May 22, 2023

180: The Alday Family Massacre

180: The Alday Family Massacre
180: The Alday Family Massacre
Southern Fried True Crime
180: The Alday Family Massacre

For the Alday family, May 14th of 1973 started like any other day. The Alday men woke up before sunrise to tend to their family farm, and the Alday women began working on their chores. They plowed the field, planted corn, and ate lunch. Little did...

For the Alday family, May 14th of 1973 started like any other day. The Alday men woke up before sunrise to tend to their family farm, and the Alday women began working on their chores. They plowed the field, planted corn, and ate lunch. Little did they know that, by the end of that afternoon, their lives would be irreparably changed forever. Six members of the Alday family dead. Their farm decimated. Their future destroyed. All because four dangerous men, three of whom were prison escapees, would accidentally stumble upon their modest home in rural Seminole County, Georgia.

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Brandon Schexnayder of Southern Gothic & Erica Kelley
Case suggested by: Tommy, Sandra, Carrie, Terry & Jordie

Sources:https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/the-alday-family-massacre
  • This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp online therapy. Give online therapy a try at BetterHelp.com/southern and get on your way to being your best self.
  • Cancel your unwanted subscriptions with RocketMoney.com/southernfried
  • Try Lume, the “whole body deodorant” by going to Lume.com/SFTC
  • Give the “dads” in your life the precious gift of memories, bound in a beautiful keepsake book. Go to StoryWorth.com/southernfried to save $10 on your purchase.


This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:02 Southern Fried true crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Today's case involves sexual assault. Listener discretion is strongly advised. On November fifteenth of nineteen fifty nine, four members of the Clutter family of Holcombe, Kansas were murdered in cold blood. Herb and Bonnie Clutter were in their late forties and their children were just teenagers, a sixteen year old daughter named Nancy and a fifteen year old son named Kenyon. They were killed by two ex convicts, Perry Smith and Richard Hickock.

0:45 Six years later in nineteen sixty five, Both killers were executed by hanging. The year after that, in nineteen sixty six, Truman Capote published his groundbreaking novel In Cold Blood, which began a new true crime genre, one that was much more respected than the salacious detective magazines born of the earlier penny dreadfuls from centuries before, and Capodi had found the perfect subject. The Clutter family massacre shocked the nation. The Clutters were the epitome of nineteen fifties innocence. They were farmers, pillars of the church, and good people beloved by their community, well off but not conspicuously wealthy, and their deaths were just so senseless the innocence was shattered. Perry Smith had heard a rumor from a former cellmate that Herb Clutter kept large amounts of cash in his home, but Herb didn't. Angry when they discovered there was no money or real valuables on the property, Smith and Hincock executed the Clutter family rather than leave any witnesses, and for what reason. There was no DNA testing, no fingerprint and database. Perry and Richard could have walked off into the sunset with no one the wiser, but they didn't. They chose to massacre a family simply because they could. This seems like an unlikely event, an anomaly, a series

2:22 of unfortunate events that led to the unwarranted deaths of an entire Midwestern family. But fourteen years later, in nineteen seventy three, history would repeat itself. Fifty years ago, the South experienced its own horrific family massacre, committed in cold blood. Welcome to Episode one eighty the All Day Family Massacre. Seminole County is located in the southwest corner of Georgia, just fifteen from the Florida border. It's a rural area with lots of trees, dirt roads, and farmland. Back in nineteen seventy, Seminole County's population was about seven thousand people, and most of them lived in Seminole's largest city, Donaldsonville, which had a population of just under three thousand. On May fourteenth, nineteen seventy three, it was a particularly beautiful day in Seminole County. Sunny, warm, not a cloud in the sky. The grass seemed especially green, the bird song was especially pretty. An idyllic spring day, the perfect kind of day for farming, which was great news for the many farmers in the county, including the all Day family. The all Days were one of the most prominent farming families in Seminole County. They had a five hundred and twenty five acre

3:53 farm just outside Donaldsonville. They grew peanuts, corn, and other crop along with raising livestock. The family was well respected by the community. Everyone said the all Days were neighborly, warm and friendly. Even the Seminole County tax collector, who was, for obvious reasons, probably not everyone's favorite person, but he really liked the all Days. He told the Rome News Tribune that the all Days were just plain good folks without an enemy in the world. The heads of the all Day family were sixty two year old Ned and his fifty nine year old wife, Ernestine. They were both born and raised in Seminole County. It's likely they knew each other their whole lives. They married on September first, nineteen thirty five, when Ernestine was twenty one years old and Ned was just a week shy of twenty five. They had five children together, four sons and one daughter, and on this gorgeous day of May fourteenth, at least three of Ned and ernest sons were working on the farm, thirty five year old Jerry, thirty two year old Chester, and twenty five year old Jimmy. Jerry was plowing the field while Jimmy and Chester planet seed corn behind him. The all Days needed the crops to grow well so they could feed their some two thousand hogs. Ned's younger brother, fifty seven year old Aubrey all Day, was also helping, and Ned himself was there

