183: The Brutal Murder of Avis Banks
28-year-old Avis Banks was five months pregnant and exhausted. On the evening of Wednesday, November 29th of 2006, Avis was driving home after a long day at work. All she wanted to do was go home, kick off her shoes, and relax. But Avis would never...
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional Writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Case recommended by Denita, Melissa and many others
Sources: http://southernfriedtruecrime.com/avis-banks
Today’s Sponsors:
- Save over 40% off your starter pack at LumeDeodorant.com and use code SFTC
- Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey. Download today on iOS or Android.
- Treat yourself to the best shapewear on the market and save 20% Off at honeylove.com/SFTC.
- Try Beam’s best-selling Dream Powder and save up to 40% at shopbeam.com/southernfried and use code southernfried at checkout.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:01 Southern Fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used listener discretion as advised. From August of two thousand and six to May of two thousand and seven, the Jackson Public School District of Jackson, Mississippi, had a really difficult year. It seemed like nothing could go right for them. They fired a middle school principle for alleged financial misconduct. Then that fired middle school principle turned around and accused the superintendent of sexual harassment. A high school teacher was arrested for possessing a jaw dropping amount of cocaine, and an elementary school teacher was convicted of killing her husband. I can only imagine the rumor mills during this time. Students probably whispered to each other, was it your teacher arrested for cocaine? Or was yours convicted of murder? The Jackson community probably nothing could make that school year any stranger. But they were wrong. And that's because when in the same academic school year, two Jackson Public School teachers were caught having an extra marital affair, a male science teacher and a female language arts teacher. Then In a shocking turn of events, one of those teachers was convicted of murdering unexpecting mother, and the other fled the state. Welcome to episode one eighty three, the brutal murder of Avis Banks. Late November in Mississippi isn't like
1:37 autumn in the North or even other parts of the South. The weather is only starting to fill crisp, with the days in the high fifties and sixties and the lows at night in the forties. But the leaves have already changed. So if you want to see the gorgeous colors of autumn in Mississippi, you need to visit in late October to early November. In this part of the South, Friday nights are for football and Saturday mornings are for raking leaves. On a Wednesday, the week after Thanksgiving in two thousand and six, it was one of those perfect days when the temperature had risen to the seventies that day and by dusk there still wasn't much of a chill in the air.
2:19 A young expectant mother named Avis had gotten off of work and was headed home. In her fifth month, Avis was tired. She had called her fiancee Keion, who was a teacher and basketball coach, to see what he wanted to do for dinner. Since he was at basketball practice late and Avis was tired, he said he would pick up some takeout dinner for the couple. When practice ended, Avis pulled her car in the driveway and used the automatic garage door opener to get in the house. She stayed in her car until the door went down, like she always did, to make sure she was home safe. But as soon as she stepped out of her car, she was shocked from shop blasts. It happened so fast that Avis was found with her keys still in her hand. She may have never even known who shot her, but they knew her. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Avis Marie Banks was born on August eighteenth, nineteen seventy nine, to parents Deborah and Frederick of Vicksburg, Mississippi. She also had two sisters. Vicksburg was and is a small town on the western border of Mississippi. It has a population of about twenty thousand people, and it also has a ton of Civil War museums and landmarks, which makes sense. Back in July of eighteen sixty three, two years before the end of the Civil
3:50 War, Vicksburg was the site of a crucial battle. Whoever controlled Vicksburg controlled the Mississippi River, and that was important. The Mississippi River was a key asset for transportation and supply reasons. The Union and Confederacy fought for several days. Thirty seven thousand lives were lost. Eventually the Union won, which was a big deal. With this victory at Vicksburg, the Union might have ended the entire Civil War. Lincoln even wrote a letter to a general indicating as much. All they had to do was take out General Robert E. Lee's army at the Potomac River in Maryland that same month. But Lee's army escaped and the war went on for two more years. But let's get out of the eighteen sixties and move back into the nineteen eighties and nineties, because Vicksburg isn't just a Civil War town. It's also where a young miss Avis Banks grew up. Avis was a quiet, soft spoken, and gentle young woman, the textbook definition of an introvert. She kept to herself and preferred staying in to going out, but when she did socialize, people remembered her as being kind and sweet. The one thing everyone knew about her. Avis loved children. In nineteen ninety seven, she graduated from Warren Central High School in Vicksburg. Then she went forty five miles south to attend Alcorn State University in Clayborne County, Mississippi. There she earned her bachelor's degree in early childhood Development.
5:26 In two thousand and two, Avios hoped to launch her own daycare one day. Her father, Frederick Banks, told Declarion Ledger that he and Avis had even looked at a few potential daycare buildings together, but she needed more time before committing to a lease. In two thousand and four, twenty five year old Avis was living in her hometown of Vicksburg, Mississippi, when she met twenty nine year old Keion Pittman. They crossed paths while working out at their gym. Avis was immediately smitten with Keion. He was confident, charming, handsome, and he knew all the right things to say. Plus, Keion and Avis had a lot in common. Keion had also attended Alkhorn State University, and he, like Avis, loved kids. He had gotten his bachelor's degree in education. Keion and Davis felt like a match made in heaven.
6:21 Two like minded individuals who would devote themselves to improving children's lives. A year after Avis and Kion began dating, in two thousand and five, Keion got a new job. He was to be the sixth grade science teacher and basketball coach at Chastain Middle School. It was forty seven miles east of Vicksburg and Jackson, Mississippi, so Keion and Avis, who were still going strong, moved to Jackson together. They got an apartment, they found a church, and Avis was hired at a local childcare called Bright Horizon Daycare. Avis and Keion looked like they were doing really well. Her new daycare loved her.
7:01 Her boss told the Clarion Ledger that she was a wonderful employee. And Keion was having a great time teaching and coaching at Chastain Middle School. And to help with money, Keon had taken a part time job as a bartender at the local Mexican restaurant. In Avis's parents' eyes, this was a green flag, a sign that Keion would do whatever it took to make sure that Avis was financially secure. Her father, Frederick Banks, told Snapped he was a very good provider. So in June of two thousand and six, when Avis became pregnant, it might have felt a little bit like fate rather than an accident. Sure, Avis and Keion weren't planning for a baby, but they would have gotten there eventually. Right. Maybe this was just one of life's little blessings, happening a bit earlier than expected. But Avis's parents struggled to see it that way. They were Christian folk who didn't want their grandchild to be born out of wedlock. Avis's dad said that she was going to make it right by marrying Keion, and so Keon and Avis became engaged.
8:07 They planned their wedding for January of two thousand and seven. Their new child would be born some time around March that year. It wasn't quite a shotgun wedding, but it was close, and as a result, Avis's parents were pretty worried that Keion was going to get cold feet. Her mother, Debora Banks told Snapped, WE knew that Avis wanted to be married to him, but I don't think he really really wanted to be married yet. Regardless, it seemed like her parents' concerns might have been misplaced. After all, Keion was excited to be a husband and father. He was thrilled when they found out that Avis was having a little boy, and he was even more excited to help pick out his unborn son's new name, Kelon. Keion was adamant that he didn't want to raise his child in an apartment, so he and Avis bought any house in Ridgeland, which is a suburb of Jackson. It was only a twenty minute drive from Chastain, where he worked. On Wednesday, November twenty ninth of two thousand and six, Keion and Avis had been dating for over two years. Their wedding was two months away, and both of them were very busy. For Keion, the fall semester was winding down with winter break just around the corner. The kids were getting squirrely in the classroom. As for Avis, she was five months pregnant and planning a wedding.
9:33 Plus Thanksgiving was the week before, and Davis's parents had come over that Sunday to help her put up Christmas decorations. So on this particular Wednesday, Avis was exhausted. The Thanksgiving holiday had worn her out. They had traveled to Houston, Texas for Thanksgiving Day and then back to Picky in Mississippi. That weekend for another family get together, and she had worked late that day. She was just then heading home at five fifteen p m. On the way, Avis called Keion. He was also going to be home late because he had to coach the boy's basketball practice. During this conversation, Avios and Keion decided they weren't up to cook and dinner that night. Keion promised he would grab some food on the way home, but he couldn't talk to Avis for long. Basketball practice was starting. At about five forty five pm, Avis pulled her late model Honda Accord into her driveway and grabbed the mail, just like normal. Her house was lit up with Christmas lights. Then she opened the garage and parked inside it just like normal. She turned off the car and used the remote to close the garage door. As an extra safety precaution and the final part of her coming home routine, Avis waited to get out of her vehicle until the garage door was completely shut, just like normal.
10:58 But when AVOs got out of her car, she was ambushed. Her attackers shot her four times with a handgun. The first bullet hit Avis's thigh, incapacitating her. Then three additional shots were unloaded into Avis's body at close range. The final shot was delivered execution style to the back of Avis's head. She never had a chance to defend herself. Even though the unknown attacker had shot Avis Banks four times, they weren't done yet. Next they pulled out a knife and stabbed her body numerous times. The last wound was a vicious slash across Avis's throat. Then they left. Avis's body went undiscovered for three hours. At eight forty five pm, Keion came home from basketball practice and that's when he opened the garage door to a nightmarish scene straight out of a horror film. I'm going to pause now to hear our word from today's sponsors. Everyone loves a good family mystery, especially one with as many twists and turns as June's Journey. Escape to a bygone age of mystery, danger, and romance. As you immerse yourself into the world of June's Journey, a hidden object mystery mobile game that puts your detective skills to the test.
12:20 Play as June Parker and investigate beautifully detailed scenes of the nineteen twenties with hundreds of mine teasing puzzles. The next clue is always within reach. I love to decorate, so I let my imagination run while decorating my own island estate. Right now in chapter five, I'm working on improving Orchid Island. It is so much fun to slip away for some me time with June's Journey. I love the era, I love the mystery, and I love decorating my own little world. And I know that you true crime lovers like me will get sucked into the suspense of June's mystery. Can you crack the case? Download June's Ernie for free today on iOS and Android. Today's episode is sponsored by Loomi, and I'm so excited to tell you about it because, as the first of its kind whole body deodorant, you can use Loomi anywhere.
13:13 Loomy is seriously safe to use anywhere on your body, pits, under boobs, thigh folds, belly buttons, butt cracks, volvas, and feet. I have very sensitive skin and it's hard to find a product to use on my under arms, much less anywhere else. Loomy is awesome. It's aluminum free, baking, soda free, parabin free, and pH balanced for safe use below the belt. And it's clinically proven to block odor all day and control odor for up to seventy two hours. Loomy Starter Pack is perfect for new customers. It comes with a solid stick deodorant, cream tube deodorant, two free products of your choice like many body wash and deodorant wipes, and free shipping. As a special offer for listeners, new customers get five dollars off a Loomy Starter Pack with code SFTC at Loomy Deodorant dot com slash s FTC that equates to over forty percent off your starter pack. When you visit Loomy Deodorant dot com and use code s FTC for five bucks off up to forty percent in savings, go to Loomy dot com slash s ftc. That's lum dot com slash s ftc. When thirty one year old Kim Pittman walked into his garage at eight forty five that night, he probably couldn't believe his eyes. His fiancee, who was also the mother of his unborn child, twenty seven year old Avis Banks, had been murdered and it was brutal.
14:37 Avis lay in a pool of blood on the garage floor next to her Honda. She was wearing her work scrubs and a jacket. Her car keys were still clutched in her hand, scattered on the floor around her arms and purse was the mail she had just retrieved from the mailbox. Keyon, who was undoubtedly in shock, said he ran to Avis's body and show her, trying to rouse her frantic. He said he kissed Avis's cold lips, and then he pulled out his cell phone, but he didn't call nine one one. Instead, he called a co worker from Chastain Middle School, a twenty five year old cheerleading coach and language arts teacher named Carla Hughes. When Keion called, Carla was already on the phone with her mother, Linda. Carla had called her mom after finishing up with her evening jog at around eight thirty pm.
15:31 Now she was cooling down and chit chatting with Linda. Carla put Linda on hold because Keon was calling her. When Carlo spoke to Keion, he explained everything and he asked Carla to come over. Carla switched back to the line with her mother and relayed the situation to her. Linda was immediately confused. Why was Keion calling Carla? Why did he want Carla to go to his house a murder scene. Was he out of his mind? What Keian needed to do? Linda told her daughter was called the police. She told Carla not to go to Keion's house. Carla switched to Keion's phone line and told him to call the police, but strangely, Keion still didn't call nine one one. After ending the call with Carla, Keon ran to his next door neighbor's house. A married couple lived there and they were shocked to hear Keon screaming at their front door. By the time he started banging on their front door, the married couple had already called nine one one, not for Avis, but because some strange man had lost his mind on their doorstep, and the recorded nine one one call you can hear the situation unfold. Keon's female neighbor tells the nine one one operator that some one is trying to break into her home. Meanwhile, her husband goes to see what's going on with Keon. After some muffled conversation between the husband and Keon, you can hear the husband yell somebody killed his wife, and then the wife says to the dispatcher, oh my god, he said somebody dun killed his wife. Minutes
17:07 later, the police arrived at Keyon's home. Officers found him holding Avis's limp body right away. The emergency responders separated Keion from Avis and declared her dead, and then his home was searched. As the investigators looked through a Keyon's home, they realized that it had been robbed, or at least it looked like it had been robbed. There were two clear footprints on the back door where someone had kicked it in, and the place was a mess. Items were pulled out from drawers, Electronic devices had been unplugged and strategically stacked as if someone was getting ready to carry them out, but nothing was actually stolen.
17:49 Anything worth stealing remained in Keyon and Avis's home, and the crime itself didn't look like Avis had walked in on a robbery. For one thing, Avis hadn't even opened the door to her home. Her keys were still in her hand. She had no idea there was a robbery taking place. Whoever was in her home had plenty of time to escape unseen. Also, her pants were pulled down as if to indicate she was possibly sexually assaulted, but the autopsy would prove that was false, and the police still believed that the way Avis was murdered didn't feel like a robbery. Whoever killed her had overdone it. Four shots, multiple stabs, and a slash across the throat.
18:33 This felt like rage, not like some random criminal trying to make a quick buck. Investigators suspected that the killer had a personal motive for wanting Avis Banks dead. Detectives concluded that this burglary was staged to cover up the murder of Avis, and their first suspect for the killer was Keyon. After all, his clothes were covered in blood when the officers arrived, and the shoeprin on the back door were the same size as Keion's feet, a men's size eight. Additionally, the officers also thought it was odd that Keion, who always parked outside and walked into the house through the front door, had opened the garage door that night. But Keion had also called Avis on his way home.
19:18 When she didn't pick up, Keion was already a little worried. Perhaps he had no idea what was in the garage. He just decided to open the door to see if Avis's car was there. Since she didn't answer his call, or perhaps Keion opened the garage because he already knew what he would find. And another mark against Keion was the whole why didn't he call nine one one question? He had his phone on him, and he had called a coworker. What stopped him from getting help in the most efficient way possible? Calling nine one one is almost a knee jerk reaction for most people in an emergency, and if they don't call nine one one, a close family member makes more sense for someone in shock, not someone you work with.
20:04 The police weren't sure that Keion was telling the whole truth. That same night, they took him to the station for questioning. As he waited in the video recorded interrogation room, he went through a range of emotions. Sometimes he was sad, at other times he was angry. When he called a lawyer on his cell phone, he said, these motherfuckers think I had something to do with this shit. Frank Dillard, the Originland detective who questioned Keion, remembered that sometimes Kion would laugh or tell jokes as if he didn't realize the seriousness of the situation, as if he didn't really mind that his fiance, Avis and their unborn baby were gone, I'm not telling you this to sway you against Keion. I'm telling you this. You understand why the police were suspicious of him. Everyone is going to grieve in their own way, but the police can only go off of what they have, and right now, what the police department had was Keion, a rather unconcerned man who had not called nine one one for his fatally wounded fiance and his unborn child. And investigating the person who finds the dead body is normal standard operating procedure. Additionally, it gave the police an opportunity to ask Keon questions. That way he could be cleared as a suspect. When the police asked Keion why he didn't call nine one one himself, he said he wasn't sure where his phone call was going to be routed. He said he was worried that since his phone was purchased in a different city, he would contact emergency responders who were too
21:38 far away. The detectives were not convinced by this answer, and frankly, that's not how calling nine one one works, but maybe Keion didn't know that. Next, the officers asked him where he was that afternoon and evening. He said he had taught at Chastain Middle School during the day, and then after school he had run some errands. He had picked up groceries and then dropped them off, but not at his and Avis's house. He had dropped them off at Carlo Hughes's apartment, the same twenty five year old cheerleading coach and teacher for Chastain Middle School that Keion called instead of the police. According to Keion, he needed to get back to the school building for basketball practice.
22:22 He didn't have time to go home and put the groceries in his own house and returned to school, so he had temporarily stored them at Carlos place. Her apartment was closer to Chastain Middle School, and if you're wondering the logistics of this, dude, checkout. Carlo's apartment was closer to the school than Keyon's house, and her place was in between the grocery store at Chastain Middle School. Then Keion explained to the officers that he went to basketball practice. Practice was over at about seven thirty PM. After that, he went to Carlos to grab the groceries. He spent some time there and then he went home. That's when he found Avis's body. As you can imagine, this interview didn't make the police feel confident about Keion's innocence. They dubbed him a person of interest, But after they did gunshot residue testing on his hands and confiscated his bloody clothing and shoes, they did let Keyon leave the station without making an arrest. While the police were waiting for Keion's test results and clothing analysis, they continued to look into him. They visited the Mexican restaurant where he moonlighted as a bartender. There they spoke to his co workers, and his co workers had a lot to say. Apparently, Keion was well known as a womanizing player. He liked women, and he wasn't shy about it. According to Keion's restaurant colleagues, he was cheating on Avis with several different women. These women would stop by the restaurant when he was bartending.
23:52 They would order drinks, flirt, and sometimes even kiss Keion, and one of the most recent women was none other than Carla Hughes. Now investigators had heard Carla's name twice, once when Keon stored groceries at her apartment, and again from Kean's co workers, it was time for the police officers to actually speak with Carla herself. On December first, the officers went to Chastain Middle School to interview Carla. Right away, she was crying. When asked why she was so affected, Carla said she was upset about her close friend's fiance's murder. When Detective Frank Dillard asked Carla directly if she had a relationship with Keion, she denied it. According to his interviews with SNAPPED, Carla said, without a doubt they were not romantically involved. Obviously, they were absolutely romantically involved, but Carlo wouldn't admit it until the police asked her to go to the station that afternoon after school, and even then she would need some cajoling before admitting the truth. All throughout the sec at police interview, Carla kept reiterating, he's not a boyfriend. He's just a friend who's a guy, nothing sexual with him. She insisted that Avis knew who she was and knew about her and Keion's friendship. Carla said that Avis had even heard her and Keyon chatting on the phone on multiple occasions. But when Detective Dillard sternly asked, were you two romantically involved. Don't lie to me about this.
25:26 Carla changed her story. She said, yes, she had been sexually involved with Keion, but now Carla added it wasn't serious. She said it was not a full blown romantic love affair, and she said specifically that she'd never ever want Kean to leave Avis for her. Their relationship hadn't been serious like that. It was, according to Carla, just sex. During this second round of questioning, Carla also explained where she was on November twenty ninth, when school got out and the students were dismissed. She and Keian chatted for a bit. They nailed down the details of how he was going to get the groceries, dropped them at her apartment and picked them up after basketball practice.
26:10 Then Kean went to go run his errands. He put the groceries in Carlo's apartment around five fifteen pm, and then his practice started at five thirty pm and went on till seven thirty. So at seven thirty five pm, Kean went to Carlo's place to pick up the groceries. According to Carla, Kean stayed for around forty five minutes and then left at about eight thirty pm. Once Carla had established a timeline. One thing became abundantly clear for the time that Avis was murdered from five to forty five pm to six pm. Carla did not have an alibi. Following these interviews, both Kian and Carlo were considered suspicious by the police working on Avis's case. They even wondered if Kean and Carlo had committed Avis's murder together. As the detective searched for more clues, they began looking in earnest for the murder weapons, a gun and a knife. Although they didn't have any leads on the knife yet, the police were able to narrow down the kind of gun the murderer had used.
27:18 Based on the crime scene, The detectives knew they were looking for a five shot revolver. There had been four shots in Avis's body and one stray bullet had gone through the garage door, so whoever shot the gun had emptied it of bullets, and whoever shot the gun had also had the forethought to pick up the shell casings off the ground. In a stroke of good luck for the police, a man reached out to them regarding Avis's case. His name was Patrick Nash and he was Carla Hughes's cousin, and Patrick told the police that Carla had recently borrowed a gun from his personal collection. She had wanted it for protection. Her neighborhood was a notorious slee unsafe area. Someone had even tried to break into her place recently, so three days before Avis was killed on Sunday, November twenty sixth, Patrick gave Carla his thirty eight caliber five shot revolver, as well as a three inch hunting knife. When Patrick handed over the gun to Carla, it was loaded, but when Carla returned the gun on December first, two days after Avis's murder, it was empty, and Carla did not return the knife. I'm going to pause now to are another word from today's sponsors. Did you know that poor sleep can cause weight gain, mood issues, poor mental health, and lower productivity. I have struggled with insomnia since I was a teenager, and I can always tell the difference when I've had a good night's sleep. That's why I'm so excited
28:49 to tell you about Beam. Beam Dream is healthy hot cocoa for sleep, and today my listeners get a special discount available on Beam's delicious dream powder. They're best selling healthy hot coco with only fifteen calories. Better Sleep has never tasted better. Dream contains natural sleep promoting premium ingredients. It's triple lab tested, contains no THHC, and you actually wake up refreshed. A recent clinical study revealed Dream helped ninety three percent of users wake up feeling more refreshed, and ninety three percent reported that Dream helped them get a more RESTful night's sleep. Just mix Beam Dream and too hot water or milk, stir or froth and enjoy before bedtime. As someone who loves a treat before bedtime, combining hot coco with a natural sleep aid is a literal dream for me. If you want to try Beam's best selling dream powder, get up to forty percent off for a limited time when you go to shopbeam dot com slash Southern Fried and use code Southern Fried to check out. That's shop Bam dot com slash Southern Fried and use code Southern Fried for up to forty percent off. Support for today's episode comes from Honeylove with Wedding Season on US. This is the ad you've been waiting for, whether you are a bride, a guest, or looking for an everyday fit Honeylove is your go to for all things shapewear.
30:07 My ninth anniversary is coming up soon, and looking back, I wish I'd had Honeylove. I remember abandoning my shapewear on just my second trip to the ladies room. No one wants to worry about that on your big day. You just want to look your best and still feel comfortable. Honeylove has revolutionalist compression technology so you no longer feel like you're suffocating while wearing effective shapewear, and Honeylove Shapewear has a convenient opening in the panty area for super easy bathroom no costume change required. Try Honeylove and you'll immediately feel and see the difference. We have an exclusive offer for my listeners. Get twenty percent off your entire order with our exclusive link Honeylove dot com slash sftc. Treat yourself to the best shapewear on the market and save twenty percent off at Honeylove dot com slash sftc. Again, that's Honeylove dot com slash sftc to get twenty percent off. Carla Anne Hughes was born in July of nineteen eighty one.
31:07 When she was very young, she was adopted by Carl and Linda Hughes. Both Carl and Linda were teachers in Greenville, Mississippi. They were prominent figures who were well respected in their community. They went to church on Sundays, They were friends with a mayor. Everyone liked them, and so of course everyone liked their adopted daughter, Carla. In fact, the small town of Greenville loved Carla. She was a bit of a rising star. She was beautiful, popular, and well liked. She competed in beauty pageants at the state and regional levels. She was a cheerleader, musician, dancer, honor student, and an award winning equestrian. Carla's friends remarked that she was always trying to better herself, and she was voted most likely to succeed in the nineteen ninety nine graduating class of TL Weston High School. After high school, Carla attended the University of Southern Mississippi. There, she completed her bachelor's degree in education, and at about the same time, Carla was in a long term relationship with a man. She and this man were engaged to be married, but he backed out only a few days before their wedding. He called the whole thing off, and Carla, now newly single, was pregnant with his child. When Carla's mother, Linda spoke to Snap, she said, the father backing out of the situation was kind of disappointing, but we sucked
32:37 it up like we always do when problems occur, and we moved on. Linda wasn't concerned about Carla being a single mom. She knew that Carlo's tenacity and perseverance would pull through. If anyone could raise a child on their own, it was Carla. And not long after all this, Carla gave birth to a baby boy. After that, Carla went to Belle Haven College for her master's degree in education. Then she started teaching kindergarten in Greenville around two thousand and four. To no one's surprise, teaching went really well for Carla. She was great at it. A friend of hers said, all the kids loved her, whether they were in her classroom or not. But Carla didn't stop there. She was determined for greatness. She enrolled at Telta State University and began studying for her Education Specialist degree. In case you don't know what that is, that's one of the highest academic achievements available for teachers.
33:35 In the summer of two thousand and six, Carla took a new teaching job in Jackson, Mississippi. She was going to work at Chastain Middle School, the same school where Keon Pittman worked. This career move wasn't an emotion for Carla. Nothing had gone wrong at her kindergarten position in Greenville or anything. Carla was just ready for a new challenge and better pay. And at Chastain Middle School, Carla could be a lead teacher, and they had also offered her a position as a cheerleading coach, which was extra money. Carlo was elated, but since she was hired right before school started in August, she had to scramble to prepare for her new job. Carlo's parents were happy to help their daughter out. They took care of her son while she found a place to live in Jackson, and that freed Carla up to look at a broader range of apartments. But since Carlo couldn't be picky about her new place on such short notice, she accidentally rented an apartment in a rough neighborhood.
34:34 Carlo's mother said, I was concerned about the safety, but school was about to start and she had to have somewhere to live. In early October, only three months after Carlo moved in, someone tried to break into her apartment. The perpetrator wasn't successful, but Carlo was still spooed. She began looking for a new place to live, but between teaching, parenting, and life in general, the apartment hunting process was slow going. But other parts of Carla's life were looking up. For instance, her new job was going very well. She loved working at Chastain Middle School and her colleagues loved her too. One colleague in particular liked Carla a lot, and that was, of course, sixth grade science teacher Keon Pittman. Carla and Keion met in August of two thousand and six when the Chastain Middle School year began. The two teachers bonded quickly, and soon after they connected at Chastain, Carla began hanging out at the Mexican restaurant where Keion worked part time. They would speak for hours and hours about school, about home, and about life. As Keion and Carla's friendship grew, they began spending more and more time together. Once Keion even visited Carlo's family in Greenville. It wasn't a long visit. Her dad, Carl remembered that he only spoke to Keion for about two minutes, just enough time for Carla to introduce her friend before they scaddled. We're not sure exactly the date when Carla and Keon's relationship became sexual, but Carla indicated
36:07 that it was fairly early on. They would have sex two or three times a week, and they weren't exactly careful about hiding it. The two lovers were definitely caught up in their passionate affair. On three occasions, Keion and Carlo waited until Avis wasn't home, and then they had sex in Avis's house. And that wasn't the only time Keion and Carla risked exposing their affair. They passed each other love notes in school, using students to ferry the messages down the hallways. They spoke to each other during the school day, They called each other almost daily, and they texted constantly. According to Keion, Carlo would tell her friends that he was her future husband. Keep in mind, Carla was fully aware that Keion was engaged to another woman, but for whatever reason, that didn't seem to bother her. I don't place one hundred percent of the blame on Carla for that. You never know what line of bs Keon was feeding her about his relationship with Avis. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Meanwhile, Avis had no idea about Carla.
37:19 She thought Carla was merely one of Kean's many co workers. Avis and Carla only ever met in passing once or twice. Occasionally, Keion would be on the phone with Carla in Avis's presence, But as far as we can tell, Avis never witnessed anything between Keion and Carla that would make her suspicious. And if you find yourself judging Avis just a little, thinking how could she not know? I would encourage you to stop. Avis loved Keion. He was her actual future husband, the father of her child. She trusted him, and you'd be surprised, which you can get away with when someone trusts you. As the police looked deeper and deeper into Carla, they became more and more suspicious of her motives. Sure, she had said the relationship between her and Kion was just sex, but what's she telling the truth?
38:10 Was she more enamored with Keion than she had let on could she have wanted Avis dead? The police knew they couldn't trust Carla, especially since she had lied to them about the nature of her and Keion's relationship, saying it wasn't romantic when it definitely was. And then there was the second lie that Carla had told. Because she hadn't just lied about her relationship with Keion, she had also lied about having access to a gun. During Carla's second police interview, when she had finally admitted to the affair with Keion, she had also told the police she didn't own a gun. When they prompted Carla again asking if she had access to a firearm, she said no, she most certainly did not. She even went on to explain that her father had many guns, but she didn't. But as we know, Carla was lying. She had had her cousin's gun during the time when Avis was murdered, and she had his hunting knife too, and when she returned the five shot revolver to her cousin after Avis was killed, the previously loaded gun was now empty.
39:13 Carla told her cousin that she had done some target practice, that's why the bullets were gone, But the cousin had gone to the police anyway. Thank God for people who do the right thing, regardless of who it might implicate. Later in court, it would come to light that when Carla's family approached her and asked hay was cousin Patrick's gun involved in Avis's murder, Carla allegedly just looked down and shrugged. The police took Carlo's cousin's gun for testing. Then on Wednesday, December sixth, they asked Carla to come down to the station for additional questions. This would be her third round of police interviews, and this time Carlo brought a lawyer. She could see the writing on the wall. This wasn't going to go well, and it didn't. That same day, Carla was arrested for being an accessory to Avis Banks's murder. On December seventh of two thousand and six, the day after Carla was arrested, the police searched her home. They were looking for the missing shell casings, the knife. Her cousin gave her, bloodstained clothing or gloves, shoes matching the print at the crime scene, and any correspondence between her and Keion that would help establish their ongoing relationship. During the search, detectives didn't find the knife, but they did find a pair of shoes that matched the two shoe prints on Avis's back door. They were Carla's women's sized tin black tennis shoes from a brand called tread Safe. They were the kind of heavy duty,
40:45 non slip, thick soled shoes a waitress might be required to wear in the service industry. Remember, the police had thought the shoe prints on the back door were keyons, and that's because Carla and Keion had the exact same shoe size. Women's size ten is the same thing as a men's size eight. But even though the shoeprints turned out to be Carlo's not Keion's, the police still thought Keion was involved. Actually, so far, the police had only charged Carla as an accessory to the murder because they believed Keion was the mastermind behind Avis's murder. They figured Keion wasn't ready to settle down and had wanted away out of his marriage and impending fatherhood with Avis. Law enforcement officers hoped that now that Carlo was facing an arrest charges in jail time, she might turn on Keion in exchange for a deal, But Carla didn't. In fact, she refused to speak with police at all, and Keion wasn't talking either.
41:44 His lawyer advised him not to go into the precinct anymore. Instead, the lawyer wanted the detectives to give Keion pre rotten questions, then Keion would answer them, presumably while his lawyer helped guide him. But the Rigeland police didn't like that. They wanted to speak to Keion in person, not through written answers filtered by his lawyer's advice. If you're a long time true crime finn, you've probably seen this pissing match before. Defense lawyers and cops don't get along, they aren't supposed to, and nothing productive ever comes from this ongoing feud. By the time everything was said and done, Keion never spoke to the police again, and therefore the police didn't get any definitive answers about Keion's involvement or lack thereof, and Avis's murder. The Ridgeland police named Keion as a suspect, but not because they had him dead to rights or anything.
