Welcome to our new website!
Aug. 12, 2025

The Disappearance of Melanie Ethier

The Disappearance of Melanie Ethier
The Disappearance of Melanie Ethier
PNW Haunts & Homicides
The Disappearance of Melanie Ethier

We’re taking a short break and using this time to amplify the voices of other creators we love in the true crime space. This week we’re bringing you a story from Alecia - host of Truly Twisted (AND Twisted & Uncorked)! Follow the show @itstrulytwisted on Instagram and @trulytwisted on TikTok as well as the host @littleleesha.

On September 29, 1996. Just after 2am, in the quiet Ontario town of New Liskeard, 15‑year‑old Melanie Ethier vanished while walking home from her friend's house. Tune in for the baffling story and the theories surrounding her disappearance.

Visit our website! Find us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Patreon, & more! If you have any true crime, paranormal, or witchy stories you'd like to share with us & possibly have them read (out loud) on an episode, email us at pnwhauntsandhomicides@gmail.com or use this link. There are so many ways that you can support the show:BuyMeACoffee,Spreaker,or by leaving a rating & review on Apple Podcasts.

For more information about the show or Fire Eyes Media you can visit our website at https://www.fireeyesmedia.com & don't forget to check out our other incredible shows while you are there.

Resources used in this episode:
https://www.ctvnews.ca/northern-ontario/article/still-missing-melanie-ethier/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Melanie_Ethier
https://www.cbc.ca/listen/cbc-podcasts/1018-the-next-call/episode/15848324-the-case-of-melanie-ethier-episode-1
https://www.northbaynipissing.com/news/new-info-prompts-search-of-north-cobalt-in-25-year-old-melanie-ethier-case/article_50bff8d5-9fa6-5398-af40-6339c853fa14.html

0:03 Fireeyes Media. On September twenty ninth, nineteen ninety six, just after two am in the quiet Ontario town of New Liscard, fifteen year old Melanie Etier left her friend's house and started the six block walk to her own home. This was a walk that she did often, but this time she manashed, leaving her family with unanswered questions and unimaginable loss.

0:44 Hello and welcome to another episode of Truly Twisted. As always, I'm your host, Alicia Watson, and every Thursday, I will be bringing you a story that is always victim focused and fact based. Today we will be talking about the disc appearance of Melanie Ettier. Melanie Ettier was born on Christmas Day, nineteen eighty to her mother, Seln. Unfortunately, her dad wasn't really in the picture. From what I understand, he lived in Botswana and he and Seln met while he was attending school in a neighboring town from her. He was relocated back home after his schooling was complete.

1:24 Seln was a great mother though, raising Melanie and her sister Jesse in New Liscard in Ontario. The family moved there when the girls were just six and five years old. Melanie was always very maternal and protective towards her sister. This was a very small, close knit community with about forty four hundred people. Melanie and her sister Jesse were two of only four black girls living in the community as well, so that raised challenges for the young teens at times. Melanie was an honor student at Saint Marie Catholic Second and she worked at the attached daycare. They would open early in the mornings and be open later after school, and Melanie loved working there because she wanted to be a teacher when she graduated. She had a good heart and she was close with her family. Her friends described her as being the salts of the earth.

2:19 On Saturday, September twenty eighth, Melanie was hanging out with one of her best friends. The two girls spent the afternoon running errands together. They had lunch at Pizza Pizza and dreamed of what their futures would look like, talked about their goals. They also went to the home of one of Melanie's babysitting jobs to pick up her payment for the last two sits that she did. The next day, the family was hosting a birthday party for Melanie's grandmother, and she was planning on getting up early for work the next day and then making her grandma's cake before the party. Part of the girl's errands that day was picking up all of the ingredients for that as well as a gift for her. While out and about, the girls ran into Neil Fortier, Melanie's boyfriend, and a few of his friends. The group all made plans to rent a movie and watch it together. There was a video rental place close to Melanie's house, so they suggested that they watch it over there. She just had to check with her mom first. They stopped at the video store between nine and nine thirty pm and rented Sudden Death.

3:27 They then walked to her place and Melanie asked her mom if it was okay for them to watch the movie there. Melanie's grandmother was over visiting and her room was crazy messy and she had to clean it before she could have any friends in there, so her mom suggested that maybe they go to one of the other teens homes this time around. The group then made their way from Melanie's and se Lynne watched her daughter walk away with her friends for the last time. That was the last time that she would see or hear from Melanie. It has been twenty eight years since she disappeared, and her mom still fights for her story to get out there in hopes of answers. Someday, someone always knows something.

4:12 At around ten PM, they arrived at the home of Ryan Chatwin, one of Neil's friends, to watch the movie. This was about six blocks from Melanie's house. The teens watched the movie in the basement of the home and Ryan's parents were upstairs. No drugs or alcohol were consumed by any of the teens that night, And I just feel like this is important to mention because I would never want there to be theories that stray too far when it comes to Melanie's disappearance. One of Neil's friends and the girlfriend that Melanie had gone there with had to leave before the movie ended in order to catch a ride. Her friend was going to get a ride home from Melanie's grandmother and left between twelve thirty am and one am. She noted following Melanie's disappearance vicious vehicle as she crossed the street. It approached her slowly, and it immediately made her feel panicked, like it was assessing her or something because it was dark and there were headlights on, she couldn't see the driver. She raced the six blocks to Melanie's home and got her ride with her grandmother. She is believed to have taken the same route that Melanie would have. The vehicle she encountered has been described as a white or light colored Chevrolet Monte Carlo or similar two door model, with signs of being in poor condition, including a gray patch on the side which was likely hiding a hole or some other damage.

5:42 Another woman had reported an unsettling interaction with the same vehicle hours earlier, when she was walking her dog and the car pulled over to ask for directions. She felt very uneasy and her dog began barking viciously as they rapidly drove off. At around from two am on September twenty ninth, Melanie left to make her way home and begin the short walk. Like I said, this was a walk that she had done before. She was very familiar with these streets. Melanie's route would have taken her through three intersections, over the Armstrong Bridge, past a gas station and apartment building, up a back alley or along a main road, and then finally to the top of Church Street, where the Ethier residence was located. The last stretch of her route past the bridge would have been poorly lit, but there was a full moon that night, believed to have providing a little bit of natural light, but there were no street lights along that back road where the video store was located by her house. Se Lynne was woken up the next morning at six am when she heard Melanie's alarm clock going off in her room, but the alarm never stopped. When she went into check on her, she was not in her room. She didn't panic right away because it wasn't uncharacteristic of Melanie to spend the night sleeping at a friend's house if it was too late, so she turned off the alarm and went back to sleep until around nine am. At ten am, Melanie's grandparents

7:14 arrived for her grandmother's party, and when Melanie still didn't return home, they started to worry. Selyn and Melanie's grandfather drove to the tim Hortons to purchase the cake and ask around about Melanie. Seln learned that Melanie had left Ryan's house that night before, and she was filled with dread. She had also not shown up for her babysitting job earlier that morning. Selynn then reported her daughter as missing at one pm with the New Liscard Police. Local police requested the assistance of the Ontario Provincial Police in the earlier days of the search, bringing in a helicopter, a police dog team, and search and rescue. They searched everywhere, ground and air. And what's even more unsettling is that there was no direction, lead, or scent of her with the dog teams. It's like she simply vanished into thin air.

8:12 Police checked surveillance videos along Melanie's likely route, and friends and neighbors were interviewed extensively. By October eighth, an underwater search and rescue team began a three day search of the Wabi River between the Armstrong Bridge that she would have crossed and the lake that I fed into. According to the Ettier family, a single item may have been recovered by police on the first day of the search, but it was never made public. Melanie had no reason to leave the community and foul play was absolutely suspected in her disappearance. Selina and volunteers from the community distributed posters in New Liscard and communities as far as Timmins, Ottawa, and even Montreal and Quebec. Despite these efforts, sadly, the search went cold, but eyewitness statements do confirm that she at least made it to the north end of the bridge on her walk. In twenty twenty one, an anonymous tip came in, leading the police team to Laroque Field, which was roughly ten kilometers from Melanie's last location, but nothing was recovered or noted as relevant in the search.

9:27 Selyyn considers North Cobalt Cemetery to be the most likely spot where Melanie's body could be buried. As one of the suspects. Dennis Labell worked for the cemetery and was very familiar with the surrounding areas. So let's get into suspects and theories. There are three viable theories in my opinion when it comes to Melanie's disappearance. She was abducted on her way home, either by a stranger or a local. But a stranger seems more possible as there was three weddings happening in town that weekend, with celebrations happening just a street over from Ryan's house. Somebody, maybe a little too drunk, saw her walking home and decided to take advantage of her. The highway off ramp was also right near the main street that she would have walked down.

10:19 If somebody grabbed her, it would have been easy to disappear into the night, which is truly haunting. Dennis LaBelle was in a long term relationship with Sullyn's best friend, Sylvie Chartrand. Sylvie had a sixteen year old daughter who was also friends with Melanie and her sister Jesse. The day after Melanie was reported missing, her grandmother had a relatively unnerving encounter with Dennis and went down to the basement to smoke a cigarette in Melanie's home. This was already weird because he had never gone down there and Celine didn't allow smoking in her house. He told the person who harmed her granddaughter would have to have been very strong, as she was capable of defending herself, showing her deep nail marks on his arms, which he said Melanie had made when they were play fighting. At this point, Seln became very suspicious of Dennis, as, according to his own versions of events, he had gone out of town on the friday before Melanie disappeared and only returned after she was reported missing, making it impossible for him to have encountered Melanie when she visited Sylvie's home on the morning of September twenty eighth, that and neither of Sylvie's children had ever reported seeing them playfight. The wounds also looked fairly recent. In the years following these interactions, Celyne distanced her family from Denis over her suspicions. On two occasions,

11:49 he called seln while he was in a hotel room, threatening suicide. On both occasions, she ran to his aid, believing that he was prepared to make some sort of deathbed candes profession about his role in her daughter's case, but he never did. Interestingly, he apparently had a long history of making sexual advances against miners and even served jail time for it. In twenty twenty one, Sylvie admitted that six of her daughter's friends had come forward describing how Dennis had sexually harassed or assaulted them. A friend later told police that on one occasion, when Denis Leavell had spotted an unfamiliar black girl in town, he commented that he had an affinity for quote unquote black chocolate.

12:34 On one occasion around two thousand, Dennis Leavell followed one of his daughter's friends into the sun room of his house and told the girl that he wanted her to experience an orgasm, which is so disgusting. And years later, Dennis was briefly jailed for sexually assaulting one of his daughter's friends in the family home while everyone was asleep, but he was acquitted in court and released, which like why. In twenty fourteen, Dennis Lavelle was sentenced to serve time in prison after pleading guilty to a similar offense, and he was released after several months. On multiple occasions, he lured teenage girls to a hotel room, often telling them that he needed a babysitter for a fictional child. Around ten years after Melanie disappeared, Dennis lard her younger sister, Jesse, with a similar trick. Dennis's father had recently died, and he offered Jesse to do some cleaning for his mother's house that afternoon, but instead he drove her to a hotel on the outskirts of New Liscard. He coaxed her inside with this imaginary cleaning job, and Dennis locked the door and consumed cocaine strip naked, made sexual comments towards her, sat on the bed used the hot tub for about four hours while Jesse was just pretending to text on her phone and avoid his advances. Jesse had plans to meet her boyfriend at around two forty five that day and finally convinced Dennis to let her leave, which is

14:08 smart because you know, if she's meeting somebody and she doesn't show up, that makes him look bad, so he really had no other choice. But she completely cut ties with him and the whole family after this incident, which convinced her that he definitely had a role in her sister's disappearance. One woman known only in the media as Josephine interviewed for the podcast called The Next Call in that she stated that Dennis had come to Sudbury and arranged for her to babysit for his girlfriend at a remote hotel, but confessed that it was a lie while driving there, and then spent the next two hours commenting on her body while drinking heavily. According to Josephine, Dennis later spread rumors that they had sex that night, and his behavior led her to believe that he was responsible for assaulting Melanie Ettia, saying that she may have had a similar interaction with Dennis and violently fought back if she rejected him. In twenty twelve, Dennis arranged for a teenage girl to babysit his granddaughter, which she found to be a lie. When she arrived at the hotel room, he again made sexual advances, and the girl later pressed charges.

15:23 This eventually made him serve time in prison for the offense. While in prison, Selne visited him and directly asked about his involvement in her daughter's case. He denied any involvement, and sadly, he died of a stroke in twenty sixteen before any confession could be pulled from him. And while Dennis seems like a viable theory, there are other theories about Melanie possibly being mistaken for another girl in town when she was attacked, or maybe the victim of a serial killer. Today, Melanie would be forty three years old and she was last seen wearing a green Nike jacket, blue jeans, a white T shirt with a pepe logo and a blue heart, and black boots. Melanie was described as five five and one hundred and twenty pounds. Roughly, she's a black female with brown eyes and long braided black hair. The Ontario Provincial Police say that the case will never be closed until it is solved, and that they would like to remind the public that even the smallest detail could have a significant impact. Any person with any information regarding the disappearance is asked to contact them at one eight eight eight three, one zero one one two two or seven oh five three two nine six one one one, their nearest police authority or crime stoppers anonymously reward money climbed from two thousand dollars to fifty

16:58 thousand dollars over the years for any information that could possibly lead to Melanie's recovery. There are two billboards along Highway eleven that still ask you know what happened to me, so why don't you help? I truly hope that someone is able to help one day. While her mother believes that it is very unlikely that Melanie is still alive today, she still deserves justice and her family deserves answers. And I do hope that you enjoyed this week's story. If you like the show, don't forget to leave me five stars wherever you are listening now. It really is the best way to help me reach new audiences, and it means so so much to me. If you have a case, suggestion, or something that you would like me to cover, please email me at Alicia at fireeyesmedia dot com or feel free to message me on social media. I will see you next week for another episode. And in the meantime, remember are wanted, you are loved, and you deserve to be here, and I will see you next week. Truly Twisted is a proud production of Fireeyes Media, a woman owned and operated network. This show is hosted, researched, and edited by me, Alicia Watson, and I would love if you would email me any case, suggestions or comments you may have at Alicia at fireeysmedia dot com. Fireeyes Media