5:27 too, but after developing arthritis, he wasn't as hands on as he used to be. He had begun letting his sons do the heavy lifting. Later, his wife Ernestine would tell the Albany Herald that Ned was extremely close with his sons. They did everything together. It's not surprising that he still wanted to help with the farm even when he probably didn't have to. He was proud of his sons and enjoyed working with them as farmers. Their days started long before sun up. Lunchtime rolled around at twelve thirty. They were plenty hungry. The men filed into Ned and Ernestine's beautiful house, which Ned had built with his own two hands almost thirty years before. They sat at the large family dining room table and they ate the hearty spread that Ernestine had spent the morning preparing for them. After a quick rest, the farmers returned to the fields, but shortly after they ran into an issue. Jerry's John Dear tractor was stuck in a bog. He had thought the land was dry enough to plow, but as soon as his tires hit the mud, he realized his mistake. Ned grabbed his jeep to pull the tractor out of the bog, but it didn't work. Trying to find a solution, Ned and Jerry decided to go get Jerry's truck from his house. Conveniently, Jerry also lived on the all Day farm. He and his younger wife, twenty six year old Mary Campbell all Day, had a home on the property. It was

7:01 about a quarter mile from the main house where Ned and Ernestine lived. Jerry's mobile home had two bedrooms, one at the north end and one at the south end, and between the bedrooms was a living area and a small kitchen. It was a good setup. A few of Jerry's brothers also lived in different mobile homes scattered throughout the all Day property. They all loved being near their family, and of course it was convenient because they all worked on the family farm. Plus, if Jerry and Mary ever felt like they needed more space or just felt like breaking bread with family, they could just head up the road to Ned and Ernestine's house. Jerry's home wasn't that far away from the cornfields either. It was only a few hundred yards. You could almost see his mobile home from where the tractor was maroon. The only thing in the way was a large strand of trees blocking the view. But even though it was pretty close by, it was quicker to hop in the jeep than to walk there, so Jerry and Ned headed over to the mobile home at about four pm, but they never returned. As the minutes passed, the remaining men, Jimmy, Chester and Aubrey were baffled. It shouldn't take this long to get the truck. Where were Ned and Jerry. Jimmy volunteered to go check on his brother and father, so he headed towards Jerry's house, but Jimmy never returned either. Now Chester and Aubrey were starting to get worried

8:33 what was going on. Just like the others, they went to Jerry's house, and just like the others, they were never seen again. By sunset. Ned's wife, Ernestine, was also worried the men were usually home. By now Chester's wife, Barbara, offered to check Jerry's house just in case the men were there. When Barbara arrived at the mobile home, she knocked on the door, but no one answered. Looking around and seeing that there were no cars, Barbara figured that no one was inside Jerry's home, so she left. At this point, the remaining all days knew something was up.

9:15 Five people were unaccounted for. They called the sheriff's office, the state patrol, and the hospital, but to no avail. No one knew where the all Day men were. The next day, at two twenty a m. Ned's youngest brother, fifty two year old Everett all Day, known as Bud, tried to begin his work day on the all Day farm, but he couldn't. His brothers Ned and Aubrey, and his nephews Jimmy, Chester and Jerry should have been there to help, but they weren't. Confused, Bud spoke with his sister in law, Ned's wife, Ernestine, the men had disappeared. She said no one knew where they were. Ernestine, who had been so worried she was probably a bit of shock, now, asked Bud to call the sheriff for her, and then Bud made his way to Jerry's house. He knocked on the door, but there was no answer.

10:11 He decided to try and see through one of Jerry's windows, and that's when he saw legs hanging from the side of a bed. The legs were arranged awkwardly and were oddly Still unaware of the situation, Bud entered the mobile home's kitchen through the back door and that's when he saw it. Beer cans were scattered on the kitchen table. Now Bud was certain something was wrong. The all Day Men were all devout Christians. In fact, all three sons, Jimmy, Chester, and Jerry were deacons at the local church. None of them drank alcohol. At this point, Bud probably suspected what he was going to find as he looked around Jerry's mobile home, but I'm sure that didn't lessen the shock or his grief as Bud discovered that all five all Day Men had been shot to death in Jerry's home. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Early in the morning of May fifteenth, nineteen seventy three, Bud all Day had found the dead bodies of his two brothers and three nephews strown throughout Jerry all Day's mobile home. In the south bedroom was thirty five year old Jerry and fifty seven year old Aubrey, and the north bedroom was thirty seven year old Chester and his father, sixty two year old Ned. And on the living room couch was the youngest all Day brother,

11:43 twenty five year old Jimmy. All five men had been shot in the back of the head, execution style. Some of them had been shot several times. Ned had clearly taken the worst of it. Later, the Seminole County Corner confirmed that Ned was shot seven times. He commented that you could cover the bullet holes with a half dollar. The local county authorities consisted of one sheriff and one deputy sheriff. They both arrived on the scene. They looked around for a while and determined that this mass murderer wasn't a robbery. While the kitchen cabinets were opened, nothing was actually missing, so the officers assumed the attack was targeted. Why else would anyone kill five people from the same family. Clearly this was the work of someone who wanted to deliberately hurt the all Days. And as if things couldn't get any worse, the all Day family still had another problem. Where was Jerry's wife, twenty six year old Mary Estelle all day? Her car wasn't there, and if she had arrived home from work the previous day, she would have seen the bodies and told someone immediately. The officers knew that Mary must have been kidnapped or worse.

13:07 Right away, the police put the word out asking everyone to look out for Mary's car, a blue and white nineteen seventy Chevrolet, but just a few hours later they found Mary's body. She was in the field of a neighboring farm about six miles away. She had been shot in the same manner as the other All Days execution style, in the back of her head. She had also been shot in the back of the shoulder. Mary's body was nude and her breasts were mutilated. It was clear that she had been sexually assaulted and tortured. Hours after the All Days had been found on May fifteenth, the front page headline of the local paper read family of six discovered slain near Donaldsonville and that's how. Less than a day after it happened, everyone in Seminole County knew that the highly respected all Day family had been massacred, and they were outraged. Upon hearing the tragic news, hundreds of people swarmed the All Day property to express their genuine concern and to get a look at the gruesome crime scene. People became worried about their own family safety, and as a result, gun sales in Seminole County skyrocketed. One resident told the Albany Herald things like this just don't happen here. This is something that happens in the wild West in Chicago, he said. The next day, on May

14:41 sixteenth, was the all Day family funeral. It was the largest funeral that Southwest Georgia had ever seen. The city of Donaldsonville closed all businesses. Over two thousand, five hundred people attended, including some big names like the State Agriculture command missioner and the chairman of the State Board of Transportation, and Rosalind Carter, wife of Jimmy Carter, who was the current Governor of Georgia. He would become president four years later in nineteen seventy seven. Unfortunately, Mary all Day's mother, whose name was IDAs Campbell, couldn't attend. After hearing what had happened to her daughter, Missus Campbell became extremely ill. The next day, she died of a heart attack in coal Quit, Georgia. Her physician told the Albany Herald that complications arising from Missus Campbell's diabetic condition and grief over her daughter's slaying probably caused her death. Officials agreed that this was by far the worst crime Georgia had ever seen, and at first the police were at a loss. They had no leads, no suspects, and no plausible explanation. Everyone loved the Day family for real, literally everyone loved them.

16:03 On May sixteenth, the Albany Herald published an article entitled Couldn't think of nobody disliking Them. It was titled after a local resident emphatically said that he couldn't think of nobody disliking the all Day family. The article called the all Days a quiet, clean, living family and said this slaughtering left their community an enraged shock. The all Days were sturdy, farming folk who kept their heads down and went to church every Sunday. Salt of the earth. People who would do such a thing to such kind, hard working people. Police only had two pieces of evidence. First, there was one witness who thought they saw a group of strange hippie type men following Mary as she came home from work. This turned out to be a red herring. Remember this would have been less than a year after the Man's and murders and also the McDonald family murders that Jeffrey McDonald was still blaming on a roving band of killer hippies.

17:08 But the police's second piece of evidence had merit, and that was a green car that had been discovered in the woods near Mary's body. The police tracked the car back to nineteen year old Richard Wayne Miller. But Richard hadn't had any part in the killing of the all Day family. Actually, it was the exact opposite, because Richard Miller was a victim two. Richard Miller was born in March nineteen four in Mcconnellsburg, Pennsylvania. In his teen years, he was described as an all American country boy. He was a good student and a member of the Future Farmers of America. He worked at the local Exelling gas station, and on May tenth, nineteen seventy three, he was only three days away from his high school graduation. But he would never graduate high school because that day, nineteen year old Richard traveled from his rural home in Flintstone, Maryland, to the nearby town of Mcconnellsburg. While in Mcconnellsburg, he bought some new parts for his green nineteen sixty eight Chevrolet Supersport.

18:15 He put them in his vehicle and headed home. But on the way home, he saw something unusual. It was his friend Lawrence's truck parked on the side of Patterson Run Road in Pennsylvania. Richard saw four men gathered around the cab of the truck, but none of them were Lawrence Scooley. Three of the men around Lawrence's truck were white and one of them was black. The black man wore thick, dark rimmed glasses. Another local had spotted the broken down truck too. Her name was Deborah Pool, and she also thought it was suspicious that Lawrence wasn't with his truck. According to Blood Echoes by Thomas H. Cook, Deborah and Richard turned aner and pulled over together. Richard got out of his car and asked Deborah if she knew why those guys had Lawrence's truck. She didn't. Richard let Deborah know he was going to hang around and watch the guys for a bit see what they did. If they drove off with Lawrence's car. Richard told Deborah he was going to follow them.

19:19 Then Richard returned to his car and repositioned it so that he could better watch the men and the truck. Deborah left, thinking nothing of it. After a while, Richard approached the four men. According to court testimony, Richard told the men to return Lawrence's truck to wherever they got it from, and in response, the four men held Richard at gunpoint and forced him back into his own car. Then the four men climbed into the car behind him. They made Richard drive to a sign that said Welcome to Maryland. Then they robbed him, took his car into the woods, and shot him in the back of the head close range. Riley Miller. Richard's father followed a missing person report with the police as soon as he realized his son hadn't returned from mcconnellsburg, but it was too late. Richard was gone. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. Today's episode is sponsored by Loomi, and I'm so excited to tell you about it because, as the first of its kind whole body deodorant, you can use Loomi anywhere.

20:34 Loomi is seriously safe to use anywhere in your body, pits, under boobs, though folds, belly buttons, butt cracks, volvas, and feet. It's aluminum free, baking, soda free, parabin free, and pH balanced for safe use below the belt, and it's clinically proven to block odor all day and control odor for up to seventy two hours. Loomy Starter Pack is perfect for new customers. It comes with a solid let's stick deodorant, cream tube deodorant two free products of your choice like many bodywash and deodorant wipes, and free shipping. As a special offer for listeners, new customers get five dollars off a Loomystarter pack with code SFTC at Loomy Deodorant dot com slash sftc.

21:19 That equates to over forty percent off your starter pack. When you visit Loomy Deodorant dot com and use code SFTC for five dollars off up to forty percent in savings, go to Loomy dot com slash sftc. That's lum dot com slash sftc. Do you know how much money you spend every month on subscriptions? If you're like me, you try to keep up with them, But I bet that dollar amount was shock you. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that finds and cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps you lower your bills, all in one place. Over eighty percent of people have subscriptions that they forgot about, and chances are you're one of them.

