Why 20 Downloads Isn’t a Total Fail (Seriously!)
So, someone on Reddit wrote, “My podcast stinks,” and I think we should talk about it.
Spoiler alert: just because your download numbers are low doesn’t mean your podcast is a total flop—like, it’s not the end of the world if you’re not raking in those big numbers. We chat about how it’s not just about the content but also the delivery, because if your audio sounds like it’s coming from a tin can, uh, good luck with that! We also throw around some ideas on getting feedback, practicing your craft, and remembering your “why” behind podcasting. So, grab your headphones and let’s chat about how to make sure your podcast doesn’t suck—unless that’s your goal, in which case, carry on!
Reddit is a wild place, huh? So, some poor soul decided to air their podcast grievances and proclaimed, 'my podcast stinks!' Cue the collective gasp from the podcasting community. But instead of spiraling into despair, we examine what this actually means for podcasters everywhere.
I mean, who defines success anyway? Our conversation kicks off by flipping the script on the typical podcasting narrative. We chat about how every download counts, even if it's just your mom and your dog tuning in. If you’ve ever thought about throwing in the towel because your download numbers look like the score of a bad baseball game, we’ve got some comforting truths for you. Your show could be a massive success if it brings you joy, which is really what matters, right?
Your Podcast Is A Journey
Then we tackle some serious podcasting wisdom. If your audience is only a handful of people, that’s still a gathering! It's like playing to a room full of friends who actually want to hear what you have to say. We argue about the importance of content and delivery, because let’s face it, you could have the most riveting subject matter, but if it sounds like you recorded it in a tin can, good luck keeping anyone around. I offer some tips on spicing things up, like practicing your delivery (yes, even if it feels like talking to yourself in the mirror). Let’s be honest, we all need to keep sharpening our skills.
And naturally, we can’t resist discussing the age-old podcasting dilemma: why are you even doing this? If your goal is to have fun, then congratulations! You’re winning! But if you’re in it for fame and fortune without a plan, well, you might want to rethink your strategy. The episode wraps up with some encouragement to get feedback and engage with your audience—because who knows, they might just love that thing you think is a total flop! So tune in and let’s redefine success together.
Takeaways:
- Just because your podcast isn't on the charts doesn't mean it’s a flop; success looks different for everyone.
- If you’re podcasting for fun and enjoying the process, then congratulations, you’re winning at life!
- Your show might be reaching just a handful of listeners, but hey, those are still real humans tuning in, right?
- Feeling like your podcast stinks? Maybe it’s time to ask for some honest feedback from friends or fellow podcasters.
- Tired of low download numbers? Remember, it takes time to grow an audience; patience is key, my friend!
- Practicing your delivery is like stretching before a workout; it makes all the difference for your podcasting game.
Companies mentioned in this episode:
Mentioned in this episode:
Is Your Podcast Not Growing?
Struggling to grow your podcast beyond friends and family? You're not alone. I've been there too. That's why I created "10 Proven Strategies to Grow Your Podcast Audience" - a free guide packed with actionable techniques that have helped countless podcasters expand their reach and build loyal listener communities. Stop guessing what works. These are battle-tested methods used by top podcasters who speak to engaged audiences every week. Head to schoolofpodcasting.com/10tips now and download the free guide because your podcast deserves to be heard.
This podcast uses the following third-party services for analysis:
OP3 - https://op3.dev/privacy
00:00 - Untitled
00:07 - Introduction to Podcasting
01:50 - Improving Your Podcast: Key Ingredients for Success
03:17 - The Importance of Practice in Skill Development
05:33 - The Importance of Passion in Podcasting
06:49 - Understanding Podcast Monetization Strategies
08:24 - Becoming Your Podcast Consultant
Someone just made a post on Reddit that says, my podcast stinks.
Speaker ALet's talk about it.
Speaker BWelcome to youo Podcast Consultant.
Speaker BSmall lessons with big Value.
Speaker BWith more than a decade of experience and millions of downloads, this hall of fame podcaster is a featured speaker, author, and mentor to thousands.
Speaker BNow he wants to work with you.
Speaker BHe's your podcast consultant, Dave Jackson.
Speaker ASo I see a post on Reddit and it says, I've been podcasting for four years now and I'm averaging about 20 downloads a show.
Speaker AI've had a few spikes here and there, but nothing to write home about.
Speaker AI've tried tweaking my format to, you know, for a bit and to see if that would work, but still no success.
Speaker AI thought about giving up on podcasting a more.
Speaker AThat's what he says a more than a few times, but always find myself back making an episode.
Speaker AToday I admitted to myself that my show is just not that good.
Speaker AAnd there's more to this, but I'm going to stop there.
Speaker AThe first thing I would ask is take podcasting out of the mix.
Speaker AIf this was a restaurant, if this was a guitar player, you know, a musician, and you're singing in a club and everybody that's in the room gets up and leaves, wouldn't the first thing you do go, wait, maybe I need to change the music.
Speaker AMaybe I'm off key.
Speaker AYou would need somebody to go, can you listen to me sing and give me honest feedback?
Speaker AIf it was a restaurant and everybody that came in and ate your food left, wouldn't you go, hey, can you taste this for me and tell me if it's good?
Speaker ASo that would be the first thing I would do because it comes down to this.
Speaker AYour episodes really have two main ingredients, and that is the content and the delivery.
Speaker AAnd you can have the best content, but if it sounds like it was recorded in a fishbowl, that's not going to work.
Speaker AAnd you could have the best equipment.
Speaker ABut if you're using the same as everyone else generated AI script, that's not going to stand out.
Speaker AAnd so some things you might want to focus on is how will this benefit the audience.
Speaker ASo this episode is hopefully going to get you to think about doing an audience survey and to also contemplate what makes a good episode.
Speaker ASo then whatever it is, whatever that benefit is, get to the topic as quickly as possible.
Speaker AI hear so many people just ramble at the beginning of the show.
Speaker AThat's your first impression.
Speaker AAnd then something else you can do is practice.
Speaker AWhat do you mean, Dave?
Speaker ALike Record something and don't release it.
Speaker AJust practice talking into a microphone.
Speaker APractice getting words to come out of your mouth.
Speaker APractice being entertaining while being educational or just being entertaining or whatever it is.
Speaker APractice.
Speaker AI play the guitar and I'm.
Speaker AI'm no slouch.
Speaker AWhy?
Speaker ABecause when I was, I don't know, 11 years old, I would play about four hours a day, and I did that for about seven years.
Speaker AI can hold my own.
Speaker AWhy?
Speaker ABecause I practiced.
Speaker AI would go downstairs, I would put on whatever album my brothers and sisters had, and I learned to play along.
Speaker ASo also, now I realize he said he's been doing this for four years.
Speaker AIt does take years to build an audience.
Speaker AAnd those who have the passion, and we'll talk about that subject for free because they love it.
Speaker AThey want to serve their audience.
Speaker AThey push through, but those that don't, don't.
Speaker ABut he had one more line here.
Speaker AHe says, I'm okay with it because I'm doing something I like to do.
Speaker AI was thinking about bringing on a co host or collaborating with fellow podcasters.
Speaker ADo you have any advice?
Speaker AWell, here's the thing.
Speaker AWhy are you doing your podcast?
Speaker AThat is the first question you have to answer.
Speaker AYou have to answer that, because if you don't get what you want, you burn out.
Speaker AAnd so if his goal is to have fun, I would say, well, congratulations, your show is a massive success.
Speaker AI'll give you an example again.
Speaker ATake podcasting out of is spring here in Ohio.
Speaker AAs I record this, and as soon as it starts getting into the 70s, I'm going to be riding my bike.
Speaker AWhy?
Speaker ABecause I love to ride my bike.
Speaker AI strap it on the back of my car, I drive out to parks where they have lanes made for bikes, and you ride them out in the trees, and it's pretty and it's nature and it's good exercise.
Speaker ASo why do I do that?
Speaker ABecause I like to ride my bike in the trees, in the forest and get some exercise.
Speaker AConsequently, that's a huge success.
Speaker ANow, I've never had a single person as I'm putting my bike on my car, go, hey, bike rider, huh?
Speaker AYep.
Speaker AYou making any money at that?
Speaker ANo, it's a hobby, yet I have fun doing it.
Speaker AAnd I think I'm going to do an episode about this in the future.
Speaker ASo many people think that the only way that a podcast is recognized or legit is if they have a sponsor.
Speaker AAnd I couldn't disagree more.
Speaker AAnd I get it.
Speaker AWhen a boxer wins a gold medal, that is recognition.
Speaker AHowever, if they were doing it to get on the Wheaties box and they're not on the Wheaties box, they feel rejected.
Speaker ASo you have to know your why and then focus on that.
Speaker AHow are you going to do that?
Speaker ASo many people say, oh, I want to start a podcast and make money.
Speaker AGreat.
Speaker AAre you going to sell your own product and services?
Speaker ANo, don't have one.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker AAre you gonna sell like affiliate stuff?
Speaker AWell, it's kind of hard because I'm all over the place.
Speaker AOkay.
Speaker AAre you gonna do donations or crowdfunding knowing that only 3% of your audience is gonna donate?
Speaker AYeah, I might try that.
Speaker APut a PayPal button on my website, but never talk about it.
Speaker AWell, that's not gonna work, you know.
Speaker AAnd then I go, well, if you're, you know, what are your strategies to make money up?
Speaker AYou don't really have any.
Speaker AAnd so consequently you're not going to make any money.
Speaker AWhat do you want the podcast to do?
Speaker AAnd make sure you're doing steps that lead the podcast to do that.
Speaker AAnd in this case, it looks like this guy's doing it for fun.
Speaker ANow he's judging it by looking at other shows.
Speaker A40 downloads is two full classrooms that could be watching Netflix or any other streaming service, listening to the radio, listen to satellite, playing video games, walking in a park, bike riding, whatever, but they're listening to your show.
Speaker AThere is no spam in podcasting.
Speaker AAnd if you were in a room with 40 people listening to you, 40 people is a full medium sized room.
Speaker AA lot of people forget that there's no spam in podcasting.
Speaker AIf I don't want to listen to your show, I just swipe left and delete.
Speaker ASo maybe your show isn't bad, but it never hurts to get some feedback and always determine why are you doing this.
Speaker AIf you need help with this, I would love to help.
Speaker AThat's what I do.
Speaker AI've been doing this for 20 years.
Speaker ACome over and visit me at the school of podcasting.
Speaker AJust go to schoolofpodcasting.com you can use the coupon code listener when you sign up and that will save on either a monthly or yearly subscription.
Speaker AThat comes with a 30 day money back guarantee, unlimited coaching, amazing courses, and a super amazing community.
Speaker ACheck it out.
Speaker ASchoolOfPodcasting.com use the coupon code listnr.
Speaker AI'm Dave Jackson.
Speaker AI help podcasters.
Speaker AIt's what I do.
Speaker AAnd I can't wait to see what we're gonna do together because I want to be your podcast consultant.