June 5, 2023

181: The Real Suburban Axe Murder: Candy & Betty

181: The Real Suburban Axe Murder: Candy & Betty
181: The Real Suburban Axe Murder: Candy & Betty
Southern Fried True Crime
181: The Real Suburban Axe Murder: Candy & Betty

On a hot Friday the 13th in June of 1980, Allan Gore was worried. He couldn't get a hold of his wife, Betty. For hours, he'd called her over and over. No answer. Betty always answered. She didn’t get out by herself, especially not with their two small...

On a hot Friday the 13th in June of 1980, Allan Gore was worried. He couldn't get a hold of his wife, Betty. For hours, he'd called her over and over. No answer. Betty always answered. She didn’t get out by herself, especially not with their two small daughters. She hated when he traveled--scared of being alone, so Allan was trying to check in to reassure her. Now he was starting to panic. He finally got his neighbors to get into his house. When he called back, he could never have been prepared for the staggering horror of what happened to his wife.

Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/candy-and-betty

This story has been requested numerous times literally since I started the show. I understand the fascination now. A real suburban axe murder. It sounds like fiction. So thank you most recently to Melody and Denise but also to everyone who has emailed me over the years. Y’all were right. This one was a doozy.

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank & Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley

  • This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at BetterHelp.com/SOUTHERN and get on your way to being your best self.


This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:01 Southern Fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. On May ninth of nineteen eighty, the blockbuster horror film Friday the Thirteenth premiered. The movie, which is now considered a classic, was a huge success. Teenage camp counselors are being murdered by a masked assailant. The killer uses multiple sharp objects to slay his victims, one time gruesomely lodging an axe and a young woman's face. On May twenty third of nineteen eighty, Stanley Kubricks the Shining debut in theaters, and this horror film was also a huge success.

0:48 Jack Nicholson stars as the caretaker of an isolated hotel and the Rocky Mountains, and the most iconic scene in the entire movie, A scene I know you've seen somewhere, is when he chases down his wife with an axe after trapping her in a bathroom. He maniacally chops his way through a wooden door and screams the famous lines here's Johnny fun fact. Jack Nicholson was actually axing through a real door. Not so fun fact Shelley Duval, who played Jack's wife Wendy, later says she was horrifically traumatized by the filming of this movie because of Kubrick's methods and probably the experience of filming with that real axe. Although Jack didn't kill his wife with that axe, there's no denying that the fervor around axe murders was at an all time high in nineteen eighty. It was thrilling because it was fake cinema fantasy, a way for us to live out our fears from the safety of a theater while munching some popcorn. But only one month following the opening night of these watershed films, an axe murder actually happened. It wasn't fake, it was real. In Texas, a schoolteacher was killed by a housewife. You cannot make this up. Welcome to episode one eighty one, The Real Suburban axe Murder. Candy and Betty. Betty

2:23 Eileen Pomeroy was born on January ninth, nineteen fifty in Norwich, Kansas. Her father, Bob, was an insurance salesman, and her mother, Bertha, was a housewife. Betty also had two brothers. Together, the family of five was the quintessential Midwestern American family, industrious Christian folk who made a modest living, went to church every Sunday and hardly ever called in sick, and they were well respected in the Norwich community because of it. Norwich was and is a barely their town in the rural countryside of south central cans It's thirty seven miles west of Wichita, and that matters because if Norwich residents wanted anything clothes, restaurants, doctors, they had to make the track to Wichita to get it. Back In nineteen fifty, when Betty was born, only about four hundred people lived in Norwich, and in the late sixties, of those four hundred Norwich residents, young Betty Pomeroy stood out from the crowd.

3:27 She was a beautiful woman with a striking smile and a bold personality. She made friends easily and was well liked, and she didn't shy away from hard work. When school let out in the summertime, Betty always got a job helping out with a harvest on a local farm, and when school was back in session, Betty thrived. She was an enthusiastic student with a clever mind. When she graduated from Norwich High school in nineteen sixty eight, she dreamed of becoming a teacher. She had wanted a classroom of her own, and she was a little girl. So that fall, Betty attended Southwestern College in Winfield, Kansas. She studied elementary education, trying to make her dream a reality, and during her freshman year there, Betty met a man. Well, actually, Betty met a lot of men equipped with both beauty and brains.

4:20 Eighteen year old Betty Pomeroy was a hot commodity. But while Betty caught the attention of many, only one man caught her eye. His name was Alan Gore. He was twenty one years old, a senior at Southwestern College, and he was also Betty's math instructor. Although she was very bright, she had always struggled with math. Alan, as her college teacher, also noticed that calculus was not Betty's strong suit, and undoubtedly he also noticed that Betty was a pretty young thing, a pretty young thing who was clearly interested in him. But Alan was a respectable g He wasn't one to take his student's home, but when Betty approached him for some extra tutoring, Alan found that he was smitten. He couldn't and wouldn't refuse her anything. They met at the campus library to study a few times, and by the next semester, when Betty was no longer Allan's student, the two were officially dating.

5:21 Alan Dean Gore was born in nineteen forty seven and raised in Larned, Kansas. Like Betty's hometown of Norwich, Larned was also a small town in rural Kansas. Alan graduated from Larned Senior High School in nineteen sixty five, and from there he pursued his math and business degrees at Southwestern College, where he met Betty. After Allan graduated from Southwestern in nineteen sixty nine, he enrolled in Kansas State University for his master's degree in computer science. This was probably a very important moment for Alan and Betty's relationship. They had only known each other for about a year. They could have easily called it quits. After all, Allan was going to go to a university that was two and a half hours away. Betty was either going to have to relocate or commit to a long distance relationship. And this was long before you could text your cross country boo. But Alan and Betty knew they had something special, so they made it work. Allan proposed to Betty in May of nineteen sixty nine, and in January of nineteen seventy they were married. Betty transferred from Southwestern to Kansas State, and Allan graduated a year later in nineteen seventy one. Alan and Betty's marriage shocked the Pomeroys. He didn't match what they thought a man should be, but remember the context. Though they weren't farmers themselves, Betty's

6:51 family embraced the farming culture of Kansas. They were tanned, calloused, Tossabelle of Hay over your shoulder type people, and Alan was the exact opposite of that. He was pale and wore horn rimmed glasses. His hands were probably as soft as a baby's bottom. According to Evidence of Love by journalist Atkinson and Briggs, Betty's father confided and Betty's mother that for a guy who grew up in a Kansas farming town, Alan sure didn't seem like a farm boy. Plus, Betty's friends and family thought that Betty was a shining star, and they weren't sure Allan was good enough for her. Betty was a dynamo and Alan, in comparison, was downright plain people described him as quiet, average looking, and kind of a snob. He was actually a bit shy, not snobby, but that's a common mistake people may still Betty was sure of Alan. She liked how smarty was, she liked how secure he was, both financially and emotionally, and she preferred men who were a little older.