22:06 Like that one streaming app, you just have to have to watch that one show. Now the show is over, and you keep forgetting to cancel. Rocket money will quickly and easily find your subscriptions for you. All you have to do is hit cancel on the ones you don't use anymore. It's that easy. Rocket Money also helps you manage all your finances in one place and automatically categorize your expenses so you can easily track your budget in real time and also get alerted if anything looks off. Over three million people have used rocket Money, saving the average person up to seven hundred twenty dollars a year. Stop throwing your money away, cancel unwanted subscriptions, and manage your expenses the easy way by going to rocketmoney dot com slash Southern fraud. That's rocketmoney dot com slash Southern fraud. Rocketmoney dot com slash Southern fraud. When the Seminole County investigators realized that Richard Miller's car was parked near Mary all Day's body, they knew exactly who their killers were. Thirty five year old George Elder Dungee, twenty six year old Wayne Carl Coleman, nineteen year old Carl Junior Isaacs, and fifteen year old William Billy Carrol Isaacs, George, Wayne and Carl had escaped from prison just a few days before. They were all serving time at a minimum security prison near Baltimore, Maryland. It was called the Poplar Hill Correctional Institute. George was serving eighteen months for contempt of court,

23:41 Wayne was doing ten years for burglary, and Carl was also doing four for burglary. Carl and Wayne had actually known each other before they were incarcerated together. The two men were half brothers. Their mom, Betty Isaacs, had had Wayne during her first marriage and then Carl and Billy during her second. But even though Carl and Wayne knew each other a little, they weren't friends. They had a really rough time growing up absent parents, homelessness, ten additional siblings, which makes for a total of twelve, multiple foster care homes, and so on, lots of trauma and very little love. Certainly not the kind of childhood where you keep in touch with your double digit number of siblings, but Carl did keep up with Billy, his younger brother. Their mother, Betty later told the Associated Press that her sons were truants and delinquents.

24:41 She said, there may be some who have criticized us for what our children have apparently done but they don't know what we had to live with. Another family member confirmed Betty sentiments, saying the three men were just plain mean. Carl was originally placed in a maximum security prison to serve his four years for breaking into and robbing a car, but two days after Karl arrived at the prison, a riot broke out. While the guards were incapacitated, Karl was repeatedly raped. I'm not excusing his later actions, but between his upbringing and this trauma, you can see the makings of a psychopath. After the riot ended and Karl received medical attention, he was transferred to a minimum security facility, the Poplar Hill Correctional Institute, and to his surprise, his half brother Wayne was already there, and Wayne introduced Karl to his friend, a black man from Baltimore named George Dungee, although Karl did not like that George was black. The three men ultimately decided to escape together, but since this was a minimum security prison often referred to as a work camp, their escape wasn't some brilliant plan. They just walked off the premises around three am and went on their merry way. The next day, the three men picked up Carl's brother and Wayne's half brother, fifteen year old Billy. Isaac's Billy was

26:15 staying at their mother, Betty's house in Baltimore County. Betty remembered how her sons nearly ran her over while picking up Billy. They did not apologize or stop the car. From there, the four men started a violent crime spree down the eastern coast of the United States. Some sources say that they were making their way to Florida, while others say Mexico. We're not sure, but one thing is for certain. George, Wayne, Carl and Billie were on a tear and no one was going to stop them. The four men robbed at least two homes in Maryland and Pennsylvania, stole a large number of cars, and coerced several people into coming with them, including some juveniles, though no details are available about them. At one point, two young women were traveling with the four men, seemingly of their own free will. When the men decided they were sick of the women, they abandoned them in Pennsylvania.

27:18 Not long after that, the four men stole Richard Miller's car and killed him. Next, they proceeded to rob stores as they went down the East coast. Later, Carl would claim that they murdered at least two other people and raped at least one additional woman along the way, but those crimes were never confirmed, and at some point the four men gained at least three handguns. All of this led to the afternoon of May fourteenth, nineteen seventy three. George, Wayne, Carl, and Billie were still in Richard Miller's car and they needed gas badly. They spotted Jerry all Day's mobile home from the road and thought they saw a gas pump behind it, so they stopped to take a look around. After realizing there was no gas pump, they noticed that the mobile home was empty, so they decided to rob it. George and Billy stayed in the car while Carl and Wayne went inside the mobile home, and that's when Billy spotted two men coming toward the property in a blue jeep. It was sixty two year old Ned all Day and his son, thirty five year old Jerry all Day, if you'll remember, They were headed to Jerry's home to grab his truck. They needed it to dislodge their tractor, which was stuck in a muddy area of their cornfield. Billy ran inside to warn Carl and Wayne about the approaching men, and shortly after Ned and Jerry parked their jeep in front of the mobile home. They had surely spotted the mysterious green car out front, but they probably never imagined that they were

28:52 being robbed. They luckily thought it was a neighbor in their friendly small town until eighteen year old Carl walked out with a gun. Carl approached the jeep with his gun pulled out, then he led Ned and Jerry to the mobile home at gunpoint. The four men made Ned and Jerry empty their pockets, as Carl stole Jerry's penknife, wallet, and some change and a cigarette lighter. He started talking to Jerry. Carl asked Jerry if he had a wife. Jerry said yes, and she would be home from work soon. He begged Karl not to hurt her. Then Karl took Jerry to the south bedroom, made him lae face down, and shot him four times in the head.

29:37 At the same time, Wayne took Ned to the north bedroom. He also made Ned lie down and then shot Ned several times in the back and head. Apparently Ned's body kept moving when Carl came in to see what was taking Wayne so long, he ended up shooting Ned a few times as well, which was why Ned was shot seven times. Next, twenty five year old Jimmy all Day arrived. He was driving a John Dear tractor. It's not clear, but it might have been the tractor that was stuck. Maybe Jimmy, Chester and Aubrey had somehow gotten it free. Regardless, Jimmy walked up, having no idea what was waiting for him inside, and knocked on the mobile home's back door. Wayne answered it while pointing his gun directly in Jimmy's face. Then Wayne forced Jimmy to come inside and take off his green coveralls, sunglasses, and hat. Then they positioned Jimmy faced down on the living room sofa, and Carl shot and killed Jimmy with several shots to the back of his head. At this point, Carl noticed that Jimmy's tractor was blocking their car, so he went outside to move the tractor. As he moved the tractor, Carl watched twenty six year old Mary all Day come home and her car. After Mary parked, Carl grabbed her and forced her into the mobile home's kitchen. Then the criminals took Mary's purse, and emptied it out. It contained car keys and a dollar bill. The men took both

31:11 while the four men were looking through Mary's purse. Two more all Days came to the mobile home. This time it was fifty seven year old Aubrey all Day and thirty two year old Chester all Day. They drove up in a green pickup and the criminals repeated their process. Carl and Billy went outside to confront the two new men. They walked along both sides of the pickup with their guns drawn and forced Aubrey and Chester inside. Before Chester and Aubrey came inside, the murderers forced Mary into the bathroom. It suspected that this was a misguided attempt to shield Mary, a delicate woman, from the horrors that were to come, as if Mary hadn't already been thoroughly terrorized, and as if she wasn't about to go through much worse. After hiding Mary away, the men took Chester to the north bedroom, and that's where Wayne shot Chester wants in the back of the head. At the same time, Carl took Aubrey to the south bedroom. Carl tried to shoot Aubrey, but his gun was only making loud clicking noises. He realized it was out of bullets, so he ran to the kitchen, grabbed a different handgun, and went back into the bedroom. Then Carl shot Aubrey twice in the back of the head.

32:28 According to court testimony, after Carl killed Aubrey, he came out of the bedroom laughing. Billy asked Carl what was so funny, and Carl replied that bastard begged me for mercy. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. I lost my dad when I was a teen, so on Father's Day, I love to celebrate my husband. He is a wonderful father. Story Worth is an online service that helps you and the dat of your choice connect through sharing stories and memories and preserves them for years to come. Every week, story Worth emails him a thought provoking question from a vast pool of possible options, questions you've never thought of, like what is one of your fondest childhood memories. I've really enjoyed reading my husband's answers to these questions. I've discovered stories and memories I never heard about, and learn new things about stories I thought I really knew. My husband embarrasses easily.

33:29 So I learned through story Worth that he was voted Homecoming King in high school. After one year, story Worth compiles all those questions and stories, including photos, into a beautiful keepsake book the whole family can share for generations. I can't wait to watch our kids tease my husband about being homecoming king. Give all the fathers in your life a meaningful gift you can both cherish for years to come. Story Worth Right now, for a limited time, you can save ten dollars on your first purchase. You go to storyworth dot com slash Southern fraud That's sto ry wo rt dot com slash Southern fraud to save ten dollars on your first purchase storyworth dot com slash Southern fraud. Today's episode is brought to you by Better Help. Whether it's a work life balance or managing your kids' schedules, not taking care of ourselves is a universal problem.

34:27 Even if you pencil in some me time on your calendar, it might be the one thing on your to do list that you don't check off. Therapy can give you the tools to find more balance in your life so you can keep supporting others without leaving yourself behind. Therapy has helped me with all kinds of serious issues, but also seemingly simple everyday life tools like setting personal boundaries so I am able to keep my work life balance more even, and I learned to make private me time a priority rather than just a notation on a to do list. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give Better Help a try. It's entirely online, designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. Find more balance with better Help. Visit betterhelp dot com slash Southern today to get ten percent off your first month. That's Better Help Help dot com slash Southern. After murdering five people, Carl and Wayne sexually assaulted Mary on the kitchen table. Then Mary was redressed, bound and blindfolded.

35:38 The four men robbed the mobile home of any valuables, and then they left, taking Mary with them. They drove both richard stolen car and Mary's now stolen car to an isolated forested area six miles away. Once there, Carl tried to force Mary to perform oral sex, but Mary fought back. In response, Karl beat her unconscious, mutilated her breasts, and raped her. Then Karl handed Wayne the gun so he could kill Mary, but then George asked the group what about me. Wayne shrugged and handed the gun to George. George forced Mary to walk a short distance away, raped her, and then shot her twice from behind. George went to shoot Mary a third time, but the others said that's enough. Then George stole Mary's tome X watch and put it in his pocket. Following the execution of five men and the brutal gang rape and murder of Mary, the four men all packed into Mary's Chevrolet. They left Richard's car behind. According to Blood Echoes by Thomas H. Cook, the men thought something might have been wrong with Richard's car it kept going through gas so quickly, and that would make sense given that Chard was buying auto parts for his car before he was killed, and it's likely that Mary's car had more gas for the four men to use, since their desire to find a gas pump was what started this whole mess. No

37:15 matter the reason that they left Richard's car behind, they did, and it was the key piece of evidence that the detectives needed to identify these four men as the cold blooded killers who had murdered six members of the esteemed all Day family. Only three days after the all Day family mass murder, the police knew exactly who did it thanks to Richard Miller's car, George Dungee, Wayne Coleman, Carl Isaacs, and Billy Isaacs. Their mugshots were printed on the front page of every newspaper in the area. The police were out for blood, especially the Seminole County officials. They had known the all Days for years.

