Jan. 23, 2023

173: The Neverending Staircase: The Death of Kathleen Peterson, PART 1

173: The Neverending Staircase: The Death of Kathleen Peterson, PART 1
173: The Neverending Staircase: The Death of Kathleen Peterson, PART 1
Southern Fried True Crime
173: The Neverending Staircase: The Death of Kathleen Peterson, PART 1

December 9th, 2001 was an unseasonably warm night in Durham, North Carolina. At 2:40 a.m., a novelist named Michael Peterson called 911. He was frantic. He said his wife Kathleen had an accident. She had fallen down some stairs. Within 10 minutes,...

December 9th, 2001 was an unseasonably warm night in Durham, North Carolina. At 2:40 a.m., a novelist named Michael Peterson called 911. He was frantic. He said his wife Kathleen had an accident. She had fallen down some stairs. Within 10 minutes, paramedics, police and the fire team swarmed the house.


They were all startled by the amount of blood. Kathleen’s blood was everywhere. It covered her body, the staircase, and the floor. Soon, homicide detectives were called to the scene. For the next 16 years, Durham law enforcement officials would pursue one fundamental question: Was Kathleen’s death an accident?


Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank and Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Erica Kelley

Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/the-neverending-staircase-part-1

  • Prose is the healthy hair regimen with your name all over it. Take your FREE in-depth hair consultation and get 15% off your first order today at Prose.com/southernfried


This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:02 Southern Fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. Eighteen year old Martha Ratliffe just wanted to go home, but as she approached her house with her sister, she immediately knew that wasn't going to happen. The large colonial mansion at eighteen tin Cedar Street was swarming with unfamiliar people, cops, crime technicians, neighbors. Yellow crime scene tape criss crossed over the front yard, barring Martha's entrance. She later told the Staircases documentary team it was the worst thing in the world, and that's understandable. The one place where Martha was always welcome no matter what, was suddenly completely off limits. Unable to get inside their home, Martha to her older sister Margaret, spoke with their father, Michael Peterson. He told them that there had been an accident, a tragic accident. He was in shock, so the details were fuzzy.

1:12 She had fallen down the stairs. There was nothing he could do, but the police were certain he was involved. Michael assured Martha and Margaret that he wasn't. Of course, Martha believed him, and Margaret too. This was Michael, their father, their caretaker. He wouldn't hurt anyone, let alone his beloved Kathleen Peterson. Welcome to Episode one seventy three, The Never Ending Staircase, Part one. Kathleen Morris Hunt was born on February twenty first, nineteen fifty three, to her mother Veronica and her father John in Greensboro, North Carolina. She had two sisters, Candice and Laurie, and one brother, Stephen. They grew up primarily in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. At that time, she went by the name Kathy, and likewise, her sister Candice's pet name was Candy. Their childhood was, by all accounts, a normal, upper middle class and happy upbringing. In her youth, Cathy had a wide range of interests, including swimming. At nine years old, she completed an intermediate swimming course at the YWCA and was awarded a Red Cross certificate.

2:35 She was awarded yet another certificate for her swimming ability the very next year and competed on her local swim team. As a teenager, she really found her stride. By age fourteen, she was already involved in many activities. She was a student athlete, a musician, and a library aide. While attending high school, she became president of the debate club and editor of the school magazine. In the early sixties, Kathy was voted Girl of the Year and Lancaster Lass. She was also recognized by the city's Optimist Club for being an outstanding student. She volunteered at Saint Joseph's Hospital. She helped form a youth advisory council that contributed to local government decisions. She was the dictionary definition of a well rounded young woman, compassionate, involved, and extremely smart. Kathy was so smart that the medium sized city of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, had to make changes to accommodate her intellect. She was the first high school student allowed to take advanced Latin classes at the nearby Franklin and Marshall College. That may not sound like such a big deal now, but in the sixties, not many teens were attending college classes, and definitely not girls. According to author Diane Fanning, there was a bit of rivalry, even jealousy Kathleen and her sisters, particularly with Candice, that would last into adulthood. Kathleen wasn't just

4:06 gifted, she was preternaturally self confident in a way that was way beyond her years and could be off putting to her siblings. She was a natural leader, and she wasn't shy about it. Later, as a wife and mother, she insisted on hosting family events, not liking to swap years or share the honors, much to her sister Candace's irritation. Laurie seemed to go along as the peacemaker, but in her teen years, that impressive self confidence was well earned. Kathleen was smart, but she also worked really hard. Her studies always came first. When she graduated high school, she was the number one student in her class of four hundred and seventy three students. She was even profiled in a publication called the Whose Who Book of American high school Students.

5:00 And if you're wondering who buys a Who's Who book for high school students, well, the answer is pretty simple the student's proud parents, and Kathleen's parents were incredibly proud, rightly so. After high school, Kathy continued to thrive. She attended North Carolina's esteemed Duke University, where she was the first female student accepted into the School of Engineering. That is an incredible achievement. From there, she received her Bachelor of Science and Civil Engineering. Then she received her Master of Science and Mechanical Engineering, also from Duke. You can only imagine the sexism she would have faced just to attend class. It's probably what made her such a tough lady in her adult years, and she was formidable. It was on a visit home from college that the serious young Kathy announced that she was going by her full name, now Kathleen. With Kathleen's glowing resume, it isn't surprising that her career was also extraordinarily successful. She worked up the ranks to executive level positions at science and tech focused companies like Baltimore Air, coil Mark, and lastly, Northern Telecom, a telecommunications company better known as NORTEL. Kathleen began working there in nineteen eighty four in an entry level position. Fifteen years later, in nineteen ninety nine, she was promoted to Director of Communications. In her seventeen years at Nortel, Kathleen received

6:34 countless awards for her leadership ability and professional success. She traveled the world for her work, going to places like Russia, Ukraine, Vietnam, Malaysia, Europe, China and Canada, she thrived and what was often a boys club, earning their respect just as she earned her accolades and high salary. And there's no doubt about it, Kathleen made good money as Nortel's Director of Communications. In two thousand and one, her yearly salary was one hundred and forty five thousand dollars. Today, that's the equivalent of almost a quarter of a million dollars. At this point, Kathleen lived in Durham, North Carolina, where a major US branch of Nortel was located. In Durham, Kathleen remained a natural leader an exemplary citizen in her community. She was the treasurer for the Durham Arts Council and frequently hosted events for the American Dance Festival as well as the Carolina Ballet, and on at least two occasions, Kathleen wrote to her local newspaper, The Herald's Son to voice helpful opinions. One time, in nineteen eighty nine, she advocated that the local Durham Bulls baseball team keep the existing baseball stadium rather than pay seventeen million dollars for a new one.

