July 10, 2023

184: The Poisoner Katie Stricklin

184: The Poisoner Katie Stricklin
184: The Poisoner Katie Stricklin
Southern Fried True Crime
184: The Poisoner Katie Stricklin

In 1971, Sundays in Savannah, Tennessee were for two things: church and family. That was especially true for the Stricklin family. One Sunday, 66-year-old Mollie and her husband, 81-year-old William, invited their son and his wife to their new home...

In 1971, Sundays in Savannah, Tennessee were for two things: church and family. That was especially true for the Stricklin family. One Sunday, 66-year-old Mollie and her husband, 81-year-old William, invited their son and his wife to their new home for a midday meal. Mollie made the food. Her daughter-in-law served the tea. Afterward, they all went for a nice drive in the city. The get-together seemed fun and innocent—until Mollie and William became terribly ill. Days later, William died. Mollie barely recovered. When evidence revealed that the Savannah couple had been poisoned with arsenic, questions started to arise. Little did they know that William’s death was only the beginning of a case that would change the Stricklin family’s lives forever.

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional Writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Case recommended by Cathy and others

Sources:

Today’s Sponsors:
  • Customize the US’s best home security system for your home by going to SimpliSafe.com/southernfried. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
  • Cancel your unwanted subscriptions with RocketMoney.com/southernfried
  • Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey. Download today on iOS or Android.
  • Access some of your hard-earned paycheck early. Download the EarnIn app and type in Southern Fried under podcast.


This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:01 Southern for a true crime cover's cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. In the early eighteen hundreds, Britain caught their most prolific female serial killer, Mary Anne Cotton. Mary was a nurse and housekeeper who, over the course of almost two decades, allegedly poisoned up to twenty one people with arsenic. Many of her victims were thought to be her own husbands and children. For most of Mary's victims, she was able to collect a large insurance payout.

0:42 She was only arrested and charged in eighteen seventy two when she suddenly suggested to a local official that her seven year old stepson, Charles Edward Cotton, was not long for this world. When Charles subsequently died of a mysterious illness, the local official notified the police. An autopsy revealed that Charles had been poisoned with arsenic. As a result, Marianne Cotton was executed on May twenty fourth, eighteen seventy three. She was around forty years old. The same year Mary was executed, another female serial killer was born, this time in the United States. Amy Dugan Archer Gilligan of Milton, Connecticut. In Amy's adult years, she ran a nursing home. That nursing home turned out to be the perfect killing grounds for as many as forty eight people. Amy was caught when detectives became suspicious about the large amounts of arsenic she was buying, but prosecutors were only able to charge her with five murders, and by the time the court proceedings were over, Amy was convicted of only one. In nineteen seventeen, she was sentenced to death, but on a pill she was resentenced to life in prison. She died in nineteen sixty two in the Connecticut Hospital for the Insane. Since Amy also used arsenic for the majority of her murders, her story inspired the famous play Arsenic and Old Lace. In nineteen sixty two, the time of Amy's death, yet another American female serial killer was

2:14 on the rise. She too would use arsenic to murder her victims, and she too would seem to escape justice time and time again. Welcome to episode one eighty four, The Poisoner Katie Strickland. On Sunday May thirtieth, nineteen seventy one, thirty three year old Katie's Stricklin got dressed to go to her in law's house for a midday mill in Savannah, Tennessee. Katie and her husband Ray were looking forward to this Sunday get together. They were close to Ray's parents and visited them often. Katie even made a point of inviting her in laws to their own home about once a week. She was a former schoolteacher and current homemaker. Ray was a factory worker. Together, they seemed to be the perfect example of traditional Southern values. God and family were everything to them, so of course they were happy to go to Ray's parents house for a mill after the Sunday service. Plus Ray's parents, sixty six year old Molly Elizabeth an eighty one year old William Talmadge, had purchased a new home about six months ago. After years of laboring as a farmer, William had been able to buy a beautiful brick home for his and Molly's golden years.

3:30 Katie and Ray were excited for Molly and William. She had presented her in laws with new curtains as a housewarming gift and helped them paint their bathroom. So this Sunday mill wasn't the first time Katie and Ray had visited Ray's parents fancy new home, but still it was going to be a splendid Sunday affair, hosted in a nice home with good food and good people. Ray's sister Mary was going to be there too. When Katie and Ray arrived at Molly and William's house, they joined the and bustle of preparing the big mill, or Katie did, at least. This was the nineteen seventies, after all, Ray probably just went to the living room to chit chat with his dad. In the kitchen, Ray's mother, Molly was in charge of the majority of the cooking. Mary was buzzing around helping where needed, and Katie made and served the iced tea before digging into their mill. The Stripland family probably said grace, and as their bellies became fuller and fuller, they probably thanked Molly for her hard work on the food. After the mill, Katie and Ray took his parents on a car ride just for fun. Again, it's the nineteen seventies. There wasn't much else to do in a small town.

