Welcome to our new website!
July 29, 2025

Vanished: The Jami Sue Hagel Sherer Case (Part 1)

Vanished: The Jami Sue Hagel Sherer Case (Part 1)
Vanished: The Jami Sue Hagel Sherer Case (Part 1)
PNW Haunts & Homicides
Vanished: The Jami Sue Hagel Sherer Case (Part 1)

What happens when a picture-perfect life hides a dangerous secret — and a young mother suddenly vanishes?

In September 1990, 26-year-old Jami Sue Hagel Sherer vanished without a trace from Redmond, Washington — leaving behind her young son, her close-knit family, and a trail of unsettling questions.

Jami’s life appeared perfect: a promising career at Microsoft, a new family home, and a bright future ahead. But behind the façade was a much darker reality — a volatile marriage to her controlling husband, Steve Sherer, a man with an explosive temper, a documented history of domestic violence and drug abuse, and a jealous streak that left Jami constantly on edge.

In Part One, we trace Jami’s life leading up to her disappearance: her seemingly idyllic upbringing, the escalating turmoil in her marriage, and the final moments before she told Steve, “It’s over. I want a divorce.”

Was that the breaking point that led to her vanishing — or did Steve’s jealousy drive events to a deadly conclusion?

Listen now to Part One of this haunting two-part case — and stay tuned for Part Two, where we dive into the investigation, Steve Sherer’s shocking behavior in the aftermath, and the resolution that finally brought answers for Jami’s loved ones.

Visit our website!Find us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Patreon, & more! If you have any true crime, paranormal, or witchy stories you'd like to share with us & possibly have them read (out loud) on an episode, email us atpnwhauntsandhomicides@gmail.com or use thislink. There are so many ways that you can support the show:BuyMeACoffee,Spreaker,or by leaving a rating & review on Apple Podcasts. Sources

0:02 A previous romantic partner had recalled a frightening incident. Resolved to escape the highly explosive relationship, she had abandoned her things in their shared apartment, only returning when it could be confirmed that Steve wouldn't be home. She returned to try to collect her things, to find that he'd laid out her stuffed animals and dolls decapitated. Hi, Cassie, Hi, Caitlin, Hi, creepy people. Hello. Hello, This is PNW Hans and Homicides, where we chat about true crime, the paranormal, and all things spooky in the PNW. If you're nicety, which is the Pacific north West, if you didn't know what that meant, I don't want. I think it means like penis not well, peanut butter, no waffles, Like we don't want them to think those things about us. So that's right. Yeah, I definitely don't want either of those associations. Oh my goodness.

1:24 We also do a little tarot reading at the end of every episode for a little bit of deeper insight into our. Topic, especially for our palate cleanser at the end of Caitlin's episodes, which today, Yeah, that is what's going on that's what's happening. You're like, that's that's what's gonna happen. We're doing that to your ear holes. So that's what's happening to us today. Sorry, I guess, Oh my goodness. Yeah, all right, Well, and I think I'm gonna be giving you guys. I don't know, maybe a little bit of a surprise. I don't know if anybody's paying attention, maybe they already know.

2:05 I don't know. Well, should I get into it? I feel like that's a lot of tom foolery for the front end. Yeah, let's get into it. I'm ready. Or were you talking about the teaser post on Instagram? Yeah? I was like, I don't know what's happening, but I did the post. All right. Jamie Sue Heigel Scherer, twenty six at the time of her disappearance, lived in Redmond with her husband Steve Schuer. That Sunday afternoon in September of nineteen ninety, Jamie's mother, Judy was looking after the couple's young son. Normally, Steve would repeatedly call to check in anytime Jamie had visited her parents' home, calling to ensure her safe arrival.

2:51 Several more times thereafter, before finally insisting that she returned home. It's one thing to call and make sure that you're her wife made it to where she was going, but then to like keep calling. I was about to ask, was she picking up? Is that why? Like was she not picking up? Is that why he kept killing or they were definitely picking up the phone. Okay, if that sounds a little toxic, yeah, a little bit, like I don't know the story. Yeah, yeah, but that Sunday he hadn't checked in for five hours, completely unheard of, because he would call sometimes in fifteen minute intervals the entire time she was gone.

3:35 WHOA if someone, dude, if someone's doing that to you, that's intense. That's entirely too. Much, very controlling, like just making sure that you're not like doing anything they wouldn't want you to be doing well. And really I think it was just like the point of like pestering her so that she would just come home. Yeah, that is so ugh. I don't like that, Like she's at her parents' house. Yeah, So I. Think it goes without saying that. We as a podcast, we hate that unless. You're both like, if you both want to be on the phone every fifteen minutes. Like, if you're both into it, go like you do, you go for it, be codependent if that's what you want.

4:19 If you are both into that, I have to insist that you see a therapist. There's just no ifs ands or butts about that. I need you to just go see someone. I feel like, yeah, I gotta talk to somebody. Some people just like to be of each other's butts all the time. And that's fine if that's what you want. That's deep in there, that's so deep, so deep. As a girl, Jamie had been incredibly petite, though even as an adult woman, she'd really never topped about ninety five pounds. Very small, yes, and she was just over five feet like super short, very.

5:04 Petite, like you said. The whole family played softball in local leagues, including Jamie. The Hagel children had what many might consider an idyllic upbringing, swimming in Lake Samamish, climbing trees with their friends, and in Jamie's case, riding horses. Very PMW stuff, you guys, that's the dream for Kate, like as a little girl, the horses. The family traveled back to North Dakota to visit extended family for holidays. Though they weren't the lone settlers in their newfound home state. They joined two of Jodie's brothers who had previously settled into Washington. Jamie was a sweet child and growing up had really close relationships with I mean, ultimately it seems like her entire family, but with both of her parents. As she went on to high school at Samamish High, little changed. So I'm sure that there were probably moments when she was a teen that, like her parents and her thought, but she never became like one of those super combative, you know, teenagers. Not a rebel, No, doesn't seem like it. Her sophomore year, Jamie began dating her high school sweetheart, Greg. Her family approved of their

6:36 relationship and all got along really well, so pretty wholesome. Yeah, I feel like most of the time, your parents don't always love who you're dating when you're a teenager. Yeah, a lot of the time. Yeah, yeah, I mean the couple dated for nearly six years, the remainder of their time in high school and for some time after graduation as well. Greg would say in hindsight that Jamie had been his first love. Oh I know. Though eventually they grew apart as a couple, the two would remain friends. That's very sweet.

7:17 I know, it's just so heartwarming. I like that. Eventually Jamie would meet someone new and very different from her first love Greg. It happens, yep, sure, yes. Steve Shearer was a twenty four year old motorcycle riding man that and this is a quote none of Jamie's family particularly cared for. Oh oh, she was getting into her rebel phase now, uh yeah, yeah yeah, and that was from the very beginning, Like, just didn't give off good vibes from the start. Man.

7:59 Though not physic imposing at five seven, his abrasive personality hardly made it easier to like him. He's tall to her, though, Yeah exactly. Yeah, he's got that like short man syndrome. Oh my god, was he ever? Oh boy, call him Napoleon. Though Steve didn't seem to have steady work, typically, he did always drive nice cars and always seemed to make or at least have more than enough money. Nice Okay, you yeah, jealous? He'd right, Okay, I don't need to make money. I would just like to have some acin has cheeseburger, He'd told Jamie early on in their relationship that he came from a wealthy family.

8:58 I feel like, by the way you said that he told her that it might not be true. Well, it's not exactly that it's untrue. I just feel like it's just a gigantic eye roll for me, oh, because it's like, okay, right, but dude, you're like twenty four, so I think most people would be hoping that maybe you'd be making some of your own money. I see, yeah, okay, huh ah, it's my family's money. How sexy is that so sexy? I love your daddy's money.

9:39 Just go straight to the source, I know, just go for daddy. Yeah, well, wasn't really an option. Steve Frank Shearer was born just before nine am on November fourth, nineteen sixty one, in California, to parents David and Sherry. His father, David, was a bricklayer at the time, but once the family relocated to Washington, he started a construction company, Shearer Quality Homes in Effett. It quickly became a success as the new suburban neighborhoods around Seattle began to expand. In addition to their home in Lynnwood, they had multiple vacation homes in Scottsdale, Arizona, and Palm Desert, California, near the desirable affluent area of Rancho Mirage, Verfa.

10:31 I've never heard of that. It's where, it's not far from like where they do Coachella. A lot of people go there to retire. There's a lot of celebrities with homes down there, a lot of like you know, high end hobbies like girls. David would die by suicide at age forty four, when Steve was just twenty two years old. Sit Reportedly he and his wife Sherry had frequent argued about his excessive drinking. On Thanksgiving nineteen eighty two, David decided to head down to their home and Palm Desert, telling Sherry he intended to get himself together, referring to his drinking, which I don't exactly think of like getting myself together as being like, here's the step I'm going to take. I'm going to go and spend a family holiday that's all about getting together and eating and being thankful by myself alone in one of our vacation properties. Doesn't really read like super serious about being sober and you know, fixing the problems in my marriage. It sounds like a maybe like a last get drunk, you know, yeah, I mean like a last hurrah. Yeah, that's the word. I was like, there's a word for this. Yes, there's a lot of words for them, and it actually there's it's not gonna go

12:06 well obviously I led with, you know, the the unaliving, So. Like that's what I would want to think when someone's doing that, like not that they're gonna. Go right unlive themselves. That they're gonna go have like a last hurrah and then go to rehab, right. Right, right exactly. Yeah, you'd want to think like, Okay, he's having one last binge and then you know things are going to get better from here. And sadly that just obviously wasn't the case. However, when David called late that night, clearly heavily intoxicated, Sherry became concerned, though she didn't take what sounded like claims of suicidal ideation seriously.

12:50 He had told her he had a gun in his possession. She wasn't aware of any besides a thirty two caliber that he had been given to him by his father. She believed that weapon to be back in their Washington State home, though she may not have believed every detail he shared as they fought bitterly over the phone. Something did compel her to get on a plane to California later that night. Wow, she got a really bad feeling either way. Yeah. I think, honestly, if your husband's talking like that, even if you don't believe him, I feel like I would be doing the same thing, right. I feel like you should just default to believing people. Yeah, yeah, it's kind of a serious thing to like roll the dice, just my two cents. But when she arrived at their Palm Desert home, she would find her husband David dead of an apparent self inflicted gunshot wound to the head. By the time ems arrived, Rigrimordes had said in there was a bullet hole marked by blood spatter, but the bullet itself was not recovered. The detective believed it had descended to the floor between studs, rather than penetrating through the nearby wall. So the interesting thing about this is, I feel like, because because that bullet wasn't recovered, it was a through and through shot and they didn't recover that.

14:19 At the scene, there were definitely some people that It's like there was almost like kind of chatter about like ooh, are we sure this was a suicide, and like, right, kind of seems a little fishy, and later events will make that seem like, oh, maybe we should look at that a second time. I don't think it ever got looked at a second time. Whohoa, that is weird. They couldn't like pull up the floorboards. I just think that when it was like seemingly such an apparent suicide, they were like, we're not gonna do that. But yeah, yeah, personally, I do think that based on the information that I have, more than likely it's a suicide. That piece of it is like a little bit wonky or kind of rolls around in the back of your mind like, ooh that.

15:18 I wish they had just recovered it so that we could just like everybody could feel like we had everything. But the house itself showed no signs of forest entry, nothing was missing, and generally it appeared the house was undisturbed. David's body showed no signs of a struggle or defensive wounds. His toxicology report revealed a blood alcohol level of point one, which is pretty high. Yeah, I mean, it's odd as high as I was expecting. Yeah, I kind of thought the same though, no note had been left behind. His death was officially a suicide. He'd been in good health, and his untimely death was a shock. So I think that's the other thing that maybe gives people pause is that, like I feel a little bit weird that there's not a note. Not everyone leaves a note, but I feel like if you have a family, more often than not there's a note, right right.

16:25 But if you're in like that drunken, yeah, say you're like not always yourself and you're. Maybe not down and yeah, maybe not feeling like the most clear headed obviously, but like making irrational decisions like yeah, yeah, I mean I think that definitely can play a part. It just I don't know. It almost made me want to look up like statistics about like, you know, what is the prevalence of people that like do versus don't leave notes. It is very interesting to like go away and be secluded, like in a house that you know, and not leave a note Like that is that makes it extra weird?

17:08 I think I think so too. I feel like it's like I understand maybe not wanting to do that with other people present that presents some challenges, but like you know that you're still going to be found obviously, but yeah, I don't know. I mean, it makes me think he wasn't planning on it when he went there, and he just like made the decision while he was intoxicated. Yeah, I mean, it's so hard to say, but it is. But I feel like that's a that's an interesting thought. I hadn't really considered that. By the time his father died, Steve had already given both of his parents hell as a frequent flyer with law enforcement, no surprise given his mercurial moods malicious mischief, heavy drinking, and frequent drug use, as well as his penchant to become abusive, even violent when under the influence, which I feel like, why is it people that really like the drugs and the drinken the most that that seems to be the case. It's like, couldn't the person who becomes violent under the influence be one of those people that's just like squeaky clean, so that nobody has to find out, Like, wouldn't that be great?

18:31 This was especially apparent when his easily inflamed jealousy reared its ugly head. He had a type petite blonde women, usually with ample chess, and he had an m O love bombing, which could turn to emotional and verbal abuse on a dime. Hmm, I just like it's so boring, it's so cliche. It's like, really, oh my god, he likes thin blonde women with big boobs. Jesus Christ. I mean, if you're thin and blonde and you have big boobs, like, nothing against you.

19:12 Nothing wrong with that, but just like, as a man, that's your type. And then you're like, also, I'm going to be the most typical and just be like an absolute trash heap. Yes, but threats, choking, and other abuse weren't beyond his wheelhouse. A previous romantic partner had recalled a frightening incident. Resolved to escape the highly explosive relationship, she had abandoned her things in their shared department, only returning when it could be confirmed that Steve wouldn't be home. She returned to try to collect her things, to find that he'd laid out her stuffed animals and dolls. Decapit.

20:03 What did they do to you? Honestly? This is like that is a sign to just like run as far and as fast as you can possibly get from this man, and like, don't ever look back, like old was he like that? This is like he's in his twenties. Like I feel like. That's something like a little girl would do. Who was throwing a fit because her sister like took something from her and she's like, I don't know, decapt it all of your dolls and stuffed animals like what? Okay. Also, I have to say, I'm sure there are kids that do things like this to get at a sibling, but like maybe that child should talk, someone should talk to them.

20:54 It just sounded like a spoiled brat kid, like you know, oh yeah, slightly disturb. I mean, he is a spoiled brat kid. It came from a wealthy family, and he's obviously very used to getting his way. Okay, Like I. Know, also gender norms and whatever, but it's just like not something a grown man I would ever picture. Would do. I just feel like, don't, like whoever you are, just maybe don't Maybe we don't do this literally ever. If you're gonna like decapitate things, maybe like use it for Halloween decorations.

21:37 Like that's fine, right if that's true. Yeah, I'm given style. I'm given to understand that this wasn't during spooky season. So that is just the weirdest any thing you've ever told me. I think, yeah, I mean it's so bizarre because obviously it's not harming her physically, but like the actual creepy ghost bumpy feeling that it gives me is just it's it's so chilling. I can like picture it too, Like I can picture his vibe and like his energy while he's like decapitating the dolls and like thinking of her.

22:19 Right exactly exactly. God, It's just I really don't like it. I'm never going to get over this, Like I just want to keep analyzing it because. I know it's so odd, and I'm going to tell you we just don't have time. Can we talk to a therapist? Can we get a therapist on the show? Any therapist less? I think the psychological psychoellis yeah, psychoanalysts. We'll take what we can get, literally care what the title is. Sadly, this wouldn't be the last straw the cycle of breaking up and gradually taking Steve back. After his persistent baking continued, this woman continued the on again, off again patterned with Steve. And I know that we all probably have an awareness at this point of how difficult it is to leave. When you do leave, it is the most unsafe time in what can be a very like dangerous situation to begin with. But oh my god, oh my god, like this this just would have been I don't, I don't. I just don't see any way of coming back from this. I feel so so horrifically sad for a woman that would feel that either she has no choice or that she has really been manipulated

23:51 by him at a level that their relationship continued after. That, that is yeah. Horrified, horrifying. Even when Steve entered a new relationship with Jamie, the abuse continued. Both women lived in the same complex, and at some point they actually became aware of one another. When she finally left for good, the other woman didn't manage to escape unscathed, and that violent assault led to Steve's arrest. As he was dragged away by officers, healed, fuck off, I'm going to kill you, bitch belligerently, which was documented in the arresting officer's report. Was he talking to the woman or the cop to the women? Yeah, okay, I mean I'm sure he was also angry at the at the officers as well. But you know, just the use of the word bitch.

24:45 You know, you can call anyone a bitch, but it seems like it would be directed at the a woman. Yeah, yep, it was pretty clear. As their relationship progressed, Jamie's family witnessed her transform from blea her hair to losing the spark of confidence in her spirit. She quickly became subservient, isolated. Still, despite her parents' shock and horror, it seemed there was nothing they could do, and the couple even secretly got engaged. Ooh so not great. Jamie's size four thirteen thousand, five hundred dollars heirloom ring was ensured and and in October nineteen eighty six, Steve would report the ring in a number of other valuables, totaling more than thirty two thousand dollars stolen.

25:39 Damn, yeah, I mean that sucks if that happened. Yep. Did I pick up a vibe? Sure did. Also, I just want to say, a thirteen thousand, five hundred dollars ring, that's a decent that's a decent ring, right, ah yeah, funny enough. The insurance company, they were kind of of the same mind as you. They thought the timing was incredibly suspicious, as their policy had been set to expire early in the new year. Ultimately, they would still pay the claim, even though doubts and suspicion seemingly lingered. Yeah, if your.

26:21 Insurance company asked suspicions. Like yeah, yeah, And here's the thing. I didn't actually include this in my notes, but we know that this was insurance fraud. We know for sure a one thousand percent because Jamie's mother a few months later was like, wait, what that's your same ring. You guys bought a replacement and she's like, no, girl, I reckon, like I know that's your same ring. This isn't like a replica, this is the ring. And Jamie admitted she didn't know that this is what was happening, and what was she supposed to do now? She didn't know that Steve was going to do this, and now she felt like trapped because what is she going to do? Read out her fiance And my my answer is yes, yes.

27:14 Yeah, but it's understandable why you wouldn't maybe. Or or maybe the right answer is drop a dime on that booch any whosel She could have been scared of him. I mean, she was definitely scared of him. Definitely, she could have been. She's definitely scared of him, and she had good reason to be. She'd already seen some things at that point. Decapitations. Well that wasn't Jamie, that was his. Oh oh wait, okay, that's right. I can't have whyse are so many. I know she doesn't. She doesn't even know about the decapitations, and she's scared presumably. I mean she knows that obviously he has a tendency to kind of fly off the handle. He's going to temper, he's got some addiction issues, so I mean she's not completely unaware of how volatile he can be. But yeah, suffice to say, yeah, she was scared of him a little bit, so, which is I mean, it's really sad to think that that's how this person lived their life.

28:22 Yeah. During this period when the couple lived in California, Jamie's parents were wrecked with anxiety and worry for their daughter. While they certainly weren't given the whole picture, for better or worse, they couldn't have known how controlling and abusive Steve was already, nor how much worse it would get. So Jamie's brothers were a little bit more aware of some of the things that were going on behind the scenes at first, and they were not getting good vibes. But I think there was a little bit of an attitude with the family. And I understand this, and I'm inclined to agree because there's only so much you can do.

29:05 This is an adult woman, and I think that you have to be there for her and whatever you can do to kind of show this person that, like, we love you and you know, I'm a safe space for you. You don't want to push them away. Yeah, because you could really easily, yeah, do that and isolate them with the. Yeah, and then there's there's no one that they feel like can be like their safety in that. And that's that's kind of worst case scenario. But it's got to be so so hard to witness and and to just sit with that that your sister, your daughter is you know, coexisting with this person his illicit hobbies and spending habits force them to take on a room. May Around this time, a young woman from Wisconsin who badly needed a place to live m She traded one bad living situation for another when she moved in with the couple. Not long after moving in with Jamie and Steve. She returned to their shared home to relax, and found herself facing Steve's wrath, oh, for which she could see really like no reason pretty.

30:29 Much, I'm sure. Yeah. Drunken reasons, yeah yeah, well drunk and high reasons, Oh yeah, yeah. Cocaine's a hell of a drug. What started as a seemingly innocuous, if you know, a little bit heated conversation quickly escalated to a physical altercation. Jesus, it's just your roommate, bro, it's not that serious. It was pretty serious pretty quickly. God. Steve threatened both women with a knife, but in the end turned it on himself.

31:10 The sound of sirens converging and their shared fear was interrupted by a brief moment of seemingly sheer dumb luck. Like literally this woman like ran into her room. She had like thrown a table to like create a physical barrier between Steve and Jamie, and she fled to her room called nine one one, and the cops got there pretty quickly. And him hearing the sirens is what prompted him to, you know, just casually stab himself in the gut. Jesus Christ, I know, can you imagine the trauma both of these poor women like he's physically attacked them. They thought they were gonna die. Christmas teen eighty six, the couple spent in Washington with family. Well, it seems at least Jamie did, because Steve was actually arrested on Christmas Eve after driving without a valid license and violating the protection order of his ex girlfriend. No, he went to her house. I don't know where he went to go to her, but he went to go to her. Sounds festive right Christmas Eve? Dude, Seriously, your fiance is enjoying the holiday with her family. But Steve did end up

32:41 spending some time in jail, but unrelated to his holiday. Humbuggery, and it wouldn't be until several months later. I love saying humbug and humbuggery, humbuggery. You gotta be kidding me. I love it. If I could fit that somewhere into this again. That needs to be on a T shirt for Christmas or sweater. Humbuggery. I love it. While he was serving his time in May of nineteen eighty seven, Steve and Jamie wrote each other, the drama never ceasing, even as she found professional success and her new job working at Microsoft. Oh, she was in on like the ground floor. Okay, she got stock options and she Jamie's family was relieved that she was closer to them once again when the couple had decided to return to Washington and were happy for her professional success.

33:42 At some point, Steve coaxed Jamie into getting implants, sizeable ones that many thought overwhelmed her small frame, and just like that, her wardrobe began to transform from clean cut, very like sporty to over feminine and often very revealing. Well, how could it not be rebellion if you got those big old kities, got them bazagnas, They're just gonna fall out of everything. That that's my problem. Now. I've seen photos of her after she had the implants done, and I actually don't think they were all that crazy, just from like what I can tell, I don't know what the before really looked like. Uh, I'm almost like late eighties or early nineties.

34:30 You said, yeah, late eighties. Yeah, so I feel like. Big like Pamela Anderson like boobies were. Yeah, they're kind of in you know hm. And I don't feel bad if she didn't want those. Though, like yeah, I you know, I I think he just wore her down basically. So, like I said, I don't think they were that crazy for the time, and I feel like you should be able to to do whatever you want. I so I just I don't think that we need quite so much commentary on women's bodies and choices, no past, present future, just maybe shut the fuck up. But like you shouldn't have any opinion on right, But this wasn't her choice, and that's that's where I get a little bit upset. I also get a little bit upset because of the way that Anne Rule in her book described Jamie's wedding dress, because I have seen the dress, and shame on you for talking about my friend Jamie that way. But I digress. Oh no, it wasn't it was it was a little slutshamy. H I know. Ultimately, like that wasn't really the that wasn't really a.

35:50 Thing that like that was the thing everyone did up until just like a couple of years ago. So right, right, yeah, yeah, and ultimately, like a lot of people are still doing. But yeah, non excuse, but it's just a fact. Yeah, I mean really, the takeaway here is just that Jamie is making a lot of changes and all at the urging of Steve. And so whether you think the boobs were big or not, it doesn't really matter. It's just giving, controlling and dick. Personally, I thought they looked incredible. Then of course eventually there would be a wedding, because they did get married. Even Steve's own sister was surprised at Jamie's choice of dress when the couple typed the Knot in July of nineteen eighty seven. Despite it being such a formal affair, the dress she dawned was far more revealing than Steve's sister thought was probably typical of her style, particularly with her newly augmented bust. Honestly, I was expecting this thing to be cut down a hill and be like like yours. I was gonna say, I actually think my wedding dress was like a lot more revealing.

37:08 Yeah, Like, now I want to see this because and now I'm feeling like it's being hyped up and I. Yeah, well, here's the thing. I was a little bit pissed off when I finally got to the point of seeing photos of the wedding dress, Like it took me a minute to process, and I was like, crazy person, say what because I'm like, okay, here, oh that is like it's like not even that is nothing. It's literally I think just because her boobs are big, that people think that and her boobs do not look. Like then they're she looks beautiful. No, she's gorgeous. I mean I feel like if the dress that she picked wasn't to her liking, or you know, having the boobs done that wasn't to her liking, I hate that. I hate that a lot, but I just, you know, like I didn't care for how Anne Rule put it at all.

38:10 I just felt like it was very slutshamy and I didn't like it. I was just reading my next line and it immediately Dixie Chick started playing in my head. Earl, how to Die wasn't too long anyways. It wasn't too long after the couple married that Jamie and Steve were expecting their first child. Steve didn't seem terribly interested. No, no, which is why not. Have someone else to control? Yeah? Yeah, yeah, I guess he hadn't thought of that ankle yet. Well I'm glad he didn't. Well, I think it would occur to him eventually, so I wouldn't get excited his interest lay in the now evident proof of his virility, and it did nothing to soften and shall we say his rough edges, because it never does. It literally never does. If he's a piece of shit before you have a baby, guess what now, you just had a baby with a piece of shit.

39:15 It's not her fault. By this time, he'd abandoned anything resembling pretense or niceties with the Hegel family. He picked it Judy, particularly, telling her so frequently to stay out of their business or she wouldn't see Jamie that she was fearful any gesture might lead to her daughter being ripped away and possibly permanently. Steve refused to be present during the delivery of their child if Judy was there. Though, when the time came and labor had worn on for Jamie, I think at this point she was at God. I want to say she'd been a and this is just off the top of my head, I want to say she'd been in labor for like twenty one hours or something. Shit.

40:07 He called missus Hagel himself. Judy was surprised and grateful, which honestly might be one of the only kind things that he ever did for anyone, and I feel like it was selfish because I'm pretty sure he left after that. He just was done. That was that's a long time. He needed to go have a drink. Yeah, hit the slopes. As you might suspect. Unfortunately, becoming a father didn't have a particularly stabilizing effect on Steve. Reliable caretaking isn't always within the wheelhouse of someone presumably in the throes of addiction, misguided as it was. In addition to being very troubling, Jamie said she sometimes used cocaine herself because, and this is a quote that a friend shared, because the more I do, the less Steve will and the less I will have to put up with. We won't have so much fighting. I do it just to keep the peace.

41:10 Holy shit balls. Yeah, that's just sad. She had tried actually just holding back some of his stash, and when he figured out that she was doing that, that was a big problem. Oh man. So so she's like, well, I'll just do it. I guess I will just also consume some as well, so that there's less for him to do. Wow, which is I feel like I don't need to explain that that's problematic, But that's. Just yeah, that's just really sad to. Me, I know. And then here's the other thing is I had this thought that, uh and here I am thinking that people do cocaine because they were told by a doctor there's ghosts in their blood. Wait, is that the care for ghost blood? I was a little cocaine, I don't think so. I think I got the ghost blood, you guys. As the decade was nearing a close in November of nineteen eighty nine, little had changed other than a young child being thrown into the mix.

42:20 Oh that's sad for everyone involved. Yes, yeah, it really is. I feel like it's just that's not a good situation. And yeah, it was like a race to the bottom for Steve to prove to everyone how badly he would, you know, fuck up a kid. Honest right. There were so many examples. They hurt my heart a lot. So I chose to leave some of those things out and just you know, we're kind of going broader strokes. But yeah, no, he was. He was not a great dad, shocking. Whenever Steve was otherwise occupied by spending time at the racetrack or whatever else he got up to, Jamie managed to sneak in visits for quality time with her parents and the rest of her family.

43:15 She was holding her own at Microsoft, and the couple was hopeful about buying a home. In the end, she'd put her She put her company's stock up as collateral so that Sherry, her mother in law, Steve's mother, would give them the means to purchase. I don't love that because I just feel like, what does Steve bring to the table, you know, and just because you can kind of force these things to pencil out on paper, I just you know, what is he doing? What's his job? Have you talked about that? So? I mentioned early on that he wasn't real great about holding down stable work and that was kind of a constant for Steve kind of thoughts. So yeah, yeah, so.

44:02 His wife and his mommy are doing it for him. You're got it. Yeah, you gotta love that. So around the time they were securing said home in Redmond, Jamie confided and at least one friend that once they moved in, she planned to leave Steve. That's kind of bold to have, like your mother in law help you get a house and. Then and then your son. Yeah. I just feel like, okay, and you can tell me maybe we'll have to cut this. But like immediately, the thought that I had was like, not quite sure. I understand the logic. I feel like it's a lot easier to to separate and to sever ties, Like you're already married and you have a kid. Why are you creating an additional tie to this man? It just, honestly, to me, it seems like the financial equivalent of like like how the mob will tie cement blocks to someone before you know they push him off a pier. I don't get that.

45:09 Maybe she was hoping that like if Steve is like has a place to be, then like he won't need her. I just I couldn't really wrap my head around it. I really, it just doesn't make sense to me. But was she Oh I was thinking like she was playing on kicking out of him out of the house or something. Maybe yeah, I feel like like part of me wants to think that, Like maybe maybe that. But also if you're relying on his mom to help you, and you've put up your Microsoft stock to like convince her to help you, guys, it just seems like that doesn't put you in a position of power from like any standpoint.

45:52 I don't get it, but which like you don't need to be in a position of power to leave, like, leave if you feel like you need to leave, you. Right, I just feel like this it just makes it more complicated. Yeah. Yeah, maybe she just wanted to make sure a kid had like a house, like somewhere to be. I mean, and that completely understandable, totally get that. I just have a hard time putting myself like where was her head at with that in particular? But once they had their fixer upper starter home, little changed and it was definitely a fixer upper. Oh, but Steve had a new passion project of sorts, and that was convincing his wife to give swinging and threesomes a try. I thought you were going to say, home renovation. Come on, come on, are.

46:46 There more important things going on in your life right now? New baby, new house, Like. Hmm, yeah, the timing of this feels a little bit is off. But suffice to say, Jamie was disinterested. No shit, she just gave birth and you know, you guys have a young child and you just bought a house. And you know, I'm not trying to yuck anybody's young, you know, but it just doesn't seem like they're in the place for that. Everybody's different but it doesn't seem like that's where her head was at. But obviously we know that Steve has no issue with just grabbing her head and directing it where he wants it. So again, Jamie was disinterested, but that didn't stop Steve from placing ads seeking a meal for an encounter with Jamie. I'm gonna say cuckolding seems an odd choice for a man who was so pretty naturally jealous, right, often saying he enjoyed the idea of watching her with another man, but that he would kill her if she ever cheated on him. There are so many people that specifically he talked to about this fantasy, but also just told them in kind of out of

48:20 context situations like if she ever cheated on me, I would kill her. But it's not cheating if you're wanting it to happen, Right, is that what he means? Or right? But he's saying I think you know ultimately, because all this is is it's another play for control. Yeah, so as long as he's the one pulling the strings, that's fine. I can't see him being okay with it even then, though, uh, well, start picturing it. Increasingly dissatisfied in her marriage, and worried about the safety of herself and their young child, Chris. Jamie was surreptitiously looking for a way out. By September nineteen ninety, it seemed there may have been a glimmer of light, I mean something resembling what she thought was maybe a very distant, very blurry glimmer of some sort of light. Lee, a low level drug dealer that Steve had frequently attempted to push on her as a potential sexual partner for his enjoyment, was someone she'd seemingly grown a lot closer to. Both he and Jamie felt embarrassed by Steve's constant pressuring. I can't even imagine how awkward that would be. Seriously, like, dude has no chill. Yeah, he has zero point zero, zero,

49:51 zero percent chill. Lee may not have been a boy scout, but he deeply disliked the abusive treatment Jamie frequently received from Steve, which is like, okay, cool, so you're about treating people like people. That's one in the column for Lee. Just because you're a drug dealer doesn't mean you're a terrible person. Well, and also I'm like okay. Well, like what kind of drugs you know right, I got a lot of follow up questions. I mean, I know that it wasn't just weed, but like, I want to just picture him as a funny weed dealer. Honestly, I kind of want to picture him as that guy, uh from that seventy show with the long hair, you know.

50:37 Oh god, I can't remember that character's name. Oh, the stony the stoner guy. Yeah, the stoner guy. Leo Leo, Leo Lee. It all connects. It all connects. Now, we sound like the Stoners, well, I mean, you know AnyWho. Additionally, around this time, a close girlfriend of Jamie's who herself was about to enter a trial separation from her husband, and actually they had been pregnant at around the same time, so both of their kids were around the same age. They had really bonded through that experience. She offered her a lifeline with a place to stay, encouraging her to leave Steve. I'm sure she was. Yeah, She's like, listen, it might not be working out, it's a trial separation with my husband, but you should for suresys get the hell out of there, Steve, who hopefully he's a distant memory.

51:40 Jamie set plans in motion for childcare lying to both Steve and her mother about precisely what her plans were, and she went on a date with Lee. I just feel like. There's other things that are more important than like sex and dating have and both of these people are just like. Yeah, I mean they're both very young, and I think at this point in their relationship, Jamie had just been beaten down so far from where she started, that her sense of self worth and that like she would ever be able to find love again, that she was worthy.

52:27 I think she needed to feel like there was someone there, like as a lifeline, and I think it's so common. I feel like, yeah. In the following days, she revealed the truth to her mother. A flurry of calls came in from Steve, and this time they weren't answering. Finally, Jamie agreed to speak with him and said directly, Steve, it's over. I don't love you anymore. I want a divorce.

53:09 It's over. Who like, give me chillies? Yeah, I know, I know, just like feeling how hard that I know it was for her to say. Saying it gave me chills because it. Just look at them goose pimples. I know my arms and it is hot in here because her conditioner is off. I don't think you can see mine either, but they are holy shit, every hair on my arm. Surprised as she was to hear it, Judy knew Jamie meant it. She was concerned her daughter's resolve would waiver when Jamie agreed to go meet step in person and tried to reason with her not to go.

53:56 That makes sense. This is the last thing that This is the last thing that she said to her mother, at least face to face. She did speak to Jamie after this. As she walked out the door, she said, all he can do is kill me. Mom. Judy said, I'm going to give you twenty minutes and then I'm going to be down there, and they were meeting in a public place. True to her word, Judy was set to send Jamie's father, Jerry, as a call came in from Jamie that she was at her in Steve's home. So they met in a public place. But she's calling now from their home.

54:43 Oh. When she'd shown up to meet him, he'd taken off with her purse. It's fucking psycho shit. So she decided to head home to pack some things for herself and Christopher knowing Steve would be there with her purse. A handful of hours went by and Jamie said she was on her way with taco time, a lunchtime ritual for the mother and daughter. Judy waited, but Jamie never showed. Strangely, the hegel phone sat silent, no follow up calls from Jamie. But almost more bizarrely was the lack of Steve's typical barrage on the line looking for Jamie because he knew that was September thirtieth, nineteen ninety and as the days wore on, Jamie's friends, family, and colleagues at Microsoft became increasingly concerned because she never showed up with taco time.

55:46 Microsoft would eventually put up a reward. As flyers were circulated and many joined search efforts for Jamie. Notably, according to the recollections of many, Steve was not among the dedicated searchers. Where is he He's there? He didn't even seem interested in sharing Jamie's missing person flyers, and indeed some would be privy to the incredibly quick romantic recovery he seemingly made. Surely, no one wanted to think about discovering a body rather than Jamie safe and alive somehow. However, through the course of the investigation, various types of K nine units were used to aid the search efforts, including cadaver dogs. October fifth, a relative of Steve's discovered Jamie's car. Now, this relative had, I forget what exactly professional position, but Steve knew that this area where Jamie's car was discovered was part of his normal area for his job, whatever that was. So Jamie's car, a nineteen eighty min RX seven, was discovered near the parking lot of the Unitarian Church north of Seattle. The driver's side door was unlocked, her duffel bag tucked behind that seat, And there were some concerning findings, like there were a lot of things packed

57:20 into that duffel bag, but it didn't appear to have been packed by Jamie. It didn't really make sense, hmmm. And it's hard for anybody to point to like precisely how they knew that, But they just knew that, Like she was going there to get her purse from Steve number one, and then she was going to pack up things for her and her son, and they were like none of the stuff she threw in that duffel bag allegedly made sense like kind of like a man would pack it. M hmm, yeah, like thirteen pairs of socks but no pants, or you know, vice versa. Interesting.

58:01 Yeah. The afternoon of October tenth, emergency services were called to the Education Hill area of Redmond. Steve had apparently attempted suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning. They found a wedding portrait of Steve and Jamie, along with a rambling note he'd written, as well as a cordless phone. As he was helicoptered off to the hospital, things weren't looking good. Chris, their young son, had already lost a missing mother and now his father in critical condition as well. Fortunately, Steve, I mean fortunately or unfortunately, it's hard to say, but Steve had called nine one one in time so that he could be saved, so Chris wouldn't be left an orphan.

58:47 After all, he called nine one one from the car while he was allegedly trying to kill himself. That's what I was gonna say, is he is this just like an act to make it seem like he's so obsese set that his wife is missing. Kind of seems like it, doesn't it, because he's not so upset that he's actually helping in the search effort. He's not so upset about her missing that he's putting up posters. Detectives went to speak with Steve at the hospital the following day, only to find he'd actually already been discharged and was actually across the street. He was sitting at a mental health center right across the street from the hospital. The detectives were met with yet another surprise.

59:35 There he was with attorney Peter Mayer, a very well known criminal defense attorney in Seattle. Why it's really interesting, right, your wife goes missing, you allegedly try to kill yourself, and immediately after being discharged from this suicide attempt, you check in to a mental health facility and hire one of the best criminal defense attorneys in your area. Was he being like, did they hint that they were looking at him? I have to imagine he had an awareness that. Okay, I mean, here's the thing, though, it's weird that he chose that moment. Yeah, you just got out of the hospital for something that could have killed you, and your number one priority is now now retaining legal counsel, and not just any counsel. Listen, it's circumstantial at best.

1:00:39 But it just seems odd. I could see if I guess if he was trying to kill himself because he thought that he might get pulled in for questioning or something. Here's the thing, You're gonna be hauled in for questioning because my wife is fucking missing. So and people that didn't kill their wife don't try to commit suicide and then immediately hire the best criminal defense attorney that you can get in a major metropolitan city. It's odd timing, sure. Is it' sus as hell? Nothing seemed to develop with Jamie's missing person's case. The Hagel sadly had to begin accepting that they may never have answers. On the bright side, they were awarded custody of Chris. Their attempts to hire pis and get answers were multiple and very costly. Finally, in mid nineteen ninety seven, the King County Emmy declared Jamie dead. It had been nearly seven years since Jamie had disappeared, after all, damn dude. The investigation was reinvigorated around this time thanks to Judy's urging when conversing at length with Lute James Taylor, head of Major crimes with the Redmond Police Department. She said they agreed it was time to face the fact that her daughter had certainly passed.

1:02:12 And that's where I'm going to leave you for part one. That's so heartbreaking. I cannot believe. Well, I can't, I mean, I can't believe. But the last thing that she said to her mom was like, all he could do is kill me. Oh, and it's so true. Oh my god. I mean, like the worst part is is that she had already she had already been through so much with Steve, and I feel like at that point she was like, listen, all this left is that he can kill me, and like she was at her breaking point. She was like I'm done. I'm not doing this anymore, and like she'd almost rather be yeah, dead than than to put up.

1:02:57 With it anymore. But to say that before, it's like she's like, Mom, like calmed down, and like the last thing that's going to do is calm your mom down. Yeah, girl, girl. And how haunting to be the mom and like have to hear that all the time in your head. That's like the. Last thing, Yeah, I mean, it's it's not the last words that she spoke to her daughter, but that was the last time she saw her face. Well, do you want to do Taro for this one or save it for part two? Like? How much longer is Part's? That's so crazy because I was thinking with this one and we don't typically do this, but I was like, I honestly kind of think we should wait to do Taro in part two. Okay, that's so weird. We read each other's minds all the time. I will say, if if you think that the wildest part of this story have already happened, they have not doll decapitation. Is there more doll decapitation? There? There are no further instances of dull decapitation, but there are some truly wild crimes that continue to be a part of our story. And without giving too much away, like literally up until the buzzer, like,

1:04:29 we will be talking about this and additional crimes until the very very last sentence. Shit crime time, baby, honestly, you had me at Tiny Petite Woman and Taco time. Seriously Part two, everyone hold on to your doll heads seriously. Though. Yeah, I will say the second half ends on slightly happier note. Okay, yeah, because this one didn't end happy at all no, very sad, and now we don't even get a palette cleanser like I talked about.

1:05:13 I know we did say something about that at the top, and I feel a little bad about that, but it just feels like the right thing for this one, because yeah, I maybe maybe this is just me, but I almost kind of don't want the Taro to be a dick and like give something away. Oh see, you think Taro's gonna be sneaky. I kind of do. I kind of do. Like I feel like there's Easter eggs and the Tarot readings like far too frequently for me to like let that happen. Yeah, that's it for now. We're coming back and have a creepy asday. See you next Tuesday Day today and we will be there. We will see part two Tuesday Part two.

1:06:04 H Oh my god, that just reminded me. I don't know where it is, but I think I have it. I do have, like literally like a tiny doll pillow. It's like, I'm not kidding, it's like all that big. Does the doll not need it anymore because it's ben decapitated, so it doesn't need a pillow? Okay, Well,