172: The Murder of Ryan Poston
On Friday, October 12th, 2012, Shayna Hubers called 911. She explained to the emergency operator that she killed her boyfriend, Ryan Poston, in self-defense. When the police investigated the crime scene, they quickly realized that Shayna’s version of...
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank and Erica Kelley
Case suggested by Amanda, “in Dolly we Trust”
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Erica Kelley
Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/the-murder-of-ryan-poston
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
- US National Domestic Violence Hotline: 800-799-7233
- National Domestic Violence Hotline: thehotline.org
- Canada: visit this website to find the hotline in your area
- UK Domestic Abuse Hotline: 0808 2000 247
- This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp online therapy. Go to BetterHelp.com/southern.
- Cancel your unwanted subscriptions with RocketMoney.com/southernfried
- Take a break and lose yourself solving a mystery set in the roaring 20’s with June’s Journey.
- Give yourself the gift of peace of mind by going to SimpliSafe.com/southernfried. There’s no safe like SimpliSafe.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:12 Southern Fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. On Friday, October twelfth, twenty twelve, pageant Queen Audrey Bolt, also known as Miss Ohio, was having a hell of a day. She had started chatting with a new guys she had met on Facebook. His name was Ryan Poston, and he seemed promising. He was a lawyer, a handsome lawyer. He was starting a law firm, had his own place, and was super smart. Sure, Ryan may have been thirty years old to Audrey's twenty three, but it could be nice to date an older, established man, someone who knows what they're looking for in life. Plus, Ryan was funny.
1:00 They had started chatting with each other after Ryan left a witty comment on Audrey's Facebook posts on that October day. They had plans to grab drinks at a local dive bar that night, maybe they would shoot some pool. Audrey was excited and she knew Ryan wouldn't forget their date. But ten thirty pm came and went, and Ryan never showed up, no text, no call, nothing. He had ghosted her. And when Audrey was subpoenaed. Months later she found out why. Welcome to episode one seventy two, The Murder of Ryan Poston. Ryan Christopher Poston was born on December thirtieth, nineteen eighty two, and Fort Mitchell, Kentucky, to his mother Lisa and his father j Ryan three sisters and was the only son in his immediate family. Ryan's parents described him as a caring son and a protective older brother. The entire post And family was very close. Ryan's father said his son often was loving and affectionate. On the way out the door. Ryan always kissed his parents and said I love you. Around nineteen eighty three, when Ryan was a year old, his parents divorced, shortly after Ryan's mother began seeing a different man named Peter Carter. Ryan's parents and stepfather co parented Ryan very successfully,
2:36 and as a result, Ryan loved both of his fathers dearly. When he was an adult, he changed his middle name from Christopher to Carter to honor his stepfather, Peter Carter, becoming Ryan Carter Postan. Ryan spent his childhood in Fort Mitchell, Kentucky, where the wealthy post And family had a small fortune, a strong reputation, and many connections. The Fort Mitchell community recognized the postings as a positive force. From kindergarten to eighth grade, Ryan went to the Blessed Sacrament School, a private Catholic school in Fort Mitchell. When Ryan entered the ninth grade, he moved out of the United States with his family. His stepfather, Peter, was a marketing executive for Procter and Gamble, a giant corporation for American hygiene products. Peter's career took Ryan's family overseas to Asia and Europe. During his early high school years, Ryan went to the International School of Manila in the Philippines, and around two thousand and one, Ryan graduated from the Geneva International School in Switzerland. Traveling the world and attending top tier private schools was probably an adventure for Ryan, especially since he was known for his impressive intellect and love of learning. His father told the Cincinnati Enquirer that Ryan's true passion was knowledge. Jokingly, his father said that Ryan's favorite book was the Dictionary. That's how much he loved learning. After high school, Ryan returned to the United States for college. In two thousand
4:08 and five, he graduated from Indiana University with three bachelor's degrees, the first in political science, the second in history, and the third in geography. To a hard working, knowledge seeking guy like Ryan, earning three degrees was a joy, not a chore. Right after finishing his undergrad education, Ryan went straight into law school. His desire to become a lawyer wasn't a surprise. He came from a long line of attorneys. Ryan's grandfather practiced law for over fifty years. He provided legal counsel for the Pacific Gas and Electric Company, and he was vice president of a committee famous for weeding out Kentucky's political corruption in the nineteen sixties. Ryan's uncle was also a practicing attorney in his hometown of Fort Mitchell. Both Ryan's grandfather and uncle attended the Salmon P.
4:58 Chase College of Law at Northern Kentucky University, and following in his family's footsteps, Ryan attended Chase Law two. In the fall of two thousand and five, things were coming up roses for Ryan. His mother and stepfather let him stay in their condominium. Not only was his parents condo free, but it was a short two minute drive from the NKU campus where Ryan attended law school. And law school went pretty well for Ryan too. His roommate and friend Matthew Herron, told The Kentucky Inquirer he was just one of those people who was good at everything. Law school wasn't hard for him. He just got it. It was something he really didn't have to work at. It came natural to him. After three years of law school, Ryan graduated with his Juris Doctor in two thousand and eight. He passed the Kentucky bar around two thousand and ten, and in April of two eleven he passed the Ohio bar.
5:54 But simply joining his family's legacy of lawyers was not enough for Ryan. In two thousand and twelve, thirty year old Ryan set his sights on starting his very own law firm in Cincinnati, Ohio. For reference, Cincinnati is located smack dab on the Ohio Kentucky border. Ryan's Cincinnati office building would have been about ten miles from his condo in Highland Heights, Kentucky. In addition to being a smart, successful lawyer, Ryan was also kind hearted. Kenneth Jayhawy, Ryan's legal mentor and friend, said he had a strong feeling of wanting to help people who couldn't otherwise have access to the legal system and who might be steamrolled by the legal system without someone there to help them. Ryan's new law firm focused on helping his clients with personal injury cases like car crashes, and during his client's most stressful times, Ryan treated them like they were family. Ryan's clients told his father that he made them feel heard like they were the only person on earth. Anytime, day or night, Ryan would always answer his client's phone calls. Often Ryan worked late into the night to research every last detail of his cases. Everyone knew that Ryan Carter Poston went above and beyond to represent his clients well. Kenneth Jayhawley told the Kentucky Inquirer he was going from zero to one hundred, probably faster and better than any young lawyer could have or than could be imagined. He was that good at what he was going to be doing. He was excited about his future,
7:25 and his future was very bright. Some of Ryan's friends even expected him to run for Congress soon. They said, when Ryan talked, people listened no matter what he had to say. Ryan seemed to know everything about everything. Despite Ryan's extreme devotion to his profession, he maintained an identity outside of work. He loved drinking Woodford reserved bourbon, playing chess, and discussing philosophy. It seemed like Ryan truly had everything. A great career, a range of personal interests, and a loving family. And if that wasn't enough, Ryan was also a handsome devil. His friends and family described him as extraordinarily attractive.
8:09 Standing at six foot three with brown hair and blue eyes and a slim build. Ryan looked great in his daily suit and tie, and he knew it. He was confident in his appearance and gained the attention of many beautiful women. One of those women was Shana Huber's Sna was a nineteen year old grad school student in Kentucky. By random chance, one of her relatives was Facebook friends with both her and Ryan. Through Facebook's suggested Friend's feature, Ryan noticed Sana's profile. She immediately caught his eye. Just like Ryan, she had brown hair, blue eyes, and was gorgeous. On March twentieth, two thousand eleven, Ryan sent Sena a Facebook friend request. After chatting through Facebook messages for just under a month, Ryan and Shanna decided to take the plunge and meet in person, so on April eighth, Ryan went to Shana's birthday party at a Lexington, Kentucky bar right away. The chemistry between Ryan and Shana was electric soon after they were dating, but it was a somewhat long distance relationship. Shana lived in Lexington, almost ninety miles from Ryan's condo in Highland Heights. The two saw each other only occasionally, but they texted constantly. Shana and Ryan appeared to be a happy couple for about eight months, but starting in November twenty eleven, they had troubled waters. From this point on, friends described them as frequently on again, off again. They
9:39 broke up at least three times and five months. Each breakup was short lived and they would quickly make up, but over time, friends and family could see that this relationship was dressing Ryan out. By Shana's own admission, she was much more interested in Ryan than he was in her, and it showed. Ryan's colleagues reported that Shana would constantly come to Ryan's office, even when the two were on a break. Sometimes Shana would show up at Ryan's office under the pretense of bringing him lunch, but other times Shana was just trying to find Ryan when he hadn't responded to her text messages. If Shana couldn't find Ryan at the office, she would wander aimlessly around the building. Shana would also go to Ryan's condo and let herself in, regardless of their current relationship status. Her unannounced visits happened so often that Ryan threatened to padlock his door. Keep in mind, visiting Ryan was not a quick trip for Shana.
10:39 She had to drive ninety minutes from Lexington to Highland Heights for Shana to visit Ryan. This often uninvited, and when they weren't even a couple, it was weird. And there's more. When Shana couldn't get to Ryan herself, she contacted his neighbor. She asked them if Ryan was at home or going to the bar with other woman. And Shana texted Ryan way too much. The Cincinnati Inquirer reported that for every one text Ryan sent Shana, she responded with approximately one hundred texts. What seemed like a promising relationship at the start was quickly turning sour, and Ryan's family saw that Ryan's dad, Jay, would regularly go to Ryan's condo to clean and do his laundry. According to Jay, Ryan was a slob who never cared what his place looked like.
11:30 Since Ryan was so busy with his law practice, Jay helped his son by picking up after him about three times a week. On numerous occasions, whether Shana and Ryan were together or not, Shana would be at Ryan's place while his dad was cleaning. She wouldn't interact with Ryan, but she wouldn't leave when Ryan asked her to. Jay told the Cincinnati Inquirer the relationship was as though she was a ghost. I would look at her and think, why are you here. Many of Ryan's friends and family believe Shana was stalking Ryan. Jaya explained that had Ryan been his daughter, he would have gotten a restraining order against Shana, but he felt that Ryan could take care of himself, As he told the Inquirer, he was my big, strapping son.
12:13 I figured let him work this out. But Ryan couldn't seem to work this out. His family explained that he was notoriously bad at handling conflict. Ryan just wanted everyone to be happy. Ending his relationship with Shana was challenging because it broke his heart to see her so upset. After months and months of Ryan and Shana's increasingly toxic relationship, he was finally ready to break things off. But Shana wouldn't let him. Ryan's friends told CBS His Forty eight Hours that Shana was determined to settle down with Ryan. She wouldn't take no for an answer no matter what Ryan said. Shana continued showing up everywhere in his life, relentlessly badgering him with text messages, popping up at his office, and using her key to get into his condo. Ryan mimicked his father's previous sentiments when he sent a text to a friend saying, this is getting to be restraining order level crazy. But under Kentucky law, Ryan didn't qualify for a restraining order. He and Shana would have had to live together or be married. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Finally, in April twenty twelve, a year after their first date, Ryan was able to severtise with Shana. Neither one of them was happy. Shana was angry that Ryan had said negative things about her to their friends. Ryan felt
13:45 smothered since Shana wouldn't leave him alone. At one point, Ryan texted Shana, I no longer have the patience to deal with you, and that was that it was over until it wasn't. In July two thousand and twelve. Barely three months later, Ryan and Shana rekindled their relationship, but this time their honeymoon period was even shorter than usual. Less than a month after they got back together, Ryan tried to escape Shannah's grasp once again. One night in August, Ryan showed up at his dad, Jay's house around twelve thirty am. He needed a place to stay because Shana once again refused to leave his condo. Jay, of course agreed. Throughout the night, Jay repeatedly heard Ryan's phone notifications going off. Shana was texting him NonStop. Although Shana struggled to let Ryan go, she wasn't feeling great about their relationship either.
14:41 After all, Ryan had been giving her the runaround for months, hot then cold, cold, then hot, over and over again. One time, Ryan physically threw Shana out of his condo without her purse, so she had to knock on a neighbor's door to call someone. Around this time, Shana sent a message to a friend of hers that was a dentist. It said, he's been begging me to ask you if you could do his veneers, but please f them up and make him ugly so he'll never get another girl, I hate him. But that next month, September twenty twelve, Ryan and Shana were on good terms again, ordering dinner together as couples do, but unsurprisingly, their relationships started to go south. Just days later, Ryan confided in his offices receptionist Laurie about his troubles with Shana. Ryan asked her, how do you break up with someone who doesn't want to break up with you. Laurie told him to break up with Shana for good, even if it meant calling the police. And Laurie wasn't the only one who gave Ryan this advice. Both his dad Jay and his stepdad Peter separately approached Ryan about leaving Shana. They knew that, despite being a fierce attorney, Ryan had a bad habit of avoiding confrontation in his personal life. They gave him their best advice. I tell her it's over as nicely as possible. Be direct, but a gentleman. And that's what Ryan wanted to do, or so he said, Because contrary to what Ryan kept telling everyone else, he continued
16:11 to engage with Shana. On October second, Ryan took Shana on a date to the shooting range. Ryan was an avid target shooter and his condo. He had multiple guns along with various bullets. Since he was a messy guy, the weapons and bullets were often strewn about his condo. Ryan also kept a loaded gun on his person at all times. On the day of the shooting range date, Shana was feeling unsure of her stormy relationship with Ryan. She texted a friend, writing, when I go to the shooting range with him tonight, I want to turn around, shoot and kill him and play like it's an accident. The friend replied, be careful, no accidents, and Shana responded, I'll try not to. She had a similar conversation with another friend. Later, the friends would clarify that this seemed like friendly banter, that she was just joking and Ryan wasn't sure of this stormy relationship either.
17:07 Around this time, he met up with a friend of his. During the get together, Ryan told the friend he intended to break up with Shana face to face soon. He told the friend that previously he had tried to end the relationship with subtle hints, but that had not worked. But then, on Thursday, October eleventh, Ryan invited Shana to watch the vice presidential debate with his family. If you're getting whiplash from Ryan's mixed signals, you're not alone. Shana's obsessive behavior is inexcusable, but Ryan couldn't seem to disentangle himself from her either. Even if Shana and Ryan were not officially together as boyfriend and girlfriend, Inviting your ex to a family gathering is not how you gain closure. On the evening of October eleventh, everything started off smoothly.
17:55 Shana, Ryan and Ryan's family ate dinner. They watched the political debate, and Ryan shared some fantastic news with everyone. For months, he had been embroiled in an ongoing civil lawsuit with his former law partner. That day they had finally settled. The entire ordeal had left Ryan extremely stressed, so this was a massive weight off his shoulders. His stepdad later said he was the happiest I had seen him in months, and his life was really on a roll right then. But as usual, Ryan and Shana ended the night with a fight. The two fought so loudly that neighbors said they often heard them fight through the walls, and this fight was huge. By the end of it, Shana seemed to understand that her relationship with Ryan was over, but when the dust settled, it was too late for Shana to drive over an hour to get home. She stayed the night on Ryan's couch. That night, she called her mother, Sharon, complaining that she didn't feel good.
18:55 Based on Shana's apparent symptoms, Sharon thought Shanah was having a stroke. Worried out of her mind, Sharon drove from Lexington to Ryan's condo and Highland Heights in the middle of the night. When she arrived, Sharon tried to convince Shana to go to the emergency room, but Shana wouldn't budge her symptoms had mysteriously vanished. Instead, Shana and Sharon napped on Ryan's couch until mid morning that day, Friday, October twelfth, Sharon helped Shanah get her belongings out of Ryan's condo. Meanwhile, Shana was texting Ryan a string of apology messages. She wrote, Ryan, I'm so sorry. I was emotional. Ryan had locked himself in the bedroom to avoid his now ex girlfriend, but Shana picked a lock with a bobby pin. It's not clear what happened when Shana opened the bedroom door. Shana claimed she des grabbed her purse and keys from the bedroom. Afterward, Shana and her mom went to a suburban Cincinnati mall called Kinwood Town Center. When they finished, Shana told her mom she would leave Ryan's and spend the night with a friend. So Sharon bought Shana gas, gave her some aspirin, and instructed her to call the emergency room if she felt sick again. Then Sharon left, she had a designa Ohio to visit some family. At this time, it was early evening, and despite what she told her mother, Shana didn't leave Ryan's condo. Meanwhile, at five forty pm, Ryan chatted with two other lawyers as he prepared to go
20:26 home and enjoy his weekend. All three attorneys had known each other for years. They said Ryan was his usual joyful self. During their chit chat, nothing seemed off. Ryan told them he had plans with friends later and headed out. Twenty minutes later, at six pm, Ryan spoke to his uncle on the phone. Ryan's uncle said he sounded happy and upbeat. His uncle said Ryan was so relieved that his lawsuit with his former partner was settled. Several hours passed, then, at eight fifty three pm, Shana called nine one one. She told the emergency despatcher, ma'am, I have killed my boyfriend in self defense. That statement would become a contentious battleground for the next six years. She was undoubtedly telling the truth about one thing. Twenty one year old Shana Michelle Hubers had killed thirty year old Ryan Carter, posting I'm going to pause now to her. A word from today's sponsors. This show is sponsored by Better Help. When I am at my best self, everything is easier, my to do list isn't overwhelming, my writing is more inspired.
21:40 When you're at your best, you can do great things, but sometimes life bogs you down. You aren't showing up like you want to. Therapy can help you get closer to the best version of you. It has helped me learn positive coping skills and how to set boundaries when I talk out my issues. It helps free me to be my self. If you're thinking of giving therapy a try, better Help is a great option. It's convenient, flexible, affordable, and entirely online. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch therapists at any time for no additional charge. If you want to live a more empowered life, therapy can get you there. Visit Betterhelp dot Com slash Southern today to get ten percent off your first month. That's Better Help Help dot Com slash Southern. We all love a good family mystery. You wouldn't be here if you didn't, and you will especially love one with as many twists and turns as June's Journey.
22:40 Play as June Parker and investigate beautifully detailed scenes set in the decadent Roaring twenties to solve her sister's murder. Whether you're a greenhorn detective or Sherlock is your middle name, new investigations await. With more than a thousand scenes full of hidden clues, there's always something new to discover. Chapters are added every week, so there's a new characters to meet and places to search. June's Journey has tons of fun and unique features to keep you entertained. Build your very owned island estate with expansive gardens and beautiful buildings. I've reached chapter two searching the estate's parlor, where I found a family portrait done just a few weeks before the murders. I love how easy it was to get started on this fun mystery, and it was so hard to put down, pick up where you left off to uncover new secrets, or start your investigation today and download June's Journey, available on Android and iOS mobile devices, as well as on PC through Facebook Games. That statement would become a contentious battleground for the next six years. She was undoubtedly telling the truth about one thing. Twenty one year old Shana Michelle Hubers had killed thirty year old Ryan Carter, posting I'm going to pause now to her a word from today's sponsors. Shana Michelle Bers was born on April eighth, nineteen ninety one, in Fayette, Kentucky, to her mother's Sharon and father Robert. Shana spent her childhood in Lexington, Kentucky, where her mother was an elementary school teacher. From a young age,
24:14 it was clear that Shana had a brilliant mind. Her childhood friends told CBS's forty eight Hours that she seemed like a genius. Shana was in her school's Gifted and Talented program and won many awards for academic leadership. She also developed a strong interest in fine arts. By her teen years, Shana considered herself a talented actress and musician, and in two thousand and eight, seventeen year old Shana was accepted into a prestigious course at the Kentucky Center Governor's School for her soprano singing voice. A year later, in two thousand and nine, Shana graduated from Paul Lawrence Dunbar High School. Following high school, Shana went to the University of Kentucky, where her spotless academic record continued. She received numerous scholarships for her vocal ability. In May two thousand twelve, after only three years, she graduated cum laude with a degree in psychology. As a student, Sena was immaculate as a person. Sena was messy. She talked about herself a lot, and she was known to take it really hard when her relationships didn't work out. Still, Sena seemed relatively normal. She had friends, a supportive family, and a clear career path. In August two thousand and twelve, Sena began working on her graduate degree in school counseling at Eastern Kentucky University. She was in her first semester of graduate school when she called nine one one on the night of Friday October twelfth, two thousand
25:45 twelve. When the despatcher asked why she killed her boyfriend in self defense. Sena said, he beat me and tried to carry me out of the house, and I came back in to get my things. He was right in front of me, and he reached down and grabbed the gun, and I grabbed it out of his hands and pulled the trigger. Senah told the despatcher that she had shot him twice, once in the face and once in the head. Then she shot him four additional times quote, just to kill him because he was twitching and I knew he was going to die anyway, and he was making funny noises. According to court documents, Sena said she wanted to make sure Ryan was dead because she knew he was going to die or have a completely deformed face. On this same phone call, Sena told the emergency worker that she had waited fifteen minutes before calling help. Instead of phoning nine one one, Sena had called her mom, who told Sena to hang up and call nine one one. The despatcher instructed Sheena to meet the officers at her front door with her hands held in front of her. About seven minutes later, the police arrived. They instructed Sena to lie on the ground, then they took her into custody. At the police station, the authorities pit Sena in a room under video surveillance. Within minutes, she requested to speak to an attorney. However, without any prompting from the police, she began to talk at length about killing Ryan. For almost three hours, Shana would speak to anyone and everyone who came into the room about Ryan's alleged abuse and her self defense. The videos show her trying to speak to one officer
27:21 who clearly wasn't questioning her. When she tried to talk to him, he brusquely explained, I'm just supposed to sit with you to get her to stop. During this recorded interview, Shana claimed that Ryan was evil, physically abusive to her, and addicted to prescription pills. That night, Shana said Ryan was so whacked out on drugs that his blue eyes turned black. According to Shana, right before she shot Ryan, he was throwing her around the room like a rag doll, against furniture, onto the floor, and into the television. After Ryan allegedly threw Shana around, he sat at the dining table and screamed insult sat her, saying he hated her and calling her derogatory names.
28:03 Shana told the authorities quote, he said, you're just a hillbilly from Kentucky, and I am. I guess the hillbilly came out in me and I took up for myself. Then, she said, Ryan reached across the table in a threatening manner. She said she couldn't tell if Ryan was trying to get to her or the gun sitting on the table, so in self defense, she grabbed the gun first and shot him six times. Ran let out a loud noise like an animal that freaked Shana out. She claimed she couldn't find her phone. Once she found it, she called her mom and then nine one one. Shana told one police officer, I don't want to go to prison. I don't think I deserved to. I didn't go over there intending to shoot Ryan. I went over there with the best of intentions.
28:51 I love you, let's work this relationship out. And he was screaming and hitting me. He resorted to violence, and most notably, Shane told the questioning officer that Ryan had wanted Rhinoplasti for a while. By shooting him in the face, Shana said she gave him, quote the nose job he always wanted. According to police Chief Bill Burkenhower. Each time Shana told the story, it evolved in her favor. Chief Berkenhauer told the Kentucky Inquirer she made numerous statements. She said the gun was in his hand. At one time, she said the gun was in the cabinet. Her final story was that she picked it up off the table When she spoke with a nine one one operator. Shana said that Ryan went down after she shot his head twice.
29:37 When she talked with the officers minutes later, she said Ryan was still coming towards her even after shooting him in the head twice. Chief Berkenhauer was also thrown by one startling detail of Shana's story. She released the safety on the gun before she shot Ryan. To Birkenhauer, that seemed like premeditation, not self defense. Investigator's suspicions increased, and Shana was not helping the situation. At one point, she pretended to cry in front of a detective. She gasped for air and contorted her face, but the exact second that he left the room, Shana's face returned to normal. Her emotional theatrics were not lost on the police officers watching the live video feed of Shana's holding room.
30:22 They were referred to her questioning as the Shana Huber's show because Shana's words felt so performative. While alone in the room, Shana did pirouettes, sang, snapped her fingers, and chanted, I did it, Yep, it was me. I killed him. Back at the crime scene, local authorities found Ryan's body on the dining room floor. His shirt was torn. They collected the murder weapon, which was Ryan's own thirty eight caliber handgun. According to Chief Barkenhauer, many elements of the crime scene did not match Shana's version of events. Shana said moments before she shot Ryan, he had thrown her in to the TV and a bookshelf, But the TV and Ryan's condo was fine.
31:03 In fact, it was dusty. Nothing had touched this TV in a long time. The bookshelf Ran had allegedly thrown Shana into was also undamaged. All of the knickknacks on it were perfectly in place. Photographs taken at the station showed that Shana had light bruising on her shin, but almost no visible bruising anywhere else, and all of the items on the dining room table were completely undisturbed. This was strange since Shana said a mad scramble for Ryan's handgun happened at this exact table. Items like prescription pill bottles and bullets which tip over easily were still sitting upright. Investigators believed that, based on their seating arrangement, Ryan's arms should have knocked the pill bottles and standing bullets over when he reached for the gun. The detectives found there was no sign of a struggle in Ryan's condo, with the position of Ryan's body, the oval dining room table, and the door. The police officers also noted that Sena shot Ryan with the unlock door directly behind her. If Ryan had been verbally and physically attacking her, there was nothing obstructing her ability to leave, and on the gun was a trace of Ryan's blood, which meant at least one shot happened very close to Ryan's body, closer than shooting him across the dining room table. The authorities speculated that Sena probably moved towards Ryan for the final kill shots. Based on the autopsy, experts determined that it was likely that Sena
32:34 shot Ryan three times while he was sitting, then she shot him three more times. After he fell to the floor, she shot him once in his forehead, once in the back of his head, once in the back, once under his arm, and twice in the chest. Two of the shots caused major damage to Ryan's aorda. Ultimately, he died of blood loss. Ryan was probably alive for all six gunshot wounds. When interviewing Ryan's condo neighbors, the police spoke to Vernon and Doris West. The older couple lived in the condo directly below Ryan's for about a year and a half, during which they didn't hear much noise from his condo. But on the night of the murder at eight forty five p m. Minutes before Ryan was shot, Doris said she heard a woman crying on Ryan's back deck. Then Doris heard the chair on the deck scooting back. Seconds later she heard two gunshots, and a few seconds after that she heard four more gunshots. At some point during the gunshots, Doris also heard a thump, as if some one had fallen.
33:38 Vernon heard the same. They both reported there was no screaming, thumping, or loud noises before the gun fire. If Ryan had been throwing shena around, neither Doris nor Vernon had heard it. The night before the murder, Doris heard a female crying on Ryan's back porch. She heard a male voice say it's okay, It's okay. Based on the evidence, this was probably Ryan consoling Shana after their breakup. Things weren't looking good for Shana, but investigators were still missing something motive. Why had Shana shot Ryan? If it wasn't in self defense, which was looking less and less likely, then why after eighteen months of the same emotional roller coaster of a relationship, what had pushed Shana from obsession to murder? The answer was simple. On the night that Shana killed Ryan, he had planned a date with none other than twenty three year old Audrey Bolt, otherwise known as Miss Ohio USA two twelve.
34:37 Born in Batavia, Ohio, Audrey won her very first beauty pageant and was crowned Miss Batavia in two thousand and twelve. Then she won Miss Ohio USA two thousand and twelve, receiving over fifty thousand dollars in scholarship awards. In the spring of two twelve, about six months before Ryan's murder, Audrey was named second runner up for the Miss us A title not bad for a young woman so new to the pageant circuit. Similar to Shana and Ryan, Audrey had also met Ryan on Facebook on January twenty seventh, two twelve. They became Facebook friends, but it wasn't until October twenty twelve that Audrey and Ryan began interacting. According to Audrey, at all started when Ryan left a funny and interesting comment on one of her posts she was asking for movie reviews.
35:27 This turned into Audrey and Ryan chatting through Facebook messages. Her first impression of Ryan was that he was witty and clever. She liked that their conversations were light hearted with lots of fun banter. After a few Facebook messages, Ryan and Audrey exchanged phone numbers and began texting. On October twelfth, twenty twelve, Audrey and Ryan planned to go to a low key dive bar to grab drinks and play pool. They originally planned to meet at nine pm, but Audrey pushed back the time to ten thirty due to a family funeral. In their text conversation, Ryan asked Audrey if he should change out of his suit and tie, and she said yes. A few media outlets speculated that Ryan's need to change clothes might have been the only reason he returned to his condo that evening. He never showed up to the date with Audrey. When investigators asked if Shana knew about Ryan's interest in Audrey Bolt, she said no, she had never heard of Audrey, but this was a lie. Shana had a bad habit of hacking into Ryan's Facebook account to see what he was up to, and two days after Ryan and Audrey had become Facebook friends, on January twenty ninth, two thousand twelve, Shana searched for Audrey's name on Facebook. Shana searched Audrey's name again in June two thousand twelve, and on October tenth, two thousand twelve, two days before killing Ryan, Sena saved a photo of Audrey to her phone. Investigators believed that Ryan told Sena about
36:57 his date with Audrey, which was what motived her to kill Ryan that night. The police arrested Shana for murder the next day, Saturday, October thirteenth, twenty twelve, Ryan's father, Jay, received a voicemail while riding his bike. It said, mister Poston, we have a body here which we think may be a member of your family. Three minutes later, Ryan's mother called Jay. At that moment, Jay knew his son was dead. He told the Cincinnati Enquirer, literally, in the blink of an eye, everything that you have known in your life is forever gone, just destroyed. Weeks after Shana shot Ryan, Jay went to Ryan's condo. He lay down in Ryan's blood and screamed. Then he scrubbed his son's blood off the walls and floor. Jay kept Ryan's dog, a Maltese Yorkie mix named Oliver. He told the Cincinnati Enquirer, I see the spirit of Ryan and this little dog.
