182: The Von Stein Attack aka The Dungeons & Dragons Murder
Bonnie and Lieth Von Stein went to bed on a Sunday night in July 1988 content and looking forward to a new future. Hours later, Bonnie would wake to the sound of her husband’s screams and an intruder standing at the foot of her bed. She barely...
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank & Erica Kelley
Additional research by Haley Gray
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Case recommended by Stephanie & Ainsley
Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/lieth-von-stein
Today’s Sponsors:
- Cancel your unwanted subscriptions with RocketMoney.com/southernfried
- Customize the US’s best home security system for your home by going to SimpliSafe.com/southernfried. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
- Access some of your hard-earned paycheck early. Download the EarnIn app and type in Southern Fried under podcast.
- Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:00 Southern fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. At four twenty seven am on July twenty fifth, nineteen eighty eight, a North Carolina dispatcher received a call from a woman who spoke very softly, saying, this is an emergency. I need the police and an ambulance. My husband may be dying and I think I may be too. When officers arrived, they found a horrific scene. There was blood everywhere in the bedroom, even on the ceiling. Forty four year old Bonnie von Steyn was lying on the floor of her bedroom suffering from life threatening injuries she would miraculously survive. Bonnie's husband, forty two year old Leath, was lying dead on the bed.
0:58 There was so much blood it was clear that someone had viciously attacked the von stein couple, but whoever was responsible was no longer at the scene. The house was empty except for Bonnie's daughter Angela, who had not been touched, even though she was only feet away from her mother's bedroom, and because it had been dark during the attack, Bonnie couldn't remember much about the intruder, just that he was wearing something over his face and was dressed in dark clothing from head to toe. Nearly a year would pass before the intruder was identified and the case was solved, and no one would be more shocked by the truth than Bonnie von Stein. Welcome to episode one eighty two, The von Stein Attack, also known as the Dungeons and Dragon's Murder. Forty four year old Bonnie Stein could barely get the words out would she die on the phone because they couldn't hear her. The Washington, North Carolina dispatcher was trying, and Bonnie, ever polite, apologized. She explained that the intruder may still be in the house, and when the operator asked for Bonnie's name, at first, she could only respond, I am bleeding. Bonnie had already struggled so hard just to get to the operator in nineteen eighty eight, Little Washington wasn't equipped with nine one one, so she had to press a bunch of
2:30 buttons on her phone until she got to an operator who connected her with the police. And she had been on the floor. She had dragged herself to the nightstand and pulled the phone down on top of herself with a cord and then tried nine, one, one before she remembered, and then started pressing random numbers until she finally got an operator. She managed to tell the dispatcher her name and address, and she explained that she and her husband had been attacked. She thought he was dead and she might be dying. The despatcher assured her that she had help on the way and kept Bonnie talking. When the police arrived at the von Stein home, the intruder was gone, but the scene was horrific. Police were initially startled by all the cats. They seemed to be all over the place. There would be thirteen in all, and one rooster. Bonnie was a member of the Humane Society and fostered the cats and I guess the rooster, even though she didn't live on a farm, but animal loving Bonnie thought nothing of bringing him in the house for the night. Once police maneuvered around the animals, they went upstairs to the bedroom on the right, as Bonnie had told the dispatcher. Despite her deadly injuries, Bonnie von Stein kept her wits about her. Police found the bedroom was absolutely covered in blood and there seemed to be two bodies, one on the bed and one on the floor. The body on the floor was Bonnie, the woman who had called for help. She was alive, but barely.
4:05 She had been stabbed in the chest and beat about the head with something like a baseball bat. The officers called despatch again, asking where the ambulance was. The situation was dire and nothing short of a miracle. Bonnie received medical treatment and time and survived, but unfortunately her husband wasn't so lucky. Forty two year old Leith von Stein was dead. He had died before the emergency responders had arrived. Leith had also been beaten and stabbed. His body lay on the bed, surrounded by a pool of red blood. Someone had viciously attacked Bonnie and Leith von Stein, someone angry, someone deranged, but whoever it was had fled the scene, and since Bonnie had been asleep when the attack started, she hadn't gotten a good look at the assailant. It was dark and she didn't have her glasses on. She was very near sighted, so even if she hadn't been in the midst of an attack, she couldn't see clearly, especially in the dark. The only thing she could recall with certainty was that he was wearing something over his face, and he was dressed in dark clothing from head to toe. For almost a year, no one knew who brutally murdered Leith von Stein and almost killed Bonnie von Stein, until finally, after eleven months, the attacker was unmasked, The case was solved, and the detectives who had relentlessly investigated for months and months probably celebrated.
5:39 An officer might have received a well deserved pad on the shoulder, maybe a supervisor bought everyone a round of drinks after work. But Bonnie von Stein was not celebrating, first of all, because of how long it took to get justice and how she had been treated by law enforcement. It was hurtful, and the early investigation was dismal. But more importantly, the man who had viciously attacked her, the man who had murdered her husband, the man who had single handedly decimated her entire life, was someone she never would have suspected. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Leith Peter von Stein was born on March sixteenth of nineteen forty six to his mother, Marie and his father, Howard, in New York City. He was an only child, and because of that he was a little spoiled. His mother, Marie doubted on him endlessly. Still, he was a good kid. He just knew from a young age that things were always going to go his way.
6:47 Later, Leith, a prolific jokester, would say they only had one because they were afraid to risk having another one like me. When Leith was a baby, the small von Stein family moved from Queens to Winston Salem, North Carolina, a city of over two hundred and fifty thousand people in central North Carolina. Leith's dad, Howard, was going to help out with his brother in law's dry cleaning business. It was called Camel City, and shortly after the von Stein's joined the business, Camel City became wildly successful. By the mid sixties, Camel City Laundry and Cleaners had several branches across the nation and over one hundred employees. Leith's dad, who had started as a general manager, had become a part owner, and the von Stein family was doing really well financially, and they were also doing really well in general. Leith and his parents lived in a quaint home and a nice part of town.
