Nov. 4, 2026

107: "The Last Medicine": Requesens and the Limits of Conciliation

107: "The Last Medicine": Requesens and the Limits of Conciliation
107: "The Last Medicine": Requesens and the Limits of Conciliation
I Take History With My Coffee
107: "The Last Medicine": Requesens and the Limits of Conciliation

Philip II called the general pardon “the last medicine,” a remedy to soften minds in the Netherlands. In November 1573, Luis de Requesens arrives in Brussels to administer it. He is a capable diplomat, a loyal servant of the king, and a man who begged not to be sent. What Philip gives him is not a policy but a stack of contradictory instructions: offer mercy but concede nothing. Talk to the rebels but never about religion.

This episode follows Requesens through two years of impossible orders. We cover the pardon that came too late and with strings attached and the siege of Leiden, which William of Orange broke by flooding the countryside. We also cover the formal talks at Breda, where the two sides agreed on nearly every political point but still could not settle, and an unpaid Spanish army that mutinies in Antwerp. Behind it all is a king whose treasury is running dry. Drawing on Geoffrey Parker, Pieter Geyl, Jonathan Israel, C. V. Wedgwood, and Requesens's own dispatches, we ask whether it matters who is in charge.

By March 1576, the governor is dead, and no successor has been appointed. The army he could not pay remains unpaid and is about to march on Antwerp.

Support the show

Find us on Substack. Both Free and Premium content is available:

https://substack.com/@itakehistorywithmycoffee


Podcast website: https://www.podpage.com/i-take-history-with-my-coffee/
Follow me on Facebook, Instagram, and Threads.


Comments and feedback can be sent to itakehistory@gmail.com.
You can also leave a review on Apple Podcast and Spotify.
Refer to the episode number in the subject line.

If you enjoy this podcast, you can help support my work to deliver great historical content. Consider buying me a coffee:
I Take History With My Coffee is writing a history blog and doing a history podcast. (buymeacoffee.com)

Visit audibletrial.com/itakehistory to sign up for your free trial of Audible, the leading destination for audiobooks.

Intro Music: Hayden Symphony #39
Outro Music: Vivaldi Concerto for Mandolin and Strings in D

00:00 - Coffee-Sized History And A Desperate Letter

00:42 - A New Governor Replaces Alba

03:15 - Requesens The Reluctant Fixer

07:00 - Pardon Promises With Strings Attached

08:50 - Leiden Starves Under Blockade

13:23 - Floodwaters Break The Siege

15:59 - Breda Talks And The Religion Wall

22:08 - Mutiny, Bankruptcy, And A Governor’s End

26:19 - No Governor, No Money, Army Still Marches

28:11 - Next Episode Tease And Ways To Support

Welcome back to the I Take History With My Coffee podcast where we explore history in the time it takes to drink a cup of coffee.

Luis de Requesens, Letter to Philip II, July 1574
“I believe anyone would be at a loss in the state in which I found things here and given what has happened since; but if there is someone who could remedy them, I wish they would entrust them to him, because I confess I cannot do more.”

On November 17, 1573, a Spanish nobleman rides into Brussels and is well received. He is lodged in the house of the exiled Cardinal Granvelle. His name is Luis de Requesens, and he has come to take over the government of the Netherlands from the Duke of Alba.

Alba is stuck in bed with gout and tells Requesens to take over immediately, but Requesens refuses. For almost two weeks, he keeps his distance, wanting to learn about the country first. He also knows people would see a quick takeover as the same old policy with a new face. He finally takes charge on November 29. Alba leaves on December 18.

From the road, Alba offers his advice. In a letter dated New Year's Day, 1574, he tells his successor to devote all his time to the war. Don't mention any arrangement with the rebels at all, he says, and don't let anyone else speak of one either, even if one should arise later. And don't alter the established order to win the favor of the natives.

Requesens begins by listening. He distances himself from two commanders, Romero and Noircarmes, who had been quietly reaching out to the Prince of Orange. Historian Geoffrey Parker notes that the disasters of 1574 will prompt Requesens to rethink his approach.

Meanwhile, the Netherlands is watching. Dutch historian Pieter Geyl openly says the supposed policy change was all show and meant nothing. Within weeks, a correspondent for Cardinal Granvelle reports that the new governor is broke and that the promised pardon is being delayed until there is some success.

This is the third governor in our story. Margaret of Parma held the position but lacked the resources. Alba had the power and no limits. Now, Requesens arrives with moderate instructions and is about to learn what they truly mean. This is the story of a capable man facing an impossible task.

Luis de Requesens is about forty-five. Born in Barcelona in 1528, he was the son of a nobleman who tutored young Prince Philip. Requesens grew up in the prince's household and became one of Philip's most trusted aides—first as ambassador in Rome, then as governor of Milan. He was a negotiator before he was a soldier. He was not much of a sailor either; he once lost galleys in a storm that a more experienced man might have avoided.

He has his critics. A Netherlandish writer called him inept, and Granvelle's correspondent Morillon says there's not a jot of rhyme or reason in him. 

He did not want this job. In February 1573, letters sent in his name ask Philip to let him off. He says his health is failing and he has only a few years left. He has a wife and a young son. He even suggests Granvelle for the job instead. On February 26, he writes that he is going under compulsion, as if being sent to the provinces were a punishment. By the time he reaches Brussels, he says he is ready to die and sees no way out.

What Philip hands him is not a policy. It is a stack of papers pulling in opposite directions. One letter calls the general pardon "the last medicine" and urges its publication to soften minds. But the same letter adds that Philip will concede nothing inconsistent with his authority, even if he should lose the provinces. A secret instruction forbids Requesens from softening the heresy laws without first asking and directs him to maintain every appearance of normality. No pardon for anyone convicted of religious offenses or rebellion. The Council of Troubles remains. The States are not to be called without an order.

And Philip, in his own hand, admits he does not know whom to believe. Alba says it is about religion, and there can be no compromise. The loyal Netherlanders say it is about ill-treatment, and mildness would work. As Parker tells us, Philip's answer is the middle road, with "complete dissimulation."

To his credit, Requesens tells the truth. The nineteenth-century archivist Louis Gachard describes his dispatches as a faithful account, noting that he asked for orders at every step. In July 1574, he tells Philip that things are stuck in a ravine, that he can find no way out, and that force will not end this. One caution: his own papers were burned in the castle of Antwerp. What survives on the Spanish side is found in the letters he sent to Philip. 

In 1574, Requesens tries to make peace. But this is less significant than it might seem.

A general pardon is announced, though with exceptions, after Philip delays it until then. It comes out in early summer. There is talk of ending the unpopular Tenth Penny tax and the Council of Troubles, Alba's special court. But even in May, Requesens writes that both are still pending, and he plans to keep the Council in some provinces. He says he will only drop it if the provinces give him money. These concessions are offered with strings attached and depend on payment.

In March, Philip authorized talks with the rebels, provided they did not prejudice his authority or religion. So through the spring and summer, envoys went to Orange. A man named Hugo Bonte met him in April. Two more reached him in July. And Philip van Marnix, one of Orange's closest advisers, was sent on parole to carry word.

Orange's answer never changes. He is the servant and elected defender of the States. He will do nothing without them. He would leave the country if they agree. But he will not ask for a pardon, because, in good conscience, he cannot believe he has offended the king. Requesens's view on that: subjects must not set limits on their prince. The day the king does not have his troops here, he says, he will not have the Estates either.

That summer, the war has a name. Leiden.

Leiden has been under blockade since last autumn. In March, Requesens lifts the blockade to face an invasion led by Orange's brother Louis. After the Spanish win at Mook in April, the blockade is put back in place in late May. This is not like Haarlem—there are no attacks. The Spaniards wait for hunger to force a surrender.

Inside are about fourteen thousand people, a militia, no garrison, and a council of cautious men. The citizens have been reduced to a ration of malt cakes, water, and meat from horses, dogs, and rats. The memory of Haarlem and Naarden remains fresh in the minds of Leiden’s people. A contemporary narrative has them exclaiming: “we will each devour our left arm, retaining our right to defend against your tyranny and prevent your bloodthirsty men from scaling our walls.” 

As the food runs out, the Spanish commander, Valdez, writes on September 5, offering a pardon to everyone, including three leaders by name. At a meeting the next day, a majority wants to treat. The motion that passes is to ask Orange to release them from their oath. A speech is attributed to the mayor, Pieter van der Werf: "I cannot break my oath; but if my body can serve you, cut it in pieces and distribute it among yourselves". 

Orange responds with water. On July 30, the States of Holland decide to flood the land, even though some worry the water might not reach Leiden and could ruin the farms. On August 3, Orange watches as a dike near Capelle is cut, one of sixteen breaches. Soon after, he falls ill with fever in an empty convent in Rotterdam. According to C. V. Wedgwood, Orange knows his cause cannot survive another defeat like Haarlem.

Next comes the fleet commanded by Admiral Boisot: flat-bottomed barges, eight hundred sailors from Zeeland, and carrier pigeons for messages. On September 10, they leave Rotterdam, break through an inner dike that night, but then get stuck. A direct attack fails. The problem is the water is only about a foot deep, but the boats need eighteen inches. For about nine days, the fleet waits within earshot of the town.

On September 29 and 30, a northwest gale and a spring tide push the sea up the river mouths. By October 1, the water is three feet deep. The fleet advances. During a night attack, the Spaniards flee across the flooded land.

On Sunday, October 3, in the mist, a boy leaves the city walls, walks into the Spanish fort at Lammen, and finds it empty. The fleet arrives by canal, and soldiers throw bread to the starving people.

Leiden today celebrates Leidens Ontzet every October to commemorate its liberation in 1574. 

 After Leiden is relieved, Spanish troops mutiny, and Valdez is captured by his own men. The Spaniards withdraw from South Holland, except for Haarlem and Amsterdam. This is what Requesens had expected.

After Leiden, Requesens grows more willing to talk. In late November, he sends a Netherlander named Leoninus to Orange in person. His instructions: give Orange no hope that religion will be heard. Orange receives him at Middelburg on New Year's Eve. He replies that the States will never abandon the new religion and that even if he wished to, he could not make them.

Then, in February 1575, the formal talks at Breda begin. The king's commissioners arrive on the fifteenth. The two sides first meet on March 3. The rebel delegates will deal only in writing and in Dutch. Philip had approved many political concessions in advance and forbade only one thing: religion. By Parker's count, the two sides agree on almost every political point. Requesens even offers a pardon and the restoration of property and privileges for Catholics, and six months for Protestants to sell up and leave.

Gachard's reading of the correspondence shows that Requesens himself rejects a truce that three of the four royal commissioners would have accepted. He will grant an armistice only if the new religion is suspended and the preachers expelled. In July, he writes that if the question were four towns or four kingdoms, they could settle. But it all depends on religion. The talks end on July 13.

Parker's verdict on Breda is that it bought the rebels three months of respite and recognition and brought Spain three months closer to default.

Philip had called the pardon “the last medicine.” Breda is where it is tried. The commissioners agree on nearly every condition, but the one point left standing is the one Philip will not move on. The medicine is on the table, and no one is allowed to swallow it.

Money, though, becomes the bigger problem.

Requesens arrives with nothing. By his own count, the army is owed more than three million, and old debts add five million more. So he borrows on his own signature: over eight hundred thousand escudos by July 1574, over a million by August, and one point two million by September. He tells Philip he would accept stones in exchange to keep the state going, but cannot find even a single real. He says his estate is worth a tenth of what he owes. He sells his furniture. He writes to his wife to sell the jewels.

Philip is not indifferent. Money does flow. In 1574, Castile sends the Army of Flanders about three point seven million ducats, but it is never enough, and by 1576 the flow has fallen below one million. Philip's entire revenue is under six million ducats a year, half of which goes to interest. He is fighting the Turks, who retake Tunis that autumn. In private, Philip despairs. He tells his secretary that everything is lost for want of money. In public, there is silence.

An army that is not paid does not remain an army. The mutinies began under Alba at Haarlem in July 1573. The Spanish veterans were already owed twenty months' pay and were given four months' pay as storm-money for a town that had surrendered on terms and could not be sacked. They mutinied. Alba paid each man thirty escudos. Then he arrested the ringleaders and shot them twenty at a time, despite the pardon. He also withheld the promised money from the sick, the wounded, and the families of the dead.

In April 1574, the same men, fresh from victory at Mook, mutiny again. They march into Antwerp and elect a leader and a council. This is not a riot. As Parker puts it, mutiny had become almost an institution. The soldiers elect a leader with absolute authority, a small council, and a secretary. They post fly-sheets with their demands. Pay for themselves and for their dead comrades. A hospital. A surgeon and a chaplain for every company. No beatings without a trial. And a safeguard signed by the King himself, because they remember Haarlem.

It ends with accountants. They work from muster lists compiled in 1567, seven years out of date, listing men as young and healthy who are now scarred. In the end, nearly 5000 men are paid half their claims. In a church, they are pardoned and paid in cash, while the creditors wait outside. The cost, Parker says, was a million florins and perhaps Spain's only real chance of winning the war.

Requesens knows it at once. The mutiny, he tells Philip in May, has shut the door on every road God seemed to be opening. In July, an official named Hernando Delgadillo describes how Requesens complains that it was not Orange who had lost the Low Countries, but the soldiers born in Valladolid and Toledo. The mutineers had driven money out of Antwerp, he said, and destroyed the king's credit. Within eight days, His Majesty would have nothing left.  Parker's verdict on the mutineers is simple. They had no program. They just wanted to be paid.

On September 1, 1575, Philip's government stops paying its bankers and declares bankruptcy. People in Holland celebrate with bonfires. For Requesens, he says the decree breaks his heart.

He is already mounting his best operation, an advance across the estuary to the islands of Zeeland and the siege of Zierikzee (Zee rik zay). He and Orange both believe the revolt's fate rests on it. His agent in Madrid, Zavala, tells the king that what has been sent would not keep the war going for a month. In November, Requesens writes to his own brother that no one in Antwerp has any credit, that he cannot find a single penny, and that the whole machine will fall into ruins so quickly he may not have time to say so.

In December, the States of Brabant refused to send more money until talks were reopened. Now no one in Brussels can pay the army or send it home.

In February 1576, Requesens leaves Antwerp for Brussels, arriving on the eighteenth. A couple of days later, a boil appears on his arm, accompanied by fever and severe pain. On the fifth of March, at four in the morning, he dies after receiving the sacraments. He is about forty-seven. He had governed for two years, three months, and four days.

Historians disagree on the illness: plague, says Parker; typhus, says Wedgwood. A letter from his colleague Roda, the closest thing to a primary source, describes a carbuncle and fever. Roda writes to Philip that they are left as orphans.

There is no successor. The day before he died, he dictated an act dividing his duties among three men: Berlaymont for administration, Mansfelt for war, and Roda for money. He was too weak to sign it. So the Council of State, nine mostly elderly men who had been sidelined since Alba's arrival, meets and decides to take the government itself. The Duke of Aarschot, head of the Croy (kroo wee) family, says in a debate that if the king sends a Spaniard no greater than himself, he will withdraw to his house. Roda warns that a Spanish governor will be abhorred and that sedition is near. The mutinous light cavalry has grown to nearly five hundred men.

Philip will name Don John of Austria in the spring to go without troops. He will not arrive until November.

So, does it matter who is in charge?

For Requesens the man, yes. That is why this story is sad. For the outcome, no. Parker argues that Philip never told his governors where the limits were. So every setback went back to Madrid for a fresh decision. And with a round trip of weeks, the answer often arrived after events had already moved on. We have touched on this pattern again and again throughout this series. 

The pardon of July 1573 reached Alba six weeks late. Distance also defeated the idea of sending a milder governor, in 1571 and again in 1573. 

Philip called the pardon “the last medicine.” But a medicine only works if the physician can adjust the dose. Requesens can’t. Every change goes back to Madrid, and the answer comes back weeks late.

However, the historian Jonathan Israel argues that the impasse was two-sided: Holland's towns could not settle without public Protestant worship, even for a more pliant Orange. At Breda, Requesens enforced the line himself. Philip’s brief was impossible to fulfill, but he did not try to break it. Don John, who would soon be asked to take the job, offered his own diagnosis in 1575: the king lets people govern who take no responsibility for what does not touch them.

Spring, 1576. Brussels has a council but no governor.

Strangely, the army is still at its posts. At Zierikzee, on the Zeeland islands, the siege continues through the winter and into the spring. Parker notes that the troops seem unaffected by Requesens's death or by the bankruptcy. The danger is not yet a break. No one can pay this army, and no one can send it home. The Council of State has no authority over it. Brabant withholds funds until talks reopen. And Philip, in Madrid, does not answer.

In Rome, our old friend Cardinal Granvelle, who has watched all of this from a distance, writes to Philip that if the town falls, the army will sack it and mutiny. By the time he writes, it already has. Zierikzee surrenders at the start of July. At once, the Spanish troops mutiny and head for Brabant to collect their pay. 

And irony waits in the wings. The terms Orange could not secure at Breda, he will secure at Ghent, after the mutinies and the sack.

The one governor who told Philip the truth is dead. The army he could not pay remains unpaid. And on the morning of November 4, 1576, that army marches on Antwerp.

That is the next episode.

As always, maps and other supporting resources for all episodes are listed in the episode description. In the meantime, for more historical content, become a free or paid Substack subscriber and get related historical content delivered to your inbox.  We’re on Facebook, Instagram, and Threads.  Feedback and comments are welcome at itakehistory@gmail.com.  Or you can leave a review on Apple Podcasts or on Spotify.  You can also help support this podcast by buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com/itakehistory.  If you know anyone else who would enjoy this podcast, please let them know.  And thanks for listening.