April 8, 2026
The Five Dysfunctions That Keep Killing the Same Platforms
Larry Benz breaks down a hard truth: most healthcare platform failures aren’t about private equity—they’re about poor operational decisions.
If you’re a clinic owner or PT leader, this conversation explains why scaling often breaks what made your clinic successful in the first place.
Key Insights:
- Healthcare is a relationship-driven business, not a scalable product
- Over-centralization destroys local clinic value
- Misaligned compensation leads directly to burnout and turnover
- Acquisition without integration creates “Frankenstein” organizations
- Decisions made far from the clinic floor create delayed failure
- The best platforms prioritize organic growth before expansion
Why This Matters:
If you’re trying to grow your clinic, these mistakes are easy to repeat—and expensive to fix. This episode helps you recognize them early and build a model that actually lasts.
WEBVTT
00:00:01.690 --> 00:00:01.870
All right,
00:00:01.909 --> 00:00:03.672
last time we talked about why healthcare
00:00:03.712 --> 00:00:05.152
platforms fail,
00:00:05.272 --> 00:00:07.915
and the headline surprised a lot of
00:00:07.934 --> 00:00:08.275
people.
00:00:08.676 --> 00:00:10.457
It got people very, very fired up,
00:00:10.917 --> 00:00:12.638
maybe because they didn't listen long
00:00:12.679 --> 00:00:13.019
enough.
00:00:13.599 --> 00:00:14.961
It's not private equity,
00:00:15.021 --> 00:00:16.823
it's not the ownership model,
00:00:17.362 --> 00:00:18.423
maybe it's the operators.
00:00:18.623 --> 00:00:19.964
So today we're gonna go deeper.
00:00:20.905 --> 00:00:22.426
Larry just dropped part two of this
00:00:22.466 --> 00:00:22.887
series.
00:00:22.926 --> 00:00:25.448
And this is where it gets uncomfortable
00:00:25.667 --> 00:00:27.147
because now we're not talking theory.
00:00:27.187 --> 00:00:29.028
We're talking about actual dysfunctions
00:00:29.489 --> 00:00:32.210
that keep blowing these things up.
00:00:32.289 --> 00:00:35.430
History keeps repeating themselves.
00:00:35.932 --> 00:00:36.472
Five of them.
00:00:36.671 --> 00:00:37.612
And the scary part,
00:00:37.972 --> 00:00:39.073
we've seen all five before.
00:00:39.872 --> 00:00:40.893
And we're still repeating them,
00:00:41.173 --> 00:00:41.994
just like history.
00:00:42.034 --> 00:00:43.837
So today we're breaking down where
00:00:43.877 --> 00:00:46.459
platforms actually go wrong and why smart
00:00:46.499 --> 00:00:49.942
people keep making the same mistakes and
00:00:49.982 --> 00:00:51.984
what the few operators who get it right
00:00:52.564 --> 00:00:53.765
are doing differently.
00:00:53.845 --> 00:00:55.067
So Larry, let's get into it.
00:00:56.067 --> 00:00:57.670
You said something that stuck with me.
00:00:58.210 --> 00:01:01.454
Failure is financing agnostic.
00:01:01.493 --> 00:01:02.615
That was the thing I think a lot
00:01:02.634 --> 00:01:04.016
of people last week said.
00:01:04.115 --> 00:01:05.076
when they heard you say,
00:01:05.456 --> 00:01:06.897
PE isn't the bad guy.
00:01:06.977 --> 00:01:08.438
They didn't stick around long enough to
00:01:08.457 --> 00:01:09.118
maybe go deeper.
00:01:09.218 --> 00:01:10.019
Maybe that's the trick.
00:01:10.299 --> 00:01:11.799
But if it's not private equity,
00:01:12.200 --> 00:01:15.042
then what actually is the root problem
00:01:15.102 --> 00:01:16.302
here?
00:01:16.362 --> 00:01:16.683
Yeah,
00:01:16.703 --> 00:01:18.963
so the root problem is that we keep
00:01:18.983 --> 00:01:21.364
treating American health care services
00:01:21.385 --> 00:01:22.585
like it's a scalable,
00:01:23.066 --> 00:01:24.787
dehumanized business product.
00:01:25.567 --> 00:01:26.628
And it isn't.
00:01:26.688 --> 00:01:28.709
CVS had ten point six billion.
00:01:28.868 --> 00:01:31.531
Amazon had effectively unlimited capital.
00:01:32.385 --> 00:01:34.167
Walgreens had the biggest national
00:01:34.206 --> 00:01:36.668
distribution infrastructure than any P
00:01:36.709 --> 00:01:38.370
firm would ever have.
00:01:39.290 --> 00:01:40.492
They were all three public,
00:01:41.332 --> 00:01:43.254
and they all walked into primary care with
00:01:43.313 --> 00:01:45.475
resources that would make any private
00:01:45.516 --> 00:01:46.756
equity sponsor blush.
00:01:47.576 --> 00:01:49.097
All three ended up with impairment
00:01:49.138 --> 00:01:50.438
charges, clinic closures,
00:01:50.498 --> 00:01:52.620
full dismemberment within three years.
00:01:53.549 --> 00:01:55.292
So if the answer were just getting better
00:01:55.331 --> 00:01:56.031
financing,
00:01:56.072 --> 00:01:58.454
then those three would have certainly
00:01:58.694 --> 00:01:59.516
figured it out.
00:01:59.596 --> 00:02:02.498
But the actual problem is structural.
00:02:03.058 --> 00:02:04.980
Healthcare is a relational,
00:02:05.120 --> 00:02:08.625
locally embedded reimbursement constrained
00:02:08.664 --> 00:02:09.765
and clinician dependent.
00:02:10.854 --> 00:02:12.776
Those are sort of four characteristics and
00:02:12.795 --> 00:02:14.739
they don't respond to capital the way that
00:02:14.758 --> 00:02:17.061
a consumer product or say a logistic
00:02:17.100 --> 00:02:17.842
business does.
00:02:18.543 --> 00:02:20.545
You can't centralize your way past them.
00:02:21.225 --> 00:02:23.209
You cannot acquire your way past them.
00:02:23.748 --> 00:02:25.771
You cannot hire sort of a McKenzie or
00:02:25.792 --> 00:02:28.014
a Bain team to optimize your past.
00:02:28.634 --> 00:02:29.395
They're optimized.
00:02:29.415 --> 00:02:30.556
You pass them at all.
00:02:31.337 --> 00:02:33.080
And the platforms that forget this,
00:02:33.161 --> 00:02:34.862
regardless of who's writing the check,
00:02:34.962 --> 00:02:36.044
end up in the same place.
00:02:36.264 --> 00:02:37.765
History does have a way of repeating
00:02:37.806 --> 00:02:38.146
itself,
00:02:38.167 --> 00:02:40.028
which is why I keep saying the financing
00:02:40.669 --> 00:02:43.554
is the accelerant, not the arsonist.
00:02:44.760 --> 00:02:44.901
Right.
00:02:44.920 --> 00:02:47.222
But it sometimes is the most visible.
00:02:47.282 --> 00:02:48.581
So we blame the most visible.
00:02:49.382 --> 00:02:50.442
You mentioned that word over
00:02:50.502 --> 00:02:51.282
centralization.
00:02:51.502 --> 00:02:53.143
My previous career was in broadcasting.
00:02:53.302 --> 00:02:53.962
We saw this.
00:02:54.143 --> 00:02:55.683
If you could manage one radio station,
00:02:55.824 --> 00:02:56.544
why not a hundred?
00:02:56.623 --> 00:02:57.443
Why not a thousand?
00:02:57.924 --> 00:03:01.104
You call over centralization the original
00:03:01.185 --> 00:03:01.485
sin.
00:03:02.104 --> 00:03:04.086
Why does something like that that looks
00:03:04.526 --> 00:03:07.127
like good management end up killing
00:03:07.546 --> 00:03:08.907
platforms in health care?
00:03:09.646 --> 00:03:11.046
Because it sort of feels like good
00:03:11.127 --> 00:03:12.728
management right up until it does it.
00:03:13.611 --> 00:03:15.812
When the platform is scaling fast and the
00:03:15.872 --> 00:03:17.774
acquisition pipeline is full and the
00:03:17.933 --> 00:03:21.096
EBITDA is growing, centralizing HR,
00:03:21.977 --> 00:03:24.258
finance and clinical protocols look like
00:03:24.277 --> 00:03:25.699
an operational discipline.
00:03:25.739 --> 00:03:26.719
It looked like a demand.
00:03:26.740 --> 00:03:28.640
It looked like a necessity, a default.
00:03:30.286 --> 00:03:31.888
but it looks like professionalizing a
00:03:31.948 --> 00:03:34.691
fragmented cottage industry.
00:03:34.730 --> 00:03:36.332
That's what we are as a cottage industry.
00:03:37.033 --> 00:03:38.915
It looks exactly what boards are asking
00:03:38.936 --> 00:03:39.096
for,
00:03:39.135 --> 00:03:41.399
but what's happening is you're dismantling
00:03:41.419 --> 00:03:43.281
the thing that makes the practice
00:03:43.360 --> 00:03:43.901
valuable.
00:03:44.461 --> 00:03:46.122
a patient's relationship with their
00:03:46.143 --> 00:03:47.483
hygienist, their PT,
00:03:47.522 --> 00:03:48.842
their primary care doctor.
00:03:49.302 --> 00:03:50.864
That's the product.
00:03:50.903 --> 00:03:52.805
The product is the relationship,
00:03:52.844 --> 00:03:55.104
the intangibles, the thing that is very,
00:03:55.145 --> 00:03:58.045
very difficult to scale and to quantify.
00:03:58.445 --> 00:04:00.747
That relationship is local, it's personal,
00:04:01.387 --> 00:04:02.907
and it also took a long time or
00:04:02.987 --> 00:04:03.888
years to build.
00:04:04.627 --> 00:04:07.049
The moment you start optimizing it from a
00:04:07.149 --> 00:04:09.750
corporate office four states away,
00:04:09.770 --> 00:04:11.251
you're not running the business better.
00:04:11.610 --> 00:04:13.191
You're consuming the business.
00:04:13.510 --> 00:04:15.391
And by the time the revenue trend makes
00:04:15.412 --> 00:04:16.091
that visible,
00:04:16.132 --> 00:04:17.432
the founders are already gone.
00:04:17.452 --> 00:04:19.053
The culture is already hollowed out.
00:04:19.454 --> 00:04:21.254
And you're trying to hire your way back
00:04:21.293 --> 00:04:24.134
to something that you destroyed on a
00:04:24.175 --> 00:04:24.836
spreadsheet.
00:04:24.855 --> 00:04:25.456
You know,
00:04:25.475 --> 00:04:27.096
if you look at the sort of the
00:04:27.137 --> 00:04:29.216
Harvard postmortem on Steward,
00:04:29.576 --> 00:04:30.838
they named it explicitly.
00:04:31.504 --> 00:04:34.346
Failure to invest in patient care combined
00:04:34.386 --> 00:04:36.766
with financial engineering that extracted
00:04:36.826 --> 00:04:38.208
value instead of building it.
00:04:38.887 --> 00:04:41.149
That's centralization's end state when it
00:04:41.189 --> 00:04:41.829
goes wrong.
00:04:42.228 --> 00:04:43.550
Five hospitals closed,
00:04:43.910 --> 00:04:45.550
five thousand workers displaced,
00:04:46.050 --> 00:04:48.130
a CEO dodging a Senate subpoena.
00:04:48.151 --> 00:04:50.672
That's where like looks like good
00:04:50.732 --> 00:04:51.992
management eventually goes.
00:04:53.805 --> 00:04:57.209
So then at what point does a platform
00:04:57.249 --> 00:04:58.029
cross the line?
00:04:58.569 --> 00:05:00.812
If I could manage one and then five
00:05:00.891 --> 00:05:01.333
okay,
00:05:02.353 --> 00:05:03.875
maybe this is a fair or unfair question,
00:05:04.396 --> 00:05:05.776
at what point does it cross the line
00:05:05.797 --> 00:05:07.458
from helpful infrastructure and
00:05:07.517 --> 00:05:09.120
centralizing thing to actually,
00:05:09.360 --> 00:05:10.000
what you just said,
00:05:10.060 --> 00:05:12.122
dismantling what actually made the
00:05:12.182 --> 00:05:13.403
business valuable?
00:05:13.803 --> 00:05:16.846
Yeah, it evolves over a process.
00:05:17.607 --> 00:05:18.627
It starts out...
00:05:19.641 --> 00:05:20.862
honoring the clinician,
00:05:20.922 --> 00:05:22.802
it ends up treating them like widget
00:05:22.822 --> 00:05:23.343
makers,
00:05:23.762 --> 00:05:25.824
that they're just fungible commodities.
00:05:26.124 --> 00:05:27.884
So that line is crossed when the local
00:05:27.983 --> 00:05:30.605
operator loses what I call real authority,
00:05:31.064 --> 00:05:33.165
not influence, authority,
00:05:33.946 --> 00:05:35.586
decision-making processes.
00:05:35.846 --> 00:05:36.687
There's a difference.
00:05:37.447 --> 00:05:39.648
Shared infrastructure at times makes
00:05:39.708 --> 00:05:40.088
sense.
00:05:40.327 --> 00:05:42.387
Billing, credentialing, supply chain,
00:05:42.468 --> 00:05:43.608
marketing, technology,
00:05:43.668 --> 00:05:44.168
nobody needs
00:05:45.346 --> 00:05:47.468
EMR implementations across a platform.
00:05:47.987 --> 00:05:50.250
That's legitimately more efficient and it
00:05:50.290 --> 00:05:51.550
frees up clinical time.
00:05:51.790 --> 00:05:53.130
I've got no argument with that.
00:05:53.690 --> 00:05:55.151
But the line gets crossed when the
00:05:55.192 --> 00:05:58.514
decision on how many patients a clinician
00:05:58.593 --> 00:06:00.394
sees and
00:06:00.555 --> 00:06:02.216
what they're being paid for seeing them
00:06:02.495 --> 00:06:04.958
and what the patients see which patients
00:06:04.978 --> 00:06:06.899
they see in terms of payer mix and
00:06:06.978 --> 00:06:09.899
whether that practice keeps the culture
00:06:09.920 --> 00:06:12.002
that they built because all of a sudden
00:06:12.242 --> 00:06:14.942
central management starts sending things
00:06:15.223 --> 00:06:17.625
out and they say you have to see
00:06:17.665 --> 00:06:19.365
this many patients you're doing this much
00:06:19.386 --> 00:06:20.627
you have to do this you have to
00:06:20.666 --> 00:06:23.028
adopt this and those decisions then
00:06:23.108 --> 00:06:25.850
migrate they could migrate even to a you
00:06:26.050 --> 00:06:28.170
know regional operator or a ceo who's
00:06:28.230 --> 00:06:29.252
never treated a patient
00:06:30.083 --> 00:06:31.423
That's when they've stopped building
00:06:31.483 --> 00:06:33.086
infrastructure on the clinical business
00:06:33.365 --> 00:06:34.927
and they started replacing the clinical
00:06:34.966 --> 00:06:36.809
business with a management layer.
00:06:37.348 --> 00:06:38.831
So that's how that thing evolves.
00:06:38.850 --> 00:06:40.451
The patients eventually figured out,
00:06:40.951 --> 00:06:42.353
referral sources figured out,
00:06:42.913 --> 00:06:44.915
and then the clinicians figure out and
00:06:44.956 --> 00:06:45.396
they leave.
00:06:45.475 --> 00:06:46.596
They go down to something better.
00:06:46.858 --> 00:06:48.298
It's usually in that order, by the way.
00:06:48.678 --> 00:06:49.160
Yep.
00:06:49.240 --> 00:06:50.461
And then the thing that made you valuable
00:06:50.480 --> 00:06:52.362
walks out the door and you're confused as
00:06:52.401 --> 00:06:53.023
to what happened.
00:06:54.194 --> 00:06:54.774
Yeah.
00:06:54.795 --> 00:06:57.036
You've said misaligned compensation isn't
00:06:57.055 --> 00:06:57.315
a bug.
00:06:57.336 --> 00:06:58.016
It's a feature.
00:06:59.016 --> 00:07:00.396
This is super zoomed in.
00:07:00.416 --> 00:07:01.598
We've seen this a lot.
00:07:01.677 --> 00:07:04.259
We had a discussion before about KPIs when
00:07:04.278 --> 00:07:05.699
you're aiming at a target that isn't
00:07:05.759 --> 00:07:07.699
valuable in the long term.
00:07:08.079 --> 00:07:10.120
So what are these systems actually
00:07:10.281 --> 00:07:13.682
incentivizing clinicians to actually do?
00:07:14.428 --> 00:07:14.569
Yeah,
00:07:14.588 --> 00:07:15.889
so this is a key out of the
00:07:15.908 --> 00:07:16.970
five dysfunctions.
00:07:17.050 --> 00:07:19.470
It's the effectively misaligning
00:07:19.509 --> 00:07:20.370
compensation.
00:07:20.910 --> 00:07:23.870
And it's two things, and they're both bad.
00:07:24.370 --> 00:07:25.790
The first is what I'll call the
00:07:25.850 --> 00:07:28.711
volume-driven model, revenue per visit,
00:07:28.771 --> 00:07:29.932
daily patient counts,
00:07:30.072 --> 00:07:31.413
units per billing targets,
00:07:31.673 --> 00:07:33.733
where you explicitly tell clinicians that
00:07:33.793 --> 00:07:34.492
more is better,
00:07:34.913 --> 00:07:37.153
regardless of what the patient actually
00:07:37.374 --> 00:07:37.514
says.
00:07:37.593 --> 00:07:40.615
is coming in on that particular day so
00:07:40.754 --> 00:07:42.574
you get treatment center you know you get
00:07:42.615 --> 00:07:43.754
these sort of treatment sessions
00:07:43.814 --> 00:07:46.375
structured around maximizing time billing
00:07:46.415 --> 00:07:48.617
codes rather than clinical outcomes it
00:07:48.697 --> 00:07:51.737
shifts the incentive shifts from the love
00:07:52.117 --> 00:07:54.418
and meaningful work of seeing patients to
00:07:54.637 --> 00:07:57.519
external numbers units time codes all
00:07:57.538 --> 00:07:58.298
those kind of things
00:07:59.019 --> 00:08:01.240
And the clinicians who take on these cases
00:08:01.800 --> 00:08:03.781
have to because the schedule demands it.
00:08:04.242 --> 00:08:06.083
They try to optimize the schedule.
00:08:06.583 --> 00:08:09.125
You get throughput, if you will,
00:08:09.165 --> 00:08:11.365
disguised as sort of productivity.
00:08:11.987 --> 00:08:14.367
And then burnout isn't a side effect of
00:08:14.408 --> 00:08:15.067
that system.
00:08:15.208 --> 00:08:18.529
It's the logical output of asking sort of
00:08:18.550 --> 00:08:20.851
a doctoral-level professional to function
00:08:20.891 --> 00:08:23.173
like a widget in an assembly line.
00:08:23.273 --> 00:08:23.552
Again,
00:08:23.593 --> 00:08:27.115
it's that migration of the business into a
00:08:27.735 --> 00:08:28.315
model system
00:08:28.809 --> 00:08:30.490
of manufacturing, if you will,
00:08:30.790 --> 00:08:32.591
rather than relating it's a people
00:08:32.631 --> 00:08:34.594
business all about the relationships.
00:08:35.173 --> 00:08:35.695
The other,
00:08:35.774 --> 00:08:38.996
the second failure is the flat salary
00:08:39.057 --> 00:08:39.457
model.
00:08:39.857 --> 00:08:41.558
Oh, we're going to pay our therapist X.
00:08:41.740 --> 00:08:41.799
Oh,
00:08:41.820 --> 00:08:43.020
and then the new class comes in a
00:08:43.041 --> 00:08:43.780
year and they're going to say,
00:08:43.801 --> 00:08:46.143
we're going to pay them X plus ten.
00:08:46.182 --> 00:08:47.024
Well, guess what?
00:08:47.043 --> 00:08:48.325
And then they go back to the other
00:08:48.524 --> 00:08:50.186
X and have to ten up them.
00:08:51.187 --> 00:08:53.668
And this is really popular more in the
00:08:53.729 --> 00:08:55.610
physical therapy and the dental hygiene
00:08:55.971 --> 00:08:57.451
space.
00:08:57.611 --> 00:08:59.212
We build professionals where the only way
00:08:59.232 --> 00:09:00.714
you can increase your income is to stop
00:09:00.734 --> 00:09:02.274
seeing patients move into management.
00:09:02.796 --> 00:09:03.996
So our best clinicians,
00:09:04.017 --> 00:09:06.077
the ones with the deepest clinical skills
00:09:06.177 --> 00:09:08.159
and the strongest patient relationships,
00:09:08.740 --> 00:09:11.042
are now economically incentivized to
00:09:11.081 --> 00:09:12.623
become a regional manager.
00:09:12.682 --> 00:09:14.264
They're incentivized to leave clinical
00:09:14.303 --> 00:09:16.605
practice as soon as it's possible.
00:09:17.984 --> 00:09:19.904
Then we run studies wondering why we have
00:09:19.945 --> 00:09:21.005
workforce shortages.
00:09:21.046 --> 00:09:22.546
Between two thousand twenty three and two
00:09:22.586 --> 00:09:25.128
thousand twenty four on the physician
00:09:25.148 --> 00:09:25.488
side,
00:09:25.628 --> 00:09:28.529
union petitions surged nearly nine hundred
00:09:29.129 --> 00:09:29.789
percent,
00:09:30.029 --> 00:09:32.230
nine hundred percent in a profession that
00:09:32.270 --> 00:09:34.613
spent decades philosophically opposed to
00:09:34.633 --> 00:09:35.773
collective bargaining.
00:09:36.092 --> 00:09:37.293
They were against unions.
00:09:37.634 --> 00:09:38.774
When you see that number,
00:09:39.315 --> 00:09:41.615
that really implies that the compensation
00:09:42.136 --> 00:09:44.158
dysfunction isn't sort of theory.
00:09:45.238 --> 00:09:46.038
It's producing,
00:09:46.360 --> 00:09:49.202
it's really a structural argument,
00:09:49.302 --> 00:09:50.264
structural response.
00:09:51.065 --> 00:09:52.686
Let's talk about this other problem that
00:09:52.706 --> 00:09:55.328
you brought up, this altitude problem.
00:09:55.469 --> 00:09:58.211
Decisions getting made further and further
00:09:58.631 --> 00:09:59.693
from the clinical floor,
00:09:59.734 --> 00:10:00.835
where that business,
00:10:00.875 --> 00:10:02.777
the value that the organization provides
00:10:02.817 --> 00:10:03.557
actually happens.
00:10:04.458 --> 00:10:06.301
What's the real cost of that disconnect,
00:10:06.321 --> 00:10:07.481
that altitude problem?
00:10:08.256 --> 00:10:08.557
Yeah,
00:10:08.576 --> 00:10:10.597
the real cost is that by the time
00:10:10.677 --> 00:10:13.418
bad decisions become visible as the
00:10:13.498 --> 00:10:14.238
revenue line,
00:10:14.258 --> 00:10:17.139
the damage has been in process for like
00:10:17.178 --> 00:10:18.399
a year to a year and a half.
00:10:18.840 --> 00:10:20.139
That's sort of a lag period,
00:10:20.179 --> 00:10:21.179
twelve to eighteen months.
00:10:21.779 --> 00:10:25.081
A CFO who's never seen a physical therapy
00:10:25.140 --> 00:10:27.822
episode designs a productivity metric.
00:10:27.942 --> 00:10:29.682
A compensation committee that's never
00:10:29.721 --> 00:10:31.942
worked in a clinical environment sets a
00:10:31.982 --> 00:10:32.623
pay structure.
00:10:33.688 --> 00:10:35.909
all these for doctoral you know
00:10:35.950 --> 00:10:38.471
professionals a regional director whose
00:10:38.511 --> 00:10:40.312
entire health care background is a
00:10:40.393 --> 00:10:42.234
consulting engagement or maybe they worked
00:10:42.274 --> 00:10:44.215
in a multi-site and worked their way up
00:10:44.774 --> 00:10:46.576
and it's all clinical efficiencies you
00:10:46.596 --> 00:10:48.636
know from a spreadsheet none of these
00:10:48.876 --> 00:10:51.097
decisions produce an immediate sort of
00:10:51.158 --> 00:10:53.578
catastrophic event it happens over time a
00:10:53.639 --> 00:10:56.441
slow degradation of clinical engagement
00:10:56.760 --> 00:10:57.682
patient experience,
00:10:57.721 --> 00:10:58.903
referral relationships,
00:10:59.342 --> 00:11:01.563
and a real bigaboo, retention.
00:11:01.985 --> 00:11:03.946
And by the time that degradation shows up
00:11:03.966 --> 00:11:04.546
in the numbers,
00:11:04.586 --> 00:11:07.587
the people who made those decisions have
00:11:08.828 --> 00:11:09.870
oftentimes moved on.
00:11:09.889 --> 00:11:11.870
They've had souped up, tricked up resumes,
00:11:11.910 --> 00:11:12.892
worked with search firms.
00:11:13.272 --> 00:11:14.832
I've had now success and growth in a
00:11:14.873 --> 00:11:16.193
multi-site and they move on.
00:11:16.854 --> 00:11:18.995
I call that the altitude problem because
00:11:19.015 --> 00:11:20.836
the higher the decision that gets made,
00:11:20.856 --> 00:11:21.977
the less grounded it is.
00:11:22.398 --> 00:11:23.958
and the reality of where that care
00:11:23.999 --> 00:11:25.799
actually happens at the clinic.
00:11:26.360 --> 00:11:27.701
And in health care services,
00:11:27.801 --> 00:11:30.883
the care is the business.
00:11:31.342 --> 00:11:32.884
Everything else is supportive
00:11:32.903 --> 00:11:33.563
infrastructure.
00:11:33.984 --> 00:11:35.705
When the supportive infrastructure starts
00:11:35.784 --> 00:11:38.427
making business decisions about the care
00:11:38.447 --> 00:11:39.868
without understanding the care,
00:11:40.408 --> 00:11:41.869
you've inverted the model,
00:11:42.149 --> 00:11:44.230
and that in itself is a symptom of
00:11:44.250 --> 00:11:44.990
the dysfunction.
00:11:45.390 --> 00:11:47.111
The tail is now wagging the dog,
00:11:47.131 --> 00:11:48.711
and the dog is the part that actually
00:11:48.772 --> 00:11:49.732
generates the revenue.
00:11:49.996 --> 00:11:51.418
Yeah, let's get even scarier.
00:11:51.438 --> 00:11:52.679
Let's bring in Frankenstein to this
00:11:52.740 --> 00:11:53.059
equation.
00:11:53.080 --> 00:11:53.980
You've described what you call
00:11:54.061 --> 00:11:55.221
Frankenstein network,
00:11:55.842 --> 00:11:57.605
where many platforms prioritize
00:11:58.004 --> 00:12:00.248
acquisition, buying new things,
00:12:00.447 --> 00:12:04.011
absorbing things over actually integrating
00:12:04.412 --> 00:12:06.173
what they've already bought.
00:12:06.274 --> 00:12:07.014
Why does this happen?
00:12:07.477 --> 00:12:07.677
Yeah,
00:12:08.118 --> 00:12:09.739
so let's get to the Frankenstein by
00:12:09.778 --> 00:12:11.480
setting some context here a little bit.
00:12:11.980 --> 00:12:14.441
See, acquisitions generate headlines.
00:12:15.020 --> 00:12:16.341
Integration doesn't.
00:12:16.942 --> 00:12:18.582
When you close a ten clinic deal,
00:12:18.623 --> 00:12:19.523
there's a press release.
00:12:19.863 --> 00:12:21.224
There's a multiple that went up.
00:12:21.764 --> 00:12:23.585
There's something to show the board at the
00:12:23.625 --> 00:12:24.645
next quarterly meeting.
00:12:25.005 --> 00:12:26.966
When you spend eighteen months integrating
00:12:26.986 --> 00:12:29.567
that acquisition, aligning EHR systems,
00:12:29.967 --> 00:12:31.187
building shared culture,
00:12:31.249 --> 00:12:32.649
developing clinical staff,
00:12:32.668 --> 00:12:34.149
investing in same-store growth,
00:12:34.690 --> 00:12:35.831
There isn't a press release.
00:12:36.172 --> 00:12:37.332
The board doesn't really care.
00:12:37.352 --> 00:12:38.794
It's an expectation they have,
00:12:38.835 --> 00:12:40.176
but that can take eighteen months.
00:12:40.876 --> 00:12:43.198
There's just quiet operational work that
00:12:43.240 --> 00:12:45.621
eventually shows up as margin improvement
00:12:45.642 --> 00:12:46.322
and retention.
00:12:46.663 --> 00:12:50.106
The way to judge an acquisition is you
00:12:50.147 --> 00:12:52.789
pay a multiple and that multiple has to
00:12:52.809 --> 00:12:55.432
be brought down to a better return on
00:12:55.452 --> 00:12:56.153
that multiple.
00:12:56.494 --> 00:12:58.034
in over a period of time.
00:12:58.475 --> 00:13:01.275
I think eighteen months is a reasonable
00:13:01.416 --> 00:13:02.255
expectation.
00:13:02.937 --> 00:13:03.836
And in my experience,
00:13:03.856 --> 00:13:05.697
you can grow a company twenty to thirty
00:13:05.738 --> 00:13:07.298
percent over that time period.
00:13:07.337 --> 00:13:09.119
The problem is you start stacking all
00:13:09.139 --> 00:13:10.119
these acquisitions,
00:13:10.158 --> 00:13:11.419
which is what happened in all these
00:13:11.460 --> 00:13:12.720
dysfunctional companies,
00:13:13.440 --> 00:13:14.780
and they couldn't integrate
00:13:15.241 --> 00:13:17.102
and one didn't get to one point two
00:13:17.143 --> 00:13:17.602
point oh,
00:13:17.623 --> 00:13:19.964
it got to point six and point seven.
00:13:20.604 --> 00:13:20.903
You see,
00:13:21.384 --> 00:13:23.784
PE incentive structures don't wait for the
00:13:23.825 --> 00:13:25.225
quiet operational work.
00:13:25.426 --> 00:13:26.866
They're on a five year hold period.
00:13:27.307 --> 00:13:29.067
Every quarter you're not acquiring is a
00:13:29.128 --> 00:13:30.628
quarter you're not building towards the
00:13:30.668 --> 00:13:31.408
exit multiple.
00:13:31.869 --> 00:13:33.548
So here's what you end up instead.
00:13:33.769 --> 00:13:35.129
That's what I call the Frankenstein
00:13:35.149 --> 00:13:35.570
network.
00:13:35.950 --> 00:13:37.730
Dozens of acquired practicing,
00:13:38.171 --> 00:13:39.631
each with its own EHR,
00:13:39.772 --> 00:13:41.052
each with its own culture,
00:13:41.472 --> 00:13:43.472
each with its own billing practice
00:13:43.513 --> 00:13:44.953
stitched together under brand
00:13:45.333 --> 00:13:47.816
shared name and a shared debt load with
00:13:47.875 --> 00:13:50.017
almost none of the operational synergies
00:13:50.076 --> 00:13:51.977
that justify the acquisition premium.
00:13:52.698 --> 00:13:54.940
Systems don't align, cultures clash.
00:13:55.019 --> 00:13:57.182
It's all one sided central management
00:13:57.261 --> 00:13:58.701
telling you what you have to do.
00:13:59.143 --> 00:14:00.764
No area of collaboration,
00:14:01.083 --> 00:14:03.325
no fierce disagreement, no teamwork,
00:14:03.806 --> 00:14:05.166
none of the things, you know,
00:14:05.206 --> 00:14:06.988
the tacit knowledge skills that you have
00:14:07.028 --> 00:14:08.368
to do when you really bring teams
00:14:08.408 --> 00:14:08.828
together.
00:14:09.621 --> 00:14:11.003
Then the clinicians who joined that
00:14:11.023 --> 00:14:11.583
platform,
00:14:12.063 --> 00:14:14.166
when they still had its original culture,
00:14:14.206 --> 00:14:17.308
they watch it get diluted with all these
00:14:17.349 --> 00:14:19.331
successive deals and same store growth,
00:14:19.350 --> 00:14:21.452
which is the actual proof that the
00:14:21.493 --> 00:14:22.433
business model works,
00:14:22.514 --> 00:14:24.274
never gets the investment it needs because
00:14:24.294 --> 00:14:26.356
the capital is always paying for the next
00:14:26.437 --> 00:14:28.379
acquisition or paying the interest on
00:14:28.418 --> 00:14:29.340
their acquisition.
00:14:29.700 --> 00:14:31.741
It's a great way to build a very
00:14:31.782 --> 00:14:33.724
impressive looking platform that is
00:14:33.783 --> 00:14:35.985
quietly hollowing out from the inside.
00:14:36.625 --> 00:14:37.826
Looks great on paper while they're
00:14:37.966 --> 00:14:39.787
quietly, I guess, running out of cash.
00:14:41.267 --> 00:14:41.486
Yes.
00:14:41.606 --> 00:14:43.847
Let's at least close on something hopeful.
00:14:45.128 --> 00:14:47.028
What are the platforms that actually get
00:14:47.067 --> 00:14:49.408
this right doing differently?
00:14:49.428 --> 00:14:51.909
This is the reason we study history all
00:14:51.929 --> 00:14:52.669
throughout school, right?
00:14:52.690 --> 00:14:54.470
We're supposed to watch the failures and
00:14:54.509 --> 00:14:55.830
piece together the things that could have,
00:14:55.850 --> 00:14:56.530
should have, would have happened.
00:14:56.551 --> 00:14:57.990
But who's doing it right now?
00:14:58.763 --> 00:14:58.942
Yeah,
00:14:58.962 --> 00:15:00.865
so I'll answer the second part of that
00:15:00.904 --> 00:15:02.765
carefully because the platforms doing this
00:15:02.826 --> 00:15:04.626
really well are usually private and
00:15:04.647 --> 00:15:06.128
they're not looking for attention.
00:15:06.629 --> 00:15:08.169
The ones that shout out about it the
00:15:08.210 --> 00:15:09.870
loudest are usually the ones that have the
00:15:09.931 --> 00:15:12.432
slickest decks and the most questionable
00:15:12.533 --> 00:15:13.693
unit economics.
00:15:13.714 --> 00:15:16.615
So I'll give you that pattern rather than
00:15:16.655 --> 00:15:17.437
the names,
00:15:17.517 --> 00:15:19.238
although I'm not afraid to name a few
00:15:19.278 --> 00:15:19.778
of them here.
00:15:20.438 --> 00:15:21.458
But what they share,
00:15:21.499 --> 00:15:22.899
let's talk about their commonalities.
00:15:22.960 --> 00:15:25.182
Clinician-informed leadership at every
00:15:25.241 --> 00:15:25.522
level.
00:15:25.822 --> 00:15:27.264
They don't run off founders.
00:15:28.222 --> 00:15:29.743
They don't do those kinds of things.
00:15:29.763 --> 00:15:33.524
They don't have this kind of poster child
00:15:33.724 --> 00:15:36.304
chief clinical officer joined at the hip
00:15:36.384 --> 00:15:38.424
of their COO as though that is some
00:15:38.465 --> 00:15:39.546
kind of big deal.
00:15:41.186 --> 00:15:42.807
But they don't care about clinical
00:15:42.826 --> 00:15:44.767
advisory boards that report up.
00:15:45.246 --> 00:15:47.168
But what they have is actual operators
00:15:47.187 --> 00:15:48.488
with actual authority
00:15:49.048 --> 00:15:51.690
and rooms where decisions get made see
00:15:51.730 --> 00:15:53.932
clinicians have transportable skills that
00:15:53.951 --> 00:15:56.092
have allowed them to be entrepreneurs and
00:15:56.153 --> 00:15:58.674
managers and they built businesses now you
00:15:58.735 --> 00:16:00.876
take them out of businesses doesn't make
00:16:00.937 --> 00:16:03.798
any sense right compensation models where
00:16:03.818 --> 00:16:06.441
a clinician who produces more takes home
00:16:06.480 --> 00:16:09.442
more that's realignment not a peloton sort
00:16:09.482 --> 00:16:11.345
of leaderboard with penalty tiers
00:16:12.065 --> 00:16:14.206
They don't do the next acquisition until
00:16:14.245 --> 00:16:16.047
the last one gets integrated.
00:16:16.486 --> 00:16:18.528
They do success one at a time.
00:16:18.548 --> 00:16:19.508
They share systems.
00:16:19.869 --> 00:16:21.089
They bring on culture.
00:16:21.408 --> 00:16:23.269
They recognize that you have different
00:16:23.309 --> 00:16:24.850
cultures and history and legacy,
00:16:24.890 --> 00:16:27.111
but you bring them together and they
00:16:27.172 --> 00:16:29.072
create new commitments around that.
00:16:29.753 --> 00:16:33.575
They use same store growth as the primary
00:16:33.855 --> 00:16:36.196
metric, organic growth.
00:16:36.990 --> 00:16:38.432
The reason they do that is if you
00:16:38.491 --> 00:16:40.373
can't do something well organically,
00:16:40.452 --> 00:16:42.313
why should you ever be entitled to buy
00:16:42.374 --> 00:16:44.095
anything?
00:16:44.115 --> 00:16:46.317
The clinician entrepreneurs who built the
00:16:46.356 --> 00:16:47.157
local businesses,
00:16:47.177 --> 00:16:48.958
they stay in the platform one way or
00:16:48.999 --> 00:16:49.399
another.
00:16:50.198 --> 00:16:51.159
They keep equity.
00:16:51.735 --> 00:16:54.557
They have genuine operational authority.
00:16:54.596 --> 00:16:56.278
They still have ownership at the local
00:16:56.317 --> 00:16:56.618
level.
00:16:56.658 --> 00:16:58.198
They might have it at the top level,
00:16:58.239 --> 00:16:59.799
but they really need it at the local
00:16:59.860 --> 00:17:00.159
level.
00:17:00.480 --> 00:17:03.062
They're not transition out six months
00:17:03.101 --> 00:17:06.804
under some cockamamie CEO trying to make a
00:17:06.864 --> 00:17:09.945
name for themselves and say, oh,
00:17:09.986 --> 00:17:11.946
we got running off founders as though that
00:17:11.987 --> 00:17:13.708
was built with some sort of strength.
00:17:14.760 --> 00:17:16.761
And here's the one ad that doesn't get
00:17:16.801 --> 00:17:17.422
enough attention.
00:17:18.042 --> 00:17:19.723
The professional managers in these
00:17:19.784 --> 00:17:23.665
platforms have verifiable track records of
00:17:23.705 --> 00:17:24.586
organic growth,
00:17:24.645 --> 00:17:27.968
not tricked up search firm resumes that
00:17:28.028 --> 00:17:29.709
claim top line growth,
00:17:29.749 --> 00:17:31.289
even though you bought a bunch of things,
00:17:31.349 --> 00:17:31.609
right?
00:17:32.130 --> 00:17:34.691
Specifically during the post COVID period,
00:17:34.730 --> 00:17:36.471
this is what is incredibly important
00:17:36.491 --> 00:17:39.054
because this is the period of time when
00:17:39.134 --> 00:17:40.513
labor costs have spiked,
00:17:40.614 --> 00:17:41.934
supply chains broke,
00:17:41.994 --> 00:17:43.615
reimbursement got cut,
00:17:44.115 --> 00:17:46.741
And clinician shortages were the new new.
00:17:46.862 --> 00:17:47.763
They were the new normal.
00:17:48.483 --> 00:17:50.184
Anyone could look at an operator in a
00:17:50.244 --> 00:17:52.145
free money environment from years ago
00:17:52.166 --> 00:17:54.067
where acquisitions were made and claimed
00:17:54.087 --> 00:17:55.528
they had all kinds of growth.
00:17:55.749 --> 00:17:57.069
And that's what you see on these tricked
00:17:57.109 --> 00:18:00.352
up resumes is the bragging of growth.
00:18:00.372 --> 00:18:01.011
Which, by the way,
00:18:01.051 --> 00:18:04.535
I'm going to go back and redo two
00:18:04.575 --> 00:18:06.395
more additions to metrics that don't
00:18:06.435 --> 00:18:06.756
matter.
00:18:06.796 --> 00:18:08.457
And growth and scale are going to be
00:18:09.258 --> 00:18:10.398
the next few episodes.
00:18:10.798 --> 00:18:11.499
But the question is,
00:18:12.460 --> 00:18:13.340
what do these companies do?
00:18:13.441 --> 00:18:15.182
They grew and they couldn't buy their way
00:18:15.261 --> 00:18:15.721
into it.
00:18:15.741 --> 00:18:17.363
These are companies that are quiet
00:18:17.462 --> 00:18:18.023
gainers.
00:18:18.844 --> 00:18:20.365
They didn't have to be flashy,
00:18:20.664 --> 00:18:22.646
shiny objects by buying new companies.
00:18:23.106 --> 00:18:25.107
The platforms that ask the questions in
00:18:25.127 --> 00:18:28.150
the hiring process are the ones that I
00:18:28.190 --> 00:18:29.270
will be watching.
00:18:29.871 --> 00:18:30.371
In dental,
00:18:30.431 --> 00:18:32.353
I could tell you Heartland Dental,
00:18:32.492 --> 00:18:35.674
a long-term DSO established by KKR,
00:18:36.315 --> 00:18:39.317
very thoughtful about how they do
00:18:39.356 --> 00:18:40.958
acquisitions and de novos.
00:18:42.439 --> 00:18:44.680
I think you've seen some physical therapy
00:18:44.720 --> 00:18:46.421
companies in the early days who've
00:18:46.461 --> 00:18:47.162
collapsed.
00:18:47.682 --> 00:18:49.584
But they started out doing mostly de
00:18:49.624 --> 00:18:50.124
novos,
00:18:50.163 --> 00:18:52.286
then went to mostly acquisitions and then
00:18:52.326 --> 00:18:53.886
failed.
00:18:53.948 --> 00:18:56.529
So there are winners in this world,
00:18:56.569 --> 00:18:59.352
but they remain relatively quiet and
00:18:59.712 --> 00:19:00.313
understated.
00:19:00.692 --> 00:19:01.374
Quiet and humble.
00:19:01.394 --> 00:19:01.673
All right.
00:19:01.693 --> 00:19:04.175
Let's play a quick segment called Operate
00:19:04.757 --> 00:19:05.617
or Overrate.
00:19:05.857 --> 00:19:06.719
Just give me an overrate.
00:19:06.759 --> 00:19:08.460
You want to operate or overrate?
00:19:09.480 --> 00:19:12.083
Centralized clinical protocols.
00:19:12.344 --> 00:19:13.825
Is that overrated or underrated?
00:19:16.278 --> 00:19:17.905
centralized clinical protocols.
00:19:20.616 --> 00:19:23.117
I think that's probably underrated.
00:19:23.917 --> 00:19:26.317
I think you have to have a
00:19:27.098 --> 00:19:31.440
consensus-driven approach to clinical
00:19:31.500 --> 00:19:33.380
protocols from the standpoint of evidence
00:19:33.420 --> 00:19:35.099
and the hierarchy of evidence.
00:19:35.800 --> 00:19:36.240
And say,
00:19:36.401 --> 00:19:39.240
out of the framework of low back pain,
00:19:39.942 --> 00:19:41.582
these are the clinical prediction rules
00:19:41.622 --> 00:19:42.281
we're going to use.
00:19:42.321 --> 00:19:44.923
These are the algorithms that we're going
00:19:44.962 --> 00:19:45.623
to teach.
00:19:46.464 --> 00:19:47.546
the treatment approaches.
00:19:47.865 --> 00:19:48.125
Yes,
00:19:48.165 --> 00:19:49.846
we understand there are deviations and
00:19:49.886 --> 00:19:52.188
comorbidities and things off of them.
00:19:53.189 --> 00:19:56.049
But I know I always wanted physicians
00:19:56.069 --> 00:19:57.730
coming back to me and saying, you know,
00:19:57.891 --> 00:19:59.172
I love the fact that when I send
00:19:59.231 --> 00:20:00.472
a low back pain patient,
00:20:00.492 --> 00:20:02.394
you do a clinical prediction rule or
00:20:02.453 --> 00:20:03.934
something and then engage them in a
00:20:03.994 --> 00:20:04.454
protocol.
00:20:04.474 --> 00:20:05.996
You don't have one person who just does
00:20:06.056 --> 00:20:06.756
manual therapy,
00:20:06.796 --> 00:20:08.237
another person that just does sports
00:20:08.277 --> 00:20:08.698
medicine,
00:20:09.097 --> 00:20:10.878
another person that just does McKenzie,
00:20:10.898 --> 00:20:12.640
another person that just does Syriax.
00:20:13.200 --> 00:20:16.001
So I do believe that an organizational's
00:20:16.063 --> 00:20:18.964
value in clinic is deciding on the top
00:20:19.005 --> 00:20:21.366
twelve to fifteen diagnosis and having
00:20:21.406 --> 00:20:22.907
treatment parameters and clinical
00:20:22.948 --> 00:20:24.910
prediction rules and evidence based
00:20:24.970 --> 00:20:25.631
process.
00:20:26.991 --> 00:20:27.271
You know,
00:20:27.432 --> 00:20:30.615
all they're driven through meta analysis
00:20:30.674 --> 00:20:31.996
and through and through the Cochrane
00:20:32.036 --> 00:20:34.077
system for the hierarchy of evidence.
00:20:34.824 --> 00:20:35.444
How about this one,
00:20:35.724 --> 00:20:37.666
which has been a buzz the last twelve
00:20:37.686 --> 00:20:38.508
to eighteen months?
00:20:39.148 --> 00:20:41.111
AI in health care operations.
00:20:41.151 --> 00:20:42.152
When it first popped up,
00:20:42.211 --> 00:20:43.413
it was going to be the savior of
00:20:43.453 --> 00:20:43.933
everything.
00:20:43.993 --> 00:20:46.237
But is it overrated or underrated or
00:20:46.297 --> 00:20:48.078
properly rated?
00:20:48.098 --> 00:20:49.621
Today, I would call it overrated.
00:20:50.642 --> 00:20:52.263
I think in the future it will be
00:20:52.344 --> 00:20:52.923
underrated.
00:20:53.204 --> 00:20:53.986
But right now.
00:20:54.590 --> 00:20:56.872
What you have is a lot of underfunded
00:20:56.932 --> 00:20:58.932
companies with shiny objects,
00:20:59.532 --> 00:21:02.094
adding things to EMR packages,
00:21:02.153 --> 00:21:03.714
marketing lead generation,
00:21:03.775 --> 00:21:05.134
schedule optimizing.
00:21:05.694 --> 00:21:07.596
All they are doing is allowing the over
00:21:07.655 --> 00:21:10.257
centralization feature that I've talked
00:21:10.277 --> 00:21:12.018
about it to be accelerated.
00:21:12.097 --> 00:21:13.278
That's not a good thing.
00:21:13.778 --> 00:21:15.118
Where it can become a good thing?
00:21:15.753 --> 00:21:17.394
Not optimizing EMR,
00:21:17.474 --> 00:21:19.036
not optimizing your schedule,
00:21:19.415 --> 00:21:21.136
not optimizing technology,
00:21:21.477 --> 00:21:23.097
optimizing humanness.
00:21:23.739 --> 00:21:25.419
What can I put in place that allows
00:21:25.480 --> 00:21:27.701
my therapists and my doctors to be more
00:21:27.760 --> 00:21:28.381
humane,
00:21:28.421 --> 00:21:30.342
to spend more time with their patients,
00:21:30.382 --> 00:21:31.423
to go home at the end of the
00:21:31.442 --> 00:21:34.304
day without the externalities of pressures
00:21:34.384 --> 00:21:34.704
on them?
00:21:35.265 --> 00:21:36.605
I have an article that I've written with
00:21:36.645 --> 00:21:39.426
Tim Flynn on the use of AI agents
00:21:39.507 --> 00:21:42.407
and how five agents running simultaneously
00:21:42.448 --> 00:21:44.528
in a physical therapist background will
00:21:44.548 --> 00:21:47.451
really enable a therapist to be more
00:21:47.510 --> 00:21:49.090
compassionate, empathetic,
00:21:49.391 --> 00:21:50.912
and spend more time with their patients.
00:21:51.291 --> 00:21:54.574
Now, that is where AI would be underrated.
00:21:54.693 --> 00:21:54.773
Well,
00:21:54.794 --> 00:21:56.055
that's what you talked about being that's
00:21:56.095 --> 00:21:57.255
where the business actually,
00:21:57.275 --> 00:21:58.336
that's where the value part of the
00:21:58.375 --> 00:21:58.935
business is.
00:21:59.355 --> 00:22:01.176
Last one I'll ask, overrated, underrated,
00:22:01.596 --> 00:22:03.337
flat salary compensation.
00:22:05.019 --> 00:22:06.201
Oh, grossly overrated.
00:22:07.141 --> 00:22:07.260
Yeah.
00:22:07.280 --> 00:22:08.842
You should never pay your top therapist
00:22:08.862 --> 00:22:10.903
the same as your bottom therapist through
00:22:10.982 --> 00:22:12.003
top line compensation.
00:22:12.523 --> 00:22:15.305
And variable compensation is not bonuses
00:22:15.365 --> 00:22:16.185
and incentives.
00:22:17.105 --> 00:22:19.948
It is the maturity to say we have
00:22:19.968 --> 00:22:22.931
a doctoring profession where we have
00:22:24.113 --> 00:22:27.316
ethics and values and expertise,
00:22:27.936 --> 00:22:30.098
and they should be paid a percentage of
00:22:30.118 --> 00:22:32.721
the compensation or the net revenue or the
00:22:32.761 --> 00:22:34.143
collections that they bring in.
00:22:34.163 --> 00:22:36.045
That's what every top doctoring profession
00:22:36.085 --> 00:22:36.384
does.
00:22:36.945 --> 00:22:39.048
And physical therapists are way behind in
00:22:39.067 --> 00:22:39.769
that area.
00:22:40.230 --> 00:22:42.592
And now that you have such penny nickel
00:22:42.632 --> 00:22:44.013
margins that we've talked about,
00:22:44.074 --> 00:22:45.455
the biggest portion of the comp,
00:22:45.476 --> 00:22:47.258
sixty seven percent is your labor.
00:22:47.798 --> 00:22:48.798
And out of that labor,
00:22:48.818 --> 00:22:50.882
you have to have a variable compensation
00:22:51.742 --> 00:22:54.005
shared risk with your therapist.
00:22:54.384 --> 00:22:57.368
This will move most of the compensation to
00:22:57.449 --> 00:22:58.089
therapists.
00:22:58.490 --> 00:22:59.090
And guess what?
00:22:59.191 --> 00:23:00.771
They're the ones who generate all the
00:23:00.832 --> 00:23:03.615
revenue and hopefully move compensation
00:23:03.714 --> 00:23:06.597
and move the number of overhead away from
00:23:06.678 --> 00:23:07.618
central management.
00:23:08.038 --> 00:23:10.641
The PT clinic, the dental clinic,
00:23:10.701 --> 00:23:12.824
the primary care clinic of the future is
00:23:12.844 --> 00:23:15.185
going to have a lot less headcount in
00:23:15.385 --> 00:23:18.249
revenue cycle management, credentialing,
00:23:18.979 --> 00:23:24.762
management in general hr finance and that
00:23:24.803 --> 00:23:27.924
will allow the profit and loss statement
00:23:28.045 --> 00:23:30.846
of to be rebalanced to a better margin
00:23:30.886 --> 00:23:33.628
but only if you shift that compensation to
00:23:33.648 --> 00:23:35.650
the people who absolutely produce it i'm
00:23:35.710 --> 00:23:38.352
very proletariat i'm like uh you know
00:23:38.432 --> 00:23:39.653
that's why i'm a big fan of major
00:23:39.673 --> 00:23:41.554
league baseball and what they've been able
00:23:41.594 --> 00:23:44.155
to do where they reward the people that
00:23:44.195 --> 00:23:46.336
generate the revenues in physical therapy
00:23:46.678 --> 00:23:48.699
what we do is the opposite we generate
00:23:50.020 --> 00:23:52.165
for therapists that get out of therapy and
00:23:52.185 --> 00:23:54.290
move it more up the ladder towards central
00:23:54.330 --> 00:23:54.872
management.
00:23:55.729 --> 00:23:57.750
that leads to partly of the five
00:23:57.790 --> 00:24:00.292
dysfunctions of healthcare platforms when
00:24:00.313 --> 00:24:02.493
they go awry all right go deeper if
00:24:02.513 --> 00:24:04.796
you're building operating or investing in
00:24:04.836 --> 00:24:06.797
healthcare this is the stuff that actually
00:24:06.836 --> 00:24:08.238
matters and you should be paying attention
00:24:08.278 --> 00:24:09.880
to not the pitch decks they can be
00:24:09.920 --> 00:24:12.060
slicked up not the multiple the way
00:24:12.121 --> 00:24:14.442
business actually runs if this hit go read
00:24:14.462 --> 00:24:16.084
the full piece links in the show notes
00:24:16.525 --> 00:24:17.786
it's worth your time and if you're not
00:24:17.826 --> 00:24:19.247
already subscribed to the operator
00:24:19.747 --> 00:24:21.911
That's where Larry is writing this in real
00:24:21.971 --> 00:24:23.374
time, one problem at a time,
00:24:23.413 --> 00:24:25.798
and now available on all podcast platforms
00:24:25.838 --> 00:24:26.721
as well as YouTube.
00:24:27.301 --> 00:24:29.185
We'll see you next time here on The
00:24:29.226 --> 00:24:29.567
Operator.
00:00:01.690 --> 00:00:01.870
All right,
00:00:01.909 --> 00:00:03.672
last time we talked about why healthcare
00:00:03.712 --> 00:00:05.152
platforms fail,
00:00:05.272 --> 00:00:07.915
and the headline surprised a lot of
00:00:07.934 --> 00:00:08.275
people.
00:00:08.676 --> 00:00:10.457
It got people very, very fired up,
00:00:10.917 --> 00:00:12.638
maybe because they didn't listen long
00:00:12.679 --> 00:00:13.019
enough.
00:00:13.599 --> 00:00:14.961
It's not private equity,
00:00:15.021 --> 00:00:16.823
it's not the ownership model,
00:00:17.362 --> 00:00:18.423
maybe it's the operators.
00:00:18.623 --> 00:00:19.964
So today we're gonna go deeper.
00:00:20.905 --> 00:00:22.426
Larry just dropped part two of this
00:00:22.466 --> 00:00:22.887
series.
00:00:22.926 --> 00:00:25.448
And this is where it gets uncomfortable
00:00:25.667 --> 00:00:27.147
because now we're not talking theory.
00:00:27.187 --> 00:00:29.028
We're talking about actual dysfunctions
00:00:29.489 --> 00:00:32.210
that keep blowing these things up.
00:00:32.289 --> 00:00:35.430
History keeps repeating themselves.
00:00:35.932 --> 00:00:36.472
Five of them.
00:00:36.671 --> 00:00:37.612
And the scary part,
00:00:37.972 --> 00:00:39.073
we've seen all five before.
00:00:39.872 --> 00:00:40.893
And we're still repeating them,
00:00:41.173 --> 00:00:41.994
just like history.
00:00:42.034 --> 00:00:43.837
So today we're breaking down where
00:00:43.877 --> 00:00:46.459
platforms actually go wrong and why smart
00:00:46.499 --> 00:00:49.942
people keep making the same mistakes and
00:00:49.982 --> 00:00:51.984
what the few operators who get it right
00:00:52.564 --> 00:00:53.765
are doing differently.
00:00:53.845 --> 00:00:55.067
So Larry, let's get into it.
00:00:56.067 --> 00:00:57.670
You said something that stuck with me.
00:00:58.210 --> 00:01:01.454
Failure is financing agnostic.
00:01:01.493 --> 00:01:02.615
That was the thing I think a lot
00:01:02.634 --> 00:01:04.016
of people last week said.
00:01:04.115 --> 00:01:05.076
when they heard you say,
00:01:05.456 --> 00:01:06.897
PE isn't the bad guy.
00:01:06.977 --> 00:01:08.438
They didn't stick around long enough to
00:01:08.457 --> 00:01:09.118
maybe go deeper.
00:01:09.218 --> 00:01:10.019
Maybe that's the trick.
00:01:10.299 --> 00:01:11.799
But if it's not private equity,
00:01:12.200 --> 00:01:15.042
then what actually is the root problem
00:01:15.102 --> 00:01:16.302
here?
00:01:16.362 --> 00:01:16.683
Yeah,
00:01:16.703 --> 00:01:18.963
so the root problem is that we keep
00:01:18.983 --> 00:01:21.364
treating American health care services
00:01:21.385 --> 00:01:22.585
like it's a scalable,
00:01:23.066 --> 00:01:24.787
dehumanized business product.
00:01:25.567 --> 00:01:26.628
And it isn't.
00:01:26.688 --> 00:01:28.709
CVS had ten point six billion.
00:01:28.868 --> 00:01:31.531
Amazon had effectively unlimited capital.
00:01:32.385 --> 00:01:34.167
Walgreens had the biggest national
00:01:34.206 --> 00:01:36.668
distribution infrastructure than any P
00:01:36.709 --> 00:01:38.370
firm would ever have.
00:01:39.290 --> 00:01:40.492
They were all three public,
00:01:41.332 --> 00:01:43.254
and they all walked into primary care with
00:01:43.313 --> 00:01:45.475
resources that would make any private
00:01:45.516 --> 00:01:46.756
equity sponsor blush.
00:01:47.576 --> 00:01:49.097
All three ended up with impairment
00:01:49.138 --> 00:01:50.438
charges, clinic closures,
00:01:50.498 --> 00:01:52.620
full dismemberment within three years.
00:01:53.549 --> 00:01:55.292
So if the answer were just getting better
00:01:55.331 --> 00:01:56.031
financing,
00:01:56.072 --> 00:01:58.454
then those three would have certainly
00:01:58.694 --> 00:01:59.516
figured it out.
00:01:59.596 --> 00:02:02.498
But the actual problem is structural.
00:02:03.058 --> 00:02:04.980
Healthcare is a relational,
00:02:05.120 --> 00:02:08.625
locally embedded reimbursement constrained
00:02:08.664 --> 00:02:09.765
and clinician dependent.
00:02:10.854 --> 00:02:12.776
Those are sort of four characteristics and
00:02:12.795 --> 00:02:14.739
they don't respond to capital the way that
00:02:14.758 --> 00:02:17.061
a consumer product or say a logistic
00:02:17.100 --> 00:02:17.842
business does.
00:02:18.543 --> 00:02:20.545
You can't centralize your way past them.
00:02:21.225 --> 00:02:23.209
You cannot acquire your way past them.
00:02:23.748 --> 00:02:25.771
You cannot hire sort of a McKenzie or
00:02:25.792 --> 00:02:28.014
a Bain team to optimize your past.
00:02:28.634 --> 00:02:29.395
They're optimized.
00:02:29.415 --> 00:02:30.556
You pass them at all.
00:02:31.337 --> 00:02:33.080
And the platforms that forget this,
00:02:33.161 --> 00:02:34.862
regardless of who's writing the check,
00:02:34.962 --> 00:02:36.044
end up in the same place.
00:02:36.264 --> 00:02:37.765
History does have a way of repeating
00:02:37.806 --> 00:02:38.146
itself,
00:02:38.167 --> 00:02:40.028
which is why I keep saying the financing
00:02:40.669 --> 00:02:43.554
is the accelerant, not the arsonist.
00:02:44.760 --> 00:02:44.901
Right.
00:02:44.920 --> 00:02:47.222
But it sometimes is the most visible.
00:02:47.282 --> 00:02:48.581
So we blame the most visible.
00:02:49.382 --> 00:02:50.442
You mentioned that word over
00:02:50.502 --> 00:02:51.282
centralization.
00:02:51.502 --> 00:02:53.143
My previous career was in broadcasting.
00:02:53.302 --> 00:02:53.962
We saw this.
00:02:54.143 --> 00:02:55.683
If you could manage one radio station,
00:02:55.824 --> 00:02:56.544
why not a hundred?
00:02:56.623 --> 00:02:57.443
Why not a thousand?
00:02:57.924 --> 00:03:01.104
You call over centralization the original
00:03:01.185 --> 00:03:01.485
sin.
00:03:02.104 --> 00:03:04.086
Why does something like that that looks
00:03:04.526 --> 00:03:07.127
like good management end up killing
00:03:07.546 --> 00:03:08.907
platforms in health care?
00:03:09.646 --> 00:03:11.046
Because it sort of feels like good
00:03:11.127 --> 00:03:12.728
management right up until it does it.
00:03:13.611 --> 00:03:15.812
When the platform is scaling fast and the
00:03:15.872 --> 00:03:17.774
acquisition pipeline is full and the
00:03:17.933 --> 00:03:21.096
EBITDA is growing, centralizing HR,
00:03:21.977 --> 00:03:24.258
finance and clinical protocols look like
00:03:24.277 --> 00:03:25.699
an operational discipline.
00:03:25.739 --> 00:03:26.719
It looked like a demand.
00:03:26.740 --> 00:03:28.640
It looked like a necessity, a default.
00:03:30.286 --> 00:03:31.888
but it looks like professionalizing a
00:03:31.948 --> 00:03:34.691
fragmented cottage industry.
00:03:34.730 --> 00:03:36.332
That's what we are as a cottage industry.
00:03:37.033 --> 00:03:38.915
It looks exactly what boards are asking
00:03:38.936 --> 00:03:39.096
for,
00:03:39.135 --> 00:03:41.399
but what's happening is you're dismantling
00:03:41.419 --> 00:03:43.281
the thing that makes the practice
00:03:43.360 --> 00:03:43.901
valuable.
00:03:44.461 --> 00:03:46.122
a patient's relationship with their
00:03:46.143 --> 00:03:47.483
hygienist, their PT,
00:03:47.522 --> 00:03:48.842
their primary care doctor.
00:03:49.302 --> 00:03:50.864
That's the product.
00:03:50.903 --> 00:03:52.805
The product is the relationship,
00:03:52.844 --> 00:03:55.104
the intangibles, the thing that is very,
00:03:55.145 --> 00:03:58.045
very difficult to scale and to quantify.
00:03:58.445 --> 00:04:00.747
That relationship is local, it's personal,
00:04:01.387 --> 00:04:02.907
and it also took a long time or
00:04:02.987 --> 00:04:03.888
years to build.
00:04:04.627 --> 00:04:07.049
The moment you start optimizing it from a
00:04:07.149 --> 00:04:09.750
corporate office four states away,
00:04:09.770 --> 00:04:11.251
you're not running the business better.
00:04:11.610 --> 00:04:13.191
You're consuming the business.
00:04:13.510 --> 00:04:15.391
And by the time the revenue trend makes
00:04:15.412 --> 00:04:16.091
that visible,
00:04:16.132 --> 00:04:17.432
the founders are already gone.
00:04:17.452 --> 00:04:19.053
The culture is already hollowed out.
00:04:19.454 --> 00:04:21.254
And you're trying to hire your way back
00:04:21.293 --> 00:04:24.134
to something that you destroyed on a
00:04:24.175 --> 00:04:24.836
spreadsheet.
00:04:24.855 --> 00:04:25.456
You know,
00:04:25.475 --> 00:04:27.096
if you look at the sort of the
00:04:27.137 --> 00:04:29.216
Harvard postmortem on Steward,
00:04:29.576 --> 00:04:30.838
they named it explicitly.
00:04:31.504 --> 00:04:34.346
Failure to invest in patient care combined
00:04:34.386 --> 00:04:36.766
with financial engineering that extracted
00:04:36.826 --> 00:04:38.208
value instead of building it.
00:04:38.887 --> 00:04:41.149
That's centralization's end state when it
00:04:41.189 --> 00:04:41.829
goes wrong.
00:04:42.228 --> 00:04:43.550
Five hospitals closed,
00:04:43.910 --> 00:04:45.550
five thousand workers displaced,
00:04:46.050 --> 00:04:48.130
a CEO dodging a Senate subpoena.
00:04:48.151 --> 00:04:50.672
That's where like looks like good
00:04:50.732 --> 00:04:51.992
management eventually goes.
00:04:53.805 --> 00:04:57.209
So then at what point does a platform
00:04:57.249 --> 00:04:58.029
cross the line?
00:04:58.569 --> 00:05:00.812
If I could manage one and then five
00:05:00.891 --> 00:05:01.333
okay,
00:05:02.353 --> 00:05:03.875
maybe this is a fair or unfair question,
00:05:04.396 --> 00:05:05.776
at what point does it cross the line
00:05:05.797 --> 00:05:07.458
from helpful infrastructure and
00:05:07.517 --> 00:05:09.120
centralizing thing to actually,
00:05:09.360 --> 00:05:10.000
what you just said,
00:05:10.060 --> 00:05:12.122
dismantling what actually made the
00:05:12.182 --> 00:05:13.403
business valuable?
00:05:13.803 --> 00:05:16.846
Yeah, it evolves over a process.
00:05:17.607 --> 00:05:18.627
It starts out...
00:05:19.641 --> 00:05:20.862
honoring the clinician,
00:05:20.922 --> 00:05:22.802
it ends up treating them like widget
00:05:22.822 --> 00:05:23.343
makers,
00:05:23.762 --> 00:05:25.824
that they're just fungible commodities.
00:05:26.124 --> 00:05:27.884
So that line is crossed when the local
00:05:27.983 --> 00:05:30.605
operator loses what I call real authority,
00:05:31.064 --> 00:05:33.165
not influence, authority,
00:05:33.946 --> 00:05:35.586
decision-making processes.
00:05:35.846 --> 00:05:36.687
There's a difference.
00:05:37.447 --> 00:05:39.648
Shared infrastructure at times makes
00:05:39.708 --> 00:05:40.088
sense.
00:05:40.327 --> 00:05:42.387
Billing, credentialing, supply chain,
00:05:42.468 --> 00:05:43.608
marketing, technology,
00:05:43.668 --> 00:05:44.168
nobody needs
00:05:45.346 --> 00:05:47.468
EMR implementations across a platform.
00:05:47.987 --> 00:05:50.250
That's legitimately more efficient and it
00:05:50.290 --> 00:05:51.550
frees up clinical time.
00:05:51.790 --> 00:05:53.130
I've got no argument with that.
00:05:53.690 --> 00:05:55.151
But the line gets crossed when the
00:05:55.192 --> 00:05:58.514
decision on how many patients a clinician
00:05:58.593 --> 00:06:00.394
sees and
00:06:00.555 --> 00:06:02.216
what they're being paid for seeing them
00:06:02.495 --> 00:06:04.958
and what the patients see which patients
00:06:04.978 --> 00:06:06.899
they see in terms of payer mix and
00:06:06.978 --> 00:06:09.899
whether that practice keeps the culture
00:06:09.920 --> 00:06:12.002
that they built because all of a sudden
00:06:12.242 --> 00:06:14.942
central management starts sending things
00:06:15.223 --> 00:06:17.625
out and they say you have to see
00:06:17.665 --> 00:06:19.365
this many patients you're doing this much
00:06:19.386 --> 00:06:20.627
you have to do this you have to
00:06:20.666 --> 00:06:23.028
adopt this and those decisions then
00:06:23.108 --> 00:06:25.850
migrate they could migrate even to a you
00:06:26.050 --> 00:06:28.170
know regional operator or a ceo who's
00:06:28.230 --> 00:06:29.252
never treated a patient
00:06:30.083 --> 00:06:31.423
That's when they've stopped building
00:06:31.483 --> 00:06:33.086
infrastructure on the clinical business
00:06:33.365 --> 00:06:34.927
and they started replacing the clinical
00:06:34.966 --> 00:06:36.809
business with a management layer.
00:06:37.348 --> 00:06:38.831
So that's how that thing evolves.
00:06:38.850 --> 00:06:40.451
The patients eventually figured out,
00:06:40.951 --> 00:06:42.353
referral sources figured out,
00:06:42.913 --> 00:06:44.915
and then the clinicians figure out and
00:06:44.956 --> 00:06:45.396
they leave.
00:06:45.475 --> 00:06:46.596
They go down to something better.
00:06:46.858 --> 00:06:48.298
It's usually in that order, by the way.
00:06:48.678 --> 00:06:49.160
Yep.
00:06:49.240 --> 00:06:50.461
And then the thing that made you valuable
00:06:50.480 --> 00:06:52.362
walks out the door and you're confused as
00:06:52.401 --> 00:06:53.023
to what happened.
00:06:54.194 --> 00:06:54.774
Yeah.
00:06:54.795 --> 00:06:57.036
You've said misaligned compensation isn't
00:06:57.055 --> 00:06:57.315
a bug.
00:06:57.336 --> 00:06:58.016
It's a feature.
00:06:59.016 --> 00:07:00.396
This is super zoomed in.
00:07:00.416 --> 00:07:01.598
We've seen this a lot.
00:07:01.677 --> 00:07:04.259
We had a discussion before about KPIs when
00:07:04.278 --> 00:07:05.699
you're aiming at a target that isn't
00:07:05.759 --> 00:07:07.699
valuable in the long term.
00:07:08.079 --> 00:07:10.120
So what are these systems actually
00:07:10.281 --> 00:07:13.682
incentivizing clinicians to actually do?
00:07:14.428 --> 00:07:14.569
Yeah,
00:07:14.588 --> 00:07:15.889
so this is a key out of the
00:07:15.908 --> 00:07:16.970
five dysfunctions.
00:07:17.050 --> 00:07:19.470
It's the effectively misaligning
00:07:19.509 --> 00:07:20.370
compensation.
00:07:20.910 --> 00:07:23.870
And it's two things, and they're both bad.
00:07:24.370 --> 00:07:25.790
The first is what I'll call the
00:07:25.850 --> 00:07:28.711
volume-driven model, revenue per visit,
00:07:28.771 --> 00:07:29.932
daily patient counts,
00:07:30.072 --> 00:07:31.413
units per billing targets,
00:07:31.673 --> 00:07:33.733
where you explicitly tell clinicians that
00:07:33.793 --> 00:07:34.492
more is better,
00:07:34.913 --> 00:07:37.153
regardless of what the patient actually
00:07:37.374 --> 00:07:37.514
says.
00:07:37.593 --> 00:07:40.615
is coming in on that particular day so
00:07:40.754 --> 00:07:42.574
you get treatment center you know you get
00:07:42.615 --> 00:07:43.754
these sort of treatment sessions
00:07:43.814 --> 00:07:46.375
structured around maximizing time billing
00:07:46.415 --> 00:07:48.617
codes rather than clinical outcomes it
00:07:48.697 --> 00:07:51.737
shifts the incentive shifts from the love
00:07:52.117 --> 00:07:54.418
and meaningful work of seeing patients to
00:07:54.637 --> 00:07:57.519
external numbers units time codes all
00:07:57.538 --> 00:07:58.298
those kind of things
00:07:59.019 --> 00:08:01.240
And the clinicians who take on these cases
00:08:01.800 --> 00:08:03.781
have to because the schedule demands it.
00:08:04.242 --> 00:08:06.083
They try to optimize the schedule.
00:08:06.583 --> 00:08:09.125
You get throughput, if you will,
00:08:09.165 --> 00:08:11.365
disguised as sort of productivity.
00:08:11.987 --> 00:08:14.367
And then burnout isn't a side effect of
00:08:14.408 --> 00:08:15.067
that system.
00:08:15.208 --> 00:08:18.529
It's the logical output of asking sort of
00:08:18.550 --> 00:08:20.851
a doctoral-level professional to function
00:08:20.891 --> 00:08:23.173
like a widget in an assembly line.
00:08:23.273 --> 00:08:23.552
Again,
00:08:23.593 --> 00:08:27.115
it's that migration of the business into a
00:08:27.735 --> 00:08:28.315
model system
00:08:28.809 --> 00:08:30.490
of manufacturing, if you will,
00:08:30.790 --> 00:08:32.591
rather than relating it's a people
00:08:32.631 --> 00:08:34.594
business all about the relationships.
00:08:35.173 --> 00:08:35.695
The other,
00:08:35.774 --> 00:08:38.996
the second failure is the flat salary
00:08:39.057 --> 00:08:39.457
model.
00:08:39.857 --> 00:08:41.558
Oh, we're going to pay our therapist X.
00:08:41.740 --> 00:08:41.799
Oh,
00:08:41.820 --> 00:08:43.020
and then the new class comes in a
00:08:43.041 --> 00:08:43.780
year and they're going to say,
00:08:43.801 --> 00:08:46.143
we're going to pay them X plus ten.
00:08:46.182 --> 00:08:47.024
Well, guess what?
00:08:47.043 --> 00:08:48.325
And then they go back to the other
00:08:48.524 --> 00:08:50.186
X and have to ten up them.
00:08:51.187 --> 00:08:53.668
And this is really popular more in the
00:08:53.729 --> 00:08:55.610
physical therapy and the dental hygiene
00:08:55.971 --> 00:08:57.451
space.
00:08:57.611 --> 00:08:59.212
We build professionals where the only way
00:08:59.232 --> 00:09:00.714
you can increase your income is to stop
00:09:00.734 --> 00:09:02.274
seeing patients move into management.
00:09:02.796 --> 00:09:03.996
So our best clinicians,
00:09:04.017 --> 00:09:06.077
the ones with the deepest clinical skills
00:09:06.177 --> 00:09:08.159
and the strongest patient relationships,
00:09:08.740 --> 00:09:11.042
are now economically incentivized to
00:09:11.081 --> 00:09:12.623
become a regional manager.
00:09:12.682 --> 00:09:14.264
They're incentivized to leave clinical
00:09:14.303 --> 00:09:16.605
practice as soon as it's possible.
00:09:17.984 --> 00:09:19.904
Then we run studies wondering why we have
00:09:19.945 --> 00:09:21.005
workforce shortages.
00:09:21.046 --> 00:09:22.546
Between two thousand twenty three and two
00:09:22.586 --> 00:09:25.128
thousand twenty four on the physician
00:09:25.148 --> 00:09:25.488
side,
00:09:25.628 --> 00:09:28.529
union petitions surged nearly nine hundred
00:09:29.129 --> 00:09:29.789
percent,
00:09:30.029 --> 00:09:32.230
nine hundred percent in a profession that
00:09:32.270 --> 00:09:34.613
spent decades philosophically opposed to
00:09:34.633 --> 00:09:35.773
collective bargaining.
00:09:36.092 --> 00:09:37.293
They were against unions.
00:09:37.634 --> 00:09:38.774
When you see that number,
00:09:39.315 --> 00:09:41.615
that really implies that the compensation
00:09:42.136 --> 00:09:44.158
dysfunction isn't sort of theory.
00:09:45.238 --> 00:09:46.038
It's producing,
00:09:46.360 --> 00:09:49.202
it's really a structural argument,
00:09:49.302 --> 00:09:50.264
structural response.
00:09:51.065 --> 00:09:52.686
Let's talk about this other problem that
00:09:52.706 --> 00:09:55.328
you brought up, this altitude problem.
00:09:55.469 --> 00:09:58.211
Decisions getting made further and further
00:09:58.631 --> 00:09:59.693
from the clinical floor,
00:09:59.734 --> 00:10:00.835
where that business,
00:10:00.875 --> 00:10:02.777
the value that the organization provides
00:10:02.817 --> 00:10:03.557
actually happens.
00:10:04.458 --> 00:10:06.301
What's the real cost of that disconnect,
00:10:06.321 --> 00:10:07.481
that altitude problem?
00:10:08.256 --> 00:10:08.557
Yeah,
00:10:08.576 --> 00:10:10.597
the real cost is that by the time
00:10:10.677 --> 00:10:13.418
bad decisions become visible as the
00:10:13.498 --> 00:10:14.238
revenue line,
00:10:14.258 --> 00:10:17.139
the damage has been in process for like
00:10:17.178 --> 00:10:18.399
a year to a year and a half.
00:10:18.840 --> 00:10:20.139
That's sort of a lag period,
00:10:20.179 --> 00:10:21.179
twelve to eighteen months.
00:10:21.779 --> 00:10:25.081
A CFO who's never seen a physical therapy
00:10:25.140 --> 00:10:27.822
episode designs a productivity metric.
00:10:27.942 --> 00:10:29.682
A compensation committee that's never
00:10:29.721 --> 00:10:31.942
worked in a clinical environment sets a
00:10:31.982 --> 00:10:32.623
pay structure.
00:10:33.688 --> 00:10:35.909
all these for doctoral you know
00:10:35.950 --> 00:10:38.471
professionals a regional director whose
00:10:38.511 --> 00:10:40.312
entire health care background is a
00:10:40.393 --> 00:10:42.234
consulting engagement or maybe they worked
00:10:42.274 --> 00:10:44.215
in a multi-site and worked their way up
00:10:44.774 --> 00:10:46.576
and it's all clinical efficiencies you
00:10:46.596 --> 00:10:48.636
know from a spreadsheet none of these
00:10:48.876 --> 00:10:51.097
decisions produce an immediate sort of
00:10:51.158 --> 00:10:53.578
catastrophic event it happens over time a
00:10:53.639 --> 00:10:56.441
slow degradation of clinical engagement
00:10:56.760 --> 00:10:57.682
patient experience,
00:10:57.721 --> 00:10:58.903
referral relationships,
00:10:59.342 --> 00:11:01.563
and a real bigaboo, retention.
00:11:01.985 --> 00:11:03.946
And by the time that degradation shows up
00:11:03.966 --> 00:11:04.546
in the numbers,
00:11:04.586 --> 00:11:07.587
the people who made those decisions have
00:11:08.828 --> 00:11:09.870
oftentimes moved on.
00:11:09.889 --> 00:11:11.870
They've had souped up, tricked up resumes,
00:11:11.910 --> 00:11:12.892
worked with search firms.
00:11:13.272 --> 00:11:14.832
I've had now success and growth in a
00:11:14.873 --> 00:11:16.193
multi-site and they move on.
00:11:16.854 --> 00:11:18.995
I call that the altitude problem because
00:11:19.015 --> 00:11:20.836
the higher the decision that gets made,
00:11:20.856 --> 00:11:21.977
the less grounded it is.
00:11:22.398 --> 00:11:23.958
and the reality of where that care
00:11:23.999 --> 00:11:25.799
actually happens at the clinic.
00:11:26.360 --> 00:11:27.701
And in health care services,
00:11:27.801 --> 00:11:30.883
the care is the business.
00:11:31.342 --> 00:11:32.884
Everything else is supportive
00:11:32.903 --> 00:11:33.563
infrastructure.
00:11:33.984 --> 00:11:35.705
When the supportive infrastructure starts
00:11:35.784 --> 00:11:38.427
making business decisions about the care
00:11:38.447 --> 00:11:39.868
without understanding the care,
00:11:40.408 --> 00:11:41.869
you've inverted the model,
00:11:42.149 --> 00:11:44.230
and that in itself is a symptom of
00:11:44.250 --> 00:11:44.990
the dysfunction.
00:11:45.390 --> 00:11:47.111
The tail is now wagging the dog,
00:11:47.131 --> 00:11:48.711
and the dog is the part that actually
00:11:48.772 --> 00:11:49.732
generates the revenue.
00:11:49.996 --> 00:11:51.418
Yeah, let's get even scarier.
00:11:51.438 --> 00:11:52.679
Let's bring in Frankenstein to this
00:11:52.740 --> 00:11:53.059
equation.
00:11:53.080 --> 00:11:53.980
You've described what you call
00:11:54.061 --> 00:11:55.221
Frankenstein network,
00:11:55.842 --> 00:11:57.605
where many platforms prioritize
00:11:58.004 --> 00:12:00.248
acquisition, buying new things,
00:12:00.447 --> 00:12:04.011
absorbing things over actually integrating
00:12:04.412 --> 00:12:06.173
what they've already bought.
00:12:06.274 --> 00:12:07.014
Why does this happen?
00:12:07.477 --> 00:12:07.677
Yeah,
00:12:08.118 --> 00:12:09.739
so let's get to the Frankenstein by
00:12:09.778 --> 00:12:11.480
setting some context here a little bit.
00:12:11.980 --> 00:12:14.441
See, acquisitions generate headlines.
00:12:15.020 --> 00:12:16.341
Integration doesn't.
00:12:16.942 --> 00:12:18.582
When you close a ten clinic deal,
00:12:18.623 --> 00:12:19.523
there's a press release.
00:12:19.863 --> 00:12:21.224
There's a multiple that went up.
00:12:21.764 --> 00:12:23.585
There's something to show the board at the
00:12:23.625 --> 00:12:24.645
next quarterly meeting.
00:12:25.005 --> 00:12:26.966
When you spend eighteen months integrating
00:12:26.986 --> 00:12:29.567
that acquisition, aligning EHR systems,
00:12:29.967 --> 00:12:31.187
building shared culture,
00:12:31.249 --> 00:12:32.649
developing clinical staff,
00:12:32.668 --> 00:12:34.149
investing in same-store growth,
00:12:34.690 --> 00:12:35.831
There isn't a press release.
00:12:36.172 --> 00:12:37.332
The board doesn't really care.
00:12:37.352 --> 00:12:38.794
It's an expectation they have,
00:12:38.835 --> 00:12:40.176
but that can take eighteen months.
00:12:40.876 --> 00:12:43.198
There's just quiet operational work that
00:12:43.240 --> 00:12:45.621
eventually shows up as margin improvement
00:12:45.642 --> 00:12:46.322
and retention.
00:12:46.663 --> 00:12:50.106
The way to judge an acquisition is you
00:12:50.147 --> 00:12:52.789
pay a multiple and that multiple has to
00:12:52.809 --> 00:12:55.432
be brought down to a better return on
00:12:55.452 --> 00:12:56.153
that multiple.
00:12:56.494 --> 00:12:58.034
in over a period of time.
00:12:58.475 --> 00:13:01.275
I think eighteen months is a reasonable
00:13:01.416 --> 00:13:02.255
expectation.
00:13:02.937 --> 00:13:03.836
And in my experience,
00:13:03.856 --> 00:13:05.697
you can grow a company twenty to thirty
00:13:05.738 --> 00:13:07.298
percent over that time period.
00:13:07.337 --> 00:13:09.119
The problem is you start stacking all
00:13:09.139 --> 00:13:10.119
these acquisitions,
00:13:10.158 --> 00:13:11.419
which is what happened in all these
00:13:11.460 --> 00:13:12.720
dysfunctional companies,
00:13:13.440 --> 00:13:14.780
and they couldn't integrate
00:13:15.241 --> 00:13:17.102
and one didn't get to one point two
00:13:17.143 --> 00:13:17.602
point oh,
00:13:17.623 --> 00:13:19.964
it got to point six and point seven.
00:13:20.604 --> 00:13:20.903
You see,
00:13:21.384 --> 00:13:23.784
PE incentive structures don't wait for the
00:13:23.825 --> 00:13:25.225
quiet operational work.
00:13:25.426 --> 00:13:26.866
They're on a five year hold period.
00:13:27.307 --> 00:13:29.067
Every quarter you're not acquiring is a
00:13:29.128 --> 00:13:30.628
quarter you're not building towards the
00:13:30.668 --> 00:13:31.408
exit multiple.
00:13:31.869 --> 00:13:33.548
So here's what you end up instead.
00:13:33.769 --> 00:13:35.129
That's what I call the Frankenstein
00:13:35.149 --> 00:13:35.570
network.
00:13:35.950 --> 00:13:37.730
Dozens of acquired practicing,
00:13:38.171 --> 00:13:39.631
each with its own EHR,
00:13:39.772 --> 00:13:41.052
each with its own culture,
00:13:41.472 --> 00:13:43.472
each with its own billing practice
00:13:43.513 --> 00:13:44.953
stitched together under brand
00:13:45.333 --> 00:13:47.816
shared name and a shared debt load with
00:13:47.875 --> 00:13:50.017
almost none of the operational synergies
00:13:50.076 --> 00:13:51.977
that justify the acquisition premium.
00:13:52.698 --> 00:13:54.940
Systems don't align, cultures clash.
00:13:55.019 --> 00:13:57.182
It's all one sided central management
00:13:57.261 --> 00:13:58.701
telling you what you have to do.
00:13:59.143 --> 00:14:00.764
No area of collaboration,
00:14:01.083 --> 00:14:03.325
no fierce disagreement, no teamwork,
00:14:03.806 --> 00:14:05.166
none of the things, you know,
00:14:05.206 --> 00:14:06.988
the tacit knowledge skills that you have
00:14:07.028 --> 00:14:08.368
to do when you really bring teams
00:14:08.408 --> 00:14:08.828
together.
00:14:09.621 --> 00:14:11.003
Then the clinicians who joined that
00:14:11.023 --> 00:14:11.583
platform,
00:14:12.063 --> 00:14:14.166
when they still had its original culture,
00:14:14.206 --> 00:14:17.308
they watch it get diluted with all these
00:14:17.349 --> 00:14:19.331
successive deals and same store growth,
00:14:19.350 --> 00:14:21.452
which is the actual proof that the
00:14:21.493 --> 00:14:22.433
business model works,
00:14:22.514 --> 00:14:24.274
never gets the investment it needs because
00:14:24.294 --> 00:14:26.356
the capital is always paying for the next
00:14:26.437 --> 00:14:28.379
acquisition or paying the interest on
00:14:28.418 --> 00:14:29.340
their acquisition.
00:14:29.700 --> 00:14:31.741
It's a great way to build a very
00:14:31.782 --> 00:14:33.724
impressive looking platform that is
00:14:33.783 --> 00:14:35.985
quietly hollowing out from the inside.
00:14:36.625 --> 00:14:37.826
Looks great on paper while they're
00:14:37.966 --> 00:14:39.787
quietly, I guess, running out of cash.
00:14:41.267 --> 00:14:41.486
Yes.
00:14:41.606 --> 00:14:43.847
Let's at least close on something hopeful.
00:14:45.128 --> 00:14:47.028
What are the platforms that actually get
00:14:47.067 --> 00:14:49.408
this right doing differently?
00:14:49.428 --> 00:14:51.909
This is the reason we study history all
00:14:51.929 --> 00:14:52.669
throughout school, right?
00:14:52.690 --> 00:14:54.470
We're supposed to watch the failures and
00:14:54.509 --> 00:14:55.830
piece together the things that could have,
00:14:55.850 --> 00:14:56.530
should have, would have happened.
00:14:56.551 --> 00:14:57.990
But who's doing it right now?
00:14:58.763 --> 00:14:58.942
Yeah,
00:14:58.962 --> 00:15:00.865
so I'll answer the second part of that
00:15:00.904 --> 00:15:02.765
carefully because the platforms doing this
00:15:02.826 --> 00:15:04.626
really well are usually private and
00:15:04.647 --> 00:15:06.128
they're not looking for attention.
00:15:06.629 --> 00:15:08.169
The ones that shout out about it the
00:15:08.210 --> 00:15:09.870
loudest are usually the ones that have the
00:15:09.931 --> 00:15:12.432
slickest decks and the most questionable
00:15:12.533 --> 00:15:13.693
unit economics.
00:15:13.714 --> 00:15:16.615
So I'll give you that pattern rather than
00:15:16.655 --> 00:15:17.437
the names,
00:15:17.517 --> 00:15:19.238
although I'm not afraid to name a few
00:15:19.278 --> 00:15:19.778
of them here.
00:15:20.438 --> 00:15:21.458
But what they share,
00:15:21.499 --> 00:15:22.899
let's talk about their commonalities.
00:15:22.960 --> 00:15:25.182
Clinician-informed leadership at every
00:15:25.241 --> 00:15:25.522
level.
00:15:25.822 --> 00:15:27.264
They don't run off founders.
00:15:28.222 --> 00:15:29.743
They don't do those kinds of things.
00:15:29.763 --> 00:15:33.524
They don't have this kind of poster child
00:15:33.724 --> 00:15:36.304
chief clinical officer joined at the hip
00:15:36.384 --> 00:15:38.424
of their COO as though that is some
00:15:38.465 --> 00:15:39.546
kind of big deal.
00:15:41.186 --> 00:15:42.807
But they don't care about clinical
00:15:42.826 --> 00:15:44.767
advisory boards that report up.
00:15:45.246 --> 00:15:47.168
But what they have is actual operators
00:15:47.187 --> 00:15:48.488
with actual authority
00:15:49.048 --> 00:15:51.690
and rooms where decisions get made see
00:15:51.730 --> 00:15:53.932
clinicians have transportable skills that
00:15:53.951 --> 00:15:56.092
have allowed them to be entrepreneurs and
00:15:56.153 --> 00:15:58.674
managers and they built businesses now you
00:15:58.735 --> 00:16:00.876
take them out of businesses doesn't make
00:16:00.937 --> 00:16:03.798
any sense right compensation models where
00:16:03.818 --> 00:16:06.441
a clinician who produces more takes home
00:16:06.480 --> 00:16:09.442
more that's realignment not a peloton sort
00:16:09.482 --> 00:16:11.345
of leaderboard with penalty tiers
00:16:12.065 --> 00:16:14.206
They don't do the next acquisition until
00:16:14.245 --> 00:16:16.047
the last one gets integrated.
00:16:16.486 --> 00:16:18.528
They do success one at a time.
00:16:18.548 --> 00:16:19.508
They share systems.
00:16:19.869 --> 00:16:21.089
They bring on culture.
00:16:21.408 --> 00:16:23.269
They recognize that you have different
00:16:23.309 --> 00:16:24.850
cultures and history and legacy,
00:16:24.890 --> 00:16:27.111
but you bring them together and they
00:16:27.172 --> 00:16:29.072
create new commitments around that.
00:16:29.753 --> 00:16:33.575
They use same store growth as the primary
00:16:33.855 --> 00:16:36.196
metric, organic growth.
00:16:36.990 --> 00:16:38.432
The reason they do that is if you
00:16:38.491 --> 00:16:40.373
can't do something well organically,
00:16:40.452 --> 00:16:42.313
why should you ever be entitled to buy
00:16:42.374 --> 00:16:44.095
anything?
00:16:44.115 --> 00:16:46.317
The clinician entrepreneurs who built the
00:16:46.356 --> 00:16:47.157
local businesses,
00:16:47.177 --> 00:16:48.958
they stay in the platform one way or
00:16:48.999 --> 00:16:49.399
another.
00:16:50.198 --> 00:16:51.159
They keep equity.
00:16:51.735 --> 00:16:54.557
They have genuine operational authority.
00:16:54.596 --> 00:16:56.278
They still have ownership at the local
00:16:56.317 --> 00:16:56.618
level.
00:16:56.658 --> 00:16:58.198
They might have it at the top level,
00:16:58.239 --> 00:16:59.799
but they really need it at the local
00:16:59.860 --> 00:17:00.159
level.
00:17:00.480 --> 00:17:03.062
They're not transition out six months
00:17:03.101 --> 00:17:06.804
under some cockamamie CEO trying to make a
00:17:06.864 --> 00:17:09.945
name for themselves and say, oh,
00:17:09.986 --> 00:17:11.946
we got running off founders as though that
00:17:11.987 --> 00:17:13.708
was built with some sort of strength.
00:17:14.760 --> 00:17:16.761
And here's the one ad that doesn't get
00:17:16.801 --> 00:17:17.422
enough attention.
00:17:18.042 --> 00:17:19.723
The professional managers in these
00:17:19.784 --> 00:17:23.665
platforms have verifiable track records of
00:17:23.705 --> 00:17:24.586
organic growth,
00:17:24.645 --> 00:17:27.968
not tricked up search firm resumes that
00:17:28.028 --> 00:17:29.709
claim top line growth,
00:17:29.749 --> 00:17:31.289
even though you bought a bunch of things,
00:17:31.349 --> 00:17:31.609
right?
00:17:32.130 --> 00:17:34.691
Specifically during the post COVID period,
00:17:34.730 --> 00:17:36.471
this is what is incredibly important
00:17:36.491 --> 00:17:39.054
because this is the period of time when
00:17:39.134 --> 00:17:40.513
labor costs have spiked,
00:17:40.614 --> 00:17:41.934
supply chains broke,
00:17:41.994 --> 00:17:43.615
reimbursement got cut,
00:17:44.115 --> 00:17:46.741
And clinician shortages were the new new.
00:17:46.862 --> 00:17:47.763
They were the new normal.
00:17:48.483 --> 00:17:50.184
Anyone could look at an operator in a
00:17:50.244 --> 00:17:52.145
free money environment from years ago
00:17:52.166 --> 00:17:54.067
where acquisitions were made and claimed
00:17:54.087 --> 00:17:55.528
they had all kinds of growth.
00:17:55.749 --> 00:17:57.069
And that's what you see on these tricked
00:17:57.109 --> 00:18:00.352
up resumes is the bragging of growth.
00:18:00.372 --> 00:18:01.011
Which, by the way,
00:18:01.051 --> 00:18:04.535
I'm going to go back and redo two
00:18:04.575 --> 00:18:06.395
more additions to metrics that don't
00:18:06.435 --> 00:18:06.756
matter.
00:18:06.796 --> 00:18:08.457
And growth and scale are going to be
00:18:09.258 --> 00:18:10.398
the next few episodes.
00:18:10.798 --> 00:18:11.499
But the question is,
00:18:12.460 --> 00:18:13.340
what do these companies do?
00:18:13.441 --> 00:18:15.182
They grew and they couldn't buy their way
00:18:15.261 --> 00:18:15.721
into it.
00:18:15.741 --> 00:18:17.363
These are companies that are quiet
00:18:17.462 --> 00:18:18.023
gainers.
00:18:18.844 --> 00:18:20.365
They didn't have to be flashy,
00:18:20.664 --> 00:18:22.646
shiny objects by buying new companies.
00:18:23.106 --> 00:18:25.107
The platforms that ask the questions in
00:18:25.127 --> 00:18:28.150
the hiring process are the ones that I
00:18:28.190 --> 00:18:29.270
will be watching.
00:18:29.871 --> 00:18:30.371
In dental,
00:18:30.431 --> 00:18:32.353
I could tell you Heartland Dental,
00:18:32.492 --> 00:18:35.674
a long-term DSO established by KKR,
00:18:36.315 --> 00:18:39.317
very thoughtful about how they do
00:18:39.356 --> 00:18:40.958
acquisitions and de novos.
00:18:42.439 --> 00:18:44.680
I think you've seen some physical therapy
00:18:44.720 --> 00:18:46.421
companies in the early days who've
00:18:46.461 --> 00:18:47.162
collapsed.
00:18:47.682 --> 00:18:49.584
But they started out doing mostly de
00:18:49.624 --> 00:18:50.124
novos,
00:18:50.163 --> 00:18:52.286
then went to mostly acquisitions and then
00:18:52.326 --> 00:18:53.886
failed.
00:18:53.948 --> 00:18:56.529
So there are winners in this world,
00:18:56.569 --> 00:18:59.352
but they remain relatively quiet and
00:18:59.712 --> 00:19:00.313
understated.
00:19:00.692 --> 00:19:01.374
Quiet and humble.
00:19:01.394 --> 00:19:01.673
All right.
00:19:01.693 --> 00:19:04.175
Let's play a quick segment called Operate
00:19:04.757 --> 00:19:05.617
or Overrate.
00:19:05.857 --> 00:19:06.719
Just give me an overrate.
00:19:06.759 --> 00:19:08.460
You want to operate or overrate?
00:19:09.480 --> 00:19:12.083
Centralized clinical protocols.
00:19:12.344 --> 00:19:13.825
Is that overrated or underrated?
00:19:16.278 --> 00:19:17.905
centralized clinical protocols.
00:19:20.616 --> 00:19:23.117
I think that's probably underrated.
00:19:23.917 --> 00:19:26.317
I think you have to have a
00:19:27.098 --> 00:19:31.440
consensus-driven approach to clinical
00:19:31.500 --> 00:19:33.380
protocols from the standpoint of evidence
00:19:33.420 --> 00:19:35.099
and the hierarchy of evidence.
00:19:35.800 --> 00:19:36.240
And say,
00:19:36.401 --> 00:19:39.240
out of the framework of low back pain,
00:19:39.942 --> 00:19:41.582
these are the clinical prediction rules
00:19:41.622 --> 00:19:42.281
we're going to use.
00:19:42.321 --> 00:19:44.923
These are the algorithms that we're going
00:19:44.962 --> 00:19:45.623
to teach.
00:19:46.464 --> 00:19:47.546
the treatment approaches.
00:19:47.865 --> 00:19:48.125
Yes,
00:19:48.165 --> 00:19:49.846
we understand there are deviations and
00:19:49.886 --> 00:19:52.188
comorbidities and things off of them.
00:19:53.189 --> 00:19:56.049
But I know I always wanted physicians
00:19:56.069 --> 00:19:57.730
coming back to me and saying, you know,
00:19:57.891 --> 00:19:59.172
I love the fact that when I send
00:19:59.231 --> 00:20:00.472
a low back pain patient,
00:20:00.492 --> 00:20:02.394
you do a clinical prediction rule or
00:20:02.453 --> 00:20:03.934
something and then engage them in a
00:20:03.994 --> 00:20:04.454
protocol.
00:20:04.474 --> 00:20:05.996
You don't have one person who just does
00:20:06.056 --> 00:20:06.756
manual therapy,
00:20:06.796 --> 00:20:08.237
another person that just does sports
00:20:08.277 --> 00:20:08.698
medicine,
00:20:09.097 --> 00:20:10.878
another person that just does McKenzie,
00:20:10.898 --> 00:20:12.640
another person that just does Syriax.
00:20:13.200 --> 00:20:16.001
So I do believe that an organizational's
00:20:16.063 --> 00:20:18.964
value in clinic is deciding on the top
00:20:19.005 --> 00:20:21.366
twelve to fifteen diagnosis and having
00:20:21.406 --> 00:20:22.907
treatment parameters and clinical
00:20:22.948 --> 00:20:24.910
prediction rules and evidence based
00:20:24.970 --> 00:20:25.631
process.
00:20:26.991 --> 00:20:27.271
You know,
00:20:27.432 --> 00:20:30.615
all they're driven through meta analysis
00:20:30.674 --> 00:20:31.996
and through and through the Cochrane
00:20:32.036 --> 00:20:34.077
system for the hierarchy of evidence.
00:20:34.824 --> 00:20:35.444
How about this one,
00:20:35.724 --> 00:20:37.666
which has been a buzz the last twelve
00:20:37.686 --> 00:20:38.508
to eighteen months?
00:20:39.148 --> 00:20:41.111
AI in health care operations.
00:20:41.151 --> 00:20:42.152
When it first popped up,
00:20:42.211 --> 00:20:43.413
it was going to be the savior of
00:20:43.453 --> 00:20:43.933
everything.
00:20:43.993 --> 00:20:46.237
But is it overrated or underrated or
00:20:46.297 --> 00:20:48.078
properly rated?
00:20:48.098 --> 00:20:49.621
Today, I would call it overrated.
00:20:50.642 --> 00:20:52.263
I think in the future it will be
00:20:52.344 --> 00:20:52.923
underrated.
00:20:53.204 --> 00:20:53.986
But right now.
00:20:54.590 --> 00:20:56.872
What you have is a lot of underfunded
00:20:56.932 --> 00:20:58.932
companies with shiny objects,
00:20:59.532 --> 00:21:02.094
adding things to EMR packages,
00:21:02.153 --> 00:21:03.714
marketing lead generation,
00:21:03.775 --> 00:21:05.134
schedule optimizing.
00:21:05.694 --> 00:21:07.596
All they are doing is allowing the over
00:21:07.655 --> 00:21:10.257
centralization feature that I've talked
00:21:10.277 --> 00:21:12.018
about it to be accelerated.
00:21:12.097 --> 00:21:13.278
That's not a good thing.
00:21:13.778 --> 00:21:15.118
Where it can become a good thing?
00:21:15.753 --> 00:21:17.394
Not optimizing EMR,
00:21:17.474 --> 00:21:19.036
not optimizing your schedule,
00:21:19.415 --> 00:21:21.136
not optimizing technology,
00:21:21.477 --> 00:21:23.097
optimizing humanness.
00:21:23.739 --> 00:21:25.419
What can I put in place that allows
00:21:25.480 --> 00:21:27.701
my therapists and my doctors to be more
00:21:27.760 --> 00:21:28.381
humane,
00:21:28.421 --> 00:21:30.342
to spend more time with their patients,
00:21:30.382 --> 00:21:31.423
to go home at the end of the
00:21:31.442 --> 00:21:34.304
day without the externalities of pressures
00:21:34.384 --> 00:21:34.704
on them?
00:21:35.265 --> 00:21:36.605
I have an article that I've written with
00:21:36.645 --> 00:21:39.426
Tim Flynn on the use of AI agents
00:21:39.507 --> 00:21:42.407
and how five agents running simultaneously
00:21:42.448 --> 00:21:44.528
in a physical therapist background will
00:21:44.548 --> 00:21:47.451
really enable a therapist to be more
00:21:47.510 --> 00:21:49.090
compassionate, empathetic,
00:21:49.391 --> 00:21:50.912
and spend more time with their patients.
00:21:51.291 --> 00:21:54.574
Now, that is where AI would be underrated.
00:21:54.693 --> 00:21:54.773
Well,
00:21:54.794 --> 00:21:56.055
that's what you talked about being that's
00:21:56.095 --> 00:21:57.255
where the business actually,
00:21:57.275 --> 00:21:58.336
that's where the value part of the
00:21:58.375 --> 00:21:58.935
business is.
00:21:59.355 --> 00:22:01.176
Last one I'll ask, overrated, underrated,
00:22:01.596 --> 00:22:03.337
flat salary compensation.
00:22:05.019 --> 00:22:06.201
Oh, grossly overrated.
00:22:07.141 --> 00:22:07.260
Yeah.
00:22:07.280 --> 00:22:08.842
You should never pay your top therapist
00:22:08.862 --> 00:22:10.903
the same as your bottom therapist through
00:22:10.982 --> 00:22:12.003
top line compensation.
00:22:12.523 --> 00:22:15.305
And variable compensation is not bonuses
00:22:15.365 --> 00:22:16.185
and incentives.
00:22:17.105 --> 00:22:19.948
It is the maturity to say we have
00:22:19.968 --> 00:22:22.931
a doctoring profession where we have
00:22:24.113 --> 00:22:27.316
ethics and values and expertise,
00:22:27.936 --> 00:22:30.098
and they should be paid a percentage of
00:22:30.118 --> 00:22:32.721
the compensation or the net revenue or the
00:22:32.761 --> 00:22:34.143
collections that they bring in.
00:22:34.163 --> 00:22:36.045
That's what every top doctoring profession
00:22:36.085 --> 00:22:36.384
does.
00:22:36.945 --> 00:22:39.048
And physical therapists are way behind in
00:22:39.067 --> 00:22:39.769
that area.
00:22:40.230 --> 00:22:42.592
And now that you have such penny nickel
00:22:42.632 --> 00:22:44.013
margins that we've talked about,
00:22:44.074 --> 00:22:45.455
the biggest portion of the comp,
00:22:45.476 --> 00:22:47.258
sixty seven percent is your labor.
00:22:47.798 --> 00:22:48.798
And out of that labor,
00:22:48.818 --> 00:22:50.882
you have to have a variable compensation
00:22:51.742 --> 00:22:54.005
shared risk with your therapist.
00:22:54.384 --> 00:22:57.368
This will move most of the compensation to
00:22:57.449 --> 00:22:58.089
therapists.
00:22:58.490 --> 00:22:59.090
And guess what?
00:22:59.191 --> 00:23:00.771
They're the ones who generate all the
00:23:00.832 --> 00:23:03.615
revenue and hopefully move compensation
00:23:03.714 --> 00:23:06.597
and move the number of overhead away from
00:23:06.678 --> 00:23:07.618
central management.
00:23:08.038 --> 00:23:10.641
The PT clinic, the dental clinic,
00:23:10.701 --> 00:23:12.824
the primary care clinic of the future is
00:23:12.844 --> 00:23:15.185
going to have a lot less headcount in
00:23:15.385 --> 00:23:18.249
revenue cycle management, credentialing,
00:23:18.979 --> 00:23:24.762
management in general hr finance and that
00:23:24.803 --> 00:23:27.924
will allow the profit and loss statement
00:23:28.045 --> 00:23:30.846
of to be rebalanced to a better margin
00:23:30.886 --> 00:23:33.628
but only if you shift that compensation to
00:23:33.648 --> 00:23:35.650
the people who absolutely produce it i'm
00:23:35.710 --> 00:23:38.352
very proletariat i'm like uh you know
00:23:38.432 --> 00:23:39.653
that's why i'm a big fan of major
00:23:39.673 --> 00:23:41.554
league baseball and what they've been able
00:23:41.594 --> 00:23:44.155
to do where they reward the people that
00:23:44.195 --> 00:23:46.336
generate the revenues in physical therapy
00:23:46.678 --> 00:23:48.699
what we do is the opposite we generate
00:23:50.020 --> 00:23:52.165
for therapists that get out of therapy and
00:23:52.185 --> 00:23:54.290
move it more up the ladder towards central
00:23:54.330 --> 00:23:54.872
management.
00:23:55.729 --> 00:23:57.750
that leads to partly of the five
00:23:57.790 --> 00:24:00.292
dysfunctions of healthcare platforms when
00:24:00.313 --> 00:24:02.493
they go awry all right go deeper if
00:24:02.513 --> 00:24:04.796
you're building operating or investing in
00:24:04.836 --> 00:24:06.797
healthcare this is the stuff that actually
00:24:06.836 --> 00:24:08.238
matters and you should be paying attention
00:24:08.278 --> 00:24:09.880
to not the pitch decks they can be
00:24:09.920 --> 00:24:12.060
slicked up not the multiple the way
00:24:12.121 --> 00:24:14.442
business actually runs if this hit go read
00:24:14.462 --> 00:24:16.084
the full piece links in the show notes
00:24:16.525 --> 00:24:17.786
it's worth your time and if you're not
00:24:17.826 --> 00:24:19.247
already subscribed to the operator
00:24:19.747 --> 00:24:21.911
That's where Larry is writing this in real
00:24:21.971 --> 00:24:23.374
time, one problem at a time,
00:24:23.413 --> 00:24:25.798
and now available on all podcast platforms
00:24:25.838 --> 00:24:26.721
as well as YouTube.
00:24:27.301 --> 00:24:29.185
We'll see you next time here on The
00:24:29.226 --> 00:24:29.567
Operator.