7:46 They went to church every Sunday, and Leith was thriving. He was a bright kid, and high school was a breeze. In nineteen sixty four, he graduated, and then he attended North Carolina State University to study engineering, but that didn't last long. Leith, a sheltered child, floundered with a newfound freedom that came with college plus engineering. School was difficult, and it was even more difficult if he partied hard and as often as Leith did. By his junior year in nineteen sixty seven, he had flunked out. In the late sixties, it was the height of the Vietnam War. As a result, in nineteen sixty eight, twenty two year old Leith von Stein was drafted into the US Army, but instead of getting shipped off to Southeast Asia, Leith somehow landed a safer assignment in Germany. Still, he left the army as soon as he could. He had only served two years, but that was fine with him. He never saw himself being happy with a lifelong career in the military. In fact, Leith's brief military experience made him disheartened about the government and the Vietnam War. According to Jerry Bledsoe's Blood Games, Leith would often ask his friends, why are we here? What are we doing? In nineteen seventy, twenty four year old Leith enrolled in Guildford College in Greensboro, North Carolina. Although he really did love numbers, he had been burned by his experience studying engineering at North Carolina State. This time around,
9:22 Leith wanted to study business, and that's exactly what he did in between getting high and drunk with his friends, of course, but that was okay. Leith managed to balance his business schoolwork and still enjoy himself. Leith's friends described him as offbeat yet charming. He was smart and clever, with a quick wit that would leave even the most stone faced professor grinning. And Leith wasn't shy. If he had something to say, he would say it, damn the consequences. And if you had something to say, you'd better be ready to defend your opinion because Leith was known for playing devil's advocate until long after the cows came home. One of Leith's friends told author Jerry Bledsoe in an interview, he would absolutely take it to the hilt, make you prove your point. Another friend said he liked to look at life in the absurd.
10:13 He was a structured person, but he was also a very creative person. Leith had a tremendous imagination. In December of nineteen seventy two, Leith graduated from Guildford College with his business degree. During college, he had developed an interest in computers, and so he merged his love for business and computers by accepting a programming position at Entigone, a North Carolina insurance company. They needed a computer genius, and Leith was just the right guy. While working at Entigone, Leith met a woman named Bonnie lou Bates Pritchard. She, like Leith, was incredibly smart, but unlike Leith, Bonnie was very shy, and she always had been. Blue. Bates had been raised along her sisters in rural Davidson County, which was only a few miles outside of Winston Salem. She loved reading and she loved animals, and in high school Bonnie had been on the newspaper staff and in the drama club. But still she was an incredibly shy woman. She was quiet, and as an adult it could make her seem unemotional. Her daughter, Angela inherited the same reserved trait.
11:28 Bonnie was extremely close to her parents, George and Polly Bates, and would lean on them tremendously after the attack. They were as salt of the Earth people and she had always leaned on them. Bonnie had a hard life starting out as an adult. After she graduated from high school in nineteen sixty two, she began working with computers at Entigon, and five years later, in sixty seven, she married her first husband, not Leth, but a different man. His name was Stephen Pritchard, and Stephen was younger than Bonnie. He was eighteen years old and still in high school when he and Bonnie tied the knot. She was twenty three years old. After their honeymoon, Stephen returned to high school to finish up his senior year, and Bonnie went back to work at Entigon. We would be horrified at this today. It would have been considered mildly scandalous then, but Bonnie Pritchard wasn't well known in their town, and neither was her young husband, so their marriage went unnoticed, or at least unremarked upon, and they started a family almost immediately.
12:35 A son named Christopher Wayne Pritchard came almost nine months after their marriage in nineteen sixty eight and second laughter, named Angela Christine Pritchard in nineteen seventy. Eventually, financial turmoil got the best of their relationship, and Bonnie and Stephen were officially divorced in November of nineteen seventy three. For the record, because I know I'll get comments, this is the exact age difference between me and my husband. But we got married in our thirties. There is a difference, and I of course understand that. But marrying a kid in high school would only be okay, and the era that Bonnie and Stephen did it, and marrying a high school kid certainly seemed to come with the consequence of him being too immature to be a husband or father. Stephen quickly left his family and Bonnie was on her own, trying to feed two small kids. There were a couple of very lean years, as Bonnie worked all the time and the Pritchard children either stayed in daycare or with Bonnie's parents. Bonnie tended to be over permissive with her kids because she felt guilty, something she kept up even when they were older. But not too long after her divorce, Bonnie and Leith, who knew each other from working together at Entigon began dating, but nobody knew about it. For reasons unknown, Leith had a history of being very secretive about his relationships with women. Maybe that's because while Leith was a
14:07 very charismatic guy, he wasn't traditionally attractive, and so asking women out was more of a struggle than he probably liked to admit. Perhaps he kept his relationships a secret to ensure he wouldn't be embarrassed if he was later rejected. It could also have been due to Bonnie's reserved sha nature. She was a very private woman. She worked hard to raise her kids, and she wasn't big on shows of affection, but in a way that made her the yen to Leith's yang. They were well matched, so Bonnie and Leith were probably dating long before their friends and family realized it. In the mid seventies. By nineteen seventy seven, Leith told his friends that he was thinking about marrying Bonnie. At that point, Leith had left Intigone for greener pastures, but he and Bonnie were still talking regularly. The only thing that held him back from popping the question was Bonnie's children, Christopher and Angela. At this point, Angela was nine years old and Chris was around eleven, and Leith hadn't spent much time with either of them, but Leith knew he wanted Bonnie.
15:16 He would figure out the rest like he always did. On August seventeenth, nineteen seventy nine, thirty three year old Leith married thirty five year old Bonnie, and fortunately, both of Bonnie's kids, Chris and Angela, seemed to be big fans of their new stepfather. According to author's Jerry Bledsoe and Joe McGuinness, who would both write famous books on the case, the beginning of the new family was a fairly peaceful transition, helped by the fact that Leith traveled a lot for work. Bonnie's kids didn't have to accept their new dad all at once, and they now had more of their mother's attention. It really seemed like everything was falling into place. Not long after the wedding, Leith became the chief auditor of a tech extall company called National Spinning Company in Washington, North Carolina, known as Little Washington. It was two hundred miles east of Winston Salem, but the move would be worth it. This was an executive position, which meant a lot more money, so Leith, Bonnie, Chris, and Angela packed their bags and moved three hours east Washington, North Carolina, is a small town, just like its nickname suggests, the type of place where everyone knows everyone and no one locks their doors. In the nineteen eighties, there were less than nine thousand residents, and National Spinning Company, the textall company Leith now worked for, was the city's largest employer.
16:42 I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. June's Journey is a hidden object mystery game with a captivating detective story taking you back to the glamor of the nineteen twenties. With a diverse cast of characters, each new scene takes you further through a thrilling murder mystery story that sets the main protagonist, June Parker, on a quest to solve the murder of her sister and uncover her family's many secrets. Engage your sense of observation to find hidden clues. Search for hidden objects from the parlors of New York to the sidewalks of Paris. Escape to a bygone age of mystery, danger and romance, and build your very own island estate with expansive gardens and beautiful buildings.
17:26 Relax and lose yourself in this captivating quest of mystery, murder, and romance. I am now in chapter five, and I just love the setting and the glamorous twenties, and I know true crime fans like me will enjoy solving the mystery yourselves. I like to slip away from my family and go lounge in my reading chair in my bedroom to lose myself in June's Journey for a while. Can you crack the case? Download June's Journey for free today on iOS and Android. I always feel guilty about my subscriptions. I have way too many and always forget to cancel, and with rising prices stressing us all out, I love that Rocket Money finally took care of it for me.
18:07 If you're looking for a way to cut costs, you need Rocket Money to Eighty percent of people have subscriptions they forgot about, so you're not alone. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that finds and cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps you lower your bills. All in one place. Rocket Money will quickly and easily find your subscriptions for you and for any you don't want to pay for anymore, just hit cancel and rocket money will cancel it for you. It's that easy. Rocket Money also helps you manage all your finances in one place and automatically categorize your expenses so you can easily track your budget in real time and also get alerted if anything looks off. Over three million people have used rocket Money, saving the average person up to seven hundred and twenty dollars a year. Stop throwing your money away, cancel unwanted subscriptions, and manage your expenses the easy way by going to rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. That's rock at money dot com slash Southern Fried, rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. The family settled in at one ten Losson Road, in a neighborhood known as Smallwood. It was the city's most exclusive area, as in, anybody who was somebody lived in Smallwood, and since the National Spinning Company was such a big deal in Little Washington, Leith's role as the chief auditor meant he was a somebody, and Leith didn't take that lightly. He worked hard, socialized just as hard, and quickly became a well respected Pillar of the little Washington community. From the outside looking in,
19:41 the vaughn Stein's seemed to be living the American dream. They had money, they had friends, they had family. What else could you possibly need? But Leith was unsatisfied. Friends of Leith's told A and E reporters that he sometimes said he wanted Bonnie's now teenaged chi Dren to move out of the house. He spent a lot of money on the children, but they didn't seem to appreciate it. He bought Chris a nineteen sixty five white Vintage Mustang souped up so you could hear the muffler coming from blocks away, but Chris didn't seem grateful enough for Leith. Nothing he did seem like enough. It was the same with Angela. But as far as his teenaged stepkids moving out, I'm not sure where Leith thought they would go, as Stephen Pritchard had never been much of a father to his kids. He wasn't even living in the state at this point and only saw his kids a couple of times a year.
20:37 Joe McGuinness wrote that Angela told Pritchard to his face that he wasn't her father, and she considered Leith her dad. You have to wonder if sometimes it was just plain old communication issues with Leith and his step kids. And you can't buy teenagers, even though it might seem like you can. Nothing replaces spending time with your stepkids to get to no trust and accept each other. But Leith was a very busy man. He worked hard, and he demanded respect from his stepchildren despite not being very close to them. Things were especially difficult with Chris, who was a student at Washington High School. Leith was frustrated by his stepson's laid back attitude, and he was disappointed that Chris didn't get good grades despite having the intellect. Leith saw potential in Chris, but it felt like Chris didn't see the potential in himself. Chris, as peers described him as moody, different, reserved, and weird, and Chris, by many accounts, was desperate for attention. He would do anything and everything to get it. Despite how Bonnie tried to connect with Chris, he was still always that kid in daycare, starved for love, so he acted out a lot. One day, he arrived at school with a python around his neck, just casually wearing it like a scarf. Chris put so much time into being noticed, it's no wonder he didn't have any energy left for
22:08 homework. His wild behavior didn't job well with Leith, who was a disciplined guy, and Leith hated spending money on Chris just to watch him squander it away. But despite their challenges, things were looking up. In June of nineteen eighty seven, Chris had just graduated from high school and started college at North Carolina State University. He was going to study political science, and Leith was starting to see some promise in Chris. He even offered to pay Chris his tuition and give him a modest allowance. It was fifty bucks a week, which is one hundred and twenty five and today's money. Definitely enough to cover groceries and gas money, but that's not what Chris was spending the money on, and it was never enough money. According to McGuinness, he also had credit cards he used that Bonnie would then quiet a payoff, or he would just ask his mom for more money, and she rarely denied him.
23:06 In the fall of nineteen eighty seven, Chris was living on campus and his first semester grades were okay, but by the end of the spring semester, his grades were declining again, and Leith was livid Chris was back to his old ways, and he suspected that Chris's lackluster performance had to do with his recreational drug use. Even though Leith was a bit of a partier in college, he couldn't stomach watching Chris make the same mistakes, at least not on his dom. Leith threatened to cut Chris off financially and their relationship rapidly deteriorated from there. And Leith might have been a former partier, but I'm not sure he had ever been on the same level as Chris. It wasn't just smoking pot and drinking. Chris was doing cocaine and was heavily into LSD.
23:56 It's difficult to skate through even freshman classes when you're tripping ball every other day. In May of nineteen eighty eight, Chris was able to finish his first year of college by the skin of his teeth. Then he enrolled in a few summer courses, maybe as a show of faith so that Leith would trust him, or maybe Chris needed to catch up on his credits so he could graduate on time. Either way, twenty year old Chris finally seemed like he had his nose to the grindstone seemed being the operative word, and tensions were still high between Chris and Leith. At the beginning of summer of nineteen eighty eight, Chris returned to Bonnie and Leith home for a visit. They argued about Chris's academic performance the entire time. A few times Chris and Leith almost came to blows. By the end of it all, Bonnie decided she would be the one to handle how to discipline Chris. Clearly, Leith and Chris could not be trusted to handle the situation without becoming violent. That same summer, eighteen year old Angela was supposed to visit Chris for the Fourth of July holiday. She drove to North Carolina State and Raleigh, but Chris was nowhere to be found. Angela, who was concerned, called Chris's phone, but he didn't pick up. Bonnie tried to reach him too, but still Chris was gone out of her mind with worry, Bonnie did what no mother ever wants to do. She followed a missing person report for her son, and shortly after that, Chris reached out. He was fine, nothing to worry
25:30 about sorry for all the trouble. Now it was Bonnie's turn to be livid. Where had Chris been for three days? Chris fed Bonnie some bullshit about where he was, but it was clear he was lying. According to Bledsoe's Blood Games, during this incident, Leith told Chris, if you're getting involved with drugs, I'm going to kick your ass. But Chris wasn't worried. From his perspective, Leith had a big bark, but not much bite. Following this debacle, Bonnie and Lee were sick of Chris's shit. They decided to keep a tighter leash on him, or they said they would. The only consequence Chris actually faced was that now he had to tell his parents how he was spending their money, but they still gave him the money. Everyone raises their kids differently, but I think at this point Chris was a legal adult. Rather than continue to bang their heads against a wall, why not tell Chris he had to get a job to pay for his lifestyle. Still pay for his tuition as long as he was passing his classes, but otherwise he would be on his own. He would either grow up or flounder and learn a lesson. You would think Bonnie, who had married an immateur high school kid, would see this, But we are often blind to our own children, and parents always want better for their kids than they had themselves.
