Top 5 Most Overrated Wrestlers in Wrestling History

Who are the most overrated wrestlers of all time? In this episode of the Pro Wrestling Escape Podcast, I break down my Top 5 picks — from WWE legends to modern AEW stars — and explain why they don’t always live up to the hype.

I’ll cover their promos, in-ring work, storylines, and how fans (and the company) may have over-pushed them. Some of these takes will definitely spark debate, but that’s what makes wrestling fun.

Plus — I share YOUR reactions from the Crowd Speaks segment, where listeners drop their hottest takes on overrated wrestlers.

👉 Follow the podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube for new weekly episodes.
👉 Join the conversation on Instagram & TikTok: @ProWrestlingEscape

• most overrated wrestlers of all time

• overrated WWE superstars

• overrated AEW wrestlers

• top 5 WWE overrated wrestlers

• WWE overrated list

• wrestling hot takes podcast

• pro wrestling podcast 2025

• WWE vs AEW debates

• overrated wrestling legends

• wrestling podcast for fans