Welcome to Celebrity Trials - True Crime and Justice coverage updated daily.!
Sept. 2, 2026

D4vd Now Has a Public Defender, Bryan Kohberger Wants His Guilty Plea Back and His Judge Off the Case, a Surgeon Gives Up His Jury

D4vd Now Has a Public Defender, Bryan Kohberger Wants His Guilty Plea Back and His Judge Off the Case, a Surgeon Gives Up His Jury

The singer D4vd — David Anthony Burke, 21 — dropped his private defense team Monday and will be represented by the Los Angeles County Public Defender's Office, after Judge Charlaine Olmedo determined he qualified for appointed counsel. Blair Berk, Marilyn Bednarski and Regina Peter withdrew without stating a reason; deputy public defenders Walid Kandeel and Lisa Roth took over and entered not-guilty pleas the same morning. Burke is charged with murder with special circumstances, continuous sexual abuse of a child under 14, and unlawful mutilation of human remains in the death of 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez, whose remains were found in his Tesla in September 2025. He is presumed innocent. His next hearing is October 19; DA Nathan Hochman has not decided whether to seek the death penalty. Also: Bryan Kohberger's new attorney has moved to disqualify Judge Steven Hippler and return his post-conviction case to Latah County, as Kohberger seeks to withdraw the guilty plea he entered to the University of Idaho murders. And in Pinellas County, Florida, Tomasz Kosowski waived his right to a jury for both phases of his capital murder trial and declined to tell the judge why.

Join our new FB groups page here. Take the poll!

Join the Daily Crime & Justice community on social media! We're building a passionate group of true crime enthusiasts who love diving deep into the most shocking cases in America.
Follow us on Facebook and Instagram by searching "Daily Crime & Justice" on either platform.


You'll get exclusive behind-the-scenes content, breaking news updates on cases we're covering, and early alerts when new episodes drop. Our social media is where Garret Fisher's hottest takes live, including reactions that don't make it into the show.

But more importantly, it's where YOU come in. Share your theories, debate the verdicts, and connect with fellow listeners who are just as obsessed with justice as you are. Did the jury get it right? What questions do you still have? Your comments and insights often shape future episodes.


We cover the trials that matter, but our community makes the conversation unforgettable. Come for Garret's signature cynical commentary, stay for the incredible discussions with thousands of true crime fans who get it.

WEBVTT

1
00:00:03.250 --> 00:00:11.550
Calaroga Shark Media. Good morning. This is Daily Crime and

2
00:00:11.589 --> 00:00:16.980
Justice from Calaroga Shark Media, powered by AI. I'm Garrett Fisher.

3
00:00:17.280 --> 00:00:21.899
It's Wednesday, September 2nd, 2026. Quick word on Plymouth before

4
00:00:21.940 --> 00:00:25.179
anything else. As of the moment we recorded this, the

5
00:00:25.260 --> 00:00:28.219
jury in the Lindsay Clancy case was still out. They

6
00:00:28.260 --> 00:00:31.379
finished a fourth day of deliberations without a verdict, and

7
00:00:31.420 --> 00:00:34.350
they sent no notes on Monday. That case could break

8
00:00:34.390 --> 00:00:36.869
at any hour, including while you are listening to this.

9
00:00:37.329 --> 00:00:40.969
And when it does, we will have it in full. Today,

10
00:00:41.390 --> 00:00:44.609
we are going somewhere else. Because three defendants in three

11
00:00:44.670 --> 00:00:49.090
states just did something you almost never see. All of them,

12
00:00:49.229 --> 00:00:51.600
in the space of about a week, tried to change

13
00:00:51.659 --> 00:00:55.340
the basic rules of their own cases. In Los Angeles,

14
00:00:55.619 --> 00:00:58.520
a 21-year-old musician who by his own case's evidence has

15
00:00:58.619 --> 00:01:01.729
earned more than $ 10 million dollars stood in a courtroom

16
00:01:01.810 --> 00:01:05.890
and asked for a public defender. His high-powered attorneys walked.

17
00:01:06.390 --> 00:01:08.750
The family of the 14-year-old girl he is charged with

18
00:01:08.799 --> 00:01:12.219
killing says he is not broke at all. In Boise,

19
00:01:12.340 --> 00:01:15.599
Brian Koberger, who confessed in open court to murdering four

20
00:01:15.680 --> 00:01:19.239
University of Idaho students and was sentenced to four consecutive

21
00:01:19.280 --> 00:01:22.599
life terms, is trying to take it all back. He

22
00:01:22.680 --> 00:01:25.780
says he is innocent, that his own lawyers misled him,

23
00:01:26.079 --> 00:01:28.730
and last week his new attorney moved to disqualify the

24
00:01:28.829 --> 00:01:32.579
judge who sentenced him. And in Pinellas County, Florida, a

25
00:01:32.640 --> 00:01:36.980
plastic surgeon facing a death penalty prosecution has fired his lawyers,

26
00:01:37.359 --> 00:01:41.840
withdrawn his own motions, withdrawn all opposition to being executed,

27
00:01:42.280 --> 00:01:45.579
and on Monday, waived his right to a jury entirely.

28
00:01:46.000 --> 00:01:49.670
The judge asked him why. He would not say. Let's

29
00:01:49.730 --> 00:01:57.689
get into it. Celeste Hernandez was 14 years old. She

30
00:01:57.730 --> 00:02:00.689
lived with her family in Lake Elsinore, California. She has

31
00:02:00.709 --> 00:02:03.150
been dead since April of last year, and her remains

32
00:02:03.189 --> 00:02:06.810
were found in September of 2025 inside a Tesla registered

33
00:02:06.829 --> 00:02:10.419
to an address in the Hollywood Hills. David Anthony Burke

34
00:02:10.500 --> 00:02:13.340
is 21. He performs under a stage name that is

35
00:02:13.379 --> 00:02:16.199
stylized with numbers, and he is one of the more

36
00:02:16.259 --> 00:02:19.740
successful young musicians of the last few years. He has

37
00:02:19.780 --> 00:02:23.090
pleaded not guilty to murder, to continuous sexual abuse of

38
00:02:23.150 --> 00:02:26.349
a child under the age of 14, and to unlawful

39
00:02:26.409 --> 00:02:30.750
mutilation of human remains. In July, a Los Angeles County

40
00:02:30.810 --> 00:02:33.909
judge ruled there was enough evidence to send him to trial.

41
00:02:34.669 --> 00:02:38.210
Prosecutors allege he killed Celeste because he feared their relationship

42
00:02:38.250 --> 00:02:41.770
becoming public would end his career. I am not going

43
00:02:41.810 --> 00:02:44.449
to walk you through the evidence in this case. Some

44
00:02:44.469 --> 00:02:46.500
of it has been described in open court, and it

45
00:02:46.569 --> 00:02:49.099
is available if you want it, and I do not

46
00:02:49.180 --> 00:02:51.460
think there is a single thing our audience gains from

47
00:02:51.539 --> 00:02:54.939
hearing me describe what was done to a 14-year-old girl.

48
00:02:55.699 --> 00:02:58.830
What matters today is what happened Monday. and Monday was

49
00:02:58.870 --> 00:03:02.050
about money. Burke came into court for what should have

50
00:03:02.090 --> 00:03:06.030
been a routine pre-trial hearing. His attorneys had a meeting

51
00:03:06.069 --> 00:03:10.069
with Judge Charlene Almedo in Chambers. And when they came out,

52
00:03:10.409 --> 00:03:13.340
defense attorney Blair Burke told the courtroom that her client

53
00:03:13.409 --> 00:03:17.199
wanted a public defender. The judge asked Burke directly if

54
00:03:17.259 --> 00:03:20.580
that was what he wanted. He said yes. Burke and

55
00:03:20.620 --> 00:03:24.319
her co-counsel withdrew on the spot. Burke, in an orange

56
00:03:24.360 --> 00:03:28.509
jumpsuit and shackles, smiled and shook their hands as court adjourned.

57
00:03:29.349 --> 00:03:32.389
Burke said afterward that the court had granted their request

58
00:03:32.430 --> 00:03:35.569
to withdraw after it was determined he qualified for appointed

59
00:03:35.610 --> 00:03:39.639
counsel and that they continued to support him. The Los

60
00:03:39.740 --> 00:03:43.259
Angeles County Public Defender's Office took the case, and I

61
00:03:43.319 --> 00:03:45.479
want to give you their statement because it was a

62
00:03:45.599 --> 00:03:49.479
genuinely graceful thing to say in an ugly moment. They

63
00:03:49.560 --> 00:03:53.000
said they recognize the loss of life underlying the allegations

64
00:03:53.120 --> 00:03:56.650
and extend their sympathies to those who are grieving. And

65
00:03:56.710 --> 00:03:59.030
then they said that David Burke is entitled to a

66
00:03:59.069 --> 00:04:03.750
defense that takes his circumstances seriously and examines the evidence carefully,

67
00:04:04.129 --> 00:04:06.789
and that they are committed to providing it. That is

68
00:04:06.909 --> 00:04:10.189
exactly right, by the way. Every word of it. A

69
00:04:10.250 --> 00:04:12.949
public defender's office that takes a case like this one

70
00:04:13.110 --> 00:04:15.469
and says both of those things in the same breath

71
00:04:15.949 --> 00:04:19.470
is doing the job properly. Now. Here is the part

72
00:04:19.509 --> 00:04:23.120
that should stop you. Public defenders exist for people who

73
00:04:23.149 --> 00:04:26.240
cannot afford a lawyer. That is the entire point of

74
00:04:26.259 --> 00:04:30.579
the institution. It is a constitutional guarantee that your poverty

75
00:04:30.620 --> 00:04:34.110
does not determine whether you get a defense. And according

76
00:04:34.129 --> 00:04:37.230
to testimony given in this very case, David Burke has

77
00:04:37.389 --> 00:04:41.240
earned at least $ 10 million over his career. So the

78
00:04:41.300 --> 00:04:45.079
court found him indigent, which means either that $ 10 million

79
00:04:45.180 --> 00:04:48.319
is gone in about 18 months or that it is

80
00:04:48.399 --> 00:04:52.579
somewhere a court could not find it. Celeste Arivas Hernandez's

81
00:04:52.620 --> 00:04:55.319
family has an opinion about which one it is. They

82
00:04:55.379 --> 00:04:58.290
issued a statement saying he is not indigent at all

83
00:04:58.759 --> 00:05:01.949
and that he has moved his money into various corporations.

84
00:05:03.069 --> 00:05:05.189
I want to be careful here because that is an

85
00:05:05.250 --> 00:05:08.110
allegation by a grieving family and not a finding by

86
00:05:08.170 --> 00:05:12.180
any court. A judge reviewed his financial situation and concluded

87
00:05:12.209 --> 00:05:15.939
he qualified. That determination was made on evidence I have

88
00:05:16.000 --> 00:05:18.620
not seen. But look, I'm going to be honest with

89
00:05:18.639 --> 00:05:22.079
you about why this matters beyond one case. There is

90
00:05:22.139 --> 00:05:25.779
a version of this that is completely legitimate. Legal defense

91
00:05:25.899 --> 00:05:29.269
in a capital eligible murder case costs a staggering amount

92
00:05:29.310 --> 00:05:32.269
of money. Blair Burke is one of the most expensive

93
00:05:32.310 --> 00:05:36.050
criminal lawyers in Los Angeles. A young man could absolutely

94
00:05:36.110 --> 00:05:39.709
burn through millions in a year of pretrial litigation and

95
00:05:39.769 --> 00:05:44.100
be genuinely broke. And there is a version of this

96
00:05:44.180 --> 00:05:47.100
that is a shell game, where the money sits in

97
00:05:47.139 --> 00:05:50.560
an LLC and the LLC owns the assets, and the

98
00:05:50.600 --> 00:05:52.899
man who controls the LLC stands in front of a

99
00:05:53.000 --> 00:05:57.319
judge and correctly states that he personally has nothing. That

100
00:05:57.399 --> 00:06:00.689
is not fraud. That is structuring, and people with good

101
00:06:00.730 --> 00:06:04.949
lawyers do it every day. Accountability doesn't have a legal department.

102
00:06:05.509 --> 00:06:09.430
But it turns out that indigency sometimes does. And there

103
00:06:09.470 --> 00:06:12.649
is a real cost when a wealthy defendant qualifies, whether

104
00:06:12.720 --> 00:06:16.759
legitimately or not. The Los Angeles County Public Defender's Office

105
00:06:16.879 --> 00:06:19.439
is one of the busiest in the country, and every

106
00:06:19.480 --> 00:06:22.519
hour its investigators and attorneys spend on this case is

107
00:06:22.579 --> 00:06:25.699
an hour not spent on somebody who never had $ 10

108
00:06:25.420 --> 00:06:28.879
million and never will. That office will do this job

109
00:06:28.920 --> 00:06:32.339
well because that is what they do. But the arithmetic

110
00:06:32.500 --> 00:06:36.579
is the arithmetic. There is one more wrinkle worth understanding

111
00:06:36.639 --> 00:06:40.199
because it explains why the withdrawal was so abrupt. Burke's

112
00:06:40.259 --> 00:06:43.509
now former attorneys had been building a specific defense, and

113
00:06:43.550 --> 00:06:47.089
you could see it in the preliminary hearing. Prosecutors laid

114
00:06:47.149 --> 00:06:49.509
out that on the night in question, a rideshare was

115
00:06:49.550 --> 00:06:51.810
sent to pick Celeste up from her family's home in

116
00:06:51.829 --> 00:06:54.149
Lake Elsinore and bring her to a residence in the

117
00:06:54.189 --> 00:06:58.199
Hollywood Hills. and that records show her arriving at 1010

118
00:06:58.199 --> 00:07:00.860
in the evening, about an hour and 20 minutes before

119
00:07:00.920 --> 00:07:03.920
Burke's phone and car left that house heading north towards

120
00:07:03.980 --> 00:07:07.759
Santa Barbara County. The defense answer to that was narrow

121
00:07:07.860 --> 00:07:11.019
and technical. There is no evidence she ever got out

122
00:07:11.040 --> 00:07:14.139
of the rideshare vehicle. That is the kind of argument

123
00:07:14.180 --> 00:07:18.939
that costs a fortune to build. It requires investigators, data experts,

124
00:07:19.379 --> 00:07:23.470
and attorneys billing at Los Angeles rates for months. Whoever

125
00:07:23.550 --> 00:07:26.879
is running this defense now inherits that work and inherits

126
00:07:26.949 --> 00:07:30.379
it on a public defender's caseload. The new team asked

127
00:07:30.420 --> 00:07:33.360
the judge for more time before entering a plea. He

128
00:07:33.420 --> 00:07:36.920
said no. So they entered not guilty on all counts

129
00:07:37.120 --> 00:07:39.759
and got to work the same morning. Here is what

130
00:07:39.800 --> 00:07:44.220
happens next. District Attorney Nathan Hockman said his office has

131
00:07:44.300 --> 00:07:47.350
not yet decided whether to seek the death penalty, and

132
00:07:47.379 --> 00:07:50.350
he said publicly that he is confident the public defender

133
00:07:50.410 --> 00:07:53.629
will give Burke a zealous defense. which is the correct

134
00:07:53.670 --> 00:07:57.689
and professional thing for a prosecutor to say. Legal analysts

135
00:07:57.730 --> 00:08:01.009
in Los Angeles are already speculating that a public defender

136
00:08:01.060 --> 00:08:04.339
makes a plea deal more likely. I would be cautious

137
00:08:04.379 --> 00:08:08.279
about that. California has a moratorium on executions and has

138
00:08:08.339 --> 00:08:11.199
not carried one out in two decades, so the practical

139
00:08:11.240 --> 00:08:13.600
leverage that normally drives a plea in a case like

140
00:08:13.639 --> 00:08:17.899
this is not really there. The next hearing is October 19th,

141
00:08:18.199 --> 00:08:20.139
and at that point, the lawyers will tell the court

142
00:08:20.180 --> 00:08:23.500
whether they are ready for trial within 90 days. And

143
00:08:23.519 --> 00:08:26.279
I want to close this segment somewhere other than the money,

144
00:08:26.399 --> 00:08:28.870
because the money is the news and it is not

145
00:08:28.930 --> 00:08:33.629
the point. Celeste Rivas Hernandez was 14 years old. She

146
00:08:33.669 --> 00:08:36.429
was somebody's daughter in Lake Elsinore, and she got into

147
00:08:36.490 --> 00:08:39.090
a rideshare on an April night and never came home.