26:51 It's part of why Chris's partying drove Leith nuts. He saw him making the same mistakes he had, and Bonnie would never ever have the heart to actually cut off one of her kids. On Friday, July twenty second, Chris came home again and he spent the night. On Saturday morning, he left to go see some friends. He returned later that day, made some hamburgers, and ate dinner with the family. After dinner, Chris announced he was headed back to the university. Bonnie and Chris stood by his car as they said their final goodbye, and according to Blood Games, that's when Bonnie noticed something odd. Chris's car was missing. It's very nice high tech radio.
27:33 Chris explained to his mother that someone had stolen it. He hadn't told her because he didn't want her to worry, but Bonnie could smell the law from them all away. Had Chris pondered off for drug money, who knows? Bonnie was tired. This was just one more way that Chris was going to piss off Leath. She let Chris have this one and didn't even tell Leath and Chris made his way back to school. I'm going to pause now to hear another word from today's sponsors. Regular Southern Fried listeners have heard me rave about Simply Safe many times. I'm proud to have the best home security system as a longtime sponsor, and there's a reason Simply Safe is number one.
28:17 They're always innovating, always working on the next thing to help keep you and your loved one safe twenty four seven like they're new two and one Smoke and CEO detector. It's next generation hazard detection that distinguishes between fire and cooking smoke, so your home is protected and you get fewer false alarms. True crime fans know how important it is to protect yourself and your home, and you really should do it with the best Simply Safe. With simply Safe twenty four seven, professional monitoring service, trained agents stand ready to respond in an emergency, dispatching police, firefighters, or EMTs to your door even if you're away or can't be reached. Monitoring service costs under one dollar a day. Simply Safe is easy to set up yourself or have a sort of technician install it for you right now. Get twenty percent off your new system when you sign up for interactive monitoring. Visit simply safe dot com slash Southern Fried. That's simply safe dot com slash Southern Fried. There's no safe like simply safe.
29:14 Life doesn't happen bi weekly, so why should pay day? The money you earn could be in your hands today with earn in. Earn In is an app that gives you access to your pay as you work, up to one hundred dollars per day or up to seven hundred and fifty dollars per pay period. Just download the urn en app and verify your paycheck, then access up to one hundred dollars a day as you work, and leave an additional tip. Any money you access plus tips are automatically repaid from your next paycheck. I wish an app like earn in had been around in my younger years. There weren't many options if I was struggling any given week. Make earn in a part of your financial routine and join earn ins. Over three and a half million customers who say when I think about earn in, I think about financial stability, security. It gives me a lot of peace of mind.
30:00 Download earn In today spelled e A r n i N in the Google Play or Apple App store. When you download the urn n app. Type in Southern Fried Under podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show. Southern Fried Under Podcast subject to your available earnings daily max and pay period max. See ernn dot com slash t os for details. Earn In as a financial technology company, not a bank. Bank. Products are issued by Evolve Bank and Trust Member FDIC. On Sunday, July twenty fourth, Leith and Bonnie went out to dinner. It was a nice time. The food was good, the wine was better. Leith and Bonnie talked about their future, their hopes, their dreams, their future retirement. According to Blood Games, Leith told Bonnie that he would have no life if not for her, no reason to live without her. When the two returned home, Leith went to bed, but Bonnie stayed up. She had been looking forward to watching a maid for TV movie about Ted Bundy called The Deliberate Stranger. It aired that night at about eleven pm. She turned in for the night. She checked on her cats, the rooster, and locked all the doors. Then she joined Leith in bed, and after reading for a while, she went to sleep. Around midnight. Hours later, Bonnie was jolted awake. Leith was screaming, and a dark figure was standing at the foot of their bed, A man, a man who was attacking Leith. Bonnie reached out for Leith,
31:32 but inadvertently got in the way of the attackers blows. Then the attacker started striking Bonnie as well. In the dark. Without her glasses and groggy from sleep, Bonnie wasn't sure what was going on. She lost consciousness. Moments later she woke up. She was on the floor. Now the intruder was standing near her feet, still striking her with something. After a while, the attacker clearly thought Bonnie was dead and left the room. She was antic Her daughter Angelo was in a nearby bedroom, but Bonnie couldn't get up, and she lost consciousness again. The next time Bonnie woke up, she reached for Leith's fingers. They were limp, but she thought she heard him breathing. Although she was panicked and disoriented, Bonnie knew she had to call for help. She managed to drag herself to the bedside table where the phone was and pull the phone by the cord until it fell on top of her.
32:27 She dialed nine one one, but there was no nine one one emergency line in Little Washington, so Bonnie forced herself to be logical and pressed random numbers. She hung up when she heard busy signals, until finally, at four twenty seven am, she was connected to an operator from Beaufort County Central Communications. Side note, it is pronounced Beaufort. This is North Carolina, not South Carolina, so I hope the pronunciation police remember that before they try to come for me this time. Thank you to local listener Ainsley who rode in and confirmed this for me. Back to the story. As Bonnie spoke with the operator, she became more and more incoherent, but the operator was able to understand enough to get Bonnie's address and send help. When the responding officers arrived, they found the von Stein's front door was locked, but the back door had been forced open. Someone had cut through the back door screen so that they could unlock the door from the inside, but they had broken the window beside the door, a double pained storm window, instead of just breaking the small window on the door. Later, when a detective thought he would test the theory, he could barely reach the handle from the window, even with his feet dangling off the porch, and he was six feet tall.
33:45 To him, this looked staged. The front door had been locked, so this backdoor was definitely the point of entry and exit, but something was hinky about it. The police entered the von Stein's house and began searching for victims. Upstairs, they found forty four year old Bonnie lying on the floor of her bedroom. The telephone was still in her hand, but Bonnie was losing blood fast. Later it would be confirmed that Bonnie had suffered a stab wound to the chest, e collapsed, long internal bleeding, a fractured thumb, and numerous cut some bruises to her face. The police quickly determined that Bonnie's injuries were life threatening, and they transported her to a hospital. Forty two year old Leith von Stein was on the bed. He wasn't breathing and his heart had stopped. They had to wait for a doctor to make the final determination, but the police already knew he was dead. Later, a medical examiner would confirm that Leith had five lacerations on his scalp, seven stab wounds in his back, and one stab wound in his heart. Additionally, Leith sustained numerous bruises and scrapes as he tried to defend himself. But as soon as the attacker's blade had pierced his heart, Leith was a goner.
35:00 He had died within minutes of the blow. Angela, thank god, was fine. The police found her sleeping in her room, which was only about twelve feet away from her parents' bedroom. They woke Angela up and had her weight downstairs. There they told her what was going on. Angela remained calm, too calm according to the police later, but I'm sure she was in some serious shock. When Angela called Chris, he was back in Raleigh playing cards with some friends. Upon hearing the news of this attack, Chris was incredibly distraught. He couldn't drive, He couldn't even find his keys, so he called the university police and they gave him a ride to the hospital so he could see Bonnie. At the time, Bonnie was in the ICU.
35:47 She would go on to make a full recovery, but despite several plastic surgeries, she would remain scarred from the attack. When she was doing better physically, investigators spoke with Bonny if she could remember anything about the assailant. Unfortunately, because the room had been dark and she wasn't wearing her glasses, she couldn't identify him. Bonnie could only describe the person as appearing dark and bulky and being armed with a stick, club or bat. He was dressed in dark clothing from head to toe and was wearing a hood or mask. When news of the attack on the von Stein's was made public, residents of Washington could not believe it. Murders were rare in the city, but they were unheard of in the small Wood neighborhood. People were terrified a madman was on the loose. They installed dead bolts, kept their houses locked up tight, and loaded their guns. Meanwhile, the Washington police were trying to figure out who attacked Leith and Bonnie von Stein. This wasn't the easiest task for this particular police force. They had very little experience investigating a murderer. Some described them as being like Don Nott's character Barney Fife from The Andy Griffiths Show.
37:01 But they tried their best. Remember, this was the epitome of a small town in the low country. They didn't even have nine one one. They definitely didn't have a CSI unit. There was an SBI rep on site who tried to call in the state team, but they were at a conference and he didn't have the authority to make them come. So the local cops did their best, but they would make a huge mistake. When the SPI rep named Lewis Young arrived on scene, he saw bloody bedsheets drawing on a motor boat parked in the driveway. Neighbors stood in their own yards watching the police work. This was supposed to be a crime scene, and they already had evidence hanging outside for folks to gawk at. Also, they closed down their work that afternoon and opened the house up for neighbors to come inside and clean.
37:52 The neighbors said they didn't want Bonnie to come home to this awful crime scene, but she was later angry about the police letting them in there. She felt like they were nosy, looky loose, not really trying to be helpful, and the police had not even taken a day to investigate the scene. I don't blame her for being pissed, and if she wasn't close to her neighbors, she was probably right about them just being nosy. So the place was scrubbed clean, and whatever evidence was left had been washed away before a real CSI unit could investigate. Luckily, a young Beaufort County detective John Taylor, twenty eight years old with four years on the force and two years into his work as a detective, had the wherewithal to go ahead and pull out a camera and snap photos of the crime scene before things had been moved.
38:40 After searching the von Stein residence and the surrounding areas, police found that some hidden cash was missing and Bonnie's purse had been dumped out, but that was it. Because of the cash, this felt like a targeted and side job. To John Taylor, this looked like a planned murder, not a burglary gone wrong. A green backpack was recovered near the home, but that was it. Luckily, they quickly got a tip that led them to crucial evidence. A farmer had contacted the authorities around four thirty a m. On July twenty fifth, the same time and day of the attack. He had seen a fire on the side of Highway two sixty four. This was around nine miles west of Washington. Police went to the area and found the remnants of burned clothing. The rubber sole of a reboked tennis shoe, a knife, and a partially burned hand drawn map of the neighborhood around the von Stein home. The map would be a huge piece of evidence in this case.
39:39 Officers showed the knife to the medical examiner, who confirmed it could have been used to attack the couple. It appeared police had found at least one of the weapons used during the attack. The baseball bat or similar item was yet to be located. Investigators kept coming back to the fact that whoever killed Leith and severely injured Bonnie had to have known the family. The first two suspects were eighteen year old Angela and twenty year old Chris, and they both had plenty of motive. If Bonnie and Leith died, Chris and Angela would inherit the von Stein estate. It was worth around two million dollars back then today that's about five million. But detectives wondered how Angela could have attacked her parents, cleaned herself up and crawled back into bed before the first responders had arrived, and Chris had been one hundred and ten miles away in Raleigh playing cards.
40:31 His friends confirmed it five weeks into the investigation, and the police were no closer to solving it. They hadn't even ruled out Bonnie, even though she was a victim, much less the kids. Bonnie couldn't believe she was a suspect, but that's just how it works. When you stand to inherit that kind of money. She could have set the attack up and then been inadvertently injured as well. The police said they needed her and the kids to take a polygraph to clear them, to which she said, why didn't you just ask? We could have done this weeks ago. She and Angela passed, but Chris didn't take the test yet. Little did investigators know, but Bonnie von Stein had hired the most famous criminal defense lawyer and North Carolina, Wade Smith. He had worked on the Jeffrey McDonald case. He sat second chair to McDonald's fancy New York lawyer and was the only one on the team who didn't rub the judge and jury the wrong way. McDonald may have lost, but Smith is still one of the most esteemed lawyers in the state.
41:35 Bonnie had never liked the way the police had talked to her. She was the victim, the grieving widow, and when she told her dad about it. He suggested she hire a lawyer. Incidentally, Wade Smith is how author Joe McGinnis later got involved. Smith counseled her to get Chris his own lawyer. He felt like she and Angela were fined since they were in the house during the attack. But even though Chris had witnessed as to his alibi, he still wasn't home when it happened, so she hired another big gun named will Austin Senior. When Austine found out about the polygraph, he said absolutely not. He said he would set up a private polygraph, but Chris would not be taking any SPI test. When Bonnie showed up with Angela for the test and informed Lewish Young and John Taylor that on the advice of his attorney, Chris wouldn't be taking the test, they were flabbergasted and pissed. Bonnie had never mentioned hiring a lawyer. She told author Joe McGuinness that Young looked at her and said, why would a victim need a criminal lawyer? Lewis Young certainly did not handle Bonnie with kid gloves. Instead, he blew up at her. According to what Bonnie told author Joe McGuinness. Young slammed a stack of papers on the table in front of her and told her he had planned to walk her through all the evidence they had, but now he would never talk to her about the case again. Whether or not he really believed she could be involved as immaterial. Today, she would have had a victim's
43:07 advocate helping her navigate this horrible experience, not some state police guy with an ego bigger than North Carolina screaming at her. Back then, she had her own wits and the support of her family and her dad wasn't wrong. When the cops want to talk to you, and especially if they're talking polygraph you need an attorney, even if you are a victim. That's still true today, and little Bonnie von Stein had quite the spine when pushed around by the cops. She didn't appreciate how they talked to her, and she let them know it. She and Angela took the polygraphs as promised and passed, ruling them both out. But Chris was still a suspect. Playing cards during the murder or not did not rule him out of planning the attack. Police knew for a fact he wasn't the actual killer, but it was possible he was still involved Somehow, Investigators kept digging, hoping to find enough evidence to bring charges. Meanwhile, Bonnie never felt safe at home again, and she was anxious to get away from Little Washington. She now owned the house that had once belonged to Leith's parents in Winston Salem, so she and Angela moved there.
44:19 I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. By February first, nineteen eighty nine, there was a new sheriff in town, so to speak. Washington County had a new chief of police named John Crone, and he considered his first order of business the von Stein murder. They had the map, and they had suspects. It was time to play hardball. Crone put together a task force, with John Taylor leading and Lewis Young as an official player. Despite his animosity towards the victim, the team took a fresh look at Chris Pritchard. Maybe he had planned the attack. That would explain while the killer had a hand drawn map of the von Stein's neighborhood, they got a subpoena and got a handwriting sample from North Carolina State. Chris had written his home address on an admittance card, and the team felt the word Lawson was a solid match to the Lawson road written on the map. Now investigators knew they were headed in the right direction, but they needed to find out who could have helped Chris pull everything off, so they looked closely at his friends. Chris spent the most time with his Dungeons and Dragons buddies, nineteen year old Gerald Neil Henderson and nineteen year old James Bartlett Bart up Church the third, but Bart's friends called him Moog for some reason. Chris had met Moog when he answered a flyer on campus about playing Dungeons and Dragons.
45:50 Moog had even met Angela, who visited Chris often at school. He supposedly had a crush on her. Neil and bart were childhood friends who grew up in a small town near the Virginia state line. They were both really smart guys, big math and science nerds, Nil especially so. One of his teachers described him as a strange little genius. Nil's IQ was over one fifty, and when he took the SAT he scored fifteen hundred out of sixteen hundred, the highest SAT score Nil's hometown and county had ever seen. But Nil wasn't going to start any revolutions. He just wasn't the type. He never got into any trouble and was an agreeable guy, a follower, not a leader. Bart was intelligent too, just not as gifted as Nil. Bart had an IQ of one thirty five, scored an eleven ninety out of sixteen hundred on the set, and was a gifted student. As a child.
46:50 Bart did not show any violent tendencies, but he had been in trouble before. In February of nineteen eighty six, Bart and three of his friends were caught stealing a TV, binoculars, and several other items from a cabin. They also stole a computer from the high school. For that, Bart was given three years of probation, but he didn't meet with his parole officers like he was supposed to, and eventually he was picked up again for driving without a license. It had been revoked earlier for a traffic offense. As a result of all this, Bart was put on twenty four hour electric monitoring, which means he had to wear a transmitter bracelet and adhere to a curfew.
47:32 In August of nineteen eighty eight, just a few weeks after the Von Stein's attack, Bart sawed off his transmitter bracelet and he stopped seeing his parole officer. He was officially on the run, but from what well The Washington police suspected they knew exactly what. On June ninth of nineteen eighty nine, almost a year after Leith and Bonnie were attacked, the police spoke with Neil Henderson. They wanted to see if he would squeal on Bart. They asked Neil if he knew where Bart was, but Neil claimed he didn't. He said he hadn't seen or heard anything about Bart since he went on the run way back in August. The police then asked him if he knew anything about the von Stein attack, and Neil did. Neil knew a lot about the von Stein attack, and boy was he ready to spill. His conscience had been killing him. Two or three weeks before the attack. Back in the summer of eighty eight, Chris and Bart had approached him. They told Neil they had an idea, a plan for Chris to come into his massive inheritance.
48:36 Early Neil remarked, oh, you're going to rob the place. Bart shook his head and said, no, We're going to murder his parents. Neil replied, isn't that a little extreme, but Chris laughed and said, no, we're serious. Here, let us show you. Chris then brought out a hand drawn map of the von Stein neighborhood and explained the plan. Bart would kill the von Stein's, then stage the scene to look like a burglary gone wrong. Chris would stay in Raleigh so he wouldn't be a suspect. But Bart didn't have a car or a driver's license, and he couldn't drive Chris's car because if he was stopped while driving the car without a license, the murder could be traced back to Chris. So they asked Neil to drive Bart to the von Stein home in Chris's car. Neil told investigators he agreed to go along with the plan because he wanted to fit in. For all of his life, Neil's high IQ had made him stand out. He said, at the time, I didn't feel very good about myself and I needed friends. They were my friends. On the night of Sunday, July twenty fourth, Neil arrived at the campus parking lot. He picked up Bart, who had a green backpack, a hunting knife, and a baseball bat.
49:50 He also had a key to the back door that Chris had given him. Neil asked about why Bart had brought the bat. Bart explained that he wasn't sure he would be able to stab the von Stein quickly enough. The bat was there to knock them out. During the two hour drive from Raleigh to Washington, North Carolina, Bart changed his clothes. He put on black shoes, a dark shirt and pants, and a ski mask. Neil and Bart arrived at Little Washington at around two thirty am. They located the von Stein house and then drove around for a while. After a while, Bart told Neil to park the car, and then he got out and said he'd be back in thirty minutes. So Neil waited and waited. Thirty minutes came and went, but Bart hadn't returned. Neil started to panic. He drove closer to the von Stein's neighborhood to look for Bart. After about ten minutes, he appeared. He was running toward Neil's car. Bart got in and said, I did it. I can't believe I did it. I never want to see that much blood again for the rest of my life. Let's get out of here immediately. Neil drove away, After they were settled on a long highway, Bart told Neil to stop in a dark place. He needed to change his clothes. He was covered in blood. After he changed, Bart through his bloody clothes in the trunk. A while later, Neil and Bart stopped at a dark, secluded spot on the side of the road.
51:15 They made a pile out of Bart's murder clothes, the murder weapon, and the map of the von Stein's house. Then they dumped gasoline on the items and set them on fire. They left quickly before the fire burned out, which is how the map didn't burn, and then they stopped for gas and to wash the mud off the car. Bart gave Neil the cash he had stolen from the von Stein home to buy gas. Neil then told the officers questioning him that he had stopped being friends with Chris and Bart after the attack, and Chris and Bart weren't friends anymore either. According to Neil, the whole situation had been too traumatic. They only ran into each other on occasion, and always by accident. When Neil was finished confessing, he took the officers to all the places he had mentioned. He even gave them the baseball bat that Bart had hidden with all of Neil's information. The police were confident in their case, and on June fifteenth of nineteen eighty nine, bart Aka Moog was arrested. The next day, on June sixteenth, Chris was also arrested. He had been staying at Bonnie's house in Winston Salem, and on June twentieth, Neil was arrested. A month later, Chris, Neil, and Bart were indicted on charges of murder, conspiracy, assault with a deadly weapon, burglary, and other charges. They faced the death penalty if they were convicted. Bart and Chris both pleaded not guilty, but Neil Henderson took
52:47 a plea deal in exchange for his testimony and a few luster charges. Neil would be sentenced to a maximum of life plus twenty years. The death penalty was taken off the table. At his hearing, Bonnie had an extreme reaction. She thought he resembled the attacker more than Moog did. She even ran out of the courtroom, scared later it would make her testimony tricky. She wouldn't identify bart Ak Moog definitively. Chris was adamant that he was not guilty until right before the trial started. Are we shocked that the death penalty spooked a spoiled twenty one year old kid? On December twenty seventh, nineteen eighty nine, Chris accepted the same plea deal as Neil. He would spend his life in prison, but he wouldn't face the death penalty. And then he confessed he corroborated Neil's story exactly, and he also said more. Chris explained how he had first thought of killing his mother and stepfather. Around June of eighty eight, Chris had been drinking with his friends. They were all shooting the ship about what they would do if they were rich, and during that conversation, someone brought up that chris his parents were rich, which Chris confirmed.
54:02 Then he said, of something were to happen to his parents, he would inherit a lot of money. So Chris and his friends began daydreaming about this inheritance money, how they could use it to buy a big house and all live together. Over the course of that summer, Chris became more heavily involved in drinking and drugs. He started to obsess about his parents' deaths and how much money he would get. On July twentieth, of nineteen eighty eight, Chris and Bart grab some dinner during the mill. Chris asked Bart what he thought about patricide, and Bart replied apathetically, saying, well, you better not believe in God. From there, Bart joined Chris in his scheme to murder his parents. They began planning the murders. In exchange for Bart's help, Chris would give him a Porsche and fifty thousand dollars that would be one hundred and twenty five thousand today. Their initial plan was to drug the von Steins and then set the house on fire. They would make it look like an accidental house fire by planting a broken fuse in the electric box.
55:10 When investigators asked Chris if he was worried about Angela dying, Chris was unconcerned. He knew it was a possibility. He was okay with her dying, but he was also okay with her living. She wasn't the main target. On Friday, July twenty second, Chris went home with the intent of carrying out his Embart's plan. That Saturday morning, when Chris told his parents he was out with friends, he actually drove to Raleigh, where he picked up Bart, who had a bunch of crushed sleeping pills. They returned to Little Washington that afternoon with the intent of drugging Bonnie and Leath. That's why Chris wanted to cook the burghers that Saturday night. He was going to lace the food with the sleeping pills, and he did, but then things started to go wrong. Chris told his family was headed back to Raleigh, and instead he drove to where Bart was waiting. They went back to the von steinhouse to start the fire, but they couldn't break the fuse that they were going to plant in the fuse box. Bart panicked, plus they had no way of knowing if the pills actually worked. He told Chris that the plan wouldn't work, and they both went back to Raleigh. On the way, they devised a new plan. Bart suggested that he and Chris chop off Bonnie and Leith's heads. It would be quick and painless, Bart argued, but when the two men tried to purchase a machette, they couldn't find one. The army surplus stores were closed on the weekends. Chris and Bart started brainstorming,
56:42 and once again they had a new plan kill the von Stein's and what would look like a burglary gone wrong. Chris said he needed to stay in Raleigh to establish an alibi, so Bart would have to carry out the murder by himself. They would ask Neil to be Bart's getaway driver, since Bart didn't have a license to stage the crime scene. Bart would steal a few things from the house, which is why the money from the secret stash was gone. On the morning of Sunday, July twenty fourth, Bart and Chris went to kmart and bought a hunting knife. Then they spoke to Neil about being the getaway driver. Chris offered Neil the same deal, a car and fifty thousand dollars. Neil agreed, and the plan was in motion. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. When Chris received the phone call he knew was coming in the early morning of Monday, July twenty fifth, he acted shocked. It wasn't until he saw his mother beaten, stabbed, and terrified in the hospital that he felt remorse. He was disgusted with himself, but he didn't confess. Chris was scared as mom would find out what happened, and he didn't want to go to jail. Bonnie later said, prior to Chris's confession, she didn't believe he could commit murder, but after he told her he had planned the attack, she had to believe him.
58:07 She said, I can't imagine him telling me such a horrible story in him not doing what he said. Despite the fact that her son planned her murder and had killed her husband, Bonnie forgave Chris and supported him throughout his court proceedings. Another interesting part to Chris's confession to his mother. It happened months after he had already confessed to authorities. His attorneys didn't want his mother to know because she was supposed to be a character witness for Chris's defense, but ethically, the DA and police wanted Bonnie to know Chris was living with her in Winston Salem while out on bond. What if he tried to kill her again. Further, Chris was under the care of a psychiatrist who was worried that Chris was suicidal because he had not come clean to his mother. I'm no lawyer, but it does seemed right to put a witness on who doesn't know all the facts. Ethically or legally, Bonnie von Stein had a right to know. She had been an adamant supporter of her son and couldn't understand why he was charged in the attack. She considered the entire investigation a shit show and it was. Bonnie read true crime books and loved watching crime shows on TV. She knew from the get go that the crime scene was mishandled and that the police had bungled the investigation. Is it any wonder? She didn't believe her son was involved until he finally confessed to her. When he finally did, it was a massive heartbreak for Bonnie, but as I said,
59:40 she quickly forgave her son and intended to support him through his entire legal ordeal. But luckily she wouldn't have to testify for him since he took a plea deal. Bart was the only one of the three men to not accept a plea deal. His trial began in early January of nineteen ninety. Exsecution told the jury that Chris, Bart and Neil planned the murder of the von Steins so they could make some fast, easy money. The motive was greed, plain and simple. Chris and Neil were star witnesses for the prosecution. Bonnie also testified, and she was probably Bart's only hope, as she would not positively identify him as her attacker. Bonnie's ethical streak was made of steel.
1:00:24 She would not say something she didn't believe. But the jury had Chris and Nil, and that meant more than a traumatized victim's memory of that night. Without their testimony, Bart probably would have walked free. In fact, the defense's arguments pointed out that there was zero physical evidence linking Bart to the attack. They claimed that Bart could be innocent, that Chris and Nil, and perhaps even Angela had framed him. But for all their hemming and hawing, this trial was pretty much open and shut. On January twenty fourth of nineteen ninety, after deliberating for ten and a half hours, the jury found Bart guilty on accounts. After the verdict was read, Bart lowered his head and held back tears. But that was about the only emotion he showed during the entire proceedings, and I'm willing to bet it took the jury over ten hours due to Bonnie's testimony. Next, the jury had to decide if they were sentencing Bart to death. The prosecution laid out all of the aggravating circumstances surrounding Leath's murder and Bonnie's attack. First, the murder occurred during the commission of a burglary, second it was committed for money, and third it involved violence against other people. All of these were considered aggravating circumstances that could justify the death penalty in the state of North Carolina back in nineteen ninety. The prosecution said that Bart should receive the death penalty because the attack on the von Stein's was quote a cold, calculated, pitiless, conscienceless act. Sentencing Bart
1:02:00 to death was the only way you could assure that he wouldn't do it again, they said. The defense countered that Bart should receive life in prison because there were eleven mitigating factors that outweighed the aggravating. Mitigating factors included Bart's age, his use of drugs, the fact that he played dungeons and dragons, which quote created a blur between fantasy and reality. The defense also said it was unfair that Bart faced death while his co conspirators got life in prison. A psychologist for the defense testified that Bart revealed an absence of violent tendencies and the presence of a primary mode of dealing with situations by denying feelings and thoughts that could be why he was acting totally fine throughout the trial. He was in a deep state of denial. Bonnie told the judge outside of the presence of the jury that she didn't think Bart should be sentenced to death. She said, I don't believe that taking another life could make amends for the law loss of Leith. The defense wanted the jury to hear Bonnie's statement, but the prosecution objected, and the judge sided with the prosecution. On January thirtieth of nineteen ninety, the jury recommended that Bart be sentenced to death, and the judge imposed the death penalty that same day. He was also given life for first degree burglary, twenty years for felonious assault with a deadly weapon was intent to kill, and six years for felonious larceny and conspiracy to commit murder.
1:03:31 After he was sentenced, Bart maintained his innocence. He said his trial was a miscarriage of justice and that he was quote appalled and shocked by the verdict and was surprised the jury had listened to two confessed murderers. Bart told the court he would try to end his own life by starving himself. That way he would avoid being a burden on his family. He told the court, I'm not cattle to be fattened for slaughter. After this statement, the judge asked that bartbie put on suicide watch. Prison staff said they would force feed him if necessary, but they didn't have to. Bart broke his fast by eating breakfast on his second day in prison. On January thirty first, the day after bart was sentenced to death, Neil and Chris had their sentencing hearing. Bonnie testified for her son, stating, I love Chris as I'm sure the parents of Neil an up Church love them. I hope and pray that these three young men can someday find peace within themselves. Chris addressed his family and stated, you don't know the kind of mental anguish that I have gone through. I just want you to know I love all of you.
1:04:41 Neil was given forty years, while Chris was given life plus twenty years. In December of two thousand, Neil was paroled after ten years in prison. Today he's a free man. He lives in the Raleigh area. Chris was paroled in May of two thousand and seven after seventeen years in prison. He's also a freeman and a born again Christian. You know x cons always find Jesus Bart up Churches. Convictions and sentences were appealed. That automatically happened when the death penalty was given in North Carolina. During the appeals process, Bart's death sentence was overturned due to errors and sentencing instructions given to the jury by the judge. On September twenty second, nineteen ninety three, Bart was re sentenced to life in prison. Today he is serving two life sentences in the Davidson Correctional Institute and Lexington, North Carolina. You might be wondering why I didn't discuss Dungeons and Dragons more in this episode, since that's one of the reasons this case was so famous. The reason is simple. It's bullshit.
1:05:50 It is how Chris met Moog aka Bart James up Church. They played Dungeons and Dragons often while tripping on acid. Moog his dealer, and they were friends who were obsessed with D and D, along with some other friends. But that's where it ends. The real motive was greed. This wasn't kids playing a stupid game that got out of hand. These were legal adults who made a plan after talking about how rich Leith von Stein was a plan for Chris to inherit money and then they could all drive cool cars, live in a house together, and play D and D to their heart's content. That's it. That's how much Dungeons and Dragons really had to do with this case.
1:06:32 If you need more convincing than that, consider that Chris and his friends were fine with killing his mother and Angela. Angela was just collateral damage, but in court Chris admitted his inheritance would have been larger if she were killed too. I'm told that one of the big differences between Jerry Bledsoe's book and Joe McGuinness' is that Angela is more of a suspect and Mcguinness's cruelled out that she might have helped and known what was going down. Maybe maybe her brother lied in court for her because he didn't see why she should go down for this too, Or maybe she just got lucky that moog up Church once had a thing for her, so he didn't decide to attack her that night.
1:07:17 There is no proof about Angela, and she did pass the spis polygraph, not that those are admissible in court. But they are good enough to clear her for the cops. If she was involved, she got damn lucky. But I don't really believe she was. I think her greedy brother didn't really want her dead, but wouldn't mind it if it meant he didn't have to split his inheritance with her. No, this is a case about a smoldering resentment between a distant stepfather and a spoiled kid, and it's about money. That's it. Leith wasn't really a father figure to Chris, and what Chris coldly planned did not bother his conscience until he saw his own mother in the hospital. So yes, this case is also about remorse. Chris regretted his actions once he saw his mother, but regret doesn't change anything. Though his mother did support him through his journey through justice. Do they have a relationship now that he has gotten out. I don't know. I did read that Bonnie visited him on every single visitation day when he was in prison, so they did reconcile as far as I know, But I tend to leave survivors in peace at the end of the case. I understand Bonnie remains a very private person. Despite Chris's remorse, it's hard to believe he's out of prison, but Upchurch is still behind bars. I know he is the one who committed the murder, but he would not have been there if it wasn't for
1:08:48 Chris Pritchard. Neil Henderson wouldn't have either. And Leith von Stein is dead at age forty two. That used to sound so old to me, but really he was a youngish middle aged man who was about to start a new life. He could have lived another forty two years. His brady step children were both about to be in college. He wanted to invest his money and travel for the first time in his life. He had been to Germany for war, but he still hadn't really seen the world, and he wanted to do it with Bonnie, the love of his life. He and his wife could start their lives anew. I'm not saying he was perfect. Most people aren't, but he did care about his family, and he loved his wife very much, and she loved him, and they both lost the lovely future he was planning for them, the future they were on the cusp of beginning, a future that was stolen in the dead of night by a plan that their own son put into motion. It's more of a Greek tragedy than some silly dungeons and dragon's tail. Southern Fraud True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank and myself, and of course all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Coley Horner.
1:10:18 Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brendan shuck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. Thank you to Stephanie and Ainsley for suggesting today's case, and especially Ainsley for protecting me from the pronunciation police. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. You'll get lost in a sea of emails if you send it to my main address, so this is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fred True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes.
1:11:08 I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shit as is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like our Heartstitcher, Spotify and now Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed