80: Blood, Vows, and the Throne: Isabel and Fernando's Fight for Castile

Welcome back to the I Take History With My Coffee podcast where we explore history in the time it takes to drink a cup of coffee.

Acclamation at Segovia, 1474
"Castile, Castile, Castile, for the very high and powerful Princess and Lady, our Lady the Queen Doña Isabel, and for the very high and very powerful Prince King and Lord, our Lord the King Don Fernando as her legitimate husband!"

In the autumn of 1469, two seventeen-year-old royal cousins would make a decision that would forever alter the course of European history. Their secret marriage, conducted in defiance of kings and kingdoms, would transform medieval Spain from a collection of fractured realms into a unified power that would dominate the world stage. 

Into this complex political setting of 15th-century Iberia, two teenagers entered the scene. They contrasted in temperament but shared similar ambitions. Isabel, born on April 22, 1451, was a princess but not expected to rise to power. Her birth was scarcely recognized. After her father's death, she was raised in the provincial town of Arévalo, where she received a traditional domestic education. Beneath her conventional appearance, she had an iron will and a romantic temperament, which would become both her greatest asset and her most dangerous weakness.

Fernando, born nearly a year later on March 10, 1452, was quite different from Isabel. While she led a secluded life, Fernando was a traveling warrior-prince, moving between Aragon, Sicily, and Navarre. He described his education as having "seen much but read little," favoring practical experience over books. By seventeen, he commanded armies and governed Sicily, earning the respect of courtiers.

The international situation of the 1460s forced these two unlikely candidates to unite. Louis XI of France, fresh from victory in the Hundred Years' War, pushed aggressively along the Pyrenees, threatening Aragonese territories in Roussillon and Cerdagne. Juan II of Aragon, Fernando's father, faced simultaneous rebellions in Catalonia and an invasion from France. Desperate for allies, he turned his attention to the marriage prospects of Isabel, who had become the official heiress to Castile.

The competition for Isabel's hand seemed like a catalog of European ambitions. Charles of Valois represented French interests, offering to make her Queen of France. Alfonso V of Portugal, although much older, had immense wealth from African gold mines and could promise dominance in the Atlantic. England's Yorkist monarchy tentatively suggested the Duke of Clarence. Still, it was the Aragonese match, initially the least appealing choice, that captured Isabella's imagination—and her heart.

The crucial moment that would make Isabel's marriage choice so dangerous came on September 19, 1468, at Los Toros de Guisando. There, Isabel met with her half-brother King Enrique IV in a carefully orchestrated reconciliation. The agreement reached that day formally recognized Isabel as Enrique's heir, passing over his own daughter, Juana. This recognition came with implicit conditions—that Isabel would marry according to Enrique's wishes and maintain the delicate balance of power that kept Castile's fractious nobility in check.

The Guisando accord made Isabel one of Europe's most coveted marriage prizes, but it also created a trap. Any marriage decision that went against Enrique's preferences could give him legal grounds to revoke her inheritance, potentially leading to civil war in Castile. The web of court intrigue meant that Isabel's future depended not only on her own choices but also on the shifting loyalties of nobles, whose main concern was their own advancement.

Isabel's choice to marry Fernando directly went against the spirit, if not the letter, of the Guisando agreement. Enrique IV strongly supported the Portuguese alliance, viewing it as a means to counter the increasing Aragonese influence while maintaining the status quo that had brought him a decade of relative peace. The powerful Marquis of Villena actively opposed the Aragonese match, understanding that it would upset the careful balance of noble power he had built. Even many of Isabel's supporters questioned whether allying with the militarily weak and financially desperate Kingdom of Aragon was a wise move.

But Isabel possessed what one chronicler called "great character and determination." In a move that shocked the European diplomatic community, she secretly committed to marrying Fernando before even meeting him. This decision reflected both romantic idealism—Fernando was young, handsome, and reportedly brave—and shrewd political calculation. Unlike the Portuguese king, who had existing heirs, Fernando needed Isabel as much as she needed him. This mutual dependency would allow her to dictate unprecedented terms that protected Castilian sovereignty while gaining Aragonese military expertise.

The Archbishop of Toledo, Alfonso Carrillo, became the key supporter of the marriage. His rivalry with the Marquis of Villena had turned hostile, and he saw the Aragonese alliance as a way to outsmart his opponent while positioning himself as the power behind a future throne. Using his wide network of contacts, Carrillo carried out a complex deception that allowed Isabel to tell Enrique IV she would take no "new steps" regarding marriage—knowing full well that her Aragonese approval came before this oath.

Fernando's journey to Castile in October 1469 exemplified the perilous romance of their union. Disguised as a merchant's servant, the Prince of Aragon traveled through hostile territory with only a few companions, carrying false papers and risking capture or death. At Burgo de Osma, mistaking them for enemies, the townspeople attacked his group with stones. Only the quick intervention of the local governor saved the future King of Spain from a shameful death in a dusty Castilian street.

The wedding itself, held on October 19, 1469, in Juan de Vivero's hall in Valladolid (vai uh dow leed), blended romantic drama with strategic political theater. Nearly 2,000 witnesses attended the ceremony. Since Isabel and Fernando were close cousins, papal dispensation was required to validate the marriage. One was provided, likely forged by agents of Juan II of Aragon. The elaborate verification rituals, including the traditional display of bedsheets, served multiple purposes: legitimizing the union, demonstrating consummation, and establishing irreversible political facts that would make annulment nearly impossible.

More importantly, the marriage documents revealed unprecedented arrangements for shared sovereignty. Fernando pledged to "command, govern, reign, and señorear as one with her," language that indicated joint rule while recognizing Isabel's superior inheritance rights. He agreed to appoint only Castilians to office, follow Castilian laws, and live permanently in the kingdom. These capitulations marked a revolutionary break from traditional royal marriages, in which wives were typically subordinate to their husbands, regardless of their inherited rights.

Enrique IV responded swiftly to his sister's defiance, revealing how Isabel's marriage had broken the Guisando settlement. On October 26, 1470, at Valdelozoya, he revoked Isabel's status as his heir and proclaimed his nine-year-old daughter Juana as his successor. He insulted Isabel as a "concubine" and claimed her marriage lacked canonical approval. Enrique then arranged Juana's betrothal to Charles, Duke of Guienne, brother of Louis XI of France, creating an alliance that threatened Isabel and Fernando's position.

The winter of 1469-70 was the darkest period in the couple’s lives. With controlling only four towns—Valladolid, Tordesillas(tor duh see uhz), Olmedo, and Sepúlveda—they found themselves practically prisoners of their own supporters. Financial desperation forced them to mortgage their future to the Archbishop of Toledo and the influential Enríquez family. When Isabel gave birth to a daughter on October 2, 1470, Fernando became seriously ill, his disappointment at not producing a male heir showing the immense psychological pressure both of them faced.

Isabel's written response to Enrique's accusations showed both her emotional ups and downs and her growing political savvy. In a passionate letter dated March 1471, she compared herself to "Santa Susana," the Biblical heroine falsely accused of adultery, framing her struggle as virtue winning over slander. This religious perspective would become a signature part of her later reign, as she often depicted political conflicts in terms of moral absolutes.

The couple's recovery began with small victories that demonstrated their growing political acumen. Military successes in the Basque Country in May 1471 gained regional support. The death of Pope Paul II and the rise of the Aragonese-friendly Sixtus IV shifted the balance of power within the Church. When Cardinal Rodrigo Borgia arrived in Valencia with a papal bull confirming Isabel's marriage and her daughter's inheritance, it gave the canonical approval missing from their wedding.

The most important development was the slow shift of the powerful Mendoza family from Enrique's side to Isabel's. Led by the shrewd Cardinal Pedro González de Mendoza, the Mendozas initially supported Juana's claims but grew increasingly concerned about Portuguese dominance and French influence. Secret negotiations opened channels of communication that would prove crucial to Isabel's eventual success.

Enrique IV's final years revealed a king increasingly at the mercy of events outside his control. The death of the Duke of Guienne in May 1472 ended the French marriage alliance that had been central to his strategy. His declining health and impressionable nature made him vulnerable to the competing influences of his court. When the Master of Santiago, Juan Pacheco—Isabel's most formidable opponent—died on October 4, 1474, it removed the last figure capable of organizing effective resistance to her claims.

Enrique's death on December 11, 1474, left the question of succession unresolved. His final statements about the inheritance were vague at best, with different chroniclers reporting conflicting deathbed claims. 

Isabel's response to her brother's death demonstrated the decisive leadership that would define her reign. On December 13, 1474, just two days after Enrique's death, she proclaimed herself Queen of Castile in an elaborate ceremony at Segovia's San Miguel Church. Most notably, she preceded the ceremony with a naked sword carried upright before her—a traditionally masculine symbol of militant royal authority that shocked contemporary observers.

When Fernando arrived from Aragon on January 2, 1475, he expected to assume the traditional role of king-consort with precedence over his wife. The negotiations that followed tested both their personal relationship and their political partnership. Isabel's position was unprecedented—a woman claiming sovereign authority over a kingdom while married to a man who held his own hereditary royal titles.

The Concordat of Segovia, signed on January 15, 1475, was a skillful compromise that maintained Isabel's ultimate authority while granting Fernando sufficient ceremonial status to preserve his dignity and secure his cooperation. Joint titles would appear on official documents, but real decision-making power stayed with Isabel as the hereditary ruler of Castile. When critics claimed this violated natural law about marriage hierarchy, Isabel responded that the precedent was "important for their daughter"—showing her long-term strategic thinking about female succession.

These initial months of joint rule highlighted their complementary strengths, making their partnership highly effective. Isabel's extensive knowledge of Castilian politics and her moral authority as the rightful heir lent vital legitimacy. Fernando's military background and international diplomatic ties supplied practical skills that Isabel's protected upbringing lacked. Their joint efforts in letter-writing and strategic cultivation of noble support revealed a maturing governance style focused on collaboration and consensus, yet still respecting hierarchical authority.

Yet even as Isabel and Fernando strengthened their hold on Castile, external threats began to emerge that would push their new alliance to its limits. The very success of their shared rule—and the vision of Castilian-Aragonese unification it represented—alarmed neighboring powers, who felt their own interests were at risk from a strong, united Spain. The most threatening of all was Alfonso V of Portugal, who saw Isabel's victory not just as a political loss but as a personal insult that required a response through military action.

Alfonso V of Portugal's decision to invade Castile in May 1475 reflected both wounded vanity and strategic calculation. The 43-year-old king had never forgotten Isabel's rejection of his marriage proposal in 1468, and he saw her brother's death as an opportunity for revenge disguised as dynastic justice. More importantly, Portuguese fears of Castilian-Aragonese unification created strong motives for intervention, while the kingdom's increasing wealth from African gold mines provided the financial resources needed for sustained military campaigns.

The Portuguese invasion began with a grand ceremony intended to legitimize Alfonso's claims. His marriage to twelve-year-old Juana at Plasencia combined official procedures with theatrical romance—the event was held on a raised platform for maximum visibility to the gathered crowds. Throughout Castile, manifestos declared the couple as rightful rulers, also referencing prophetic texts that linked Alfonso to the legendary "Hooded King" destined to restore rightful governance in Spain.

Fernando's military response highlighted both the strengths and weaknesses of their emerging regime. The quick assembly of an army at Valladolid—ultimately numbering over 28,000 men—showed effective administrative ability and the loyalty of major noble families like the Enríquez and Mendoza clans. However, the force's composition of independent noble contingents and municipal levies led to critical coordination issues that became apparent during the disastrous siege of Toro in July 1475.

Isabel's role in the campaign challenged traditional queenly behavior and established patterns for her reign. Her attendance at military councils and her furious response to the Toro failure showed her determination to remain actively involved in strategic decisions. Faced with a financial crisis that risked dissolving their army, she approached the Cortes for a loan of church silver worth thirty million maravedíes—an estimated $ 8 million in today’s money.

The couple's relationship was severely tested during this time. Isabel's miscarriage of a male child at Cebreros in May 1475, caused by the stress of constant travel and military worries, was both a personal tragedy and a political setback. 

By early 1476, the war had reached a deadly deadlock. Portuguese forces controlled key fortress towns of Toro and Zamora, effectively splitting Castile and threatening to cut off Isabel and Fernando's communications with their northern strongholds. Alfonso V had proven more resilient than expected, while French gold continued to flow into Portuguese coffers. The arrival of Prince Juan of Portugal with new reinforcements in February 1476 seemed to decisively shift the balance against the Castilian monarchs.

 Something had to give soon—neither side could afford to sustain the enormous costs of ongoing warfare forever. When Fernando learned that the combined Portuguese forces were preparing to march from Zamora, he realized the time for a decisive confrontation had come, one that would determine not just the war’s outcome but the very survival of their cause.

The Battle of Peleagonzalo on March 1, 1476, lasted only three hours but determined Spain's future for centuries. Although both sides claimed victory and the tactical result was unclear, the strategic impact clearly favored Isabel and Fernando. Prince Juan of Portugal's successful cavalry charge on the left wing fueled Portuguese propaganda, but the collapse of their center and right wings, along with Alfonso V's retreat to Castronuño, showed the true outcome.

More important than the military details was the battle's psychological effect. Alfonso V's subsequent spiritual crisis and his desperate trip to France to seek Louis XI's support showed his recognition that the Castilian campaign had failed. The quick surrender of key Portuguese strongholds—Burgos castle, Zamora's citadel, and finally Toro itself—confirmed what the battlefield had hinted at: that foreign intervention in Castile's succession had been firmly rejected.

Louis XI's response to Alfonso's appeals showed the limitations of late medieval alliance systems. The French king's grand reception of the Portuguese monarch at Orleans and Tours masked his unwillingness to invest heavily in Iberian affairs. Charles the Bold's death in 1477 shifted French focus toward Burgundy, isolating Portugal diplomatically.

The aftermath of the battle also showed Isabel and Fernando's changing approach to rulership. Instead of seeking severe revenge against their enemies, they granted generous pardons and confirmed privileges to nobles who submitted. This policy of reconciliation, along with their proven military strength, accelerated the loss of Portuguese support and enhanced their reputation for both strength and mercy.

The period from 1476 to 1479 witnessed Isabel and Fernando's transformation from embattled claimants to confident sovereigns actively reshaping the Castilian government. Isabel's southern progress through Extremadura and Andalusia in 1477-1478 revealed her mastery of both the symbolic and practical dimensions of royal authority. 

Fernando's peaceful accession to the Aragonese throne on January 19, 1479, following his father's death, finalized the dynastic unification that had started with their marriage a decade earlier. For the first time since the early Middle Ages, most of Christian Spain was united under a single ruling house, though the kingdoms kept their separate institutions and legal systems.

The Treaty of Alcáçovas (al kuh so vush), signed on September 4, 1479, officially ended the Portuguese war and established territorial divisions that would influence Atlantic expansion for centuries. Portugal recognized Isabel's legitimacy while securing acknowledgment of their dominance in Africa and the important Canary Islands for Castile. Most notably, the treaty required the Princess Juana to choose between marrying Isabel's young son, Juan, or retiring to a convent—effectively removing the last major claimant to the Castilian throne.

Juana's decision to take religious vows at Santa Clara de Coimbra on November 15, 1480, marked a poignant end to a decade of dynastic conflict. Her formal profession as a nun resolved the succession dispute that had torn Castile apart while allowing her to uphold dignity in defeat. The ceremony's religious symbolism—a royal claimant willingly renouncing worldly power for spiritual service—resonated strongly in an era that appreciated such dramatic gestures.

The decade from 1469 to 1479 transformed two unlikely teenagers into the founders of early modern Spain. Isabel shifted from a defensive claimant to an assertive monarch. Fernando's transformation from a provincial prince to co-sovereign was equally impressive—his initial resentment at subordinate status developed into a genuine partnership that enhanced both monarchs' abilities.

Their developing governmental approach—merging centralized power with religious endorsement, personal appeal with institutional reforms—shaped their subsequent successes in completing the Reconquest, founding the Spanish Inquisition, and funding Columbus's voyages to the New World.

In our next episode, we’ll look at the ways the Catholic Monarchs, Isabel and Fernando, attempted to establish a centralized monarchy in Spain.

As always, maps and other supporting resources for all episodes are listed in the episode description. In the meantime, for more historical content, please visit the “I Take History With My Coffee” blog at itakehistory.com.  Become a free or paid subscriber on Substack and get related historical content delivered to your inbox.  We’re on Facebook, Instagram, and Threads.  Feedback and comments are welcome at itakehistory@gmail.com.  Or you can leave a review on Apple Podcasts or on Spotify.  You can also help support this podcast by buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com/itakehistory.  If you know anyone else who would enjoy this podcast, please let them know.  And thanks for listening.