Reviews

I know it just came out and I am happy to wait but my dream is for you to one day cover The Bone Temple. It has dad-son dynamics and satanists!!

I love you Alex, truly. I just miss Sarah. The recent episode of Anchorman was a new low with endless nervous laughter between movie quotes. Perhaps the least quote worthy film to be quoted. Those who do seam to have an entirely misunderstood meaning of film. It felt beneath the material and quality of cere once so earnestly equated with this show. I miss Sarah. She would have shut up the guest in immediate sharp quip that intelligence can cut. Please consider your sources when fishing out guests. Maybe ask your listeners instead of a random pizza guy guy. I love you Alex but managing hosting is not your mastered forte. You need a cohost to reel your guests in time and time again. I am not enjoying the show as of late, I’m hating the choices of fims. I am reluctant to write this out of fear of being perceived as a hater but it is the damn truth. I miss old You Are Good. Lately we aren’t good and we need that extra extra. Please. Upgrade the films & guests or don’t have a guest at all. I would rather hear you all cover more meaningful material.

This is such a special show. Alex, Sarah, and their guest hosts do an incredible job using movies to peel back societal layers and gently explore the beautiful, chaotic, poignant, desperate, and hilarious aspects of being a human in the world and in community. Their observations and thoughts allow us to be curious, reflective, and occasionally critical of the way we interact with the world, and allow for gentle growth. The heart they and their team put into each episode shines through every time, and I’ve never walked away unhappy with anything other than that it ended. Thank you Alex, Sarah, Miranda, Caroline, and everyone who makes this show, your care makes the world a whole lot better!

I discovered this podcast on a solo drive across the country in 2021 and have been listening to it religiously ever since. It’s the podcast of my dreams and the hosts are just the best. Please never stop making this podcast, it’s a part of my being now! My absolute favorite

This is such a cozy listen, even when the episode centers on a not-so-cozy film. This isn’t the kind of movie podcast where you’ll get the scoop on behind-the-scenes mayhem or the various quirks of production (yes, we know the damn shark was broken), but rather what a film says to us now. Alex Steed is a phenomenal host, who brings a wry sense of humor balanced with an incredibly generous capacity for compassion and humanity. Sarah Marshall is at the top of her game, witty and inspiring. Their individual backgrounds bring such a unique frame to each film featured, and the pair’s long friendship only serves to heighten the conversation. I really appreciate how down to earth this show feels, even when discussing the most unearthly of films. One of the shows best features is its ability to find unexpected connection to the films, bolstered by a diverse rotation of guests. Too often I find myself reaching for a forgotten favorite or discovering a new movie that scratches an itch I didn’t know I had. Especially right now, while it feels like the world is crumbling, You Are Good is a hopeful, bright piece of humanity.

I listen to several movie pods, the ones I stick with give me something other than the recap and same hot takes on the characters story arc. YAG is truly a feelings pod about movies and I take away so much every time I listen. Cheers to Alex and the guests for the wonderful conversations and perspectives. Thank you for allowing me to glimpse my favorite films through your lense.

Love this podcast! It’s like hanging out with old friends. It’s always so interesting to hear someone else’s take on a movie I love, without any pretentiousness or judgement. It reminds me of why I love films in the first place, the conversations they inspire.

The show is a delight. No matter who’s hosting, who’s guesting or what movie is up for discussion, I know I’m gonna get a funny, moving, enlightening and engaging discussion that somehow or other changes my perspective on something. Every episode is like a warm blanket. It’s too easy to forget how much we all need the weekly reminder that we, “my friend, are good.”

I want to share my profound admiration and sincere gratitude for the exceptional content you consistently produce. Your podcast(s) stand out as a truly unique and enriching experience, offering a remarkable blend of insight, depth, and genuine engagement that I find both stimulating and consistently uplifting. The dedication and collaborative spirit you both bring to your discussions are evident in every episode, creating an invaluable resource that deeply resonates with your listeners. It is rare to find a platform that so reliably delivers both intellectual nourishment and authentic entertainment. Alex, your individual contributions are particularly captivating. Your distinctive vocal delivery possesses an engaging charm that effortlessly commands attention, making even the most intricate subjects thoroughly enjoyable. This, coupled with your sharp intellect and incisive wit, creates a magnetic presence that ensures every moment is compelling, regardless of the topic at hand. I would happily listen to you read a Sear’s catalogue. I am immensely thankful for the significant effort and passion you invest in your work. Your collective talent is a genuine asset, and I eagerly look forward to every new release.

I love the show more than words can say. It has gotten me through so many hard times where I felt so alone and like nobody understood what was going on. And then I’d listen to the show and I’d realize that I was not they would discuss things that I deeply related to. It truly may have saved my life at certain points. I’m neurodivergent and I live alone on an island which I really enjoy but can be lonely and the show helps to separate the loneliness. So do yourself a favor and make it a part of your life.

This podcast remains a weekly comfort and joy after years of listening. Whether I have seen the movie or not, I always feel like I have spent quality time with good friends. During these bleak times we are living through, I’m grateful to the wonderful cast of folks who make this show, it is evident it is a labor of love.

This pod is my perfect blend of reality and escapism. Any iteration of this crew and their guests make me go “OH” about my real parents, The Movies. Alex Steed is the sex positive heir apparent to Fred Rogers and an aural ballast in these trying times.

This show is great, both hosts are great! Alex is doing a great job, Sarah is making another cool podcast. Why are we writing review’s that should like we know them irl? It is weird (derogatory) to write a 1 star review and internet yell at one host because the other host is doing another thing.

Alex, Sarah, Carolyn, and their friends have life-giving conversations about art, friendship, grief, heartbreak, silliness, curiosity, delight, love… and so much more. This is not a Very Serious Movie Boys Have Very Correct Thoughts Podcast. Thank goodness. There are plenty of fish in *that* sea. This is a pod for lonely nights and frustrating days and everyone trying to stay human and hopeful and tenderhearted in spite of it all.

This show is absolute magic. We are truly lucky to have Sarah & Alex share it with us.

thank you for thoughtful examination and relatable commentary. this is a comfort podcast for me (along with various other alex steed / sarah marshall properties!). thanks for the countless hours you spend putting these episodes together so that i may have something to entertain my brain and make me laugh while assembling zines + doing various other tedious, repetitive tasks! 🖤

It’s the best feelings podcast about movies around. Alex rules and his choice of guests is top notch. My friends and I have an ongoing list of movies to watched based of this show and the references you make. Thanks for sharing love!

The perfect show about movies, in which a collection of beautiful freaks talks about feelings through the lens of pop culture and film. Unpretentious and raw at times, it feels like a cozy coffee date with your smart friends.

i’ve been listening to ‘you are good’ since 2020. alex and sarah kept me company while i gardened and cleaned my way through covid and have become my regular touchstone for a dose of queer, neurodivergent, leftist sanity ever since. this show is incredibly unpretentious and has such a humanistic approach that i do think it has made me a better, kinder person all while genuinely improving my cultural fluency around essential viewing i never got around to. finally, if you’re a scaredy cat about horror like me, they do a great job making scary movies accessible. i love this show and think (if you’re cool), you might, too!

Sarah, Alex, and guests of their choosing always produce episodes that are lively, sweet, and surprising, no matter the subject.

I’ve been listening since the show was in its first iteration and it’s the only podcast where I’ve never skipped an episode. The hosts and guests are always the most thoughtful people and because it’s foremost a podcast about how movies impact us personally, the format makes the episodes accessible and relatable even if you’ve never even heard of the movie being reviewed.

This podcast is a spark of light and a reminder of our shared humanity in an increasingly chaotic world. I'm not smart enough to analyze movies or feelings with the emotional intelligence and care of the hosts, but I am smart enough to miss high school English book discussions. This pod scratches that itch!! Alex's voice is now a go to portable comfort for me (OBGYN in Louisiana, on call with a crazy sleep and work schedule which can be isolating and sometimes I just need a little human boost).

I love this show- thank you Sarah and Alex! ❤️ It’s so refreshing to hear people look at these movies as art, and talk about what the art means to them, or what it meant in the context of the time/place it was made, and by whom. Looking forward to hearing more episodes!

I came from YWA for Sarah Marshall and cinephile talk stayed for the wisdom about literally anything and everything, particularly from Alex. So much goodness here. Thanks, guys.