170: Blue Eyed Butcher: The Controversial Murder of Jeff Wright
In January 2003, police arrived at an unassuming house in Northwest Houston, Texas after receiving a vague message from a local lawyer about a potential crime scene. In the backyard, they discovered the mutilated body of Jeff Wright. The master...
Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Andrea Marshbank
Additional Writing by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Erica Kelley
Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/blue-eyed-butcher-the-controversial-murder-of-jeff-wright
- US National Domestic Violence Hotline: 800-799-7233
- National Domestic Violence Hotline: thehotline.org
- Canada: visit this website to find the hotline in your area
- UK Domestic Abuse Hotline: 0808 2000 247
- For resources in other countries, visit this website
- This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp online therapy. Go to BetterHelp.com/southern.
- Every holiday, we are sponsored by the amazing gift for loved ones, StoryWorth. Go to StoryWorth.com/southern to save $10 off your first purchase.
- Also for a unique gift this holiday season, so to Highland Titles.com and use code “CRIME”
- Today’s show is also brought to you by Bare Necessities, he biggest online intimate apparel retailer. Go to BareNecessities.com code: sftc20 for 20% off your first order.
This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement
0:00 Southern Fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. On a Saturday in January of two thousand three, Neil Davis was trying to enjoy his weekend. He was a young criminal defense attorney who had recently secured a job at an impressive Texas law firm. His new firm represented a laundry list of high profile clients like American cult leader David Koresh, but so far, Davis hadn't had a chance to test his medal on a high profile case of his own. Little did Davis know that was about to change. He received a cryptic call from his firm that he needed a head over to northwest Houston.
0:49 There was a situation with a client's daughter. It was urgent, a matter of life and death. Saying about at his week end, Davis copied down an address. By mid afternoon, he arrived at the small suburban home of Jeff and Susan Wright. It looked like a normal house. It was small, with a small lawn and a wooden privacy fence. The woman who answered the door also looked normal. If a little teary eyed. After some conversation, the woman led Davis through the house and opened the door to the back yard. Again normal, a dog, grass, some tools lying around, but after a moment's pause, Davis saw it an arm sticking out of a plot of recently disturbed dirt. Welcome to episode one seventy, The Blue Eyed Butcher, The controversial murder of Jeff Wright. Jeffrey Andrew Wright was born on March first, nineteen sixty eight, in Kenosha, Wisconsin, to his mother Kay and his father, Ronald Senior. Jeff had a sister and a brother. We don't know much about his childhood or upbringing, but as an adult, Jeff's friends described him as a happy, go lucky guy with a congenial, backslapping personality. He was a Christian who attended church regularly, but Jeff didn't follow the straight narrow path strictly. Actually, Jeff's friends described him
2:24 as a hardcore party animal. His friend Paul Collin said, when Jeff and I would party, anything went. I mean drugs, alcohol, partying for days at a time, no sleep. It was just completely out of control. But Jeff didn't just do drugs. He also sold, distributed and muled illegal drugs across the country. In nineteen ninety six, twenty eight year old Jeff was called smuggling a large amount of marijuana from Mexico to the US. He was held in jail and Mexico until his then girlfriend Misty McMichael drug of hours from Central Texas to the Mexican border and paid his twenty five hundred dollar bill. Misty later claimed Jeff never paid her back. But the next year, in nineteen ninety seven, everything changed for Jeff. While lounging on a beach in Galveston, Texas, Jeff met an attractive woman named Susan Wike.
3:21 She was a twenty year old Houston waitress on vacation with her friends. Jeff was a twenty nine year old carpet and flooring salesman. Immediately, Jeff knew he had found something special in Susan. In an interview, Jeff's friend Paul said, He'd told me he found the girl who was going to be the one. This was the one he was going to marry, This would be the mother of his kids. He was ecstatic. Susan Lucille Wike was born on April twenty fourth, nineteen seventy six to her mother Sue and her father, Jimmy. She had a twin brother and an older sister named Cindy. They were raised in an up her middle class home in the Champions area of northwest Harris County in Houston, Texas. Susan was a Texas woman born and raised. She spent her entire life within or nearby Houston. Susan's mother was a stay at home mom who loved to bake. Her father was a wealthy mechanical engineer with a bad temper, but it's debatable just how bad his temper was. In twenty ten, Susan's sister, Cindy, gave an interview with Texas Monthly. At the time of the interview, Cindy was an assistant professor of psychology at the University of Houston Downtown. In the interview, Cindy explained that their father would regularly beat their mother. According to Cindy, she and her siblings were taught that it was perfectly acceptable for husbands to yell at,
4:51 belittle, and rape their wives. As a child, Cindy didn't realize other people's father's didn't attack their mothers. She also said that sometimes their father would hit her. Susan and their brother too. Both of the white parents have consistently denied these domestic violence allegations, and later in court, Susan didn't use this to defend herself. She said she didn't want to embarrass her family. However, Susan agreed with Cindy's account of their traumatic childhood. Susan's friends and family described her as timid and quick to cry when other students were mean to Susan at school, she would never stand up for herself. One time, she tried out for the high school drill team. During tryouts, an older girl made a rude comment to her, and Susan was so upset that she transferred schools. In class, Susan was a C student. Outside of class, she had an active social life and dated boys regularly. She told Texas Monthly that she craved the attention that young men gave her in her teen years, and for Susan, young men were an abundant supply. By all accounts, she was a pretty woman, but Susan lacked self confidence, so she was susceptible to criticism, no matter how dumb it was. Once a boyfriend insulted Susan's weight despite how slender she was, so she went on a crash
6:24 diet and lost nineteen pounds in a matter of weeks. Shortly after high school, Susan moved out of her family's home. She didn't seem to have a clear path forward, yet, she worked at a harri salon while taking classes at the local junior college. When she turned eighteen, she became a topless dancer at the Gold Cup strip club in Houston. Susan's family was baffled by her choice of a job. Susan had always aspired to be a stereotypical, prim and proper young lady, the kind of woman who would apologize for saying crap as a curseword. But Susan told Texas Monthly that she started stripping mostly because her then boyfriend encouraged her too. She didn't dance at the Gold Cup for long, only working for two months and only on Saturdays. After that, she stayed on as a waitress for a while. In less than two years, Susan had left the Gold Cup entirely and was waitressing for a different restaurant. That's when she met Jeff Wright, the cute and successful salesman on her vacation to a beach in Galveston. As soon as Jeff met Susan, he began showering her with attention. He called her two or three times a day. He brought her flowers and gifts. He took her to fancy nightclubs.
7:46 Basically, Jeff was trying to sweep Susan off her feet, and Susan was thoroughly swept. Today we would call this love bombing. The clinical definition of love bombing has been around since the seventies, but it wasn't a part of the larger discussion on relationships that we have to day. Susan thought Jeff was charming, and she appreciated that he had traditional values. He wanted a stay at home wife, kids, a house, and a dog. Susan wanted that life too. When Jeff told her he wanted to open his own carpet and flooring business some day, Susan thought Jeff showed ambition. Plus, Susan thought Jeff was handsome. He was six foot two, fit, and, in Susan's words, had beautiful brown eyes. Jeff also thought Susan was gorgeous. She had blonde hair, blue eyes, and was petite. Susan barely reached Jeff's shoulder, since she was five foot three inches tall, almost a foot shorter than he was. They matched in that classical opposite kind of way. He was dark with boyish, impish dimples. She was fair with a beauty queen's wide, perfect smile. Jeff told his friends that Susan saved his life. Before he met her, he was drinking and partying way too much. But now that he had Susan, Jeff wanted to be home with her and start a family. It seemed like that's what Susan wanted to She
9:20 described her relationship with Jeff as a fairy tale. Susan and Jeff's friends could see how enamored they were with each other, and an interview with Snapped. Jeff's friend Mary Brow said, they did look adoringly at each other. They hugged, they were affectionate, they held hands. I thought it was a very good relationship, but fairy tales can be deceiving. In February of nineteen ninety eight, Susan became unexpectedly pregnant. The couple had only been dating less than a year. She and Jeff discussed having an abortion, which Jeff was okay with but ultimately they decided to keep the baby. But Jeff's friends weren't sure he was ready to be a dad yet, after all, he had only just stopped his intense party lifestyle when he had met Susan. But also, according to his friends, Jeff was determined to do the right thing by marrying Susan, but it took him a while to decide. Susan said, when she was eight months pregnant, he handed her an engagement ringing while they were in his truck and asked her to marry him. So shortly after, on October tenth of nineteen ninety eight, Susan and Jeff were married in a small church ceremony. Their wedding reception was held at the local outback steakhouse.
10:41 It wasn't their dream wedding, but it was the best they could afford. And even if people won't say it, not all couples want the big wedding with the fancy dress. When the bride is that pregnant, this would be more of a shotgun wedding. On November fourteenth, Susan gave birth to a boy who will call gus. In April of nineteen ninety nine, the Right family moved into a small but nice house in the White Oak Bend subdivision in northwest Harris County. Two years later, Susan gave birth to their second child, a daughter we will call Kara. Jeff's friends said he was incredibly proud of his wife and two children, and, according to Susan's best friend, Jamie, Susan should have been living her dream. She loved being a homemaker, taking care of the kids and having dinner on the table every evening.
11:33 Jamie said she was always giving me cleaning tips and cooking tips, and how to get the baseboards clean, and how to whip up this great three course meal in twenty minutes. She managed to do it all. It's true, Susan did trove very hard to be the picture perfect wife and mother. Although Susan was the primary caretaker for her and Jeff's children, she also worked part time at an orthodonist office. She wanted to become a nurse and was trying to earn enough money to pay for her nursing school tuition, but Jeff controlled all of their finances. At his request, Susan gave him her paychecks. In return, Jeff would give Susan a weekly allowance of seventy five dollars to raise the kids and buy the family groceries. Seventy five dollars in nineteen ninety eight is one hundred and forty dollars today. Maybe enough to pay for a family of four's groceries, but just barely, certainly not enough for Susan to save money for nursing school. Money was always a tough topic for Jeff and Susan. In the fall of two thousand and two, Susan said Jeff wasn't making it. Susan said Jeff wasn't making as much money as he had been for unknown reasons. Jeff had to get a new, lower paying job, and Jeff was struggling with his drug addictions. Again. I'm going to pause now for a short commercial break. Susan claimed that Jeff came home drunk,
13:07 often smoked pot daily, and occasionally used harder drugs like cocaine. Ron Wright, Jeff's father, confirmed that Jeff had a drug problem during this time, but according to Ron it wasn't a big deal. He said Jeff was good at keeping his drug habit under control, but a habit is a habit, and this was Jeff's dad, talking Ron also said that Susan was incorrect about her family's finances. From Ron's perspective, Jeff was quote making good money and in fact was planning on building a new house and at the time shopping for a new car for her. A friend of Jeff's also believed that the right family was financially fine. He told Snapped, I wouldn't say they were rich.
13:52 Jeff had a pretty decent truck, Susan had a nice car. But these are outside appearances, and a cocaine habit is expensive. So even if someone is making good money and seems financially stable, they still could have been struggling. And despite what others thought the marriage looked like from the outside, Susan was unhappy with how things were, and in two thousand three, their marriage of five years was falling apart. On Monday, January thirteenth, two thousand three, Susan called her mother in law Kay. She was extremely upset. She told Kay that Jeff had come home from his boxing class high on cocaine. He had, according to Susan, punched their four year old Gusts in the face. Outraged that Jeff had hit their son, Susan said she snapped at Jeff, which started a heated argument. She said she kicked him out of the house and he left on foot. She said that Jeff's parting words were, fucked this house, I'm tired of you and the kids.
14:58 Kay was caught off guard. Her son had called her several hours earlier on his way home from the boxing class. To Kay, he had seemed fine. Susan also called her best friend Jamie. She explained to Jamie that she and Jeff had had a terrible fight. Once more, Susan reiterated that Jeff had stormed off in a fit of anger. Concerned for her friend, Jamie urged Susan to call the authorities and make a report about Jeff hitting gus, but at this time Susan didn't. On Tuesday, January fourteenth, Susan went to her doctor, Stephen Fisher. She was covered in bruises and cuts, which Susan said happened when Jeff had attacked her during their argument the day before.
15:46 Susan hadn't told her mother in law, Kay or her best friend Jamie that Jeff was violent toward her that night. She had only mentioned Jeff punching Gus. At doctor Fisher's urging, Susan made plans to get a restraining order against Jeff the next day. Two days after Jeff left, on Wednesday, January fifteenth, Susan entered the Harris County Police station. She spoke to a deputy, telling him about Jeff's drug usage, that he hit their son, Guss, and had attacked her. She explained that when she fussed Jeff for hitting Gus, he lashed out. He grabbed Susan by the wrists, twisted her face to the wall, and repeatedly slammed her into the walls while screaming at her. The cuts on Susan's hands happened because Jeff was holding his keys when he grabbed her, As Susan had told several others, after Jeff had hurt her, he walked out of the home and had not returned this.
16:45 Deputy Officer Scott Hall believed Susan's account without question. He took pictures of the cuts on her hands for evidence and put out an arrest warrant for Jeff Wright. Officer Hall said in interviews, Susan appeared to be a victim of domestic violence. That's what I perceived at the time, she was very tearful, crying a lot, acted extremely afraid of Jeff returning home. Indeed, every time Susan spoke to a person about Jeff's violence, she appeared very concerned that he would return and harm her. When the authorities called Susan on Friday, January seventeenth to ask if Susan had figured out where Jeff was, she claimed she still had no idea, but she could tell the police that she feared Jeff would come back to the house to hurt her. Susan's close family members said during this time after Jeff disappeared, Susan was withdrawn and panicked. She had also told them that she was terrified Jeff would return and hurt her.
17:47 It had been four days since anyone had laid eyes on Jeff Wright. People were starting to get worried. Jeff's friends said his cell phone went straight to voicemail. Ron Wright, his dad, said he became anxious about Jeff's disappearance when Jeff didn't call on his wedding anniversary. Jeff always remembered to call on important dates, and Ron also wondered why was jeff truck still in the driveway even if Jeff intended to leave his wife and kids, wouldn't he have taken his truck. Meanwhile, Susan continued to tell people that Jeff had walked out on her and the kids, but her story changed a little over time.
18:29 At first, Susan told her mother in law and friend that Jeff had only struck gus Later, Susan told the doctor and the police that Jeff slammed her into the wall. Susan also told the police that Jeff had cut her hands with his car keys, but she told others that Jeff had scratched her with his nails. But no matter who Susan spoke to, she repeated over and over again that she was scared Jeff was going to come home and hurt her. To some people, Susan said, Jeff did return home, but she wasn't present at the time, and her absence, Jeff had allegedly ransacked the house, poured bleach onto Susan's clothing, wrote Susan a note, and left the house again. Strangely, Jeff again did not take his truck. It was still in the driveway. On Saturday, January eighteenth, five days after Jeff went missing, Susan met with her parents. She told them that she was feeling physically and mentally awful. I'm not sure exactly how the conversation came to this question, but eventually Susan's mother asked her what we've all been wondering, did she kill Jeff? In response, Susan put her head down on the table. After a time, she told her mother that she had killed Jeff on Monday, January thirteenth. He had never walked out. In a fit of anger, Susan used a knife to stab Jeff death and had hidden
20:00 his body on the property. She said the murder happened when four year old Guests and baby Kara were in bed. She said, Mamma, it wasn't me. I snapped. I was up in there and I saw somebody do it, but it wasn't me. Immediately, Susan's mother called attorney Neil Davis, who went to the police station. At this time, Davis didn't reveal much to law enforcement. He just wrote down Susan's address on the back of a business card, gave it to the officers, and explained that there was a body at this location. A short while after, Davis had given the authorities a cryptic message about a body and an address scrawled on the back of a business card. Detective Mark Reynolds and his investigative team arrived at the right family home. Reynolds had been employed by the Harris County Sheriff's Apartment for over twenty years. He had been a detective for twelve years and worked in the Homiest Side division for ten years. Throughout his law enforcement career, Reynolds had investigated hundreds of homicides, but none like this one. In Susan and Jeff's backyard were several unfinished home improvement projects. Jeff had dug a shallow hole so that he could install a water fountain. In that same hole, investigators found thirty four year old Jeff's partially buried body. He was faced down. The back of his head, left shoulder, and left arm were exposed. When
21:34 the police unearthed Jeff's body, they discovered he was completely nude. Neck ties were tied around each of his wrists, and a bathrobe sash was tied around his right ankle. There was no binding on his left ankle. The officers also documented candle wax on Jeff's thigh and scrotum. Based on the scene, investigators suspected that Jeff's body was fully buried, but the family dog had dug it up. An animal, probably the same family dog, had partially eaten one of Jeff's hands. Inside the house, the master bedroom was a mess. Blood was splattered on their curtains, walls, ceiling, furniture, and other items in the bedroom. Blood was especially visible on one wall in particular, although someone had recently tried to paint over it. A piece of the carpet had been cut out and other portions of the carpet were bleached. The floor was littered with different items, including paint supplies, a box cutter, and scissors. Authorities found a receipt for two gallons of bleach bleach stained size, six women's jeans, and a towel. The bed was in pieces.
22:48 All that remained of it was the footboard and rails. The police recovered the bed's mattress, box spring, and headboard from the backyard where they had found Jeff's body. The mattress was soaked with blood. While searching the back yard, further investigators found a bloody knife with the tip broken off. The knife tip was later found lodged in Jeff's skull. Immediately Detective Reynolds suspected that Susan was the killer. His suspicions were solidified when he saw at least ten bags of topsoil and the back of Jeff's pickup truck. Reynolds also received a report that someone had recently seen Susan covered in dirt. I'm going to pause now for a word from today's sponsors. This show is sponsored by Better Help.
23:41 Big life changes can often be stressful and make you feel unsure of yourself, whether it's a career change, new relationship, or becoming apparent. Therapists are trained to help you figure out the cause of challenging emotions and learn productive coping skills, which makes therapy the closest thing to a guided tour of the complex engine called you. I have used therapy through many life challenges, good and bad, from before I got married and became a stepmother to when I lost my own mother. Therapy helped me feel I had a roadmap and I wasn't as overwhelmed. Just talking to someone objective is the first step, and better Help is a great way to get started. As the world's largest therapy service, Better Help has matched three million people with professionally licensed and vetted therapists available one hundred percent online, plus it's affordable. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to match with a therapist. If things aren't clicking, you can easily switch to a new therapist anytime. It couldn't be simpler. No waiting rooms, no traffic, no endless searching for the right therapist. Learn more and save ten percent off your first month at betterhelp dot com slash southern. That's better help help dot com slash southern. Thirty million and women are impacted by weakened or thinning hair. If you're among them, No, you're not alone, and that there's a solution you can trust to deliver results. Neutrofol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement clinically shown to improve your hair growth,
25:14 thickness, and visible scalp coverage. Neutrofol supports healthy hair growth from within by targeting the five root causes of thinning, stress, hormones, environment, nutrition, and metabolism through whole body health. Neutropole has three unique formulas to support women throughout all stages of life, including postpartum and menopause. Each formula is physician formulated using natural drug free, medical grade ingredients in consistently effective dosages so you get the most reliable results. In a clinical study, eighty six percent of women reported improved hair growth after six months. Three thousand plus top doctors and stylists recommend neutrofol as an effective and high quality solution for healthier hair.
25:56 You can grow thicker, healthier hair and to support our show by going to Neutralfall dot com and entering the promo code SFTC to say fifteen dollars off your first month's subscription. This is their best offer anywhere and it is only available to US customers for a limited time, plus free shipping on every order. Get fifteen dollars off Neutralfall dot com spelled in utr afol dot com promo code SFTC. Jeff's autopsy was performed by the Assistant Harris County Medical Examiner, Doctor Dwayne Wolfe. Doctor Wolfe determined that Jeff had been stabbed approximately one hundred and ninety three times. He had received forty one stab wounds to the face, twenty three to his neck, forty six to his chest, twenty two to his abdomen, seven to his pubic region, including superficial cuts on his penis, eighteen to his legs, twenty three to his arms and hands, and one to his back. The wounds were not deep. No single stab wound would have been fatal to Jeff on its own, but the culmination of all one hundred and ninety three had killed him. Doctor Wolfe also clarified Jeff had probably been stabbed more than one hundred and ninety three times. Since Jeff's body
27:26 was so extraordinarily mutilated, it was difficult for doctor Wolfe to differentiate one stab wound from the next. Toxicology reports showed that Jeff had alcohol, cocaine, and GHB, which is commonly known as a date rape drug, in his system before he died. From Monday, January thirteenth to Saturday January eighteenth, Susan had lied. She had told friends, family, doctors, and law enforcement officials that Jeff had walked out of their home after a bad fight. Why would she do that? What would push her to? As Susan herself said Snap. Incidentally, Susan's case was featured on the very first season of the show Snapped. While local law enforcement was searching Susan's home on Saturday January eighteenth, Susan was voluntary checking into a psychiatric unit at the Ben Taub General Hospital. One of the hospital's psychiatrists, doctor Jerome Brown, worked with Susan extensively. She told doctor Brown that her husband, Jeff Wright, had been physically and emotionally abusing her for years. Susan told forty eight Hours, I couldn't go on how things were. Our whole marriage was a really big cover up. According to Susan, Jeff was not the easy going, good guy he appeared to be behind closed doors. She said Jeff was a sadistic and
28:56 manipulative monster. When Susan first married Jeff, she was sure they were a match made in heaven. But after the birth of their son in nineteen ninety eight, Susan said, Jeff changed instantly. Where he was thoughtful and nice before, now he was controlling and demanding. Suddenly, Jeff wanted Susan to be the perfect housewife and mother. Dinner had to be on time, the house had to be spotless, the newborn baby had to be quiet. When Susan didn't meet Jeff's impossible standards, he would become furious, and initially that's all it was misplaced anger, Susan said, Jeff's extreme anger started after she had Guess. She said he was critical of the weight she gained during her pregnancy. She said he called her a fat ass, stupid, and worthless.
29:52 When Susan was diagnosed with postpartum depression, she said Jeff wouldn't let her take the antidepressants she had been prescribed. Susan explained, he said it wasn't rocket science what women did and that I needed to suck it up and do my job. Susan said she tried to talk with Jeff about improving his behavior. After all, Jeff had never treated Susan like this when they were dating. Surely they could restore their relationship to what it was before baby gus. But soon after Susan began sharing her complaints with Jeff, he began physically abusing her. She reported that Jeff would kick her or hit her repeatedly, especially in the chest, stomach, back, and legs. While Susan never explicitly told her sister Cindy that Jeff had physically abused her, it was no surprise to Cindy. She had seen the bruises on Susan's arms and legs on two occasions. Susan had a black eye. Susan's best friend, Jamie Darrhall, also suspected Jeff abused Susan, but Susan never said Jeff caused the bruises.
31:02 Instead, she claimed they were accidents or that Guss had accidentally thrown a toy at her. Despite the alleged abuse, Susan felt it was her job to keep up the family's appearances. Cindy told reporters that Susan wanted to make things look beautiful on the outside so that no one would wonder what it was like on the inside. Cindy attributed Susan's behavior to their childhood and how their father was abusive toward their mother in a seemingly picturesque home. One time in the summer of nineteen ninety nine, Susan said Jeff had thrown her through a wall in her home. Cindy said she saw the Susan sized hole in the wall The next day. Cindy moved Susan and her son Gus to their parents' house, but Susan and Gus didn't stay long. After one night, Susan said Jeff called her and told her that he would kill her and Gus if she didn't return hern home. The next day, Jeff sent a moving truck to Susan's parents' house. She packed up her belongings and returned to Jeff with their son. On another occasion of horrific abuse, in December of two thousand, Susan claimed that she miscarried after Jeff kicked her in the stomach. Susan said she couldn't go to the hospital because Jeff forbade it. He said they couldn't afford the medical bill. This was between the birth of Susan's first child, Gus, and her second child, Kara. After Kara was born in two
32:35 thousand and one, Susan had postpartum depression again. Just like when she struggled after Guss's birth, Jeff had no sympathy for her. To make matters worse, Susan said Jeff began cheating on her. He used Internet dating sites to meet new women. Jeff told Susan he needed other women because she wasn't good enough. Due to Jeff's frequent extramarital affairs, Susan claimed he her harpies. While Susan never shared with a single soul that Jeff had abused her, she did tell her sister Cindy that Jeff had a drug problem. He used cocaine and marijuana regularly. As their marriage continued, Susan claimed that Jeff's drug abuse worsened. According to Susan, when Jeff was high, he was more likely to abuse her. For example, one time, he got high and began tossing baby gusts up into the air as a way of playing with him.
33:32 Susan was worried Jeff would accidentally drop him and asked him to stop. In response, Jeff told Susan she didn't have the right to tell him when or how he would pick up his son. She said, he threw her against the wall, shook her by her arms, and punched her in the chest repeatedly. Basically, Susan said Jeff was unfaithful, drug addicted, physically abusive to her, and inappropriately aggressive toward their children. By the time two thousand and three came around. Every mild inconvenience sent Jeff into a spiral of anger and abuse. If there was an issue with his paycheck, if he had had a bad encounter with a customer at work, if the bills were too high, if Susan hadn't cleaned the house, correctly or made dinner to his standards. Still, Susan told no one about Jeff's abuse. Even her sister Cindy and best friend Jamie, who both suspected Jeff was abusive, didn't have true confirmation. Susan said she never considered going to the doctor to document the bruises on her body, or falling a police report to try to escape Jeff.
34:44 She feared he would become even more dangerous if she did. She later told Texas Monthly, I felt like it was my fault. I felt if I could be perfect enough and he would always be happy, then everything would be okay. When asked why she didn't divorce Jeff, Susan said she couldn't. Jeff had explained that if she left him, he'd kill her, and Susan believed him. That winter, Susan claimed Jeff was out of control. He wasn't making as much money and was constantly frustrated about their finances. He was drunk all the time. Once, Jeff was so inebriated that he ped and their baby daughter Kara's crib. Also, he had bought an air rifle and hit Susan with it. He threw bricks at her while they were working in the backyard, and Jeff's rules for Susan were getting stricter and stricter.
35:40 Susan was only allowed to go to the grocery store and visit her mother. She could not leave the house for longer than ninety minutes. When Susan asked to take some college classes, Jeff said no, he thought Susan would lie about going to classes and cheat on him instead. Susan and Jeff's words, as reported by Susan a nasty whore, On New Year's Day of two thousand and three, she said, Jeff told her happy fucking New Year, bitch, this will be your last. Two weeks later, twenty six year old Susan killed thirty four year old Jeff. For five days, Susan hid the murder, telling everyone Jeff had left. On January eighteenth, Susan confessed and checked herself into a hospital psychiatric unit. On January twenty third, Susan was arrested, charged with first degree murder, and held in jail without bond.
36:42 I'm going to pause now for a word from today's sponsors. I love gift giving and I want my holiday gifts to be really thoughtful, not in personal stuff you see on shelves like candles or gift baskets. Do you take about a millions only to let them sit on your phone or get lost in your files? Me too? What if you could put all your photos onto one gorgeous frame? You can with Aura Frames. Aura is nothing like the digital frames from a decade ago. Aura Frames are artfully designed to fit with any decourse style and with stunning HD display, unlimited storage, super easy setup, and no fees, you cannot miss giving the gift of Aura. Simply connect your Aura frame to Wi Fi and use the free Aura app to add endless picks and videos from anywhere in the world. Invite friends and family on the app and have them comment, heart and send new photos to your frame.
37:38 Aura frames make easy, meaningful holiday gifts, especially for the hard to shop for folks in your life. Preload with favorite photos and even a personalized video message. Listeners can take advantage of Aura's Black Friday Cyber Monday sell and get up to fifty dollars off Ora's best selling carvermap frames. Just go to Aura Frames dot com Southern Fried. That's Aurea Frames dot com slash Southern Fried. These are Aura's lowest prices ever, so get yours now. Terms and conditions apply. I am the worst about canceling subscriptions. I've kept newspaper subscriptions for certain small towns for years for episodes that I could not access the sources without the subscription, and then I would just keep forgetting to cancel it or keep putting it off. And that's why I love using rocket money formerly known as true Bill. The app shows all your subscriptions in one place and then cancels for you whatever you don't still want. Rocket Money can even find subscriptions you didn't know you were still paying for. You may even find out you've been double charged for a subscription. To cancel a subscription, all you have to do is press cancel and rocket money takes care of the rest. Get rid of useless subscriptions with rocket money now. Go to rocketmoney dot com slash Southern fraud. Seriously, it could save you hundreds per year. That's rocketmoney dot com slash Southern fraud. Cancel your unnecessary subscriptions right now at rocketmoney dot com
39:10 slash Southern fraud. Many of Jeff's family and friends do not believe Jeff ever laid a hand on Susan. They think that Susan lied about his domestic violence so she would be able to claim she was a battered wife. Then she could say she killed him in self defense in hopes of reducing or eliminating her prison sentence. Ron Wright, Jeff's father, told Court TV that Susan never had any symptoms of being an abused woman. But let's be fair. He's Jeff's dad. I've watched the interviews, I've read the court documents. I want to believe Susan is telling the truth. I know these situations have happened where victims do not report their abuser's violence, and with Susan saying Jeff usually punched her in the chest, stomach, and legs, that is the classic way for an abuser to hide the bruises. Not all domestic violence victims have black eyes all the time. People always respond, will they never reported it, so it can't be true. But we know, of course that sometimes it is true. Sometimes it is literally impossible for a victim to escape their abuser without violence. In fact, we know that the most dangerous time for a battered woman is when she tries to leave her abuser. But it is
40:44 really, really difficult to believe. Susan is telling the whole truth. In a moment, you'll understand why. According to Susan, this is what happened when she killed Jeff. On the evening of Monday, January thirteenth, Jeff came home from his boxing lesson. His eyes were red and glassy. He was extremely agitated. He tried to rough house with their four year old son, Gus. He wanted to box, probably since he had just come from his boxing class. When Gus lost interest, Jeff became angry. He hit Gus with a closed fist so hard that Gus flew backward into a love seat. Frustrated, Jeff called Gus as sissy and then went to take a shower.
41:30 When Jeff entered the master bedroom wearing only a towel, Susan confronted him. She said that unless he sought professional help for his drug abuse and anger issues, she would leave him. At this news, Jeff became enraged. He threw Susan on the bed, kicked her, and raped her. Susan said she closed her eyes during the rape. After he was done, Susan felt Jeff move then she heard him say die bitch. That's when she opened her eyes and saw Jeff had a knife. A struggle ensued. Susan went for the knife and and the process was cut. She kneed Jeff in the groin, which allowed her to gain control of the knife and a feet of strength. She pushed him off of her. Fearing for her life, Susan used to the knife and stabbed Jeff repeatedly, first in the neck and then in his chest. At this point, Susan claimed she suffered a break from reality. This is important to Susan's story from here on out. Susan claimed that she didn't understand Jeff was dead. Susan said she was certain Jeff would wake up and continue to hurt her, so she continued to stab Jeff over and over again. At first, she stood next to him while stabbing him, but then she climbed on top of him, marrying how he had been on top of her during the sexual assault. Once she mounted Jeff, she
43:00 continued stabbing. During her court testimony, Susan cried while she explained that she stabbed Jeff in his head and in his chest, and in his neck and in his stomach and his leg from when he kicked me and I stabbed him in his penis for all the times he made me have sex and I didn't want to. I couldn't stop. He was going to kill me. I couldn't stop. The only thing that stopped Susan was her toddler, Gus, knocking on their bedroom door. Susan panicked. In her delusional state, she said, she continued to believe Jeff would open his eyes and attack her, so her solution was to tie one of his hands to the bed so that he couldn't escape. To be clear, it's almost certain that Jeff was already dead. Susan put on a robe, hid the knife in the bedroom, and put her son, Gus, to bed. Then she retrieved a different knife from the kitchen. She was worried Jeff might have escaped his bonds and found the knife she had hidden in the bedroom. With the second knife in hand, Susan returned to the bedroom and continued to stab Jeff. Eventually she stopped stabbing him. After killing her alleged abuser, Susan did not go to the police. She did not go to her family or friends. Instead, Susan did many strange and frankly incriminating things. But why well, According to Susan, she was in a post traumatic stress disorder induced fog. From Monday
44:35 through Saturday. Susan experienced a unique fugue state. She reported that she didn't understand anything that was happening around her, including her own words and actions. Susan reported that the fog began when she stabbed Jeff, which is why she couldn't fathom that he was dead. While in her fog, Susan seemed to have a convenient explanation and for all of the evidence that made her look guilty of murdering her husband in cold blood. After killing Jeff, Susan hid his body due to the fog. She didn't think of it as hiding her crimes. She was determined to get Jeff out of the house so that when he woke up, he couldn't attack her. She tried to drag Jeff off the bed, but he was too heavy. His head and shoulder hit the nightstand, causing a lit candle to fall on him. That's how Susan explained the wax on his scrotum and thigh. Then Susan tied Jeff to a dolly with two neckties and a bathrobe. If you don't know what a dolly is, picture the thing that movers used to handle heavy things like appliances. It has wheels on the bottom. And as a woman who thought I could never move my own washer and dryer when I left my first husband, my best friend proved me wrong when she showed up at my apartment with a dolly. I'll have a photo of the one Susan used on my social media. So with a dolly, Susan managed to get Jeff's body to the backyard, where she
46:08 buried him in the pre dug hole, the one Jeff was going to install a water fountain in. Again, Susan said she wasn't quote hiding the body when she shoveled dirt on Jeff. Rather, she wanted to make it harder for Jeff to quote get out when he woke up. Next, Susan sat on the couch facing the backyard. She stayed awake the entire night, waiting for Jeff to return and come after her. And then Susan lied a lot. For nearly a week, she acted as if she hadn't killed her husband. She told friends and family that Jeff had left their home of his own will. Once again, Susan attributed this to the fog Throughout the week, Susan repainted the master bedroom. She dragged the bloody mattress to her backyard, along with other parts of the ruined bed. She cut out the bloodier portions of the bedroom's carpet and bleached other sections. But again, Susan said she wasn't trying to hide evidence. As a part of her fog. Susan was terrified that Jeff would come home to a dirty house. She knew he liked things spotless, so she needed to clean up the blood in the bedroom.
47:23 If she didn't, Jeff would beat her. As we have discussed, Susan went to the doctor to get treatment for the cuts on her hands. Then she went to the police to receive her straining order against the now deceased Jeff. To onlookers, it appeared as if Susan was establishing a pattern of domestic violence after she had already killed him. If you'll recall, Susan had never gone to the doctor or made a police report before she killed Jeff. She maintained that due to her fog, she genuinely thought that Jeff would return. After this horrible experience, Susan was ready to take the precautionary steps that would allow her to leave him in the future. And there's one more small odd detail. Susan rerecorded the answering machine message removing Jeff's name. Instead of something like, this is Susan, Jeff, Gus and Kara, leave a message and we'll get back to you, it became this is Susan, Gus and Kara. Why would Susan do that if she thought Jeff would return? Was it she cleaning the bedroom specifically in preparation for his return. If you're wondering if Susan's fogg was actually an elaborate hoax to avoid the consequences of killing her husband and hiding the body, well you're not alone. But doctor Jerome brown believed Susan. After Susan confessed and checked into the psychiatric unit, she spoke
48:59 to doctor Browne for several days. From their conversations, he determined that Susan was disassociated from reality. Doctor Browne described Susan as dreamy and unfocussed. He said Susan responded to his questions with poor concentration, no eye contact, flat emotions, frequent sighing, and continuous crying. He theorized that Susan's contact with reality was tenuous, and doctor Browne also observed Susan's obsessive paranoia that Jeff would return. While in the hospital, Susan was convinced that Jeff was wandering the hallways. She said he was trying to find her so he could beat her to death. Doctor Browne diagnosed Susan with PTSD and depression. He thought that Susan's fog was a psychological defense mechanism, which essentially removes the person from their immediate situation. Additionally, Susan told doctor Browne that when Jeff raped her, she would go away in her mind to cope with a trauma. Doctor Browne believed that this impaired Susan's memory. He told Texas Monthly Quote, on the night she stabbed her husband, she had some kind of mental break, and she stayed that way for days, probably weeks. I don't want to say she became completely psychotic, but she drifted in and out of reality. She didn't have any real idea of what she was doing or why. This may
50:34 sound wild to someone who hasn't experienced PTSD or have been a domestic violence victim, but doctor Browne's opinion is not abnormal. Many domestic violence experts report that victims can experience disassociative states, especially after a violent incident. Later, the victims can't remember the events clearly. Throughout the year lead up to Susan's trial, her case gained national attention. News outlets had dubbed Susan the blue Eyed Butcher. Local TV reporter Jessica Willie told Snapped people were shocked. They couldn't imagine such a pretty young thing stabbing her husband one hundred and ninety three times.
51:20 When Susan's trial began in early two thousand and four, the courtroom was packed. Many people stood because there weren't enough seats. Susan's defense lawyer, Neil Davis, was relatively inexperienced. He had never defended a murder case involving a domestic violence victim. His co counsel, Todd Ward, had never defended a murder case at all. Right from the jump, these two young men were no match for state prosecutor forty one year old Kelly Siegler, a renowned veteran of fifteen years. Usually, lawyers are tools in the courtroom. Their job is to extract the truth as much as they can from a plaintiff and a defendant. Most of the time, lawyers are minor characters and crime cases, but Kelly Siegler played a much larger role in Susan Wright's trial. In fact, there are a few moments in Susan's trial where Siegler wasn't just a character, she was the protagonist. In the early two thousands, Kelly Siegler was described as the fiercest prosecutor in Houston. By two thousand and four, she had prosecuted sixteen murderers who had ended up on death row. Siegler was known to stand very close to defendants during the trial, gesturing to them as she talked about their alleged crimes. When defendants testified, Siegler would stand within inches of them, grilling them face to face. She told the Houston Chronicle,
52:53 I think a right thinking juror appreciates the fact that someone accused of murder gets to be treated like they're accused of murder, and they don't feel sorry for them when they're treated that way. So much for guilty until proven innocent, but anyway, Siegler's supervisor referred to her affectionately as pushy. Besides being pushy, Siegler was also known for her theatrics in the courtroom. A few years before Susan's case, Siegler sat on a pickle bucket in front of a jury. She told the jury that the defendant sat on the same bucket right after he murdered a four year old girl. On another occasion, Siegler brought an entire wall and window frame into the courtroom. She used it to demonstrate how a killer broke into their victim's home. A former judge told The Houston Chronicle, she keeps the jurors on the edge of their seat. Trial with Her was a soap opera and a law and order television show wrapped into one experience. Around two thousand and four, Siegler was included on a list of the nation's top forty litigators under age forty. She was also recognized as one of the top fifty women litigators in the country. In two thousand and thirteen, Siegler would star in an investigative true crime series on T and T and Oxygen called Cold Justice, produced by Law and Orders Dick Wolfe. It followed Siegler and her team as they reopened unsolved murder cases. It ran for six
54:30 seasons and might be renewed for a seventh. Oxygen stated that Cold Justice has helped lead to twenty one convictions and fifty five arrests. There was even a short lived spin off show called Cold Justice Sex Crimes, but Siegler and her show Cold Justice have been sued twice now for defamation. She was also sanctioned for withholding evidence in two other cases. Southern Fried listeners may remember her as the first secutor in the Belinda Temple murder, specifically from episode one twenty eight. That was another famous case that happened after Susan Wright's murder trial. It was just a year after Susan's trial in February of two thousand and five.
55:15 I definitely recommend checking out the two part Belinda Temple series because it was one of the most interesting courtroom dramas I've ever covered. But most of Siegler's celebrity awards and TV shows can be traced back to Susan Wright's trial. After a twenty minute courtroom demonstration, Siegler's career was launched into the stratosphere. I'm going to pause now for a final commercial break. When preparing for Susan's trial, Siegler knew the jury would be tempted to sympathize with Susan since she was a young, pretty woman. Strategy was to make the jury see and feel what happened to Jeff. She wanted the jurors to look past the martyr act she thought Susan was putting on. Siegler did not believe Susan was ever abused.
56:13 She said, all that battered wife abuse was bull was just that it was bull. In two thousand and eight, Siegler publicly stated that her stepfather abused her mother. When a Texas Monthly reporter asked if that affected how she handled Susan Wright's case, Siegler said it did. But even though Siegler's familial abuse was also a secret, there were still small incidents that let people know it was happening. She said that evidence of it all the bruises, the one time we called law enforcement and they did nothing, The little bit we told our friends, the little bit they witnessed, the visits to the doctor, the arguments, both public and private, all in spite of our efforts to keep it secret, were still there. Susan Wright had no evidence of any of that. I looked for it as hard as I ever looked for evidence of any defendant's guilt or innocence. But if you believe Susan's sister and friends, they're were psalms. They saw Bruce's, they worried for Susan, and everyone knew Jeff was abusing drugs, even his family, even though they minimized his drug abuse and said it didn't affect his job, finances, or marriage, which if you've ever lived with an addict, you know cannot be true.
57:34 During opening statements, Siglar asserted that Susan planned to kill Jeff to avoid a divorce and benefit from Jeff's recently acquired two hundred thousand dollars life insurance policy. Siglar explained that Susan seduced Jeff and then tied his arms and legs to the bed to initiate BDSM style sex. Susan wanted Jeff to be defenseless. And I will point out here that Jeff had alcohol, cocaine, and GHB, which is commonly known as a date rape drug, in his system before he died. He definitely used pot and coke regularly, but it's strange he would have a date rape drug in his system. GHB is also used by partiers. No doubt, it can cause a sense of euphoria and was popular with club kids at the time. Jeff was known to party hard and maybe this was something he used. It could help come down from the cocaine or enhance it as well as create the sense of euphoria. But on the other hand, if Susan slipped it in his drink, it is a depressant and can cause sleepiness and blackouts. That's why it is known as a date rape drug. He would have been easier to control if she had slipped him GHB.
58:52 But now I guess you need to wonder if Susan Wright had access to drugs the way her husband did. Siegler painted a detailed picture of Susan's seduction. She told the jury Susan was setting the mood. She was teasing him, she was leading him on, she was getting him aroused. She was kissing him, licking him, she was flirting with him and loving him for all she was worth. And at some point, when the wax was melted just enough, she poured a little bit on his penis. Then, with unfathomable anger, Susan brutally stabbed Jeff over and over again. According to Siegler, Susan spent the next week covering up her crime. She buried Jeff's body in the backyard, cleaned up the bedroom, and began a campaign of lies.
59:39 She told Jeff's friends and family that Jeff had abused their son and her, and then left. At some point, Susan emptied their joint bank account. She knew if Jeff had abused her, she might escape a harsh sentence, so Susan went to the doctor and made a false report of Jeff's abuse. Also lied to the police when she followed a restraining order against Jeff, which resulted in a warrant for his arrest. The only reason Susan's plan fell apart, according to Siegler, was because the family dog partially dug up Jeff's body, leaving out the part that Susan confessed to her mother, who called her attorney, who then reported a dead body to the police at the right home. Also, the Texas Monthly article reported that Susan had said that Jeff had also abused their sixty pound dog, often kicking him and throwing him across the room gallows. Humor in the courtroom was that the dog had dug up the hand and ate it for revenge. During the trial, Sigler called Detective Mark Reynolds to the stand. I've mentioned him before. He was there when Jeff's body was unearthed. He was also present for the autopsy. When Siegler cross examined Reynold, he told the jury that he believed Jeff was tied to the bed when he was murdered. The placement of Jeff's wounds was especially damning.
1:01:07 When a person is being stabbed repeatedly, they try to move away from the attacker, causing the majority of the stab wounds to happen on the victim's side or back as they try to escape. This wasn't the case for Jeff. All but two of his one hundred and three wounds were on the front of his body. Jeff was probably tied down, spread eagle, face to face with his killer. He couldn't move away. Reynolds believed Susan was lying about killing Jeff in self defense. He admitted that he didn't understand how Susan, who was a small woman of five foot three, could have wrestled a knife away from Jeff, a man who was six foot two tall. And athletic. Between the two, there was over a hundred pound weight difference.
1:01:54 As Siegler questioned the detective, several police officers arrived in the courtroom carrying pieces of wood in a mattress. At her instruction, the officers assembled Susan and Jeff's bed in the courtroom. Get ready. This is what took Siegler from a locally known lawyer to a nationwide phenomenon. Siegler had organized an in court demonstration of Jeff's murder on the exact bed the murder had occurred on. It was crazy. Everyone could see Jeff's bloodstains on the mattress. Then Siegler taught her male colleague Paul Doyle to the bed. She used neckties and a bathrobe sash, just like the ones discovered with Jeff's body. Next, she established that she was the same size as Susan Wright and that Paul was about the same size as Jeff Wright. Once that was settled, Kelly climbed on the bed and straddled her bound colleague. She held a knife in her hand and proceeded to ask the detective clarifying questions about how Susan could have murdered Jeff.
1:03:00 As she asked the questions, Sigler would mind stabbing her colleague. For example, Siegler asked Reynolds to identify where most of the wounds would be on Jeff's body if Susan were positioned like she was. Reynolds said that the wounds would be on the left side of Jeff's body because Susan was right handed. Sigler mimed stabbing her colleague on the left side of his head, and Reynolds confirmed that most of Jeff's wounds were concentrated in the same area. Susan's defense lawyer, Neil Davis objected several times throughout this in court demonstration, but the judge almost always overruled him. Siegler and her colleague Paul were careful not to use facial expressions or play out the murder as a scene. For as weird as the demonstration was, it was done in a fairly matter of fact way.
1:03:54 Siegler didn't reenact all one hundred and ninety three stabbings or pretend to sedu Jeff to the bed with promises of sex. Still, by courtroom standards, this was a spectacle. Both Susan and Siegler's lives were changed forever. Before Susan's trial had even ended, Hollywood producers were calling ABC to pitch a show based on Siegler's persona, an off the wall female lawyer who beat out the good old boy Texas lawyers with her creative arguments. People magazine was also inspired by the bed demonstration and profiled Siegler in an article entitled Drama Queen. During Susan's testimony, she was obviously disgusted at Siegler's description of the murder as a bondage sex scene, but Siegler implied that Susan was not the traditional Christian housewife who never dripped candlewax on her husband. She pointed out that Susan had been a topless dancer when she was eighteen. Siegler told Snapped, she just acted so so offended that how dare I suggest she would do anything besides regular, boring missionary sex. It's like, come on, lady, you got handcuffs in the drawer. Susan's defense lawyer, Neil Davis, tried to convince the jury that Jeff had emotionally and physically abused Susan throughout their marriage, that Susan had to kill Jeff out of self defense, that she had a genuine mental break
1:05:26 that caused her to hide the murder for almost a week under the mistaken belief that Jeff was alive and trying to kill her, But Davis didn't do a very good job. Rather than bring in an expert on PTSD to help explain Susan's fogg state, Davis said, let's talk about another topic briefly. It's called post traumatic stress disorder. Anyone know about that? Does everyone here understand that going through that can lead to a break in reality? Anyone not understand that or not believe in that at all? Imagine raising your hand as a juror and saying I don't understand that requires a nerve racking level of vulnerability that lawyers cannot expect of jurors, especially with court TV cameras on. Davis treated Susan's battered women's syndrome defense in the same flippant manner. Rather than putting a domestic violence expert on the stand, he said, anyone ever hear of battered wife syndrome? Here? Do people understand that when you're a battered spouse that divorce is not a realistic solution sometimes. Later, Davis clarified that he didn't want to overwhelm the jury with experts. He felt that battered women's syndrome wasn't rocket science and that the jury should understand it easily. For the record, juries don't understand battered women's syndrome easily. Juries are often unknowingly prejudiced against victims
1:07:00 of domestic violence. They need help from experts to understand the answers to questions like why didn't she leave? Did she really feel that trapped? Could she legitimately have had a mental breakdown and snapped. Historically, juries are biased against women who kill their abusers, so much so that women will often receive longer prison sentences for killing their male abusers than their male abusers would if they had killed their female victims. The legal system is more kind to male centered definitions of self defense. For example, juries understand when a defendant says, he hint me so hard, I feared for my wife, so I stabbed him.
1:07:45 However, women who are victims of domestic violence can often predict imminent danger because they have lived with it for so long they know their abuser. Therefore, self defense doesn't look like a cut and dry punched me, so I killed him situation. The abuser could be asleep or tied up, but the victim might still act in self defense because they know they will be harmed later. It does make some sense why Nell Davis didn't call doctor Jerome Browne to the stand. When Susan first checked herself into doctor Browne's psychiatric unit, she told him a vastly different story about Jeff's murder than what she would later tell the authorities. Susan told doctor Browne that she had attacked Jeff while he was sleeping. She told Texas Monthly she does not remember telling doctor Browne that Jeff was asleep, and doctor brown believed that Susan was so rattled by her experiences and her fog that she shouldn't be held to this original story. In the end, Davis didn't bring doctor Browne to the stand because he didn't want two stories muddying the waters for the jury. But that doesn't explain why Davis didn't hire a different domestic violence expert. Shelby Moore, a Harvard educated professor at South Texas of Law, was an expert in domestic violence who offered to testify for free, but Davis never followed up with more, and Davis also didn't
1:09:15 bring to the stand Jeff Sex's girlfriend, Misty McMichael i, spoke of her earlier. She billed Jeff out of jail in Mexico when he was caught with illegal drugs. After hearing about Susan's case on the news, Misty reached out to Susan's lawyers. Misty said Jeff had abused her too. In the early nineties, Misty was working at a trip club. Jeff was a regular who was known as a big spender. Similar to Susan's experience with Jeff, he was very charming at first, but over time his demeanor changed. Misty said Jeff had two sides to him. When he was sober, he was really sweet and he wanted to go to church and pray a lot. But when he was drinking, he was mean and abusive toward me. During a fight at Misty's apartment, Jeff grabbed her and threw her down a spiral staircase.
1:10:09 In response, Misty through a ring that Jeff had given her at him. With no hesitation. Jeff backhanded Misty. She called the police to report the incident, but Jeff told the officers she had hit him first so that he could avoid being arrested. Later on, the couple got into a fight at a bar. Jeff tried to strike Misty and broke a few glasses as he swung at her. A piece of glass cut Misty on her chin, and she bled profusely. To this day, she says a shot of glass is still embedded in her chin. Someone called the police, and Jeff was arrested for aggravated assault. An ambulance took Misty to the hospital, but she declined treatment. She was worried that Jeff would be angry when he got out of jail. To mitigate his response, Misty called the police and told them the whole thing was an accident. Davis knew of Jeff's prior arrest for assaulting an ex girlfriend. He had even contacted Misty, but after some communication Snaphews, Davis didn't get Misty on the stand during Susan's trial. Communication issues are a bullshit excuse. She could have been the key to Susan's defense, and it's not like she was a hostile witness. She reached out to Davis, willing to come testify for Susan. Another point I'll make about Misty is that she had some notoriety. She was married to Stephen McMichael, an NFL player who played for the Patriots, the Bears, and the Packers. But he also
1:11:41 played college football at the University of Texas at Austin and was an All American player. Texas jurors might have known him even if he wasn't a big shot in the NFL. So Misty McMichael would have brought star power to Susan's side of the trial. Her testimony have helped immensely for obvious reasons, but you can't ignore how her celebrity status may have helped Susan. But jurrors never got to hear from Misty. By the end of Susan's trial, the jury was conflicted. It was Susan's word against the word of her dead husband. In Kelly Siegler's closing statement, she accused Susan of being a good actress. She said, she said, what you're left with is the word of Susan Lucille Wright, the word of a card carrying obvious no doubt about it, caught red handed, confirmed documented liar. After five hours of deliberation, the jury found twenty seven year old Susan guilty a first degree murder. She was sentenced to twenty five years in prison. Jurrors said it was problematic that there was no evidence of Jeff's abuse from unbiased third parties like medical records or police reports.
1:12:55 Only Susan's friends and family said they saw bruises, and Susan never said Jeff caused them. However, it's clear the jury sympathized with Susan. Prosecutors wanted Susan to receive forty five years in prison, so twenty five years was a best case scenario. Later, Susan would have a well known appellate attorney take up her cause and work for her pro bono. Brian Weiss would appeal to the courts that her defense lawyer, Neil Davis, provided her with ineffective counsel, and Susan won that appeal. Her sentence was reduced from twenty five years in prison to twenty Susan's other appeals were denied. Ironically, at the beginning of the episode, I told you Neil Davis was starting at a new law firm who had represented David koresh Well Dick Degeron, who famously defended Koresh was the trial attorney who did battle with Kelly Siegler in the Belenda Temple case I told you about. It was known as the Clash of the Titans, but Siegler would wind up losing big time on appeal. I actually defended her in that case, not so much in this one. In January of twenty twenty one, Susan Wright was released from prison. She had served sixteen years, which was nine years fewer than her original twenty five years sentence. Susan will remain on parole until twenty twenty four. As a part of her parole,
1:14:25 she must wear a GPS ankle monitor, attend anger management classes, and stay in Texas. Susan lost all parental rights to her two children, Gus and Kara. They are adults now and were raised by Jeff's family. I really did try not to editorialize much in this episode. My sympathies will almost always be with women who are abused, and it's not that I don't believe Susan. I do. I believe her sister and friends who saw bruises. I believe Misty McMichael, for whom Jeff did have an arrest record for abusing. I believe a neighbor who testified that they saw Jeff grab Susan's arm angrily a lot. The problem is the murder looks premeditated, and not in the way that many abused women are accused of premeditation. Shooting a sleeping abuser who had just beaten them is something we see a lot. But you know what, prisons are filled with women like that. Anyway. I told you earlier that statistically, women killing their abusers get harsher sentences than the men who kill a women they have abused. But it's the GHB in Jeff's system. It is the way he was tied up and the wounds on his body. I don't believe she could have fought him off on a knife attack, especially if he was high. And even though doctors say these feugue states can happen, it's hard to imagine one where the woman is buying cleaning materials, burying her
1:15:56 husband in the backyard, repainting the room. That all just looks bad. Kelly Siegler's antics got her national news attention and made her a media darling, but I'm not sure that's what really convicted Susan, though Siegler had a lot of circumstantial evidence on her side. She is a good lawyer, folksy, a good storyteller. She could set the scene. But Susan did not have any police reports of the abuse or doctor's visits. That's not unusual, but it hurt her in trial, and losing Misty McMichael and refusing to put on domestic violence in PTSD experts at trial made Neil Davis's defense a travesty. It's funny. Susan testified that Jeff told her the postpartum depression wasn't real because what women do wasn't quote rocket science, and Neil Davis told Texas Monthly that battered women's syndrome to him wasn't rocket science. Nothing Susan Wright experienced was supposedly rocket science, so why should a defense attorney try to explain it to a jury.
1:17:05 Davis also called it psychobabble, indicating his lack of belief or respect for battered women's syndrome. He's the last man who should have been defending an abused woman. Luckily, an appellent attorney named Brian Weiss watched the whole trial in disbelief and did Susan's appeals on pro bono. He wasn't just outraged by Neil Davis but also by Kelly siegler belittling of battered women's syndrome with what he called her quote blatant attempts to mislead the jury with misconceptions and stereotypes about battered women. It's fair her sentence was reduced because of Neil Davis's shitty defense, and I'm not surprised she got out early after being a model prisoner. As for Kelly Siegler, it's fine. If that's the way she wants to prosecute abused women, that's her choice. It sucks, but she's within legal bounds for now. But I wish Siegler didn't prop up her own experience with domestic abuse as the way it always happens, and that women can so easily just run away from their abusers. She doesn't believe in this type of self defense.
1:18:16 As she put it at trial. Self defense would have been once she got him tied up, running out the door for all she was worth with her babies. But what's the story after that? After Jeff got free and came looking for Susan. How long until he made good on his threats to kill her. That's what people don't understand about battered women's syndrome causing murders to look premeditated, and Jeff Writes's murder did look premeditated. I think it's possible she had had enough of his abuse and the only way she knew she could get the upper hand was by seducing him. It's sad that she never felt safe enough to report his abuse before this happened. It's sad that it came to this, and it's sad that she knew no one would understand how it happened, so it wasn't the story she told in court. She may have truly felt like a prisoner in her own home and that this was her only way out. Southern frid True Crime is hosted and produced by me Erica Kelly.
1:19:23 Today's episode was researched and written by Andrea Marshbank. As usual, any editorial comments and opinions are my own. Southern Frad's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic artist by Colly Horner. If you have any case suggestions, please go to my website and click on the listeners suggestion tab. This is the best way for me to get those little known cases you'll always send me. Please remember that I do not accept suggestions on social media private messages. With three platforms to manage, that is very overwhelming for me. I hope you understand, but please come join our Facebook group, Southern Fridtrue Crime Fans Discussion Group, where we swap recipes, worship Dolly Parton, and share memes. I much prefer spending my social media time and our lovely group. Our group is a safe and fund corner of Facebook, and by god, we mean it when we say no shitas is allowed. It's not a motto, it's how we run the group. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on all large platforms like a Heart, Stitcher, Spotify and now Amazon and Audible. Until next time, thanks so much for listening. Y'all. Take care
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed