Why Leaving Faith Is a Grieving Process with Jenna Lee Anderson
"Faith is like water to a fish. You're in it. It's your everything. It's your community, your family, your school, your food. It is your oxygen." — Jenna Lee Anderson Jenna Lee Anderson is a neuroheart alchemist and psychology practitioner who helps people transform trauma and grief into clarity and self-knowledge. Raised Catholic and now non-religious, she brings both professional expertise and lived experience to the question of what happens to the body and brain when someone leaves faith b...
"Faith is like water to a fish. You're in it. It's your everything. It's your community, your family, your school, your food. It is your oxygen." — Jenna Lee Anderson
Jenna Lee Anderson is a neuroheart alchemist and psychology practitioner who helps people transform trauma and grief into clarity and self-knowledge. Raised Catholic and now non-religious, she brings both professional expertise and lived experience to the question of what happens to the body and brain when someone leaves faith behind.
In this conversation with hosts Clive Aruede and Lola Tinubu, Jenna traces her journey from a devastating childhood loss to a life lived on her own terms. When her younger brother died suddenly on her sixth birthday, Jenna was left emotionally alone with only God to make sense of it. She came to believe she was being punished, spending decades trying to get back into God's good books for a crime she could not name.
Jenna explains why leaving religion is not a decision but a grieving process. Why the nervous system fights back when you ask it to abandon the beliefs that kept you safe. Why anger at religion often signals unresolved trauma underneath. And why the kindest thing humanists can do for those still in faith is refuse to shame them.
⚠️ Content note: This episode discusses childhood bereavement, emotional neglect, religious trauma, and grief.
🎙️ In this episode
- How the sudden death of Jenna's brother on her sixth birthday shaped a lifetime of belief
- Why a grieving child concluded God hated her, and nobody corrected her
- Neuroheart alchemy explained: turning heavy experiences into clarity and peace
- Why the brain physically resists leaving faith, and what that resistance feels like
- Separating faith and belief from doctrine and dogma
- Leaving religion as a breakup, complete with mourning, loneliness, and doubt
- What Jenna says to people who want to leave but cannot, especially in Black nations
- Why anger at religion often points to grief that has not been processed
- The weaponisation of Christianity against Black people and the trauma it left behind
- Why street preachers get a dopamine hit, and why kindness beats mockery
Thanks for listening to the Secular Sankofa Podcast, produced by the Association of Black Humanists (ABH). If you enjoy the show, please follow, rate, and review.
Stay connected:
🌍 Meetup • 👍 Facebook • 📸 Instagram • 🕊️ Twitter • ▶️ YouTube • 🎵 TikTok
Learn more at abhumanists.org
🎙️ Podcast produced by Humanise Live | hello@humanise.live
🎶 Music: Icy by Jeff Kaale
Thanks for listening to the Secular Sankofa Podcast, produced by the Association of Black Humanists (ABH). If you enjoy the show, please follow, rate, and review — it helps more people discover Black humanist voices.
Stay connected with us:
- 🌍 Meetup: association-of-black-humanists
- 👍Facebook: @AssociationBlackHumanists
- 📸 Instagram: @abhumanists
- 🕊️ X / Twitter: @abhumanists
- ▶️ YouTube: Association of Black Humanists
- 🎵 TikTok: @assoc_of_black_humanists
Learn more about our work and community at abhumanists.org
🎙️ Podcast produced by Humanise Live a podcast production agency based in London, serving charities, companies, and individuals across the globe.
.Learn more at www.humanise.live or hello@humanise.live
🎶 Music: Icy by Jeff Kaale
00:00 - Welcome and Intro to Jenna Lee Anderson
00:46 - A Birthday Loss That Changed Everything
03:09 - God, Guilt And A Child’s Shame
07:15 - Unlearning Religion Without Losing Yourself
10:25 - Neuroheart Alchemy And Closing The Loop
16:07 - Why Leaving Faith Hits The Body
20:48 - Practical Support For Religious Grief
28:10 - Identity, Community And Survival Stakes
34:51 - Street Preaching, Black Trauma And Boundaries
41:45 - Thanks, Where To Find Us
Welcome and Intro to Jenna Lee Anderson
Clive AruedeHello, welcome to Secular Sankopha, the podcast of the Association of Black Humanists. This is a space where we speak boldly, think freely, and live consciously. So here we have honest and unapologetic conversations about race, belief, power, and liberation from a black and godless point of view. So I'm your host, Clive Arreddi, and my co-host today is Lola Tinabu. Our special guest today is Jenna Lee Anderson, and this is going to be for me a most interesting conversation. So, Jenna, nice to see you.
Jenna Lee AndersonNice to see you.
Clive AruedeLovely, thank you.
A Birthday Loss That Changed Everything
Clive AruedeJenna, if I can just start by asking what you've told me, everything begins with a deeply personal tragedy. When you were just six years old, your younger brother died suddenly on your birthday. And of course, the loss profoundly impacted your childhood and shaped many of the adaptations you would carry into adulthood. Looking back now, how has your understanding of that six-year-old girl changed? Well, thank you, Clive.
Jenna Lee AndersonThat's a really, really interesting question. My understanding of my six-year-old self has changed in the most profound way. When I'm 54 now, and when I think about the journey that I've been on, unconsciously for most part of it, I'm blown away by my own resilience and my ability to live my life authentically in peace and as a happy person. Like the person I was meant to be before trauma got to me, before grief arrived. That's how I feel now.
Clive AruedeYou often say nothing is wrong with you. You make perfect sense. Was there a particular moment when you first believed that about yourself?
Jenna Lee AndersonIronically enough, I always knew that there was nothing wrong with me. I have this very vivid picture, this very vivid memory of myself when I was about three years old, and I had my photograph taken at the old co-op. And I look so happy and so radiant and beautiful, and I knew that that was the authentic me. And I always knew deep down inside that that was who I was. So that version of me has always existed, and I think that true version of all of us has always existed. This point of being born perfect and being wonderful and having an innate sense of knowing who you are, and then you meet life, and that changes for all of us, and we have to become a different version of ourselves in order to navigate life happens, and it can be confounded by experiences that we have that are based in faith.
Lola TinubuI want to ask, I know you said your background, you are a Catholic, and you are no longer a believer. No.
God, Guilt And A Child’s Shame
Lola TinubuIs there any connection between the loss of your brother, the grief, and everything that you went through as a result? Is there any connection between that and you leaving religion? Absolutely, 100%.
Jenna Lee AndersonBecause when my brother died, what happened was he died very suddenly, literally within 24 hours, and the adults around me um were grief stricken, understandably. But what happened then was they neglect, I was a miss I was emotionally neglected. Everybody observed the fact that I was grieving and that I had had this grief experience. Up until the day my brother died, I was the happiest child. We were the happiest family, and we went to church regularly. And I used to look forward to going to church and singing and having my tempee to put in the collection plate and then going to show. And it was a whole ritual around Sundays that was special. And as a as a as a half car half Caribbean, half-Jamaican child, we had rice and peas dinner afterwards. So there was a whole ritual associated with this ritual, you know, that made me feel, and I think this is what's so important, I felt safe, absolutely safe. So when my brother died, and I was uh left emotionally to fend for myself, I was still cared for, I was still sheltered and fed, but emotionally nobody recognized that a six-year-old child can grieve. So I only had God. I had a little picture of, I had a little statue of a crucifix, I think, in my room. And I had this, I had God, and that's all I had. And so I blamed when my brother died, I held myself responsible and I was to blame for that disaster, and I was to blame for everything that happened, and that I actually believed that I was being punished by God. I didn't recognize it at the time because I'm a child and you're very self-centric. So I'm just thinking, I didn't understand the cognitive complexity that I was actually believing. I didn't understand the belief that I'd formed. But I genuinely believed that the sadness, and again, I had no language for it, the pain was my fault because somehow I had upset God. And because the routine was gone, suddenly we weren't going to church. There was no rice and peas on Sunday, there was none of the stuff that I'd associated with being a good Catholic, even though I didn't know that's fully what it was. It was gone and I was responsible. So the relationship with God and my brother's death, that was huge, absolutely huge, because I then subsequently spent so much of my life trying to get back into God's good books, not knowing what I'd done to upset him. You know, and I would sing and I would pray and I would have I would hold the Catholic Mass in my bedroom, you know, because I was trying to repair this relationship with this being who, according to my upbringing, um, had sent his son to die for me because I was so wicked, and he had sent his son to die for me, and now my brother was dead. So what kind of person am I? You know, and that's kind of like the belief that I had, and it was traumatic. It's really, really traumatic when you're six years old and you you start to think that. And then because nobody corrects you, because you can't ask questions, nobody allows you to question anything, no one's there to bounce off of. You make up your own beliefs and they start to snowball because that's the way the brain is designed. The brain is designed to find evidence of what you believe in, which is why it's so important to find out what you believe, you know? It's really, really important to know.
Lola TinubuSo how gosh, so so you went through that that period that that I've observed, especially black people, um, in terms of grief with karma, they still they hang on to God even more. Absolutely. And they fall in love with God even more, and it is it's it's not even out of fear, it's it's it becomes uh there is an entanglement and there is love there, love for this being. What made you
Unlearning Religion Without Losing Yourself
Lola Tinubuwhat made you move away? What made you leave the religion?
Jenna Lee AndersonGood question. So it wasn't like a conscious choice for me, it was an unlearning. I think that's what it was. Because Fun Suminity, like I said, when I was a when I was three, I knew I was perfect. I knew there was nothing. I was a drawer, I knew I was lovely. And then this tragedy happened and my world changed, and suddenly I'm not in the same world that I was before. But it was always there. That seed of I'm good was was always there. So as I went on my journey, as I started to grow, rather, I knew enough about myself to know the kind of person I had a really good sense of who I was, in that I was kind, I was funny, I'm caring, I'm compassionate. These are my core qualities. And as I started to grow, those started to grow within me. And there became like a conflict of interest between who I felt I was on the inside because I support the LGBTQIA plus community, I'm anti-racist, I'm you know, I'm anti-capacist, I'm anti-Zionist, I'm anti- all of these things that the the church seemed to be support, you know, seemed to be supporting of, or seemed to be against a lot of the things that I innately felt were true because I couldn't reconcile. How could a divine being create things? It didn't make sense. Why would you make things you don't like? It seems it seemed silly to me, and that was friction. That created such friction in me that I needed to figure out a way to resolve it. And it was hard. And this is the point that I really want to make is the fact that it was frightening. I felt deep fear in my heart that I was rebelling against something, I was betraying something, like I was going to be punished, and that I was being disobedient. That's the word I'm looking for. I was felt as if I was being disobedient by wanting to acknowledge and honour the transition of the feelings I was having because they were so raw and so real. But they were also in my head, I was like, no, God loves us. I like I like singing, I like the church, I like the the things. It was became a challenge to separate faith and belief from doctrine and dogma. Those two are separate things, and it took me a while to work out that you can have faith in something bigger than yourself, like they do in the 12 steps. Um, but it doesn't have to be the same as a man-made doctrine. It doesn't, they don't they can be two separate things, and that was almost like having to tease myself gently into that understanding, like a real gentle unwrapping. It's almost as if, like, when you're at Christmas, when you unpick the paper on the wrapping paper gently, you don't just tear it, you pull up the little corner. That's exactly how it felt for me, like picking the corner and slowly opening up who I really was and my potential. And studying psychology made a big difference because suddenly I understand, hold on a minute, we're human and we are biological and we are wired and we are bound by the laws of nature. So there has to be something else going on here. And so that was pretty much the beginning of my unlearning.
Neuroheart Alchemy And Closing The Loop
Lola TinubuWe've we've spoken about this. You've you've talked about the process of living religion.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah.
Lola TinubuAnd you've compared it to grieving. Yeah. I I don't even think you said comparison. You said it is a grieving process. And you are a neuroheart alchemist. Yeah. I want to bring these two together. Now, first, please explain what that is and how do you use that to help people who are going through grief, which may be grief to loss of a person, like in your situation, your brother could be their parent, partner, brother, to the loss of a beloved one, or loss of religion, loss of God.
Jenna Lee AndersonHey, thank you. So, an alchemist is somebody who can take something basic and turn it into gold. And I believe that's what that's what neuroheart alchemy is about. It's about taking something that is heavy, like lead, emotions, beliefs, experiences, and then transforming them into gold, which is the quality of life that you have. The way that we do that is by reframing your experiences through the lens of the nervous system and understanding that you have a baseline, have a your your body has a natural baseline for where you sit in terms of what feels good. It's when you have an experience, if you have a negative experience, so if you imagine it goes like this, and then you have a negative experience, it goes and then you know it it peaks and it never comes back to its natural state. So, with neural heart alchemy, what we do is we go back to the blip and we look at what happened in terms of what did you then learn to believe about that. So, in my case, when I left, when my brother died, that was a huge blip. And the belief that I formed was I am nothing. Actually, the the the core belief, because you've got thousands of beliefs. The one that was actually at the root core of me was I don't exist, I am death, I am nothing, God hates me. Those were kind of like the root beliefs that I had and the other beliefs about that. So I had those beliefs equally, I had feelings that were attached to those beliefs, and they were well, they become welded together and they become your identity. They became my identity rather. So I believed that God hated me in a nutshell. And that belief created the experience of shame. So I felt I am shame because I felt ashamed of who I am and what I was and what I'd done. You know, I'd broken the universe, basically. So I felt deeply ashamed and guilty about that. So with neuroheart alchemy, what we're able to do is through a process of witnessing, you can see what happened and what you what the feeling that was created, but you do so from a place of objectivity as the grown adult that I am now, because the younger version of me created the beliefs and the younger version of me is holding the feeling. And because that loop hasn't been closed, because nobody said to me, Jenna, it's not your fault, you know, your brother died and he's he's not coming. If somebody had explained that to me, my brain would have been able to close the loop. So it was never closed. So with neural heart alchemy, what we do is we don't re-traumatize you because that's pointless. I teach you to be able to go into yourself so you can identify the story because it's just a story, because human beings are storytellers, that's all we are. The story and the feeling, and we separate them like velcro, you pull them apart, and then you pull them apart, but you allow yourself to fully experience them because my six-year-old has a whole story about what happened to her, and she's not going to tell it to me all in one go. This is a continuous ongoing process, it's not one and done. But beginning that dialogue, that conversation with myself was the key. Doing it from as a compassionate, objective witness was fundamental because I, as an adult, as a m, as a grown woman, can say, baby girl, you are only six. The adults were traumatized, you were neglected, they did you wrong. School was a horrible place for you. People ignored you, all of these things, and validate the experience of the child in order to close the psychological loop. Once you do that, you release that energy back because you're not holding it anymore. It's like you're not holding it like this anymore. You're letting it go and it comes back to you as clarity, it comes back to you as confidence, it comes back to you as peace, as calm, as truth. And you get to own it and do what you want. And you your world changes because suddenly you can see more. So that's the kind of heart alchemy that we do. And then once you kind of have that conversation as an adult with yourself, that no voids can exist in nature. You are then in a position where you can reframe that. You can say to yourself, I am lovable, I am kind, I am worthy, I am good, I am lovable, I am, and you can go into who you are now and what feelings that you want to do, and you cultivate those feelings because they're available to you. And the beauty is because we have we have neurons in our brain that mirror each other, surround yourself, start surrounding yourself with people who feel the same way as you do, who have the same beliefs as you do, which is why something like the humanist is so important, because you're sharing your beliefs with others. And when you share your story, what they do is they mirror back to you what is inherently good in you, what is right in you. So we all share our stories, and that is how you heal. But you've got to find the original story that you're telling. Otherwise, you're just papering over, you're just papering over belief with without healing it.
Why Leaving Faith Hits The Body
Jenna Lee AndersonAnd this is something that I think we spoke about before, where I've witnessed with people who have left faith, yeah, that they become quite, and this is a very general job, this is a very generalization. I'm not judging anybody, it's just something I've observed and I've witnessed, is people get so like some people get so indifferent, so so tense about the fact that they don't believe this thing anymore. And it was, you know, they have a lot of opinions about the faith that they've left, quite rightly or quite wrongly. It it doesn't matter. But the tension that you're holding when you are talking about it says to me there's trauma underneath. So congratulations that you've left your faith behind. I love that for you. I'm happy for you. I think that's amazing. It takes courage to do so, it takes courage to do that. I know that, but I can still feel that you haven't resolved your your relationship with God or the divine or whatever. There's stuff going on with your family, with your pit, no, whatever it is, there's stuff underneath because of your reaction, the way that you are looking at me. So yeah, you know that. And I've had those conversations with people, and I'm like, okay, all right, what else do you want to talk about?
Lola TinubuJust draw. I think I kind of I think you're just fucking about me.
Jenna Lee AndersonBecause it hurts, Lola. Here's the thing when people leave faith. I like, let me rephrase that. Faith is like water to a fish, you're in it, it's your everything, it's your community, your family, your school, your food, you know, where you travel, it's all of these things can be dictated by the faith that you've been raised in. It is your oxygen. And for you to then defy that, for you to then leave that or question it, you know, that is a shock to a biological shock to your system. And it's not, it's real because your brain has pathways that it makes based on your day-to-day existence. And the brain is the laziest, the laziest organ in the body, you know, because it lights routine. And once you've learned something, it doesn't really want to push to learn anything else, which is why procrastinating is so hard, which is why an extra giving up smoking is so hard, because the brain's like, well, I'm used to doing this, don't ask me to give it up. The same applies to faith because you your your neural pathways have been wired in a certain way. When you suddenly go, hold on a minute, actually, this doesn't quite work for me anymore. You're asking your brain to pull apart its wires, and it doesn't want to do that because by the time I'm assuming you you make that decision, you're an adult, and the brain wants you to eat, sleep, and procreate. It doesn't care how you feel, it doesn't care what you believe, it doesn't care if you'd shower or what, it doesn't care. It just wants you to stay alive and make more humans. So when you then challenge that status quo by going, no, I don't believe this anymore, it will fight back. Your nervous system will fight back physically. That's the biological thing that happens. Your body says, Hello, you want me to do what now? You want me to, if you're a Muslim, you want me to eat bacon? No. That's gonna make you sick, you know. And it's all of these things that you that you have to navigate in the body as opposed to just cognitively and psychologically that you wrestle with as well. The body does the same thing. So does that all make sense?
Lola TinubuVery much Yeah, I'm I'm sure you are speaking to a lot of our viewers. You are speaking to a lot of our.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah, because you know, the here's the most important thing. Being human is about having choices and friends and and careers and and living. That's a fundamental part of our experience. That's what makes us human, is that's what separates us from the rest of the animal kingdom, is that we have the free will and the capability and this higher functioning brain that allows us to have this joyful experience whilst we're here. But we are bound by the laws of nature, we are physical beings, regardless of whether we like it or not. And we have a mammalian brain which prioritises safety over comfort every time. Whatever you might have the best intentions in the world to do something, but if your body does not feel safe doing it, it will fight back. It will, and when I say fight back, it well, I don't mean it physically attacks you. What happens is it it acts up like procrastination, burnout, fatigue, you know, uh immune deficiency, immune autoimmune uh illnesses, things like this. This is your body going, I don't I I don't I don't know what you're doing here. But there's a rebellion and it happens in the brain, and that happens when you leave a faith, the same thing happens because your faith has been oxygen and water to you, and you're asking your brain to give it up, and it's it's not gonna give it up easily.
Practical Support For Religious Grief
Clive AruedeSo Jenna, that's I I I'm blown away. I'm not uh I'm not 100% sure. If if if somebody came to you today, whether they're six or twenty six or sixty, how would you handle how would you handle this situation? Because um as you say, faith is to to to leave faith is to grieve. So how would you handle it?
Jenna Lee AndersonI would first of all listen. I'd be silent and I would let them feel what it is that they're experiencing. I think it's very important to be present and allow somebody to feel, and I would encourage them and I would ask them to, I would guide them to go a little deeper. What does that mean? What does that feel like? And I would ask them to sit with it, close their eyes and just sit with it. What does that feel? Where are you feeling it? And to be really present to the feelings, the give it a name. Does that feel like? Is it sadness? Is it anger? Is it grief? Is it rage? Is it longing? Is it lost? What is it that feel you're feeling? Loneliness. You know, it's a big one. You know, feeling lonely is is is a big one. And being there. Witnessing with somebody compassionately what they are going through. And if I couldn't be there with them physically, I would 100% validate by saying what you are experiencing, what you are feeling is real. And it's natural and it's to be expected based on your biology, based on, like I said, this withdrawing of your support of your faith has a physiological impact on you. And to be kind and gentle about that, and above all, to breathe, because we forget to breathe. And so keep breathing, keep breathing. That's something I always say to clients: keep breathing, keep breathing, and just stay present. It will, it will, the discomfort, the confusion, the overwhelm, the sadness, the heartbreak. I know I felt foolish. I was like, I felt like a joke had been played on me with regards to um my religion. I felt so angry about being so humiliated, especially as a woman in the Catholic faith and the way that women are regarded. Mary Madeline's called a prostitute, you know, Mary was a Mary was a virgin, and all these things misogynistic. So there was a lot to unpack for me. So being kind and be prepared for what's comes up because it's a natural process when we outgrow something and it's the birth of a new you. You are giving birth to a new you, and everybody knows giving birth ain't easy, and it's not the funniest thing on earth. So be okay with becoming someone else. It's fine. You'll get through it, you'll be fine on the other side and encourage, allow yourself to receive support. Allow yourself to receive because it is a challenging process that you are undergoing.
Clive AruedeYeah, um, it's I don't know, we're not all lucky enough to have a sort of professional guidance when it happens, you know. You sometimes some kind of penny drops and you realize that the whole belief thing, the whole faith, the whole it's all you regard it as nonsense, you know, and for some people they might feel happy. I was I wasn't happy at all. I was very unhappy because it was as if I'd wasted so much time and effort and energy into this way of life, and it was just there was nothing there at the at the end of the day, nothing at the bottom of it, you know. So um yeah, so so you know what what what what do you say to people who um you know they have different reactions to leave in faith? Well wha how do you cope with that?
Jenna Lee AndersonOkay, so speaking to what you just shared, Clive, that is grief. That that is grief, and there isn't anything that I can there's nothing I can do about that. There's nothing I can say other because it's your grief and I can't experience it for you, but I can witness it, you know. So to somebody who is experiencing that, what I would offer if I'm not in the room with them is the the validation that what you are experiencing, every single feeling that you are feeling is true, and more importantly, it's okay. And if it's you are feeling it, then it wants to be seen, it wants to be witnessed, and it deserves its place in the pantheon of your emotion. It's there because, like I said, I found I have experienced with some people who have left faith, but there that there is a defiance and a refusal to acknowledge the real depth of pain and disappointment, the hurt, shame, guilt that comes up when you when you make this decision. When I don't think it's necessarily you make a decision, I think it's like it happens. You know, it comes upon you. It's not like you sit down one day and go, I know, I'm gonna do this. That's not what happens. I feel for most people, that's not what happens. There's a slow awakening, there's a slow realization, and that realizing process is traumatic. That's trauma. That in itself is where you're suddenly going, hold on a minute, I'm questioning everything that I've ever believed. I'm quite it's oh, it's not making sense. That is something that needs to be respected. And then what I would say is what will come next, what comes next is to be expected. Everything that you described in terms of how you felt is part of grieving. That's grief. You've just described grief. So it's about finding meaning. I think it's about finding meaning, Clove, if I'm honest. To go through the stages of grief and then to come to an understanding that is peaceful for you is the most important thing. And coming to that peace is going to be emotionally violent, psychologically violent. It's painful. Coming to that place where you go, actually, this is my truth. I liken it to Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz. You know, when she looks behind the curtain and she suddenly realizes that the wizard is actually some a little old man playing the piano. That's how exactly how I felt. That is exactly how I felt about my unlearning of faith is the fact that I've been deceived. I've been deceived, and that was not nice. It was painful, it was hurtful. And I also had to grieve, and I think this is something else as well. The things that you lose, the life I had to really grieve, and this was hard. The life that um the trajectory that I was on with my relationship with God, where I was gonna live, I was gonna be a good Catholic, and I was gonna do all go to go to Rome, go to Lourdes, do all these things. When I came to accept that this is not my reality, I had to let go of the fairy tale that I had been clinging to, which was I would get married in church, have a beautiful white dress, and you know, that fairy tale, and having to go, Jenna, that's not gonna happen. That's that's that's not gonna happen. That was painful because I'd been raised as a bride of Christ. I was destined to marry Jesus. I was destined to marry in the church. You know, I was destined to that's what I was destined to be, and it it wasn't gonna happen. So who are you? That's the question that needs to be answered. Who are you now?
Lola TinubuI think you know, you've just hit on my next question, and I think you've almost finished answering it, but I I I want to see whether you can even take it further.
Identity, Community And Survival Stakes
Lola TinubuThere are a lot of people in church because I went through that before I finally left religion.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah.
Lola TinubuAnd and some may never have that courage to leave. You know, at the beginning you said what religion is, the the oxygen, it's it's your essence, yeah, it's your structure.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah.
Lola TinubuAnd for most people, for I think almost everyone, it's your family, yeah. Friendship, education. And in countries, you know, um, in let's talk about black nations. In most black nations, your jobs, you know, your livelihood, everything is, you know, attached to to the fate. If you don't belong in in a in a group, you know, your your survivor is at risk.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah.
Lola TinubuSo most sadly, I don't, you know, I don't have any statistics behind. I'm just, I think it's a guess, probably and probably a correct guess. I I I I am confident that in a country like Nigeria, you will not even entertain it because it means everything. Where do you go? Okay, I can I when I went through living the process of living religion, you know, I was in the UK, I was already an adult, I had my job, I had everything. Even for me, it was it was traumatic. It was, you know, sometimes people think you you just do it. That you just I don't believe in God anymore, and then you just leave. No, you don't want to leave. You really don't want to leave. So what do you say to people who who are questioning, you know, the faith and who but they they they for some maybe they can leave and some they can't leave. Because we are not going to assume as much as we want to, we would like to help those who can. But not sadly, in 2026, not everyone who wants to can. So who what do you want to say to those who can? They can, but they are really, you know, they are going to lose their sense of identity, the sense of self, which the their oxygen, like put it. How are they going to breathe? You know, who do you what do you say to them? And what do you say to those who will never leave?
Jenna Lee AndersonOkay. I think we need to frame it as it's a relationship.
Lola TinubuYeah.
Jenna Lee AndersonFaith, religion, it's a relationship. Unlike any relationship, living is hard. And some people never do. And to speaking to the people who will never leave, I accept that's fine. If you respect your because one thing I believe you have free will. And if you want to stay in your faith, and you are happy to do so, or you choose to do so, it's your choice. Because you've got free will, then I I I I I respect that. And I love you unconditionally for that because I've never walked a mile in your shoes, and it's not my you know, it it's it's not my place to say that to tell you what to do. So I would just respectfully respect that. I believe that every experience contributes to the whole. Even people who don't leave for whatever reason, they will impact life in a different way because everybody we don't walk upon this earth and leave nothing and leave without footsteps. We we leave traces of our existence, um, regardless. And I may not understand their path, is the point you're making. To somebody who wants to leave and is ready to leave their faith, I would be brutally honest and say it's a process, like any relationship, like any breakup. It's gonna take time. You are going to doubt yourself, you are going to feel lonely, not just physically lonely or emotionally lonely, existentially lonely, like a like a like a like a rock in the like an asteroid, like a rock in the universe. That's how the loneliness feels, and that's okay, that's to be expected. You are not bad, there's nothing wrong with you. You've had experiences that have programmed you to accept certain behaviors as true, and you've been programmed to have beliefs that define you, but you were born by yourself, and you have the power to redefine yourself because that's the power of the brain. And I will always come back to the brain because of the nature of neuroplasticity. You can rewire, you can become whoever that whoever you want to be. I was about to say whoever the hell then, whoever you want to be. You can, because that's what the brain does, and that's what being human does. It's gonna be uncomfortable, is what I would say. It's gonna get deeply uncomfortable. It will hurt. I'm not gonna shy away from it. It's not like you've done a great job, but happy you. Because again, when you break up, if you've ever broken up with somebody, there is a period of mourning, and that mourning period is real. How you choose to handle that mourning will determine what happens next. If you allow the anger, the resentment, the hurt, the betrayal, the deceit, the lies, the humiliation, the shame to take you, and it can, then you will create a reality that brings you those feelings that will keep validating those feelings. If you allow yourself to surrender to the discomfort, the pain, the hurt, the shame, the humanity. If you allow yourself to surrender to it, accept it without judging it, be present to it. So when it twists and turns in your heart and your gut and your stomach and your legs and your throat and your head hurts and your eyes and you're crying, if you can stay with it, what's happening is your nervous system is releasing energy. That's all that's happening when that happens. Is you are consciously becoming aware of the feelings that you are feeling. Those are your feelings, you're feeling them, and you are aware that you're feeling them. That's why it hurts so much. But it passes, it will pass. And when it passes, what it does is it creates space, it creates silence, and that's where you reflect. And in the reflection, you start to feel something new because that nature hates avoid. So something has to replace what you've let go of, what you've lost. You get to decide whether it's positive and uplifting or whether it's not. It's your choice. So there's nothing I can say in terms of comfort per se. I think honesty, being honest about my perspective, my experience is the biggest gift I can give to anybody. Validating, witnessing, not shaming, leaving judgment behind, not judging you because I've never walked a mile in your shoes. That's the kindest thing I can do. And
Street Preaching, Black Trauma And Boundaries
Jenna Lee AndersonI think that's the kindest thing that we can do. And the most emotionally immature thing we can do is to shame those who are still there. I met a lady, I was I was um walking my dog. I was coming home in the evening. And this lady appeared from I wasn't expecting her in the most unusual place. She kind of appeared, and she said, Can I give you something? And I knew she was hanging me in Laplet, and I automatically saw it as some form of religious leaplet. And I said, So no, thank you. And I carried on walking. And she said, Jesus loves you. And I said, Yes, thank you. I appreciate that. I appreciate the fact that she thinks she believes Jesus loves me because, well, the Jesus of my understanding loves me. And so I appreciate and validated that for her because that's what she believes. And I don't have the right to mock that or shame that or humiliate her for having those beliefs if they work for her. And I think that's important to be kind, to truly be understanding of other people's experiences, knowing that they the reason how I look at it is the fact that they have a nervous system too that has been programmed to feel safe under these circumstances, to feel safe when they go to church at 10 o'clock in the morning, clap hands and give praise is what gives is what makes them feel safe. And every living being on this earth wants to feel safe, and we find a way to feel safe by any means necessary. And if they're if their safety is through a Bible or the Quran or the Torah or whatever, the Sanskrit, whatever their faith is, if it makes them feel safe, I do not have the right to judge it.
Lola TinubuSo I feel like I would say you just told me off without yes, because I go I I go to Peckham at weekends. Okay. I go to Peckham on Saturday and Sundays. And when you are in Peckham, oh my god, Peckham Riley. Imagine where this is going. Today was today was the you know, I I've been saying it since since I've been going to Peckham at weekend, but so they they were like an army, you know, and you know, like targeting black people.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah.
Lola TinubuAnd maybe it's the trauma, is the you know, the residual trauma that I still have in me. Yeah, I was very angry.
Jenna Lee AndersonYeah.
Lola TinubuAnd then, you know, one of them, not one of them, a few of them came to me, and it's like you have to like fight your way through through them. And I'm sorry, I just said this thing is not true. Most of the time, I you know, I've learned, you know, when I when I first became an atheist humanist, I was like on fire, I was everything that you you know, I was very angry, I was very militant. Over time, I think you go through different phases. Over time, I've mellowed, and I just see them I smile, you know, they go their way, I go my way. But now and again that thing comes out of me, and today it really came out of me.
Jenna Lee AndersonAnd like I think it's understandable, Lola, because there's a couple of things there to unpack. One is uh the Christian faith as it is, as it has been given to black people, was weapon, it's it was violent, and it was it's violent, it was weaponized. The teachings of the Christ, in and of themselves, are lovely. Love thy neighbour, be kind. Those are nice instructions to be a decent human being. I think with black people, we have trauma attached to the way that we were forced to take this particular brand of faith against our will. And I know what you're saying because when, like I said, when that lady gave me the um the leaflet, there was a part of me that went, oh, for crying out loud, this is just nonsense. And I was triggered, I'm not gonna lie, I was triggered, I'm like it, but it breaks my heart equally that for black people, we have taken on this version of Christ, we've taken on Christianity, and we've we've not unburdened ourselves from it. We haven't seen how damaging and what it's done to us. So that triggers me is the fact that it makes me so sad that my fellow people have taken on the white man's religion basically that was used to enslave us, that was weaponized against my ancestors. I take it personally. So I empathize with what you're saying, but again, two so two things can be true at once. You can be angry and annoyed and peeved off by somebody doing that, and that the approach that they come with as well can often feel to me desperate. Like you've got to believe what I believe. You have to, I'm going to the and it's like there's a desperation. It's the the idea that you have held, you have pinned your identity to saving me. Do you know what I mean? It's almost as if you you really need me to get this, you really need me to to see it your way, otherwise, your safety is compromised. So, what then happens taking it back to the nervous system is in those situations, you have people who whose nervous system is based on this idea about the God of their understanding. And part of that idea is to make sure everybody else understands what they understand. And if those people don't, the more you get rewarded for the amount of people that you bring in, or you convert, or you encourage, or you have these conversations with, there's a reward. And it's not a just a biblical reward, it's actually a nervous system reward. If I walk on the street and it's almost like sales, I I've got these beliefs, I'm going to um share them with you. And if you agree with me, or if we converse and I get to show my expertise, because a lot of people in faith, they know their religious books, they know the scriptures, they know their stuff, and they get a chance to show off on the street, you know, and it's not conscious. This is the thing, it's not like I'm gonna show you how much of the Old Testament I know. It's not that at all. It's just the way that we are wired is for reward. And there is a dopamine hit. If I stop you on the street and you talk to me and I tell you something that you don't know, or I can answer something that you've said with something that I know, I get a hit of dopamine. Do you see what I mean? So it's not personal, it's biological. There's a reward there, it's a nervous system reward. So, like I said with that lady that I saw, when she stopped me and I was kind to her, and I said to her, No, thank you. I know what happened to her biologically was that she was experiencing, she was excited to see me, and she was hoping for the reward of being able to share her truth with me. And when I rejected it, she responded by saying, as I'm walking off, Jesus loved you because she felt rejected. So, in order to pick herself back up, she had to give me a truth that makes sense to her, that makes her feel better, not me. So her take to be Jesus loves me was not about me, it was about her. Does that make sense?
Clive AruedeYeah, absolutely.
Thanks, Where To Find Us
Clive AruedeSo thanks very much, Jenna. Um, so I'd just like to thank you for taking the time out to talk to us today and share your thoughts with us.
Jenna Lee AndersonThank you.
Clive AruedeAnd uh, of course, I want to thank my co-host Lola Tinobu and James, who's helping us uh out with the technical stuff. And of course, I want to thank all of you who have joined us here on Secular Sankopha. If you've liked what you've heard today, please follow us wherever you get your podcast, share the podcast widely, and tell others. If you want to contact Association of Black Humanists, you can do so on meetup.com and uh we're also on X, formerly Twitter, and on Facebook. I have been your host live already, and this has been Secular Sankofa, where we speak boldly, think freely, and live consciously.