The Dark Strangler, Every Landlady's Nightmare | Part 2: Earle Nelson | Portland, Oregon
Part 2 follows Nelson to Iowa, Kansas City, Philadelphia, and Buffalo where he would continue his brutal crimes. His final ten days would become the most violent stretch of the entire spree — five women killed across Detroit, Chicago, and Winnipeg between June 1st and June 10th, 1927. It's Winnipeg where the trail finally catches up with him, thanks to a jeweler, a barber, and a citywide search of boardinghouses.
We follow Nelson's arrest, trial, and eventual execution — hanged on Friday, January 13th, 1928 at the Vaughan Street Jail, becoming the 13th person to hang there, after walking 13 steps to the gallows. His confirmed count of over twenty victims would stand as a horrifying record in America for nearly fifty years.
Visit our website! Find us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Patreon, & more! There are so many ways that you can support the show: BuyMeACoffee, Spreaker, or by leaving a rating & review on Apple Podcasts. Sources
0:00 Every single one of his victims fits the biblical definition of a quote unquote strange woman. Women running boarding houses or showing properties without the oversight of a man, whether they were unmarried or widowed, women who were basically just managing their own affairs, Like can you even imagine that audacity? The exact demographic he was hunting is the very same one the passage warns men to be fearful of. That's not scripture. It's a hit list with a theological alibi. Hi, Cassie, Hi, Caitlyn, Hi, creepy people. Oh hello, Hey, this is PNW Hanson Homicide to where we chat about true crime, the paranormal and.
0:56 Lots of spooky stuff in the Pacific Northwest or the p and W. If you're nice, nice you forgot to say it last episode. Oh I know, I forget like it's honestly, it's far and feun in between when I actually remember of my own accord, It's okay, but you know, I try get it. They'll get the nasty when they get it exactly well, I'm you know what, They're gonna get it today, and they're going to get the long way to tarot reading. Because this is parts two and normally we do a taro reading in every episode of the show, but this particular topic has turned into decidedly a two part, two part series, so we are we save the tarot reading for today.
1:51 Yeah, yep, so looking forward to that. Stick around little something to look forward too, or just. Skip right to it. Oh well, just listen to that. If all you're interested in is the tarot. That would be so interesting if people were like not interested in the actual like content of the case, they just wanted to hear us read the tarot. Yeah, but we read the tarot about technically about the topic, so like you're gonna have to know what's going on because we will reference exactly. Yeah. I feel like otherwise it doesn't really make sense. Yeah, but you know, do you.
2:35 Unless you're just taking the readings for yourself. I mean you could do that too, Yeah yeah, whatever, you float your boat man, all right. So I'm going to jump in exactly where we. Left off to the Midwest. Yeah. I was gonna say, I am so proud of you for remembering. Thank you. It was only like ten minutes ago. I know for some people it's been week, but for us, it's only been a few minutes. But you know, we were known to be a little bit gold fishy. So I don't know. Patreon, maybe if you're nice, if you're good, if you're good for girls and boys, maybe we'll give you two parts at once. Oh you don't have to wait.
3:18 Yeah, and there is a Patreon bonus for this episode too, So say. Good things could be in store, santable see if you're on the not on your nice list. Yeah, it's too late for Christmas in July, but you know it's still summer. Yeah, and as we pick this up, we are picking the story up right around Christmas time. So, and Christmas is in our hearts all year, don't you know? Exactly, just like Halloween two days before Christmas. Our not so lovely character here he garrotted. Forty one year old Almera Berrard of Council bluffs Iowa with a shirt in her own home.
4:08 I don't know why I had a physical reaction to that word. You know, garat is not a pleasant one. My body like jumped. I didn't like it. No, you know, as it turns out, I don't think that anyone does yet again, and I'm not sure I'll ever quite grasp how this kept happening. Her death was presumed a suicide initially. What what? Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, it happens in a few of these cases. Though I will say of all of the cases where this does pop up, it's perhaps the most justified because this was due to her recent discharge from a psychiatric institution. However, obviously the sexual assault findings would dispel that misguided theory.
4:57 So yeah, I was kind of thinking that last time. I forgot to ask, like, it doesn't that did they not examine the other bodies that they thought were suicides and find like sexual assault? Yeah? I mean, I think eventually whether it was theft or that the body was examined more closely and they realized there were signs of like a struggle or sexual assault. You know, those are kind of even back then one hundred you know, one hundred years ago as of recording, those things did tend to jump out, and it would sort of move them in their right direction in terms of the investigation. Thankfully, it seems, at least for this killer, a break for the holidays, likely for practical reasons alone, was due, though it wouldn't last for long. Two days after Christmas, Nelson murdered his youngest victim to date at the time, Bonnie Pace of Kansas City, Missouri, twenty three years old.
6:02 Wow, that is quite young, yes, compared. Yeah, I mean compared to the majority of his victims, very very young. The following day, December twenty eighth, while still in Kansas City, Nelson marked another horrifying first. He killed Germania harpin twenty eight as well as her eight month old son, Oh my god, strangling him with a diaper. What. Yeah, I mean remember at this point in history, like you're using cloth diapers too, so you know, the visual is different than you know in twenty twenty six, but horrifying. Nonetheless, it's just so eerie because like a diaper, Yeah, I don't know, it like takes care of the baby, Like it's a symbol of like a baby, like it is to use that and it doesn't feeling it should be a weapon.
7:02 Yeah yeah, I mean, well sometimes some babies do make it a weapon, right. But right what they're blasting into the diaper, Yeah, like that diaper you know, yeah, no, I totally get it, but yeah, I mean in this context, it's just very it is disturbing. I mean, it's disturbing because obviously it's an infant, but then just something about. That visual is so unsettling. Their bodies were discovered by mister Harpin, husband and father to the victims, respectively, when he returned home that evening from work.
7:44 Robert is the. Only male and only true child victim in the confirmed victim list. And I think it was just about opportunity most likely. Yeah, he was just like in the way. Yeah, I mean, he just happened to be there. Still, it seems unnecessary to have killed him. Obviously, what the he're gonna do? He can't say anything. He's not a witness, he's not power to remember this, like cognitively, but obviously this is about what he wanted. It wasn't necessarily a killing that occurred for any disgusting obviously say this, but.
8:27 The worst thought he was probably crying, Yeah, like the. Baby unclear like which of them died first. But yeah, no, I mean that was kind of the same thought that I had, Like you might do that because what you don't want is a crying baby potentially drawing attention. Yeah, very sad, I mean, and think about that. This is three days after Christmas and your wife and it didn't say anything else about there being other children in the home, So presumably your wife and your only child, your firstborn son, are murdered three days after Christmas. Like, I don't know how you go on to have anything resembling a normal life after that. Following this crime, Nelson went dormant for nearly four months exactly, though it's clear that in that time he had navigated further east, landing in Philadelphia, where he killed his next victim on April twenty seventh of nineteen twenty seven, fifty three year old Mary McConnell. He stole several pieces of her jewelry, attempting to pawn one of her gold watches before being turned away. Though it's not exactly clear why the proprietor, Mary ke decline the transaction.
10:02 I'm not sure why she said no, I don't want it. That is interesting, Yeah, just an interesting aside. I guess maybe because he gives creepy vibes and she's like, this is. Clearly a woman's watch or whatever. It was like, yeah, I don't know, how did you get this? And maybe he couldn't come up with like a good answer. I mean, it would be interesting to know more and kind of pull it that thread, like did she immediately like report something to the authorities, And that's how it was determined that like, oh yeah, this is this is him? Or is this something that we only learned kind of in hindsight, I don't really I.
10:44 Don't have. Like that detailed of information on Well, I'm disappointed in you. Well, it's just interesting to think about, like maybe it is. Yeah, And to be honest, like some of this, even if I had tried to kind of like pull at these like specific little threads at the case, it's like the case is already like one hundred years old, and there's certain information that it's just like if it doesn't already exist publicly somehow like there, it's unlikely that I would ever be able to get that information. You know, yeah, if it wasn't already reported in a newspaper or you know, if somebody hadn't already yeah, whatever the channel would be.
11:32 It's just now that's kind of lost to time a little bit. Again. In Buffalo, New York, just about a month later, on May thirtieth, nineteen twenty seven, Nelson killed fifty three year old Jenny Randolph, from whom he had rented a room three days earlier under the alias Charles Harrison, her brother Gideon Gilley, had met him and described him as about thirty three years old with a stocky build, dark complexion, and black hair slicked straight back. Yeah, which, okay, I.
12:18 Picture it greasy. That's why I will about me too. But to expand on that, and this is like kind of one of those moments of levity. Have you ever watched the show? I think you should leave. No, there is a whole bit that he does about you think this is slicked back, and he's talking about like I used to splic my hair back all the time. The whole bit is about like, oh, yeah, I used to be a real piece of shit, slick my hair back. And like all of the scenarios are just like so silly and kind of outlandish, and they're not all equal winners, but that one's a classic. It's a good one. Her body was discovered stuffed under a bed. This is Jenny Randolph.
13:13 Fellow border Fred Merritt later positively identified Nelson as Charles Harrison. Ooh, there's a lot of people that like, even if they weren't directly a witness to the crime, they are witnesses that can testify to like this is the alias he used, and yes, I can positively identify like this is the same man. So yeah, because he's so distinct. I mean, honestly, yeah. No, and his aliases are not very. Clever, but they're better than Clark. I don't know. Maybe where.
13:54 Nelson had previously seemed to be engaged in an escalating spree prior to the new year. His crimes in nineteen twenty seven were initially roughly thirty days apart, but good things never last. In Detroit, Michigan, on June first, he killed two victims for the second time, the bodies of fifty three year old boarding house manager Fannie May and border Marine Atrothe Her maiden name was Oswald. Probably should have just gone with that because the atrothe I'm probably butchering it, is what I'm saying. They were discovered by the building owner, Leonard Sink as he made the rounds to collect rent, which is just I feel like a lot more than he bargained for. But two women.
14:46 Mm hm, oh my gosh. Yeah. May was grotted with an electrical cord cut from a table lamp while the current was still live. Holy Jesus, did he get electrocuted. I mean one would hope, right, Like we should all be so lucky. How does electricity work. Well, here's the thing. It did work in a unique way, in a way that was in the end kind of helpful. Investigators determine the knife used to cut the cord would show burn marks and a nicked blade. Oh okay, we'll just put a pin in that for now.
15:31 I like that. Uh huh, I like where this is going. Only that particular part. But that is so crazy that he like looked around the room and was like, yep, that's the only thing I can like right, and like planning it in your head. Now, these other people don't know what you're thinking, and they just think it's a normal day and all of a sudden, the cord is cut. Yeah, and you're being attacked. It's pretty horrifying, Like it's hard to imagine what would be going through your head at that moment. I'm never leaving my house again, and no one's ever coming in.
16:14 Okay, I was going to say, you know, the thing is a lot of these people were in their homes or coming in. Yeah, no one's invited over vampire rules. Yeah, exactly. You have to be invited. Three days later, on June fourth, Nelson strangled twenty seven year old Mary Cecilia Sietsma of Chicago, Illinois, with an appliance cord. So he kind of goes through like these sort of phases where it's like he's he's liking a specific thing that he's. Finding and using. And I hate that because he does it so often.
16:55 Like yeah, like you can tell there's certain things that it's like he's like, oh this is interesting, or you know, this is I like how this works, or I don't want my head to exist in that space. Her body was discovered by her husband on the floor of their home. Another poor husband. I mean, the good news is that we are nearing the end of the actual spree. Okay, we're getting We're getting We're getting close, sir. Days later, reportedly June eighth of nineteen twenty seven, Nelson was crossing the border into Canada hitching a ride with the Chandler family of Minnesota, Minnesota.
17:52 They described him as well dressed in a blue suit, gray cap, and tan shoes, though he was apparently carrying nothing else, no bible, nothing, That's what they said. Another motorists later reported giving Nelson a ride further on from Emerson, Manitoba to Winnipeg that same day, which is like Jesus fucking Christ, there are two people in their vehicle, like an entire family in the first one that they are so lucky. Do you think he would take out like a whole family, though. I'm not sure that he would have been able to, And I will say that it seems like that is probably from both like a physical like because it is very difficult for like a single attacker to take out an entire family unless they have like just an insane advantage.
18:48 Of course, being confined in a single vehicle is you know, one way that you might be able to accomplish that. But more than anything, I think psychologically I'm not sure that he could have done that, because it really seems that in the cases where there are survivors, you see that like when he's met with even the slightest resistance where they don't do things exactly the way that he wants in order to like carry out his mo o, like he just leaves. Yeah, so I think he could have escalated at some point to that level. I don't think that like, oh, he's just not capable of that kind of evil.
19:35 He I mean, yeah, he definitely is. He he strangled an eight month old baby, like that's not beyond him. But I just don't think that it's in his nature for other reasons, if that makes sense. And was that was there a man in the car too, like a like a mom and dad? And yeah, it sounds like it was a whole family, because I doubt that a woman driving into Canada with her small children would have picked up a lone male hitchhiker, even at this time, right, I just I don't see that many women would have done that. Obviously, it is always a possibility, But yeah, I think that's the other thing is I think there being a man present clearly that changes the dynamics for him. On June eighth, in Winnipeg, Manitoba, fourteen year old Lola Cowan of three University Places, was selling artificial flowers door to door to help support her family.
20:41 Oh Nelson lured her into his rented room at Catherine Hill's boarding house at one thirty three Smith Street. Her body and this goes back to escalation reportedly mutilated in a manner period reports described as reminiscent of Jack the Ripper's victims Oh my god, would not be found for days, and that's really horrifying because she's another one of his like very young victims. It's a level of aggression in violence that he hasn't stereotypically exhibited. So I feel like it does speak to like him. Escalating. Evidence also indicated Nelson slept in the bed above her corpse overnight.
21:30 Ew. Yeah, I mean he doesn't care, no, clearly very unbothered. Later, Nelson was still in Winnipeg when he killed twenty seven year old Emily Patterson of one hundred Riverton Avenue, who, in addition to the strangulation and sexual assault standard to his MO, was also bludgeoned with a clawhammer. Wow, so he's getting pretty violent. Yes, I mean, this is a level of like devastation and destruction to their bodies that we have not seen with his prior victims. Her body was left underneath her young son's bed and discovered by her husband as he knelt at the bedside to say evening prayers.
22:26 Oh my god, that is the worst thing I've ever heard. I know, And it's like it's I don't know, there's something about it where it's like, you know, not all people that are religious, are good people? Like I think we all understand that, but there's something that's it's like such a wholesome image of this man, like kneeling down beside his child's bed to say evening prayers and then that's how he discovers this horrific thing has been done to his wife, and to leave her there underneath her child's bed like.
23:07 That is so gross. It is wrong with him. I know, and for somebody that was just such a fucking nut about religion, it's like. That image is. Just I don't know, it's so unsettling. It's just it's really disturbing. Nelson stole a whipcord suit, Emily's gold wedding ring, the family Bible, and seventy dollars Canadian in. Ten dollar bills. He also left behind a knife bearing burn marks and a nicked blade. Oh, the same distinctive damage that would have been seen on the knife used to cut the electrical cord in the Fannie May murder in Detroit just nine days earlier.
24:07 Holy shit, he's done so much. Yeah, he is doing the absolute most, and I must insist that he just takes several seats. I have to look this up. I never did end up looking up what a whipcord suit was, and I was curious, but I was like, I have so much to do. Oh, it's literally just a man's suit. I don't know why they call it that whipcord a sturdy worsted wool or cotton fabric. Oh, so he took it so he would like have something nice to wear. I guess. So that's what I'm thinking.
24:47 And he got his Bible back. He could be Bible man, I guess. Yeah, he didn't have a Bible when he was crossing the border, apparently, so he took theirs, which is just like fuck you. So, I mean, we kind of touched on this. But the claw hammer was a striking departure from Nelson's otherwise strangulation consistent method, and, together with the mutilation of Lola Cowan two days prior, has been read by later analysts as evidence of psychological deterioration in the final week of the spree. And I may not be a qualified analyst of really almost anything, but I'm inclined to agree for whatever that's worth.
25:34 Right, it sounds right, it sounds right. Yeah, you know what. I can't always find the right mouth words but when I hear them sometimes I'm like, that's. It that resonates. Yeah, there it is, you know what what they said. Yeah. The day after Patterson's murder, Winnipeg jeweler Fred England unknowingly purchased Emily Patterson's wedding ring from Nelson. Later that afternoon, Nelson traded the whipcord suit and other clothing that he had stolen from the Patterson home at Sam Waldman's second hand store. Oh okay, well I was wrong, but whatever what oh I said? He wanted like the nice suit to trick people to like wear it, so he just sold it.
26:21 I kind of thought so too. But maybe he didn't want anything that looked distinctive. Maybe he didn't want anything that was going to like set him apart. So like maybe he wanted to change out his clothes. But what he wanted because it does say trade it, So maybe what he wanted was something that was just like a little bit more run of the mill, right, And he's an opportunist, But also he does a lot of things that like just straight up don't make sense. So I mean, who knows, there's no way to know a barber next door Nicholas taber gave a man matching Nelson's description a shave, haircut, and massage, noticing dried blood and scratch marks on his scalp. When asked about them, the man grew agitated and asked the barber not to touch them.
27:14 I got attacked by a squirrel. Leave me alone. Yeah, don't ask me any questions, and I won't tell you any laughs. On June twelfth, during a city wide search of Winnipeg boarding houses, police entered Catherine Hill's boarding house at one thirty three Smith Street and discovered Lola Cowan's decaying body beneath the bed of the room Nelson had recently occupied. The Winnipeg City Council posted a fifteen hundred dollars Canadian reward for information leading to conviction. The reward would later become a point of dispute as multiple tipsters came forward because of course, I mean there's money involved, so we have to have some sort of bickering. Likely seriously feeling the heat, Nelson fled south by hitchhiking and stowing away on trains aiming for the United States border.
28:12 On June fourteenth, a man claiming to be Mike Mouski was arrested at the war Road, Minnesota border crossing by US Customs officers, but escape the next day. Because he who denis that's how he do? Yeah, so does he? Who DD's Mike Mouski. Yeah it's Mickey mouse So Mouseki is spelled Mowski. I think it was meant to sound like an Eastern European name, that's my guess. But then on my mom's birthday June sixteenth, nineteen twenty seven, constables in Killarney, a border town approximately twelve miles from North Dakota, arrested a calm, cooperative man calling himself Virgil Wilson.
29:12 I'm Virgil Wilson. Now. Yeah, his demeanor was so unremarkable that the arresting constables believed they had the wrong man. They were like, this obviously can't be him. He just is like so chill. Oh my god. I know, I don't even know what to say about that. I know. I well, listen, this is long before there was any sort of like precedent for like, okay, we have to stop saying things like oh, he looked so normal like the Boogeyman. He might look surprisingly normal. Yeah, for real. Like, actually, it's incredibly likely he's gonna look just like you are you are you are? You?
29:58 Like, didn't you start off episode one saying this very same thing? Yeah? Interesting, I believe so. Weird, you know what. I am glad someone is paying attention. I try so really this is I mean, it's just such a fun little part of the story here. I know you're gonna be shocked. Nelson escaped the century old Killarney cell that night by picking the lock, but made a fatal mistake when he attempted to board the same train carrying Winnipeg police on the hunt to retrieve him.
30:41 Ah. Shit, the first half is exactly what you think it's gonna be, and then the second half is kind of like the m Night Twist. And I love that. Yeah. I was like, you deserve it. He did. Yeah. So he was recaptured roughly twelve hours after his initials by an officer of the Crystal City, Manitoba Police Department on the rail line seventy five kilometers east of Wakopa. I hope I'm saying that right, but you know, stay stupid, I guess now. I'm just still like picturing him walking into the train and everyone just looks at him and they're all staring at each other like wait, wait that is that the guy?
31:28 Is the guy? Like he's like, ah, there's just no way. Nelson was taken to the Rupert Street Police station in Winnipeg, where he was photographed, fingerprinted, measured, and prepared for identification lineups. Thousands of spectators gathered outside the station. Fun fact about this case, and I hadn't initially included it in my notes, and I think I just was like, I he says, there's so much to research and things to verify and all of that. I read that reportedly up to a thousand Canadian farmers just casually joined search parties that were like on the hunt for him. Oh so thousands of spectators showing up at the police station in Winnipeg when he's like actually recaptured, recaptured like that part, I was like, you know what I that that feels about, right Like at the house, they.
32:34 Were all looking for him, and they're like, yeah. And this was a big fucking deal just in general, and we'll talk about that more later because you know, old timey things and we'll get there. But I just was like, wow, like I love that piece of it. How much people just were like, we got to get this guy. They were really invested. Get this fucking guy out of here. Hey, yeah, get him the fuck out. Sergeant James Hoskins of the Winnipeg Police noted that the clothing Nelson was wearing was the same clothing Sam Waldman had received in trade for the wick Cord suit stolen from the Patterson home, physical evidence tying Nelson directly to the murder scene, so they were able to identify. Like, Okay, so the guy that gave us the stolen clothing from the family, this is what he got in trade and he's wearing it.
33:33 So he should have just taken money and went to a different store. Yep, No, I mean, stay stupid. I love that. I love that the store owner just knows what clothes were his or hers or whatever. Right. Captain Mathison of the San Francisco Police Department personally traveled to Winnipeg with Nelson's fingerprint records from a prior californi Ornia arrest. The prints were a match, and his identity as Virgil Wilson collapsed. By the end of Nelson's first week in custody, more than forty witnesses had identified Nelson either in lineups or from photographs. A lot of people those are cosby numbers.
34:19 Baby him in his big hands and greasy hair. Arguably the most damning was Catherine Hill's positive identification of him as the man who had rented the room in which Lola Cowan died. That'll do it, yep, not older. When first asked about the murders, Nelson bluntly told a reporter, I only do my lady killings on Saturday nights. Oh sir, what he told a dad joke about murder, right, like, ugh, U exqueeze me butthole.
35:01 What an actual anus wow. But of course, he would later retract this and refuse to confess to anything, insisting to the Manitoba Free Press, I'm charged with two murders, but I'm not the one who'd done it, not the one who'd done it. See, I just the dad joke killer god. When asked how so many witnesses in so many cities had identified him, he said, all of them are wrong. I could be anybody. I look like everybody. What do you mean, right? No, I'm sorry, I just like that. Many people I just don't believe are wrong. Also, all of the physical evidence, yeah, duh.
35:51 Within weeks of his arrest. Though he was wanted for murder in several other jurisdictions, including San Francisco, in Detroit, Philadelphia, and Buffalo, just to name a few, it was determined that he would be first tried in Manitoba, which still had the death penalty at that time. Ha ha Yeah. Capital punishment would not be abolished for civilians in Canada until the summer of nineteen seventy six, and for military offenses full abolishment would not come until nineteen ninety eight. So I guess he should have just waited until then to do all of his murdering in Canadia.
36:36 Dummy. Oh well. Nelson's trial was scheduled to begin June twenty seventh of nineteen twenty seven, but was postponed at his attorney's request, finally beginning November one at the Winnipeg Law Courts building. And it looks kneku. Oh yeah. I don't know if the building looks exactly like it did back in nineteen twenty seven, but the picture I saw lekum. The case was prosecuted by R. B. Graham before Justice Andrew Dysert and James Herbert Stitt. I just this so many names serving as this court appointed defense, so Stitt is his defense lawyer. Though Nelson was tried only for the murder of Emily Patterson, fingerprints from other crime scenes were a match, and dental impressions taken at the time of his arrest also matched bite marks found on victims.
37:38 Oo and his hard teeth. Yeah, I didn't you like pick things up with his teeth or something? Yeah, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep. Yeah. That that's something that came up in his life, like pretty early on. So I hate it. Of course, through a modern lends, this specific aspect of forensic odontology has far less credibility than it did at the time, but the mountain of other evidence and statements stacked up heavily against him. So even if you want to. Play Devil's advocate and be like, well, forensic odontologies kind of like especially bite marks, and you know that's.
38:23 Not all they had, so piped out. Investigators had also matched the knife recovered at the Patterson scene with its distinctive burn marks and nicked blade to the knife used to cut the electrical cord that garrotted Fannie May in Detroit physically linking Nelson to crimes he had committed across the international border. Over sixty witnesses from both Canada and the United States testified, many placing Nelson at the scenes of crimes or linking him to stolen property. Nelson's ex wife, Mary Martin, testified against him, calling him absolutely insane, which shit.
39:08 Normally I would. Say that is not a polite thing to say about your grandson's slash husband. But you know, if the shoe. Fits, yeah. Oh. Doctor Alvin T. Mathers, chief of the psychiatric ward at Winnipeg General Hospital, testified that after examining Nelson five times between July and October of nineteen twenty seven, he had quote not found any evidence that to me would constitute insanity. No evidence. I think he means, you know, in the legal sense. Okay. This is not to say that like he's not like what woo, like there's a screw loose. Something ain't right, the boy ain't right, buck.
39:52 Okay, but he can't like plea insanity or whatever. Right, Okay, get it. I'm like, no, he's crazy. What do you mean? You're like it? But he's like so crazy. A jail guard who supervised Nelson throughout the trial, noted that he had become fixated on a passage from the Book of Proverbs and read it aloud repeatedly, which is not at all annoying and obnoxious. Okay, I will read it for you, and then yeah, I will tell you all about why I fucking hate it. Okay, my son, give me thine heart and let thine eyes observe my ways. For a whore is a deep ditch, and a strange woman is a narrow pit. She also lieth in wait as for a prey, and increaseth the transgressors among men. Now, if I were to try to explain that to you in slightly plainar English, I might say something like, every single one of his victims fits the biblical definition of a quote unquote strange woman. Women running boarding houses or showing properties without the oversight of a man, whether they were unmarried or widowed, women who were basically just managing their own affairs, Like, can you even imagine that audacity? The
41:25 exact demographic he was hunting is the very same one the passage warns men to be fearful of. That's not scripture, it's a hit list with a theological alibi. Damn, it's particularly gross textbook victim blaming. The women he murdered were being framed in his deluded mind as the predators because he wasn't stalking them, they were tempting him, like. What was she wearing you? He wasn't strangling them, he was escaping the traps of their feminine wiles. My god, it's honestly the oldest trick in the book, and Nelson didn't invent it. He just baptized it and passed it down to future in cells.
42:22 I hate this so much. I'm That's all I have to say about that is that it Are you sure you done? We have to move on? Yeah? No, I mean I could literally expound for days. I mean the amount of time that I spent on the reflection on that, Like I don't know, four lines of scripture. No, while you're reading it, I was like, did wait did they mean? When I think yeah, and then fancy words are covering up what is the same. Yeah, It's one of those ones where you're like, hold on, no, hold on, I just maybe I'm confused by the thine and I'm sure they didn't mean that. Well, no, they appear to mean just exactly that. Hmmm, No, it's exactly what you think. And obviously part of the problem is the context in which it's being used. But it's pretty I mean, that's a passage that's pretty problematic regardless.
43:24 Take that out of there. Just like, on the face of things, we're just like whorees and you know, ew strange, Like, how about actually go fuck yourself. I'd rather be a strange horror than. Right be one of you. I know, I think I would rather be both a whore and arguably strange. I like that life. Yeah, I think I'm literally about that life. On November fifth, nineteen twenty seven, closing arguments concluded that you're deliberated for forty minutes before returning a guilty verdict because duh. But honestly, when the jury comes back that quickly, it's almost never a good thing for the defendant, just like statistically and anecdotally, I think most lawyers say that. That's what I've always heard, and it's carried through. Nelson received the mandatory death sentence, and I mandatorily Yeah, I don't normally love capital punishment, but I kind of I'm not going to say that.
44:34 I you know, like I kind of love. That for him a little bit. Yeah, yeah, I'm not historically someone that considers themselves a fan, but like I like their latest work. If they're like this clearly guilty and terrible and yeah, just get rid of them, like we don't. Like it could not be any more clear cut. And I'm just like, you know what, the world is now a better place, And I know I normally just don't think that the system gets it correct reliably enough to feel confident about carrying out that sentence. That's my issue. But I mean, somebody wants to argue that this is not the guy. First of all, you're listening to the wrong show because you're Aloney Tune and your name is Clark.
45:28 Yeah yeah, and I think what I think you meant to go to the red pill side of the internet. I don't know, go not wipe your buttthole over there. Oh my god. Oh it makes me so fucking angry, so disgusted. I've been waiting for an opportunity to bring that up again. I know well, and honestly I just didn't want to sound like a crazy feminazi the whole way through, But like that is what this case is giving like in a way, right, because it's just it's just such misogyny. And there's other facets of this case obviously, but like there's a clear hatred of women in this Like there's literally only a single male victim and that was a fucking infant, which is horrific. But like, clearly this is about hating women. Okay, so then this is just fucking weird.
46:29 I I really don't know how else to put it. Asked whether he wished to make a statement after, you know, he's been given his sentence. He responded, no, not that I know of, And it's a weird choice of words. Not that I know of. Uh huh, not that anyone in my head is telling me, right now, I know, So moving on, we don't have anything to say at the moment. I know, I know, did you need to like take a minute, and like I don't take a poll of everybody that's in there, like what or what? And I hate to sound like like I would, you know, make light of anyone with like mental illness, but like at the same time, this is so clearly such a deranged and evil person that it's hurt so many innocent people that I just I'm sorry, I just I can't.
47:26 I mean, it's I think arguably one of, if not. The worst case that I've ever covered. So yeah, there's a lot of women. Two episodes of women, children, and an actual fucking baby, an infant. So excuse me if I. Feel a little bit lase fair about what happens to him at this point, please forgive me. And then she was struck down by lightning? Can you imagine? We have had episodes It's just like not like for anything other than like it just was like cool ambiyonce, but like we've had like thunder lightning like in the background. But like, wow, listen, if that like, if that's my cross to bear, so to speak, then like I'm okay with that, Okay, forging ahead. Stit submitted a thirty page clemency petition to Minister of Justice Earnest Lapointe in late December, supported by twenty affidavits attesting that Nelson had an I quote, for a long period of time, been a person of unsound mind.
48:43 M hm uh huh. Yeah, unsound is a very kind way to put it. Yeah, it mayhaps be a bit generous. Missus L. J. Casey, who had employed him as a groundskeeper in nineteen twenty six described him another quote, sitting right outside in the drenching rain, looking at the sky without a coat until he was soaked through. That's normal. Yeah, I'm not sure which way that supports exactly. I mean, I guess just that he's deeply on Well. Yeah, but the appeal was denied. And here's where we get some super I'm just a little stitious, you know, like the kind of like little synchronicities. The following year, on Friday, January thirteenth, nineteen twenty eight, after walking thirteen steps to the gallows at seven thirty am, Earl Leonard Nelson became the thirteenth person to hang at the Von Street Jail in Winnipeg.
49:55 Ooh, I like all the thirteen? Does that not just give you like the chili willies though? Yeah, that's creepy. The hangman was Arthur Ellis, the official executioner to the Dominion of Canada, which is a hell of a title. Ellis is reported to have described the Nelson hanging as the one he was most satisfied to have officiated. I get that, Yeah, I kind of get that too. Nelson's last words on the platform were and this is so fucking infuriating. I just have to say, I declare my innocence before God and Man. I forgive those who have injured me, and I ask pardon from those I have injured, to which I say, nah, dude.
50:53 But he just said he didn't hurt anybody. He's innocent, So who is he injured? Right? I thought you were innocent? So like what what? Yeah? It's interesting. Widely credited by crime historians Harold Scheckter and David Everett as the first serial sex murderer of the twentieth century in America, Nelson's crimes received widespread national and international coverage, aided by the emerging medium of broadcast radio. Ooh yeahplast news, I know wild times. His trial was reported on across the United States, Canada, and even Australia.
51:40 Damn, Honor, They're like, what the fuck is happening up there? Like these Yanks are out of control over there? Down there. I don't know where Australia is. They're down You're like, I barely know where I am. Is that enough? His confirmed count of twenty two remained the highest number of murders attributed to a single US offender for nearly fifty years until the discovery of Juan Corona's crimes in California in nineteen seventy one. In criminal literature, Nelson is often cited as the archetype of the traveling or transient serial killer, a category that would later include Ted Bundy, Henry Lee, Lucas Ottis, Toole Otis Otis, you know what, who Cares? And Israel Kis. They are all very fucking scary. Serial Killers in general are scary, but like there is something so chilling about those particular individuals for sure. Nelson's case also demonstrates a form of inter state law enforcement cooperation that predates modern institutional structures, such as the FBI's Violent Criminal Apprehension Program known as VISCAP
53:10 that was established in nineteen eighty five. Fingerprint records were physically handcarried by Captain Matheson from San Francisco to Winnipeg to establish Nelson's identity, and Winnipeg police sent Nelson's photograph to police departments throughout the United States, both costly measures that were slow to process compared to, you know, setting an email compared to modern digital methods, though in the end effective enough to generate positive identifications from Illinois and California within days, So like they were doing. The damn thing. They're working together, working together, instead of measuring dicks. Portland is central to Nelson's story to a degree that most national retellings understate. Four of his twenty two confirmed victims were killed in Portland, Beta Withers, Virginia, Grant, Mabel Fluke, and Blanchemier's, making Portland the single city with the highest concentration of nelson murders anywhere on his route, ahead of San Francisco and Kansas City that had three each, and Winnipeg with two confirmed victims. With the Seattle murder of Florence Monks added, the Pacific Northwest accounts for five of Nelson's confirmed victims, roughly a quarter of the total, a significant regional concentration for a killer known for his mobility,
54:47 And like, what the fuck do you have against us? Like why, I don't know, And to be honest, as is the chase with so many serial killers, there are unfortunately suspected but unconfirmed victims. And that's a little bit of what I want to talk about in the Patreon bonus. So you know, if you are really intrigued by this case, that's something to look forward to a reason to join, or if you're just like sick to death of this creepy fucker, also totally understandable, you.
55:35 Could still join, just don't listen to it. Yeah, there's other content there, you know, if you just want to support us, that's cool too. What ifs. But that's all I have for both parts one and two of Ugh, this this guy Earl. I was definitely wondering if there was a chance like he had murdered more yeah people than they knew about mm hmm. And I will say that, I well, you're just gonna have to You're just gonna have to listen to the Patreon bonus for that. Yeah, yeah, but I'm subscribed.
56:22 Yeah. I do firmly believe that there are likely other victims that were not included in the body of our two episodes, damn, which is unfortunate because it's already just you know, it's a lot of people that I mean, their lives were ended and then the people that loved them, their lives were just irreparably changed, and I can't even imagine, I mean, and we talked about this so many times. The victims were so frequently discovered by you. Know people, the people closest to them, and yeah, the husband's the kids.
57:08 Because they were killed inside of you know, their homes or inside of other properties that they owned or you know, worked at. It's like, really, that's the only thing that makes sense. It just adds. It's just salt in the wound in this case because it's already just so ugly. But should we do. Some terror about it? And maybe, yeah, maybe we'll get a pretty tarot card and that'll make us feel better. They're all pretty so that Yeah, I mean the words aren't always pretty. But yeah, no, I mean, you know, it gets complicated at times.
57:50 All right, well, let's. Taro it up. Wow, vibes are being transferred. I like it. It That was weird and then you like moved and. It zoomed in on you. Yeah, it felt like the vibes got closer in that moment. They did. Okay, I've got them laid out in front of my keyboard as per usual when we're remote. So is there like a letter or a number that lines up with my. Keyboard that's calling to you?
58:31 N N Okay, Oh interesting, Okay, here we go. Oh it's a cute card. Okay, Well, like we said, yeah, oh oh yeah, it's another one of those that we've gotten quite frequently. Seven of swords. Okay, the little weasel eating an egg. He was a little fucking weasel. Yeah he was a weasel. Well he was a big weasel. Yeah, it's an Olympic short tailed weasel. Okay. So this is really interesting though, because obviously weasels, they have sort of a persona, are easily right, weasely exactly.
59:16 Our keywords in the Little Book are cunning, trickery, sneakiness, deceit, resourcefulness, strategy, and stell like all of that. Shut the fuck up. Okay, so this takes me back to part one. I just glanced at the Little Story because you know me, I'm like, sometimes I like to just get to the big book interpretation. But we have I love the stories. Yeah, well, and we have to read it this time. We literally have to we m. Weasel me. Listen, everybody's got to eat. It ain't my fault. And Papa Robin decided to fly off at the same time.
1:00:05 Opportunity. Yes, but remember he was orphaned. Parents died like very close together. But I agree it works two ways. Yeah, ooh, creepy. It goes on to say. See, I wouldn't call that a wise decision. I know they're not going to want to hear this, but when you think about it, this one's on them. No, that's what we were saying about the victim blaming and. The look that's how nature works. It's opportunistic. Wow, And I know an opportunity when I see it.
1:00:54 That is so him. Anyway, if I didn't wipe these eggs, somebody else would have. Anybody could have been waiting in the leaves, still and silent as death, watching that nest all afternoon. And he did that. He like stalked and waited for Oh my. God, anybody could have deftly climbed the tallest tree, swung out onto that rickety bow, and dove neatly into the nest cup without so much a scuffing a single delicious egg. So what if I got there first? Don't blame me for playing the game and winning. So what do you want me to do?
1:01:42 Starve? Oh my god, that was like so his mindset too. And I've not We've read this before for sure, and it like it has related to all these dudes who kill, But like that, every single word was so spot on for him specifically in what he did. Yikes that truly truly. Wow, he's a weasel. Okay, seven of sorts here we go. Keywords are uncertainty, illusion, impetuousness, stealth, cunning, and strategy. So we did draw this in the reverse.
1:02:28 So this is when I think it's really good that we have like the Big Book to kind of give us a more nuanced interpretation between the upright and the reverse. Interesting, okay, m m. Some decks, including the Writer, Waite, Smith, Aquarian, and Gilded Taro, show a man carrying away five swords, leaving two stuck in the ground behind him. When this card appears, it suggests you're facing a challenger problem. I must use caution to overcome potential danger. Girl, you in danger? Yeah, I was kind of like the people who did get away, like they they were using caution and ended up getting away from him. Yeah.
1:03:18 Honestly, when the seven appears reversed, it can mean either you're behaving impetuously or that you're overly cautious and afraid to act. I mean, I think we know which way that one falls. I think we know which way that cookie crumbles. I think it's the first one. It can also represent coming clean about a mistake and trying to make restitution. Which not something that he did. Did he He never admitted it. I mean, there was kind of an early admission, but like he very quickly reversed course and just was like, oh no, it's all lies. All these people are wrong.
1:04:03 And it's interesting because it's like the exact opposite of what he did. Yeah, pretty much. Just what he needed to do. See, he needed taro. Yeah he really did. Yeah, because remember initially, when first asked about the murders, Nelson bluntly told a reporter, I only do my lady killings on Saturday. Nights, the dad joke. Yeah. But then he immediately was like, oh no, I didn't do it. I didn't do it. All of them are wrong. Oh yeah. I mean, but that was like also saying he didn't do it, because I think I picked. I thought he was saying, like, I go to the club and I kill it with the ladies, like, yeah, Saturday nights.
1:04:44 I mean, I don't know that clubbing was so much a thing back in the nineteen twenty. That's what I thought he was saying. Yeah, it does seem like even that you could kind of read that in more than one way. I see what you're saying. In a reading about money, be careful of get rich quick schemes, gambling, or dubious endeavors. Like killing people and taking their money and jewelry and selling their clothes and then getting caught right Literally, the reverse seven can represent deception or leaving yourself vulnerable. Sometimes it suggests you may have gained through or are considering underhanded means. I would say, I mean to put it mildly. If the reading is about your job, this card can warn of dishonesty or deception in your workplace.
1:05:37 Perhaps you'll need to separate yourself from a situation, stay open minded and flexible so that you can respond to changes quickly. It can also mean taking advantage of someone else. Yep, all that, I would say professionally, Like all. These women they owned the properties and were like renting out rooms and. Yeah, yeah, I mean almost all of these women. It was like either they were renting a room or they ran a boarding house, they were selling a home something like that. There was like so few of the victims didn't fit that exact. Profile, like they're just trying to work man your deception.
1:06:20 In a reading about love, The reverse seven can mean apologizing for a mistake or injury. Perhaps you've betrayed, hurt or manipulated someone. That's kind of an interesting thing that it's literally says injury, and that was like one of his last words. Yeah that's so true. Oh my God, Like and he forgave, forgave the people who injured him. Yeah, God, blow me. However, this card can also show you assisting a partner through a challenge or warning him or her against a risky course of action. That kind of reminds me of like the warning that went out to everyone, right, like, hey, don't be alone in a house with a man ever.
1:07:07 Right never a Yeah, there is an extra excerpt I would just like to note it is from his holiness the fourteenth Dalai Lama. Tragedy should be utilized as a source of strength, no matter what sort of difficulties, how painful experiences. If we lose our hope, that's our real disaster. I like that. I know we always do. We always feel we let that fill us up because. We hear about all these families and people and they go through this horrible shit. Yeah, and we're like, oh God, like, how are you gonna survive after that, and then we get this beautiful quote I know, and actually I don't know.
1:07:59 I'm trying to think of a way to say this about like what I have, and it's it's kind of a short one. It's not like the length of a full episode, but the Patreon bonus like it just shows like truly the length of the tentacles with a case like this, and in some respects it shows like kind of the darkest aspects of this that like we haven't really even touched on. And then on the flip side, like what feels like kind of the closest thing to sort of like a silver lining in a way, And I don't know, I've just this one. I mean it was, it was. It was rough to research and certainly a challenge to write up.
1:08:52 But I think in some ways, like some of the aspects of it that it were the most intriguing to me. And then that kind of like in the end writing about it like made me feel like kind of hopeful in a way. I don't know. I got to the end and I was like, this is just like I simply can't like this cannot this episode even part two, Like this is not going to be three parts, because I don't think we have three parts here. But I was like, there's just there's just these things that like didn't quite fit in that, like I couldn't not make this part of.
1:09:37 The overall experience. I guess, I don't know. I don't know. I just I'm excited about this Patreon bonus just because of me too. Now. Yeah, well, and once it's over and like we kind of we we got our palate cleanser with the taro, and it feels like this ended where it should in a lot of ways. You know, mm hmm, that's perfect all things. It's like you planned it, I know, right, Well, I literally texted you and I was like, okay, based on current page length, like this feels like it may be two parts. But sometimes when it's like this dense and like it's this dark, sometimes those end up going really quick when we record because we sort of feel like, oh my god, like what do you even say?
1:10:33 Like that? I guess this isn't one of our more comedic episodes. Yeah right, but like this one, I felt like, I mean thankfully it played out that there there was a lot for us to just kind of like try to lighten things up. With a little bit, and I felt like our discussions were good. It like adds value to Yeah, I think so, I hope so yeah. Otherwise just running my fucking mouth, you know what. But that's allowed, so they can't stop us. Well, my goodness, should we do that? Faye? Yeah? Yeah, probably have a creepy day. We'll see you next Thursday.
1:11:23 But not you, earl, like this is the end. Of the road. Never Nelson, never now said the new Never Bundy, I know, never Clark, never Clark, or Virgil Virgil. Wilson, Yeah, Virgil Wilson. I mean, this man had so many aliases it's wild.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Goodpods
Amazon Music
Castro
RSS Feed