7:55 It wasn't a matter of suggesting a reallocation of funds or just tightening the city's budget. Actually, Kathleen was really concerned that ticket prices would increase and remove an affordable option for family fund. Kathleen cared about the children of Durham, all the children. Later in nineteen ninety one, she attended a dinner to help fund public education. During the mill, thirty seven students put on an outstanding performance, singing and dancing a wonderful cabaret. Kathleen thoroughly enjoyed the concert and wrote to the paper about how great the students did. She called their show impeccable. Besides being a great community member, Kathleen was really just a cool person to know. She threw a great party. She often invited her friends over for an evening. During these get togethers, she would go above and beyond, decorating her house to the nines, cooking the extravagant mills herself, whether it was for ten people or fifty plus. Kathleen was an incredible mother. While attending Duke University, she met her first husband, physicist Fred Atwater. They married in nineteen seventy seven. On April twenty seventh nineteen eighty two. They had a daughter named Caitlin, but when Fred was unfaithful, he and Kathleen divorced. She was devastated by the divorce, but she persevered.

9:24 She had to for her daughter, Caitlin. So in nineteen eighty six, Kathleen and four year old Caitlin were living in Durham, North Carolina. Around this time, Caitlyn became friends with two little girls who lived down the street. Those girls were four year old Margaret Ratliffe and her little sister, three year old Martha Caitlin. Margaret and Martha became best friends. They loved to play with barbies and have sleepovers. One day, Margaret and Martha introduced thirty three year old Kathleen to their adoptive father, forty three year old Michael Peter. Michael was a handsome, charismatic novelist. He was well traveled, a Vietnam War veteran, and clever. With his devilish grin and charming demeanor.

10:11 He and Kathleen got on famously. Kathleen probably liked his sharp mind and quick humor. He stood about five eight to Kathleen's five foot two, so they looked like the perfect match in photos. I've seen one author describe him as someone with a Napoleon complex, but it's not something I see. I see a natural confidence much like Kathleen's. He worked out constantly, his fitness remaining a priority as a former marine. Kathleen also took care of herself, eating right and exercising. So they were one of those couples that just seemed to naturally match. Both of them were fit, attractive, and gregarious.

10:54 They're always smiling widely in photos and seemed to be a very tactile couple, arms around each other or Kathleen's sitting on Michael's lap. Their ten year age difference was barely even noticeable. Michael thought Kathleen was a dynamo, a spitfire. She was smarter than him and didn't let him forget it. Some men might have shied away from a strong woman like Kathleen, but not Michael. He liked how they sparred, matching wits time and again. Kathleen and Michael truly seemed to fit together like two puzzle pieces. Years later, Kathleen's daughter Caitlin would write about her mother meeting Michael in a college essay. Michael Peterson stopped my mother's tears. I used to sit at the top of the stairs, leaning through the banister and listen to my mother's sob every night for a year. After my father left. My father had torn her apart, crushing her shell and the illusion in which she lived, destroying her dignity and pride.

11:54 But Mike was able to restore her strength and confidence and show her that she could find true love. From the beginning, I was in debt to Mike and my heart and mind for bringing back my mother's happiness. Kathleen and Michael fell deeply in love, and they changed each other's lives forever. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Michael Ivor Peterson was born on October twenty third, nineteen forty three, to his mother Eleanor and his father, Eugene. Michael was from Nashville, Tennessee. In nineteen sixty one, when he was eighteen years old, he moved to Durham so that he could attend college at Duke University. According to Michael, even though he went to Duke, he wasn't a brainiac like his future wife Kathleen. He was a sea student and proud of it. Instead of worrying too much about classes, Michael spent time with his friends and joined activities he cared about. By the end of his time at Duke, Michael didn't have good grades, but he still had a lot of accomplishments. He was the president of his fraternity, the managing editor for the college's newspaper, and in the student union.

13:13 Despite not being a stellar student, he was featured in the Who's Who among students in American universities and colleges, an odd coincidence that was similar to Kathleen's feature in the high school version of the Who's Who publication. Not too bad for a Sea student. In nineteen sixty five, Michael graduated from Duke with a bachelor's degree in political science. A year later, on July twenty third, nineteen sixty six, twenty two year old Michael married his first wife, twenty three year old Patricia Sue Bachmann. She went by Patty, and Patty was a traveler. She was born in Arkansas, went to high school in Pennsylvania College in Texas, and married Michael in Virginia. Around the time of their wedding, Michael became interested in the media coverage of the Vietnam War.

14:03 Curious, he went to Vietnam to see what was going on for himself. He worked for a US government agency in Ho Chimen City, which was called Saigon. Then, Michael helped research the effects of mechanized infantry and armor in relation to the Vietnam War. The US government was trying to justify sending more tanks, more soldiers, more everything to Vietnam. Later, Michael explained that he believed the research was a facade. The government would send more tanks, more soldiers, and more of everything else no matter what Michael's dat approved. After Michael finished his job, he returned to the States. Then he enlisted in the US military, and on August twenty fourth, nineteen sixty eight, Michael returned to Vietnam, this time as a Marine. He served in Vietnam for a few years before retiring from the military. He was honorably discharged after he was injured a landmine accident. His right leg was so badly wounded he was declared permanently disabled, or at least that's what he told everyone. We'll get into that more later. According to Michael, Vietnam provided him with a wealth of new experiences. Several military medals and the inspiration to write his first book. Michael's debut novel was a paperback called The Immortal Dragon. It's about nineteenth century Vietnam and was pretty successful, selling over two hundred and fifty thousand copies. He later told The Herald's son, I wanted to write about the

15:35 war as it really was. War is an awful thing, and I had to show it. Shakespeare had his King Lear I had my war. Meanwhile, Michael's wife, Patty, who had received her bachelor's in English and her master's in education, was a teacher. While Michael was in Vietnam, she taught for the US Department of Defense in Europe. Over the course of her life, Patty Peterson would spend thirty five years teaching for the DoD. After Michael returned from Vietnam, he and Patty lived together in the States, but Patty loved Europe and wanted to return. Since Michael had just published his second book on the Vietnam War, called A Time of War. They were doing well financially, so Michael and Patty figured it was as good a time as any to go back to Europe. In nineteen seventy three, they moved to Groffenhausen, Germany. Groffenhausen is located in southwest Germany. It's less than ninety miles from Switzerland and also close to the border of France. While in Germany, Michael and Patty had two sons, first Clayton Sumner on December thirteenth, nineteen seventy four, and then Todd Bancroft on March fourteenth, nineteen seventy six.

16:48 Still working for the U. S. Department of Defense, Patty taught at an American military bass elementary school. It was there that she met another teacher, Elizabeth Ratliffe, who went by Liz. Patty and Liz immediately hit it off. They became good friends. Liz's husband, George Ratliffe, was a retired U. S. Air Force captain. Michael, as a retired US Marines captain, bonded with George quickly. For years, the two couples were best friends. They even lived near each other. In the early eighties, Liz and George welcome two daughters into the world, one right after the other, first Margaret Elizabeth on December tenth, nineteen eighty one, and then thirteen months later, Martha Cataline on January third, nineteen eighty three, but shortly after Martha's birth, tragedy struck the Ratliffe household. Martha was only six months old when George Ratliffe died in a military excursion. According to Michael's two thousand nineteen memoir Behind the Staircase, George was sent to Central America to help the Contras overthrow the Marxist government in Nicaragua. According to Michael, George suffered from an extreme sunburn after a long run. Due to this stress on his body, he had a heart attack and died that night. Ultimately, the details of George's death have not been confirmed. Two years after George died, in nineteen eighty five, Liz passed away. Two German medical examiners determined Liz's death was caused by a cerebral hemorrhage. But as I'm sure you know,

18:23 we will revisit her death again exhaustively. The important thing to note is that Liz was not Michael's first wife. Many people somehow confused the story that way. In fact, she wasn't even really Michael's friend. She was more friends with Patty, and Michael was close to George. The couples were close. They had dinners together, weekly vacation together, and seemed to be each other's family. While in Germany. They were close enough that in both of their wills, George and Liz chose Michael Peterson to be legal guardian to their daughters, now orphans, Margaret and Martha moved in with Michael and Patty's family, just as George and Liz had wonted. Though Liz's family was unhappy about it, Lizz's sister would later say they did come to understand because George and Liz had lived in Germany so long that they were closer to the Petersons. They were family in a way. It might have hurt not to raise her nieces, but it's not like they went to total strangers. But unfortunately, it was around this time, in the mid nineteen eighties, that Michael and Patty began having marital issues. While we don't know the nuances of their breakup, we do know that Michael cheated on Patty multiple times, with both men and women. Later, he would identify as bisexual. Of course, many people say he is gay and was closeted, which would not have been unusual for a man of his generation, and the same goes for being bisexual, But

19:56 it's important to note that it's obvious Michael loved women. He married twice. He had children with his first wife, and then fell in love with and married Kathleen. After Kathleen died, he had a decades long relationship with another woman. He was attracted to women. I think he really is bisexual, but ultimately it's not anyone else's place to question how he self identifies. If it was anyone else other than a man accused of murder, we would consider it wrong to question his sexuality. But yes, he did keep his sexuality private. He has always insisted he only had physical relationships with other men, not affairs of the heart, whatever happened between him and Patty. Author Diane Fanning said that taking in Margaret and Martha was also a stressor. She didn't sign up for four kids as how she put it. I am not certain whether the Ratliffs named Michael and Patty in their wills or just Michael, but I have always read that it was just Michael, which and of makes sense.

21:00 When George Ratliffe made his will, he was close to Michael. By the time Liz changed her will, she depended a lot on Michael. She hired a nanny to take care of her little girls so she could work, but she moved just a few doors down from the Petersons so they could help too. By Michael and Patty's account, he constantly helped Liz around the house and helped pick up and drop off the girls when the nanny wasn't around. It isn't implicitly said, but you get the sense that Patty was a bit of a strange bird. Diane Fanning said that she was an academic. She preferred to work late doing paperwork instead of rushing home to her family, and she was a bit of a dreamer, not really interested in domestic life.

21:45 She didn't care about cleaning the house or making dinner. Michael took on those responsibilities and that's just fine. However, it is said that due to her religious upbringing, she only believed in marrying once. She refused to worse Michael for quite some time, and even when she did, she never remarried, and she remained close to her ex husband, not just as a co parent, but as a friend. She would stand by him for the rest of her life. After their separation, Michael moved from Germany to Durham, North Carolina with Margaret and Martha, who were essentially babies. Margaret was about three years old and Martha eighteen months old when their mother died, so they were still pretty much toddlers when they moved with Michael. His sons Clayton and Todd remained with Patty and Germany through their teen years, which may explain some things about them that I'll get into later. And when Michael moved into his new home in Durham, it just so happened to be right down the street from Kathleen Hunt Atwater. Kathleen's daughter, Caitlin, befriended Michael's daughters, and shortly after Kathleen and Michael became smitten. From the beginning, Kathleen and Michael knew their relationship was special for starters. They had so much in common. They were both Duke University alumni and of course huge Duke basketball fans. They were both brilliant, witty, and funny, so their flirty banter came easily, and they were both the opposite of their former partners. According to Michael,

23:18 Kathleen's previous husband was very controlling and direct. Contrast, Michael was carefree and Kathleen was calm, whereas Patty could be harried. It seemed like a match made in heaven. Michael's son, Clayton, later told documentarians that Michael and Patty's relationship was largely platonic. Clayton hadn't seen his father be romantically in love until he saw Michael interact with Kathleen, his stepmother. He said, Dad and Kathleen just connected on a different plane. By nineteen eighty nine, Kathleen and Michael had merged their families. Instead of living on the same street, Kathleen, her daughter Caitlin, Michael and his two daughters, Margaret and Martha, were in the same house. When speaking with NBC about the transition, Kathleen's daughter Caitlin explained how excited she was for her two friends, Margaret and Martha to move in. They all sat me down and said, how would you like it if Martha and Margaret came to live with you? And I immediately thought a permanent sleepover. Later, Clayton and Todd came from Germany to live with them too. For fourteen years, all seven of them lived together.

24:30 They were a family. For those of you with families of your own, I know what you're thinking, that's two adults and five kids. That's a lot of mouths to feed, that's a lot of sports and piano practices to drive to, and that's a lot of money to spend. And you're right, But Michael and Kathleen could afford their large family, and they were committed to being good parents. They loved their hectic, lively family life. As I mentioned before, Kathleen was working her way up the Nortel corporate ladder and Michael had accepted a five hundred thousand dollars advance for a book deal. In today's money, that's almost one point three million. In nineteen ninety two, Kathleen and Michael bought a ten thousand square foot mansion. Michael put down a large deposit, about half of which he had gotten from his book advance.

25:21 Located on three wooded acres on sprawling land in Durham's Forest Hills neighborhood. This house was gorgeous. The home was older, built in the nineteen forties. It had a colonial fill with white siding and square shuttered windows. Outside it was glorious, beautiful green foliage and a large outdoor pool with a water fountain in its center. Inside it was just as grand, five bedrooms, six bathrooms, a library, a home gym, and a large kitchen, and other rooms for entertaining. One of the home's most notable features was a grand spiral staircase leading from the first floor inch freeway to the second floor, with white trim and dark wood. It was the first thing you noticed when you walked in the front door. But this staircase would not become the most important staircase in the Peterson house. Less noticeable and tucked away near the kitchen was a second staircase and narrow stairwell that also led to the second floor.

26:22 The Petersons had paid about six hundred thousand for this house, but today it would be worth two and two point six million dollars. For Michael and Kathleen's big, blended family, this was the perfect house, but as time went on, not everything was perfect for the Petersons. Michael's oldest son from his first marriage, eighteen year old Clayton, was struggling in the early nineties. Clayton graduated high school in Germany, then he moved to the US to live with Michael in the fall. Clayton planned to attend Duke University like his father, but unlike his father, Clayton was a bit of a loose cannon, and on April eighth of nineteen ninety three, he was arrested for going one hundred miles per hour on Durham City streets while driving drunk. After some finagling in court that summer, Clayton pled guilty to a lesser charge. He paid a five hundred dollars fine and was given a six month suspended sentence plus one year of unsupervised probation. But soon after Clayton had a second drunk driving arrest.

27:23 He had also attempted to flee the police while handcuffed, so instead of attending Duke University that fall, Clayton spent thirty days in rehab treating his alcohol abuse. The next spring, Clayton was able to go to Duke as planned. He studied engineering, But even after multiple runnings with the law, Clayton hadn't cleaned up his act. In fact, he had done the exact opposite. Before Clayton's year of probation for drunk driving was up, he was in legal trouble again. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. I have saying the praises of Prose before it's the world's most personalized hair care. Switching to a custom routine from Prose was one of the best things I've done for my hair. It is stronger and shinier than before I started using Prose. I love the gentle sulfate free shampoo and creamy conditioner.

28:18 I chose both with a corsica fragrance with notes of Aju pair Pony and cedar wood. I chose my products with Prose's simple but in depth quiz. Prose has done over a million consultations, so they know they're stuff. They don't just ask about your hair routine, but also your diet and things like stress levels. As a carbon neutral certified b CORP, Prose as an industry leader in clean and responsible beauty. All their ingredients are substantially sourced, ethically gathered, and cruelty free. They're also the first custom beauty brand to go carbon neutral. If you're not one hundred percent positive Prose is the best hair care you've had, they will take the products back, no questions asked. Prose is the healthy hair regiment with your name all over it. Take your free, in depth hair consultation and get fifteen percent off your first order today.

29:07 Go to pros dot com slash Southern Fried. That's p r o se dot com slash Southern Fried for your free end depth hair consultation and fifteen percent off. Sleep Sounds Meditation for Women offer sounds ranging from relaxing sleep meditation music, ambient and nature sounds by neural beats, white noise, and more. It's so easy to press play and fall asleep with ease. I have been an insomniac since I was a teenager, and I know I am more affected by stress than a lot of people, which disrupts not only my sleep but my peace of mind. Meditation has really helped me learn to breathe and calm myself, and I find that I sleep so much better listening to the Sleep Sounds Meditation for Women podcast before bedtime. The music is so soothing and her voice is so gentle. I fall asleep in no time. You just press play and lose yourself and meditation right away, and there is a huge library of past episodes to choose from. Just about every topic as covered, from anxiety, forgiveness, gratitude, calm, presence, sadness, and so much more.

30:15 So go follow sleep Sounds Meditation for Women now wherever you listen to podcasts and start listening for free today. Just search sleep Sounds Meditation for Women on your favorite podcast app and follow, or simply click on the link in the show notes. It was April of nineteen ninety four and nineteen year old Clayton Peterson was enjoying college, but not for the academics. He liked a party. As a result, he had run into issues with Duke Universities administrators. Duke had instituted a ban on fraternity keg parties. They had also forbidden on campus bonfires due to basketball fans being destructive during the NCAA March Madness tournament.

30:56 Clayton felt these restrictions were ridiculous they infringed upon his right to party, so on the weekend of April twenty fourth, Clayton took action. First, he wrote a tongue in cheek note criticizing the university's policies. One line of the note said, of course you realize that this means war. Then he pried, opened the basement window of the university's main administrative building, crept into the registrar's office, left the note nearby and led the fuse to a homemade pipe bomb. Clayton had submerged the gunpowder bomb and a gasolene filled gatorade bottle. The bomb could have caused a fiery explosion. Luckily, the fuse didn't work properly and it didn't detonate, but it was a close call. The fuse burned out mere inches away from the bomb. The Herald's son reported that a Duke University registrar worker found the bomb at noon that Sunday. They noticed scorch marks on the carpet leading to the registrar's office. Following the discovery, university authorities questioned many Duke's students, including Clayton. Their investigation led them to search Michael and Kathleen's home, where Clayton lived. Sometimes. Michael cooperated fully, helpfully showing them around. To his chagrin, the officers discovered Clayton's six additional explosive devices hidden in a closet. According to The Herald's son, Clayton had made these bombs with bottle rocket fuel from a toy store. A federal agent

32:28 testified that two of these bombs were rigged to shoot arrows outward as they exploded. Officials also uncovered Clayton's materials to make at least thirteen more bombs. And when Clayton broke into the university registrar's office, he didn't just plan a bomb. He also stole several items. He took a camera, blank ID cards, a card laminator, and a check book. He intended to use these things to create fake IDs for an upcoming vacation. He was going to mar Beach, a place famous for college age drinking and debauchery. The police found these stolen goods in Clayton's Duke University dorm room about a week after the break in. In early May of nineteen ninety four, law enforcement officials arrested Clayton.

33:15 He immediately confessed. Duke officials were glad to have caught the perpetrator before graduation that Sunday. If they hadn't, the students aka potential suspects would have left for summer break. According to the Herald's Sun, Clayton was charged for three counts related to breaking and entering, as well as possessing an unregistered destructive device. He faced a maximum of thirty years in prison and seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars in fines. Initially, he pled not guilty. As the legal proceedings began, Clayton's defense lawyer made the best of a bad situation. After all, his client had already confessed to the crime, but it was sheer luck that Clayton's bomb fuse failed. Someone could have easily been hurt.

34:01 Still, the attorney claimed that Clayton had purposely made sure the bomb didn't work. According to the lawyer, Clayton wasn't attempting to destroy campus property or hurt anyone. Instead, he was trying to divert attention while he stole the materials to make the fake ideas. Clayton's lawyers told the Harold's son. Obviously, Clayton had absolutely no intention that anyone would be hurt by any of this. Michael told a paper there was never an intent to ignite the bomb. There was only an apolitical, hedonistic intent to party. Just to clarify, Clayton did ignite the views that led to the bomb, but I suppose that's beside the point when your son is trying to escape federal prison. Michael did admit that his son's actions were ill advised. He told the Harold's son He's guilty, even though there was never any intent to hurt either people or property.

34:53 Clayton never should have done it. What he did was stupid and wrong. While nineteen year old Clayton was in jail, he underwent a forty five day court ordered psychiatric evaluation, which determined he was mentally fit to stand trial. He tried to get psychiatric treatment from Duke, but Duke's legal team refused him. Then Clayton was placed under house arrest in Michael and Kathleen's home for weeks. Clayton's case made Durham headlines. Michael publicly argued that his son's antics were foolish but excusable. However, federal agents pointed out Clayton's concerning history. While attending high school in Germany, Clayton had blown up a telephone booth with a homemade bomb. He had also stolen chemicals from his school. Then he had tried to ship them to Michael's house in North Carolina. According to The Herald's son, Clayton's shipped chemicals were intercepted by postal inspectors. Asset had leaked out of the parcel and injured several male handlers. Maybe Clayton had faced real repercussions for the German bomb or the dangerous chemicals he shipped. He never would have tried it again at Duke, But after getting away with it, he seemed to escalate, and Michael did seem to make a lot of excuses for his son. You have to wonder if he felt guilty about the time he lost as a father to his boys when he moved back to the US and his son stayed with Patty, who admittedly wasn't a strong parent. Clayton Peterson seemed

36:28 to be a very troubled young man, a dangerous young man, and he was about to seriously pay for it. Taking into account Clayton's concerning history and his numerous DIY explosives, things were not looking good for him. So he switched his plea from not guilty to guilty, avoiding trial. On December twenty ninth, nineteen ninety four, now twenty year old Clayton Peterson was sentenced to four years and one month in prison. At the sentencing hearing, Clayton apologized for his actions. Four years later he was released from prison, and in prison he seemed to have cleaned up his act. He went on to be valedictorian at North Carolina State University. Then he studied engineering and graduate school.

37:15 Clayton's illegal antics undoubtedly put Michael and Kathleen's family through the ringer. Maybe going through this time together as a united front brought them even closer because Michael and Kathleen's relationship was still doing well, really well. Friends and family said the couple was strong. They traveled together frequently, going to places like London, Paris, Florence, Athens, Venice, Tokyo, Hong Kong, and Hanoi. Martha, their youngest daughter, explained to documentarians that her parents didn't have any problems. She said Michael and Kathleen's relationship was wonderful, beautiful, and joyful. In an interview for the documentary The Staircase, Martha said that even when the couple did fight, it was lighthearted. For example, Michael would always come home late from the gym, which frustrated Kathleen. Dinner was ready and Michael was late again, but no one ever lost their temper. The situation just became a running joke, and in October of nineteen ninety six, Michael finally officially divorced his first wife, Patty. Then he proposed to Kathleen on that New Year's Eve. Kathleen's sister Candace, described Kathleen as glowing on her wedding day. The following June, she and Michael were married at home, with Kathleen gliding down the beautiful grand staircase decorated with flowers. Her daughters were all bridesmaids. Kathleen would describe it as one of the happiest days of her life. The photos of the event are so lovely, with Kathleen and

38:51 Michael gazing adoringly at each other and the giggling preteen bridesmaids were bursting with happiness as they posed together. It was a permanent sleepover for the close knit sisters. Near this time, Michael began writing regularly for the local Durham newspaper, the Herald Sun. He had written a few things for the paper in the past. In February of nineteen ninety six, he wrote a piece criticizing the Durham education system for failing its black students, and sometimes Michael was even the subject of the Herald Sun articles. In June of nineteen ninety six, journalist Blake Dickinson wrote a feature on Michael. It outlined that despite being a successful author, most of Michael's local fame came primarily from his son Clayton. The bomb attempt was more newsworthy than Michael's novels. This is quite a petty piece of journalism, even if it was true. Sounds like a writer didn't like Michael poaching his territory at the paper, and Michael seemed to hit back by writing even more guest columns. Then, in nineteen ninety seven, Michael began a regular twice a week column Underham's Current Events. No one was surprised, it was a natural progression. In Michael's column, he wrote about a wide range of hot button topics, but he spent most of his time advocating against racism. He wrote about Durham's white supremacy, historical lynching, prejudiced public officials, and more hard subjects. For North Carolina, a former slave state,

40:24 to this day, it has over forty Confederate monuments, Durham's citizens had strong feelings about Michael's writing, and he leaned into that. He used fictional characters and satirical humor to drive his controversial points home. He would guest star on local radio shows to hear what his readers thought. He held a seminar called the Ethics of Outspoken Journalism, and the Haraldson, managing editor deemed Michael's calm outrageous and irreverent. Overall, Michael's writing was polarizing. His readers either loved him or loved to hate him, and perhaps most notably, Michael's column regularly criticized the Durham legal system, especially the police department. Michael wrote about how they seemed to target black people, how they let politicians get away with illegal activity, how Durham had the highest crime rate in North Carolina. Michael often sarcastically awarded well known Durham figures stupid prizes. On numerous occasions, he called out the police for these stupid prizes. He accused the copse of being rotten and covering up crime. Unsurprisingly, the Durham Police Department did not appreciate the constant criticism. In Michael's memoir Behind the Staircase, he said that the chief of police emailed him that the column hurt police morale. But Michael wasn't worried about the police department's moral He wanted justice. The last troll for him happened.

41:55 Around nineteen ninety eight, a Dirham dentist had called the police he had seen a drug deal happen at the house next door to his practice. But this house wasn't just any house, it was the city mayor's house. Soon after the dentist called the authorities, a local gang burned down his dental practice. Michael thought that the dentist police report and the subsequent arson were related. Michael suspected it was all result of city corruption, as if the mayor had a drug habit and wanted the dentist kept quiet. So in August of nineteen ninety nine, Michael took matters into his own hands. He resigned from his calumnist position with the Herald's son and ran for city mayor himself. Was there actual corruption in Durham's politics and police department in the late nineties, It's unclear, but that's certainly what Michael thought. He ran alongside four other mayoral candidates, most of whom were vastly more qualified than him. There was the incumbent mayor, Nick Tennyson, on An Ernie, a Durham City Council member, and one other man, who, like Michael, was running for mayor.

43:05 With little to no political or legal expertise, Michael's campaign centered on his desire to reform Durham City government and the police department. He wanted to improve crime, race relations, and the economy, which honestly is an admirable campaign to run on. In the Herald Sun's profile of mayoral candidates, Michael identified as in between conservative and liberal views. He listed his hobbies as swimming, weightlifting, and reading. His hero was FDR and his favorite book was To the Lighthouse by Virginia Woolf. He left the prompt self written description of political philosophy part blank. When asked, why are you qualified to hold this office, Michael responded, for two years I have written almost exclusively about Durham. I think I have a better understanding of this city, it's problem and potential than anyone else. I should be elected because I have brought forward problems and concerns no one else has dared to raise, and I have the ability to correct and solve those problems. But in September of nineteen ninety nine, Michael's credibility was tainted and he would lose the mayoral election partly because of it. To explain this fully, We'll have to go back a few years. Remember that Vietnam leg injury, almost ten years before Michael ran for mayor. It was March of nineteen ninety At Hodges, a columnist for The Herald's son, wrote a piece on Michael. Michael was, after all, a minor celebrity.

44:38 He was known as a Vietnam veteran and a successful novelist reporter. Hodge's angle was simple. Michael's fatal injury in the Vietnam War inspired him to write his books. In an eight hundred word article, Michael regaled Hodges with specific details about how a landmine exploded near him. His right leg was bad wounded. Another officer died. Michael told him, you never believe you're the one who's going to be killed. You think it's going to be a buddy, someone else, not you. Michael had a long hospital state in Vietnam, recovered fully, and was honorably discharged from the US military with a permanent disability.

45:20 He returned from Vietnam well decorated with a silver star, a bronze star, and two purple hearts. Fast forward three years. It was November of nineteen ninety three. Michael and Kathleen visited Vietnam. This was the first time Michael had returned to Vietnam since he served as a marine in the Vietnam War. When he returned to the US, Michael wrote a five part series chronicling his trip for The Herald's Sun. Throughout the series, Michael compared his past experience as in Vietnam to his current from American soldier to American tourist. The articles were well written, haunting, and insightful. In the first of five articles, Michael described how he watched coffins of US soldiers get forklifted off an airplane while he was awaiting his own flight from California to Vietnam. By chance, Michael spotted the coffin of a marine he knew. Ronald Michael wrote, he was a poster marine, a perfect physical specimen. We double dated. He was a great guy. He lasted two weeks in Vietnam before taking a bullet to the brain. It was a poignant way to demonstrate the nerves a young man must feel as he heads to war again. He mentions his many military medals, including the two Purple Hearts. But Michael's five part series wasn't perfect.

46:43 Sometimes he wrote with casual racism. He called Vietnamese women promiscuous and poked fun at a singer's accent to English. It was unusual for a man so concerned with Durham's race relations. But it also sort of reads as something a man of his generation would consider harmless. He wasn't using racist slurs and would probably be surprised to know that people thought his writing was racist. I also noticed it in his memoirs from his time in prison. It definitely sometimes reads as something an old man would say, out of touch with our evolving understanding of underlying prejudices, and yet he would probably staunchly deny being racist. It's complicated for men of his age, even when they are well meaning. Still, this series and The Herald's Son helped Michael nab his job as a biweekly columnist years later. Plus it was great publicity for his new book, which was published the same year as the series. It, like his other books, was about the Vietnam War. All of this is to say, in Durham, North Carolina, Michael was known for his status as a decorated Vietnam veteran. It was his identity what he talked about. It's what he wrote his novels about and it was part of his appeal as a potential mayor.

48:07 So when The Herald's son published an article in September of nineteen ninety nine entitled Durham mayoral candidate Michael Peterson fabricated war injury admits falsehood, it changed everything. Someone had uncovered Michael's military records. As it turns out, he hadn't narrowly escaped death while standing near a Vietnamese landmine in nineteen seventy one. In fact, he hadn't been in Vietnam in nineteen seventy one. He left two years earlier, on September fourth, nineteen sixty nine. Then he went to San Diego. In June of nineteen seventy he was deployed to Atsugi, Japan. There he provided security as a military police officer for a naval air station.

48:53 While in Japan, Michael did have a leg injury, but it was from a car crash. Another car hit Michael's vehicle head on at a railroad crossing. Some facets of Michael's original story were true. The officer Michael was with did die and Michael suffered severe injuries, including rib fractures, A punctured lung and a badly wounded right leg. As he said, he was honorably discharged and considered permanently disabled. Still, Michael knew what he did was wrong. He told the Herald's son, it's a cover. I admit it. My second wife she doesn't know. I'm going to discuss it with her today.

49:35 In addition to the false landmine story, Michael's military record also did not indicate that he had received two Purple hearts. Michael couldn't provide the written certifications that come with the medals. However, Michael maintained that he did receive them. He explained that he had had two minor wounds caused by shrapnel, and Michael did possess a medal that he said represented to purple hearts. But at the end of the day, Michael had lied his military career was already fine, even if his red badge of courage was a little unexciting. Durham residence were baffled by Michael's deceit. Why did he needlessly embellish? Michael's mayoral campaign was entrenched in demanding honesty from public officials, yet here he was lying for seemingly no reason. At all except probably to sell more of his Vietnam War related novels. It's possible he was not really considering being a politician who would have to defend his war record when he chose to embellish as an author. But if he would lie about that, what else would he lie about. In October of nineteen ninety nine, Michael lost in the primary elections. His mayoral candidacy was over incumbent mayor Nick Tennyson was reelected that November. This was a tough time for Michael, Kathleen and their family. Their reputation was more damaged

51:06 than it was a few months ago, and for the first time ever, money was a little tight for the Petersons. Since Michael quit his position at the Herald's Sun, he didn't really have a regular income, but he did, however, have a military pension due to his disability, which was forty five thousand dollars a year. That would be about seventy five thousand today, which is not insignificant. I've often read or heard in documentaries and other podcasts that Michael had no income, that he did not work and just lived off Kathleen. That's not true, but in comparison Kathleen was the main breadwinner. After her promotion at Nortel in nineteen ninety nine, she made a reasonably high salary, and unlike her husband, the writer, who puttered around the house and went to the gym daily, Kathleen worked grueling out hours at Nortel.

52:00 She was always on the clock, even at home, often bringing homework and taking calls at night and on weekends. And beyond their extravagant lifestyle, they had five children, three of whom still needed college tuition money. Caitlin was at Cornell, an Ivy League school, and Margaret was at Tulane, a prestigious private school in New Orleans. And Martha began Auroba University in San Francisco the fall before Kathleen's death, another expensive out of state school. Clayton and Todd had both already graduated from North Carolina University and were out of the house, but they were still financially dependent on their parents. Patty included Clayton was going for his master's degree. Michael and Patty had even thrown an empty nest party when Martha went off to college in September of two thousand and one.

52:52 During that party, everyone drunkenly wound up in the swimming pool, and Kathleen dove into the shallow end, scaring everyone. Today when Michael had to pull her out of the pool, she had a neck injury from the incident, for which she was still taking valium and flexoryl a muscle relaccent when she died that following December. According to an article from All That's Interesting, Kathleen and Michael had a few tense moments of her money, especially after Michael lost the election, but it's likely that these weren't shouting matches. That wasn't Michael's style. His son Todd, told interviewers for The Staircase that Michael was far more likely to chuckle and walk off than engage in an argument. He just didn't have that temper. Todd said that as kids, Michael never hit him or his siblings. He might have spanked them for disciplinary reasons, but as the kids got older, Michael stopped. For all intents and purposes, Michael and Kathleen's relationship seemed fine. The Peterson family was fine. Everyone was safe and healthy. That's all that mattered, and the rest would figure itself out.

54:01 And in a way it almost did. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. On Friday, December seventh, two thousand and one, David Pearl Mutt had some good news. David and Michael were co authors. Three years before, they had written a book about US Marines called Charlie two Shoes and the Marines of Love Company. David had recently spoken with Stratton Leopold, a Hollywood producer. For a while, Stratton had hinted that he was thinking about optioning Charlie two Shoes in the film industry, that's when the author gives someone the rights to make their book into a movie. It's no guarantee that you'll get a film, but it is a very good sign. And just that day Stratton had pulled the trigger. He told David the option was one hundred percent certain. Elated, David went to call the Peterson household so he could tell Michael that there book might become a movie. At about six pm, Kathleen answered David's call. They spoke for a while, and David later reported that everything seemed normal. After about ten minutes, David asked, is the old man there? Referring to Michael, a common joke for many friends and family due to Mike and Kathleen's age difference. Kathleen teased that Michael was there, but he would have to do some chores before he could talk to David. Empty the dryer, mopped the kitchen floor. David said he could hear Michael laughing in the background. This was normal for Kathleen and Michael.

55:35 They were known for their playful teasing. At last, Michael got on the phone and heard the good news from David. His financial struggles were over. A movie was in the works later that evening. Later that evening, Michael and Kathleen went to a Christmas party to celebrate. They danced the night away before returning home at about one am on Saturday, December eighth, two thousand and one, and Kathleen spent the day bringing Christmas decorations out of storage. This was their annual tradition. According to Michael, they went all out. They had forty eight candles for their forty eight windows, thirty six nutcrackers for each step in the hallway, two large wooden reindeer lawn ornaments adorned with red bows on their necks, and an uncountable number of Christmas lights, and many many ornaments for their twelve foot Christmas tree. The plan was to set up all the decorations the next day. That evening, Michael rented the movie America's Sweethearts from Blockbuster. Around ten pm. Michael and Kathleen watched it while drinking wine. Todd stopped by the Lefa's car at the house. He was going to a Christmas party in the neighborhood, but was riding with a friend because he would be drinking. Todd said his father and Kathleen looked like they were in good spirits as they waved goodbye when he left for the party at eleven o eight pm. Toward the end of the movie, Kathleen's co worker Ellen called Helen and Kathleen made plans for an eight am conference call the next morning. On Sunday. Helen told Kathleen that she would send a follow up

57:08 email, and she did at eleven fifty three pm, but Kathleen never opened the email. According to Michael, at midnight, he and Kathleen went outside and sat by the pool. He described the night as magical. It was ununseasonably warm December night, about fifty five to sixty degrees fahrenheit, or over twelve degrees Celsius. Many people, especially those who don't live in the South, have doubted the story. They think it was too cold, particularly for Michael, who was wearing shorts, but Kathleen was also wearing flip flops. But as many Southerners will tell you, this is nice weather. My husband will wear shorts until it gets into the thirties here. And what's more, they were smoking. Most people know Michael smoked a pipe from the Staircase documentary, but they don't know that Kathleen was a casual cigarette smoker. And while Mike puffed his pipe constantly, he didn't smoke cigars in the house and Kathleen wouldn't have smoked inside either. Kathleen did not smoke during the day or even every day, but she did enjoy a couple of cigarettes with wine after dinner sometimes. She and Michael both were wine connoisseurs and drank it with dinner most nights, sometimes switching to champagne later. So they would grab a bottle of wine or champagne, a couple of glasses, a cigar for Michael and cigarettes for Kathleen and head down to their pool. And the pool really was a showcase. You got to it from a winding footpath from the house, and it was surrounded by beautiful foliage even in the winter, and it was kept

58:43 open year round with a fountain going. The Petersons were known to sit by their pool and gaze at the stars as they finished their drinks and smoked. That night, Michael said they were drinking champagne, celebrating his movie option and talking about the future. He puffed on a cigar as Kathleen smoked her cigarettes. Their two English bulldogs lay at their feet. A little before two o'clock in the morning, Michael said that Kathleen left the pool and went to bed. She had to get to sleep since she had that conference call the next morning. Michael told his wife good night and said that he would be up in a bed. He was still finishing his cigar. Thirty minutes later, at two thirty am, Michael left the pool and went inside. At two forty am, Michael called nine one one. The dispatcher later said that Michael was hysterical. I won't read you the transcript of the call or play it.

59:37 I'm sure many of you have heard it enough times to recite at yourself. If not, it's very easy to find online. But I will tell you about some portions. Michael did seem out of breath, possibly hysterical. The first thing he says is eighteen ten Cedar Street. Please. He said his wife has had an accident, but she was still breathing, egged for help. As the dispatcher calmly asked the necessary questions, he shouts, she fell down the stairs. Please come. Like many people who call nine one one, Michael sounds impatient with the questions when she asks him how many stairs? She meant how many did his wife fall down? But Michael seems to think she's asking how many stairs were on the staircase in total. He says huh, then what, sounding aggravated, and then says, oh, fifteen twenty. I don't know. I've seen many true crying people grasp at this part, saying he sounds flustered like it wasn't part of the script he had planned when he called nine one one. To me, he sounds confused as to why this woman wanted to know how many stairs they had. I think this is a misunderstanding and one I've heard on plenty of other documentaries and podcasts.

1:00:51 Those that think he's guilty and those that think he's innocent. I'm not calling anyone out. I just don't think it's that important. I think it elite does sound like a misunderstanding. In general, it's hard to judge nine one one calls, especially for laypeople. We often feel that the dispatcher isn't being sympathetic enough, or that the caller sounds suspicious. It is always a subjective experience listening to these calls. What's important to me is that Michael clearly gives his address right away, something that even innocent people forget to do. He also says it's in forest Tills, giving the subdivision. The only thing I did find odd about Michael's nine one one call is he never mentions all the blood. I'm sure you have also seen the crime scene photos of Kathleen Peterson at the bottom of the stairs. If not, that's also a quick google. But I warn you it is very gruesome. It's one of the bloodiest crime scenes I've ever seen, so to me, that is strange.

1:01:55 You would think that in all his hysteria, he would say, my god, there's so much blood. But again, nine one one calls are subjective. To be fair to him, he called, he gave the address, right away, and while something it's strange that he hung up twice, it's not that strange to me. If it was my husband dying before my eyes, I would make sure nine one one knew the emergency and my address, and then I would want to do all I could to help him. I would want to hold him, not sit on the phone with nine one one answering questions. And something that is rarely mentioned is that Michael ran to get towels to put under Kathleen's head. It seems he was trying to help her as instinct was either to stanch the bleeding or cushion her head without moving her body. Many people are trained not to move someone after a fall in case they have a neck injury. Considering Michael's training as a marine, this makes sense. He would later say he wiped blood from her face as he was putting towels under her head, but did not attempt CPR, which, considering his marine training, you can see. It's strange. You can read this scene in all sorts of ways, which is a harbinger to come for this entire case. It's all about perception. And six minutes later, when an ambulance still hadn't shown up. He calls nine one one back, even more distressed now shouting that she's not breathing and please, would you hurry up?

1:03:25 And then he hung up again. But he doesn't ask about mouth to mouth, nor does he indicate that he's trying it. Many people have a problem with that. That's understandable. But he would also later say that he knew she was dying. He had seen men die in war, and he knew what it looked like as the light left their eyes. Less than ten minutes after Michael's first call, two paramedics arrival on the scene. They reported that the front door to the Peterson's home was open. They noticed it had smeared blood on it, along with a couple blood droplets in the walk. Straight ahead through the front door was the main staircase that led to the second floor.

1:04:05 To the left, down a hallway was the enclosed staircase, which also led to the second floor. This staircase did not have a spiral. It went parallel to the hallway, so at the very bottom of the steps there was a sharp turn. This allowed the staircase to open into the hallway. That's where paramedics found Kathleen. She was lying at the bottom of the stairwell. Her legs were out in the hallway with her torso on the landing of the stairs and her head toward the steps, and like I said, there were towels under her head. Shoes, socks, and paper towels were also near her body, as if Michael had grabbed anything and everything to help soak up the blood. Because there was a lot of blood, Kathleen's white pants and blue top were covered in it, and the stairwell there was even more on the floor, the walls, and the steps. As I said, the amount of blood was staggering. The emergency responders said Michael had a dazed stare and was audibly sobbing. He was obviously very very upset. They said his tennis, shoes and clothes were covered in Kathleen's blood. Paramedics could not find Kathleen's heartbeat. Forty eight year old Kathleen hunt Atwater Peterson was dead.

1:05:26 It appeared to be an accident that she had fallen down the stairs, but the first responders were shocked by the amount of blood present, and some of them thought the blood was dry, as if Kathleen had lain in that stairwell, not for thirty minutes, but for hours suspicious. They called homicide detectives to the scene, and the detectives immediately treated this as a criminal investigation. However, it's important to note that not one of the policemen nor the detectives noted in their reports that they thought the blood was dry, even though the detectives were definitely not on the scene within minutes, even the uniform police trailed to paramedics by a few minutes. That detail about dried blood might not seem like that big a deal, but it would be a big deal at trial.

1:06:15 It would call into question just how long Kathleen had lain there. It would call into question Michael's version of events. Was she really breathing when he found her? Law enforcement was allowed to testify to the dried blood, even though they neglected to put it in their reports. That is an extremely important detail for a police report. And I'll want to mention one other thing. It is entirely possible that Michael was mistaken when he said Kathleen was still breathing. There are many reasons he could have thought she was. If he was moving her head to place towels, her mouth may have moved and air or gas left in her body may have been expelled, or it may have simply just been wishful thinking. And you know what, maybe she was still breathing when he called. Maybe it was a death rattle, the final gasps.

1:07:11 It is very common when someone dies we don't have actual proof that the blood was dry, No photographs actually show that, no reports in the crime scene, and we can talk about the possibility of how long she lived later with the autopsy, the photos taken or after she died, and after her body is moved, and you still can't exactly tell what, if any of the blood is dry, just by looking at these photos. But still, even when her body is eventually moved, there is so much blood pooling it splashes around more, according to some witnesses, making matters worse. Shortly after the paramedics arrived, a parade of people entered the home. A fire engine crew, then police officers. Michael's son Todd arrived home from the party. Next a friend of Todd's who is a med student, then neighbors, friends, the medical examiner, crime scene technicians, a photographer, and more. There were conflicting accounts of the crime scene, amateur investigation tactics, misleading clues and skewed motivations. The crime scene was not secured for more than an hour.

1:08:21 The police would later defensively say they weren't used to securing a crime scene. That big, ten thousand square feet is not your average house. But it's not like the whole family was there. Most of the people there were there people, and they could have called in more officers if that's what they needed to secure the scene. It's a weak excuse for what would be a shitty crime scene investigation. From the start, police did not believe Michael's version of events. Over the course of the next week, investigators found incriminating material on Michael's computer. It was a lot of gay horn and also conversations about meeting up with escorts. The police and prosecutors would lean heavily on this as evidence.

1:09:10 The police also discovered Kathleen's one point eight million dollar life insurance policy. Michael was named the beneficiary, and the officers were hesitant to support Michael, the outspoken journalist who wrote disparaging articles about the Durham Police Department for two long years. Eleven days after Kathleen's death on December twentieth, fifty eight year old Michael Ivor Peterson was indicted for his wife's murder. He surrendered himself to the police and was taken into custody. To news reporters, Michael said, Kathleen was my life. I've whispered her name in my heart a thousand times. She is there and I can't stop crying. I would never have done anything to hurt her. He spent the holidays in jail, and his pitiful children spent that horrific holiday alone in that big house by themselves, wearing brave faces as they put up the Christmas decorations and decorated the tree that their parents never got to. Pulling together a Christmas dinner, opening the presents their mother had thoughtfully chosen for them. It's truly heartbreaking to think about it. Caitlin had lost her real mother, though thankfully her father would rush to her side.

1:10:28 Todd and Clayton had lost a loving stepmother, but they also had Patty rush to be with them, and Margaret and Martha were devastated. They called Kathleen mom. She was the first woman in their lives who had combed their hair, bought them pretty dresses. They didn't remember their own mother at all. And only had faint memories of Patty. Kathleen and Michael were their world, and now she was gone and he sat in jail awaiting his bond hearing. Southern Fridtrue Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank and me, and of course all editorial opinions are my own. Join me for part two of Kathleen Peterson's case next week as we analyze the crime scene in detail, outline the police investigation, explore Michael's potential motives, court experiences, and more. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic art is by Coley Horner.

1:11:32 If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listener suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases you'll always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group Southern Fridtrue Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. We do, of course discuss true crime, not just Southern fraud, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by God, we mean it when we say no shit us is allowed.

1:12:16 It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoyed today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like iHeart, Stitcher, Spotify and now Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care,