Aug. 28, 2023

128: The Belinda Temple Case, Part 2 - REMASTERED

128: The Belinda Temple Case, Part 2 - REMASTERED
128: The Belinda Temple Case, Part 2 - REMASTERED
Southern Fried True Crime
128: The Belinda Temple Case, Part 2 - REMASTERED

After the brutal murder of Belinda Temple, an 8 month pregnant school teacher in 1999, the Harris County DA’s office took five years to finally charge her husband, David, with murder. They had an ace in the hole. They had star prosecutor Kelley...

After the brutal murder of Belinda Temple, an 8 month pregnant school teacher in 1999, the Harris County DA’s office took five years to finally charge her husband, David, with murder. They had an ace in the hole. They had star prosecutor Kelley Siegler. But David Temple’s family hired Dick DeGuerin, the guy who got Robert Durst off after he dismembered his landlord. The trial had the promised fireworks but afterwards, Kelly Siegler was accused of prosecutorial misconduct. So David Temple went to trial for a second time, 20 years after his wife was murdered. Will Belinda Temple and her unborn daughter ever get justice?

Sources: https://www.southernfriedtruecrime.com/127-128-the-belinda-temple-case-part-1-part-2

Hosted and produced by Erica Kelley
Researched and written by Erica Kelley
Original Graphic Art by Coley Horner
Original Music by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio
Edited & Mixed by Erica Kelley
Suggested by: Amy Brooks, Landry Moore & Michelle Kimmey

This show is part of the Spreaker Prime Network, if you are interested in advertising on this podcast, contact us at https://www.spreaker.com/show/2975465/advertisement

0:11 Southern Fried True crime covers cases that are not suitable for young listeners, and there may also be some explicit language used. Listener discretion is advised. I like circumstantial evidence. I've said this before. It tells a story. Obviously you want DNA evidence, fingerprints and other scientific evidence to bolster the story. But when it's a domestic crime, the defense will be able to scoff at a lot of that evidence. They will say, my client lived with the victim. Of course, his fingerprints in DNA are in the house. In the Belinda Temple case, they needed the gun. If they had found the murder weapon, David Temple probably would have been arrested right away. It's probably the main reason this case went cold. The other issue we have to discuss as prosecutorial misconduct. Harris County DA Kelly Siegler was excoriated over her actions in this case. What is sad is that she herself like circumstantial evidence. She was indisputably a very effective trial lawyer. She's folksy, sarcastic, and very engaging. She tells that story and she didn't need to play dirty. But was it as bad as people think ended David's attorney playfair. He was also a famous and respected lawyer, and he tried plenty of tricks himself. So David Temple got a second trial. Welcome to Episode one twenty eight, The

1:45 Belinda Temple Case, Part two, The Trials of David Temple. Before we get started, I've got a correction to make. Heather Scott was not from Kansas, as I stated in the last episode. She was from Little Rock, Arkansas. However, she moved to Franklin, Texas when she was in the eighth grade. I know it's not a big deal, but I like to get things right. It also means to me that it doesn't sound like Heather just fell off the turnip truck from Kansas on the way to Houston, Texas. Franklin is about two hours away from Houston. She was, essentially, at age twenty nine, a Texan and had worked at Hastings High for a year. Then she moved into the new ninth grade NX building along with David Temple and his coach and friend Quinton Harlan. Tammy. Harlan would later say she found out from other teachers that Heather was a groupie for coaches.

2:39 Tammy called her Barbie bitch, something she would proudly admit on the witness stand. Heather's flirtation started with Quinton, something he would later have to embarrassingly admit in court. But then David, ever competitive, started his own flirt campaign with Heather. The amount of emails between the two were of a lotus. This wasn't just some casual hookup, as he would later try to portray it, and if he wanted to call it a hookup that he had ended, he probably shouldn't have married her. In May of two thousand and one, two weeks before they married, David bought a nice house in Richmond, Texas, about a half hour from Katie. The house was beautiful and it had palm trees around the swimming pool. Friends had been disturbed by David bragging about the money he had made when he sold the house on Round Valley Drive, the house where his wife was murdered, and now he quickly moved on marrying Heather at a fancy country club and settling into the new house with her and Evan. Heather proudly began telling people that Evan called her mommy all on his own. Heather's mother would later speculate to author Catherine Casey that Heather didn't have babies of her own because she and David had this dark cloud over them.

3:53 She did become a mother to Evan, and maybe she didn't want to risk having more children on her own if David was ever convicted, or maybe she didn't want to have a baby with a murderer. There are many people who believe that David's family knew he killed Belinda, though not all would go on record. Becky Temple, Kevin's wife, had been close to her sister in law, Belinda, and she made comments to both Brenda Lucas, Belinda's twin sister, and Tammy Harland, Belinda's best friend. Becky not only suspected David, but seemed like she detested Heather. She and Kevin were so angry at David for his relationship with Heather that they stopped speaking to him for months, something Becky would later have to admit to at trial, though by then she was towing the Temple family line. She wasn't the only one who didn't like Heather. Initially, Kennemoreene Temple, David's parents kept a shrine to Belinda in their home and were indeed frosty to Heather for a while before finally accepting her, probably because David insisted on. At Hastings football games, Tammy Harland, ever, the football wife there to support Quinton, shouted at and heckled Heather when she tried to sit in the section for coach's families. Heather, embarrassed, would get up and go to a different section. After a few games, Heather walked into the stands with the Temple family a show of solidarity.

5:21 She was now on the fold, but David and Heather were definitely living under a cloud. He knew he was still under investigation. He was so narcissistic that even though he knew he was being investigated, he still continued the relationship with Heather right after Belinda's murder. Heather's roommate Tara Hall, later confirmed in court that David sentos Valentine's Day roses a month after his wife's brutal murder, and that David and Heather immediately began seeing each other again. At first, they just stayed at home at the condo watching TV rather than being seen around town, but by the next football season in nineteen ninety nine, they were ready to go public whether Tammy Harland liked it or not. Maybe David did love her that much, But if you were at risk for being tried for murder, wouldn't you stop the affair and do everything you could to look like the grieving husband. David didn't seem to care how it looked, and it did anger his family, and while he eventually let Tom and Carol Lucas see their grandson, it was under his supervision Adam McDonald's. There would be no weekends with Evan's other grandparents or with his aunt Brenda, who began tape recording conversations with David, and soon even those pitifully short visits stopped. None of y'all are supporting me. I don't know what you expect me to do, he whined to Brenda on tape. His strategy of keeping Evan from Belinda's family

6:54 seemed to have worked. Maybe Evan would have always believed in his father's innocence. Anyway. The bad part is Evan missed growing up with his mother's family in his life, and they missed him so much that it intensified they are already immense grief. Investigators were frustrated, even haunted. Detective Mark Schmidt said, I thought about Belinda Temple's murder before I closed my eyes at night and first thing in the morning. But police and the DA's office knew they only had one shot at David, and there is no statute of limitations on murder. No matter how frustrated they were, they still hoped to find the murder weapon, And of course they hoped David would slip up and say something incriminating to someone who had come forward. What Brenda Lucas had on those tapes made him look like a shitty husband, and of course cruel and petty to Belinda's grieving family. The tapes may not have had a confession, but they would prove to be damaging in court. As I told you in the last episode, the DA's office did take the case to a grand jury. It wasn't so much to get an indictment as it was to get the testimony of certain witnesses on record before memories faded. They had investigators, friends, neighbors, Belinda's co workers, and family members called to testify. Even an alternate suspect who I briefly mentioned but haven't discussed yet, agreed to testify without a subpoena.

8:20 David of course, pled the fifth. When the grand jury was pulled, they said the case was weak, but at least they had witnesses on record. Weeks turned into months, and within a year, Belinda's case was no longer a high priority. Her file sat on the desks of many investigators, but technically it was a cold case now, and Belinda's family simmered. Obviously, they were hurting and angry that David hadn't been brought to justice. The months slipped into years, and then another pregnant woman was murdered and made national news when Lacy Peterson went missing in December of two thousand and two in Modesto, California. They watched the TV seeing her radiant smile everywhere, and of course thought of their beautiful Belinda. After Lacy and her unborn baby, Connor were found in April just a few months later, washed up on the shores of San Francisco Bay, her husband, Scott Peterson was arrested just five days later. Modesto police had already been building a case against him without Lacy's body. As soon as they found her, they arrested him. The similarities in the case polarized the family, and the DA's office. Even the media picked up on the similarities. The National Inquirer ran their photos on the front page, calling Belinda the new Lacy Peterson and Heather Scott the new Amber Fry.

9:46 I'm sure you haven't forgotten, but just in case, Amber Fry was Scott Peterson's mistress. But modesto authorities got lucky. Amber did the right thing and testified against Scott Peterson, while Heather Scott would insist that there was no real affair, despite the fact that they resumed their relationship almost immediately after Belinda's murder and got married two years later. The tabloid called David Quote an outrageous liar whose deceitful tricks seemed ripped directly from Scott Peterson's game plan. Well, timing wise, it would be the other way around, But this kind of sensational publicity helped. Belinda's father, Tom Lucas, wrote to Harris County District Attorney Chuck Rosenthal and threatened to go public with how he felt that his daughter's case had been mishandled and ignored. It was then that Rosenthal emailed Kelly Siegler, one of his star prosecutors at that point in her career, Siegler was working as a special prosecutor. She liked cold cases. She reportedly kept a file of them on her desk labeled Waiting for God. But she also later said that Peterson case had changed perception and made the public more aware that these types of murders do happen. Husbands and fathers do murder their pregnant wives and their unborn babies. She was right. By then, we had come a long way from charismatic assholes like Jeffrey McDonald. I'm going to pause now for

11:18 a short commercial break. When Kelly Siegler took over the David Temple case, she had won nineteen out of twenty death penalty cases, but David got lucky. It wasn't until September of two thousand and three that the Texas state legislature passed to law mandating that the killing of an unborn, viable infant was murder. Texas law requires murder with special circumstances for capital cases, like one committed during the commission of another felony. But Belinda was murdered in nineteen ninety nine, so her unborn but viable baby girl didn't count. It was not a double murder, not a death penalty case. Kelly Siegler was an infamous bulldog of a prosecutor. She wasn't just well known in Harris County or even Texas, but nationally. There was a People magazine article on her. They dubbed her a drama queen. A show about her life was being shopped around for television. However, David's family also hired a very famous and successful lone star lawyer named Dick de Geron. He handled several high profile clients, most notably David Koresh before the Waco Siege, obviously, and Robert Durst. If you've watched the documentary Jinks, you know all about Robert Durst. If you haven't watched it, I highly recommend it. Already suspected in two other murders, Durst was accused of killing his landlord, whose dismembered body parts were found in

12:50 Galveston Bay in two thousand and one. Dick de Geron convinced a jury that Durst didn't kill his landlord, but just dismembered his body. Durst was amazingly acquitted on self defense. Newspapers were calling the Temple trial the Clash of the Titans. Now. Siegler and Dagerran were both known for dramatic courtroom antics, and they had also sparred before. Dagerran had lost Siegler twice. Whether or not he held a grudge, he had an excellent reputation as an attorney who was very prepared and chipped away at witnesses like Perry Mason. According to the Houston Chronicle. With these two on the case, legal wranglings delayed the trial until October of two thousand seven. David had been out on a thirty thousand dollars bond since his arrest in November of two thousand four. Sparks flew at the first hearing in February two thousand five, when da Geran criticized Siegler for not getting an indictment from a grand jury, she told the judge she would, but then Dageron asked for an evidentiary hearing. It was a huge mistake.

13:58 The Harris County Days Office had a policy of keeping their case fall open to defense attorneys. It was more than just a courtesy. Once some defense attorneys saw the evidence against their clients, they made a plea deal unless the defense attorney asked for an evidentiary hearing. Then the DA's office strategically closed their file and only gave up what they had to by law, and they could do it painstakingly slow. By law, they only had to hand over reports after someone had testified, leaving the defense to scramble before their cross examination in court. When DA Gerin asked for the evidentiary hearing, Kelly Siegler looked at him and said, quote, are you sure you want that, dick?

14:43 You know that will close the file. You need to put that in your back pocket. It is very important. A few weeks later, Siegler did get an indictment from a grand jury. She had the gunshot residue evidence from the FBI and ace in the hole that they didn't have five years earlier. I mentioned that in the last episode. It's why they supposedly made the arrest. Degeron lost his evidentiary hearing now that there was an indictment. Under Texas law, he was no longer entitled to the hearing. After a grand jury indict at David Temple. And remember, prosecutors do not have to put on their whole case for the grand jury, just enough to get an indictment.

15:24 Degeron dunked back on Siegler in September of two thousand and five when he got the GSR evidence called into question. Initially, the first report showed gunshot residue on David's clothes and shoes. So while David's arrest was initially based on the FBI's lab finally getting their report back, it wound up being useless. What's more, the DA's office knew that the clothing sent to the FBI would need further testing. Remember what I told you to keep in your pocket In the last episode, A lieutenant with the Sheriff's department had been careful to say that there was no new evidence. The arrest was based on increased work and totality of the evidence. I think increased work and totality of the evidence actually meant that they had scored infamous prosecutor Kelly Siegler because they knew for their testing, specifically, something called metallurgy testing was needed for the GSR evidence to hold up in court. Then The Washington Post wrote a story discrediting metallurgy testing as junk science in September of two thousand and five, in the middle of all the pre trial hearings. It was a pretty big scandal. Faxes were sent out to police departments all over the country. It would call many convictions into question.

16:41 But the DA's office still had David's clothes retested, and months later, in the middle of the trial, the results showed GSR only on David's jacket and could not conclusively link it to the GSR on Belinda's clothes. Dick de Geran, who had been objecting to this evidence all along, went further. His team began looking into the testing process that the articles of clothing had undergone, including the lab facilities itself. During this investigation, the defense team found that the FBI labs shared the same ventilation system as a shooting range, meaning that all of the gunshot residue from the shooting range was going up into the vents and then coming back down into the lab. And a new hearing, the judge sided with the defense. Prosecutors had just lost their only piece of forensic evidence in the case, but they trudged ahead. Siegler felt confident in how the case was going. In total, she put five of the detectives on the stand, but three of the detectives who worked the crime scene defended their investigation under hard grilling by Dick de Garon. They also all testified to David Temple's lack of emotion at the scene, how he avoided eye contact, and how his story kept changing during questioning. When one of the detectives, Chuck Lythner, was on the stand, Kelly Siegler decided to face head on the only ace she believed Dick de Geran was holding. She asked the detective if he had interviewed Joe Sanders Riley. Joe Sanders the third was one of

18:15 Belinda's students and her next door neighbor. He was an admitted pothead who had missed so much school that Belinda went to speak with his parents about his truancy. He had skipped one hundred and thirty one classes already that year. She had also gone to Joe's parents and complained that when they were out of town, sixteen year old Joe had thrown a noisy party and she had to clean beer bottles out of her yard. The next day, Siegler asked Detective Lythner, quote, did there come a time when you were satisfied or completely finished in your mind that you had what you needed from Joe Sanders? And he answered yes. Dick Degarran jumped up and asked to approach the bench. He wanted it on the record that Joe Sanders had failed multiple polygraphs. That is going to be denied. The judge replied, we all know polygraphs are inadmissible in court, but de Geran tried anyway, So he took another tack with the detectives, asking about ammunition found in sanders home. Yes, it was double all shells like the one used in the murder. But what all the detectives were able to testify to was that Joe Sanders and his friends had all been thoroughly investigated. His friends because they were with Joe on the day of Belinda's murder. All of the teens and their parents allowed their homes to be searched, handed over all weapons, and cooperated fully with the police. And yes, there were two twelve gaye shotguns that Sanders had access to, but they had been fully tested. But Dick de Geran called Joe Sanders a thug.

19:45 He said the Temple family had always suspected him, but try as he might, he could not shake the officers. On cross examination. He would have to take his own shot at Joe Sanders later on direct examination when he put on his defense, Kelly Siegler was smart to get out ahead of the Joe Sanders question. It diffused whatever bombshell Dick de Garon believed he would toss out. During the defense, things were going very smoothly. The other witnesses she put on were already damaging to David's character. Quintin Harlan had detestified to his own flirtation with Heather Scott. Heather didn't break up the Harlan marriage, but there really wasn't a un affair to begin with. Quintin was bad for David on the stand. He called him manipulative and calculating, the type of man who planned out everything meticulously. He also said David jeered at him for not controlling his wife the way David supposedly kept Belinda in line as he went out partying at bars and strip clubs. He told Dick de Garon, my wife is strong willed. You'll see he was right. Tammy Harlan, Belinda's best friend in particular, was bad for the defense. She had firsthand knowledge of the problems in the Temple marriage, and specifically how cruel and cold David was to his pregnant wife. He didn't even buy her a gift for her thirtieth birthday. Remember on December thirtieth, when he announced he was going hunting

21:15 and actually spent New Year's Eve with Heather Scott. Brenda Lucas, Belinda's twin, also witnessed that and would testify to it. Brenda said he didn't buy her sister a Christmas gift either. Tammy also knew more about Belinda's daily habits. She said that when Belinda came home, she put her keys in a tray on the table and immediately kicked her shoes off. Remember, Belinda's keys were found on the stairs going up to the bedroom, and David claimed that's where she always dropped them. Already said I thought that was weird, but think about it again. She had a toddler in the house and she's just tossing her keys on the stairs. And also Crimescene photos showed that Belinda was still wearing her shoes Tammy. He also said Belinda would never have allowed David to take Evan without a car seat. This was a point I wasn't so sure about because of court transcripts, but evidently it was not something the defense could definitively dispute. When David was asked, he just said, I have no idea. Dagheran did not try to explain the missing car seat and David's truck. Furthermore, Tammy testified that Belinda certainly would not have allowed David to take Evan to a park when he had been sick. The child had a fever. The soup Belinda picked up from David's mom was still sitting on the kitchen table, and crime scene photos Tammy helped paint a chilling picture. Belinda didn't have time to put the soup in the fridge, kick off her shoes, or put her purse and keys where they normally would be. Why is

22:48 that? Probably because she was ambushed when she walked in the door. Heather Scott Temple was called as a witness for the prosecution, but she was hostile and argued over Siegler painting herself as a victim of police harassment. She was even warned by the judge to stop getting into arguments with the prosecution. You're not going to win, he told her. Still, Heather minimized the affair, saying she was only flirting with two married men, including Quentin, and she even said that sex with David wasn't memorable, causing laughter in the courtroom. She also denied her initial statement to police that three days before Belinda's murder, David told her he was falling in love with her, and she had replied, I feel the same way. I do not agree with those words and my statement, Heather insisted. Siegler asked her if the detective had made the statement up, and then Heather said those words were forced upon her, but the truth is she volunteered that statement. In an interview with Detective Tracy Shipley. Catherine Casey interviewed the detectives about this official statement in her books Shattered, which was really helpful in understanding Heather Scott Temple's later claims of coercion.

24:03 This was a second interview with Heather after a polygraph she had taken had shown deceit. A male detective began the interview being intimidating. He said, you lied to me, didn't you. She said, no, I just didn't tell you everything. He said, that's the same as lying, and then left the interview in a huff. It was good cop, bad cop now. Detective Tracy Shipley began the questioning, but in a softer tone. She still made it clear though, that leaving anything out was the same as lying. Heather started opening up to the female investigator. She said David made her feel good about herself, but she still downplayed the relationship and the number of times the couple actually had sex. But she did say, quote to me, David was not dating me for the sex. He didn't push the relationship on me. I think she wanted to be clear that she wasn't some horse sleeping around with him, but that David was also not really asking her to be in a relationship. Those are contradictory statements, and she shot herself in the foot. Detective Shipley immediately followed up, asking if David had ever told Heather he loved her. Heather said David told her, quote, you know, I think I have totally fallen in love with you. Shipley asked, what did you tell him, and Heather answered, quote that I felt the same. Shipley told her they evaluated a suspect for motive and being in love with someone else could be a motive to kill his wife. Detective Shipley later said Heather gave a small smile and said, you mean you think he killed

25:37 his wife for me. Shipley was disgusted, but nuance doesn't necessarily go into the official statement, but Heather's words did, and when she saw them typed up, she freaked out, especially the part where she said David told her he was falling in love with her. It didn't mean anything, she insisted, but Shipley told her if it was true that David said it, then it needed to be in the report. So Heather begrudgingly agreed to sign the statement, and Detective Shipley dutifully noted her objections and attitude, calling Heather Scott evasive and not forthcoming in her notes. Of course, Heather's polygraph was inadmissible, but her statement was not, and now she was suggesting that she was forced to say all that Siegler rolled her eyes, but it didn't matter.

26:25 Heather's demeanor on the stand spoke for itself, and her next witnesses would bolster the case even more. Throughout the trial, the prosecution maintained that David had access to hunting guns, obviously because no murder weapon was found, but it didn't mean David never had one. Shotgun. Shells matching the type used to murder Belinda were literally found in the same closet where her body was found. There were also two hunting rifles found in the same closet. One was a twenty two and the other a thirty odd six, but no twelve gates shotgun. What David and later his brother and father would testify to is that David only ever had a twenty gage shotgun, which obviously was also not found.

27:11 Their lie might have worked better if they could have produced a twenty gage shotgun, but they couldn't. David's father, Ken would insist though, that he bought his sons Kevin and Darren, twelve gage shotguns, but David a twenty gage, all at the same time in nineteen eighty five for Christmas. His reasoning the twenty gauge was cheaper. That would have been David's junior year in a high school, so you bought your golden boy, star football player, most favored son the cheapest rifle. Kin Temple was also a hostile aggravated witness, snapping at Kelly Siegler when she basically called bullshit on this story. A high school friend of Kevin Temple's disputed all of this, saying that all three Temple sons had twelve gage shotguns and he had hunted with them for years.

28:00 Though he was a reluctant witness, Clint stock Dick was honest. He said the Temple family was like a second family to him growing up. He also said the Temples used reloaded shotgun shells like the one used in the murder. He further testified that all of the Temples, Ken and his three sons used twelve gage shotguns. That's four total plus one that was sought off, But he had never seen a twenty gage shotgun at the Temple house or used by Ken or any of his sons. Clint insisted that David Temple always used a twelve gage shotgun when they hunted. De Gerren could not get him to budge. On cross examination, David's brother Darren also insisted his brother used a twenty gates shotgun. He was really blase about a lot of things on the stand, including whether or not he had lied about his brother's affair to the grand jury. He denied saying David had an affair, So Siegler handed him a copy of his testimony. He replied, there's a definition of affair that I would like to discuss. Kelly Siegler, always quick witted and effectively sarcastic, replied, are we doing a Bill Clinton? Are we going to argue about what affair means? It was an extremely clever come back, even almost ten years after Bill Clinton's sex scandal, and it was not lost on the jury.

29:19 When Darren clarified, he meant unfaithful. Okay, sure, that's not at all the same thing. Circling back, Ken Temple went so far as to suggest that Evan wasn't sick that day. When Siegler grilled him on this, he corrected himself by saying he was quote not well, boy, these Temple men love their semantics. An affair just means unfaithful. Sick enough to come home from school with a fever just means not well. Maureen Temple, David's mother, while not quite as hostile, didn't fare much better. When asked about the affair, She said, quote, well, he spent a couple of nights with a female school teacher, not even naming her now daughter in law, the woman raising her grandson. When asked to clarify, Maureene Temple said it was a two day weekend. I do not know about an affair. I know about a two day weekend. When outright asked if her son was having an affair or not, Maureen lied and said no. Becky Temple, Kevin's wife, was also called by the prosecution. As I mentioned, she had made several comments to people about how she doubted David's innocence and how much she hated Heather Scott, but now she was trying to be a loyal Temple family member. Siegler asked her, do you remember a time, missus Temple, when you had a conversation with Tammy Harlan and you told Tammy that you thought David killed Belinda. Dick de Geran was furious and called for a sidebar. The jury was cleared from the room, and despite de Geran

30:52 saying Tammy Harland was a liar and the testimony was inflammatory, Kelly Siegler informed the judge about the tape records Brenda Lucas had that would prove what Becky Temple had said. With a judge's help, Siegler and da Geran came to a compromise. Becky Temple agreed to stipulate to nine different statements she had made to Brenda. Among those were that she didn't speak to David for months after the murderer, and that her husband Kevin, had a falling out with his mother Maureen over Heather. Remember, Ken and Marine were reluctant at first, but soon decided to accept Heather as part of the family. This had upset Kevin. Becky also told Brenda on tape that she didn't want to see Heather because I don't like to be lied to. A Lot of the damage Becky could have done was mitigated by this compromise, but it still looked bad. None of David's family members helped his case. It would have been better for them to have admitted that, yes, he was having an affair, but he still loved his wife and he was a good father. He and Belinda were having problems, but that doesn't mean he would have killed I think that by having Heather his family and ultimately David insist that there was no real affair, de Geran thought it would take away motive. David had a fleeing. He had no plans to leave or hurt his pregnant wife. That is not the impression his family left with the jury. They appeared defensive, hostile, and at times untruthful. That's the last thing you want from an accused murderer's family

32:24 in court, and Dick de Geran would have prepared them for Siegler's questioning. He was again a very well respected trial lawyer, not just for his performance in trial, but in his exhaustive preparation. There's no way he let David's family get on the stand without preparing them. But de Geran could not control their behavior on the stand, no matter how much he may have tried. Some witnesses just will not save themselves on the stand, no matter how much you try to prepare them. And it's not like he had a choice. They were called by the prosecution. As the trial progressed. There was also much testimony about the rice fields around the Temple family home. Kin Temple reluctantly admitted that his sons knew the acreage around their home very well, so lots of places for David to have disposed of the shotgun between the times that he was caught on surveillance cameras. And there is that witness who saw him at the intersection of Morton Ranch Road and Katie Hockley cut Off between four fifty and five pm. His name was Bug Bendaman and he knew David from high school, but maybe more importantly, he was really into trucks. He was able to describe David's truck make and model, down to the shade of blue it was painted. Bendaman screwed up the timeline for the defense, but actually helps explain the gaps in the prosecution's timeline. The timeline of that day would be important. Belinda came home between three forty five and three fifty five. According

33:57 to David's parents. She didn't leave until three, so it had to be closer to four. David himself had originally said it was four. David also said she was tired, so he told her to go rest as he took their son to go to the park, the son who was so sick he was sent home from preschool with a fever, and Belinda had stopped to get homemade soup for him. And then David and Evan are spotted on a camera at four thirty two at the grocery store, walking back out at four thirty eight. They were not on camera again until fourteen, entering home depot, and then David was home by five thirty. Despite David's claims of traffic, that is thirty six minutes of time he couldn't account for. Though he changed his stories about the parks he took Evan to. His final story was that he changed his mind about the park, decided to stop at home depot and then go home, go home to have dinner with his wife. Actually to take his wife out to dinner, he said he always did on Bunco nights the Ladies dice game. Belinda was expected at LA that evening, except as Tammy Harlan would testify, dinner was served at Bunco. I've played Bunco.

35:07 There is usually dinner, even if it's just or Derv's or pot luck. It's part of the fun. So why would they have gone to dinner before she went to Bunco? Why would he claim they always did when that could be so easily disproven. Brenda Lucas was the last witness for the prosecution. She testified till the last time she saw her sister, on their birthday, December thirtieth, nineteen ninety eight, just twelve days before her murder. Her twin sister was extremely unhappy. David openly belittled Linda, calling her a fat ass in front of her sister. That's right, he called his eight month pregnant wife a fat ass on her birthday. Brenda was able to tell the jury that David told Belinda he was going camping for New Year's Eve, something at this point in trial was an indisputable lie. Some of and his tape recordings were played, one of which David explained that his jewelry wasn't stolen by Belinda's killer because he had been wearing it that day. There was a photograph in evidence of all of David's jewelry, his wedding ring, championship football ring, gold watch, and gold chain were all sitting on a tray in their bedroom when the crime scene text took photos. Brenda didn't just prove he was lying. But if you're a juror, are you asking yourself just why David wasn't wearing his jewelry. Maybe because there would be no chance of getting blood on it. And Brenda had an even more damning statement from David on tape.

36:37 When Brenda asked if he wanted the crime solved, David replied, what difference would it make? It won't bring Belinda back. Then he said Belinda wouldn't want all of this, She'd want us to leave it alone. Someone else had testified to a similar statement. When Quentin Harland testified, he said that a few weeks after Belinda's death, he asked of it if you wanted to know who killed Belinda, David said, what difference is it going to make? It won't bring her back. You know. I gave David some benefit of the doubt in my last episode about the timeline. I do believe the heavy traffic in the area. I do think a man whose wife has just been murdered can be rattled and get a story confused. I do think that some people react differently to crime scene horror, so I even defended David's lack of emotion as possibly shock. But once you get to trial, all the little pieces start adding up to something totally different. Kelly Siegler said, quote, this is a case of little bits and pieces. You put the pieces together, and you have a picture. I'm going to pause now to hear a word from today's sponsors. Once the prosecution rested, Dick de Geron began his case with the opening statement quote, David and Belinda Temple were deeply in love with each other. David and Belinda Temple were happy in their marriage, David was eagerly awaiting the birth of a little girl both David and Belinda

38:09 named Aaron. I guess this was his plan of action all along, but after the disastrous performance by David's family not to mention his new wife, I would have backed off this tactic at least a little bit. When de Geron began his questioning, David said, I loved Belinda very much as well as she me, and loved my son an unborn daughter, as I will to the day I die. Da Geron asked him, can you expect the jury to believe a man can love his wife and be unfaithful? David said, I made a mistake. I wish I could go back and change, but I cannot. But I loved my wife very much from day one to the day she died. Then he was asked to describe his relationship with Heather at the time of Belinda's murder, and he minimized, of course, saying it was flirtatious emails, a casual romantic relationship. Dig Geron asked him, were you in love with Heather? Then David answered firmly not at all. When it came to the question of when David professed his love for Heather. He insisted that Heather and her roommate were wrong, contradicting Heather's official statement. He said, I did not use those words. I did not. He also claimed that Brenda lied about a lot of things, including that he didn't give Belinda a birthday present. He testified that he gave her a purse for Christmas and perfume for her birthday. Heather's roommate, Tara Hall, had testified to

39:42 the nature of their relationship before Belinda's murder, including that Heather confided in her that he had said he was falling in love with her, and she also testified to the roses he sent for Valentines a month after his wife's murder, and how often David was at their condo and would disappear here into Heather's room and the weeks following his wife's death. It's why de Geran's strategy of denial was so ill advised. There were too many witnesses. Tara was at the New Year's Eve party. It was at the condos she shared with Heather. She knew David was there and that he had spent the night with Heather. Siegler went after David easily on cross examination. So when Brenda asked him if he slept with another woman on New Year's Eve on that tape, was he lying yes? David admitted. Over and over she asked him questions about things he had said while Brenda was secretly taping him, and he had to admit he had lied. There were so many things he lied about, stupid things like dinner before Bunco games and how Belinda always dropped her keys on the stairs.

40:46 He could have easily just said she dropped them by mistake that day because she was tired, But he was trying to stick to his original statement as much as he could, and he was also trying to casually revise it places, shifting times around, insisting that Evan woke up perky and full of energy. He said that boat Bendaman, who saw David miles away from where he claimed to be that day, must have been mistaken. To his credit, he did not seem to get rattled the same way his wife and family had. He appeared self spoken and reasonable. But when you have to admit to lying that many times, or simply saying I have no idea, it doesn't matter how calm your demeanor is you're still a liar. When Siegler asked him about their sixteen year old neighbor, who was Belinda's student, David said, I do not trust that Sanders kit. He said they'd had problems with him before. To be fair, Belinda did find those beer bottles in their yard after his party, but that's a far cry from cold blooded murder. Kelly Siegler asked, are you telling this jury that you really believe Joe Sanders is the person who put a shotgun in the back of your wife's head and blew her face off. I have no idea David shot back. I wouldn't doubt it one bit if he did it. David also denied having a twelve gage shotgun that Clint Stocktic had described as For the sawtoff shotgun he had, he said he threw it away because it didn't work. You didn't own a shotgun,

42:20 Siegler asked, no. David insisted, and what about the twelve gage shells found in his closet. He said, I don't know exactly where the shotgun shells came from. They were from previous use, is what I said. De Geron asked David about the alternate suspect Joe Sanders. What is your conclusion from these things? He was talking about the shotguns the Sanders had willingly given to the police for testing. David said, I would not like anybody to be falsely accused, because I know how that feels. But that needs to be totally investigated. De Geron recalled Detective Dean Holtke, who again tested that yes, two twelve Gage rifles were found in the Sanders household, along with the same size shells as the one used in the murder. But once Siegler was able to cross examine her witness he was able to testify that no glass or blood was found inside Sanders shotguns and that the reloaded shells didn't match Dick. Degerren also trotted out the Roberts family kids now teenagers, who said they heard a boom like a gun shot at four thirty five while watching a movie. Because David was on camera at four thirty two, Degeron was still trying to prove the timeline wasn't possible and that someone else shot Belinda at four thirty five, but the Roberts kids were the only ear witnesses. De Geron was able to produce. No other neighbors heard a shot. The defense rested and the prosecutor called one final witness in rebuttal. Joe Sanders, now,

43:53 a twenty four year old, clean cut young man, sat down on the witness stand. Questioned him about what he did the day of the murder, about how he had cut classes and spent most of the day either smoking pot or looking for more pot. Yes, he had been grounded after Belinda spoke to his parents about his truancy. His parents took his truck away, but Joe said he wasn't angry. He just left school at lunch time and took his truck back. He was polite and talked about how Belinda Temple was kind to him. He said he saw her daily at school and went to him quote whenever he needed help. He even said he saw her in the halls and she would joke with him, telling him to hurry up and get to class. She was a very nice lady, a good teacher, he said.

44:38 He also described how he had been cooperative from day one, voluntarily testifying at the grand jury without a subpoena. He gave repeated statements to police. Siegler asked him why he agreed to talk to the detectives because I wanted to, he said, I didn't try to hide. When Dagherin got up to cross examine Sanders, his first question was, have you been told you wouldn't be prosecuted for your testimony? Kelly Siegler jumped up and objected, and the attorneys got into a heated argument. Degeron was insinuating that Joe Sanders had been giving immunity from prosecution for Belinda's murder. In fact, he was given immunity for being charged with possession of marijuana back in nineteen ninety nine for agreeing to talk to detectives. This wasn't a drug case, it was a murder case.

45:30 As everyone waited, the judge read back over the original grand jury testimony and agreed with Siegler. The testimony explained they were talking about marijuana, the judge said, Dick de Geran said, but it doesn't. The judge then angrily warned Degeran, your question is absolutely trying to mislead the jury. Degeran went back to questioning Sanders, basically shooting rapid fire questions, hoping Sanders would slip up. Instead, Sanders remained calm admitted to smoking pot, skipping classes, and insisting he was not angry with Belinda Temple. He even told the court about how the week before the murder, he was out shooting shotguns with his friends and then riding around and his friends had knocked down some of the Temple Christmas decorations. He said he made the other boys put them back up.

46:23 Dick de Gerren was never able to rattle Joe Sanders. He couldn't catch him in a lie because Joe wasn't lying. While David Temple had also remained calm, he had been caught in numerous lies. Closing arguments began the morning of Wednesday, November fourteenth, two thousand, seven eighty A. Craig Goodheart began for the prosecution, pointing at David Temple that man executed Belinda and his unborn child, a cold blooded murder, There's no doubt about it. Did the Sheriff's department make mistakes? They probably did, but that didn't mean that David wasn't guilty. Not one of the shotguns the defense pointed to, including those at the disposal of Joe Sanders, tested positive for glass blood or brain matter, and there was no evidence against Joe Sanders, What does your gut tell you? He asked, Goodheart finished with David Temple is the only human who had motive, opportunity, and the desire to kill his wife. De Garin came out swinging with his alternate suspect, there is more circumstantial evidence against Joe Sanders than against David Temple. Do I think the evidence against Sanders is enough for a conviction? No, but there is stronger evidence against him than against David. Kelly Siegler then stood up for her closing argument rebuttal. She said, no matter how much you want to deceive, no one can do

47:53 it perfectly. You know they lied to you and insulted your intelligence. Temple family denied everything, acted like it never happened. Why because the family knows him. Because the family knows what happened. Facing the lack of a murder weapon, Siegler said, why don't we have the murder weapon? Because he got rid of it. She also pointed out that even though David had said he checked Belinda's pulse specifically he said he checked her cardo at artery, there had been no blood on his clothes or hands. Then she said, quote, why was Belinda executed in the closet because David the planner realized it was the most protected room in the house, without windows and surrounded by clothes to muffle the sound of the gun shot. Then Kelly Siegler went after Dick de Gerin's alternate suspect. She said, quote, Joe Sanders, you know what you learned from Joe Sanders. He came here from Arkansas without a subpoena.

48:54 And what did he tell you? I smoked weed. You know with all your heart that David Temple is guilty, she said. The jury deliberated for a couple of hours that last day of court and then rested for the night. The next day, they came back with a verdict fairly quickly. In eight hours, they found David Temple guilty. It took even less time for them to recommend he spent the rest of his life in prison. I'm going to pause now to hear a final word from today's sponsors. For years, David sat in prison for the murder of his wife. But five years into his sentence, his attorney got a break. A man named David Glasscock approached Dick Nageron, supposedly after he caught a TV special on David's case. One night in May of twenty twelve, after seeing the special, Glasscock felt uncomfortable with information he had been sitting on about Belinda's murder. He told d garn that back in nineteen ninety nine, he had over heard a disturbing story shared by one of his high school buddies that not long after Belinda was killed, he was at a friend's house when he heard a story about a burglary that had gone wrong. One of the guys said that he had to shoot a dog and put it in the closet during the theft. Glascock assumed a dog was code for Belinda, but he did not share the information with anyone else until he made the call to David's defense attorney. The friend that Glascock was

50:27 referring to was Riley Joe Sanders, the third Dick Degeron's alternate suspect. Dick Geron believed Daniel Glascock's story, which would later fall apart under more scrutiny, But the fire under Dick de Garren had been lit again with the help of a man named Stephen Claphart, an investigator at the DA's office. The evidence and information about the Belinda Temple murder investigation was re examined, and it was learned that almost fourteen hundred pages from the Temple case fall had been withheld. Only parts were given to the defense, and only during the trial after direct testimony. One of the main things the defense claimed to have found was that Joe Sanders was indeed a real suspect in Belinda's murder, a fact detectives disputed in David Temple's first trial. They all testified that he had been ruled out as a suspect. What they did find in the file was that a deeper investigation into Joe Sanders was not brought up at trial. Between January eleventh and February first, Joe was interviewed six times by several different officers and provide a police with conflicting statements. Joe said he was allowed to use his dad's guns whenever he wanted. Police found out that early in January, Joe had taken his dad's twelve gate shotgun without permission and then gave the gun to his friend Cody Ellis to hide. The teen did hide the gun under his bed, but it was surrendered to the police the moment they asked to search the Ellis

51:59 home. As I told you about in the first trial, all the shotguns the police seized were tested, including those that belonged to Sanders as well as the Temple family. None of the rifles tested positive for blood, brain matter, or glass. And as I told you in the last episode, the medical examiner had concluded that the gun had been put directly at the back of Belinda's head, and he testified that there would have been blowback on and in the barrel of the gun, and a firearms expert testified at the first trial and explained that shotgun barrels do not have rifling, a series of grooves cut into the barrel that leaves striation marks on the bullets, so shotguns cannot be positively identified through ballistics the way other guns can. The best thing the prosecution could have found would have been David Temple's twelve gage shotgun, if for anything, just to prove he had one. And it is much more difficult than some people might be to clean a gun and leave absolutely no evidence. Lab tests more than likely would have shown blood on the guns tested. The other issue de Geron and ap Pellet attorney Steve Schneider used in David's appeal is that Joe also failed three polygraph tests, which included the question did you kill Belinda Temple? Now, polygraphs can't be used in court. We all know this, but twice during the first trial, de gern argued to get them in.

53:30 But in the file records, on February first, back in nineteen ninety nine, police told Joe's parents that he couldn't be excluded as a suspect, and on February tenth, Ada Ted Wilson ordered police to continue investigating Joe Sanders. De Geron would later say the defense learned that many investigators thought Joe Sanders was a viable suspect, but it was Kelly Siegler who had decided not to pursue the investigation against Joe, much less prosecute him. Aaron said Sanders was cleared as a suspect because Siegler had already set her sights on David Temple, but Assistant District Attorney Donna Good had agreed with Siegler. She said, teenagers don't usually make good criminals. They tend to be impulsive, leave evidence, get caught. The way the evidence laid out Belinda Temple's murder was not like that. It was a calculated crime. Remember, Kelly Siegler was brought on as a special prosecutor by the Harris County day after the Lacy Peterson case had put pressure on their then five year old case. David Temple was their only suspect. As a team, Harris County detectives and prosecutors had cleared Joe Sanders for years. Da Geron and Appellet attorney Stanley Schneider accused Siegler of withholding evidence because the defense didn't have all of the files during the original trial. They claimed they only knew that Joe had skipped school and that Belinda had complained to his parents about his behavior. Degern and Schneider also said they didn't know the

55:04 names of Joe's friends, or the fact that two of Joe's friends had also flunked their polygraphs when asked if they knew who killed Belinda, but investigators at the time had thought these tests could not be conclusive. All the boys admitted to have tripped on LSD around the time they took the polygraphs, and of course smoked a lot of pot. Those drugs can cause paranoia, which can look like deception. During a polygraph examination. When Joe Sanders was asked to take a polygraph for the fourth time, it was his parents who refused permission. They said he had been through enough and was distraught over the brutal murder of his teacher. Furthermore, the polygraph examiner explained that he didn't interpret their tests to mean that they may have been involved in the murder, but that they knew something they weren't Divulging. Investigators also pointed out that Joe and his friends had been in special classes at Katie High School. They had lower IQ's, so one of their teachers helped the examiner form the questions. The examiner finally asked one of the boys who he thought killed Belinda Temple, and he said, my mom told me David Temple did it. The original question had been do you know who killed Belinda Temple, and the boys had answered no.

56:21 They were trying to be truthful about if they personally knew who killed Belinda, and there had been no physical evidence whatsoever to tie Joe Sanders, Cody Ellis, or his other friend Corey Reid to the Temple house. De gern and Schneider had theorized that the teenagers looking for cash to score more weed, had broken into the temple home, surprised Belinda, and then killed her because she was a witness. But the scene at the Temple House had looked methodical. The only things out of place were some opened drawers and that t V set carefully on its side. Belinda's jewelry box sat untouched on the dresser near the closet where she was murdered. David's jewelry lay on a tray on a table with a TV nearby. Belinda's purse had been found in the downstairs closet.

57:12 Nothing had been stolen, Her cash and credit cards were still there. If the teenagers were on drugs looking for cash, they didn't look very hard. They didn't take anything that could have been pawned, and they didn't leave a mess you would expect, and they certainly didn't leave any fingerprints or DNA to prove they had been in that house. But according to Dick de Gern, Joe Sanders took his eight month pregnant teacher and neighbor to her closet and executed her. De Gerren and Schneider also alleged that Heather Scott had been coerced into making that statement about her and David declaring their love for one another in the days leading up to Belinda's murder. I already discussed this in detail because I did know it came up on a pill. Heather only balked once she saw her words writing. She was not coerced. She was questioned by a seasoned detective who knew that Heather's ego would trip her up. She didn't like being thought of as a whore or a one night stand, and she was in love with David. But David's attorneys filed an appeal stating that David's conviction needed to be overturned due to all the new evidence they were just uncovering.

58:22 A two and a half month long writ hearing was held with Judge Larry Guest presiding. Under Texas law. During the time of the first trial, the defense was titled to the police reports, which made up many of the fourteen hundred pages that were uncovered in the investigation, but they were only entitled to the reports after the officer had finished testifying. But they believed, now many years later, that Kelly Siegler had purposely excluded evidence and particular officers from testifying so that she would not have to provide them with all of the evidence. Siegler also determined as lead prosecuter, what was exculpatory and what evidence she deemed untrue and irrelevant. During the writ hearing, thirty witnesses and two hundred exhibits were examined. The defense argued that Brady violations had been committed through prosecutorial misconduct, causing David to have an unfair trial. Brady violations, for those that are unfamiliar, have to do with the state or prosecutor in a case not handing over evidence that could benefit a defendance case. Under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, a prosecutor has a duty to disclose favorable evidence to defendants upon request if the evidence is material to either guilt or punishment. Failure to comply with this duty has become commonly known as a Brady violation. It was named for a precedent setting case from nineteen sixty three called Brady the Maryland. Kelly Siegler testified at the writ hearing that she didn't give the defense all the material regarding

59:54 Riley Joe Sanders because she thought it was irrelevant and ridiculous. Siegler later stated, I would give them all the discovery they were entitled to, piece by piece, day by day, very slowly and very miserably, they got what they were entitled to have. She said she was going by the hard rules. The defense felt emotion for continuance, but were denied, And I think this is what sunk Kelly Siegler. Her ego was too big. She first ignored subpoenas to appear at the hearing, and when she did come, she was haughty and sarcastic. She was obviously irritated that her judgment had been called into question. It's not that she was wrong, it was her manner.

1:00:38 She did not come off as professional, but as disrespectful. And I do think it's important to note that Kelly Siegler was following the letter of the law during the David Temple case in two thousand and seven. The Michael Morton Act wasn't signed into law until twenty thirteen. I covered Morton's case of wrongful conviction in episode one ten. The Act, signed into law, requires prosecutors to open their files to defendants and keep records of the evidence they disclose. The Daily Sentinel reported that Judge Giest sided with defense lawyers who claimed Kelly Siegler violated this quote central tenant of modern criminal law by not handing over the information she knew about that could have been helpful in David Temple's defense. Well that central tenant was not an effect in two thousand seven, reporters were basing their opinions of Kelly Siegler in the year two thousand sixteen. At the end of the hearing, guests found that Kelly Siegler had committed thirty six distinct acts of prosecutorial misconduct in the case of David Temple. Judge Giest recommended that David Temple receive a new trial due to the Brady violations. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals would look over Judge gifts recommendation and make the final decision. Judge Gifts said trial counsel's performance was not perfect, but much of the difficulty he faced was driven by constant resistance of the trial prosecutor to reveal necessary information. Trial counsel continued to seek helpful information from the prosecutor, but little was disclosed prior to

1:02:13 trial. It was literally impossible for trial counsel to sufficiently investigate verify it or dispute the disclosures. Following this, Kelly Siegler said, just because one judge made these ridiculous findings that none of us can understand, he's not the final say. The Court of Criminal Appeals is, thank god, and she was right. On November twenty third, twenty sixteen, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals granted David a new trial. A little less than a month later, in December twenty sixteen, he was released from prison to await his retrial. Kelly Siegler was absolutely demonized in the press, understandably so. According to Judge Giest, either her conduct had gotten a murderer out of jail or an innocent man had sat behind bars for almost ten years. The Houston Chronicle was particularly scathing in their reporting on Kelly Siegler, but they weren't the only ones.

1:03:10 Many reporters believed that Siegler used the Temple case to bolster her TV career, and for the record, Siegler and her show Cold Justice have been sued twice now for defamation. She was also sanctioned for withholding evidence in another case, and it was a capital murder trial. While it's alarming to see the claims of defamation, prosecutorial misconduct, and other shady behaviors of Kelly Siegler. It's not surprising that this kind of behavior was borne out of the Harris County District Attorney's office, which has an upsetting track record itself. Harris County, Texas, has executed more people than any other county in the United States since nineteen seventy six. The Houston Law Review study of the death penalty cases found ninety six percent of cases, judges accepted the prosecutor's findings without additional investigations or evidentiary hearings. Kelly Siegler had won nineteen out of twenty capital cases, and since the year nineteen seventy five, three people condemned to die in Harris County were later exonerated. I admit because of the writ hearing and the supposed thirty six distinct acts of prosecutorial misconduct, I began to have my doubts, especially once I read all the articles about Kelly Siegler's practices. Because of the defamation lawsuits, col Justice was put on hold. It's still undecided if the show will

1:04:41 come back. Then I came across an article in the Houston Press by Craig Melso. He said, in the rush to persecute Siegler and make a martyr of Temple, the media neglected to compare guests findings to the trial record. If they had, they would have seen that the findings don't stand up to scrutiny. They're afflawed and often contradictory assessment of what actually occurred at trial. A closer look doesn't suggest proof of a reckless prosecutor caught in her tracks, but of shrewd defense attorneys able to kick up enough dust to cloud a judge's vision. So I got curious, and I decided to look a lot harder at David's first trial than I had planned. It At all seemed fairly straightforward to me in the beginning. Now I wanted to see these contradictions for myself.

1:05:32 This is why I decided to split the episode into two parts. In that Houston Press article, most notably, Craig Melso pointed out de Geron had taken over the case in November two thousand and four. By the time he sought an examining trial in February two thousand five, he had had two months of unfettered access to the case. Guests findings don't acknowledge that de Geron simply took a legal gamble and lost. Do you remember that part earlier in this episode that I said to keep in your back pocket? I told you it was really important. When Dick de Garon asked for the evidentiary hearing in February of two thousand five, Kelly warned him. She said to him, are you sure you want that? Dick? You know that will close the file.

1:06:23 David Temple was arrested on November thirtieth, two thousand and four. The pre trial hearing where Dick de Garon asked for an evidentiary hearing was on February first, two thousand and five, meaning he did have all of December and January to look at all of the evidence the DA's office had on his client and on his alternate suspect, Joe Sanders, and Kelly Siegler warned him that in case he had forgotten, he still had access to all the evidence she had unless he insisted on the evidentiary hearing. As I told you, Harris County had a policy of keeping their evidence opened for defense attorneys. It wasn't just to give them a fair shot. It was more because once they got to look at the evidence against their clients, most attorneys wanted to plea bargain.

1:07:12 So Dick de Garin was full of shit. He was either too lazy to look at the file, which from his reputation is hard to believe, or he specifically asked for that evidentiary hearing to close the file. Kelly Siegler later said Dick was a prosecutor before a defense attorney. He should have known asking for the exam trial was a dumb move. How do you prepare for a circumstantial evidence case without seeing the evidence, unless, of course, that was his strategy. He saw the evidence, knew Joe Sanders had been rightly dismissed as a suspect, but using him as an alternate suspect might sway the jury. That would only work if David had come off a sympathetic and truthful which he didn't. Or maybe da Geron figured he might could leave an opening for his client on appeal and that did work. David's second trial began on July ninth, twenty nineteen, twenty years after his wife's murder, and during this time, Heather fold for divorce from David. Obviously, no public reason was given, and she did not change her testimony from the first trial.

1:08:24 She still tried to protect David. Following the finding of prosecutorial misconduct in the first trial, the Office of the Texas Attorney General acted as a special prosecutor in the retrial. Their case was still that David killed Belinda, but this time they theorized that David split up the tasks of killing her and staging the burglary. According to the prosecution, David could have killed Belinda between the times she got home and when he left to run errands, then staged the burglary when he got home before he ran to his neighbors for help. Prosecutors said that there was time between leaving the grocery store and arriving at home depot when David could have gone somewhere to throw the shotgun away. The defense's theory was that Joe Sanders killed Belinda and that the timeline proved David couldn't have killed her.

1:09:15 According to David's father, Belinda was at his house until three fifty five p m. That meant Belinda probably didn't get home until four twelve p m. David was seen on a surveillance camera entering the grocery store at four thirty two p m. Based on those times, David wouldn't have had time to kill Belinda between four twelve p m and four nineteen p m when he left to run errands. The defense also re emphasized that there was no physical evidence tying David to the murder. During the trial, Joe Sanders testified that he had nothing to do with Belinda's murder. He was now thirty seven years old and married with children. He told jurors that the murder of his former school teacher had stayed with him his whole life, along with the suspicion against him.

1:10:04 He was Riley Joe Sanders the Third, but he didn't want to keep the tradition and give his son his name because it was still so tied to Belinda's murder. Joe Sanders's ex girlfriend from high school also testified for the prosecution, telling the jurors that her then boyfriend wasn't very good at keeping secrets and that he told her after Belinda's murder that she was one of the only teachers who truly cared for him and wanted him to succeed. And the whistleblower David Glascock, who started this whole thing, didn't testify a trial. They couldn't use him. He kept contradicting himself on what he knew and when, and it came out that he didn't even know the murder weapon was a shotgun until Dick de Geran told him during his first interview. Glascock, with his own record of an assault conviction from two thousand and eight, showed a substantial criminal history and a predilection for drugs. That assault conviction was from when Glascock pulled a man from his car and beat him so severely he required seven metal plates to be surgically inserted into his face and head. It wasn't some silly bar fight. He almost killed a man and a road rage incident. Daniel Glascock had no independent knowledge of the murder except what Dick de Gern fed him during their interviews. Also, as it turns out, Glascock's original epiphany, which he said came from watching a documentary about the murder on the Investigation Discovery Network,

1:11:35 couldn't even have happened when he said it did. The show didn't er at all in the month of May or any surrounding months, So essentially, David Temple was put on trial with the same evidence. There was just more detail about Joe Sanders and his friends during the initial investigation, and it didn't help Temple's case one bit. On August six, two thousand nineteen, David was once again found guilty of murder. The jury was tasked with coming up with a sentence for David, with the possibility ranging from probation to life. They deliberated for twenty hours but were unable to make a decision. Two people wanted probation, six wanted between thirty and forty years, and four wanted life.

1:12:23 Because of this indecision, the judge had to declare a mistrial. For the sentencing phase of the proceedings, David's bond was set at one million and a sentencing hearing was set for March of twenty twenty, but due to COVID nineteen, David's sentencing was again delayed. His family was not able to pay that high of a bond, so David has remained in jail while awaiting his sentencing trial. Because of the deadlock jury. During the sentencing phase of his second trial, David Temple and his counsel requested a third trial rather than a new jury that would only review the conviction and possibilities for sentencing, instead of getting to see an entire trial played out before them. State law from nineteen ninety nine, the year of Belinda's murder, required the same jury to determine guilt and sentencing. That law changed in two thousand and five before David's first trial. Now a different jury could be seated just to determine sentencing. David's attorney's request for a new trial was made in January of twenty twenty, but was denied. Since then, there has been no movement on the case because of the pandemic. Evan Temple's testimony during the sentencing portion in his father's second trial was seemingly enough to impact the jury. Now in his mid twenties, Evans still believes his father. He also considers Heather Scott, David's now ex wife, to be his mom, as she raised him the majority of his

1:13:56 life and has treated him as her own. He's a college guy working as an accountant and is happily married. I am glad Evans seems to be living such a happy life, and I am looking forward to a very unprecedented trial just for sentencing a mistrial only on the sentencing portion is highly unusual. And though I believe David Temple is guilty, I'm not sure I agree that this new jury should only hear evidence of his guilt. I think it should be a whole new trial. What's the harm Glascock as a witness has been neutered, so to speak. Joe Sanders was never a viable suspect, so let's put it all on again. It's not like this case hasn't received enough publicity that new jurors won't know a lot of this anyway. What worries me is that the publicity of Kelly Siegler's misconduct has overshadowed the fact that she did do her job, even if she had turned over every bit of evidence to Dick de Garin before trial. I do not believe that reasonab bulgerors would believe that a pot had sixteen year old would execute his pregnant teacher, and that even if he would, he would leave no evidence at the scene. David Temple was a meticulous man. I don't think you even need to split up that timeline. He had been home with Evan since around one pm that day.

1:15:19 He easily could have staged the break in before Belinda ever walked through that door. No, I believe David Temple met his wife at the door with his shotgun. Evan had a fever. He probably gave him simochron and put him to bed. Belinda would not have screamed. She would not have wanted Evan to see this. I think he grabbed her purse in the soup and then marched her up the stairs to their bedroom. She dropped the keys on the way. He probably did choose the closet as the most soundproof room in the house. Maybe he told her to get on her knees. Maybe Belinda crouched down, protecting her belly and unborn child as her husband, the man she loved despite everything, put a shotgun to the back of her head as she begged for mercy and blew her beautiful face off. Southern Fried True Crime is produced by me Erica Kelly. Today's episode was researched and written by me I also edited this long episode, so apologies if it isn't perfect, and I'm sorry for the weight. I found so much more detail I wanted to include, and I hope you found it as fascinating as I did. I think we'll all be following in this case, and I'll make sure and update you on social media when David does finally get his sentencing trial. Southern Fried's original music is by Rob Harrison of Gamma Radio and the original graphic art is by

1:16:51 Coly Horner. I've been reminding y'all, but don't forget to come find our new Facebook group search for Southern Fried True Crime Fans Discussion, and please submit case suggestions to Southern Fried Truecrime at gmail dot com. I do not accept suggestions on social media, and I apologize if I am unable to answer your email. I get dozens of suggestions a week and it takes me time to go through and check out each case. I will definitely contact you if I plan to use the case you submit to see if you would like to be credited in the episode. Thank you all so much for sending in these cases. I truly get my most interesting cases from listener suggestions, so keep them coming. If you enjoy today's show, don't forget to subscribe and please tell a friend or rate and review on iTunes. I'm also on most large platforms like Stitcher and Spotify, as well as Stitcher Premium, where you can listen add free until next time. Thanks so much for listening, y'all. Take care,