38:00 When describing how Ryan's death impacted his life, Jay said he struggled to be happy. Part of that is guilt, He explained. If you start getting better, if you are happy, you were doing a disservice to your child. I do know that's not true, but it's still there eating at you. Bryan's family was aware that Ryan had been trying to remove Shana from his life, but was scared of hurting her feelings, and one statement, the family said he was trying to move on with his life. Tragically, his life was taken from him. In another statement, they said, our only solace is an unwavering confidence. In our legal system and our strong belief that justice shall be served. After Sena was arrested, she was held at the Campbell County Detention Center in Newport. Her bond was set at a steep two million. She couldn't make Bell, so Shena remained in jail until her trial, which happened three years later. I'm going to pause now for a final word from today's sponsors. Did you know that property crimes like burglaries and package thefts spike over the winter. That's why now is the best time to secure your home with award winning home security Simply Safe as the home security system I recommend to everybody. I just moved to the country after living my whole life in the city. I love the quiet, but it also spooks this city girl. But Simply Safe gives me incredible peace of mind right in the
39:31 palm of my hand. With the top rated Simply Safe app, stay in complete control of your system anytime anywhere, arm or disarm, unlock for a guest, access your cameras, or adjust system settings. Simply Safe as whole home security with advanced censors for every room, window and door, and HD security cameras for inside and out and their twenty four seven professional monitoring service costs under one dollar a day. Customize the perfect system for your home in just a few minutes at simply safe dot com slash Southern Fried. Go today and claim a free indoor security camera plus twenty percent off your order with interactive monitoring. That's simply safe dot com slash Southern Fried. There's no safe like simply Safe. I am the worst about canceling subscriptions. I've kept newspaper subscriptions for small towns I've researched for years after the episode came out. It was for episodes that I could not access the sources without the subscription, and then I would just keep forgetting to cancel or keep putting it off. And that's why I love using rocket Money formally known as true Bill. The app shows all of your subscriptions in one place and then cancels for you whatever you don't still want. Rocket Money can even find subscriptions you didn't know you were still paying for. You may even find out you've been double charged for a subscription.
40:52 To cancel a subscription, all you have to do is press cancel and rocket money takes care of the rest. Get rid of useless subscriptions with rocket money now go to rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. Seriously, it could save you hundreds per year. That's rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. Cancel your unnecessary subscriptions right now at rocketmoney dot com slash Southern Fried. On April thirteenth, twenty fifteen, Shana's trial began. From the beginning, Shana maintained that she fatally shot Ryan. The only question for the jury to determine was why. In the three years before Shanah's trial, this case received extensive media coverage a beautiful young woman had killed her beautiful ex boyfriend. In response to the increased media attention, the presiding judge only allowed one TV camera inside the courtroom.
41:47 All live coverage, including social media posts, was banned. Still, reporters from national news outlets including ABC, CBS, and NBC took notes in the courtroom during the trial. The prosecution argued that Shanah did not kill Ryan in self defense, but in cold blood. According to the state, Shana went into a jealous rage after discovering that Ryan had planned a date with a new woman just a day after their latest break up. As evidence, the prosecution relied heavily on Shanah's own words. They played Shana's nine one one phone call, where her original story was vastly different from what she would tell the authorities later. Then they showed Shanah's recorded police interview, which was, as you know, incredibly damning. On one occasion, when the officers walked out of the room, Shana said to herself, I'm so good at acting.
42:44 And they brought three of Shanah's fellow inmates to the stand, Holly Nivens, Donna Dooley, and Cecily Miller. Since Shana had been in jail for so long, she had gotten quite comfortable discussing her crime with these women. At first, Shanah told Hall that Ryan had abused her physically and sexually, but after some time, Shana revealed to Holly that she, not Ryan, was the aggressor. Shana would regularly throw stuff around Ryan's condo to try and convince his neighbors they were fighting. She gave herself bruises on her arms and showed them to people, claiming that Ryan assaulted her. One time, Shana drew a diagram of Ryan's dining room on the back of a napkin. So she could better explain to Holly how she had killed Ryan. Shana also explained to Holly her plan to get diagnosed with a mental disorder so she could convince the court she was crazy. In the same vein, Shana told Cecily that she was going to plead insanity, but she was too smart because she had the IQ of Einstein, so she was going to plead bettered wife's syndrome. Previously, Shana underwent a psychological evaluation to make sure she was fit to stand trial.
43:57 She scored an IQ of one twenty five, which is in the ninety fifth percentile. This might have been what Shena was referring to when she told Cecily she had the IQ of Einstein and if you're wondering, I'll save you the Google. Einstein's i Q was over one sixty during that psycho vow. The psychologist also diagnosed Shena with symptoms of being a narcissist. The psychologist remarked that Sena didn't understand that others didn't find her accomplishments and achievements as interesting as she did. Shena's additional diagnoses included PTSD personality disorder, and bipolar disorder. At the trial, the psychologist agreed that these ailments did not excuse Shena from murder. And last, but not least, Donna told the court exactly how the murder played out. She testified that Sena told me they were sitting at the kitchen table. He was sitting at the table and he had his gun on the table. She told me. She picked up the gun and said, what would you do fi, and he smirked, and she shot him.
45:00 All three women explained that Senah killed Ryan because he was breaking up with her and going on a date with a new woman, and all three women said that Sna expressed no remorse for her actions. Instead, Sena was known to laugh when describing the murder, and when Sena was on the phone in the jail, she would pretend to cry while simultaneously smiling and winking at her fellow inmates. Keep in mind, sometimes testimony from a defendant's fellow inmate is questionable. Usually they have received some sort of deal, like getting a lighter sentence in exchange for throwing someone under the bus. They might be motivated to lie so they can get out of prison faster. But Donna, Holly, and Cecily received nothing in return for their testimony against Sena Hubers. In preparation for the trial, relevant officials reviewed over fifty thousand text messages and twenty thousand Facebook messages between Ryan and Sana the prosecution and used them to show that Shana was angry with Ryan. Near the time of the murder. Shana texted a friend quote, my love for him has turned into hate. She texted another person, he's such a loser. Another message said, he says he's only with me because he feels so awful when he breaks up with me. And of course, don't forget the text exchange we've already covered when she threatened to kill him accidentally at a shooting range in a tragic case of irony. Shana's text messages also revealed that she was seeing multiple other men without Ryan's knowledge.
46:36 She wrote to a friend quote, it's going to be hard one day to choose between him and Ryan. One means the future and one means being with someone I love who doesn't love me as much. She also texted the friend, I'm in love with this other guy. A month before she killed Ryan, she texted a friend about getting an STD and wrote who knows who I got it from, right. Sena, who became murderous at the news that Ryan was seeing other people, was seeing other people herself. Its almost Shakespearian. In response, Sheena's defense team maintained that she acted in self defense. They admitted that Senna's behavior towards Ryan was obsessive, but claimed that did not make her a murderer. Most of their arguments were predicated on smearing Ryan's reputation.
47:24 According to the Cincinnati Enquirer, they argued that he was a gun nut whose career was falling apart. They claimed that Ryan was enduring the pressure of his career, an ongoing lawsuit with his former law partner, and had a prescription pill problem. As a result of this immense personal and professional stress, Ryan snapped and attacked Sena. Since Ryan was a tall man at six three and Senna was only five four, she was forced to shoot him in self defense. The defense used text messages from Ryan to depict him as a troubled, violent man. For example, Ryan wrote to a friend, my brain has a trip wire in there somewhere, and if it snaps, I worry what could happen? He texted someone else, I'm starting to feel like life passed by me while I was making brilliant plans for it. Other text messages indicated that Ryan might have had a problem overusing prescription pills, but the court didn't allow most of these messages to be submitted as evidence. Ryan sent them seven months before his death, so there was reason to believe that Ryan had stopped abusing prescription pills. Shana's defense explained that Shana and Ryan had not broken up. They were still boyfriend and girlfriend. They pointed out that Shana still had toiletries at Ryan's condo. However, by Shana's own admission, her mom was helping her get her stuff out of Ryan's condo on the day of the murder, and one of the last text messages Ryan sent to Shana read, I think I need some time by myself this weekend. Still, the defense
48:59 tried to establi that Ryan and Shana were a couple so that they could claim that Shana lived in Ryan's condo. You see, if Shana lived in the condo, she might have been protected under Kentucky's stand your ground law. This law states that you can use deadly force and self defense in your own home even if you have the opportunity to escape danger by exiting your home, which we know Shana did since she was near the front door, you don't have to. Instead, you can stand your ground and hurt someone who seeks to harm you. But Shana and Ryan were not living together. In Shana's video recorded police interview, they asked if they were, and she clearly said no.
49:40 When they asked what Shana's address was, she provided a different address from Ryan's condo. Shana's trial lasted nine days. Although she didn't take the stand, the jury heard over forty other witness testimonies. They reviewed over one hundred pieces of evidence, and on April twenty third, twenty fifteen, they left the court room to deliberate. Everyone was left to wonder would Shana be allowed to walk free. After deliberating for five hours, the jury convicted twenty three year old Shannah Hubers of murdering Ryan Poston three years earlier. Everyone was in agreement Shana had not killed Ryan in self defense. Later, a juror explained that the entire jury had immediately agreed on Shanah's guilt. They spent the majority of their five hours deciding what sentence to suggest for her. Even the judge said, I never heard a word or saw a look from her that said I'm sorry. As far as Shannah's sentence goes, the prosecution was seeking prison for life, which Ryan's family supported. One of his sisters testified, when you never get to say bye to someone and you know they were in so much pain, your heart is breaking, your heart actually feels like it's crumbling in your chest, your heart feels empty. I never got to say goodbye to my brother. I never got to hug my brother one last time.
51:02 He made us complete, and without him, there is always the chair that's going to be empty. There is no amount of time that will take away what was taken from us. Ultimately, the jury recommended that Shanaby sentenced to forty years in prison. She would be eligible for parole in twenty years, when she would be just forty three years old. Afterward, Ryan's family expressed their disappointment. Her mother said a forty year sentence was a shallow victory. Ryan's stepfather said, it's very bitter sweet. We have gotten justice. Ryan loved the law, and this is what the law has given us. We'll take that. It's okay, And that seemed like the end of that things were bitter sweet, but okay. The legal system delivered as much justice as it could, and Shana went to prison. But in January two thousand and sixteen months after her conviction, Shana sought a retrial, and in a rare occurrence, she got it. When looking over Shane's A Pill documents, Dina Denison, one of Shanah's lawyers, realized that she recognized a juror from Shanah's trial jurn Number four eighty three, a fifty three year old man named David Craig. Dinah had represented him in November nineteen ninety two, when David had not paid over eight thousand dollars in child support. He pled guilty to the crime, which was a low level felony in Kentucky, and in Kentucky, convicted felons cannot serve on juries. Suddenly, the nation was in an uproar.
52:37 Was Shana going to escape any more prison time on a technicality? How could this happen? As it turned out, David Craig, the one person who shouldn't be serving on a jury, was thrilled about jury duty. When he received his summons, he was beside himself. He told the Cincinnati Enquirer. I was so proud I got to serve on a jury, to serve my community. I think I'm the first one of my family to ever serve on a jury. By his own admission, David writes at about a third grade level, so his longtime girlfriend helped him fill out the acquired juror questionnaire. When they came to the question are you a convicted felon, they simply checked the no box instead of the yes one. According to David, he had no idea he was a convicted felon. He had almost forgotten about the child support snaphew from over twenty years before. Later, David told court officials that he didn't believe he was a felon. David explained that felon's go to prison. He was just behind on child support payments. David told the Cincinnati Inquirer, I wonder, will twenty deputies come here to arrest me? If forgetting us wrong, then lock me up? I guess. Lucky for David, they did not lock him up. No perjury charges were pressed, so on August twenty fifth, twenty sixteen, the Campbell's Circuit Court awarded sham Huber's a new trial Ryan's family was devastated. A new trial meant a new opportunity
54:07 for Shana to escape justice. Ryan's father said that his son's murder was a wound that just wouldn't heal. Then Shanah's retrial was delayed for two years. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. Shana hired a new out of state lawyer who needed extra time to research the case. Finally, on August eighth, twenty eighteen, now twenty seven year old Shana Michelle Huber's second trial for the murder of Ryan Carter Poston began. It was almost six years after his death. This time, Shana did testify in her own defense.
54:49 It did not go well. She admitted to showing possessive and controlling behaviors in her relationship with Ryan. She agreed that when Ryan tried to end things, she would flood him with tech messages even though he did not respond. Sometimes she would contact him from a different phone because she knew that he wouldn't respond if he recognized the number. When Shana had the opportunity, she searched Ryan's phone for evidence of cheating and blocked other women through Ryan's Facebook account. During one breakup, Shana faked a heart condition to gain Ryan's sympathy. The prosecution suggested that the stroke like symptoms Shana displayed on October eleventh were probably another false attempt to earn Ryan's attention. Shana's main defense strategy rested on revealing every sort of detail of her in Ryan's sex life. She claimed that Ryan was frustrated that she couldn't achieve orgasm easily. In response, Ryan abused her or threatened to abuse her. For the most part, the prosecution presented largely the same case, Shana killed Ryan Enna. If I can't have him, no one can fit. However, the prosecution did bring a new witness to the table. On the day of Ryan's murder, Shana and her mother went to a nearby mall. One of the shop workers testified. They said that Shannah came into their store visibly angry. She was upset because her boyfriend was going on a date with another woman. According to this shop worker, Shana said she was going to kill her boyfriend. Originally, the shop worker didn't call
56:22 the police, but when the media coverage of Shanah gained speed, including a two part CBS forty eight Hours special, they recognized Shana. On August twenty ninth, twenty eighteen, after three and a half hours of deliberation, the jury convicted Shana of murder. This time, they recommended that Shana receive a life sentence, and in October twenty eighteen, she did. She still will be eligible for parole in twenty thirty two. She will be only forty one years old if she gets out. Shana's mother, Sharon, still maintains that her daughter shot Ryan in self defense. She told CBS forty eight Hours she has a heart of gold. She's like her mommy, a loving spirit.
57:06 Ryan's elementary school started a memorial scholarship in his name. By two fifteen, the donation based award was ever one hundred thousand dollars. According to the Kentucky Inquirer, it's given to a sixth grader who demonstrates kindness, compassion, and caring for others. North Kentucky University also started a memorial scholarship in Ryan's name. On the anniversary of Ryan's death, his family and friends gathered at his grave site. They prayed, shared memories, and took shots of Ryan's favorite Woodford Reserve bourbon. There is a reason I chose Ryan's story to tell, not just because Shana was a female stalker, but also her false accusations about Ryan. Shana Hubers made a false claim of domestic abuse. This is rare.
57:55 Only three percent of domestic violence allegations are false, meaning ninety seven percent of them are true. When a woman says her partner abuses her, it is statistically in your favor to believe her. False allegations of domestic violence happen more often when the woman, not the man, is the abuser. According to George Mason University, seventy three percent of men who experienced female perpetrated violence reported that the woman threatened to make false accusations. The female abusers use false accusations as a tool to manipulate control and maintain power over their victims. Any demographic of people will have liars, men and women. Some people want to save their skin no matter the cost. And every time people make false claims of abuse, they negatively impact society's perception of actual domestic violence victims. And the other issue in this case is that Ryan did not comfortable reporting Shanea's stalking.
59:01 He wasn't perfect. It was definitely a toxic relationship, but He also felt he should be able to handle it himself. Even his poor father had that thought. Men often don't report stalking or abuse because of ingrained feelings of masculinity. They think they should be able to handle it. As men, they are raised to believe they can handle their own problems, especially when it comes to relationships. It isn't manly to ask for help. We need to advocate more for men as a society. We need to normalize the reality that men are also abused, They are also stalked, and as in Ryan's case, it can be deadly. Ryan was raised by two lovely, thoughtful men.
59:49 Even though they could see how toxic the relationship was, they trusted their son to be able to resolve it on his own safely. Ryan was smart and successful. He was a lawyer. He was handsome and had no self esteem issues. He knew Shana was bad news and should not be in his life, but he was more worried about hurting her, and he could not see the danger he was in until it was too late. Southern frid True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank. And all editorial opinions are my own. Southern Frid's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Colly Horner. Thank you to listener Amanda for suggesting today's episode. It is an important topic that isn't discussed enough, and yes, ma'am and Dolly, we do trust. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases he'll always send me. Please remember I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fred True Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time in our lovely group. We do, of course
1:01:20 discuss true crime, not just Southern Fried, but all kinds, but it is still very much a Southern lifestyle group. Our group is a safe and fun corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shitass is allowed. It's not just a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like a heart, Stitcher, Spotify, and now Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. Y'all, Take care,
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed