"TEXAS MOM TRIED TO DROWN KIDS TO ESCAPE HUSBAND, MARINE VETERAN GUILTY & ANGELS KNEW"
Reid Carter updates Jessica Quintana case with disturbing revelations - Texas mother tried to drown three kids with tequila and Nyquil because husband Domingo trapped her on 300-acre estate, took phone and car keys. Children desperate to see mother but terrified of father. New Hampshire jury finds Marine veteran Dustin Duren guilty on all counts after three-hour deliberation - shot girlfriend Caitlyn Naffziger in head, fled 170 miles triggering Amber Alert. Tyler Skaggs civil trial as Eric Kay's ex-wife Camela testifies Angels knew about addiction, saw pills for Skaggs, did nothing. Widow seeking $118 million.
Join our new FB groups page here. Take the poll!
Join the Celebrity Trials community on social media! We're building a passionate group of true crime enthusiasts who love diving deep into the most shocking cases in America.
Follow us on Facebook and Instagram by searching "Celebrity Trials Podcast" on either platform.
You'll get exclusive behind-the-scenes content, breaking news updates on cases we're covering, and early alerts when new episodes drop. Our social media is where Reid Carter's hottest takes live, including reactions that don't make it into the show.
But more importantly, it's where YOU come in. Share your theories, debate the verdicts, and connect with fellow listeners who are just as obsessed with justice as you are. Did the jury get it right? What questions do you still have? Your comments and insights often shape future episodes.
We cover the trials that matter, but our community makes the conversation unforgettable. Come for Reid's signature cynical commentary, stay for the incredible discussions with thousands of true crime fans who get it.
0:03 Callarogu Shark Media. Good morning, I'm read Carter Thursday, October thirtieth, twenty twenty five. Three stories, three families destroyed. Let me tell you where we are. Texas. Update on Jessica Quintana, the mother who tried to drown her three kids in a pond on their three hundred acre estate. New details reveal why she did it. Her husband wouldn't let her leave, took her phone, took her car, keys, trapped her on the property, so she gave the kids tequila and niquill and tried to roll them into the water. The children are desperate to see their mother, but not their father. New Hampshire Marine veteran Dustin Duran found guilty on all counts yesterday. Second degree murder, reckless conduct, child endangerment. Shot girlfriend Caitlin Nafzger in the head. Claimed he was protecting their daughters from being kidnapped. Jury didn't buy it. Three hours of deliberation. Sentencing December eleventh, California. Eric Kay's ex wife takes the stand in the Tyler Skaggs wrongful death trial.
1:08 Testifies she saw Angels players passing pills on the team plane, told team officials her husband was using drugs, had pills meant for Skags. They did nothing. Three months later, Skaggs was dead. Family wants one hundred eighteen million dollars from the Angels. I'm reed, Carter today. When domestic captivity leads to attempted murder, suicide, when self defense claims collapse under evidence, when MLB teams enabled drug dealers in their own front office, this is celebrity trials. Quick update on the Jessica Quintana case we covered yesterday September twenty ninth, twenty twenty five, Dayton, Texas Rancho Monte Carmelo, a three hundred acre estate, three million dollar property. Jessica Quintana, thirty nine years old, allegedly tried to drown herself and her three children, ages six, eleven, and fifteen, in an ornamental pond. Yesterday we told you what happened. Today we know why. According to affidavits from interviews with both Quintana and her fifteen year old daughter, the poisoning and drowning attempt was a back up plan to flee the isolated estate. Jessica and her husband, Domingo Quintana, sixty one, had been having problems for some time. The last straw came on September twenty eighth, when he took her phone and refused to return it. Plan A pack up the kids and leave home, but when Jessica went to leave, she discovered Domingo had taken her car keys.
2:41 She was trapped on the three hundred acre property, so she allegedly carried out Plan B. September twenty ninth, Jessica began drinking tequila, told the kids to drink with her until they felt fuzzy, then gave them naiquil so they would pass out by the pond. Told them she would roll them into the water once they were knocked out. According to her six year old son, she assured them they wouldn't feel anything. Jessica allegedly told the children they had to go because she couldn't live with Domingo anymore, and if she only took her own life, there would be no one to protect them from him. Think about that, a mother so terrified of what her husband would do to the children that she decided killing them was the more merciful option. Domingo dragged them all out of the water before police arrived. Liberty County Sheriff's Office Captain David Meyers said Quintana was unconscious and unresponsive when pulled from the water. They pretty much went into the water together, and based on the evidence we have, the intent was that they would drown and not wake up. All four spent weeks in hospital. Jessica was arrested Friday morning as she was released from medical care, charged with attempted capital murder.
3:55 Here's where it gets interesting. Despite their mother allegedly trying to kill them, reports showed the children were desperate to see their mother, but not their father. Quintana was eventually allowed brief supervised visitation with her children, but Domingo was blocked entirely. Courts wouldn't let him near them. Liberty County District Attorney Jennifer Bergmann refused to elaborate on what was going on between Quintana and her husband, but she made one thing clear. As of today, the father of the children will not be charged with the current murder suicide plot. That phrasing current murder suicide plot, not the murder suicide plot current, implying there might be other plots, other incidents, other reasons to charge him. Domingo was charged in an unrelated animal abuse case. Emaciated cat found on the property made his own court appearance last week. Ordered to remove his three dogs from his care without harming them, not allowed to own any non livestock animals. The court records showed Domingo Quintana named in multiple civil lawsuits, owes thousands in property taxes, accused of failing to pay contractors hundreds of thousands of dollars for work on Rancho Monte Carmelo.
5:13 The Quintana family lived at the estate since twenty seventeen, but the children hadn't been enrolled in school for a little bit. Police said, isolated home, schooled, no outside contact. At least one previous nine to one one call for an alleged assault at the residence. Unclear if it involved the Quintana family, but it's on record. The three children were released into custody of Child Protective Services, then handed over to family members away from both parents safe. Here's the pattern. Controlling husband, isolated property, no school, no phones, no car, keys, no escape, wife so desperate she tries to kill herself and the kids rather than leave them with him. And the children who their mother tried to drown, are desperate to see her, but terrified of him. The courts saw it too. Supervised visits with mom, no contact with dad. Jessica Quintana may have committed an unspeakable crime, attempted to murder her own children, But the question nobody's asking what was happening in that house that made death seem like the better option? Will update you as this case develops. We'll be right back with the Dustin Duran verdict Marine veteran claims self defense. Jury says second degree murder.
6:46 Tuesday October twenty eighth, Manchester, New Hampshire, Coups Superior Court Judge Jonathan Eazaul presiding the jury reached a verdict after three hours of deliberation. Dustin Durhan, thirty eight years old, guilty of second degree murder, Guilty of reckless conduct with a deadly weapon, guilty of child endangerment. As the verdicts were read, Durrenn put his hands on his head, appeared dismayed. Taken back into custody immediately. Sentencing scheduled for December eleventh at ten a m in Lancaster. Let me remind you what happened. February twenty ninth, twenty twenty four, Berlin, New Hampshire dustin Duran's apartment afternoon, he and his girlfriend, Caitlin Nafzinger, thirty one, got into an argument about money and travel arrangements.
7:36 Their two daughters, ages four and one, were present. According to Durren's testimony, Nafziger threatened to report him for kidnapping if he didn't pay her money he didn't have, said she'd call police and have the girls taken away. At one point, they struggled over one of the children. Durrenn said the child started crying. That's when he crossed his line, grabbed his father's Beretta nine millimeter handgun, chambered around, grabbed his daughter by the shirt collar, pulled her forward to create distance from Caitlin, then fired one shot left side of Nafziger's head above the ear. Bullet passed through skull and brain exited above the right ear. She died instantly.
8:21 Medical examiner doctor Mitchell Weinberg testified no markers of close range firing were present, no soot, no muzzle imprints, no gunpowder stippling. The shot was fired from at least three feet away, three feet not in the middle of a struggle, not in the heat of a physical altercation three feet away, aimed fired. Durham described it as muscle memory from his marine training. He served deployments to Japan, Philippines, Thailand, Iraq, Kuwait, honorably discharged as a sergeant in twenty eleven. Diagnosed with service related PTSD in twenty twenty one to twenty twenty two. After shooting Nafziger, Duran packed clothes for both daughters, put them in his twenty seventeen white Subaru, drove one hundred seventy miles south through the night, made a video for his parents showing the children were safe. Called his mother, told her he shot Caitlin. The girls were okay. He was going dark for a bit. Prosecutors asked if he was concerned enough to call police. Duran answered at that point he wasn't. He drove through New York, stopped at a gas station, slept in the car with his daughters.
9:28 Next morning, decided to return to New Hampshire and turn himself in. Amber alert issued March first. Caroline Campbell, former Las Vegas police dispatcher, spotted the white Subaru in an Applebee's parking lot in Keene. Called nine one one followed the vehicle. Police arrived, Duran arrested. Both daughters found safe and unharmed. The defense argument self defense and child rescue. Nafziger was holding their daughter hostage, using her her as leverage, threatening to call police and make false kidnapping claims. Duran, a marine with PTSD, responded to a threat, saved his daughter.
10:11 The prosecution argument rage and control. Duran demanded Nafziger leave his apartment. She refused. He shot her to silence her forever, then fled one hundred seventy miles to avoid consequences. The evidence destroyed the self defense claim. First, Nafziger was sitting on a couch wrapped in a blanket when shot, not holding a child hostage, not physically threatening anyone sitting on a couch wrapped in a blanket. Second, the shot was fired from three feet away, not during a struggle, not in immediate response to violence, from three feet away, after Duran chambered around and aimed. Third, Duran fled, immediately, drove one hundred seventy miles, didn't call nine one one, didn't render aid, didn't stay at the seat. If you truly act in self defense, you call police immediately. You report what happened. You don't trigger an amber alert and hide in an Appleby's parking lot. Fourth, Duran never mentioned kidnapping or self defense in his original police statement. That story didn't emerge until his first court appearance a year and a half after the shooting. That's not trauma induced memory lapse.
11:23 That's a fabricated defense. Fifth, Nafziger had equal rights to her own child. There's zero evidence she was planning to kidnap anyone. She had no means to flee, no car, no transportation, no plan. The jury saw through it three hours of deliberation. Guilty on all counts. Senior Assistant Attorney General Joshua Spiker put it plainly in closing arguments, this was a situation that did not need to occur. Defendant tried to blame Caitlin Nafzger for her death. New Hampshire Attorney General John Formela released a statement, This verdict brings account of for the tragic and senseless death of Caitlyn Nafzinger.
12:05 Caitlin was thirty one years old, mother of two, should be raising her daughters, watching them grow, building a life. Instead, she was shot in the head by the father of her children because she refused to leave his apartment fast enough. PTSD doesn't excuse murder. Marine training doesn't justify executing your girlfriend on a couch. Self defense doesn't mean shooting someone three feet away who's wrapped in a blanket, your tax dollars at work. Six day trial, jury of six men and six women, three hours to determine Dustin Duran murdered Caitlin Nafzinger, Rest in peace, Caitlin Santa Anna, California Federal Court, wrongful death lawsuit Tyler Skagg's family versus the Los Angeles Angels. Tuesday, October twenty ninth, Kamala Kay took the stand his wife of Eric Kay, the Angel's former communications director, currently serving twenty two years in federal prison for providing the fentanyl laced pill that killed Tyler Skaggs. Her testimony is the heart of this lawsuit. Both sides agree on that Kamala testified she saw Angels players partying, drinking, and passing pills on the team plane when she traveled with her husband.
13:22 Saw at first hand players openly sharing drugs on the team plane while she was present. She said the pills were Percocet and Xanax. Her husband told her so she flew on the plane most recently between twenty thirteen and twenty sixteen. Twenty nineteen, Eric Kay was hospitalized for a drug overdose. Camella said she heard he had pills intended for Tyler Skaggs shared that information with the team's traveling secretary. Three months later, Skaggs was dead. The Angels failed, Eric, Kamella told the court, I am sitting in a courtroom for two days in front of a mother who lost her son and a widow. The father of my three children is in prison. The Angels failed Eric. Here's what else.
14:08 Kamala testified. Twenty seventeen, she and other family members held an intervention with Eric over drugs. The next day, two Angels officials came to their house. One pulled plastic baggies containing white pills from the bedroom, fueled her concerns he was dealing. Twenty nineteen, Eric was driven home by an Angel's employee after he was found shirtless and dancing in his office at the stadium. Kamella found blue pills among his belongings. He was hospitalized three days for an overdose before going to rehab. Her sister in law visited Eric in the hospital, told Kamala that Eric said the pills were for Skags. Kamala found text messages on Eric's phone him discussing getting his candy at the stadium. She relayed this to his supervisor at the Angels also saw messages from Skags asking about candy. Eric told Commide while in rehab that he'd asked his boss to keep Tyler off his back. Medical records for Eric's twenty nineteen hospitalization showed he'd been battling addiction for twelve years, known to use norco, oxycodone, antidepressants, marijuana.
15:17 Caamella expressed concern Eric was returning to work too quickly after only six weeks in rehab, taking on more responsibilities, traveling to Texas with the team less than three months after rehab. Tyler Skaggs was dead July first, twenty nineteen, South Lake, Texas, Dallas suburb Angels scheduled to open a four game series against the Rangers. Tyler Skaggs, twenty seven years old, found dead in his hotel room, choked on his own vomit, toxic mix of alcohol, fentanyl, and oxycodone in his system. Eric Kaye provided the pill counterfeit oxy codone laced with fentanyl killed Skags. February twenty twenty two, Eric Kaye convicted in federal criminal trial. Five MLB players testified they'd received oxy codone from him between twenty seventeen and twenty nineteen. Kay sentenced to twenty two years in federal prison. Now the family wants one hundred eighteen million dollars from the Angels, arguing the team knew kay was addicted, knew he was dealing, did nothing enabled him, let him travel with the team, gave him access to players, and that negligence killed Tyler Skaggs. The Angel's defense team officials didn't know Skags was taking drugs. Any drug use happened on personal time in the privacy of hotel rooms. Can't be held responsible for decisions players make in private. Angels attorney Todd Theodora Cross examined Kamala. How could she know
16:49 what was going on with her husband's drug use when she was sleeping in a separate bedroom keeping her distance since twenty seventeen. The report about pills for Skags came when Eric was acting a radically during his overdose. Was that reliable? But here's the problem. For the Angels. They were told multiple times. Twoy seventeen officials came to the KA house after the intervention, found baggies of pills in the bedroom. Twenty nineteen employee found Eric shirtless dancing in his office, drove him home. He overdosed, hospitalized, went to rehab. Twenty nineteen, Camella told the Traveling Secretary Eric had pills intended for Skags. The Angels knew, and they sent Eric Kay right back to work, traveling with the team Access to players Communications Director position intact. Six weeks later, Tyler Skaggs was dead in a Texas hotel room. Mike Trout testified earlier in the trial. Three time MVP said he loved Skags like a brother, never saw drug use from him, but saw Eric Kay acting wired, sweating. The first thing that came to mind was drugs. It was clear k was using something. Players knew, Kemala knew, the Traveling Secretary knew.
18:09 Did management know? That's what the jury has to decide. After Skag's death, MLB and the Player's Association started testing for opioids, referring players who test positive to treatment. Too late for Tyler, but maybe saves the next one. Tyler Skaggs was twenty seven years old, left handed pitcher, regular in the Angel's rotation since twenty sixteen. Struggled with injuries but kept fighting. Should be pitching today, should be mentoring young players. Should be alive. The trial continues, more witnesses expected could last weeks. Jury will decide if the Angels are liable for Tyler's death, if one hundred eighteen million dollars is appropriate compensation for failing to stop a drug dealer in their own front office. Rest in peace, Tyler.
19:00 At celebrity trials for Thursday, October thirtieth, twenty twenty five. Jessica Quintana tried to drown her three kids because her husband trapped her on their estate, took her phone, took her car keys. She decided killing them was more merciful than leaving them with him. The children are desperate to see their mother, but not their father. Dustin Duran guilty on all counts, shot girlfriend in the head, claimed self defense. Jury didn't buy it. Three hours sentencing December eleventh, and the Angel's civil trial continues. Eric Kay's ex wife testified the team knew about his addiction and dealing, did nothing three months later, Tyler Skaggs was dead. I'm Red Carter, see you tomorrow. This is celebrity trials.