhere between thirty and fifty thousand dollars profit on the three bedroom, two bath house. At first, Jason seemed supportive of Lindsay's decision to sell the house. He even helped her remodel the upstairs bathroom. Everyone thought Lindsay and Jason's divorce was going as well as it possibly could have. Jason was dating a different woman. Lindsay's Facebook relationship status was set to separate it, and around February of twenty seventeen, freshened up her hair color and style. I'm not sure if she felt like it was a rite of passage, but I'd like to think of it that way. Many women changed their hair or appearance in some way after a breakup. She was moving on, preparing herself for the next stage of her adventure. Lindsay and Jason finalized the day for their divorce. It was going to happen in April of twenty seventeen, so when

23:25 Lindsay wasn't at work on Tuesday, March fourteenth of twenty seventeen. Everyone was surprised, and when Deputy Shannon Lovell found her body in the upstairs bathroom of her home, they were flabbergasted. No one could have predicted this. Lindsay's parents were overcome with grief. This level of violence was extremely traumatic in and of itself, apart from just normal grief. Lindsay's father, Steve, said he had to hear the news from his boss end quote. I just couldn't wrap my head around what happened and why. Her mother, Debbie, told Discovery ID that upon hearing the news, she screamed and cried. She didn't believe that her eldest daughter was actually gone. She said, it's not okay, It's never going to be okay. Since Lindsey worked the Lexington County Sheriff's Department, they couldn't investigate her murder. It would have been a conflict of interest. Lindsay's close friend, Lieutenant Allin Sexton told Discovery ID, I couldn't be the best detective for her. I couldn't help and that's hard. As a result, SLED took over the case. SLED is the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division. It's a state level organization that I've discussed many times on this show before, for better or for worse better in this case, of course.

24:49 The first thing SLED did was talked to Lindsay's estranged husband, Jason. They found him at the locksmith store in Greenville County. According to reporter Caroline Hecker, Jason was stunned to see the police right away. He asked what was wrong, and as he learned of Lindsay's violent death, Jason began crying. After his tears subsided, Jason went to the police station at the SLED agent's request, and that's when, unprompted, he began explaining where he was the night Lindsay was killed. He said he had recently suffered a fairly serious foot injury while on the job on Monday night, March thirteenth. His foote was killing him, so he said he had taken some strong pain meds and gone to bed. When he woke up the next morning, he noticed his car was missing, but that didn't really surprise him. Jason explained to the officers that he was behind on his car payments. He just figured the vehicle had been repossessed. But the point of the story here was Jason was saying he had no way to get to Lindsay's house. The interviewing lieutenant asked Jason about some scratch marks he had on his face, but Jason had an explanation for that too, Apparently he had cut himself while dry shaving. Then Jason agreed to provide a DNA sample. Back at the crime scene, investigators were searching Lindsay's house for any clues that might lead to her killer, and there

26:21 were quite a few. First off, it was clear that a struggle had occurred in Lindsay's fourier near her front door. Groceries were spilled everywhere, which makes sense since Lindsay was at Walmart only a half hour before she arrived home. The investigators verified that through her time stamped receipt, Lindsay's attacker must have struck just as she entered the house. Next, law enforcement agents pulled the security footage from Walmart. They saw Lindsay clear as day, walking around the vegetables and fruit aisles with her handheld shopping basket. She looked calm, no furtive glances over her shoulder or otherwise weird behavior. But this local Walmart became very important because investigators received an odd tip from a patrol officer. The day after Lindsey was killed, on Tuesday, March fourteenth, a man matching Jason's description had an altercation with this officer. The man who looked like Jason was upset at how close the officer was to his car, and the patrol officer remembered that this angry man had a big scratch across his cheek. Now the investigators were focused on Jason. When the detectives ran this Jason's doppelganger's vehicles plates, they discovered it was indeed registered to Jason Lee himself. Something was clearly wrong. How could Jason have been angrily shoeing a police officer away from his car when he had claimed it had been repossessed recently, unless his car had

27:52 not been repossessed at all, and instead he had been caught red handed lying to the police. As the detective started to pull the threads of Jason's story, they unraveled more and more. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. In light of this new information, the SLED agents carefully come through Walmart's parking lot security footage and on Tuesday, March fourteenth, at five seventeen am, they saw Jason's vehicle park A figure who looked like Jason exited the vehicle. It's dark and this area of the parking lot isn't well lit, so it's hard to be certain it's him, but it almost certainly is him. Additionally, other surveillance footage and CCTV caught this Jason looking figure walking in the direction of his apartment. He crossed multiple business parking lots, so there was a lot of video evidence. Fifty minutes later, Jason's work truck appeared next to his vehicle and the Walmart parking lot, as if Jason had gone to a different location where he had planted his work truck, grabbed the truck, and then took it to his personal vehicle. The work truck stayed park next to Jason's personal vehicle for four minutes. Later, detectives would suggest that this is when Jason moved the murder weapon from his personal vehicle to his work vehicle, but that's never been proven and the murder weapon was never found.

29:27 Additionally, the security cameras inside Walmart caught Jason buying groceries the night that Lindsay was killed. So let's take stock even if we give the mysterious dark figure that matches Jason's exact height and weight the benefit of the doubt. Even if we say, hey, maybe that's not Jason moving Jason's personal vehicle work vehicle and walking towards Jason's apartment along the very route where he would have stashed his work truck. Well, there was Jason, plain as day, buying groceries in Walmart during the exact time he told agents he was at home, asleep and on pain medication for his foot. Jason had lied to the police twice so far. What else was he lying about? The investigators obtained a search warrant for his apartment, and that's how the sled agents found damning evidence.

30:17 Inside his apartment was a box of blue latex gloves surgical gloves, or the kind you would wear to avoid leaving fingerprints. They were stored in a backpack back at Lindsay's house in the four Yer, where she had been attacked. The authorities had recovered three dime sized pieces of blue latex and they were covered in both Lindsay and Jason's DNA. So much of Jason's DNA was on the gloves that an expert would later testify that he was probably wearing them. On March seventeenth, twenty seventeen, three days after Lindsay's body was found, thirty eight year old Jason Donneley was arrested by sled. He was charged with first degree murder and first degree burglary. He was held without bond at the Alvin Eskland Detention Center in Richland County, and if convicted, Jason could have faced life in prison or even the death penalty. The news of Jason's arrest astonished Lindsay's family. Her mother Debby, said, we did not see this coming. They had broken bread with this man, exchanged Christmas presents. Jason's betrayal was unfathomable and unforgivable, but he wouldn't admit his wrongdoing. He claimed he was innocent, and he maintained that claim all the way into his trial.

31:37 Meanwhile, Lindsay's funeral was held on Sunday, March nineteenth, at the Kaufman Harmon Funeral Home in Lexington. Jason Lee's trial was held in Lexington County and took place in November of twenty nineteen. The prosecution posited that he had broken into Lindsay's house. When he knew she would be away, he broke the back door to make sure it looked like an assailant had to force their way in. Then, using his locksmithing ability or maybe his key if Lindsay hadn't changed the locks yet, that was unclear, he entered her home. As soon as Lindsay arrived from Walmart, Jason overpowered her. He slammed her against the front door. Then he strangled her until she passed out, put her in the bathtub, and cut her throat. However, from the deep defensive wounds on Lindsay's hands, it was clear she had woken in the tub and fought desperately for her life. After Jason killed Lindsay, the state alleged that he planted a bag of marijuana in her car. He wanted to make her death appear to be a drug deal gone wrong, but according to Lindsay's friends and family, she was not a drug user. The medical examiner, doctor Janice Ross, testified and agreed with the state's version of events. She found bruising on Lindsey's hands, arms, neck, back, and head.

32:59 Notably, he had fingerprint bruises on the back of her left shoulder. When prompted by the prosecutor, Ross agreed that that was consistent with someone wrapping their arm around Lindsay's neck and holding her in place. According to doctor Ross's best assessment, Lindsay had been strangled until she passed out, beaten and cut across the neck with a sharp object. Her cause of death was blood lost due to the six inch incision on her throat. So why would Jason kill Lindsay, his almost ex wife who appeared to be on good terms with him. The States suggested that Jason couldn't let Lindsay go, that he had never wanted their relationship to end, and to add insult to injury, Jason was bitter.

33:45 Lindsay was doing well financially. She was going to make tens of thousands off the sale of their marital home. Even though it was his idea, it was probably an idea that had backfired on him. Meanwhile, Jason was floundering. As I said before, he was behind on car payments, but that was just the beginning of his money troubles. The state demonstrated that Jason had less than a hundred dollars to his name when he was arrested. He had maxed out his credit card, he was going to be evicted from his apartment, and he even owed Lindsay thirteen hundred dollars. Jason had been ordered by the court to pay her back by April first of twenty seventeen, less than a month after she was murdered, and according to Jason's co workers' court testimony, Lindsay was going to put Jason in jail if he didn't pay her.

34:35 During the trial, it was revealed that Jason had also changed Lindsay's name in his phone to Hungry Money. So obviously this divorce was not as amicable as Jason had wanted people to think, and maybe Lindsay too. She hid the uglier parts from her family and just kept her head down as she tried to get through it. Jason also had a girlfriend around this time, and he had complained to her at length. He had whined about how unfair it was that Lindsey got the house, never mind that he had offered Lindsey the house. But on the day Lindsey was murdered, Jason had suddenly changed his tune to his girlfriend. According to the girlfriend's court testimony, he said that his financial struggles were over he was going to get the house. The girlfriend said she had no idea how That night Jason had called her. He said his foot hurt badly and that he was going to go home, take some meds, and head the hay. This seemed a little strange to the girlfriend.

35:36 She had never seen Jason take pain medication before. He just wasn't the type. But maybe Jason's foot was in excruciating pain, so bad that he had to take the prescribed meds. But according to Jason's co workers testimony, Jason hadn't looked like he was in pain the Monday morning before Lindsey was murdered. He didn't complain, he didn't limp, He just fine. The next day, when Lindsay's body was found, Jason's co workers had asked him about his newly scratched face. Jason, who had told the investigators that he cut himself shaving, told his co workers that his cat had scratched him. SLED agents and other experts testified that Jason's fitbit also held important data. Based on the information, Jason wore his fitbit religiously, but during the times that he would have had to travel to and from Lindsay's home, if he killed her, the fitbit was mysteriously turned off. The data from Jason's work band GPS also indicated that he had traveled to and from Lindsay's home. And there's more.

36:43 Jason had deleted his call records from January fourteenth to March fourteenth, the day when Lindsay's body was discovered. He had also deleted his web search history on March fifteenth, but experts were able to recover some of his search queries. They included how to reset passwords, criminal defense attorneys, an obituary website, and news articles related to Lindsay's death. And the day Lindsay's body was discovered, Jason had called their tax prep consultant that they had hired when they were married. He asked if their tax refund could be transferred to his account. It's unclear if the police had told Jason about Lindsay's death at the time he had made this call, so it's undeniably suspicious. Why else would he suddenly be entitled to their joint refund. Graham Hockley, the fitness trainer who was good friends with Lindsay, also testified. He explained he and Lindsay were best friends and that he was her personal trainer nothing more. Graham was likely the last person to have seen Lindsay alive, as she had worked out with him before going to Walmart the night she died. Graham told the jury that he wished he had taught Lindsay more self defense moves, he said tearfully, if I had talked her, she might have had a chance. We talked about it, but we didn't actually get to it. I didn't think she needed it, to be fair, Jason's defense team argued that he didn't do it. They explained that no items in Jason's apartment, work then, or

38:15 personal car tested positive for blood, and the gloves that investigators founded Jason's home, well, those could be used for hunting. Jason himself didn't testify, and his defense team didn't put anyone else on the stand. Bluntly put, they didn't put on a case at all. They just cross examined state witnesses without calling any of their own and so. On November twenty second, twenty nineteen, after deliberating for a mere sixty two minutes, the jury convicted the now forty year old Jason Lee of murdering his estranged wife thirty one year old Lindsay Nicole Lee. He was also convicted of first degree burglary. He was sentenced to life in prison with out the possibility of parole. Before Jason was carted off to jail, he stood and said the following. The only thing I have to say is I didn't do it, and I will be appealing this and I will be coming back on a bill. I did not murder Lindsay Lee, and I'll want that on the record. I am an innocent man. I did not murder her, and I will prove my innocence and I don't care if it takes twenty years. I will prove my innocence today.

39:25 Lindsay's friends and family have started the Lindsay Pilkington Memorial Foundation. Their mission is to empower women. They offer scholarship opportunities, mental health services, and self defense training for women. Alin Sexton as a former lieutenant for the Lexington County Sheriff's Department and a friend of Lindsay's. He is now the CEO of the Lindsay Pilkington Memorial Foundation. He told wis TV News she was something that was unstoppable and when she set her mind to something, it was going to get taken care of, whether it be wor working on computers of the Sheriff's Department, whether it be her fitness. She was serious about those things, and she always put her mind to it and took care of other people before she would take care of herself. Jason is currently incarcerated in the Broad River, South Carolina Department of Corrections. As of twenty twenty, he maintains his innocence, but he has yet to appeal. When I first read about this case, I was worried the press or others might have tried to blame Lindsay.

40:30 You see, I covered a case back in early twenty nineteen that felt similar, episode number thirty seven, the Heather Palumbo Jones case. She had gone on a weight lost journey also and then was murdered by her jealous soon to be ex husband. Heather, like Lindsay, had decided to go on a journey to change her life, not just lose weight. She wanted to feel better, not just look better. But when she was murdered, headlines screamed that she was killed for weight loss. Her own friends went on talk shows and said things like if she hadn't lost the weight, she would still be alive. But thankfully Lindsay's case was several years after Heather's and we have come a long way. When discussing weight loss, no one blamed Lindsay for wanting to get healthy and change her life. The only problem was that changing her life included leaving her husband. On the outside, they seem to be a happy couple, but life is never really how it looks. What may have seemed like a sudden decision on Lindsay's part had actually been stewing for a while. She was just the one to pull off the band aid and separate first. If Jason was jealous, it wasn't about Lindsay's weight, and it wasn't just about Graham. I wonder if he told her she could have the house and sell it, hoping she would see him as not just generous but independent himself. Helping her remodel seemed to be a way to stay close to her without making her feel smoke, and it would seem as though he did

42:02 fool her, except that he borrowed money from her, and she wasn't playing around about that they were getting a divorce. He owed her the money, and that was that. Lindsay had drawn clear boundaries in all aspects of their divorce. Maybe that was the trigger for Jason. After everything he had done to try on woo Lindsay back, she had the court ordering him to repay a loan she had given him. He then cruelly snuffed out her young life, and he was viciously angry about it. It was a personal murder. He strangled and beat her before cutting her throat. You don't murder someone with that much violence without rage. I'm sure jealousy and a sense of desertion played into Jason's savage thoughts, but in the end it seems like all he cared about was the money. But that's the second oldest reason to murder someone after love. Whatever his motive, Jason's murderous jealousy is a tale as old as time. Southern Fraud True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly.

43:12 Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank, with additional writing by myself, and of course, all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Fraud's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio, and the original graphic art is by Klei Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon Shuck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. Thank you to Jennifer, an anonymous sender and others for suggesting Lindsay's case. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. You'll get lost in a sea of emails if you send it to my main address, so this is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time in our lovely group. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern Fried, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shit. US is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on it tunes. I'm also on all large platforms like Our Hearts, Spotify, Amazon, Audible and YouTube.

44:38 Until next time, thanks so much for listening. You'll take care