37:57 These killings, perhaps more than any other crime in Seminole County, felt very personal. The sheriff told the Albany Herald quote, if I'd had my way about it, I'd have a large oven and I'd precook them for several days, just keep them alive and let them punish. And I don't think that would satisfy me. The acts of these men are lower than animals. If a citizen gets out of hand and starts shooting people up, there's only one way to arrest, and that's with a shotgun. I could throw the switch to the electric chair and never lose a minute sleep. But the article that published the sheriff's quote also specifically noted that quote. The integrity of the twenty year old veteran of law enforcement, however, overrides such emotion. Now that law enforcement officers knew who they were looking for, the all Day murder investigation moved quickly. On May seventeenth, the Georgia Bureau of Investigations director told the public that they had matched fingerprints from inside richards stolen car with Carl Isaacs and Billy Isaac's fingerprints had also been matched to a camera in Jerry all Day's mobile home. The fingerprints of Wayne and George were also found in incriminating locations.

39:15 Between the fingerprints and the overwhelming circumstantial evidence, the GBI director was confident that they had enough to charge and convict the four men, but first they had to find them. Fortunately, it wasn't that hard. George, Wayne, Carl, and Billie weren't carefully covering their tracks. Their trek down the East Coast could best be described as a wild rampage. On May eighteenth, four days after the massacre, the four men robbed a grocery store in Virginia. They took over three thousand dollars. This led to a high speed chase in which the four men led the Virginia officials following them into West Virginia, but the West Virginia officials were ready for the fugitives. They had set up a roadblock and the West Virginia officers were armed with high powered hunting rifles and shotguns, and as a result, George, Wayne Carl, and Billy were forced to abandon Mary's car and make a run for it. George, who couldn't run very fast, was immediately caught. The other three men fled into the woods. After an all night search, bloodhounds finally found Wayne, Carl, and Billy about six miles away from the initial roadblock. They were sleeping under a rock ledge in the forests of southern West Virginia. The three fugitives did not resist being captured. They were worn out and required medical attention after being exposed to the elements. The officers later remarked that they were lucky that

40:51 the men hadn't hidden in any nearby cities. It would have been impossible to track them with their bloodhounds an unpopulated area. When the detectives arrested the four men, they found three handguns in their possession. Ballistics testing later confirmed that these pistols were the weapons used to murder the all Days, and the officers also found Mary all Day's tome X watch. It was still in George's pocket. Mary's sister in law and Chester's now widowed wife, Barbara, was able to identify it. Barbara had once taken the watch into a repair shop for Mary, and she noticed a distinctive glue stain on its back. The men were charged with six counts of murder, one count of kidnapping, armed robbery, rape, and burglary except for Billy. Billy wasn't charged with kidnapping, murder, or rape. And that's because on the same day he was arrested, fifteen year old Billy Isaac's flipped. He confessed everything to the FBI, and in return, he received fewer charges. That's how we know exactly what happened to the all days. Billy testified to it in court later on.

42:07 Billy's eyewitness testimony would be vital to the States case against George, Wayne, and Billy's older brother Carl. Also on the same day the men were arrested, the Albany Herald published an interview with Wayne, Carl and Billy's mother, Betty Isaacs. In the interview, Betty washed her hands clean of her sons, saying they are old enough to know right from wrong and deserve what they get when captured. They had no respect for their family and those people in Georgia. How can they expect any from us? After they were captured, George, Wayne, Carl and Billy were held without belle. Their location was supposed to be a secret, but the local papers published it anyway. They were at the Randolph County Jail and Cuthbert, Georgia. It's one hour north of Donaldsonville. Despite the Seminole County Sheriff's harsh words from earlier, he knew that these killers couldn't be held in the Seminole County jail. Too many locals wanted the men dead for what they had done to the All days, the chance that the Seminole County residence would start mob violence was incredibly high. People were calling the sheriff directly and saying as much. Some locals were even discussing a public lynching. But for some reason, the GBI director wasn't worried.

43:30 He told the Albany Herald, I don't believe that they are that kind of people down there. I think they will be adequately treated. It was a subtle warning for the local sheriff. Now that the sheriff was Facing the criticism from the head of the GBI, he came up with a new reason as to why the killers couldn't be held in the Seminole County jail. He claimed their facilities were inadequate. But everyone knew what was actually going on. These four killers wouldn't last one day in Seminole County. So here's some food for thought. If George, Wayne, Carl and Billy couldn't even be held at the Seminole County jail, how in the world were they going to go to trial there? In the US, everyone has a right to a jury of their peers, but if those peers are unfairly biased against you, well you're doomed from the start. And that is, of course not usually allowed.

44:27 And it's clear that the people of Seminole County were very, very biased. For example, consider this, a judge appointed eight lawyers for the four men. That's two lawyers per defendant. Each and every one of these lawyers loudly protested this assignment. Nobody wanted to represent these men, but public defenders cannot refuse to represent their assigned clients. One attorney told the media quote, I've done everything I can to get out of it. It's worse than a dose of CA colomel, but I have to take it. To refuse would be contempt of court. Colomel was a popular laxative at the time. However, one lawyer, Julian Webb, was able to successfully evade representing the men he had recently sponsored Georgia's new death penalty laws. He told the press, I absolutely cannot in good conscience, both personally and professionally, defend any of the accused. It worked. Webb was released from his duty to serve as counsel for one of the All Day Killers, and it is true that the death penalty was relevant to George, Wayne and Carl's upcoming sentencings. On March twenty eighth, nineteen seventy three, the state of Georgia had reinstated the death penalty.

45:47 In nineteen sixty four, the Supreme Court had suspended all executions in the United States. On June twenty ninth, nineteen seventy two, the Supreme Court in Firman v. Georgia, struck down the laws then existing in the US. The Georgia General Assembly passed a new death sentence law that went into effect on March twenty eighth, nineteen seventy three, less than two months before the All Day massacre, and it was death by electrocution. Lethal injection didn't come around until the year two thousand. Under this new legislation, if someone committed a capital offense with aggravating circumstances, then the jury could sentence the convicted person to death by the electric chair. So the crime of murder, which is a capital offense, might not constitute the death penalty on its own, but murder that was combined with an aggravating circumstance could qualify. There are eleven aggravating circumstances that Georgia considers, and the All Day murders clearly met a few of them, the most straightforward of which was basically, if you murder someone while having escaped from prison, he'll be susceptible to the death penalty, not to mention a vicious gang rape and murder. Billy Isaacs had not escaped prison.

47:12 He just got pulled in along with his brothers after they escaped, and since he confessed early and agreed to testify for the state, he never faced murder charges. The fifteen year old would have only been charged as an accomplice anyway. He didn't shoot anyone, and he did not take part in the rape of Mary all Day. But the three other prison escapeees, George, Wayne and Carl did face the death penalty. Their trials were considered a test of this new Georgia law. A local defense attorney told the Albany Herald, if they are found guilty, I believe this case will be used to determine whether the state's death penalty law will stand up before the Supreme Court. And this all Day murder case also bolstered statewide support for the death The Donaldsonville News reported on May thirty first that quote, the brutal, senseless murders of six members of the all Day family should serve as another warning to all society that there is a need for capital punishment in this country. How can anyone who is aware of this heinous crime still maintain that capital punishment is too harsh and should be stricken from our society for all time. And that's how most of the Seminole County community felt, because while the four criminals were laying about in a city jail, these residents were left picking up the pieces of the tragedy they had cost. On June fourteenth, Seminole County declared Father's Day the new All

48:45 Day Memorial Day. All of the local churches took up a special collection for the All Day Memorial Fund. Around the same time, the all Day's neighbors helped the remaining family members how their peanut fields. Without Ned, Jerry, Aubrey, Chester, and Jimmy, they didn't have enough farm hands to run everything. Later, the all Day family would have to shut down their farm entirely. They auctioned off their farm equipment for about thirty three thousand dollars. That's worth about a quarter of a million today. But you cannot put a dollar amount on the immense grief and loss felt by who was left of the All Day family. Ernestine, Ned's widow, grieved intensely for the massive loss of her family. She told the Albany Harold we never dreamed someone was going to come along and try to kill everybody. Somebody comes along who does not like to work and tries to take everything away from us. The AP News reported that multiple All Day family members openly advocated for the death penalty following their families murder. One All Day family member said, I didn't believe in the death penalty. This has changed my life and changed my opinions. Three months after Billy Isaacs was arrested, he formerly played guilty to armed robbery and burglary, escaping, murder, kidnapping, and rape charges. In exchange for his

50:15 confession and subsequent eyewitness testimony, he was sentenced to forty years in prison. Some might say he got off easy, but I have to point out again that he was only fifteen years old and did not participate in any of the violence against the all Days. But he was an accomplice all the same, his life ruined by jumping in the car with his older brothers that day. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. The three trials for George Dungee, Wayne Coleman, and Karl Isaacs were widely publicized. Everyone in Donaldsonville and many Seminole County had personally known or were even related to the All Day Family. Many of them had gone to their funeral at the very least, they had heard of the All Day Family massacre and formed their own opinions.

51:14 Locals were threatening to murder the killers. Hundreds upon hundreds of front page articles were published in the Seminole County area. Everyone within spitting distance of the All Day farm was now suddenly very pro death penalty, and as a result of all of this, George, Wayne and Karl's lawyers came to the conclusion that their clients trials should happen in a different county. In fact, it could be anywhere except Seminole County. All three defendants motioned for a change of venue, and all three defendants were denied. They were tried in Seminole County, and they were, of course found guilty and sentenced to death by the electric chair. Between Billy bone chilling testimony, the damning fingerprints, and Mary's time X watch, it really was a no brainer. Wayne had even told an FBI agent that he shot nineteen year old Richard Wayne Miller because he quote didn't want any witnesses, and then he helped the authorities found the body.

52:20 It was so obvious that these men had committed these crimes. Their lawyers didn't even try to argue their innocence. They all just argued that their clients should not receive the death penalty, And to be honest, it doesn't look like they argued very hard, and it's hard to blame them. Numerous reports said that during Wayne's arraignment, he chuckled when the judge read him his list of charges. If ever there was evil in this world, it was probably these guys, and they needed to be locked up. Luckily, the juries felt the same for each of George, Wayne, and Karl's separate trials. The three different juries took less than an hour to reach their guilty verdicts. At this point, you might be thinking, hey, that sounds like good news, but it's not. And that's because, in nineteen eighty five, a federal appeals court determined that their juries were biased due to rampant pre trial publicity.

53:16 This was a huge deal in Georgia. Everyone was furious. In fact, over one hundred thousand Georgians signed a petition to have the appeals court judge that made that call impeached, but the US House of Representatives rejected that petition. The judge did admit publicly that the men were clearly guilty, but he couldn't believe that they had received an impartial jury, which was their constitutional right. Now, George, Wayne and Carl would receive new trials, new verdicts, and, if convicted, once more, new sentences. First up was thirty three year old Carl Junior Isaacs and early nineteen eighty eight, Karl was again convicted and sentenced to death. This was an especially easy decision for the jury and for a few good reasons. First of all, Karl confessed to the murders and rape while giving an interview to a filmmaker for a documentary on the All Day Family massacre. As in that moron sat in front of a recording camera and said he did it, and then he walked into a courtroom thinking he might get away scott free. That's not how this works, Carl.

54:31 Additionally, Karl had also orchestrated two separate prison breaks while incarcerated between nineteen seventy four and nineteen eighty eight. Karl was never able to get himself out, but he did help others escape. In the nineteen seventy four attempt, he smuggled in hacks, all blades, pajamas, shoes, belts, and other illicit items into his prison cell. He crafted makeshift guard uniforms from the clothes and use the hacksall blades to slowly saw through the bars of the prison windows. He concealed his progress with bubble gum paint and cardboard. On the day of the escape, Carl and his friends would change into their fake uniforms and exit their cell through the windows that led to the roof. Then they would get in an empty car in the parking lot, which had been left for them earlier by a friend. But Carl never got to see his magnificent plan unfold because two hours before the escape was going to happen, he was transferred to a different prison. Carl wrote a forty six page statement about this escape attempt. Here's a standout line. Herein lies the truthful story about one of the greatest escapes that has ever been recorded in the annals of history.

55:50 Perhaps it could even be the greatest. The second prison break Carl attempted, or I guess it's the third if we're counting his nineteen seventy three break, was equally complicated and crazy. But long story short, Carl was caught when a guard noticed that his ventilation ducked, was a slightly different color than the rest of his cell. Carl had been trying to cut his way through to get to the outside world on a different occasion before Georgia passed a law banning death row inmates from speaking to the media. Carl told reporters that he did not regret killing the All Days. He said, quote, I'd like to get out and kill more of them. They represent the type of society I don't like. They love church so damn much. Working people don't do a damn thing for me. Carl also said that he would kill his brother Billy in a heartbeat for betraying him. His exact words were, if he were free, and how we're free, he would be the first person I would kill. Have I told you how much I'd love to kill little Billy.

56:52 I started to kill him several times, but I didn't, and I should have killed him. Carl's lack of remorse for his wrongdoing would be the final kneil in his coffin. No jury wanted to see this man walk free. Forty nine year old Carl Junior Isaacs was executed on May sixth, two thousand and three, by lethal injection, just over three years too late for old Sparky and almost thirty years to the day of the All Day massacre. Carl's final mill was a regular institutional tray of pork and macaroni, pinto beans, cabbage, carrot salad, a dineroll, chocolate cake, and fruit punch, but he pushed the mill away. All in all, he had spent twenty nine years and one hundred and two days on death row. This made Carl one of the longest serving death row inmates in the US. In May of nineteen eighty eight, the same year Carl was reconvicted, Wayne had his retrial into cab County. He was convicted easily, but the jury struggled with giving him the death penalty. After seven days of liberation, the jury was deadlocked, so the judge sentenced forty year old Wayne Carl Coleman to six consecutive life sentences in prison. Today he's seventy five years old and in Wilcox State Prison.

58:15 And in July of nineteen eighty eight, fifty year old George Elder Dungee pled guilty on accounts in Muskegee County. He was sentenced to three consecutive life terms and three concurrent life terms. He died in prison in two thousand and six at age sixty eight. Thirty six year old Billy Carroll Isaacs was released from prison in April of nineteen ninety four after serving for almost twenty one years. He was originally sentenced to forty years, but his case was logistically a little weird. He was imprisoned for two decades, starting at age fifteen four technically armed robbery and burglary. With all that in mind, plus his repeated testimony appearances, I'm not surprised that they led him out early despite his presence that horrific day in Georgia. He always sought to do right by the All Day Family afterward, but he still died young at the age of fifty one in Florida on May fourth, two thousand and nine. Even though the All Day murderers are imprisoned or dead, their impact will last lifetimes. Decades after the All Day Family massacre, members of the All Day Family told the Associated Press that Seminole County was still changed forever before it was a place of innocence.

59:37 Now people still have two or three locks on their doors, and probably an entire generation of All Day descendants were lost, all because three evil men escaped prison and then ran out of gas that fateful day fifty years ago. Southern True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank, with additional writing by me and of course all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic arts by Coli Horner. Today's episode was edited and mixed by Brandon shack Snyder of Southern Gothic and Erica Kelly. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tab or email SFTC Research at gmail dot com. You'll get lost in a sea of emails if you send it to my main address, so this is the best way for me to get those little known cases. Y'all always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media.

1:00:45 Private messaging with three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group Southern Frid True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worshiped, all parton and share means. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do of course discussed truecrime, not just Southern Fried, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shout asses allowed. It's not just a motto, it is how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate interview on iTunes.

1:01:28 I'm also on all large platforms like our Heartstitcher, Spotify, Spreaker, and now Amazon and Audible. You can also find me on YouTube as well as listen through my website, Southern Fried Truecrime dot com. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. Y'all. Take care