THANKSGIVING ROMANCE | Second Helping Pt 2: Leftovers
Every road out loops her back to town. When she breaks down on the shoulder of the one highway that will not end, it is Sam who pulls up behind her, and the warmth is gone from his face, replaced by the exhaustion of a man rationing something he has nearly run out of. He already knows about the loop. He has been living it for more than a hundred Thursdays. And the one thing that changes in every version, the single variable the day keeps adjusting, is her, because every loop ends the same way: Charlie leaves. She always leaves. The day will not let go of either of them until, for once, she stays.
Unlock an ad-free podcast experience with Caloroga Media! For Apple users, hit the banner on your Apple podcasts app.
Subscribe now for exclusive shows like 'Palace Intrigue,' and get bonus content from Deep Crown (our exclusive Palace Insider!) Or get 'Daily Comedy News,' and '5 Good News Stories’ with no commercials! Plans start at $4.99 per month, or save 20% with a yearly plan at $49.99. Join today and help support the show!
Get more info from Caloroga Media and if you have any comments, suggestions, or just want to get in touch our email is info@caloroga.com
0:01 Caloroga Media. Hello and welcome to A Caloroga Media Romantasy. This series is The Second Helping. Episode 2, Leftovers. Here is what I did on the second Thursday, in order, because a professional keeps a log. I checked every calendar in the house, all Thursday. I checked the news, the scores, the date on the milk. Thursday, Thursday, Thursday. I called the airline and confirmed a red-eye I had already taken.
0:57 I asked my mother, with as much calm as I could fake, what day it was, and she said, Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving. Are you drinking already? In the exact cadence she'd used the day before, and the day before that, which to her was today. I stood in the kitchen while Beth's gravy committed the same suicide at the same minute. 11.17. A thing I now knew to the second, and I thought, with the particular clarity of a woman whose entire identity is leaving, I am trapped. The universe has finally called my bluff. The one place I will not stay is the one place that will not let me go. I want to be clear that I did not handle this gracefully.
1:44 I am a logistics professional. When a thing does not make sense, I stress test it. So I ran experiments. I told my mother at 11.16, Beth's gravy is about to break, and watched it break at 11.17. and watched my mother look at me like I was psychic instead of correct. I told Uncle Rich the Plymouth Rock punchline before he could, word for word, and he looked so wounded, so genuinely robbed, that I apologized to a man for ruining a joke I have hated for 20 years. I caught the football score before Danny announced it. I knew the knock of the neighbor returning the folding chairs. I moved through my own family like a stagehand who has run the show a thousand times hitting every mark a half second early. And the horror of it was not that it was strange. The horror was how good I was at it. I have spent my life learning rooms fast so I can leave them clean. And now I had a room I had learned completely and could not leave at all. I tried to leave. Obviously I tried to leave.
2:53 I am me. I drove to the airport at noon, nine hours early. and the highway on-ramp put me back on the road into town. I do not mean it was closed. I mean I took the ramp, drove the ramp, and arrived at the other end of the ramp facing the way I had come. The town laid out ahead of me like it had been waiting, patient, pleased. I tried it again, slower, watching the road the whole way, certain I would catch the trick, and I caught nothing, because there was no trick to catch. just a westbound ramp that delivered me east with my own house growing in the windshield. I tried the old county route my dad used to take, Loop.
3:38 I tried the interstate in the other direction entirely, reasoning that if the town would not let me leave toward the airport, it might let me leave away from it. And I drove forty minutes into open country, feeling the first clean lift of escape in my chest, and then the road bent, gently, apologetically, the way a parent turns a toddler around by the shoulders, and there was the water tower, with the town's name on it, ahead of me, welcoming me home. I tried it four times. The fourth time I pulled over on the shoulder and laughed until I cried, which are closer together than I usually let them get, and a truck pulled up behind me with its hazards on, and it was Sam. Sam. Parked behind me on the shoulder of the one road that would not let me leave. like a man who had known exactly where to find a woman trying to escape, because he had found her there before. He got out. He walked up to my window in the cold with his hands in his pockets and an expression I had never seen on him in ten years of Thanksgivings, which was not warm, which was tired all the way to the bone, which was the face of a man who has run out of a thing he has been carefully rationing for a very long time. It was so unlike him that it frightened me more than the road had, Sam does not run out of warmth. Warmth is his whole climate.
5:03 And here he was, grey and spent, looking at me through my window, like the sight of me was both the only good thing in his life and a wound he could not stop reopening. The ramp, he said. It loops you back. The airport road. The interstate. The bus. I know. I've tried all of them. He crouched down to my window, so we were level. You're stuck in Thursday. So am I. And you're going to tell me you don't believe me. And then you're going to spend the rest of today proving to yourself that I'm right. And I'd really rather we skip to the part where you believe me. Because Charlie, I am so tired of the first day. I stared at him.
5:47 How many? I said. How many Thursdays? And Sam, warm Sam, the guy who knows where the roasting pan is Sam, looked at me through my car window, on the shoulder of a road that would not end, and said, I stopped counting at a hundred. I did not say anything for a while. The road hummed. Somewhere a hundred Thursdays deep, this warm, steady man had been waking up every single morning to my mother's hostage video narration, and Beth's doomed gravy, and the specific private hell of loving someone who treats every room as a place to be gotten out, of... and he had kept being warm, had kept walking me to my car, had kept saying drive safe like a door held open, knowing every time that I would drive straight through it and he would wake up and have to do all of it again. Sam, I said finally, and my voice came out strange. How are you not furious with me? He considered it, crouched there by my window in the cold. I was, he said, around Thursday forty, I had a whole speech. It was devastating. You'd have cried.
7:00 But you cannot stay angry at a person for a hundred days without either hating them or understanding them. And I ran out of hate a long way back. He almost smiled, the ghost of the warm one. That's the part that should scare you, honestly. Not that I remember. That I understand. Here is the thing that reframed the entire holiday, the entire year, the entire decade I'd spent being proud of how lightly I travelled. It was not a new loop. I was not the first one in it. Sam had been looping this Thanksgiving for longer than I could stand to think about. And the one thing that changed, the only variable in a hundred identical Thursdays, the single thing the day kept adjusting like it was trying to get a landing right, was me. What I did. What I said. Whether, this time, I stayed. Every version, he said, quiet, in the cold. You do something a little different every time, which is how I keep from losing my mind. I watch for what's new. One year you got drunk and told Uncle Rich his pilgrim joke was a hate crime, and he cried, and it was, honestly, a great Thanksgiving.
8:20 One year, you cried during Grace and wouldn't say why, and I have spent probably nine Thursdays since trying to find out. One year, you decided the loop meant you should finally learn to make the gravy. And you made the gravy, Charlie. You broke a hundred-year curse of bad gravy, and then got on the plane anyway. And nobody but me ever tasted it. One year, you kissed me on the porch at eleven. Just once. Best night of my life. and I'm the only one who was ever in it, because you got in the car at 11.04, and I stood in the driveway and watched the taillights, and woke up, and have never been kissed by you, except that I have, except that I'm the only one who remembers it. He said all of it without accusation, which was so much worse than if he had thrown it at me. A hundred Thursdays. And every single one of them, no matter what else changes, no matter how good it gets, ends the same way. You leave. You always leave. The day won't let go of me until it lets go of you.
9:26 And it won't let go of you until you stay. And you have never, not once, in a hundred tries, stayed. I've started to think you're the only person alive who could be handed infinite time with the people who love her and use it, every time, to practice leaving. I sat with that. It should have made me defensive. In a hundred other conversations it would have, I keep a whole arsenal for when people decide to tell me what I am. But he had not said it like an accusation. He had said it like a weather report. like a man describing a season he has lived through so many times he has stopped resenting it and started simply knowing it and there is nothing to argue with in a man who just knows you it is the ones who are guessing that you can fight Sam was not guessing Sam had the data a hundred Thursdays of it, all pointing the same direction, which was away. The road hummed.
10:27 The town sat there ahead of us, patient, keeping its place. Why you? I said, because it was the only question I could hold. Why are you the one who remembers? He stood up, looked down the impossible road. I used to think it was a punishment, he said. Now I think it's because I'm the only one at that table who was never going to leave on my own. Your grandmother says the day keeps who needs keeping. She knows about it. Graham, she's the only one besides us who ever has. I asked her, maybe Thursday 30, when I was sure I'd lost my mind. She made me tea and told me the women in your family have always been able to hold a day that isn't finished. Her mother did it once, and her grandmother before that. She said it isn't a curse, it's more like, her words, a kettle that won't let you leave the kitchen until the water's boiled. He shook his head, almost fond, and then she looked at me over the tea with those eyes, and she told me the day wasn't holding on my account, it was holding on yours. And it would hold exactly as long as it took. A ghost of the warm smile, finally. turns out we needed keeping for opposite reasons you can't stay i can't stop waiting for you to we drove back to town because there was nowhere else on earth to
11:57 drive two cars in a slow funeral procession returning to a thanksgiving that would not end i spent the whole drive doing the only thing i know how to do which is hunt the exit run the logistics of the impossible and i came up empty and underneath the panic there was a second feeling I liked even less, which was that a man I had held at exactly arm's length for ten years had just told me he had spent a hundred lifetimes at that same arm's length and never once stopped reaching for me across it. That night, the second night, the night that was also the first night, I lay in my childhood bed and listened to the house settle around me, the loud, imperfect house I could not leave and I thought about a hundred Thursdays, and a porch, and a pair of taillights that only one person in the world remembered. And I will tell you the thing I did not admit to myself for several more Thursdays, the thing that frightened me more than any looping road. I was somewhere I could not leave. And some buried, mutinous, long-starved part of me was relieved.
13:14 You
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed