Welcome to The Whole Hearted Woman!
November 10, 2026

Season 2 Episode 10: The Surrendered Life: When Your Heart Wants One Thing, but Trusting God Requires Another

Have you ever prayed about something, surrendered it to God, and then found yourself trying to take control of it again? Perhaps there's something you've been holding tightly—a relationship, a decision, an unanswered prayer, or an outcome you desperately want to see change. You love God. You trust Him. But letting go isn't always easy, especially when your heart is deepl…

Season 2 Episode 10: The Surrendered Life: When Your Heart Wants One Thing, but Trusting God Requires Another
The Whole Hearted Woman
Season 2 Episode 10: The Surrendered Life: When Your Heart Wants One Thing, but Trusting God Requires Another

Have you ever prayed about something, surrendered it to God, and then found yourself trying to take control of it again?

Perhaps there's something you've been holding tightly—a relationship, a decision, an unanswered prayer, or an outcome you desperately want to see change.

You love God. You trust Him. But letting go isn't always easy, especially when your heart is deeply invested in what happens next.

In Episode 10 of The Whole Hearted Woman Podcast, Kris Rey takes us into the Garden of Gethsemane, where Jesus prayed in the hours before His arrest and crucifixion.

Through Matthew 26:36–46 and Luke 22:39–46, we explore what Jesus reveals about bringing our deepest desires honestly before the Father while surrendering to His will.

We'll talk about the fears and beliefs that can make surrender difficult, the difference between trusting God and trying to control outcomes, and why surrender doesn't mean denying our feelings, abandoning our responsibilities, or passively accepting harmful circumstances.

Surrender doesn't mean pretending you don't have desires. It means bringing those desires honestly before the Father and entrusting yourself to His will.

If you've been wrestling with something you cannot change, trying to figure everything out, or wondering how to trust God when the outcome remains uncertain, this conversation is for you.

Because living a Whole Hearted life isn't about having everything under control. It's about learning to trust the One who holds us, even when we don't know what comes next.

Scripture: Matthew 26:36–46; Luke 22:39–46

Your Whole Hearted Step: Consider something you've been trying to control. Bring it honestly before the Lord. Tell Him what you desire, what you fear, and where you're struggling to trust. Then ask Him to show you what is yours to do—and what you need to entrust to Him.

Connect with Kris and explore more resources:
Heart2HeartMinistry.com

You are seen. You are deeply loved. And the Shepherd is still speaking.


About the Podcast

The Whole Hearted Woman Podcast with Kristen Rey is a faith-based podcast for women who love God — or want to — but know there are parts of their heart that still need healing. Through Scripture, emotional insight, and Spirit-led reflection, each episode helps women move from surviving to living from a whole heart.

If this episode spoke to your heart, follow or subscribe so you can continue the journey.

SPEAKER_00

Have you ever prayed about something and known exactly how you wanted God to answer? I mean, you weren't confused about what you wanted. You knew. Maybe you wanted a relationship to be restored. Maybe you wanted a difficult situation to get solved. Maybe you were praying for healing, provision, or an opportunity. Or perhaps you were standing at a crossroads and one direction felt comfortable and familiar, while the other required you to trust God in ways you never had before. And you prayed, you asked, you believed. But somewhere in the middle of all that praying, you began recognizing something. You weren't simply bringing your desire to God. You were holding tightly to the outcome you wanted. And perhaps you found yourself saying, Lord, I trust you. But somewhere deep inside there was another thought. As long as you do what I'm asking. You know, I think we can love Jesus deeply and still struggle with surrender. We can believe that God is good and he is. And we can know that his ways are higher than ours, and they are. And we can quote Scripture about trusting him. And yet, when something matters so deeply to us, realizing our grip can feel frightening. Because the fear is what if it doesn't happen? Surrender isn't always about giving up something we know is wrong. Sometimes it's about entrusting something good, something precious, or something deeply desired to God. And today I want to take us into one of the most sacred and moving moments in Scripture, the Garden of Ghessene. A place where we see Jesus in profound anguish, a place where he prays honestly to his Father, a place where we hear words that reveal the heart of surrender. Nevertheless, not my will but yours be done. What does that mean for us? What does it look like to live with a surrendered heart when the circumstances are difficult and the outcome is uncertain and what we want is not what lies before us. That's what we're going to explore today. Welcome to the Wholehearted Woman Podcast. I'm Chris Ray, and this is season two, The Wholehearted Life: Learning to Live from a Heart Formed by Jesus. Throughout this season, we've been exploring what it means to live wholeheartedly, not simply knowing God's Word, and not merely understanding our wounds or recognizing our patterns of that support. But always allowing Jesus to form the way we live. In our last episode, we explore the scary Jesus before we talk about what it means to receive patience and recognize it that we never depend it till it's completely self-sufficient. lives. Today we're going deeper into what it means to depend upon God Because there are moments when we can do everything we know to do. We know we've played with sufficiently patient. We've considered our options and we've tried to make the wisest decisions, but yet we still find ourselves facing something we can't control. In those moments, the questions become can I trust God with what I cannot control, even when I desperately wish things were different? So before we open the word, let's pray. Father, thank you that we come to you honestly. We don't have to pretend that we're not afraid. We don't have to hide our desires from you, and we don't have to act as though difficult circumstances aren't painful. Jesus, as we look at your prayer and Ghessanome, help us to see your heart. Help us to understand what it means to trust our Father, even when obedience is costly. Holy Spirit, show us where we've been holding tightly to something that we need to entrust to you and give us the courage to respond to your leading. In Jesus' name. Amen. I'd like to begin with something I think a lot of us have experienced. Some of us believe we're trusting God because we're praying about something. And prayer is absolutely an expression of dependence upon Him. It's a language, it's a holy language. But I wonder whether there are times when we've already decided what the answer should be. We know what we want, we know how we'd like things to unfold. And so we pray, hoping God will bring about that outcome. Maybe we're asking him to open a particular door or to change someone's heart, or we're asking him to remove a difficulty. Maybe we're asking him to restore something that we've lost. And there's nothing wrong at all with bringing those desires before God. Scripture actually encourages us to bring our request to him. But what happens when the answer isn't what we had hoped? What happens when the door doesn't open? When the person doesn't change, when the situation remains difficult, when the healing doesn't come in the way we expected, or the answer to our prayer doesn't come and it seems to be like it may never come. That's where we begin discovering what we've come to believe about trust. These situations bring that up in us. Because sometimes without realizing it, we begin measuring God's faithfulness by whether he gives us what we want. And we have to be honest about that because deep in our hearts, that is true for a lot of us. If it's not true for you, I'd have you reconsider that. And if he doesn't, we begin wondering whether he even hurt us, whether we prayed correctly, whether we had enough faith, or whether he's disappointed in us. Our minds go through all sorts of things and things come up in our hearts based upon not getting an answer to our prayer or waiting for an answer to our prayer. So I'd like us to consider something. God's faithfulness isn't measured by his willingness to fulfill every desire we bring before him. And trusting him doesn't mean we're guaranteed the outcome we're hoping for. Sometimes trust means continuing to walk with him when the outcome is different from what we wanted. And that's not easy. And I don't want to pretend it is, but that's why I think Gesemy is so important. Because there we see Jesus bringing his anguish and his desire honestly before the Father. So let's go to Matthew 26. Jesus has shared the Passover meal with his disciples. He knows what lies ahead. His betrayal is approaching, his arrest is near. He is moving toward the suffering and death that he came to endure. Jesus goes with his disciples to a place called Gethsemane. He tells them to sit while he goes to pray. And then he takes Peter and the two sons of Zebedee with him. And Matthew tells us that Jesus begins to be sorrowful and troubled. Listen to what Jesus says in Matthew 26, verse 38. My soul is very sorrowful, even to death. Remain here and watch with me. I want us to stop for a minute because sometimes we imagine surrender as something calm, peaceful, or effortless. We picture someone who has reached a place of such extraordinary faith that nothing troubles them anymore. But that's not what we see in Gethsemane. We see Jesus in deep anguish. And we need to understand that his anguish is not evidence of a lack of faith. Jesus is without sin. He is not struggling with disobedience the way we sometimes do. He is facing the suffering and death that lie before him. And his sorrow is real. Surrender does not require the absence of sorrow. I think that's something many women need to hear. You can trust God and still grieve. You can obey him and still feel afraid. You can know that he is good and still wish your circumstances were different. Faith doesn't require us to pretend that painful things don't hurt. And Jesus shows us that honest prayer belongs in the life of surrender. Matthew tells us that Jesus walks a little further, falls on his face, and prays. My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me. Nevertheless, not as I will, but as you will. Think about those words. If it be possible, Jesus is not pretending that the suffering ahead is insignificant. He brings his desire before his father. And then he says, But nevertheless, not as I will, but as you will. And here we see something extraordinary that we need to pay attention to. Jesus' surrender is not the denial of his desire, it is his willing submission to the Father's will. He doesn't say that what lies ahead will be easy. He doesn't pretend that the cup is pleasant. He prays honestly and he submits himself to the Father. Now Jesus' experience here is unique. He is the sinless Son of God, willingly moving toward the cross for our redemption. Our personal difficulties are not equivalent to what he was about to endure. But his prayer teaches us something essential about trust. We can bring our desires honestly before God while remaining willing to obey him. And that raises a question for us. Can we tell God what we want without making what we want the condition of our trust? And that's worth sitting with. I think surrender is one of those words we use frequently in Christian conversation. Let's think about this. We sing about it, we pray about it, we talk about surrendering, everything to Jesus. But what does it actually mean in everyday life? Does surrender mean we stop caring? No. Does it mean we stop praying? No. Does it mean we no longer make decisions or take responsibility? Not at all. Does it mean we simply accept whatever happens without considering whether something needs to change? No. Surrender is not passivity. It's not giving up our responsibility to act wisely. It's not remaining in a harmful situation because we believe suffering must be God's will. Definitely not. And it certainly doesn't mean allowing another person to control us in the name of obedience to God. No. Surrender is about our relationship with the Father. It's about yielding our will to His. It's about choosing obedience when our desires pull us in another direction. And it's about entrusting the outcomes we can't control to Him. Sometimes surrender means taking action. Sometimes it means waiting. Sometimes it means walking away from something. Sometimes it means staying faithful to a responsibility. Sometimes it means releasing an expectation. And sometimes it means accepting that we can't make another person choose what is right. But in every case, surrender calls us to bring our hearts honestly before God and respond to what He is asking of us. So I want to bring this into our everyday lives. Because I think there's a difference between having a desire and allowing that desire to govern us. Sure, we may desire a particular outcome, and that's fine. A restored relationship, there's nothing wrong with that. A different job, financial security, a better position, healing, a new opportunity, an answer to prayer. And all of those desires are good. But sometimes something begins to shift. What began as a desire now becomes an expectation. And then the expectation becomes something we feel we can't be okay without. We begin thinking, if this doesn't happen, I don't know what I'll do. If this person doesn't change, I'll never be at peace. If God doesn't open this door, everything I work for will be wasted. If this situation doesn't turn out the way I want, I won't be able to move forward. And suddenly our sense of peace has become tied to an outcome we can't control. So I want to be careful here because there are situations in which our needs are genuinely urgent, there are losses that do change our lives, and there are circumstances that require real help, protection, and action. Surrender doesn't make those realities disappear, but it does invite us to examine what has begun governing our hearts. And that's what we're always looking for. We can ask, am I bringing this desire to God, or have I begun entrusting that God fulfill it before I can trust Him? And that's not always an easy distinction to recognize. It's very subtle, but it's an important one that we need to pay attention to. So throughout the Wholehearted Woman, we've explored how our experiences can shape the ways we respond to life. And sometimes our desires for control have roots we may not immediately recognize. Perhaps maybe you've experienced seasons when life felt unpredictable. Maybe you depended upon people who were inconsistent. Maybe you learned that the best way to avoid disappointment was to anticipate everything that could go wrong. And over time, you became very good at managing circumstances. You plan ahead, you prepare for problems. What if this, what if that? You take responsibility. You try to make sure nothing can fall apart. And those abilities may have helped you navigate difficult seasons. But sometimes a pattern that once helped us feel safe at one time begins influencing how we relate to God all the time. We pray, but we keep trying to manage every detail. We ask him to lead, but we struggle when the direction isn't clear. We say we trust him, but we're constantly trying to secure the outcome. And perhaps beneath all of that is a belief we haven't recognized. What if it says, if I don't stay in control, I won't be safe? Or what if it says, if I don't make this happen, it won't happen? No, not every desire for control comes from a wound. A wise planning is not the same thing as unhealthy control. But I think it's worth asking, what am I afraid will happen if I release my grip on it? Because sometimes the difficulty isn't that we don't believe God exists or that we don't believe God is powerful. Sometimes the difficulty is that we don't know whether we can trust him fully with something that matters so deeply to us. And that's where our hearts need his transforming work. Let's return to Ghessene. After praying, Jesus comes back to his disciples and he finds them sleeping. He asks Peter whether they could not watch him just for one hour, and he tells them, Watch and pray that you may not enter into temptation. The spirit is indeed willing, but the flesh is weak. Then Jesus goes away and prays again. Matthew 26, 42 records his prayer, My Father, if this cannot pass unless I drink it, your will be done. And later he prays a third time. And I think there's something important here. Jesus continues praying. He doesn't treat prayer as a one-time statement. He remains in communion with the Father as he faces what lies ahead. And that's worth remembering. Sometimes we imagine surrender as a single moment. We pray, Lord, I give this to you, I surrender. And then we expect never to feel troubled about it again. But our experience may be telling us something completely different. We may surrender something today and find ourselves anxious about it tomorrow or an hour from now. We may trust God with a decision and still experience uncertainty and anxiety. We may release an expectation and still grieve what we hoped would happen. That doesn't automatically mean our surrender wasn't insincere. Sometimes we need to return to prayer again and again, not because God didn't hear us the first time, but because our hearts need to remain connected to Him as we walk through the process. And you shouldn't feel embarrassed for feeling that anxiety and that uneasiness through these situations, because it's a call to have Him walk with you in the process. That's what it's saying. It's knocking on the door of your heart. So surrender is not merely something we say, it's a posture we continue learning to live, even if we have to do it over and over and over again. And there's something about Ghessene that we can't overlook. The cup did not pass from Jesus. He went to the cross. Hallelujah. And through his obedience, God's redemptive purpose was accomplished. And I want to be careful about how we apply this. We should never tell someone that every painful circumstance they're experiencing is something God specifically wants them to endure. And we should never use Jesus' suffering to pressure someone into remaining in abuse or accepting injustice or refusing appropriate help. Jesus' journey to the cross was unique, but Ghessene does teach us that obedience to God is not always accompanied by the removal of difficulty. And that's important. Because sometimes we begin believing that if we're walking with God, he will always make the path easier. And he does eventually or in some other way. But scripture doesn't promise that the outcome will be exactly what we want. Jesus himself told his followers that they would experience trouble in this world. Yet he also told them to take heart because he has overcome the world. And that's where surrender becomes deeply relational. We don't surrender because we don't understand everything God is doing. No, we surrender because we trust the one to whom we're surrendering. And that trust is rooted in who he has revealed himself to be. And it always will be. He will always be faithful, holy, merciful, wise, and loving and just. And I'd like to speak now about something that may be important for some women listening today. Sometimes the word surrender can sound frightening, especially if you've experienced relationships where your needs, your opinions, your sense of self, and your desires were diminished, ignored, completely overlooked. Perhaps someone told you that being loving meant never disagreeing. Or maybe that a good Christian means never saying no. Or trusting God means tolerating behavior that is harmful. So I want to be clear: biblical surrender to God is not the same thing as surrendering your judgment, your dignity, or safety to another person. Jesus' obedience to the Father does not give another human being the right to control you. You can surrender to God and still establish boundaries, you have to. You can trust God and still seek protection, you must. And you can obey him and still speak truth about wrongdoing. You can forgive someone and still recognize that trust has been broken. And you can love someone without accepting responsibility for their choices. Surrender isn't about becoming powerless before other people. It's about entrusting yourself to God and allowing him to lead you in truth. And that's especially important as we learn what it means to live wholeheartedly. And I'd like to make another distinction because surrender can sometimes be confused with resignation. Here's the difference. Resignation says, there's nothing I can do. I guess I just have to accept it. Where surrender says, Father, I don't know how this will unfold. I may not understand what you're doing, but I want to remain faithful to you. Resignation can come from hopelessness. Surrender is rooted in trust. Resignation may stop engaging and you may shut down. Surrender continues seeking God. Resignation may say, nothing matters anymore. Why bother? Where surrender says, what matters most of all is that I remain connected to you because my needs will be met and the way and my path will be clear before me. And sometimes surrender involves taking a difficult step of obedience. Sometimes it involves releasing an outcome. Sometimes it involves asking for help. And sometimes it involves accepting that a door we desperately wanted to open has remained closed. But surrender doesn't mean our lives stop moving forward. It means we allow God to lead us forward. And here we are back at this question that I ask in every episode. So, what does a whole-hearted woman look like and mean when she's learning to surrender? She's not someone who never experiences fear. She's not someone who has stopped having desires. And she's definitely not someone who always knows exactly what God is doing. No, she's someone who is learning to bring her whole heart before Him. She brings her hopes, her dreams, her disappointments, her questions, her fears, her desires, even her reluctance. And she's a woman who's learning to pray. Father, this is what I want. He's a God that supplies our needs and he wants us to ask. This is what I'm afraid of. This is what I'm struggling to release. This is what I don't understand. But I want your will more than I want to remain in control, because what you see is far different than what I see. Sometimes we may have to pray that more than once. Sometimes we may need wise counsel so that our eyes can be opened. Sometimes we may need to take a step before we feel completely confident, and that's trusting Him also. But she's a woman who continues to. Turning toward God. Because a surrendered heart isn't a heart without desires. It's a heart that is learning to trust God with them. And here's what I'd love for you to do this week. Find a quiet place with Jesus and ask yourself, what am I holding so tightly that the thought of releasing it makes me afraid? Maybe it's a relationship or a decision or a particular outcome or worry about the future, an expectation you may have been carrying for years. Or maybe it's a plan you've worked hard to build. Or maybe it's simply your need to know what's going to happen next. Whatever comes to mind, bring it honestly before the Lord. You don't have to pretend you don't care. You don't have to minimize what you're feeling. And you don't have to manufacture a sense of peace. Just bring it honestly before God. And you might pray something like, Father, this is what I would like. This is why it matters to me. And this is what I'm afraid will happen if things don't turn out the way I hope. And then ask, Lord, what does being faithful look like for me right now? Is there something you're asking me to do? Is there something I need to release? Is there a step of obedience I've been avoiding? And then maybe pray the words Jesus prayed, not my will but yours be done. Not as a way of denying what you feel, but as an expression of trust in the Father who knows you and loves you. And if you keep finding yourself struggling again tomorrow, return to him again. Keep praying, keep listening, keep walking, because surrender is a relationship, not a performance, and not something to be afraid of. Father, thank you that we can bring our whole hearts before you, our hopes, our fears, our desires, our disappointments, all of it. And the things we've been holding so tightly to because we're afraid of what might happen if we let go. Jesus, thank you for showing us what perfect trust and obedience looks like. Thank you for willingly going to the cross for our redemption. And thank you that through you we can come confidently before the Father. Holy Spirit, reveal the places where our desires for control have begun, governing our choices. Show us where fear has made surrender difficult, and help us recognize the difference between taking faithful responsibility and trying to control what belongs beyond our reach. Give us wisdom to know when to act, the courage to obey, and patience when we must wait. And peace as we continue trusting you. Father, we don't want to bring you only the desires we're comfortable releasing. We want to bring you everything, even the things that matter most to us, the things we're afraid to lose, the things that we don't understand. And so we pray, not our will but yours be done in Jesus' name. So before we finish today, I want to leave you with something. Surrender doesn't mean you stop caring. It doesn't mean you stop praying, and it certainly doesn't mean you have to pretend that something difficult isn't painful. It means you're learning to trust the Father with what matters so deeply to you. And perhaps today Jesus is inviting you to release your grip on something you've been trying to control. Not because it doesn't matter, but because it matters enough to bring honestly before you. Remember, a wholehearted life isn't a life where we always get the outcome we want. It's a life where we continue walking with Jesus, leaving him to form our hearts, even when the outcome is uncertain. And the trust to know it will be even better than what we imagined, because he sees things we don't. So bring him your desires, bring him your fears and questions, and keep your heart open to his leading. And remember, you are seen, you are deeply loved, and the shepherd is still speaking. See you next time.