7:58 She wasn't looking for a farm boy. She wanted Allan and that was the end of it. In nineteen seventy one, Allan was hired at the White Sands Missile Range in New Mexico. When he and Betty moved to New Mexico, she continued working on her elementary education degree, and in nineteen seventy three she graduated from New Mexico State University. That same year, she became pregnant with their first child. The pregnancy was really hard on Betty. She had to go to the doctor all the time. Her normal aches and pains, which were already pretty frequent, skyrocketed, and Betty's chronic depression, which she had always managed without medication, became worse. When she gave birth to a little girl named Elissa in nineteen seventy four, she was really struggling and Allen who had to travel often for his job, wasn't home as much as Betty would have liked. She hated being alone. By nineteen seventy seven, Betty, Allen and Alissa had moved to a few different places, but they ended up in Wyley, Texas, a small suburb twenty five miles northeast of Dallas and ten miles east of Plano. Back then, it was a population of only about three thousand, seven hundred people, and Betty found a job teaching fifth grade reading at Arcy Dodd Middle School. Unfortunately, she hated teaching, she had since she had gotten her very first teaching job a few years earlier. As it turns out, dreaming about becoming a teacher and actually stepping

9:31 into the classroom were two very different things. Betty didn't like how much the kids misbehaved. She became agitated when her lesson plans didn't go perfectly. Ultimately, teaching just did not make Betty happy, and it showed just the summer before in nineteen seventy four, a different Texas school district had not invited Betty to return after one year, and teachers speak, Betty was fired. Did it hurt her feelings now more? Than ever. She was determined to get into the classroom and prove herself. Fortunately, she found that job at rc DOT, and there Betty decided she could tolerate teaching. At this time, Alan was in a fairly high up position at Rockwell International, an electronics conglomerate and major defense contractor. Alan had been at Rockwell for several years by then, but in nineteen seventy seven, he was starting a new position with a company. It wasn't a demotion or anything. He had requested the change before.

10:37 Alan's job required him to travel for many weeks at a time, but all that travel upset Betty. She was afraid of being alone, and she frankly abhorded. It wasn't an oh, sweetie, i'll miss you, I wish you were home more situation. Betty could not stand when Alan was gone. It truly affected her mental health. One time, when Alan was on a business trip in Switzerland, Betty begged him to come home. When he wouldn't, she actually called his boss and asked if Allen could come home. So realizing that Betty was seriously distressed and didn't seem like she would ever get used to all his required travel, Allen transferred to a different position with Rockwell, one that would allow him to stay in Dallas, a more stable position, hopefully stabilizing his home life. In nineteen seventy seven, everything seemed to be coming up roses for the Gore family. Betty and Allan's little girl, Alyssa, was healthy. They had just moved to a nice seventy thousand dollars three bedroom, two bathroom brick house in the bedroom community of Wiley, Texas, and they had started attending the local Methodist church and nearby Lucas. Their home would be worth about three hundred and fifty thousand dollars today. The small suburb of Dallas is home to about fifty five thousand people now and is still known one of the nicest places to live around the big city. Wiley has a highly rated school system, lots of parks, and most residents own their

12:07 homes. It would be considered an extremely safetown in nineteen seventy seven as well as today. Wiley is in Collin County, which is home to several small cities and towns, including Fairview, where friends of the Gores lived, which will be important later. Lucas plain O McKinney Richardson, and others were all conglomerated in Collin County, and many people from these towns traveled to the first United Methodist Church of Lucas. Betty seemed to thrive in Wiley. She became an active member of their chosen church. She sang in the choir, co ordinated the youth group, and helped arrange the women's division. And Alan's job, which now did not require travel, was going well, and Betty, who still wasn't a big fan of teaching, was managing all right with her fifth grade students. But looks are deceiving. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. In the fall of nineteen seventy eight, Betty and Allen decided that they were ready for their second child. This baby would be carefully planned, unlike their firstborn. Betty wanted to give birth in the summer so she wouldn't have to take time off from teaching, so she and Alan started having sex primarily and Betty's fertility window. At first, Alan thought trying for her second baby sounded like a lot of fun, but he was quickly turned off by this new rigid sex schedule. To him, it wasn't romantic

13:43 and honestly, Betty and Allan weren't doing so well in the romance department even before the sex schedule. Keep in mind, Betty and Allen had been married for eight years. I don't care who you are. The honeymoon period does pass, and your partner is going to annoy the shit out of you some days. But Alan felt like he and Betty were doing way worse than the average married couple, and he attributed a lot of it to Betty's job. Since Betty hated teaching, she would come home from work anxious and stressed. Even before they started trying for their second child, Betty and Allan rarely had sex due to Betty's stress, and when they did, according to Alan, it was mechanical, not fun. Some church friends of Betty and Allan noticed their relationship troubles, so they suggested a program they had done called Marriage Encounters.

14:37 Basically, it was a weekend of marriage counseling disguised as a fun vacation getaway. Couples would arrive at a hotel, spend two days doing guided therapy exercises with their spouse, and leave feeling closer than ever. Alan thought this was a great idea. A chance to reconnect with Betty. But Betty, who was constantly overwhelmed by teaching, thought it sounded like the weekend from hell. How was she going to get these papers graded if she was away for the weekend? Who was going to write her lesson plans if she was busy working on her marriage? According to Texas Monthly, Betty turned to Alan and asked, you don't think there's something wrong with us, do you? And after that, Alan dropped the subject of their relationship altogether. Now let's take a second to appreciate Betty's perspective. You might be thinking, Wow, she's just so negative. She didn't want to try at all. But Betty isn't here to tell her side of the story, and so their relationship has only been conveyed through Alan's perspective, in combination with some friends and family who spoke with reporters. And also, Betty was a teacher, she was busy.

15:50 Why couldn't they do the marriage Encounters program in the summer. Why was it always Allan's way or the highway? I've known a lot of teachers in my life, and it is an extremely stressful job, even if you love it, which Betty didn't. I can see how adding stuff to her plate during the school year would antagonize her. I'll get back to the case now, but just remember Betty was really going through it, and Alan could have done a million things other than what he actually did. In early July of nineteen seventy nine, Betty and Allan had their second child, Bethany, and following Bethany's birth, Betty and Allan were closer than ever. Finally it felt like they were on their way to rekindling their relationship. They chose kind of sweet matching names for their girls, Allan and Alissa, Betty and Bethany, details like this twist my heart. And about a year later, in the summer of nineteen eighty, Alan and Betty had put a lot of work into their marriage. Alan had taken a new job that required almost zero travel, just how Betty liked it, and Betty had agreed to do that marriage Encounters program.

17:03 Things were going swell for the Gore family. It finally felt like they were back on track. On June thirteenth of nineteen eighty, thirty three year old Alan Gore left his wily home at about eight am. He was catching a flight to Saint Paul, Minnesota on a business trip. Since he had accepted this new job, these trips were rare, but he couldn't avoid this one, and he was actually kind of looking forward to it. The project really intrigued him, but at the same time, Alan knew this trip would be hard on Betty. Right before he boarded the plane at Dallas Fort Worth, he called the landline at his home, expecting Betty to pick up.

17:45 He waited for eleven or twelve rings, but no one answered the phone, and she should have picked up, but she didn't. Huh. Alan probably thought weird. When he arrived in Saint Paul, he called Betty again, still no answer. As he worked on a Saint Paul project, his mind wandered back to his wife. Why wasn't Betty answering the phone. Allan was getting worried. He rationalized that perhaps Betty had taken an afternoon walk with baby Bethany, or maybe she was angry with him. It's possible she could have said something that morning that Alan forgot. But Allan wasn't too concerned that Betty was mad at him. After all, he had planned a trip to Europe for Betty. They were leaving the next week, and they were very excited.

18:32 This would be Alan and Betty's first outing without their kids in four years. Their daughters were staying with Betty's parents. In many ways, this could be considered Alan and Betty's second honeymoon, and that felt especially appropriate after all the work they had done on their marriage recently, including renewing their vows at that marriage Encounter's program. Alan called Betty from his hotel room that night, still no answer. At this point, he was very concerned. He called his neighbor and real estate agent, Richard Parker. Allan and Richard weren't really friends, but when he asked Richard to go check on Betty, Richard agreed.

19:12 He knocked on the door to the Gore home, but no one answered. Richard told Allan that Betty must be out, but Alan knew that Betty would have told him if she was leaving. She was always extra careful when he was gone. Allan called his friend from church, a woman named Candy Montgomery, to see if she could go check on Betty. Candy was watching Betty and Allan's oldest daughter, five year old Alyssa, that day. Candy explained to Allan that she had seen Betty just that morning, and Betty had been fine. She reassured Allan that nothing was wrong, but she did offer to go to Allan's house to check on Betty, but Candy lived over in Fairview, so he said he would call his neighbors back instead. He tried calling Betty again first, then doled Richard's number again. This time, he asked Richard to look in the garage for Betty's car. Richard came back to the phone and said that the garage door was open, the lights were on, but he didn't see Betty's car. Alan was baffled. Why would Betty leave the garage door open? Was she sick? He called the local hospitals, but she wasn't there. He called the police, but they also couldn't help him, which is a bit odd. A welfare check wouldn't have been out of line for a young mother, but they did decline to help, so Alan was left hanging on the other end of the phone, becoming more and more frantic about his wife. Betty was a fragile person, and even more so when she was alone. Alan called Candy again, then he called

20:44 Richard again. Richard was getting annoyed he didn't know Alan all that well, and he thought Alan's wife was probably fine, just one drunk at a friend's house or something. Since Allan was out of town still, he agreed to go check on the house again. Alan suggested that maybe Betty had left a note on a door somewhere, so Richard kept his eyes peeled this time. As he checked the house, he noticed that there were two cars in the garage. If Betty had gone somewhere, one of the cars should have been gone. Richard also noticed that the lights were on inside the house, but still no one was answering the door. Now he had a bad feeling.

21:26 He told Allan something's wrong. Alan, I don't know what, but something's wrong. Both cars are there and the lights are on, but nobody answers. If Alan was ever calm during all of this, he wasn't anymore. This was an emergency. He told Richard to get into that house by any means necessary. Reluctantly, Richard agreed. Alan could sense Richard's reluctance, so he called yet another friend. This friend was Jerry McMahon, a computer analyst who lived across the street from the Gores. At Alan's request, Jerry grabbed his flashlight and went to investigate the Gore house. He didn't find anything new, same lights on open garage, no one answering, repeated Knox. Jerry called Allan back and insisted Betty must be at a friend's house. But Allan, now probably losing his damn mind, knew better, He knew his wife better. Allan told Jerry, no, she's not with friends. I've already tried that. Get in that house and see what's wrong. Take the windows off, force the doors, whatever it takes. Jerry didn't want to break into Allan's house, so he called his barber, Leicester Galer. As Jerry and Lester prepared to break into Allan's house, Richard, the reluctant neighbor, finally showed up. He had a bunch of house keys with him. Since Richard was the real estate agent who sold the house to Betty and Allan, he figured he might still have a key to the place in his key stash.

22:56 Together, the three men went through key after key trying to get the backdoor open, but none of the keys worked. Finally, Richard tried the front door and to his surprise, it swung open. It was unlocked. It had probably been unlocked this entire time. All three men immediately understood the importance of an unlocked door and Betty not answering the phone. They hesitated before going in. When they did, it was like stepping into a horror movie. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsor. This show is sponsored by Better Help. I have found that working from home can make you feel silly about scheduling me time. You already have an advantage, but it also means you're always working no set hours, so you need to schedule that time for yourself. And especially if you're juggling a family, you probably tend to their needs before your own. Therapy can give you the tools to find more balance in your life so you can keep supporting others without leaving yourself behind. I've used therapy all my life for big traumas and sometimes just hitting the reset button I get a refresher on positive coping skills and setting boundaries.

24:17 If you're thinking of starting therapy, give Better Help a try. It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist. And switch therapists at any time for no additional charge. Find more balance with better help visit betterhelp dot com slash Southern today to get ten percent off your first month. That's better Help help dot com slash Southern. At eleven fifteen pm on June thirteenth, nineteen eighty, Richard Parker, Jerry McMahon, and Lester Galor gathered up their courage to enter the Gore home. They were looking for Alan's wife, Betty, and they all had a bad feeling about this.

25:04 Now she hadn't answered the Gore's house land line for over ten hours. As the three men went inside and started searching each room, they yelled Betty's name, but she didn't respond. They found eleven month old Bethany Gore first. She was crying in her crib and she had clearly been alone for some time. The poor baby was covered in her own filth, and she had cried so long her voice was hoarse. Richard took Bethany across the street to his house, where his wife took care of her. Back in the Gore house, the men carefully opened each door looking for Betty. During the search, they noticed a strong pungent odor coming from somewhere. They couldn't tell where until Lester opened the door to the laundry room. It was attached to the kitchen. When he opened the door, he saw all blood, so much blood. He immediately closed it. He hadn't seen Betty's body, but he knew she was in there. Next, Jerry looked inside the small twelve by six room. He shut the door quickly and declared, she's dead. She's blown her head off. At this same time, Allan called his home's landline again. Lester picked up, but chickened out and handed the phone to Jerry, and Jerry told Alan that his baby daughter Bethany was safe, but thirty year old Betty Eileen Gore was dead. Jerry had assumed it was a suicide

26:37 and probably told Alan as much, but Jerry also said that he had seen a three foot long wood handled axe in the utility room with Betty, so maybe this was an axe murder. Allan called Candy to tell her the news at eleven thirty pm. Candy sounded shocked and then asked if Bethany was okay, and Alan and said she was. Then he asked Candy not to tell five year old Elissa of her mother's death, he wanted to tell her himself. Before Alan hung up, He asked Candy to watch Elyssa for a few more days, and she agreed. When detectives arrived at the Gore house, they quickly determined that Betty's death was definitely not a suicide. No one could have done to themselves what someone had done to Betty. It just wasn't physically possible. The blood covered axe in the laundry room was obviously the murder weapon, and initial reports claimed that Betty had suffered fifteen chop wounds from the axe, but later the autopsy would indicate that Betty had actually endured forty one chop wounds, and she was alive for forty of them. Twenty eight of the blows were directly to her face. Her skull was crushed from the front and back. One of her arms was almost severed, probably in her desperate attempt to shield her head. Her cause of death was written as blows to the head. Needless to say, the crime scene was incredibly gruesome, with blood

28:08 splashed up the walls and all over the small room, and Betty lying in a very large, congealing pool of blood. Her head was so mangled. The officers struggled to look at her. Journalist Jim Atkinson and John Bloom wrote in Texas Monthly the following description, which is graphic if you want to skip ahead about thirty seconds. To get a look at her face, the men had to walk around the ocean of red. What they saw was even more unsettling. Her lips were parted, showing her front teeth, her mouth fashioned into a half grin. Her hair radiated in all directions a tangled, soaked mess of glistening black, and Betty's left eye was wide open, staring down at the gaping black craters in her arm. As to her right eye, she appeared to not have one. The entire right half of her face seemed to be gone. The investigation into Betty's murder was conducted by the Collin County Sheriff's Office, the Wily Police Department, and the Dallas Homicide Detective Unit.

29:12 From the jump, they knew this wasn't a robbery. There was cash lying out in the open, completely untouched. As police combed the Gore household, they of course found the axe, but they also discovered the following key pieces of evidence. A small bloody footprint near Betty's body, a bloody fingerprint on the refrigerator, and both blood and hair in the Gore shower, as if someone had tried to clean themselves up after killing Betty. There was blood on the Fawcets soap, dish, shower curtain and in the tub. Keep in mind, we're in nineteen eighty right now. DNA analysis was a long ways away, so despite having both blood and hair samples that were probably from the killer, the detectives couldn't do much with it. They could do something with a fingerprint. However, the police chief told the fort Worth Star Telegram that he had no motive and no suspects. Betty hadn't been robbed or raped.

30:11 There weren't even signs of a forced entry, but clearly she was murdered. It looked like a crime of passion and also not premeditated. The acts came from inside the Gore home. The killer did not bring it with them, and Betty had clearly opened the door for this person. It was someone she knew, or at least wasn't afraid of. News about Betty Gore's death traveled fast. Hers was the first murderer while he had seen in fifteen years, and as a result, the entire town was a twitter. Friends called friends, who called two more friends. They all concluded that it had to be some very sick person who had so viciously murdered Betty Gore. The only solace they had as the murderer walked free was that they probably weren't going to kill again. After all, the axe that was used to murder Betty was from Betty's own house. It hung in her garage. If some psycho ax murderer was wandering the streets, surely they would have their own acts, or at the very least, they would have taken the one they used to murder Betty.

31:17 One law official named John Buddy Newton told the Associated Press, it's just my personal opinion, based on no evidence, that this was a one shot deal executed in a moment of frenzy. I don't feel like there's a psycho on the loose. I think the person was the intended victim and there was no reason other than what motivated the killer. I could be entirely wrong, but it is just a gut feeling. The killer went after the person they wanted and did a very thorough job of it. Newton would be pretty much right. This was personal and people probably didn't need to worry about a killer on the loose. Regardless, the public was still scared. A woman was literally chopped to pieces. It's scary. Everyone double checked that their doors were locked each night and kept loaded guns at the ready. One of Betty's neighbors told the AP I hate to say this, but I hope it was someone who knew her. It's really scary to think about some weirdo just walking in off the street and doing it. On June sixteenth, three days after the murderer, over two hundred and fifty people attended Betty's funeral at her Methodist church.

32:27 The next day, AP News reported that local detectives were still unsure of what happened Betty. A wily police officer told the reporters, we don't have anything, really, and we don't know anything, not a thing so far. The investigators had picked up two men thinking they could be somehow related to Betty's case, but they weren't. And then on June twentieth, seven days after Betty's murder, newspapers reported that a Dallas County fingerprint expert had a strong lead. They had successful identified a suspect for Betty Gore's killer. Using that bloody fingerprint on the fridge, they matched a set of prints from a female subject. They wouldn't name who this female subject was. They only referenced her as a friend of the family. Two days passed and no arrest was made.

33:19 The people of Wiley were baffled. If the police had, as they said in their own words, a good clean match for the bloody fingerprint, why was there no arrest. Was a killer just walking free? None of this made sense. Finally, on Jean twenty sixth, nineteen eighty, thirteen days after Betty was killed, some progress was made. The police arrested thirty year old Candy Lynn Montgomery, a friend of the Gore family, a housewife, a devout churchgoer, and Alan Gore's mistress. I'm going to pause now for a commercial break. Candice Lynne Wheeler was born on November fifteenth, nineteen forty nine. Her father was a radar technician for the military, so Candy was an army brat, moving across the United States a lot during her childhood, as well as overseas, and every time Candy's family relocated to a new state, she did pretty well. She would meet new people, build a new life, and do her best to thrive. After moving around so much, she learned to be really friendly, not necessarily outspoken or loud, but just nice, the kind of woman who felt at home anywhere and everywhere.

34:38 She was easygoing and had a quiet confidence about her. Texas Monthly described Candy as a pretty vivacious, utterly normal suburban housewife. They went on to say she was a loving mother, a devoted wife, a churchgoer, and everyone's friend to those around Candy, her sweetness didn't feel like an act. She wasn't a sociopath hidden in plain sight. She was just a kind person, or at least she seemed like one. Candy married her husband, Pat on October sixth, nineteen seventy in al Paso, Texas, when she was twenty years old. Pat Montgomery, as they pronounced it, had been older at twenty five, and he was a rising star in the electrical engineering world.

35:27 He worked for Texas Instruments, which was actually where he met Candy. She was a secretary there. In nineteen seventy seven, after seven years of marriage, Candy and Pat moved to Fairview, Texas, another suburb of Dallas. By this time, they had a son and a daughter, and Pat was doing really well. He made seventy thousand a year at Texas Instruments today about three hundred and fifty thousand dollars a year. As you can imagine, Candy did not need to work, so she was a housewife. She took care of the kids, the house, cooked, ran all the errands, and by Candy's own admission, she was still bored. She decided to do something about it, create a little adventure in her humdrum, whitebread life. So she decided to have an affair. She even spoke to her friends about it in a hypothetical way. Of course, she joked about taking a lover, but it wasn't all jokes. She explained to her friends that she wasn't feeling the spark with Pat anymore. They had been arguing a lot, and she wanted better sex. Candy's exact words were, I want fireworks. She met Alan Gore in late nineteen seventy seven. She and Pat went to the same church as Alan and Betty, and as active church members, they ran into each other a lot. Their choir practices were at the same time they played on the church volleyball team together, and because of all that, Candy and Allan would chat frequently and no one thought anything of it. Maybe Allan teased

37:00 Candy a little more than he did the other women at church. Maybe their shared smiles seemed to tad too intimate. But for the most part, it just seemed like Candy and Pat had bonded with Betty and Allan. Though way married couples with kids do. They would babysit each other's children and wave if they passed each other on the street. They had a lot in common. Both men worked in what was called silicon prairie and lucrative tech jobs, and they were both relatively happy with home and work. Both women felt stifled and bored in their small towns, their lives molded around their husband and children. Of course, outwardly they would say they had the church choir and young daughters in common. Their girls were best friends. But they were both unhappy in their lives. In a way, they were warped mirror images of their happy, go lucky husbands. Candy just hid it under a happy housewife facade, while Betty seemed to emanate unhappy happiness to everyone. But back to the affair, if Candy knew Allan for months before they began their affair. What spurred it? What caused Candy to think Allan, of all people, would be a great person to have an affair with. Remember, Allan was not a traditionally handsome guy. He had a receding hairline, a bit of a gut.

38:22 He wasn't a snappy dresser. I am not trying to hate on Alan, but it's the truth, and a lot of people have wondered why she was attracted to him. I feel like I need to point out that Candy was considered attractive, though not a knockout. She was thin, an athletic build. But it's her styling you'll wonder about. Many of you may see photos and disagree that she was attractive. I went through this with Darley Routier, so I get it. I ask of you to remember that hairstyles over forty years ago were a trip. Perms were all the rage, though at least my mom had long hair when she permed hers. But the hairstyle Candy war was not unusual, just a tad short. She was also later advised to change her hair to a more conservative style for court, which is where most photos you will see come from. Is it attractive now once she changed it? Hell no, But this isn't nineteen eighty and it was considered a mousei hairdo even then. And let's be more fair, Candy's husband Pat wasn't a looker either, and Betty, while she did have a lovely smile, had a haircut worse than Candies, and the stress and depression she suffered in her later years showed on her. The point is all of these people were just normal people. That's what makes this story so salacious. It wasn't really Candy's looks that attracted Alan. He was flattered and enjoyed her forwardness anyway.

39:52 According to Texas Monthly, in the summer of nineteen seventy eight, there was a catalyst that ignited Candy's flame for Alan. As the story goes, Candy and Allan bumped into each other while playing volleyball together, and that's when Candy noticed that Alan smelled really good. According to Texas Monthly, Alan smelled so good that Candy just had to have him. So one day, following choir practice, Alan was walking to his car and that's when Candy stopped him. He was already in the driver's seat, so she opened the passenger door and got in his car. According to Texas Monthly, Candy said, Alan, I'll want to talk to you sometime about something that's been bothering me. I've been thinking about you a lot, and I don't know whether I want you to do anything about it or not. Then she got out of the car and left. Alan was shocked, though, like I said, flattered.

40:50 This exchange was very unusual for him, but he was intrigued. A week later, Alan and Candy began chatting after a church volleyball game. They were cleaning up the gym and walked out to their cars together. It was then that Allan asked Candy what she had meant when she approached him earlier, and Candy asked, would you be interested in having an affair? Allan didn't know how to respond. He told Candy that he loved Betty. He mentioned that Betty had had a brief affair when they lived in New Mexico years earlier. He had obviously forgiven her, but not forgotten it. Alan remembered that he was so incredibly hurt by her infidelity that he didn't want to do the same thing to Betty, especially since they had just found out that Betty was pregnant, so Candy pulled back. She agreed with Alan, and she said it would be best not to hurt her husband too. According to Texas Monthly, Candy said, I was just putting the option out there because of how I felt, and it's up to you to decide. I don't want to hurt your marriage. All I wanted to do was go to bed. I won't mention it again. Then Candy chased, kissed Alan on the lips, and left. About three weeks past Then, on Candy's twenty ninth birthday, Alan called her. He offered to take her out to lunch to discuss a potential affair. He needed to go to an auto repair shop that was relatively close to Candy, so they met at the car shop and Alan gave her a

42:22 birthday card. It read for the Last of the Red Hot Lovers and had a bat of red Hot candies inside. Then they just chatted about anything and everything. Candy spoke with Alan about her creative writing course, which was especially exciting since her husband Pat never wanted to talk about how well she was doing in that class. At the end of this conversation, Alan admitted that he had never had an affair before. Candy said she never had either. The two discussed how concerned they were about hurting their spouses. They vowed to not get emotionally involved, that everything would be purely physical. By the end of the conversation, they determined they would continue evaluating the risks again. Weeks passed, Candy and Allan continued to talk about the risks of having an affair.

43:15 Truly, it feels like they were hemming and hawing just for show, or I guess this was a type of four play. They had never really flirted before Candy's proposition, so maybe that's what all this was. But they definitely kept it about the ramifications of an affair. They would ask questions like when would we do it? What if somebody saw us, and debate the answers to no end. At one point, Candy invited Alan to her house for lunch one day and presented a big piece of butcher paper for them to write down a proclm list about their affair. It was titled Whys and why Nots. It was intended as a cute joke, but it was also in a way serious. After all, they did write down pro con bulletin points on the butcher paper. The biggest con was, of course, getting caught, but Candy reassured Alan that they would be very careful. Alan was also worried that either he or Candy would become emotionally entangled. Candy said, as reported by Texas Monthly, Alan, as far as I'm concerned, this is just for fun. I'm not serious about it. It's just a companionship thing, and we shouldn't be afraid of it. Whatever happens, will do it for a while, and then it will be over. That lunch at Candy's helped keep building the tension towards the big moment when it finally happened, and eventually it did happen. A few days after the big pro con list, Allan

44:46 called An affirmed he wanted an affair with Candy. Then Candy created a list of rules so they could keep the affair with them predetermined parameters. Some stand out rules included if either one of them ever wanted to end the affair for whatever reason, it would end, no questions asked. If either one became too emotionally involved, the affair would end. If they ever started taking risks that shouldn't be taken, the affair would end. All expenses, food, motel, room, gasoline would be shared equally. They would meet only on week days while their spouses were at work. Candy would be in charge of fixing lunch on the days they met so that they could have more time with every possible TEA crossed and I dotted. The two set the date for their affair to launch, December twelfth, nineteen seventy eight. Betty, who was still pregnant, didn't suspect anything, and Pat was also none the wiser.

45:47 Once every other week, Candy would wake up extra early to cook a lavish lunch. She'd pack it neatly in a picnic basket, and then she and Alan would meet during his lunch hour. Candy always booked the Como motel and Richardson for twenty three dollars a day. Allan was in a high up, trusted position at work, so he could take two hour lunches with no one noticing, and he often did when he was with Candy. Richardson is another suburb of Dallas and about fifteen minutes from Candy's home in Fairview, so it wasn't in the town's either new lover lived nor where Allan and Pat worked, but it was close enough to be convenient for Candy, who, let's face it, did all the work at the como. The two would eat half sex, and then it was just pillow talk until it was time for Allan to head back to work. For a few months, this was pretty exciting for both Allan and Candy. Allan, who wasn't very experienced sexually, thought Candy was good in bed, and Candy thought Allan showed potential. But after a while she realized the sex with Allan was not getting any better, and it was actually a lot of work for her to get up early and make these extravagant lunches on their affair days. Not to mention, Alan had started expecting more from Candy, sweet notes packed in the lunch cookies for him to take home, little things that just gave Candy more and more work to do.

47:16 She had done these things willingly in the beginning, little shows of affection, but now it was becoming work. After a while, Candy and Alan stopped having sexes often. They still met regularly and had sex sometimes, but they were more best friends than lovers, as Texas Monthly described it. But that didn't stop Candy from falling for Alan, which is now when my old ass will remind you that the best romantic relationships are people who are best friends companionship, being able to really talk to someone creates real intimacy. So even though Candy was disappointed by the sex in February of nineteen seventy nine, old Allan she was thinking about him too much and she didn't want to have to deal with the inevitable heartbreak. She was trying to end the affair, but Alan stopped Candy in her tracks. He reassured her that the relationship wouldn't get too serious. Without much argument, Candy agreed. Although Alan was in this just as deeply as Candy, he wasn't catching feelings the way she was.

48:23 He just felt like he needed her. Did you just hear Phil Collins singing to you? Because I did? I love that song in too deep? Anyway, their relationship was special and thrilling. It improved Alan's self confidence to have a pretty woman infatuated with him, cooking meals for him and having sex with him. Of Course, Alan had no intention ever of divorcing Betty, let alone marrying Candy. He just liked their little secret, their shared glances at church, Alan felt wanted and that's all he wanted. And now at Erica will tell you that this is another cliche. This affair was supposed to be exciting. Candy didn't feel excited yet she felt emotionally attached. Alan was excited, but he didn't fell in love with Candy, but he had bigger problems. In June of nineteen seventy nine, Allan became worried that is now seven months pregnant wife would go into labor while he was out having an affair with Candy. He wouldn't be reachable since he would be at the unknown hotel.

49:30 And yes, cheating on your pregnant wife is some next level stassary, but at least Alan knew he would be devastated if his baby was born while he was off cheating on his wife. He suggested to Candy that they paused their affair until the baby was born, and Candy agreed. What a gentleman. That same month, Candy threw Betty a surprised baby shower. Most of the churchwomen came. They ate cake, open gifts, and a generally good time. Betty appeared unaware of Candy's affair with her husband, which is just bananas. Alan haunts the affair, so then Candy throws his wife a baby shower. You can't make this shut up anyway. That July of nineteen seventy nine, as you know, Betty gave birth to Bethany. Following that, Candy and Allan resumed their affair, but it wasn't the same. Allan, for the first time ever, felt guilty about what he was doing to Betty, and Alan might have had a gut feeling that Betty suspected something. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Right after Bethany was born, Alan and Betty planned a trip to Kansas. They wanted to show off their new baby to Betty's parents in Norwich. They arrived back at their home late on a Thursday night. Betty figured that Allan wouldn't go into work the

51:01 next day, after all, that's what he had done in the past. But for some reason, Allan was insistent he needed to go back to the office tomorrow. And we know why. Alan had a date with Candy over his lunch hour. But Betty didn't know this, and she was pissed. She kept asking Alan why what on earth was going on at work that was so urgent. She needed his help unpacking, managing the kids, and running errands. It felt like Alan was abandoning her. Finally, Alan relented, but before he went to bed that Thursday night, he did something out of the ordinary. He called Candy Montgomery. While on the phone with Candy, Allan brought up some church function that Betty hadn't heard of. He told Candy he wouldn't be able to make it to the function the next day. Betty didn't think much of this exchange. She and Allan were heavily involved at the local Methodist church. They did a lot of events. It's not impossible that maybe some function or another had slipped her mind. But Betty did remember this incident later, whether she meant to or not, and she might have thought about it a few times, especially after one particular night when Betty wanted to have sex with Alan. This was rare for Betty. She never initiated sex.

52:22 In fact, they hadn't even had sex since Bethany was born weeks earlier, and Allan, knowing that his wife hardly ever offered sex without coaxing, turned her down. He said he was too tired. Now Betty was hurt defeated, and she told Alan as much. Betty said she felt unloved and fat, and nothing Allan said could fix it. For such a conservatively raised woman to get up the nerve to make the first move and then be rejected would be the ultimate humiliation, and it certainly was for Betty. Fall of nineteen seventy nine, Betty became depressed. She returned to teaching, which, considering how little she enjoyed her job, didn't help her depression, and she started getting horrible back pains. Her neck was constantly sore. That's the thing with depression, it can make your whole body hurt. Betty was losing her spark. Her confidence was gone. She was a shell of who she used to be, and Alan noticed. He came to Candy trying to end the affair, but Candy wasn't having it. Alan tried to explain he told Candy about the night that he couldn't perform for Betty and how destructive it was to his marriage, but Candy argued. She said that Betty was being unfair, and she also accused Allan of being unfair. When Candy had wanted to end things months ago, he wouldn't let her, but now now he wanted to

53:54 end things. After this debacle, Candy and Allan's affair and last much longer. Allan started a new job, one that required less travel so he could spend more time with Betty, and then he and Betty had their life changing experience at the Marriage Encounters program. That was the last straw that broke the camel's back. In late nineteen seventy nine, Allan came to Candy and explained that he wanted to give his full resources to his family. Their affair was over. Candy and pat actually did the same Marriage Accounters program too, once Candy saw the difference in the Gore marriage, but they didn't have the same great results as Betty and Allen. On Friday, June thirteenth of nineteen eighty, the day Betty was murdered, Candy and Allan's affair had been over for about half a year. Alyssa had spent the night at Candy's house the night before. She was best friends with Jenny, Candy's daughter. Candy then took all the kids to vacation Bobble School, which she, of course had held help to organize. Alyssa often spent the night, but this week Candy could drive her to vacation Bible School for Betty. Candy, always the perfect mom, never hesitated to help out her friends. I think it's a testament that she didn't have any lingering, jealousy or feelings for Alan too. That morning, the girls begged for Elissa to stay one more night because the Montgomery family was going to the movies that night to see The Empire Strikes Back. She

55:29 said, of course and promised to ask Betty for Elyssa. She called her and was supposed to come by around noon to pick up Alyssa's swimsuit. The little girl had swim lessons that afternoon, and despite the busy day and evening plans, Candy was still taken Alyssa to her lesson, but she decided to run over to the Gore House earlier. That way, Candy could take Alyssa to her swim lesson right after Vacation Bobble School, and then they would all go meet Pat Montgomery at the movie theme her. Candy also needed to stop and get Father's Day cards. The holiday was that weekend. She had her day regimented tightly, and she also wanted to get back to vacation Bobble school, and time to see the kid's puppet show. In the book Evidence of Love, they illustrate what a pain in the ass all this was for Candy.

56:21 She lived in Fairview, the church was in Lucas, but Betty was in Wiley. She spent a lot of time on the road in her station wagon, but never complained. When Candy knocked on Betty's door around ten am, she thought Betty looked irritated when she opened it, and she probably was. Candy was two hours early and her eleven month old daughter Bethany had just gone down for her mid morning nap. Betty had a cup of coffee in her hand and was about to take a few minutes to herself and watch the Phil Donahue show. Also, Alan was gone, which Betty hated, and the night before or Betty had started wondering if she was pregnant again. She felt all the sogns were there, so Betty wasn't in the best mood, but she offered coffee to Candy, who politely declined. Candy was friendly enough for the both of them. They chatted about everything, and she even asked to meet the Gore's new dog. Everything was normal, Finally, Candy mentioned that she needed to get going, and then Betty explained that Alyssa didn't like putting her face underwater during her swim lessons. She gave Candy the peppermints that she used to reward Alyssa for submerging her whole body. Starting from here onward, the version of events I'm about to tell you comes straight from Candy's court testimony, as reported by many local newspapers and Texas Monthly. Nobody knows exactly what happened to Betty. Nobody but Candy Montgomery, and this is what she

57:54 said happened to Betty on June thirteenth, nineteen eighty. According to Candy, Betty said, out of the blue, are you having an affair with Alan, to which Candy said, no, of course not. And then Betty followed up with a different question, But you did, didn't you. At this Candy admitted she had, but it was a long time ago, she promised. Betty told Candy to hold on for a moment, and she left the room. When she reappeared, she was holding a three foot axe in her hand. She wasn't wielding it, just holding it loosely in both hands with the blade pointed toward the floor. Betty told Candy, well, don't see him again. Candy could tell the situation was dire, even though Betty's tone was subdued, and Candy said that under the circumstances, she would just bring the Lissa straight home from Bobble school. But Betty said, no, keep Alissa overnight. She wanted Candy to return Alissa the next day. I guess when Alan would be home, because she never wanted to see Candy again.

59:01 Then Betty put the axe down. She went to grab Alyssa's towel and told Candy to get a Lissa's swimsuit off of the washer. Betty also gave Candy the peppermints that Alyssa liked. Then Candy put the swimsuit, towel and candies in her handbag. She said that Betty looked so sad that she put her hand on her arm and said, oh Betty, I'm so sorry. And at that Candy said, Betty lost it. She shoved Candy into the laundry room, grabbed the axe and rushed her. Betty screamed, you can't have him, over and over again. I'm going to have a baby, and you can't have him this time, she cried. Candy put her hands on the axe handle as Betty approached, denying that she wanted alan. For a long time, the two women held onto the axe, waiting for the other's shoe to drop. Would the situation de escalate or was someone about to get hurt. Finally, Betty jerked the axe. Candy held on but started pleading. She said, Betty, don't do this, please stop, and Betty, according to Candy, responded, I've got to kill you. They fought for control of the axe. In the process, the flat part of the blade hit Candy in the head. Then Candy saw Betty raise the axe over her head. She was going to strike Candy very very hard. At this point, Candy screamed and jumped out of the way as best she could, but it was a small room, so she couldn't go very far.

1:00:35 She knocked some of the knick knacks off the cabinets in an effort to escape. Betty swing missed and hit the linoleum, but the blade bounced and struck Candy's foot. Candy grabbed the blade of the axe while Betty jerked on the handle. Betty moved her hands down the handle toward the blade, trying to get leverage. Then she leaned in and bit Candy's hand, and that's when Candy saw her opportunity. Betty was off balance from leaning over so far, so Candy shoved her with the axe and Betty fell. Candy then struck Betty's head with the axe. It was a death blow, at least Candy thought so, but miraculously Betty wasn't dead yet. She got up and grabbed the axe to go after Candy again. Candy once again grabbed the axe by the handle and the two women did the same four hands on the axe dance again.

1:01:30 It was now a struggle to the death for Betty. Candy tried to get out of the laundry room, but Betty was able to stop her and lock the door. Candy said she slipped and fell due to all the blood, but Betty, who had lost all that blood, didn't have the strength to raise the axe anymore. Candy attacked Betty's leg and Betty fell practically on top of Candy. Now they fought over the axe while sitting next. He gave up the axe and ran for the door, but it wouldn't open because Betty had locked it. She turned toward Betty, who was wielding the axe, and said, Betty, don't please let me go. I don't want him. I don't want him. Betty responded by saying sh and placing one finger over her mouth, and according to Candy's defense team at trial, this triggered a response in Candy. It was just like when Candy's own mother had shushed her when she was in immense pain as a child, and it caused Candy to snap. She grabbed the axe from Betty, knocked her down, and hit her over and over again with the axe. Forty one wax.

1:02:43 Betty Gore was obliterated. After Candy killed Betty, she went to great links to hide it. First, she tried to shower with her clothes on in the Gore home, but when that wasn't effective, she left for her own house. Once there, she showed, houred, and changed clothes. She washed and dried the same shirt and found some jeans that were the same color as she had been wearing so no one would notice. She found some tennis shoes to cover up the wound on her toe and keep the bandage tight. The wound on her head was harder, the bandage wouldn't stay because of her hairdo She just kept dabbing the blood when she thought about it and her head. She had already concocted a story about cutting her toe on a broken storm door. And then she picked up her children and Alyssa from church. She spoke with her friend Barbara Green, and then she took the kids to see the Empire strikes back like nothing had ever happened. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. The next day, everyone knew that Betty Gore had been horrifically murdered. Candy did yardwork. She trimmed her hedges and shrubs.

1:03:59 Then she used those same garden shears to cut up the sandals she had worn while killing Betty. She threw the shoe pieces away in the outdoor garbage can. Around this time, Candy spoke to her friend Barbara Green on the phone. Barbara was shocked to hear that Candy had visited Betty so close to the time when someone had murdered her. Barbara later told the court, I remember telling her how glad I was that she was not hurt, that if she had been there when it happened, she might have been hurt too. When Candy was arrested on June twenty six, people couldn't believe it. It seemed like poor innocent Candy had been mistakenly nabbed based on some unrelated fingerprints while the real murderer was running free. The church helped her raise the money to cover the hundred thousand dollar bond. People from the Wily community sent her greeting cards and well wishes, letting Candy know they were on her side. Her church reverend said that she would be guilty of what they say. She is is incomprehensible. She's not capable of committing murder. She's a very creative, very talented, very highly intelligent person. And Candy's husband, Pat, also expressed his support for his wife. But less than a week later, people started having doubts about Candy's innocence. And that's because Alan told the police about his affair with Candy, and the newspapers, as newspapers do, caught wind of it. Candy and Alan's church congregation was stunned to learn of the affair.

1:05:33 Even though it had ended, very few people even knew it had happened. Candy's husband, Pat knew last spring he had been looking for his and Candy's old love letters. In the process, he found a love letter to Candy from someone other than him. It was a goodbye letter from Alan Gore, finalizing the end of his affair with Candy. But his wife was going on trial for her life and he was going to support her. Candy hired a personal injury lawyer if she knew from church, named Don Crowder. He told her she needed an experienced criminal defense attorney, but she wanted him.

1:06:15 She knew him and felt comfortable, so he hired a criminal lawyer to help him with the case and sit second chair. Don Crowder was going to trot an Axe murder case as his first criminal case in a court of law. It seemed crazy. Candy's trial began on Monday, October twentieth, nineteen eighty. It was a media circus. Over two hundred people packed the courtroom. The trial would only last eight sensational days. For weeks, Candy's lawyers had been hinting that she was going to plead guilty, so the courtroom was stunned when Candy started off by pleading self defense. Now her testimony was tantamount to the case, and we know defendants rarely take the stand. This was a huge gamble. The prosecution had a hint of what was to come because they knew Candy had passed a polygraph when she told her story, but they still thought self defense was outrageous and impossible as a defense in this brutal murder.

1:07:19 And when Candy got to the witness stand, she didn't do well. She came across clipped and cool, according to Texas Monthly, not personable, kind or friendly, not even shy, which probably would have been better in the eyes of the jury, But Texas Monthly was not on that jury, and newspapers don't always read a courtroom right. Candy's lawyer, Don Crowder, asked Candy's softball questions about her kids, her family, her community, her church, anything and everything to humanize Candy, but Candy was not cooperating. She gave what Texas Monthly described as short, functional answer. She sounded like a stuffy schoolmarm over enunciating her sentences and banishing all emotion from her voice, they wrote. Then Candy was given the chance to tell her story, the version of the murder that I already told you. As Candy told the story, she remained emotionless, with a few straight tears. Following Candy's testimony about the murder, her lawyer Don Crowder decided to try a tactic. Candy wasn't given him much to work with, so he had nothing to lose. He asked her, when you went over there, did you mean to kill her with that axe? And Candy responded no. But then Crowder became loud and urgent.

1:08:44 He said, but you did kill her with that axe, didn't you. Then he grabbed the axe from the evidence table and put it in front of Candy's face. He said, this ax right here. You killed her with this axe right here. Didn't you killed her with this axe right here? Didn't you? This is when Candy jumped up from her chair, screamed, and burst into tears. It was the most emotion anyone had seen out of her during the entire court proceedings, and it visibly affected the jury. One woman wiped her tears. The state argued that Candy didn't kill Betty in self defense because of the sheer number of wounds she inflicted. It was far more damage or injury than is needed to take the life of that person, so said an expert from the Institute of Forensic Sciences in Dallas. In response to this argument, Candy's defense team elaborated on the childhood trauma we touched on earlier. Before the trial, her lawyers had taken her to a hypnotist.

1:09:48 He was actually a psychiatrist named Fred Fazon who used hypnotism on his patients, and based on three sessions, they were able to determine the following Candy Respon wanted to Betty's attack out of trauma. She had acted in pure, uncontrollable rage. She hadn't even known what she was doing. It was a moment of fight or flight that had turned into a fight due to that experience with her mother, saying sh, just like Betty had said, sh Now, whether you believe this or not is up to you personally. I've never seen hypnotism, never tried it myself, or even seen a silly magic show.

1:10:30 I know that regression therapy is supposed to have the same results as well, but I have no idea if it worked, other than Don Crowder saying it did in fact work, as well as the psychiatrist testifying to it at trial. Crowder also used a tactic many found distasteful but it was effective. He blamed the victim. He put Betty Gore on trial. Candy had had many character witnesses who talked about what a wonderful mother she was, how friendly an outgoing she was, how helpful to anyone and everyone. By contrast, Betty was portrayed as sullen, unhappy, and standoffish. Even her pastor, who had eulogized her, testified that she was a difficult woman. If Candy's defense was that Betty started the fight, I guess it made sense to explain why she started it, how she was kind of an angry person to begin with.

1:11:27 And Candy might have come off as robotic in her direct testimony, but she held up well under cross examination. She became more detailed and never faltered with her answers. When asked how she could walk out of the house and leave that baby alone, she explained that she was in shock. She wasn't thinking about the baby, she was putting one foot in front of the other and trying to act normal. Of all the names, Candy was called, murderer, adulteress, or leaving baby Bethany alone was the cherry on top. She did later care very much. In the book Evidence of Love, pat said she called him that afternoon, asking where Alan Gore was that day, worried about how long it would be before he got home. She also offered to go over and check on Betty when Alan was calling around to everyone worried.

1:12:19 You could argue that she wanted to get over there and possibly be able to explain any fingerprints of hers, but you could also argue that she was worried about Bethany. As soon as Alan called with the news about Betty, she asked about Bethany to make sure she was okay. I think she probably couldn't explain herself like this, because the whole point of the prosecution was that she lied and carried on like she didn't do it, but now insisted it with self defense. It probably would have been better had she called the police at the time, but her story was she was in shock, she was traumatized, and I think she probably was, But I do think she was worried about that baby. She wasn't a monster. On Wednesday, October twenty ninth, the jury went to deliberate, and after three hours of deliberation, the call came that they were back. Both sides would have been scared about that short amount of Tom it's always uneasy when a jury comes back quickly.

1:13:18 The judge read the verdict. Candy Montgomery was found not guilty. She was acquitted of all charges. Had Candy been found guilty, she could have been sentenced up to ninety nine years in prison. The courtroom was flabbergasted onlookers chanted murderer, murderer. One wiley resident said, everybody is in shock. I think they forgot about Betty Gore. There are thieves who still and get sent to jail for less than she has done. Betty's brother in law publicly said, I don't think justice was served in the least bit. I think it was murder. And Bob Pomeroy, Betty's father and a godfearing man, said, as far as I am concerned, justice will be done. Eventually, Candy left the courtroom and about a week later, she and her family moved out of Texas. Don Crowder rode the wave of publicity he had earned getting his client off with self defense and an axe murder. He ran for governor of Texas in nineteen eighty six, but he took his own life in nineteen ninety eight. After all of this, Candy and Pat remained married. Pat accepted a teaching position with Georgia Tech University immediately following the trial, but the Montgomery marriage ultimately did not survive. They divorced four years later. Pat still works in defense technologies in Georgia. Candy now goes by Candy Wheeler, her maiden name. She has worked as a mental health therapist for teens and adults.

1:14:49 In a twentieth anniversary retrospective in two thousand, Candy refused to speak to the Dallas Morning News reporters. She said, I'm telling you in big bold letters, I'm not interested. Alan Gore remarried three months after Betty's murder to a woman named Elaine, who was the church organist. That marriage ended in divorce. He lost a custody battle with Betty's parents, so Elyssa and Bethany were raised by their maternal grandparents in Norwich, Kansas. Today, according to Facebook, Alan lives in Sarasota, Florida, and I imagine is still an asshole. Can you believe how fast he remarried. Alyssa is exactly my age, so both girls are now women in their forties. They spoke out during the twenty year anniversary retrospective, but it was mostly about the drama with their father and stepmother. Alyssa, who goes by Lisa, barely remembered her mother, and Bethany, of course, didn't remember her at all. Even though they didn't remember much, they did say they felt Candy wasn't telling the whole story and wished they knew the truth. I cannot imagine growing up and having to live with a woman who murdered your mother going free. I hope that both women have gotten help and moved on with their lives, but losing a parent, especially so violently, as a whole, you can never feel.

1:16:17 Since nineteen eighty, there have been multiple remakes of Candy and Betty's case in the media. It inspired a nineteen ninety CBS made for TV movie called A Killing in a Small Town and a non fiction book called Evidence of Love. The two most well known adaptations right now are Elizabeth Olsen's Max show called Love and Death and Jessica Bill's Hulu show called Candy. I have watched all of them, and, of course time permitting, soon Andrea and I are going to discuss these shows for Patreon. As for Candy Montgomery and the truth of what happened in the laundry room on a hot day in June of nineteen eighty.

1:16:57 I'm going to take a lot of ship for this, but I believe her. Hear me out because nothing else makes sense. KNDy told people she was going to Betty's house to get Lyssa's swimsuit. She parked her station wagon right in front of the house. It was clearly a crime of passion. There was no planning. She didn't bring a gun and her purse. The axe came from the Gores garage, and Candy was no longer involved with Alan. It is crazy to me that she could just carry on taking care of Alyssa and even babysitting Bethany after the affair. But she did. She was a woman who was capable of compartmentalizing her entire life. Call me crazy, but I do believe her version of events with one problem. I have said before that intent can be formed within seconds. Forty one wax with an axe does not seem like self defense, but her attorneys argued that she snapped, and clearly the jury believed it. Psychiatrist Fred face On, the hypnotist, testified at the trial and claimed that Candy had a dissociative reaction that led her to chop at Betty repeatedly. Don Crowder also argued that the violent death was also protected under Texas's stand your Ground law, which permits the use of deadly force if necessary to prevent a violent crime. And Candy said that Betty attacked her with the axe, she had to defend herself. And it was a

1:18:30 jury of nine women and three men. I think that could have helped. Have you ever picked up an axe, much less a three foot axe, which was the murder weapon. They are so heavy, I'm not strong enough to raise one for even one chop. And I'm willing to bet those women believed he'd of passion because they know what it's like to try and pick up an axe. That Candy was already wounded twice and was terrified then enraged that Betty attacked her. I also think this is one of those cases where the prosecutions screwed up by not giving the jury more options. They might have said guilty for manslaughter or some other lesser offense, but not first degree murderer.

1:19:14 They didn't believe that Candy went there to murder Betty, and they did believe that the gruesome forty one wax were born of rage after Betty attacked Candy. Maybe they would have acquitted her either way, but we will never know, and it's really important to note that we don't know Betty Gore's thought of the story. We don't know why she went and grabbed that axe other than what Candy said. Candy said Betty thought she was pregnant. If she found out about the affair and felt so vulnerable, maybe she did attack for the record. An autopsy showed she was not actually pregnant. Whatever really happened between the two women resulted in a death match for an extremely heavy axe, and Kendy Montgomery was the winner. But she won a lifetime of whispers and people pointing, even if she changed her name and moved, but it was a life all the same. Southern Fried True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank and myself, and of course all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Colly Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brennan Scheck Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly.

1:20:36 If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. You will get lost in a sea of emails if you send it to my main address, so this is the best way for me to get those little known cases you'll always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, But please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern Fried, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shut as is allowed.

1:21:30 It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe, and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like I Heart, Stitcher, Spotify, Amazon, and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care,