4:41 But that's when something strange happened. Molly and William began vomiting uncontrollably, and they also experienced horrible diarrhea. Their sickness was so severe that Katie and Ray took them straight to the local Savannah hospital right away. The doctors thought Molly and William had a virus or baby had eaten something bad. They gave Molly an injection of medicine and sent her on her way, but they kept William for a few days. Remember, William was older and he had had a history of high blah pressure and hardening arteries. The doctors wanted to ensure he was okay before releasing him. By Wednesday, June second, three days after the sickness began, William's health had greatly improved. On that day, Katie and her sister in law Mary were at the hospital checking on William, and without warning, William's condition deteriorated. He suffered convulsions, and by the morning of Thursday, June third, eighty one year old William Talmutch Strickland had died. William's funeral was scheduled for the next day, Friday, June fourth.

5:46 Following the funeral, the Strickland family went to Molly's home. Molly was beside herself, even though William was elderly, he had seemed healthy. His death was unexpected, and after about forty six years of mary marriage, the newly widowed Molly was in deep grief. After Molly's hospital visit earlier that week, the doctor had told her to eat softer foods that were gentler on her stomach, soups, puddings, things like that. So Katie brought Molly a few soft drinks and some jello on Sunday, June sixth, two days after William's funeral. Katie wasn't the only one who brought Molly food. It's such a human thing to do, bring our loved one's food when we're not sure how else to help them. On Monday, June seventh, Molly became wildly sick again. She was experiencing the same symptoms as before, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea. Molly soon checked into the county hospital. The next day, at the urging of one of Ray's brothers, Molly was transported to a bigger, better equipped hospital in Memphis, Tennessee. At this second hospital, the doctors pumped her stomach, and luckily Molly survived this second bout of six, but just barely. The doctors were baffled by Molly and William's illnesses.

7:05 They had happened so quickly and were so deadly. Was something going on and race parents new home, some environmental anomaly that was contaminating their food with dangerous substances. According to the Tennesseean, the doctors ordered the Strickland family to get out of Molly's Savannah house and locked the doors. The family was to contact the health department immediately. Meanwhile, medical experts examined Molly's urine and they found something in there that definitely shouldn't be there, arsenic, a lot of it, thousands of times more than the fatal amount. Molly and the rest of the Strickland family were bewildered. How had she ingested so much arsenic. Over the next few years, the Strickland family would be shocked to learn that Molly's arsenic poison wasn't an accident. Someone had tried and failed to kill her.

7:56 And this wasn't the first time the attacker had struck It wasn't the second, it wasn't even the third. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Katie Levina Browder was born in late July of nineteen thirty eight to parents Nelson and d Alma. She was an only child, and she spent her childhood growing up in areas near the small town of Henderson, Tennessee. Henderson is located in West Tennessee, and it's the seat of Chester County. Today, the city of Henderson has a population of about six thousand people. When Katie lived there, it was about half that. It's famous for the Chester County Barbecue Festival and calls itself the best small town on the map.

8:41 Katie's father, Nelson, was from an even smaller community just a few miles southwest of Henderson called Oak Grove. At the time of Katie's birth, thirty nine year old Nelson was a bookkeeper. He worked for Chevrolet and Henderson Sales. Some time before that, Nelson had been a schoolteacher, but as Katie got older, Nelson decided to leave bookkeeping and school teaching behind to begin a new venture. He opened a general store in Oak Grove and it was pretty successful. He owned it for seventeen years. Katie worked there in the summers when school was out. Katie's mother, Almah, was a homemaker, and she and Katie spent a lot of time together at home. They were described as very close, and the Browers were a religious family. They attended the Oakland Baptist Church services regularly. Over the years, Katie appeared to become a fine young woman. One of her neighbors told the Tennessee In that she was nice and kind, a real friendly type, and another person who knew Katie said she was sweet to everybody and she was a pretty good student. Her teachers explained that she was of average intelligence, but she did get all a's her sophomore year of high school. Her high school principle remembered that Katie kept herself in school. He explained that while the other students were excited about playing basketball all with their friends, Katie was not. She was a bit of a lone wolf. Instead of playing team sports, she participated in more individual activities. She did four h and took private piano lessons. Katie's piano teacher

10:13 remembered that she was okay at the piano cooperative, but she didn't practice enough. But it's not like that. Asn't a common complaint from piano teachers, with disciplined repetition being the best way to learn, even if you're a prodigy. When Katie graduated from Chester County High School, she decided she wanted to become a teacher like her dad. So in the fall of nineteen fifty five, Katie enrolled in the University of Memphis, Lambeth and Jackson, Tennessee. She might have chosen Lambeth specifically because it was close to her parents home. At this time, Katie's parents resided in Mifflin, Tennessee, which was a few miles outside of Henderson, and Mifflin was less than twenty miles from Katie's new university. While attending, Katie visited her parents frequently. Not only did she return for the normal holiday festivities, but she also spent many weekends at her parents' home. Back then, small town newspapers would release lists of visitors from other cities, so each and every time Katie visited her parents, she was mentioned in the paper, and Katie was mentioned a lot. At least ten times, maybe more. I lost count. From the outside looking in, it seemed like Katie really cared for and loved her parents, Why else would she visit them so often. After taking some teaching courses at Lambeth for a year, Katie set her sights on attending George Peabody College and Nashville.

11:41 Peabody was a private education school that is now housed under Vanderbilt University. To get in, Katie had to retrieve an arsenal of recommendation letters from high standing people in her community, and she did. Katie got glowing her views from her pastor, assistant high school principal, a deputy marshall, a county judge, and the vice president of a local bank. In nineteen fifty six, Katie was accepted into Peabody's College's teaching program. There she would complete her Bachelor of Arts in teaching, and despite Nashville being one hundred and thirty miles away from Mifflin, Katie still made frequent visits to her parents Mifflin home. In the fall of nineteen fifty eight, she was hired at Lexington High School.

12:24 She was going to teach science, Civics, and geography. Then in nineteen sixty she moved to Hardin County Central High School in Savannah, Tennessee. There she taught business education, but by the fall of nineteen sixty one, Katie was teaching fifth and sixth grade students at Beach Bluff School. Katie realized that she preferred the younger students, and she stated this teaching position for a while. Years later, she would receive her master's degree in education from Memphis State University. It appears that Katie's college in young adult years might have been more social than her high school ones. She joined a music club, attended parties regularly, and went to the theater with her friends, which could be why she bounced around jobs so much. We're not sure, but it was a red flag to me. Still, Katie's family was her top priority. Once she organized a surprise anniversary picnic lunch for her parents, Nelson and Alma, and seventy five friends, family, neighbors, and fellow parishioners came. Katie also entered a few different beauty pageants as a young adult, and she was considered attractive, if tall for that era's standards. She was five ten with black hair, blue eyes, and a soft smile. It's unclear how Katie did in the pageants, but apparently she didn't win, or it probably would have made the paper. And even if the pageants didn't reward Katie's beauty, others certainly did. Around nineteen sixty one, twenty three year old Katie met

13:56 a man who thought Katie was gorgeous. This was twenty five year old Andrew Ray Strickland. He was named after his paternal grandfather, Andrew, so he went by Ray. In many ways, Ray was the opposite of Katie. Where Katie was an only child, he was one of eight children, and while Katie was extremely well educated, Ray was not. He had dropped out of school in the eighth grade. School just wasn't for him, and perhaps because of that, Ray wasn't much for reading and writing either. He liked to work with his hands. When Katie met him, he was a mechanic at a local gas station. Later he would become a successful machinist at Rockwell Manufacturing. Six months after Katie and Ray first locked, as they were married.

14:43 The service happened at Beech Bluff Methodist Church on the afternoon of Sunday, December twenty third, nineteen sixty two. It was deemed impressive by the Jackson Son newspaper. The church was decorated with white moms, red points atas, and long tapered candles framed the alter. The family pews were marked with white satin bows that matched Katie's floor length. Satin gown. Her gown was extravagant with a chapel train and massive four tier veil, and her bridesmaids were Christmasy red velvet dresses. The Jackson's son described Katie as radiant. After their wedding, Katy and Ray moved to a farm owned by Katie's father near Mefflin.

15:26 Less than three years after Katie was married, on September thirteenth, nineteen sixty five, her father, Nelson, was admitted to the hospital for an unknown illness. Just over a week later, on September twenty second, Nelson died. This broke Katie's mother's heart for years. She struggled with Nelson's death. Around nineteen sixty eight, Alma moved in with Katie and Ray. It appears as if this was Katie's idea, not Almah's, because according to Katie, Alma didn't like living with them. She said, you would say that no home was big enough for two families. She felt like she was in our way. We aren't sure how big the Browder's Jackson, Tennessee home was, but we do know it was worth about sixty four thousand back in nineteen sixty eight. Today that's over half a million dollars. Eight months after she moved into Katie's home, Alma was admitted to the hospital. She died July eighteenth, nineteen sixty nine, at age fifty one. Almah's doctor attributed her death to a coronary occlusion or a toxic effect of some toxin on the heart muscle, so heart failure. Fifty one is considered young for heart failure today, but not so much back then. Katie probably leaned on her mother in law, Molly a great deal after Almah's unexpected death. Molly would later say she and Katie were incredibly close. She likened their relationship to a mother and daughter.

16:55 By this time, in nineteen sixty nine, thirty one year old Katie had mostly stopped he was a full time homemaker. It doesn't appear as though Katie was fired. Her colleagues and principal said Katie was cheerful and pleasant, but a little dramatic about her own illnesses, which is a nice way of saying she was a hypochondriac. But Katie did still teach some evening classes at a local community college. Perhaps Ray was making enough money at his factory job that she didn't really need to work. Over their seven years of marriage, Katie and Ray discussed having children, but for unknown reasons, it never happened for them. But Katie was quick to spoil her nieces and nephews on Ray side with sweets, especially on special occasions like their birthdays. Katie was always good at making food for gatherings. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. When an intruder threatens your home, every second counts.

17:55 It's why I'm so excited to tell you about the latest innovation from simply Safe Home Security. It's called twenty four seven Live Guard Protection, and it's made possible only by Simply Safe new smart alarm, wireless indoor camera. Now with a fast protect monitoring plan. If an intruder breaks into your home, simply Safe monitoring agents can actually see, speak to and deter them through the camera, warning them that they're being recorded and that police are on their way. It's a game changer in home security. My family has had simply Safer years, and with each new innovation, I feel even more secure. I have a lot of travel coming up, and I love the new camera and the new layer of protection. The new camera is also the only indoor security camera that can trigger the alarm and instantly deter intruders with a built in siren.

18:40 With Simply Safe professional monitoring calls center one dollar a day, a bargain for the peace of mind it provides. Right now, Southern Fried listeners get a special twenty percent off any simply Safe system when you sign up for fast Protect monitoring. This huge offer is for a limited time. Visit simply safe dot com slash Southern Fried. That's simply safe slash Southern Fried. There's no safe like simply Safe. I am the worst about canceling subscriptions. I've kept newspaper subscriptions for certain small towns I've researched for years after the episode came out. Over eighty percent of people have subscriptions they've forgot about, and chances are you're one of them. Like that one streaming app you have just to watch one show. Now the show is over, and you keep forgetting to cancel.

19:25 That's why I love using rocket Money formerly known as true Bill. The app shows all your subscriptions in one place and then cancels for you whatever you don't still want. Rocket Money can even find subscriptions you didn't know you were still paying for You may even find out you've been double charged for a subscription. To cancel a subscription, all you have to do is press cancel and rocket money takes care of the rest. Stop throwing your money away, Cancel unwanted subscriptions, and manage your expenses the easy way by going to rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. That's rocket money dot slash Southern Fried. Rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. Now that we're all caught up, a quick reminder.

20:10 Ray's father, William, died on Thursday, June third, nineteen seventy one, due to a mysterious illness. Molly had caught the same illness, but she had recovered a few days before William's death. His funeral was on Friday, June fourth, and Molly became sick again on Monday, June seventh. She would have died except one of Ray's brothers insisted she be moved to a Memphis hospital, which pumped Molly's stomach. When the medical experts at the hospital tested Molly's urine, there was arsenic in it. Someone had tried to poison Molly, so the local authorities became involved. When the police searched Ray's parents house, they didn't find any arsenic. There nothing that could have accidentally contaminated their food through a leak or an honest mistake. Oh I thought this was a bag of sugar type thing. So at first the officers didn't know what had happened to Molly, and then some of Molly's relatives started talking to the police about Katie. Apparently she had behaved very oddly in the days leading up to Molly's final hospitalization. Upon hearing the news that Molly had somehow eaten arsenic on Monday, June seventh of nineteen seventy one, Katie had asked the physicians if the arsenic was from the jello. She appeared deeply concerned. She exclaimed that if it was from the jello, she would be at fault.

21:32 At the time, Katie's statement didn't come across like a confession. It felt like an attempt to understand the situation, like was it the jello? Oh wow? I brought the jello? And Ray's sister Mary had said almost the same thing about the beings which she had made for Molly's soft food diet. Right before Molly was rehospitalized, on June seventh, after the doctors told everyone to stay out of Molly and William's home so it could be affected by the Health Department, the doctors had another idea. They were going to analyze the food in Molly's fridge. Tons of people had brought her food after her husband's recent funeral. Surely one of these food items had arsenic in it, which is what caused Molly's severe illness. When Katie heard that the doctors were going to test the food for arsenic, she called Ray's brother, who was still at Molly's house. She told him to throw out all the prepared food, but Ray's brother had already heard about the doctor's requests to analyze the food, so he didn't throw it out. He put it in an ice chest and brought it to Memphis Hospital. Later, Ray would tell the Tennessee And that Katie struggled to understand that the doctors could test the food for arsenic. He had to explain it to her a few times for her to fully grasp it.

22:48 Maybe she didn't know that was scientifically possible, and when Ray's brother showed up at the hospital with the ice chest cooler full of food from Molly's fridge, Katie came running up to him. She looked anxious. She opened the cooler and filtered through the food inside, looking for something, but Ray's brother didn't know what. Katie tried to take the cooler and carry it into the hospital herself, but Ray's brother quickly took it from her, saying it was too heavy for Katie. It's important to note that when Katie made jello to bring to Molly's house, she hit made two bowls, a big bowl and a small bowl. The big bowl was meant for other Strickland family members who were milling around Molly's house to eat. The small bowl was just for Molly.

23:32 Katie said as much to Molly and Ray's sister Mary, and she put the small jello bowl and Molly's fridge. When Katie left that day, she called out to Molly be sure and eat some of it, and Molly did. She ate a few spoonfuls of the jello on the morning of Monday, June seventh, right before she became horribly sick. When the Memphis Medical Examiner's office analyzed the food, the only item that had any remnants of arsenic was Katie's small bowl. Of jello, the one she had made just for her mother in law, Molly. Now the local police were suspicious of Katie. Even though it felt like this lead was wrong, everyone thought Katie was on great terms with Molly. Plus, Katie was a soft spoken and mild mannered former schoolteacher and frankly a woman. Remember this was nineteen seventy one. For this small southern town, murder was rare and a female murderer almost unheard of.

24:29 Katie Strickland was the exact opposite of the murderers the police usually arrested. But even if Katie's motive was shrouded in mystery, the evidence was clear she made the jello, and the jello was poisoned. Following the news that Katie had almost certainly tried to kill her mother in law, authorities exhumed Katie's father in law, William Strickland's body on June twenty fifth, three weeks after he had been buried. The autopsy revealed that William, like Molly, had also consumed a larger amount of arsenic William's kidneys, liver, and gastric tract had nearly five thousand times more arsenic than the human body can handle, which just so you know, is only one sixth of an ounce. That's why today we primarily use arsenic to kill pests. But how had Katie poisoned William?

25:19 Well, remember, Katie had been at her in laws for Sunday dinner on May thirtieth, and she had made the iced tea. She poured both William and Molly's glasses, and afterward, both William and Molly became incredibly ill. When investigators tested the utensils Katie would have used to make the tea, they found traces of arsenic. After William drank the tea, he was admitted to the hospital, but he did start recovering after a few days. And that's when, as I mentioned before, Katie stopped by to visit William with Ray's sister Mary, and when Mary left the room for a moment, Katie had served William a Coca Cola beverage. She poured the coke into a paper cup and helped William lift the straw to his mouth. There was no way to test that coke for arsenaic the paper cup was long gone, but shortly after William drank it, he died. Katie was finally arrested in July of nineteen seventy one, she was charged for the murder of her father in law, William Strickland, and the attempted murder of her mother in law, Molly Strickland.

26:22 I can't imagine how Ray, Katie's husband felt. Molly was certainly surprised. She told the Tennessee in that up until Katie had started poisoning people, we were one big, happy family. But the police investigation into Katie wasn't over yet. They had received an anonymous tip from someone at the Jackson Madison County General Hospital, the hospital where Katie's mother, Almah, was treated before she died by what was then determined to be heart failure. The tipster told the detectives that Almah had experienced all the symptoms of arsenic poisoning, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea, the same exact things that both William and Molly had suffered after Katie allegedly poisoned them. So the authority started the process of exhuming Almah's body. Katie obviously opposed the autopsy. She claimed that she didn't want her mother cut up, and Almah's family almost agreed with Katy's wishes, except her brother, Bobby Butler spoke up. He demanded that Madison County do the autopsy. In fact, Bobby said they should have done an autopsy back in nineteen sixty nine, right after Almah died, but they hadn't for several reasons.

27:36 Number one, everyone loved Katie and didn't suspect her of killing her own mother, whom she appeared to be very close to. And two, Bobby had received a letter from an insurance company asking him not to do an autopsy. Now Bobby pulled that insurance letter back out, and he quickly realized that it was fake. It was signed by a quote anonymous insurance company and postmarked only with the single word now ashful. Later investigators would determine that the letter was typed on a very specific, very old model typewriter, and Katie Strickland owned that exact model of typewriter. So Almah's body was exhoomed and she had indeed died of arsenic poisoning. At this news, Almah's brother, Bobby expressed his frustration to the local newspapers. He said, Katie grew up in a good Christian home. She never wanted for anything. I'm sure, Bobby had the same question on his mind that we all do. Why had Katie killed all these people? Thirty three year old Katie was held in the McNairy County Jail without bond for almost a year, and the jailers there really seemed to like Katie. They didn't think she was a murderer. One told the Tennesseean, you couldn't ask to know a nicer person. I don't think she is the type that would poison anybody. And Katie's husband, Ray, who was yes still her husband, visited her three times a week, which sounds crazy since Ye was accused of killing his father and attempting to kill his mother.

29:03 But Ray's family told the Tennessee in he feels responsible for her and doesn't know which way to turn. When journalists approached Ray, he refused to speak poorly of his wife of nine years. While all of this was happening, Katie maintained her innocence. She didn't offer any other explanation for how her mother, Almah, her father in law William, or her mother in law Molly had been poisoned. According to Katie, she just knew that she had nothing to do with it. At this point, Katie was now facing three trials. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. Escape to a bygone age of mystery, danger, and romance as you immerse yourself into the world of June's Journey, a hidden object mystery mobile game that puts your detective skills to the test. Each chapter uncovers a collection of dazzling hidden check spectacles for you to solve. Search for hidden objects from the parlors of New York to the sidewalks of Paris. Collect scraps of information to fill your photo album and learn more about each character. Chat and play with other or against other players. By joining a detective club, you'll even get the chance to play in a detective league to put your skills to the test. I am now in the Hidden Seller in the sixth chapter of volume one, I'm continuing the investigation into the homicides of Claire and Harry van Buren, stretching my detective skills even further. In June's Journey, I love slipping away to my favorite

30:33 reading chair to play my favorite game. If you're craving a good mystery or just looking for an escape, June's Journey is the game for you discover your inner detective when you download June's Journey for free today on iOS and Android. Financial anxiety anyone worrying about it doesn't help earn In does. Earn In is the app that provides up to one hundred dollars a day of your paycheck within minutes of earning it. No mandatory fees and no credit check, no debt traps. Watch your earnings tick up as you work and access up to seven hundred and fifty dollars per pay period. It's easy and free to get started. Add your bank end employment info and they'll verify your paycheck. Like many people, I've been forced into payday loans and emergencies, and it's a vicious cycle. Looking back, I would have killed for an app like earn In.

31:23 Make earn In a part of your financial routine and join urn ends. Over three and a half million customers who rely on the peace of mind earn In gives them. Download earn in today spelled ear ni n in the Google Play or Apple app Store. When you download the earn and app, type in Southern Fried Under podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show. Southern frieda Under podcast subject to your available, earnings daily MAX and pay period max. See Arnin dot com to slash ts for details. Earnin is a financial technology company, not a bank. Bank products are issued by Evolved Bank and Trust Member FDIs. Katie's first trial, the one for the murder of her father in law, William, took place in April of nineteen seventy two. As everyone walked into the courtroom, Katie greeted her mother in law Molly, like nothing had happened. She gave Molly a big hug and tried to make small talk. Ray's sister Mary told the papers and not so many words, that she was weirded out. During this trial, the state prosecuting attorneys painted Katie as a cold blooded killer. They asserted that Katie didn't have a clear motive because she didn't need one. She was killing just to kill, and they asserted that Katie's heartless actions proved that. For example, when William was hospitalized after his initial arsenip poisoning from the tee, Katie would make fun of him. As William lay helpless in the hospital bed, she would

32:53 lift his covers, and if he had messed himself with diarrhea, Katie would laugh and say he's done it again. Also, during William's funeral, Katie sat near his grave and nonchalantly ate green apples, and after the funeral, she didn't join the Strickland family to grieve in William and Molly's home. Instead, she planted flowers on their front lawn. The state's attorneys also claimed that Katie had actually already confessed to arsenic poisoning twice. First, when Katie heard of Molly's arsenic poisoning, that's when she asked the doctor if it was the jello and said something along the lines of if it was in the jello, then it was my fault. The exact wording is disputed. The second was when the police arrested Katie, she confessed again. The police told Katie her rights and then she started babbling. According to the officer who arrested her, she said, I might have done these things. I don't remember. I could have done it. If I did these things, I don't know what I used to do it. I must have done this again. The exact wording is disputed. Alma's sister, Mary Butler, who was Katie's aunt, testified against Katie, and Mary Butler stated that as Alma was dying. She said, be good to Katie. I'm not going to make it. Katie has poisoned me. She got me this time. Another one of Alma's sisters, Virginia, verified this conversation. When asked why they didn't share this information with anyone, they explained that Almah had asked them not to. Mary and

34:27 Virginia were respecting Almah's dying wish. During her first trial, Katie did not testify. In fact, the only defense her lawyers presented was a ninety minute speech centered largely on the fact that Katie had no motive. After over eight hours of deliberation, the jury convicted thirty three year old Katie Strickland a first degree murderer in the case of her father in law in a split decision of eight to four. Katie was sentenced to twenty years and one day in prison. Following her conviction and sentencing, Katy motioned for a new trial, but it was overruled. She tried to appeal, but it was denied by the Supreme Court of Tennessee. Katy's second trial, this one for the attempted murder of her mother in law, Molly Strickland, began in late August of nineteen seventy two, and it was very similar to her first trial. The same people spoke, the same evidence was brought up, and Katy still didn't testify.

35:24 Perhaps the only difference was sixty six year old Molly Strickland's testimony, but that didn't go well. Molly couldn't remember if she had eaten the jello out of the big unpoisoned bowl or the small poisoned one. And there was one other big difference between this trial and the last one. This time Katy was found not guilty after less than an hour of deliberation. The jury determined that there was not enough evidence to convict Katy. The jury foreman explained to the Tennesseean that there were simply too many gaps in the states case against Katy. How could that possibly be if she was convicted on the same evidence less than a year or earlier. What had happened for this child to have gone so differently? Well, a few things. First, it is true that the only evidence the state had against Katie was entirely circumstantial. No one had witnessed Katie poisoning her in laws, and of course they wouldn't have the nature of this crime is secretive, and Katie's lawyers were now very prepared for this trial.

36:28 They had seen the state's case in detail, and they used that to their advantage. Katie's defense team pointed out the following information, which was apparently compelling to the jury. According to Katie, she didn't make the jello and separate bowls to poison Molly. She had done it because the doctors thought Molly might have had a virus, so Katie was trying to keep Molly's food separate from the other family members in the household who were visiting for William's funeral. Next, Katie didn't purchase the jello for Molly until the physician ordered us off food diet. With this line of thinking, Katie couldn't have masterminded poisoning Molly since she didn't know that the doctor would prescribe the specific food regiment. Next, Katie's lawyers really took advantage of Molly's confusion over which bowl she ate the jello out of, and Katie's defense team also claimed that the arsenic poisoning symptoms could have been caused by the prescription medication that Molly was given after her first round of sickness. Lastly, Katie had returned to Molly's home on Monday, June seventh, when she took Molly to the hospital. If she had tried to kill Molly, why didn't she destroy the jello. Then it sounds like Katie's lawyers were just throwing shit at the wall to see what stuck. But the jurors were probably so confused by the end of the trial they didn't feel comfortable convicting Katie. But all of this, in my eyes, is explainable.

37:53 Katie didn't purchase the jello before the doctor prescribed it, true, but she was just looking for opportunities to kill Molly. It could have been jello, tea, Coca cola, it didn't matter. Next, Molly was just wrong about which jello bowls she ate out of. It was a stressful time for her. Her husband died, she was sick, she didn't know up from down, and Molly had to take the doctor's prescription medication because Katie had poisoned her tea earlier that week well allegedly even though she had been convicted of poisoning Molly's husband at the same time. And lastly, Katie didn't destroy the jello because she didn't understand it could be tested for arsenic. That's why she was so flabbergasted when it came to the hospital. As I said, Katie asked Ray a million questions about how the doctors could do that. But however, all this happened, Katie's lawyers worked their magic, and she escaped her second trial scott free. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break.

39:02 Next was Katie's third trial, and this one was for the alleged murder of her own mother, Almah. And yes, the local authorities had also exhumed an autopsied Katie's father, Nelson, but they were holding on to the results until after these three trials. Katie's first trial for her mother's murder ended in a hung jury. After nine hours, the jurors could not make a decision, so the judge declared a mistrial and Katie had another trial, her fourth, in December of nineteen seventy three. According to the state, Katie had poisoned her own mother through a mill of cornbread and milk, but according to Katie, who was testifying for the first time ever, that wasn't true.

39:45 When asked if she killed Almah, she told the lawyer no, sir. Instead, Katie told the court she was very, very close to her mother. Then, Katie depicted her mother as a depressed woman who was overwhelm by grief after Nelson's death. To illustrate her mother's alleged mental health struggles, Katie said Almah would often visit Nelson's grave, and Almah would supposedly tell Katie, when you buried your father, you buried me. Katie insinuated that Almah probably took her own life by jesting arsenic on purpose. And in regards to Katie's weird babbling confession at the time of her arrest for William's murder and Molly's attempted murder, Katie said she was just trying to ask the officers what happened.

40:32 She clarified that she wasn't saying I must have done it. Instead, Katie says she meant to convey if I did it, I don't remember it, so will you please help me remember what kind of poison was it? What container was it in? How did I give it? Was it in the food? Katie's lawyers claimed that she was very upset because she had never been arrested before, but the jury didn't buy Katie's story. This time. On December fifth, nineteen seventy, after deliberating for four and a half hours, they convicted thirty five year old Katie Levina Browder Strickland a first degree murder for poisoning her mother, Alma. She was sentenced to life in prison.

41:12 At this news, Katie had no emotional reaction. As soon as the trial concluded, the local district attorney tried to indict Katie for her father's murder as well. The autopsy of Nelson Alexander Browder had revealed that he too was poisoned with a large amount of arsenic. But through some legal footwork that was not explained in the local newspapers, I found Katie was cleared of all charges related to her father. Honestly, maybe the court system was tired of Katie Strickland, and after all, she was going to be in prison for the rest of her life. Perhaps they were fine to let her get away with this one murder. That's more unusual these days. Prosecutors won't hedge their bets that way in case of appeals. I wish this story ended here, but it and that's because in January nineteen seventy nine, Tennessee's then Governor Ray Blnton made one of the most shocking political moves the United States had ever seen. It was on the front page of almost every newspaper in the state and many national papers as well. Five days before his term ended, he granted clemency to fifty two convicts. Forty two of them were felons, including twenty three murderers and fifteen armed robbers. Their sentences would be reduced by huge amount. Many of them would immediately be eligible for parole. As Blanton signed the paperwork putting these decisions into motion, he was quoted as saying, this takes guts.

42:40 The Secretary of State, who was in the same room, replied, yeah, some people have more guts than they've got brains. Governor Ray Blnton's actions caused a storm of controversy in Tennessee. The public was outraged, and Blenton's only explanation was that he was being pressured by a court order from the state Erection Department to reduce the prison population. It's hard not to wonder if Blanton was giving the State of Tennessee, or maybe some of his political opponents, a big middle finger, or worse, freeing co conspirators. Blanton hadn't run for reelection in the nineteen seventy eight election in lieu of pending investigation and scandal.

43:22 He eventually served twenty two months in a federal prison for male fraud, conspiracy, and extortion in his side hustle of selling liquor licenses. It was said that Blaton planned a pardon more before Lamar Alexander's inauguration five days later, but the Lieutenant governor and state Speaker of the House found a loophole in the state constitution about when a new governor can be sworn in, so they swore in Alexander three days early to stop Blanton. It was jokingly called impeachment Tennessee style. If you're a longtime Southern Fraud listener, or maybe someone who has recently binge listened, you may remember the governor Ray Blnton's name. I've mentioned him in at least two other episodes. The first one way back in number fourteen. Blatton pardoned the convicted killer of Paula Herring in that episode. But anyway, Katie Levina Browder benefited from the corrupt governor, she was no longer Katie Strickland. Ray had sued her for divorce two years earlier, in nineteen seventy seven. He would remarry in the eighties. Meanwhile, Katie's first degree murder convictions were knocked down to second degree murders and her life sentence was reduced to ten years. The moment that Tennessee Governor Bletten signed the papers, Katie was up for parole. Katie was released from prison on the fourth of July and nineteen eighty one. At some point after that, she tried working in South Carolina at her friend's beauty shop. When that didn't work out, she ended up in Knoxville, Tennessee. She got a job at her cousin's mobile

44:54 home business. When she was approached by the Jackson Sun reporters to discuss her criminal past, she said, I know it's all public, but I'd rather not talk about it. It's all over with and I don't want to bring it back up. On March first, nineteen ninety five, fifty six year old Katie Browder died from leukemia. She was buried in the Highland Memorial Cemetery in Knoxville, Tennessee, and her obituary is the familiar line proceeded in death by parents. Of course, they left out that Katie killed them, which I have pointed out before is not unusual. Back when obituaries were the norm, most family members of murderers didn't list their crimes. But you would think a notorious arsenic poisoner would have been front page news upon her death. However, Katie Strickland and her victims were apparently forgotten by history. By then.

45:47 The famed arsenic murderess didn't even warrant the front page when she was pardoned, swamped by all the other convicts involved in the scandal. Katie lived a very quiet life after that, though it was short, but she did live five years longer than her mother, who died a horrific death at her hands. All of her victims suffered tremendously before their deaths, while Katie behaved strangely, or at least seemed indifferent. Sometimes she is a bit of an enigma, like many poisoners. With her parents, there was probably a financial motive. That's a modier issue. With her in laws, who had eight children, maybe she had gotten a taste for killing by then she enjoyed watching them suffer.

46:36 Who knows what lies in the stony heart of a poisoner like Katie browder Strickland. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank and me, and of course all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Fried's original music is by Rob Harrison of a Gamma Radio and the original graphic art is by Coli Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon scheck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. The case was recommended by Kathy and several others. Incidentally, I love to cover older cases like these, especially reading those old wedding announcements, but they do have one problem. Andrea was worried that we had so much more biographical information about Katie instead of her victims. That's not really unusual considering their ages. Katie was in the paper all the time about all kinds of things, especially details about her wedding, all of which was normal for that era.

47:37 Her victims were of a different generation, but we did the best twe could to humanize them. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. You'll get lost in a sea of emails if you send it to my main address, so this is the best way for me to get those little known cases you'll always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Froud True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Partner, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shut asses allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group.

48:32 If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like iHeart, Spotify, Amazon, and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening y'all take care,