42:38 They were pissed that they couldn't interview Keion on their terms anymore, and they more than likely named him hoping to shake things up either with Keion or with Carla. The same day that Carlo went for her third police interview, December sixth, two thousand and six, Avis Marie Banks was laid to rest at the Locust Grove Missionary Baptist Church Cemetery in Vicksburg. She was survived by her parents, sisters, cousins, and many friends and family, who were all devastated by her loss. They wanted answers, and their suspicions were on Keion. At Avis's funeral, the family's anger at Keion was simmered to a boil when they noticed he didn't seem to be crying or grieving. Avis's parents told Dateline that her older sister believed a woman might have killed Avis, a woman that Keion was fooling around with. The sister became enraged and was about to go after Keion physically, but was stopped by another family member. Other folks and Avis's family grew angry and the scene became so heated that the police, who were on hand had to escort Keion out of the funeral home with a coat over his head. Two days after Avis was buried, on December eighth, two thousand and six, the police charged Carla Hughes with two counts of capital murder, one for Avis Banks and one for her unborn son, and the state of Mississippi a five month old fetus is considered a human being
44:13 in murder cases. Carlo was held without bell at the Madison County Detention Center. Once again, the police weren't sold that Carla had actually committed this crime by herself. They hoped that these charges would incentivize Carla to flip on Keion. The police even told Carla's attorney as much, but still Carla would not implicate Keyon. She remained silent. Carla's friends, family, and hometown community were shocked by these developments. Carla had killed a pregnant woman. Our Carla, there must be a mistake. Multiple people spoke to journalists from local newspapers expressing their disbelief that Carla, the all American girl they had all known in love, would do such a thing. One person told the Clarion Leger, the Carla Hughes that I know is an upstanding professional, intelligent, caring, dependable, and respectable friend. Another friend of Carlos said I hold her in very high regard, and another said I have never seen Carla act aggressively or even raise her voice for that matter. Carla's Greenville church, a congregation of over two hundred people, also stood behind her. The pastor, Gene Fowler, said she was very smart, energetic, motivated, a great role model for the other young people. The mayor of Greenville and about sixty additional Greenville residents wrote letters to the judge in Carla's case. They wanted Carla to be
45:45 granted bond so she could stay out of jail before her trial, but the judge refused. It wasn't out of spider anything. In Mississippi, a person charged with capital murder almost never receives a bond, and Carla had been charged with capital murder twice, she was most certainly going to sit in jail until her trial. The students and parents of Chastain Middle School were also shocked by this horrendous scandal. They didn't know what to make of any of it. Two teachers caught in an extramarital love affair, a wife and mother to be dead. One parent told the Clarion Ledger, it's just sat on both sides. The kids kind of knew before it got out, and they're just kind of confused they look up to teachers as role models. Carla had resigned from her Chastain Middle School teaching and coaching positions an early December of two thousand and six, probably when she was first arrested. It's unclear if Keyon was fired from Chastain Middle School, but he was recommended for termination that same December, and it appears that he never returned to teach their Following Avis's death, the general public was also flabbergasted. Richland was a nice neighborhood, not one where people feared break ins, staged robberies, shootings, and stabbings. Ridgeland's last homicide had occurred over a year earlier, and the public was especially horrified that Carla, a mother herself, was accused of murdering and expecting mother. I'm
47:21 going to pause now for a final commercial break. January of two thousand and seven, the month when Avis and Keion were set to be married, came and went. In February of two thousand and seven, Keion sold his in Avis's Richland home. He moved to Michigan, and less than a year later, in December of two thousand and seven, Keion married a different woman from Detroit, and in July of two thousand and seven, Carla was formally indicted, and in October of two thousand and nine, now twenty eight year old Carla Hughes's trial began. If you're like woe, that's three whole year years after the murder, You're right it is. It's not clear why Carlo's trial took so long to get started. Her lawyer, Johnny Walls, tried to do some legal sidestepping on Carlo's behalf, But most defense attorneys don't want to delay trial. By filing for a speedy trial, they're making sure their client doesn't sit behind bars for too long. And also it's often strategy giving the state less time to prepare, particularly in murder trials. But evidently the police never stopped trying to get a confession out of Carla. On Valentine's Day of two thousand and eight, they sent her a copy of Kean's marriage license to the woman in Michigan her date line. She said she wasn't surprised her attorney wanted Carlo's case to be thrown out because quote, Carlo was a descendant of slaves and experienced overt and cruel discrimination in Mississippi on the basis of race,
48:58 but this argument did not hold. A court. Also, Ridgeland switched district attorneys in the midst of Carlo's legal proceedings. I imagine that also slowed the process down, but still justice delayed is very painful for victims families. Finally, on October fifth of two thousand and nine, Carlo's trial began. The DA was seeking the death penalty due to the particularly vicious nature of Avis's murder, and her family publicly supported this decision. The state argued that Carlo killed Avis out of jealousy. She wanted Avis out of the picture so she could be with Keion. The prosecution claimed that Carla and Keion's relationship wasn't just sex, as Carla had previously told the police. In fact, the prosecution believed it was the exact opposite. Carlo was madly in love with Keion, but he didn't feel the same way about her, and Kion, who testified for the prosecution, agree with this assessment of their relationship. Kean told the court that Carla was furious that he wouldn't leave Avis for her. According to Keion, he and Carla had once had a pregnancy scare, and he said when Carla thought she was pregnant, she really pressured Kean to leave Avis, but he wouldn't. Kean's refusal to choose Carla made her so mad, allegedly that she started driving to Kean and Avis's house. If Keion wasn't going to tell
50:28 Avis about their affair, then Carlo would do it herself. Keion testified that the only thing that stopped Carla from exposing their relationship was that he threatened to call the police on her, assuming because she was stalking the couple, and yet he didn't end it with Carla, which might have diffused the situation. Keion also testified that there were other moments when Carla was frustrated by his commitment to Avis. For example, the week before Avis was murdered, Kean and Avis traveled to see family and Picayune, Mississippi, for Thanksgiving. The Saturday after Thanksgiving, and then Keion and Carla met up at a Picayune hotel.
51:09 According to Keion, Carla begged him to stay at the hotel with her for longer and longer, but he couldn't stay too late because he was in town to see family. Carla allegedly was put out by this, and their date ended poorly. The next day, Carla told Keion that quote, from this point on, some things are going to change. Then she borrowed her cousin's gun and hunting knife, and four days later Avis was dead. The prosecution proposed that Carla had snapped completely lost it. The prosecution insinuated that perhaps Carla's previous felled engagement back when her fiance and father of her child left her just days before their wedding, had made Keion's consistent rejection especially hurtful, and they painted Keion as a sympathetic grief leaving widower. He had a box of tissues with him while on the stand and everything, which ug this freaking guy.
52:07 Obviously, I am with Avis's family and have a really hard time finding sympathy for him. When Keion was asked why did you call Carla after finding Avis's body, he responded, because I was looking for anyone to come at that point. I didn't care. I just wanted someone there. And when asked if Keion ever intended to leave Avis for Carla, he said, no, Carla wasn't long term. His relationship with her was quote sexual, caught up in the moment. He was also asked if he killed Avis, to which he of course said no, but he did say that he felt partially responsible for Avis's death. The prosecution also proved that Carla's cousin's gun was the murder weapon. Ballistics experts testified and confirmed it with forensic testing, and an independent crime lab had found trace amounts of Avis's blood on the soul of Carlo's tread safe shoes, the same shoes that matched the shoeprints on Avis's kicked in back door. In response, Carlo's attorney tried to suggest that Carlo wasn't Avis's killer, Keion was. He suggested that Keon had gotten into Carlo's apartment with a key, he already had taken Carlo's cousin's gun, put on Carlo's shoes, traveled to his own home, kicked in his own back door, staged a robbery, killed Avis, and then framed Carla. This guy should write for the movies. But to support this, he pointed out that Carlo's hands hadn't
53:38 had any gun residue on them, while Keyon's hat, Mind you, it was a negligible amount a single particle of gun residue on each of Kean's hands. An expert testified that Keon easily could have gotten it from touching Avis's body, and we know that he was cradling her when the police arrived, and Carlo's hands would not have been tested the day that Avis was killed, so this is a stupid moot argument. But Carla's defense wasn't done. He also cast out on Kean's alibi, claiming that Chesting Middle School was near enough to his and Avis's home that he could have slipped out of basketball practice, killed her, and returned without anyone ever noticing. But that didn't hold up either, and for good reason. Kean's cell phone records placed him definitively, without a doubt, at the boys basketball practice during the time of Avis's murder, and we are one hundred percent certain that Keion attended the entire basketball practice without sneaking off to kill Avis because he was hitting on one of the player's mothers the whole time. Keion and this basketball mom were texting across the gym.
54:50 They couldn't speak out loud to each other because they wanted to hide their flirtatious conversation from any onlookers. After all, Keion was supposed to be engaged. Jesus, this guy and this mother, well, she wanted to hide her conversations with Keion because she was married. In the months after Avis's death, Keion would go on to have a sexual relationship with this married mother. But regardless of his shitty actions, he had an airtight alibi. He was at basketball practice when Carla killed Avis. That's all there is to it. There is still a chance that Keion colluded with Carla to kill Avis. If you'll recall, Keon did know to open the garage when he got home. Usually he would have just walked through the front door. And Carla did call Keyon at five thirty pm and again at six oh five pm, the exact window of time when Avis would have been killed. Perhaps Carla was discussing the murder plans with Keion. We'll never know. After all, Carla couldn't accused Keion of colluding with her without admitting she killed If this was true, I can only imagine Carla's silent, simmering anger at trial when she couldn't implicate Keion.
56:09 The detectives in Avis's case told Dateline they still believed Keon Pittman may have been an accomplice, but he never talked, and neither did Carla. What we do know is that when Carlo called Keion at five thirty pm and at six o five pm, her phone peemed a cell tower less than half a mile from Keon in Avis's house, placing her near the scene of the crime at the precise time the crime would have happened. At the end of the day, Keion never faced any charges, and he walked away from this entire ordeal scott free. On October twelfth, the defense rested their case. Carla did not testify in her own defense, and on October thirteenth, two thousand and nine, after deliberating for over eight hours, a Madison count NY jury found twenty eight year old Carla Hughes guilty of murdering Avis Banks and Avis Banks's unborn child. Upon hearing the news, Carla burst into tears. Avis's family was also emotional, but for different reasons. Avis's mother felt justice had been served, and her father told the Clarion ledger Avis can finally rest in peace.
57:23 The next day, Carla was sentenced to two life sentences without the possibility of parole. The jury had been uncomfortable recommending the death penalty for Carla since she was the mother of a five year old boy. Today, Carla Hughes is serving her two life sentences at the Central Mississippi Women's Correctional Facility in Pearl, Mississippi. She was denied a new trial in two thousand and ten. She uphealed that decision in two twelve, but was denied. Carla's parents raised her son. Her mother, Linda, continues to assert Carla's innocence. Keon, as I mentioned, moved to Michigan and married a woman from there. I would hope that he learned his lesson about cheating, but seeing as he kept up sexual relationships right after Avis's murder, I doubt it. Cheaters typically don't stop being cheaters, and if he was involved in Avis's murder, hopefully one day he will face judgment in this life or the next. As for Carla, I understand the jury's decision and respect it. John Dryden wrote, Jealousy is the jaundice of the soul. Avis Banks is now resting in peace, but I wonder if Carla Hughes is even capable of finding peace. Southern Fried True Crimes, hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched
58:59 and written by Andrew Marshbank, with additional writing by myself, and of course, all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio, and the original graphic art is by Holy Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon shuck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Rika Kelly. Thank you to Danita, Melissa and others for suggesting today's case. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. You'll get lost in a sea of emails if you send it to my main address, so this is the best way for me to get those little known cases.
59:39 Y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fred's True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share me. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fried but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shitasses allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like I Heart, Stitcher, Spotify and now Amazon, Audible and YouTube. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed