Two Deaths, One Date: Patience Boston & the Purrinton Family | York & Augusta, Maine
On July 9, 1734, a Native woman named Patience Boston confessed to drowning an eight-year-old boy in a well — then walked two miles to turn herself in. Seventy-two years later, to the day, a respected Maine farmer spent an evening sharpening an axe and reading his Bible by candlelight before murdering nearly his entire family.
Two tragedies. Same calendar date. Both set in colonial Maine, centuries ago.
Two documents, centuries-old that survive only because someone who knew the people involved decided to write down what happened — a pair of Puritan ministers shaping one woman's last words into a lesson for their congregation; a midwife, recording only what she witnessed, with no agenda at all, though her heartbreak is apparent.
This episode pairs both cases – set in York and Augusta, Maine – tracing the unlikely survival of their stories throughout history, and asking who gets to tell the story of the dead, and why it matters.
This episode exists because July 9 is our cohost Cassie's birthday — and when that date flagged two colonial Maine tragedies separated by exactly seventy-two years, it felt like too strange a pairing to pass up. I had no idea quite how dark it would get when I picked up the mantle of telling these stories – sorry, Cassie.
Visit our website! Find us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Patreon, & more! There are so many ways that you can support the show: BuyMeACoffee, Spreaker, or by leaving a rating & review on Apple Podcasts.
0:00 When I had the moment, I had the epiphany. I was like, this very specifically has to be my next one because of the. Date, because it's my birthday. Yes, barring any unexpected circumstances, this episode is going to come out on your birthday, July nine. Happy birthday to me. Happy birthday. Do you so? This episode pairs two unrelated tragedies that happened exactly seventy two years apart on the very same calendar date. Hi Cassie, Hi Caitlin, Hi creepy people. Oh hellou hell. This is PNW Hansen Homicides, where we chat about true crime, the paranormal, and all the spooky things that happen in the Pacific Northwest.
0:59 All of them, all of them or the PNW I f you're nasty. Oh yeah, And we do a tarot reading at the end of every episode for a little deeper insight into our topic. Oh right, that old thing. So this is like kind of a little late in the game sort of. But do you remember it? You know, it was like last summer, I think right around it was. It was a holiday weekend. I want to say it was the Memorial Day weekend. I went and did an interview for a true crime TV show.
1:39 Yes, I remember, I wasn't there, just Caitlin exactly. Well, I bet you remember it because they sent me with some goodies. Yeah they did. Yeah, it got drunk. Yeah, those Irish flag pins and then we were gifted a bottle of Jamison. Each yo, thank you. Yeah. So the show is actually it's it's called Bloodline Detectives, and I had to do a little poking around to find out where I could watch it. I'm sure it's different, like in all different regions and stuff. I think I ended up finding it on to Be and it was free.
2:23 To watch, so oh okay. So it's actually two episodes that aired actually all the way back in I think January that I'm in. It's season six, episodes fourteen and fifteen. Pretty exciting. I think it goes without saying that at some point I will have to cover the two cases that the show talked about. They're very interesting. It'll probably be a while because now that I've I've talked about it, I don't you know, I want to surprise.
3:04 Everybody, right, I haven't watched it yet, so I have to go find it. I tried, and I could only find it on like YouTube, but then that they didn't have those episodes or that season out yet. Yeah, it is recent enough that probably you would want to watch it on TB or it's on like Pluto TV. There's there's actually a bunch of places you can watch it. Caitlyn's famous. I wonder if anyone like watched it and was like, hey, that's Caitlin. That would be really to be a hopeful homicide. Why didn't you tell us that you watched it? Yeah, female us, Yeah. If you watch it, let us know and just know that the camera adds ten pounds and I think they had at least three cameras on me. And it was very hot. So if i'm if I'm like listening at all, you know, just a couple of disclaimers.
4:07 You're beautiful. Your skin is just glowing. That's the style right now, glowy skin. So you're yeah, Well, I will say that after kind of taking a break from doing video for the podcast, coming across the episodes in that timeframe, I was like, wow, I've I guess I didn't realize how I'm like just not used to seeing my face and stuff. Yeah, I was like self conscious in a way that I haven't been since we first started doing video for the podcast, and I was like. Oh god, I know I would be too, but that's not what it's about exactly.
4:53 I was like, well, listen, hopefully I don't look like a swamp troll or something. But yeah, it's really not about how good or bad I look. But selfishly, you know, you do hope that you, you know, look reasonably well put together when you appear on camera. Yeah. Well, I don't know. I've watched a lot of documentaries and some people look questionable on camera. But yeah, it's fine. Yeah, well, everyone go watch it and tell Caylen how beautiful she is and what a good job she did. Yes, please, Well I'm excited for this. Obviously. We talked about this offline before we started recording. I had an idea.
5:43 Last night. I had an episode that was completely ready to go. It actually has show notes prepared when we upload it to Apple and everything. And then I thought, you know what, this pattern of like seemingly kind of having my shit together for a little bit, it's really rubbing me the wrong way. Love that, so let's introduce some chaos. But I'm like, I wasn't looking for this. It just happened. Okay, it was meant to be. It was meant to be. I was watching a show that at this point it's like kind of a historical democracy, and they were talking about like colonial days in America, like back when it was the thirteen Colonies.
6:37 Not Pacific Northwest. No. No, But something that I googled last night while I was watching this documentary set me off down this path, this rabbit hole. I love if you will, I love it. I love when plans just get switched last minute. It's my favorite thing. Yeah. Yeah, so I knew it all the time. We talk about this all the time, Like I had this other episode and I just wasn't feeling it and I had to go find something else. I mean, I was totally feeling that episode. But the thing is, when I had the moment, I had the epiphany, I was like, this very specifically has to be my next one because of the date, because.
7:30 Because it's my birthday. Yes, barring any unexpected circumstances, this episode is going to come out on your birthday, July ninth. Happy birthday to me, Happy birthday to you. So this episode pairs two unrelated tragedies that happened exactly seventy two years apart, on the very same calendar date, Oh creepy July ninth. That date lines up with, as I've already said, a certain co host birthday, and both stories are set in and around Portland. That is Portland, Maine.
8:19 Oh you trickster, a city to whom Portland, Oregon is considered the coin toss sibling city on the opposite coast. That's right. Do you know the other name? Oh? I do. I'm about to get into what Okay. When Francis Pettygrove of Maine and Asa Lovejoy of Massachusetts decided to make the Oregon Territory their new home in eighteen forty five, both wanted to name it after their own hometown. A Yeah, they did. I feel like every time I go on any type of tour of this in Portland, we get this story and I just love it.
9:02 I honestly, I don't think I had ever heard this before. Really, dude, Like it was like being hit with a lightning bolt repeatedly. Every time I was like looking at and like I'm not even to the actual topics yet, but like, holy shit, it was like being hit with lightning bolts repeatedly. Everything about this was just like, oh, and this and this. I was so excited. I'm a vote for coin toss the other direction. But it's fine. In the end, it was a coin toss that decided between Boston and Portland, and the rest is history. But did you know, Cassie Today the eighteen thirty five Portland penny is preserved by the Oregon Historical Society and on display at their downtown Portland Museum.
9:59 Oh well, okay, the penny they used for the coin toss. Yep C, I know right, want to see it. That's an old Niosh pany. So, the two cases that I'm going to be talking about today are a deliberate, intentional choice for this episode, precisely because of the odd parallels and connections. My research even turned up an additional, genuinely unplanned synchronicity. I realized there's another one as I was finishing writing the case literally today. What the first one is a death that is very, very sad, and I feel weird sounding excited about it right now. But in the second case, the death occurs at around three am on July thirtieth, eighteen oh six, and that is the date that was anticipated to be my own date of birth, Aka, it was my doo date, but just obviously centuries later, right, Yeah, no one else that old. It's me to be born in eighteen oh six.
11:10 She actually is a vampire. Right. Just strange things like that cluster around this story. There's all these like kind of little syncreticities. And I'm going to tell you about a couple little things that got me going down this road. Both cases also share a second, quieter thread. They rely on documents written by the people closest to them. In patients Boston's case, two Puritan ministers shaping her words into a conversion narrative. In the Puritan case, a midwife named Martha Ballard, writing in her own diary the same week of the event, with no agenda at all beyond bearing witness. In seventeen thirty four, Maine was not yet its own state. It was a remote district of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and York was one of its oldest English settlements, first established in the sixteen twenties, repeatedly burned and rebuilt through decades of conflict between English colonists and the region's native nations. By the time this story takes place, York had a courthouse, a meeting house, and a jail, which in the source material they referred to it as the old jail, but it's
12:43 spelled gaol, which all, yes, huh, it's apparently an archaic or traditional British spelling of jail, but it's literally just pronounced jail. Okay, fancy jail things in the. UK be wild. It was built in seventeen nineteen and still stands today as one of the oldest public buildings in the United States. Wow, over fifty years before we became a country. Yeah, I mean before we even tried to become a country. It sets a tone that the oldest building still standing today is like, oh, one of our earliest jails.
13:33 Yeah, I feel so lico civilized. We are proud of ourselves that we can put people away. Well, you know, the trend definitely continued, I guess, so there's that. It feels like that really captures our vibe. Yeah. This was also a world built on two intertwined systems of forced labor and forced belonging. Native indentured servitude an African enslavement. Patience Boston's life touched both. She was indentured to an English family as a small child, after her mother's death, she would go on to marry an enslaved black whaler.
14:18 Oh yes, okay. Nearly everyone she lived among, worked for, or was bound to, held some form of power over her that she had no say in or very little say in her story. It's important that that doesn't get separated from the structure of it. It's the frame the entire tragedy sits inside. Patience was born December twenty sixth, seventeen eleven on Montamoy Island to a couple that were members of the Nauset tribe. The pronunciation guide that I found says it literally looks like it says, nah sit, you know, nah sit, you know, go ahead and sit down.
15:09 I am. Her parents, John Samson and Sarah Jethrow, are described in at least one source as coming from high ranking families within their community, which is I feel like kind of a significant detail about her history because whatever standing her family held ultimately really meant nothing within the colonial system, especially when you think about that's the same system that would go on to indenture patients as a young child. So I mean, these are people that are of some you know, whether it may have been more fractional for you know, one or the other of her parents, but they are of Native descent. I get the feeling that they were both like full native. Sarah Jethro died when Patience was just three years old. After her mother's death, Patience's father indentured her to a man named Paul. Though it's not a critical detail in the story, his last name either Krowell or crow. I just couldn't really confirm definitively across historical records. Okay, kind of fuck that guy though, anyway, because who's like, yeah, I want to indenture a three year old.
16:35 I have questions about that. And I do feel like this next little section here is probably gonna have some answers for you, because I kind of had the same reaction. Actually, wait, I don't want the answers. I changed my mind. I don't want to take it back. Well, I'm afraid we're already into deep. It's my birthday. Why nothing bad has even happened on your birthday yet? So the fact that Patience is indentured to presumably a you know, maybe not even wealthy, but essentially an English family, it says a lot about the precariousness of Native family life under English colonial law, her father grieving the loss of his wife, handing his daughter over to an English household because the system really gave him few other paths to ensure she'd be fed and housed. Oh, I don't know that it was necessarily a situation where he couldn't care for her outright, or maybe more so that just like I can't deal. I don't know that it was necessarily that he didn't have the resources. It might have just been more like, personally, I don't have the bandwidth.
18:03 Yeah, that would be really hard. Yeah. In either case, it's ultimately like Sucksville for patients, I will say, uh. Yeah. So after the death of Paul's wife, patients began to exhibit what most would categorize as either typical teenage behavior kind of keeping bad company and sneaking out. Okay, she could have been a kid of. The nineteen nineties. When I read some of that they did back then, I honestly was like, we're teenagers sneaking out in the seventeen hundreds. I guess, yeah, probably since the dawn of time.
18:48 It's probably easier because they didn't have cameras or cell phones, right alarm system exactly. Yeah, though perhaps In hindsight, these behaviors may have been the earliest signs of her childhood trauma and unprocessed grief experiences and feelings that she had neither the language to express nor the tools to heal from. Patients began drinking heavily as her term of servitude ended. Later, she would marry Caesar Boston, who was well acquainted with the struggles of bondage as a literally enslaved black man working on whaling ships.
19:30 So that would be just crazy. You have to be a whaler. Like to listen, there's sh there's a lot that like intellectually from like looking back through like a twenty twenty six lens that I'm like, like, my head doesn't really I can't go there. Yeah, Patience was a real one choosing to bind herself in servitude along inside him. Wow, though Massachusetts law did not require it of her as a free native woman. And at this point, like I said, her you know, indentured servitude, like that term had ended from when her dad basically you know, handed her over.
20:19 But if she wanted to stay with her husband, binding herself to the same household was practically speaking, kind of the only way to do it. Because Caesar, as an enslaved person, uh literally had no say in the matter of like where he went, what he did, had no bodily autonomy. So it's interesting to me that he could get married though. Yeah, the documentary that I was watching, you know, they talked quite a bit about the Transatlantic slave trade, but they also, i mean just about slavery in general in the colonies. And one of the things that kind of obviously we know about the three fifths, it was designed basically to give the South more votes, oh, because they had a ton more people, but just most of them weren't even really counted like people.
21:20 Right. I'm just trying to do like a super service level explanation here. But one of the things that kind of the Founders and the Framers had to sort of negotiate was there were a lot of people in northern States that were like very adamantly opposed to slavery. I think we all, you know, intellectually understand that on some level, but seeing how passionate the debate was as they were writing the Constitution, and seeing how close our country in the very very early days came to like very nearly just not even like just dissolving because they're like, hey, this is you know what, we can't agree on anything, so fuck it.
22:07 Wow weird. Yeah, I know, not a lot's changed. Yeah, strange. One of like the really like the sticking points was sort of the South did not want to do away with specifically the Transatlantic slave trade, which meant they were still actively kidnapping people from Africa and bringing them here versus you know, having to essentially depend on your enslaved workforce reproducing to kind of maintain.
22:49 That makes sense. Yeah, this is gross. Yeah. When they were writing up the Constitution, one of the things that was negotiated was that Congress would not make the Transatlantic slave trade and bringing in new slaves. They could not outlaw that for twenty years. And the reason is that the plantation owners in the South firmly believed that if they could keep bringing importing essentially more humans for the next twenty years, that once that twenty year period ended, either they would just you know, they would just basically like, oh, well, we're going to either convince or browbeat the Northern States, or worst case scenario, if they do end that aspect of you know, slavery and you know, new trading, we will have enough literal humans that we own that they will just reproduce. We won't have to bring in more because we'll have enough.
23:57 Then twenty years is a long time. It's so upsetting, it's so gross. Oh my god, so gross. And I say all I mean just the timing of like coming across this case as I was watching that documentary about like you know, the formation, the founding of America and you know, our War for Independence, like so many unique and interesting like details about like America's history, like from basically like day one. It's like, uh BC versus a D. Yeah, oh jeez.
24:37 But it's like it's such a huge component of her story because she's a native woman who was you know, crazy, She actually was supposedly part of a family that had some sort of status and standing in society, and she ends up becoming an indentured servant. Then she goes on to marry a black man who is enslaved. Literal bondage was such a huge theme in her life from from start to finish. It just is like, I don't know, anyways, I really went I really went hard there for a little bit. And probably some of.
25:17 That nobody you've explained it good because I had the question, right. I know, but it like I was, like, this is totally off book. I have so much here, but like I just I found it so interesting watching that and then like the tie in with this, I can't I can't help myself. I don't know how to shut up. It's not in the script, but here we are. That's okay. The couple had two children together, both sadly dying in infancy. Oh oh god. Yeah, a lot of infant death. Yeah, yeah, on that time. Mm hmm.
25:58 I think between the two famis that were kind of focusing on, like the two kind of main pillar women of these stories, I think they have a combined like at least six infant deaths between the two of them. Why babies, I know. Very very sad. That's why I guess a lot of times they would hold off on naming babies until they or they would give them like a placeholder name. Yeah, Like they wouldn't give them like the you wouldn't become like, oh I'm John's son, you wouldn't become John junior until you, like, you know, prove that you weren't just gonna die of dysentery immediately. Yeah, Or they would name more than one boy, John right, because that's the namesake.
26:53 Like God, you get one of them to stick. Jesus just so dark. According to the roughly three hundred year old court and church records, Patients told people, including her husband and later even the authorities, that she had thoughts of murdering both children before they were even born, though authorities declined to act on her confession for lack of any evidence that a crime had actually occurred. Twice twice they said, she's confessed and there's no evidence twice. In fact, it was clear that she blamed herself for their deaths, which is rooted in the Puritan religion and culture of the period. Bad things happened for a reason, because you're a goddamn sinner. That's terrible, really awful.
27:51 But she said that she had thoughts of harming. Them, of killing them before they were even born. I mean, that's rough mental health stuff right there. Mm hmmm, nailed it. It's gonna come back. Perhaps that explains her insistence and the eventual charge for their second child's death. While in jail awaiting trial, she became afraid of dying with what she called a lie in my mouth. This led to her eventually changing her plea to not guilty, and the court actually acquitted her. It's possible that postpartum depression, complex trauma from a lifetime of forced removal and servitude as a child, an undiagnosed mental health crisis, or some combination that honestly none of us are going to be able to readily name or understand from the distance of literal centuries later. It's possible that those were contributing factors, and her bizarre documented pattern of false self accusation occurring years before the actual crime she would ultimately undeniably commit.
29:08 Oh shit, oh shit. After her acquittal, Patience left her husband and asked to be bound instead to a man named Joseph Bailey of Casco Bay. It seems almost unfathomable Patients essentially chose her own next master, rather than remaining with the husband that she literally married and had bound herself to up to that point. While in Bailey's household, Patients confessed to murdering a third child. Authorities took this confession seriously enough and did investigate. Though midwives examined her and searchers looked for a grave, ultimately they found nothing because, as it turned out, the child had never existed at all.
29:57 Oh, I was thinking maybe she had like a miscaracter something, which. Would also be another lovely parallel to modern day America. Right, it's not murder if you have a miscarriage. It certainly isn't hot take. I don't whoo call us two hot takes. This is yet another documented instance of patients confessing to a murder that she did not commit, that literally did not happen, and it raises the same unanswerable questions as the first. I mean, what was actually happening inside this woman's mind in a world with absolutely no framework, no vocabulary, and no compassion available to even ask or question seriously, like what is going on in your mind? Like? Yeah, it's so sad to look back on cases like this and just see these stunningly clear examples of like this is some sort of you know, mental health issue that's present, and it doesn't take away from obviously the eventual crime. But it's like, Yo, she's been confessing to murder for like years at this point.
31:15 Yeah help her. Yeah they couldn't. I know, there wasn't the tools. There's nothing Joseph Bailey for reasons, the record doesn't actually specify, but can probably be guessed. Eventually sold Patience's contract for her indentured servitude to another master, and that's the household where the story turns from false confession to real tragedy. Patience was eventually transferred to the household of Benjamin's skill Ins in York. Also living in the same household was his eight year old grandson, Benjamin Trott. Basically, he was being raised like he was Benjamin Senior's own son. Not exactly sure what the circumstances were that brought that about, but it's kind of cute. Benjamin being raised by his grandpa.
32:15 Also Benjamin Benjamin Troll. Benjamin Troll. Patients stated both that she grew to love the young boy and vice versa, while also developing some, as she put it, groundless prejudice against the senior Benjamin. In time, the latter instinct seems to have won. In the fall of seventeen thirty three, in her own words, she bound herself by a wicked oath ooh to kill Skillen's grandson. No, the contradiction of her clearly stated pre medic intent to kill a child she also described as loving is kind of the dark center of this case.
33:09 Yeah, this makes like no sense so far right. I don't know if you're going to make it make sense. I mean, unfortunately in cases of child murder, I feel like you can't really make it make sense. Yeah, there ain't no sense. Ain't no sense in that. On July ninth, seventeen thirty four, while both mister and Missus Skillens were away from home, patients lured the boy out into the woods. She intended to beat him over the head with a large stick, but as she attempted to do so, she started trembling and she just kind of lost her nerve.
33:50 Well, yeah, you're trying to kill a kid that you love. Why would for some reason with a stick? Oh God. She decided instead to drop the stick into a well nearby, asking Benjamin to climb down and retrieve. It for her. I don't this is the worst birthday gift you've ever given me. I'm so sorry. I'm not happy with you. I know, I'm gonnat you. I'm gonna fix this, Okay, I'm gonna make it better. I don't believe you, I promise. Okay, I'm gonna mute you for the rest of the. Wow.
34:31 Rude, I don't want to Okay, go do it. Rip off the band dude. All right, it's gonna get Game of Thrones here for a sec. Only when he reached the edge, she just pushed him in. She used a long pole to hold him under the water within the well until he drowned. I didn't realize how dark this crime was, but the fact that these two stories that we're talking about today have the connection to July ninth. I was like, listen, who am I to tell the universe?
35:11 Nah? I don't wanna. I would. I don't want this to be in my mind. I know well, regardless of the day that it happened on, it was going to be in your mind, because you know through crime and all that what happened immediately afterward is recorded with unusual specificity for a case. This old Patience raised her hands to the sky and said, now I am guilty of murder. Indeed, though formerly I accused myself falsely, yet now God has left me. Afterwards, she walked to a neighboring house about two miles away. She confessed what she had done and turned herself in.
36:02 Just so so strange, my mouth is just open. Yeah, you're like, oh man, Patience was arrested and remained in York's Old Jail, Old Gail Jail for roughly a year. As she awaited her trial. She was visited dozens of times by the Reverend Samuel Moody and his son, the Reverend Joseph Moody, pastors of York's Church. Perhaps as a result of their visits, Patience seems to have experienced a spiritual transformation. Something seems to have genuinely shifted in Patience.
36:44 During that year, she read scripture, and after years of drinking quite heavily, she found sobriety. Well that's great. Yeah, I mean, I can't imagine that you have a choice in beverage when you're in prison, so right, some of that may not necessarily have been my choice. Hard to say. There could be toilet wine, could. Yeah, certainly, she refused it. Yeah, that's what I Yeah, as I feel one perhaps should maybe decline. And this part it's sort of a double edged sword because the implications are a little bit dark. She also gave birth to a child while in custody, a boy who at one point fell dangerously ill with a fever. Patients admitted to a dark thought in that moment that it might be better if God willed it for the child to die before she did. Instead, she asked the congregation to pray for him, and he recovered oh records never name his father. And when I say there's kind of a double edge soared with that, it's like, well, either she was impregnated by someone before she went to prison. I don't know. I'm not digging into the timeline on this that deep. There wasn't enough information about that. Or she
38:18 was impregnated while she was in prison, which is completely plausible based on what I do know about the timeline and also about incarceration for women, you know, just for the last three hundred years. That's what I was thinking. That's terrible, possibly terrible. I don't it's hard to say. So this is kind of a weird, kind of a weird little aside that I almost just completely left out of my notes. But it's so weird that I was like, I think we have to. Have that, okay, I like a weird fact.
39:00 Joseph Moody, the younger minister who helped compile her story, he began a strange practice around the same time that he was finishing it. He started wearing a black veil over his face, refusing to remove it except when alone or facing a wall, and apparently this was a habit he kept for the rest of his life. History remembers him today as Handkerchief Moody what in the world hu, and he is the direct historical inspiration for Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story The Minister's Black Veil. It's a strange footnote in the case, but a true one.
39:44 I mean, you do you But that's fucking weird. Yeah? Yeah, do you think she got to him? Like I don't know, I don't know what, like like I don't know, and like, yeah, it's very weird. It's just it's bizarred. I'm just gonna do that. Then we can do video again. Oh, I'll just wear my black veil. A veil, yeah, why not? Just having a goth moment. Patience went to trial on June nineteenth, seventeen thirty five.
40:24 Pleading guilty. The judge sentenced her to hang July twenty fourth, seventeen thirty five. On the morning of her execution. Oddly, Patience reportedly slept very well the night before, not the vibe I would have, but it's your last sleep. I yeah, you know. Before the big long sleep. She described having in her own words, a more realizing sense of death and some fears, but her hopes were above her fears. Do you think she was just suicidal like I and she just you know how people like suicide by cop or whatever, but they're you know, maybe that was like her.
41:11 I don't know her way. I mean, all of this is so strange. It's anything's possible in my book, to be honest, there's certain things that I feel like we can point to and say, like, Okay, well I think like I can make some assumptions or you know, yeah, some inferences, but like it's just bizarre. It's just bizarre. She prayed with several ministers that morning, but when the time came, it was quite hard for her to part with her infant son, who'd been born there in the jail. Yeah, which is just really. Sad for so many reasons, but just to think about like that is, you know, the only living child that she had to that point. When the sheriff arrived, patients asked for a few more minutes alone. Then she emerged from her cell and said, simply, I am ready. She walked calmly to the cart that would carry her to the gallows, where a noose hung from a sturdy tree limb, and hundreds of people had gathered to watch, because that was what people did back then.
42:26 Yeah, that's. I mean, listen, I get it. There's nothing on TV. Back then, I was thinking that there was no Game of Thrones. Yep. Now we just watch fake deaths on TV. Yeah. A minister read from scripture to the assembled crowd. Then Patience herself stood and spoke, declaring her love of God, asking mercy for her sins, praying for the child that she was now leaving behind, and then turning to the crowd itself to pray for them that they would take warning from her life and be aware, especially the sin of drunkenness, which she clearly believed had played its own role in everything that led her there.
43:15 Oh shit. Patience Boston, just twenty three years old, was hanged at York on July twenty fourth, seventeen thirty five. Before her death, she was assured her child had been placed with a family who would care for both his body and soul. Patience's story didn't end with her execution. It became something else, entirely in the hands of the people who outlived her. In seventeen thirty five, around the time of her death, a short pamphlet was published, the Confession Declaration, Dying, Warning and Advice of Patience Samson alias Patience Boston. Then in seventeen thirty eight, the Moody's published a much longer and more elaborate work, and the title is half a paragraph, Oh Sure, Deep Breath. A faithful narrative of the wicked life and remarkable conversion of Patients Boston alias Sampson. It belongs to his genre historians call gallows literature, narratives assembled by Puritan clergy from the words of condemned prisoners, intended less to document the facts of a crime than to use, shall we say, a sinner's spiritual journey toward repentance as
44:45 a lesson for the living. I thought, I thought that's where it was going. Yeah, yeah, it's still kind of cool. Though. I do think it's cool, and I do think that is still kind of a service to those individuals in a way, if that's something that they respond to, and you know, perhaps also to the broader community. I wish it maybe wasn't tied to like organize religion specifically, but like beggars can't be choosers, right, So the version of Patients Boston that has survived through this work is filtered and shaped by two Puritan ministers with their own theological agenda, men who were, by the era's own standards, more interested in her conversion than in her guilt, or her innocence or any of the conditions in her life. Patience Boston really did kill an eight year old boy. There's no ambiguity about that specific fact, and Benjamin Trott deserves to be remembered as a real child with a life cut short, not just a supporting detail and someone else's tragic narrative.
46:03 But I mean, god damn, in a very real way. They very much are both victims. She just also happens to be a perpetrator. Of violence, which happens a lot. I mean, it does, I feel like probably most of the time. Yeah, I mean yeah, I would argue, yes, I have observed a pattern, shall we say, in the last handful of years. And at the same time, Patience's documented history of multiple separate false confessions to murders that never happened involving infants preceding the one murder she actually committed is the kind of pattern that in any modern court would trigger a serious psychiatric evaluation before anyone moved toward a verdict, let alone a death sentence. But obviously that wasn't happening in seventeen thirty five. No, there was no language at the time for what we would describe now as potentially postpartum psychosis, complex trauma, or the cumulative psychological toll of a childhood spent, indentured, orphaned, and passed between households that held all of the legal power over her existence with no say on her part. There was only sin, confession
47:36 and the gallows. This is also, unavoidably a story about whose voice gets preserved and whose doesn't. Ooh part two, Part two? Yeah, because I said there's two stories. Oh is this just one episode? Though? Right? It is? Yeah? Okay. In August eighteen o five, Captain James Purenton, a handsome revolutionary war veteran and well regarded farmer said to be of good character, moved his family to a Ballard neighborhood just outside Augusta, Originally known to the area's native inhabitants as Kushnak. Augusta had grown from a fur trading post on the Kennebec River into a small but established town.
48:30 Maine was still not yet a state. She's out there fighting the good fight. Though it remained part of Massachusetts and wouldn't receive statehood for another fourteen years. It was part of Massachusetts. Wow, apparently I don't think I knew that. I didn't either. Over the following winter and spring, Purenton family settled in The Captain's wife, Elizabeth, known as Beth's see Love, visited neighbors, trading herbs and other goods, quickly becoming part of the fabric of their new small community.
49:12 As soon as I read trading herbs and stuff, I was like, this, bitch sounds kind of witchy. Oh, I was thinking, she's drug dealer. What kind of herb? You trading their bits? Listen, I'm just saying, technically, this is still part of messages. That's why I think witchy. I think, yeah, No, you're ray. I'm just a pie head. Yeah, I guess. Hey, listen, two things can be true. Herb means a lot of things to a lot of different people. One neighbor, Martha Ballard, a midwife in her seventies that had delivered hundreds of babies all over the valley for four decades kept a diary and it's actually like a pretty important historical document.
50:03 WHOA. I love that. Like, her diaries are like kind of a big deal. The entries throughout the winter and spring of eighteen oh six are full of small, ordinary contact, Like all of these details about interacting with the Puritan family, Missus Puringon stopping by for tea young poly Purenton coming for herbs for her ailing mother, even Captain Purington himself once walking Martha home after a difficult birth late at night in May. Wow, she like wrote all this shit down. Yeah, she wrote a lot of shit down. I found all of these really interesting, like little quoted sections of her diaries, and I was like, bitch, we gotta pick and choose. Like I started out where I was like, oh, I'm gonna take that one, and I'm like, oh boy, we gotta we got to get real. And they're all just like a lot of them are so wholesome. Even the entries that aren't strictly speaking wholesome, maybe they're just so earnest. I feel like I know her now. Martha's my bitch Martha. But by the summer of eighteen oh six, something had changed. The Purentan family's entire crop for the season was threatened by severe drought. And I mean, I'm sure they weren't the only ones, because drought tends to kind of affect everybody, right, but they're who we're talking about.
51:37 So the family's household of eight living children ranging from eighteen months to nineteen years old roughly. Holy shit, Yeah, that's a range. Yeah, I mean, that's what we gather kind of from, like the historical records. There's a lot of sources that have like kind of slightly differing ages for different kids in the family. And I'm like, listen, they had basically from toddlers to tiaras and then to teenagers and young adults. And that's just living children. So how I wonder how many they had? At least four children that died in infancy. Oh wow, And that was before they moved. The family's household of eight living children, ranging from eighteen months to nineteen years old, dependent on the farm for survival. The financial pressure was real and immediate, Like, if we don't have enough food that our farm is producing, we will not make it through the winter. Captain Puringon had told neighbors he was concerned about the state of his farm, worried he might soon be unable to provide food for his family or even their livestock. On a Sunday in early July, Purenton wrote a letter and seal it in black with a death's head drawn on it, which is essentially like a skull in crossbones situation. Okay, yeah, Inside he wrote instructions
53:12 for his children's futures, as if he would not be alive to provide for them himself. And this is from the letter. I cannot see the distress of my family. God only knows my distress. I would have you put Nathaniel to Uncle Purrenton, to a tanner's trade. I want James to go to school until sufficient to attend in a store, Benjamin, to a blacksmith's trade, or to what you think best, but to be sure to give them learning. If it takes all, divide what is left for I am no more. Ooh, that's so ominous, like a suicide note.
53:54 Yeah, and it definitely could read that way. For sure, It definitely read that way to me at first. His wife Betsy found the letter the following day, Monday, and confronted him. Uh, because you know, she had, of course assumed, like you said, that he meant to die by suicide, but he told her that she had it all wrong, and she's like, uh, pray I do, because if you saddle me with all of these fucking kids. Alone, yeah seriously, you. Know she said something like that, but like it was more like, uh puritanically, yeah, you know.
54:36 And then just leave a note telling me what to do with all of them, like. Well, and yeah, you'll note that. Uh. I don't know if maybe the source that I found didn't have all of the note transcribe, but you will notice that, uh, he only mentions, let's see one, two, three children. The boys. Oh well, the girls have obvious futures. They just need to get married, right, marry them off to the richest bidder. Yeah yeah, highest bidder, yeah, highest bidder. Yeah yeah yeah yeah. Rather than intending to kill himself, he said he was simply taking precautions as a result of a premonition of his death approaching. He's like, I'm not gonna kill myself.
55:28 I just I just know that, like I'm gonna die and like pretty soon. I mean, no, how old was he How long do people live back then? I don't know. Yeah, I mean it seems plausible at any rate. Betsy, she was inconsolable either way. She's thinking, my husband is having a premonition about his like approaching death just you know, right around the corner. And then uh, you know, the other possibility is uh or or you know, he's planning to off himself. So really, for a woman in her circumstances, neither is preferable. Whatever happened in the days between Betsy's confrontation and the night of July eighth, we have no further record of, no diary entry, no surviving conversation. Kind of the only blank spot July eighth is sort of I mean, there's there's like a little there's a little bit of information, but not a lot. It's just the outcome and a letter that reads less like a man planning murder than a man planning his own absence. Like it kind of does sound like he thinks he's gonna die. Yeah, he's giving instructions for what to do, you know, for the future of their boys. On the evening of July eighth, eighteen oh six, Captain purrenton ground, his axe sharpened. It feels very deliberate ahead of whatever it is that he
57:02 has planned here. After his wife and children went to bed, he stayed up alone reading the Bible. His conduct and demeanor had remained calm all day and into the night, but then sometime between two and three in the morning, he moved through the house with the axe. James Purrenton Junior woke to the sound of his mother screaming. He ran toward the noise and found his father standing with a bloodied axe. Purenton swung at his own son, striking him across the back, but James Junior managed to escape, fleeing the house in nothing but his shirt.
57:46 Holy shit. He ran to the home of neighbor Dean Wyman and raised the alarm. Wyman immediately ran for help to Jonas Ballard, Martha the midwife's son. Small town pretty prey knows, you know a lot of the same last names floating around here books. The two men went to the Puritan house together to find Elizabeth and six of the children's lane. Oh god, only one child was carried back to the Ballard house, where surgical aid was called. There was a quote from her diary about how she had breath left.
58:32 That was the one that you know they're trying to save it just oh it just it gave me chills. Captain Purrington himself lay on the floor of the outer room, his throat cut with a razor, dead by his own hand. Jesus, fuck, dude, couldn't you've just done that? Yeah? I hate I hate murder suicide. People like just fucking kill yourself. Yeah. Family annihilators are like, I don't want to sound crazy here, but they are a huge fucking bummer. Martha Ballard and her husband walked to the Purenton house themselves before sunrise. That next morning. The bodies of the deceased Purenton family were carried to Jonas Ballard's barn, washed and laid out side by side. Martha Ballard wrote that many hundreds of persons came to behold the scene, a detail that captures something kind of important about how this tragedy was experienced by their broader community. It's not just, you know, this private tragedy and grief, but it's kind of a mass public event and almost immediately. I mean again, it's a very small town, even kind of by eighteen oh six terms, so everybody knew each other. This is I mean,
1:00:02 it's got to be devastating for a lot of people that knew this family. Martha Purenton, the daughter, pulled from the house, still breathing, lingered at the Ballard house for roughly three weeks under Martha Ballard's own care. Sadly, she died at three am on July thirtieth, eighteen oh six. That's the death that was on my due date. And I was like, shit, this has kind of a weird link to both of these synchronicities with important dates in our lives. Yeah, oh, poor baby, I know. But I mean, god, those three weeks were probably so horrific.
1:00:45 Martha Ballard recorded the moment in her diary in exactly those terms. Martha Purenton expired, and she's got it in kind of old timey shorthand, but at three am, essentially what it says. The funeral took place the following day, on July tenth, Reverend mister Stone offered a prayer, and a reverend mister Taylor delivered a sermon drawn from Proverbs twenty five twenty eight. He that hath no rule over his own spirit is like a city broken down and without walls. Given what the town had just witnessed, I feel like that that particular I'm not a fan strictly speaking of scripture, but that one kind of feels like it makes sense.
1:01:39 Yeah, it does. Martha Ballard described a genuinely staggering public turnout. A stage was erected in front of the meetinghouse, the surrounding houses were crowded with onlookers, the street was packed, and in her own words, ye, tops of buildings covered with peace people. Wow, that's where i'd want to be. Yeah, I think in a way, you know, they're just the reverence and respect that you know, was inherent in society at that point. It makes sense. And it was such a small town, but you know, for a town of Augustus size in eighteen oh six, it was such a monumental event. It was an event on a scale that nothing else that most of them had seen, certainly recently, if ever, would have matched it.
1:02:35 It just and they can't go home and like watch it on TV. Yeah, true, there is nothing on TV. Captain Purington's body was laid out in the porch of the meetinghouse, separated from his family. I mean kind of significant. I mean yeah, literally physically denied entry into the building where his family was, you know, for lack of a better term displayed. I think that's fitting. The axe and razor he had used were displayed on top of his coffin. Oh yikes. His wife and six children's remains were laid in the aisle inside. The funeral procession crossed the Kennebec Bridge, turned up the hill, came down Second Street, passed the jail, and arrived at the burial ground where Elizabeth and her children were buried together. James Purenton was interred separately outside the consecrated cemetery walls ha his murder weapons buried alongside him.
1:03:43 WHOA, yeah, they. Were big into symbolism. Apparently. A coroner's story of eleven local men, with John Evelyth serving as foreman, formally found that Purenton had end quote of his mallee a forethought, murdered his wife and children that he had as a felon quote voluntarily killed and murdered himself. That second part feels a little redundant. But for three weeks, as we know, Martha Purenton clung to life at the Ballard house. Martha Ballard's diary tracks her decline almost literally, like, if not hour by hour, day by day. Her funeral took place two days later, on August first, which, as you certainly and maybe some people listening will recall, is my wedding anniversary.
1:04:37 So no one's getting out of this unscathed. Geez dude. It's just weird, like all of these important dates. And I picked them because I was like, oh, what if I did something? Be me? Yeah, and then the theme got really out of control. Okay, next year for my birthday. No murder, Okay, no sad child murders, even the worst what's wrong with you? I didn't think that they were. They didn't look that bad with like the short summary when I first found the cases and I was like, oh, it's our coin toss city and it started cute anyway. Martha Ballard closed her account of the entire ordeal with a line that needs I would argue no embellishment. I attended the funeral of Martha Purenton, who came to her end by the wounds which her father gave her. Oh the dreadful scene.
1:05:41 Nearly two hundred and twenty years later, it's hard to improve on that as a closing thought. Oh the dreadful scene, Like seriously. Yeah, sums it up. Why did he write that letter? Then saying like what to do with his kids. I don't. That's kind of another parallel with both of these stories. It's like these kind of inexplicable actions on the part of the perpetrator. It's just like. What maybe he was just like thinking that at first he would just take himself out, and then he's like, eh, why not just do them all? I mean, maybe part of him thought that would be cruel to abandon them. I don't know. Obviously, what he did do was horrific. In the days that followed, survivors and relatives of the Puritan family, James Junior and Hezekiah, Captain Purrington's brother, boarded at the Ballard house while they sort it through the wreckage of the family's affairs. Martha Ballard herself helped prepare burial Linen's, carried supplies between households, and continued tending to the dying Martha Purenton in her own home. The same woman who had shared tea and traded herbs with his family for my I mean, arguably, like very close small town bonds, was now the one washing their bodies and nursing the gravely injured child left behind after the tragedy. James Junior, the family's only true
1:07:15 survivor chose Elias Craig, the same man who had served as coroner, to be his legal guardian. Hezekiah Purenton was made administrator of his late brother's estate. Record show Hezekiah continued paying for James's board as late as July eighteen oh seven, a full year after the murders. By eighteen eleven, land records place James back in the family's hometown, the one that they had left six years prior to everything that had happened. There's no record of him ever marrying, which is kind of sad because I feel like that's unusual for the time.
1:08:00 I mean, he's got some trauma. But lots of traumatized people still got married because that was just what you did. Yeah, I don't know. Within days, a broadside titled Horrid Murder was printed in Augusta by local publisher Peter Eddies, A graphic, heavily bordered, single page bulletin featuring woodcut images of coffins lined up side by side by size, presumably representing the victims. The story spread fast and far for pre telegraph era. It reached newspapers along the entire East Coast and reportedly overseas as well. The Portland Gazette ran its own account on July fourteenth, just days after the murders. The leading popular theory regarding the motive was hereditary insanity, of vague sort of era appropriate term. It's a way of saying that mental illness ran in Puritan's family, which actually several modern accounts do confirm that was documented. Interesting others pointed to religious confusion or fanaticism, though he was never explicitly described as a religious extremist or a fanatic by anyone who knew him. In fact, they said, like he was pretty
1:09:32 cash about like religion and spiritual beliefs and stuff. So and like, why would that make you kill? I mean it wouldn't be the first or the last, but I. Meant, like, other than for unless your whole family you think is like sinners? I guess right, which every I mean, Hey, the Puritans thought everyone was a sinner and we were all just seconds away from the burning hell fire. But we're already there, yeah. And there we are. Financial ruin from the drought is the most consistently cited practical trigger, and it lines up with Purenton's own documented fears about being able to provide for his family and their future. This was not a man who snapped in a single moment of rage. He sharpened the acts ahead of time. I mean, within hours of the murders. He sat reading scripture. By all appearances, very calmly, very everything about his behavior was deliberate and calm that day, that evening, while his family slept just rooms away. The coroner's jury used the phrase malice a forethought deliberately because it was premeditated. And I would say that's one aspect of this case that feels pretty obvious to me, just based on the information we have. The
1:11:03 honest answer regarding his motive then and now is that no one really knows for certain. As one broadsheet from the time concluded, we have no evidence to lead us satisfactorily to the motives for this barbarous and unnatural deed. Bars I believe the kids say. In twenty nineteen, the Augusta Historic Preservation Commission located the actual site of the Puritan family grave, long since unmarked, and placed a memorial marker there, finally giving the victims a recognized resting place nearly two and a half centuries after.
1:11:46 They were buried. Oh wow, I know, isn't that cool? Local folklore has long claimed that Boden Bowdwin College secretly exhumed Captain Purenton's body from his roadside grave for early medical research, and that's obviously completely unconfirmed. It's a rumor. Honestly, I kind of hope. So though, right, that would be crazy, But like, if you're going to exhume someone might as well be that guy. You know. I'm just saying, there's a song that says, give your life to science, and you know, if the true fits wear the shit out of it Cinderella, And then there's the connection that gives this case it's real staying power.
1:12:36 Martha Ballard's superhistoric Diary and everything that came after it. Over two centuries after she wrote those entries, Historian Laurel Thatcher Ulrich used Ballard's diary as the foundation for A Midwife's Tale, which won the Pulitzer Prize for History in nineteen ninety one and was laid adapted into a PBS American Experience documentary WHOA. I want to watch it. I know, isn't that cool? Can you imagine being a midwife in the eighteen hundreds? I can't imagine being one now in like oh no.
1:13:17 Like her career was like the seventeen fifty sixties to like eighteen the early aughts of the eighteen hundreds, like what an entire chapter of that book is devoted to the Puritan murders. This small town main tragedy from eighteen oh six has improbably already been the subject of serious prize winning historic scholarship. That's kind of. Cool, think goodness, she like kept such good diary entries. Seriously though, Two families, two colonial Maine towns, seventy two years apart on the same lie date. One story ends with a native woman indentured and enslaved by circumstance, literally walking two miles to confess what no one had caught her doing. The other ends with a respected farmer who planned his family's deaths for days, maybe weeks, while sharpening in acts and reading scripture by candlelight. Both stories survived because someone close to them wrote them down, and in both cases it's worth asking who that someone was and what they wanted the story to mean. Two ministers shaping Patience Boston into a redemption narrative arc for their congregation.
1:14:44 A midwife grieving in literal real time writing down exactly what she saw. Two very different kinds of witnesses, separated by decades, seventy two years, still reaching us today. If you're ever in Portland, Maine, our sibling city on the other coast, York's Old Jail and the Puritan families marked grave near Augusta are both still there, still standing, still telling the same two stories they've been telling since seventeen thirty four and eighteen o six. The history Happy birthday, mey. I do love history, though, so yeah, I like that part of it. But it's just sad.
1:15:35 It's horrifically sad. I really truly did not know that both of these cases were going to be quite as heinous and dark as they were. But the fact that. Like, there's so many aspects of I mean, we talked about like indigenous culture, we talked about like what slavery and colonial times, what you know, these aspects of religion, all of these different things that affected people living in America in this like broad swath of almost one hundred years. We covered a lot of ground, Yeah, we did. If nothing else, Yeah, they're both really interesting cases. And I did start to feel a little bit better when I was personally victimized with you know, my own invent dates included.
1:16:31 So I just thought these are both such interesting, bizarre, truly sad, but just such interesting stories. And you know, I think sometimes we get caught up thinking that so much has changed, or you know, the circumstances of today are nothing like you know this or that, and it's like, I don't know, part of me thinks, you know, the more things change, the more they stay the same in a weird way. I don't know. I hope that means. No, but you know what I think. I mean, I know, yeah, I feel like now everything's documented on like social media, like that's people's diaries now it is.
1:17:18 I just thought these were really interesting stories, and I found like the most bizarre and I don't know, sort of tangential ways to kind of tie all of this together. I definitely feel like Charlie Day in front of the corkboard, like I need a lot of the red string, very much my usual, but then also just the historical aspect of it and kind of getting to see things from a different perspective. I mean, how about that, like at the very beginning, Petty Grove and Lovejoy ever heard of them? I know right, just saying, and they were both from Maine and Massachusetts, and now we know that Maine used to be part of Massachusetts. Like, I feel like we learned a lot knowledge bomb.
1:18:11 Should we try to, like maybe learn a little more with some taro? Some taro? Yeah, wonder what kind of vibes we're gonna get? Oh boy, wow, all right, what are you thinking? I don't know. I feel like I have an idea. But yeah, you pickle, I'm guiding your hands from this side. Oh you got the mole? Yeah, two of swords. It's a coast mole. It is moll. All right. Oh wow, I turned right to it. That's crazy. Oh I just realized my working title for this episode is two deaths one date or some variation there are ooh, I.
1:19:02 Didn't even think about the two that we got two of sorts. Obviously more than two people died, unfortunately. But yeah, but you talk about two event two to two. Yeah, and you kept saying two events, two events. Yeah. Okay. So our keywords are combined resources, courage, faith, friendship, conflict, and balance. In the traditional deck, this card depicts a blindfolded woman holding two swords crossing over her chest. Twos generally signify balance or conflict as well as pairing. I think if the two of swords as the blind faith card because it can represent courage and making decisions on your own and in some cases spiritual guidance, which is interesting because I feel like there's an element of like spirituality with both of these cases. There is the upper right to can symbolize balancing the right and left hemispheres of your brain. It's interesting that we talk about balancing your brain.
1:20:09 Yeah, there are some imbalances with these two. I think so combining intuition with intellect, Drawing this card may mean you must make a decision and need to call on both. This too, can. Also advise you to take off your blindfold and look at a situation honestly. In a reading about money, the upright too recommends trusting your own wisdom and inner guidance in a financial matter, pay attention to your intuition as well as logic. That's interesting that you talk about like intuition because you said that he like had like intuition that he.
1:20:49 Was going to die. Yeah. Yeah. If the reading is about your job, you may be confused or conflicted about a work related issue. Have faith than your own judgment and ideas. Sometimes the upright too represents a job that requires both intellect and imagination. In a reading about love, this card suggest listening to both your head and your heart. It can mean you and your partner hold conflicting perspectives, or that you're trying to resolve differences and find harmony. I mean the balance piece of it, and that it like literally talks so much about like kind of the two sides of the of the coin, so to speak, with like the head and the heart and its soords.
1:21:37 Yeah, I know that these people were just kind of like listening to a part of them but not really like seeing. Maybe the whole picture. Like how you could you don't have to kill your family just because you're in debt. Or right, Yeah, I mean, please don't. In fact, if you could not, that would be so great. Well, on that note, I think we better wrap this up. We've got we've got some antsy dogs on both ends of this recording. Like that's that's it, they said, all done, all done. Well, hopefully I can get a quiet second to say goodbye.
1:22:22 That'd be nice. Oh there's deer in the yard. Oh it's so cute. Well, now I'm not letting you fools out. Yeah, obviously have a creepy day. We'll see you next Thursday. Unless you. Ax, murder your family or throw a kid in a well, like, don't come back then. I just feel like we just yeah, just maybe don't. That's terrible. Nobody do that. I feel like it goes without saying. I almost feel like by saying don't do it, it's like we're giving people ideas, you know what I mean.
1:23:06 No, No, we would never, they would never think to do that. Don't. No, but for real, like, hopefully everyone's doing okay, check your mental health. Yeah, that feels like that particular sentiment feels kind of on point for us. Right now, right, I'll go check mine health and look at some deer on the grass. I know they're so cute. I'm so jealous. My allergies have been kind of kicking up for me. So Jesus Christ Christ, Oh my god, excuse me. I'm about to become part three of this episode. I just in my peripheral was like, there is a man outside my window. Yeah, she's sot on. We're almost done.
1:24:02 But
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Goodpods
Amazon Music
Castro
RSS Feed