Welcome to Celebrity Trials - True Crime and Justice coverage updated daily.!
Sept. 10, 2026

Four Clancy Jurors Speak and Their Accounts Don't Match, Patrick Clancy's Lawyer Warns the Conspiracy Theorists, and a Case in Illinois

Four Clancy Jurors Speak and Their Accounts Don't Match, Patrick Clancy's Lawyer Warns the Conspiracy Theorists, and a Case in Illinois

Four jurors from Lindsay Clancy's murder trial have now spoken publicly, and their accounts conflict. Foreperson Roni Carlson, a retired fifth-grade special needs teacher, told NBC10 Boston the holdout juror "admitted he had reasonable doubt" — that she began signing the verdict forms before he said, "But I'm still not going to say that she's not guilty by reason of insanity." Jurors Kellie Farina and Paula Devlin described him as closed off and unwilling to engage. A fourth juror, speaking anonymously to CBS Boston, said the majority pressed him from the beginning, that he was not the only one unwilling to move, and that she would defend him. Judge William Sullivan has temporarily sealed the jurors' names, and the holdout has not spoken. Also: Patrick Clancy's attorney Howard Cooper issued a statement calling the online claims that he was involved in his children's deaths a "relentless, escalating and destructive defamation campaign," saying law enforcement has been notified. And in Frankfort, Illinois, Corie Walsh, 40, was ordered held without bond on three counts of first-degree murder in the death of her two-year-old son, Barrett; her attorneys say she was in a psychotic episode.

Join our new FB groups page here. Take the poll!

Join the Daily Crime & Justice community on social media! We're building a passionate group of true crime enthusiasts who love diving deep into the most shocking cases in America.
Follow us on Facebook and Instagram by searching "Daily Crime & Justice" on either platform.


You'll get exclusive behind-the-scenes content, breaking news updates on cases we're covering, and early alerts when new episodes drop. Our social media is where Garret Fisher's hottest takes live, including reactions that don't make it into the show.

But more importantly, it's where YOU come in. Share your theories, debate the verdicts, and connect with fellow listeners who are just as obsessed with justice as you are. Did the jury get it right? What questions do you still have? Your comments and insights often shape future episodes.


We cover the trials that matter, but our community makes the conversation unforgettable. Come for Garret's signature cynical commentary, stay for the incredible discussions with thousands of true crime fans who get it.

WEBVTT

1
00:00:03.250 --> 00:00:10.230
Calaroga Shark Media. Good morning.

2
00:00:10.570 --> 00:00:13.990
This is Daily Crime and Justice from Calaroga Shark Media,

3
00:00:14.210 --> 00:00:20.500
powered by AI. I'm Garrett Fisher. It's Thursday, September 10th, 2026.

4
00:00:20.500 --> 00:00:23.120
On Monday, we said we were putting the Lindsay Clancy

5
00:00:23.160 --> 00:00:27.719
case down until Judge Sullivan reconvenes on September 29th. That

6
00:00:27.760 --> 00:00:30.640
lasted about 48 hours, and it is not because we

7
00:00:30.679 --> 00:00:33.950
went looking. It is because four of the 12 people

8
00:00:33.990 --> 00:00:36.590
who sat in that jury room have now given interviews,

9
00:00:36.850 --> 00:00:39.780
and their accounts do not match each other. Three of

10
00:00:39.820 --> 00:00:42.340
them went on television Tuesday and blamed one man for

11
00:00:42.359 --> 00:00:45.719
the mistrial. The foreperson said she was excited to be

12
00:00:45.780 --> 00:00:48.060
filling out the not guilty forms when he told her

13
00:00:48.119 --> 00:00:51.560
he still would not sign. And then a fourth juror

14
00:00:51.619 --> 00:00:55.210
gave a completely different picture of that room. She said

15
00:00:55.250 --> 00:00:58.509
the majority was trying to sway him from the very beginnings.

16
00:00:59.219 --> 00:01:01.399
She said he was not the only person in there

17
00:01:01.460 --> 00:01:04.700
who refused to move. And she said she would defend him.

18
00:01:05.420 --> 00:01:08.530
Also this week, Patrick Clancy's lawyer put out a statement

19
00:01:08.569 --> 00:01:11.250
warning the people who have spent months accusing him of

20
00:01:11.329 --> 00:01:14.730
murdering his own children that law enforcement has been notified

21
00:01:14.930 --> 00:01:18.030
and there will be consequences. And then there is a

22
00:01:18.090 --> 00:01:20.299
case in Illinois that I have been going back and

23
00:01:20.359 --> 00:01:24.000
forth about all week involving a two-year-old boy named Barrett

24
00:01:24.400 --> 00:01:27.629
and a mother whose lawyers say she was psychotic. We

25
00:01:27.670 --> 00:01:29.780
are going to handle that one carefully, and I will

26
00:01:29.799 --> 00:01:31.680
tell you exactly what I am not.

27
00:01:31.540 --> 00:01:33.689
Going to do with it. Let's get into it.

28
00:01:38.340 --> 00:01:42.180
Last Friday, after seven days and roughly 38 hours, Judge

29
00:01:42.219 --> 00:01:45.620
William Sullivan declared a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case.

30
00:01:46.379 --> 00:01:49.640
Jury notes indicated the panel was split 11 to 1

31
00:01:49.640 --> 00:01:52.099
in favor of acquitting her on grounds of lack of

32
00:01:52.159 --> 00:01:57.329
criminal responsibility. Sullivan has temporarily sealed the jurors' names. That

33
00:01:57.469 --> 00:02:00.750
is a protective measure and a sensible one. Three of

34
00:02:00.790 --> 00:02:04.349
them came forward anyway, voluntarily, and sat down with NBC

35
00:02:04.409 --> 00:02:09.770
Boston on Tuesday. The foreperson, Ronnie Carlson, and two other jurors,

36
00:02:10.009 --> 00:02:13.990
Kelly Farina and Paula Devlin. Here's what they said, and

37
00:02:14.030 --> 00:02:15.729
I want to be fair to them because some of

38
00:02:15.830 --> 00:02:19.629
it is genuinely illuminating. Carlson explained what the jury was

39
00:02:19.830 --> 00:02:22.349
actually doing in there, and she explained it better than

40
00:02:22.409 --> 00:02:25.460
most of the coverage has. She said they were not

41
00:02:25.539 --> 00:02:28.319
trying to figure out whether Lindsay Clancy killed the children.

42
00:02:28.639 --> 00:02:31.219
She did, and she admitted it. They were trying to

43
00:02:31.259 --> 00:02:33.740
figure out whether she knew right from wrong at the time.

44
00:02:34.430 --> 00:02:37.389
And she described how she got there. She said everything

45
00:02:37.430 --> 00:02:41.330
in that trial proved this woman loved her children, the journals,

46
00:02:41.990 --> 00:02:45.849
her mother-in-law's testimony, all of it. And that if that

47
00:02:45.889 --> 00:02:49.009
was true, then something must have broken. That is a

48
00:02:49.129 --> 00:02:52.800
jury doing its job. Then she described the moment it

49
00:02:52.840 --> 00:02:56.759
fell apart. She said the holdout had reasonable doubt, that

50
00:02:56.900 --> 00:03:00.300
he admitted he had reasonable doubt. She said she started

51
00:03:00.340 --> 00:03:03.080
filling out the forms, that there were three of them,

52
00:03:03.419 --> 00:03:06.340
and that she was so excited. And then he said

53
00:03:06.479 --> 00:03:09.719
he was still not going to say she was not guilty.

54
00:03:10.659 --> 00:03:13.419
Paula Devlin described that juror as arrogant and said he

55
00:03:13.479 --> 00:03:17.379
really did not take in anything anybody said. The three

56
00:03:17.400 --> 00:03:21.379
of them also said they found Kevin Reddington entertaining, that

57
00:03:21.430 --> 00:03:24.270
his whole demeanor was funny. that he made one of

58
00:03:24.310 --> 00:03:28.689
them laugh out loud, and that they needed some of that. Now,

59
00:03:28.849 --> 00:03:32.310
those two things, being excited and being entertained, have set

60
00:03:32.349 --> 00:03:36.080
off a considerable amount of anger online. People are furious

61
00:03:36.120 --> 00:03:38.860
that a juror described herself as excited to sign an

62
00:03:38.900 --> 00:03:42.139
acquittal in a case with three dead children, and furious

63
00:03:42.180 --> 00:03:44.819
that anybody found anything in that courtroom entertaining.

64
00:03:45.680 --> 00:03:47.969
I want to push back on that, at least partly.

65
00:03:48.710 --> 00:03:51.490
Those 12 people sat through five and a half weeks

66
00:03:51.550 --> 00:03:54.460
of the worst material any of them will ever encounter.

67
00:03:55.159 --> 00:03:57.819
If a defense attorney with 50 years of courtroom instincts

68
00:03:57.960 --> 00:04:02.919
occasionally broke the tension, that is not disrespect. That is

69
00:04:02.979 --> 00:04:06.060
how human beings survive a room like that. Anybody who

70
00:04:06.080 --> 00:04:09.319
has worked a hospital, a firehouse, or a homicide unit

71
00:04:09.699 --> 00:04:13.719
knows exactly what that is. And the word excited in

72
00:04:13.780 --> 00:04:17.310
context is a woman describing the moment she thought seven

73
00:04:17.329 --> 00:04:21.129
days of deadlock were finally over. It was clumsy. It

74
00:04:21.170 --> 00:04:25.509
was not celebratory. But then, on Tuesday, a fourth juror

75
00:04:25.560 --> 00:04:28.939
talked to CBS Boston, and she told a different story.

76
00:04:29.540 --> 00:04:31.839
She has not been named. She said she had not

77
00:04:31.899 --> 00:04:34.819
followed the case at all before she was summoned, because

78
00:04:34.860 --> 00:04:37.300
she does not watch the news, and she described herself

79
00:04:37.360 --> 00:04:39.990
as close to a perfect juror for this trial. She

80
00:04:40.019 --> 00:04:42.149
has no children of her own. She walked in with

81
00:04:42.209 --> 00:04:45.879
no view. And her initial view after hearing the evidence

82
00:04:46.259 --> 00:04:50.129
was that Lindsay Clancy was guilty. She said originally she

83
00:04:50.189 --> 00:04:54.550
felt Clancy was guilty and criminally responsible. She voted to

84
00:04:54.610 --> 00:04:57.829
acquit anyway. And here is what she said about that.

85
00:04:58.430 --> 00:05:01.569
Maybe she still believes it in a certain way. Think

86
00:05:01.610 --> 00:05:04.069
about that for a second. That is a juror who

87
00:05:04.110 --> 00:05:07.189
voted not guilty and is telling you out loud that

88
00:05:07.269 --> 00:05:10.620
she is not at peace with it. That is not weakness.

89
00:05:11.279 --> 00:05:14.930
That is what reasonable doubt actually feels like from the inside.

90
00:05:15.379 --> 00:05:17.829
You do not have to be convinced of innocence. You

91
00:05:17.870 --> 00:05:20.870
have to be unconvinced of guilt. And those are extremely

92
00:05:20.930 --> 00:05:24.009
different things. And almost nobody who has not sat on

93
00:05:24.050 --> 00:05:28.230
a jury understands the difference. She explained why she got there.

94
00:05:28.589 --> 00:05:30.730
She said she believed this was a woman who was

95
00:05:30.810 --> 00:05:33.600
not mentally healthy, who was in the throes of a

96
00:05:33.660 --> 00:05:36.939
significant mental crisis, and who was so deep in it

97
00:05:37.000 --> 00:05:39.610
she could not see her way out. And she said

98
00:05:39.649 --> 00:05:44.670
the prosecution never gave her a moment where she could say, yes, 100%,

99
00:05:44.670 --> 00:05:47.709
I am certain. She said there was too much gray area.

100
00:05:48.230 --> 00:05:51.360
Now here is the part that matters most. She was

101
00:05:51.449 --> 00:05:54.180
asked about the holdout. And she did not join the

102
00:05:54.199 --> 00:05:56.879
pile on. She said that juror was not the only

103
00:05:56.980 --> 00:05:58.899
one in that room who was unwilling to see things

104
00:05:58.920 --> 00:06:01.939
from the other side. She said there were some big

105
00:06:02.000 --> 00:06:05.490
personalities in there. She said the majority of the room

106
00:06:05.519 --> 00:06:08.709
was trying to sway that person from the very beginning.

107
00:06:09.240 --> 00:06:11.980
and she said plainly that she would defend that individual.

108
00:06:12.439 --> 00:06:14.879
She also described shouting loud enough to be heard from

109
00:06:15.019 --> 00:06:17.670
other rooms in the courthouse. So now you have two

110
00:06:17.730 --> 00:06:21.129
accounts from inside the same room. One is three people

111
00:06:21.170 --> 00:06:23.769
describing an arrogant man who would not engage.

112
00:06:24.410 --> 00:06:25.209
The other is a.

113
00:06:25.250 --> 00:06:28.649
Fourth person describing 11 people leaning on one from the

114
00:06:28.689 --> 00:06:32.750
moment the door closed, with big personalities and raised voices.

115
00:06:33.449 --> 00:06:36.300
Both of those accounts came from people who were actually there.

116
00:06:36.740 --> 00:06:39.819
Both of them are probably partly true. And that is

117
00:06:39.899 --> 00:06:44.009
precisely why deliberations are secret. And precisely why I said

118
00:06:44.089 --> 00:06:47.089
on Monday that a note from a foreperson is not

119
00:06:47.149 --> 00:06:50.089
a finding of fact. It is one person's account of

120
00:06:50.129 --> 00:06:53.230
an argument. Look, I'm going to say the same thing

121
00:06:53.310 --> 00:06:55.959
I said Monday and I am going to keep saying it.

122
00:06:56.500 --> 00:06:59.779
That man has not spoken publicly. His name is under seal.

123
00:07:00.300 --> 00:07:04.470
He did nothing that any court has found improper. Judge

124
00:07:04.529 --> 00:07:07.920
Sullivan looked directly at the accusation that he was refusing

125
00:07:07.949 --> 00:07:09.980
to follow the law and said the note did not

126
00:07:10.060 --> 00:07:12.759
show that. And in the space of one week, he

127
00:07:12.779 --> 00:07:15.420
has been accused of perjury in open court by a

128
00:07:15.459 --> 00:07:19.540
defense attorney, told on national television to lose sleep, and

129
00:07:19.600 --> 00:07:22.220
now described as arrogant by his fellow jurors on the

130
00:07:22.279 --> 00:07:24.959
local news. And a fourth juror who was in the

131
00:07:25.019 --> 00:07:28.560
same room says the pressure ran the other way. The

132
00:07:28.680 --> 00:07:31.069
one thing everybody seems to agree on is that he

133
00:07:31.110 --> 00:07:34.990
had reasonable doubt and would not vote to acquit. And

134
00:07:35.009 --> 00:07:38.170
I want to be careful here, because if that is accurate,

135
00:07:38.350 --> 00:07:41.610
it may in fact be a misunderstanding of the instruction.

136
00:07:42.589 --> 00:07:45.629
Reasonable doubt about guilt is supposed to produce a not

137
00:07:45.689 --> 00:07:49.170
guilty verdict. That is what it is for. But we

138
00:07:49.230 --> 00:07:51.870
do not know what he actually thought, because he has

139
00:07:51.930 --> 00:07:55.550
not said a word. And until he does, the only

140
00:07:55.610 --> 00:07:58.829
fair position is the one Judge Sullivan took. You do

141
00:07:58.870 --> 00:08:01.730
not get to referee somebody's conscience from outside the room.

142
00:08:02.490 --> 00:08:05.470
There is one more thing from that fourth juror, and

143
00:08:05.629 --> 00:08:08.329
it is the most important thing anybody has said about

144
00:08:08.370 --> 00:08:11.920
this case in two weeks. She talked about Patrick Clancy's

145
00:08:11.920 --> 00:08:15.019
911 call, the one the judge ordered the cameras turned

146
00:08:15.120 --> 00:08:17.819
off for. She said she will never be the same

147
00:08:17.899 --> 00:08:23.079
after that call. She described a visceral, blood-curdling scream. And

148
00:08:23.139 --> 00:08:26.139
she said that the people online pushing theories that Patrick

149
00:08:26.180 --> 00:08:29.120
had something to do with his children's deaths would feel

150
00:08:29.259 --> 00:08:32.649
differently if they had heard it. Cora Clancy was five.

151
00:08:33.090 --> 00:08:37.320
Dawson Clancy was three. Callan Clancy was eight months old.

152
00:08:37.840 --> 00:08:40.519
Twelve strangers heard something on a recording that they will

153
00:08:40.580 --> 00:08:41.399
carry for the.

154
00:08:41.440 --> 00:08:42.519
Rest of their lives.

155
00:08:43.179 --> 00:08:47.009
Someone has to say their names. When we come back,

156
00:08:47.309 --> 00:08:49.750
the father of those three children has hired a lawyer

157
00:08:49.870 --> 00:08:52.250
and is coming after the people who say he killed them.

158
00:09:01.519 --> 00:09:05.330
On the night of January 24th, 2023, Patrick Clancy left

159
00:09:05.370 --> 00:09:07.789
his house to pick up takeout and a prescription for

160
00:09:07.850 --> 00:09:08.950
his five-year-old daughter.

161
00:09:09.529 --> 00:09:11.169
He was gone about 25 minutes.

162
00:09:11.509 --> 00:09:13.389
He came home to find his wife outside in the

163
00:09:13.450 --> 00:09:16.690
snow and his three children dead in the basement. He

164
00:09:16.730 --> 00:09:19.250
was the first witness the Commonwealth called at his wife's

165
00:09:19.309 --> 00:09:22.690
murder trial. He testified about all of it. He has

166
00:09:22.730 --> 00:09:26.830
since divorced her, remarried, and moved out of Massachusetts. He

167
00:09:26.870 --> 00:09:29.830
has also publicly forgiven her and described her as a

168
00:09:29.929 --> 00:09:33.830
good mother who became ill. And for months, a substantial

169
00:09:33.889 --> 00:09:36.090
number of people on the internet have been saying he

170
00:09:36.190 --> 00:09:40.509
did it. On Tuesday morning, his attorney, Howard Cooper, issued

171
00:09:40.549 --> 00:09:43.529
a statement. And it is one of the more direct

172
00:09:43.570 --> 00:09:46.409
things I have read from a lawyer this year. Cooper

173
00:09:46.450 --> 00:09:49.100
said that over the past months, Patrick Clancy and his

174
00:09:49.159 --> 00:09:53.519
family have been subjected to a relentless, escalating, and destructive

175
00:09:53.559 --> 00:09:56.980
defamation campaign. He said it has been launched and promoted

176
00:09:57.019 --> 00:10:02.570
by minor celebrities, so-called influencers, and outright conspiracy theorists, who

177
00:10:02.610 --> 00:10:05.210
he said appear intent on boosting their own social media

178
00:10:05.250 --> 00:10:08.360
profiles and their own profit by publishing what they know

179
00:10:08.409 --> 00:10:12.019
to be falsehoods. He said it has resulted in real-life

180
00:10:12.059 --> 00:10:16.059
threats to his clients' reputation, livelihood, and life. And then,

181
00:10:16.639 --> 00:10:20.840
enough is enough. Those responsible should understand that there will

182
00:10:20.860 --> 00:10:25.299
be consequences, and every appropriate measure will be pursued to

183
00:10:25.360 --> 00:10:30.669
hold them accountable, including legally. Law enforcement has been notified.

184
00:10:31.029 --> 00:10:34.669
A legal analyst described the statement as essentially a cease

185
00:10:34.730 --> 00:10:37.529
and desist letter, and that is exactly what it is.

186
00:10:38.169 --> 00:10:40.970
It is not a lawsuit. It is a warning shot

187
00:10:41.049 --> 00:10:43.590
with a firm's name on it. Now let me deal

188
00:10:43.629 --> 00:10:47.500
with the underlying claim directly, because it deserves about 15

189
00:10:47.500 --> 00:10:51.360
seconds and then it deserves to be over. Lindsay Clancy

190
00:10:51.379 --> 00:10:54.360
has admitted through counsel that she killed her three children.

191
00:10:54.639 --> 00:10:57.080
Her own defense at trial was not that somebody else

192
00:10:57.120 --> 00:11:00.159
did it. It was that she was not criminally responsible

193
00:11:00.210 --> 00:11:03.250
when she did it. The prosecution and the defense agreed

194
00:11:03.309 --> 00:11:05.570
on this point. There was no dispute about it in

195
00:11:05.610 --> 00:11:08.460
that courtroom for five and a half weeks. And there

196
00:11:08.600 --> 00:11:12.840
is CVS surveillance video and phone records placing Patrick Clancy

197
00:11:13.019 --> 00:11:16.220
away from that house. The theory that he was involved

198
00:11:16.279 --> 00:11:17.460
never came up at trial.

199
00:11:17.940 --> 00:11:18.539
Not once.

200
00:11:19.019 --> 00:11:22.600
Because there is nothing to it. So could he actually sue?

201
00:11:23.019 --> 00:11:27.610
Probably against the right defendants. Defamation requires a false statement

202
00:11:27.629 --> 00:11:31.049
of fact published to others made with the required level

203
00:11:31.070 --> 00:11:35.309
of fault that causes harm. Accusing a named private individual

204
00:11:35.350 --> 00:11:37.649
of murdering his own children is about as clean a

205
00:11:37.690 --> 00:11:41.620
false statement of fact as you can construct. Patrick Clancy

206
00:11:41.740 --> 00:11:44.000
is not a public figure in the legal sense, which

207
00:11:44.080 --> 00:11:47.940
lowers his burden considerably. The practical problems are the ones

208
00:11:47.980 --> 00:11:51.419
that always apply. Some of these accounts are anonymous, and

209
00:11:51.600 --> 00:11:55.840
unmasking them means subpoenas to platforms that fight subpoenas. Some

210
00:11:55.960 --> 00:12:00.759
are overseas and effectively beyond reach. Suing is expensive and slow,

211
00:12:01.019 --> 00:12:03.179
and every filing feeds the thing it is trying to

212
00:12:03.259 --> 00:12:07.090
stop because a lawsuit is content too. And there is

213
00:12:07.149 --> 00:12:11.370
a harder problem underneath all of it. Section 230 of

214
00:12:11.409 --> 00:12:15.190
the Communications Decency Act means the platforms carrying this material

215
00:12:15.549 --> 00:12:19.269
are generally not liable for what their users post. So

216
00:12:19.309 --> 00:12:22.820
the person with a following of 2 million faces a lawsuit.

217
00:12:23.360 --> 00:12:25.399
The company that put the video in front of 2

218
00:12:25.399 --> 00:12:29.539
million people does not. That is the entire architecture of

219
00:12:29.580 --> 00:12:32.960
this problem, and no defamation suit filed by one grieving

220
00:12:33.019 --> 00:12:35.620
father is going to change it. But I want to

221
00:12:35.740 --> 00:12:38.009
end this segment on the line in that statement that

222
00:12:38.190 --> 00:12:42.250
almost nobody has quoted. Cooper said Patrick has no choice

223
00:12:42.309 --> 00:12:44.789
but to address this so he can return his attention

224
00:12:44.830 --> 00:12:48.690
to what matters. Preserving the memory of Cora, Dawson, and

225
00:12:48.750 --> 00:12:53.559
Callan Clancy, and supporting other women facing perinatal mental health challenges.

226
00:12:53.940 --> 00:12:56.700
That is not a line a lawyer writes for effect.

227
00:12:57.299 --> 00:13:01.659
Patrick Clancy has been doing exactly that publicly for three years.

228
00:13:02.419 --> 00:13:04.159
He is the person who stood up and said his

229
00:13:04.220 --> 00:13:07.000
wife was sick when saying anything else would have been

230
00:13:07.120 --> 00:13:10.419
easier and more sympathetic. The man whose three children were

231
00:13:10.460 --> 00:13:13.259
killed by their mother is spending his time supporting women

232
00:13:13.320 --> 00:13:17.179
with perinatal mental illness. And while he does that, people

233
00:13:17.220 --> 00:13:19.639
with ring lights are telling their followers he is a

234
00:13:19.820 --> 00:13:21.440
murderer for engagement.

235
00:13:22.019 --> 00:13:25.000
That's not a mistake. That's a choice. And there is

236
00:13:25.139 --> 00:13:25.690
money in it.

237
00:13:26.610 --> 00:13:29.580
That is the entire business model, and it is why

238
00:13:29.639 --> 00:13:34.179
he is finally hiring lawyers. When we come back, a

239
00:13:34.240 --> 00:13:36.639
case in Illinois that I want to be very careful with.

240
00:13:50.169 --> 00:13:52.830
Before I start this, one word about why it is

241
00:13:52.889 --> 00:13:55.330
on the show at all. For six weeks, we have

242
00:13:55.370 --> 00:13:58.519
said the Lindsay Clancy case is really a story about

243
00:13:58.559 --> 00:14:01.340
a mental health system that watched a woman come apart

244
00:14:01.519 --> 00:14:04.779
and did nothing in time. If we only make that

245
00:14:04.860 --> 00:14:07.940
argument when it is comfortable and historical, we are not

246
00:14:08.000 --> 00:14:10.320
making it. So we are going to make it about

247
00:14:10.360 --> 00:14:13.590
a case from nine days ago. Barrett Walsh was two

248
00:14:13.620 --> 00:14:16.750
years old. He lived in Frankfort, Illinois, which is about

249
00:14:16.750 --> 00:14:20.549
40 miles southwest of Chicago, with his mother, his father,

250
00:14:20.850 --> 00:14:25.059
and three siblings. On September 1st, he died in that house.

251
00:14:25.600 --> 00:14:28.779
His mother, Corey Walsh, who is 40, has been charged

252
00:14:28.840 --> 00:14:32.539
with three counts of first-degree murder. On Tuesday, a Will

253
00:14:32.580 --> 00:14:35.860
County judge granted the prosecution's petition to hold her without

254
00:14:35.980 --> 00:14:39.340
bond pending trial. She appeared in court in a red

255
00:14:39.399 --> 00:14:43.100
jumpsuit with a bandage on her wrist, in handcuffs and shackles,

256
00:14:43.539 --> 00:14:46.919
at times with her head down. Her husband, Michael, was

257
00:14:46.990 --> 00:14:50.279
not there. He was at Barrett's funeral. I am not

258
00:14:50.340 --> 00:14:53.159
going to describe how Barrett died. It is in the

259
00:14:53.220 --> 00:14:55.629
court file, it is in other coverage if you want it,

260
00:14:55.899 --> 00:14:59.309
and it adds nothing here. Here is what her lawyers

261
00:14:59.350 --> 00:15:02.870
say happened. Attorney Robert Kerr told the court his client

262
00:15:02.889 --> 00:15:05.509
was in a state of psychosis. He said that when

263
00:15:05.570 --> 00:15:09.870
first responders arrived, she was in and out of consciousness, incoherent,

264
00:15:09.990 --> 00:15:12.649
calling out the names of different kinds of fruit and singing,

265
00:15:12.889 --> 00:15:16.200
follow the yellow brick road. He said she is severely

266
00:15:16.250 --> 00:15:20.419
mentally ill, was experiencing hallucinations, and has a psychotic disorder.

267
00:15:21.139 --> 00:15:24.220
According to court documents, she told officers she believed her

268
00:15:24.299 --> 00:15:28.950
son was the devil. Her co-counsel is Andrea Lyon, who

269
00:15:28.990 --> 00:15:33.029
nearly two decades ago briefly served on Casey Anthony's defense team.

270
00:15:33.929 --> 00:15:35.490
Lyon's statement was short.

271
00:15:35.950 --> 00:15:38.610
This is a tragedy for the whole family, and it

272
00:15:38.669 --> 00:15:41.879
is also a tragedy that Corey herself was experiencing a

273
00:15:41.980 --> 00:15:43.919
psychotic episode when it happened.

274
00:15:44.929 --> 00:15:47.549
She said afterward that there are no winners here.

275
00:15:47.980 --> 00:15:51.279
Her own psychiatrist, according to her lawyers, described her as

276
00:15:51.360 --> 00:15:54.340
a good mother who attended to her children's special needs.

277
00:15:55.080 --> 00:15:58.720
Prosecutors argued she poses a real and present threat, and

278
00:15:58.759 --> 00:16:03.179
the judge agreed. Her other three children were unharmed. Two

279
00:16:03.259 --> 00:16:05.779
school-age children came home and called a neighbor for help.

280
00:16:06.440 --> 00:16:08.879
An infant was found on the main floor. Now the

281
00:16:08.919 --> 00:16:11.679
part that put this case on national television, and the

282
00:16:11.720 --> 00:16:16.700
part I have thought hardest about. Prosecutors say witnesses told

283
00:16:16.720 --> 00:16:20.399
investigators that Corey Walsh had recently become very invested in

284
00:16:20.450 --> 00:16:24.299
the Lindsay Clancy trial, that she followed it, discussed it,

285
00:16:24.590 --> 00:16:27.149
and according to one report, was discussing it in a

286
00:16:27.210 --> 00:16:31.090
group text in the hours before her son died. TMZ

287
00:16:31.149 --> 00:16:34.269
has already run a headline calling her an alleged Lindsay

288
00:16:34.309 --> 00:16:37.830
Clancy copycat. I am not going to do that, and

289
00:16:37.870 --> 00:16:41.529
I want to tell you exactly why. Nobody knows whether

290
00:16:41.590 --> 00:16:44.330
watching a trial had anything to do with what happened

291
00:16:44.389 --> 00:16:48.970
in that house. Not the prosecutors, not the defense, not me.

292
00:16:49.690 --> 00:16:53.250
Millions of people followed the Clancy trial obsessively for six

293
00:16:53.289 --> 00:16:57.480
weeks and did not harm anybody. The overwhelming majority of

294
00:16:57.529 --> 00:17:00.519
people with serious mental illness never hurt anyone at all

295
00:17:00.940 --> 00:17:03.240
and are far more likely to be victims of violence

296
00:17:03.279 --> 00:17:06.319
than to commit it. Drawing a causal line from a

297
00:17:06.380 --> 00:17:09.680
true crime obsession to a dead toddler is not analysis.

298
00:17:10.390 --> 00:17:12.869
It is a headline, and it is a dangerous one,

299
00:17:13.029 --> 00:17:16.190
because the message every struggling mother in America receives from

300
00:17:16.250 --> 00:17:19.150
it is, do not tell anyone what is in your head,

301
00:17:19.450 --> 00:17:21.089
or they will look at you the way they are

302
00:17:21.109 --> 00:17:24.710
looking at her. That is the exact opposite of what

303
00:17:24.819 --> 00:17:26.150
anybody should be doing this week.

304
00:17:26.880 --> 00:17:27.930
What I will say is this.

305
00:17:28.339 --> 00:17:30.259
Her lawyers put a picture in front of that judge

306
00:17:30.339 --> 00:17:33.079
on Tuesday of a woman who, by their account, was

307
00:17:33.180 --> 00:17:35.220
floridly psychotic when police arrived.

308
00:17:35.900 --> 00:17:36.619
Yelling fruit.

309
00:17:37.119 --> 00:17:40.319
Singing a song from a children's movie. bleeding from her

310
00:17:40.400 --> 00:17:44.680
own wrist, telling officers her toddler was the devil. If

311
00:17:44.720 --> 00:17:47.380
that is accurate, then somewhere in the days and weeks

312
00:17:47.420 --> 00:17:52.589
before September 1st, there were people who saw her. A husband, neighbors,

313
00:17:53.130 --> 00:17:56.549
a psychiatrist she apparently already had, and the machinery that

314
00:17:56.609 --> 00:17:59.269
is supposed to catch someone in that condition did not

315
00:17:59.329 --> 00:18:03.099
catch her in time. That is not a Lindsay Clancy story.

316
00:18:03.599 --> 00:18:06.140
It is the same story we have been telling since July,

317
00:18:06.400 --> 00:18:10.650
which is that this country is extraordinarily bad at intervening

318
00:18:10.710 --> 00:18:14.930
in a psychiatric emergency before it becomes a homicide. There

319
00:18:15.009 --> 00:18:18.430
is one legal difference between these two cases that is enormous,

320
00:18:18.730 --> 00:18:21.210
and I want you to understand it, because it will

321
00:18:21.250 --> 00:18:25.490
decide what happens to Corey Walsh. In Massachusetts, once criminal

322
00:18:25.559 --> 00:18:29.980
responsibility is genuinely in play, the burden is on the prosecution.

323
00:18:30.769 --> 00:18:34.349
The Commonwealth had to prove Lindsay Clancy was criminally responsible

324
00:18:34.410 --> 00:18:38.190
beyond a reasonable doubt, and 11 of 12 jurors said

325
00:18:38.250 --> 00:18:41.779
it had not. In Illinois, the burden runs the other way.

326
00:18:42.190 --> 00:18:46.180
The defense has to prove insanity. A legal analyst put

327
00:18:46.220 --> 00:18:48.740
it plainly this week, it is a harder road in

328
00:18:48.839 --> 00:18:53.259
Illinois than it was in Massachusetts. Same claim, opposite burden,

329
00:18:53.519 --> 00:18:57.359
different state line. And Illinois has a third option that

330
00:18:57.420 --> 00:19:01.059
Massachusetts does not, which is a verdict of guilty but

331
00:19:01.119 --> 00:19:04.920
mentally ill. That is a conviction. You go to prison,

332
00:19:05.160 --> 00:19:08.210
and you are supposed to receive treatment there. Critics have

333
00:19:08.289 --> 00:19:11.089
argued for decades that it is a compromise verdict that

334
00:19:11.130 --> 00:19:14.289
lets juries feel humane while producing the same outcome as

335
00:19:14.329 --> 00:19:18.069
a conviction, and it exists in about a dozen states.

336
00:19:18.799 --> 00:19:22.190
That is not a small technicality. That is very likely

337
00:19:22.250 --> 00:19:24.970
the difference between a hospital and a prison, and it

338
00:19:25.029 --> 00:19:27.690
depends entirely on which side of a border a woman

339
00:19:27.730 --> 00:19:28.859
happened to be living on.

340
00:19:29.619 --> 00:19:31.119
Barrett Walsh was two years old.

341
00:19:31.400 --> 00:19:33.799
He had three brothers and sisters, and two of them

342
00:19:33.859 --> 00:19:35.900
came home from school that day and had to go

343
00:19:35.940 --> 00:19:39.619
get a neighbor. Corey Walsh is presumed innocent. She has

344
00:19:39.640 --> 00:19:42.849
been convicted of nothing. Everything her lawyers said in court

345
00:19:42.890 --> 00:19:45.349
on Tuesday is an assertion that has not been tested,

346
00:19:45.789 --> 00:19:47.509
and everything prosecutors said.

347
00:19:47.390 --> 00:19:51.200
Is an allegation. But Barrett is not. not an allegation.

348
00:19:51.220 --> 00:19:52.319
He was two.

349
00:19:53.039 --> 00:19:55.299
Someone has to say his name, and I would rather

350
00:19:55.339 --> 00:19:57.619
it was said here than in a headline calling his

351
00:19:57.759 --> 00:20:05.450
mother a copycat. That's the show for Thursday, September 10th.

352
00:20:05.890 --> 00:20:08.789
Tomorrow is September 11th, and it is the 25th anniversary.

353
00:20:10.539 --> 00:20:13.599
We are doing something different. The entire legal story of

354
00:20:13.640 --> 00:20:18.779
that day, which almost nobody tells. 25 years and there

355
00:20:18.839 --> 00:20:22.369
has never been a trial. There is also a deadline

356
00:20:22.390 --> 00:20:24.529
tomorrow that some of you need to know about. So

357
00:20:24.809 --> 00:20:28.750
please listen. If today was useful, send it to one person.

358
00:20:29.490 --> 00:20:32.529
And if you're listening on Spotify, drop a comment about

359
00:20:32.569 --> 00:20:35.490
the jurors. Four people who sat in the same room

360
00:20:35.529 --> 00:20:38.289
have now given two different accounts of it. Which one

361
00:20:38.329 --> 00:20:40.630
do you believe? And does it change what you think

362
00:20:40.650 --> 00:20:43.369
should happen next? I'm Garrett Fisher.

363
00:20:43.890 --> 00:20:49.309
Do better. A few notes on sourcing. On the jurors.

364
00:20:49.839 --> 00:20:53.559
Judge Sullivan has temporarily sealed the jurors' names. Three jurors

365
00:20:53.619 --> 00:20:57.960
identified themselves voluntarily in an interview with NBC Boston. A

366
00:20:58.019 --> 00:21:01.980
fourth spoke anonymously to CBS Boston. Their accounts of what

367
00:21:02.019 --> 00:21:06.549
happened during deliberations are their own recollections and characterizations. They

368
00:21:06.589 --> 00:21:09.819
conflict with one another in significant respects. and none of

369
00:21:09.880 --> 00:21:13.309
them has been tested or verified. The juror they describe

370
00:21:13.369 --> 00:21:16.990
has not spoken publicly, has not been identified, and has

371
00:21:17.069 --> 00:21:20.210
not been found by any court to have done anything improper.

372
00:21:20.930 --> 00:21:24.289
Judge Sullivan expressly declined to find that he refused to

373
00:21:24.349 --> 00:21:27.150
follow the law. We are not going to identify or

374
00:21:27.250 --> 00:21:31.250
further describe him. On Patrick Clancy, the claim that he

375
00:21:31.289 --> 00:21:34.190
had any involvement in his children's deaths was never raised

376
00:21:34.250 --> 00:21:38.160
at trial by either side. Lindsay Clancy admitted through counsel

377
00:21:38.220 --> 00:21:41.160
that she killed the children. Her defense was lack of

378
00:21:41.240 --> 00:21:45.029
criminal responsibility. The statement described here was issued by his

379
00:21:45.089 --> 00:21:48.910
attorney and threatens potential legal action. No lawsuit has been

380
00:21:48.950 --> 00:21:52.890
filed as of recording. On the Illinois case, Corey Walsh

381
00:21:52.930 --> 00:21:56.109
has been charged and is presumed innocent. She has not

382
00:21:56.150 --> 00:22:00.210
been convicted of anything. The description of her condition comes

383
00:22:00.230 --> 00:22:03.220
from her defense attorney's arguments at a detention hearing and

384
00:22:03.279 --> 00:22:07.279
from court documents and has not been tested. Her lawyers

385
00:22:07.319 --> 00:22:10.240
have stated she has not been diagnosed with postpartum depression

386
00:22:10.400 --> 00:22:14.619
or postpartum psychosis, and this is not a postpartum case.

387
00:22:15.559 --> 00:22:17.700
The claim that she had an interest in the Lindsay

388
00:22:17.740 --> 00:22:19.259
Clancy trial comes.

389
00:22:19.029 --> 00:22:20.849
From prosecutors citing witnesses.

390
00:22:21.549 --> 00:22:24.630
No court has found any connection between that interest and

391
00:22:24.670 --> 00:22:27.369
the death of her son, and we do not assert one.

392
00:22:28.170 --> 00:22:32.109
We have deliberately not described how Barrett Walsh died. This

393
00:22:32.190 --> 00:22:36.710
episode discusses the deaths of children, suicide, and severe mental illness.

394
00:22:37.549 --> 00:22:40.869
If you are struggling, you can call or text 988

395
00:22:40.869 --> 00:22:44.660
in the United States to reach the suicide and crisis lifeline.

396
00:22:45.460 --> 00:22:49.140
For maternal mental health specifically, the National Maternal Mental Health

397
00:22:49.180 --> 00:22:56.200
Hotline is available by call or text at 1-833-TLC-MAMA. If

398
00:22:56.240 --> 00:22:58.670
you are having thoughts of harming yourself or a child,

399
00:22:58.769 --> 00:23:02.170
that is a medical emergency and help exists. And reaching

400
00:23:02.250 --> 00:23:04.400
out for it is the thing that protects everyone.