148
00:08:39.649 --> 00:08:41.929
When she was found, it was months later, and it

149
00:08:41.960 --> 00:08:44.220
was in a vehicle in a tow yard, and nobody

150
00:08:44.259 --> 00:08:46.840
had been looking in the right place. There is going

151
00:08:46.879 --> 00:08:49.409
to be an enormous amount of coverage of this case,

152
00:08:49.629 --> 00:08:51.330
and almost all of it is going to be about

153
00:08:51.370 --> 00:08:54.490
a famous young man and his career and his money.

154
00:08:55.149 --> 00:08:58.029
She is the one who is dead. Someone has to

155
00:08:58.110 --> 00:09:03.120
say her name. When we come back, Brian Koberger confessed

156
00:09:03.139 --> 00:09:05.740
to four murders in open court, and now he wants

157
00:09:05.799 --> 00:09:26.240
a do-over. On November 13th, 2022, four students at the

158
00:09:26.299 --> 00:09:29.220
University of Idaho were stabbed to death in an off-campus

159
00:09:29.259 --> 00:09:33.240
house on King Road in Moscow. Ethan Chapin was 20.

160
00:09:33.240 --> 00:09:37.899
Madison Mogan was 21. Zana Kernodle was 20. Kaylee Goncalves

161
00:09:37.960 --> 00:09:43.190
was 21. In July of 2025, Brian Koberger pleaded guilty.

162
00:09:43.929 --> 00:09:47.690
Not a no-contest plea. Not an Alford plea where you

163
00:09:47.750 --> 00:09:51.909
maintain innocence while accepting the conviction. He stood in a

164
00:09:51.950 --> 00:09:54.669
courtroom and admitted he did it in exchange for the

165
00:09:54.730 --> 00:09:58.669
state dropping the death penalty. Judge Stephen Hippler sentenced him

166
00:09:58.730 --> 00:10:02.620
to four consecutive life terms plus 10 years. That was

167
00:10:02.659 --> 00:10:05.399
supposed to be the end. In July of this year,

168
00:10:05.659 --> 00:10:09.139
one year after his sentencing, Koberger filed a handwritten petition

169
00:10:09.559 --> 00:10:13.350
seeking to withdraw that plea and go to trial. His

170
00:10:13.409 --> 00:10:15.950
position now is that he is innocent and that his

171
00:10:16.009 --> 00:10:19.559
own attorneys misled him into a false confession. He has

172
00:10:19.580 --> 00:10:22.870
been appointed a new lawyer, an Idaho attorney named Greg Rauch.

173
00:10:23.669 --> 00:10:27.690
And last Thursday, Rauch filed two motions that escalate this considerably.

174
00:10:28.610 --> 00:10:31.470
The first asked that Judge Hipler be disqualified from hearing

175
00:10:31.509 --> 00:10:34.970
the post-conviction case. The second asked that the proceedings be

176
00:10:35.029 --> 00:10:37.580
moved out of Ada County and back to Lata County,

177
00:10:37.940 --> 00:10:40.570
where the students were killed. I want to walk through

178
00:10:40.649 --> 00:10:43.450
both of those because the reflex is to dismiss this

179
00:10:43.549 --> 00:10:47.230
as a guilty man wasting everyone's time, and the actual

180
00:10:47.289 --> 00:10:51.750
legal argument is more interesting than that. Start with the judge.

181
00:10:52.590 --> 00:10:56.230
At sentencing, Hippler was not restrained, and frankly, there is

182
00:10:56.289 --> 00:10:59.330
no reason he should have been. He called Koberger a

183
00:10:59.470 --> 00:11:02.649
faceless coward. He called him the worst of the worst.

184
00:11:03.240 --> 00:11:06.080
And he asked out loud whether this defendant was even

185
00:11:06.179 --> 00:11:10.299
capable of speaking the truth. Now, none of that was improper.

186
00:11:10.659 --> 00:11:13.320
A judge imposing four life sentences for the murders of

187
00:11:13.399 --> 00:11:16.080
four young people is allowed to say what he thinks.

188
00:11:16.799 --> 00:11:19.419
But here is Rauch's argument, and it is not stupid.

189
00:11:20.059 --> 00:11:24.009
The question in a post-conviction proceeding is entirely about credibility.

190
00:11:24.669 --> 00:11:27.409
Koberger is claiming his lawyers coerced him and that his

191
00:11:27.470 --> 00:11:31.309
confession was false. The judge deciding that has to weigh

192
00:11:31.370 --> 00:11:34.529
whether to believe him. And that same judge already said,

193
00:11:34.789 --> 00:11:37.440
on the record, that he doubts this man is capable

194
00:11:37.480 --> 00:11:40.460
of telling the truth. The motion puts it this way.

195
00:11:40.799 --> 00:11:43.279
It does not rest on one adverse ruling or one

196
00:11:43.320 --> 00:11:47.159
harsh statement, but on the extraordinary convergence of all of them.

197
00:11:47.980 --> 00:11:51.370
Rauch has also pointed at a specific ruling that Hippler

198
00:11:51.389 --> 00:11:54.929
declined to give Koberger's original defense team more time when

199
00:11:54.970 --> 00:11:58.090
they said they had not finished reviewing Discovery weeks before

200
00:11:58.129 --> 00:12:01.850
a capital trial. which matters because that is the exact

201
00:12:01.889 --> 00:12:04.309
complaint at the heart of the whole petition, that his

202
00:12:04.370 --> 00:12:07.169
lawyers were not prepared and pushed him into a plea.

203
00:12:07.690 --> 00:12:10.070
And the venue piece has an irony you can see

204
00:12:10.110 --> 00:12:13.149
from space. The reason this case isn't Ada County at

205
00:12:13.289 --> 00:12:16.419
all is that Koberger's original defense fought hard to get

206
00:12:16.460 --> 00:12:19.440
it out of Lotta County, arguing the community was too

207
00:12:19.480 --> 00:12:22.539
small and too saturated with publicity for a fair jury.

208
00:12:22.840 --> 00:12:25.990
They won. The case moved to Boise. Now his new

209
00:12:26.029 --> 00:12:28.690
lawyer wants it back in Lata County, arguing the old

210
00:12:28.730 --> 00:12:32.269
concerns are irrelevant because this is a proceeding decided by

211
00:12:32.309 --> 00:12:35.330
a judge and not a jury, and that the transfer

212
00:12:35.389 --> 00:12:39.450
would be more convenient for witnesses and attorneys. It is also,

213
00:12:39.649 --> 00:12:42.690
as it happens, where Rauch's office is and where the

214
00:12:42.750 --> 00:12:46.820
Lata County prosecutor sits. There is also a wrinkle in

215
00:12:46.860 --> 00:12:50.460
what Koberger is asking for that people keep missing. He

216
00:12:50.519 --> 00:12:53.740
pleaded guilty specifically to take the death penalty off the table.

217
00:12:54.480 --> 00:12:57.620
Idaho was seeking execution and he traded a confession for

218
00:12:57.679 --> 00:13:01.429
four life terms. If he succeeds in withdrawing that plea,

219
00:13:01.669 --> 00:13:04.669
the deal goes with it. He would be back to

220
00:13:04.710 --> 00:13:09.169
facing a capital trial at his own request. Read that again.

221
00:13:09.190 --> 00:13:12.000
A man is asking a court for permission to put

222
00:13:12.009 --> 00:13:14.700
himself back in front of a jury that could sentence

223
00:13:14.759 --> 00:13:18.159
him to death. Either he believes something about this case

224
00:13:18.200 --> 00:13:21.600
that nobody else does or somebody has convinced him that

225
00:13:21.639 --> 00:13:24.529
this is the play. and I genuinely cannot tell you which.

226
00:13:25.289 --> 00:13:28.669
Prosecutors are not entertaining any of it. Their position is

227
00:13:28.730 --> 00:13:31.850
that Koberger has not made the substantial factual showing the

228
00:13:31.889 --> 00:13:35.399
law requires, and that he does not deserve an evidentiary

229
00:13:35.440 --> 00:13:39.120
hearing at all. They have asked that the whole petition

230
00:13:39.159 --> 00:13:42.639
be dismissed. Hippler has a status conference on the calendar,

231
00:13:42.860 --> 00:13:46.000
and the evidentiary hearing, if there is one, is currently

232
00:13:46.059 --> 00:13:49.840
set for June of 2027. Look, I'm going to give

233
00:13:49.879 --> 00:13:53.830
you my honest read. Withdrawing a guilty plea after sentencing

234
00:13:53.950 --> 00:13:55.850
is one of the hardest things to do in American

235
00:13:55.889 --> 00:14:00.019
criminal law, and it should be. The whole system depends

236
00:14:00.080 --> 00:14:03.620
on a plea meaning something. When Brian Koberger stood in

237
00:14:03.659 --> 00:14:06.440
that courtroom, he was asked a long series of questions

238
00:14:06.480 --> 00:14:10.100
designed for exactly this moment, and he answered them under

239
00:14:10.279 --> 00:14:14.759
oath with counsel beside him. That colloquy exists so that

240
00:14:14.799 --> 00:14:17.830
a year later, nobody can say they did not understand.

241
00:14:18.639 --> 00:14:20.980
And there is a cost to this that has nothing

242
00:14:21.019 --> 00:14:24.320
to do with law. Four families sat in that courtroom

243
00:14:24.340 --> 00:14:27.399
in July of 2025 and got the closest thing to

244
00:14:27.440 --> 00:14:31.480
an ending this system offers. 14 months later, they are

245
00:14:31.539 --> 00:14:36.179
reading motions again. That said, the right to challenge a

246
00:14:36.220 --> 00:14:40.909
conviction on ineffective assistance grounds exists precisely because innocent people

247
00:14:40.990 --> 00:14:45.250
do plead guilty. It happens constantly, mostly to poor people,

248
00:14:45.690 --> 00:14:50.429
mostly quietly. and almost never with this much attention. Someone

249
00:14:50.500 --> 00:14:53.100
facing a charge they did not commit, sitting in a

250
00:14:53.159 --> 00:14:56.259
jail they cannot bond out of, is offered time served

251
00:14:56.399 --> 00:14:59.360
or a decade of exposure at trial, and they take

252
00:14:59.399 --> 00:15:02.240
the deal because taking the deal is the only rational

253
00:15:02.299 --> 00:15:05.789
move available to them. That is a real and documented

254
00:15:05.830 --> 00:15:09.629
failure in American criminal law, and the mechanism Brian Koberger

255
00:15:09.710 --> 00:15:13.629
is using exists because of those people. The principle does

256
00:15:13.669 --> 00:15:16.909
not become worthless because the man invoking it is who

257
00:15:16.970 --> 00:15:21.129
he is. That is what makes it a principle. Ethan

258
00:15:21.169 --> 00:15:26.409
Chapin was 20. Madison Mogan was 21. Zana Kernodle was 20.

259
00:15:26.409 --> 00:15:30.350
Kaylee Goncalves was 21. They were college students asleep in

260
00:15:30.389 --> 00:15:33.049
a rented house on an ordinary November night, two of

261
00:15:33.090 --> 00:15:35.549
them with finals coming, all four of them with the

262
00:15:35.629 --> 00:15:39.269
entire rest of their lives scheduled. There is a roommate

263
00:15:39.350 --> 00:15:42.529
who survived, who saw a masked man on the second floor,

264
00:15:42.980 --> 00:15:45.659
and has had to live inside that memory for four years.

265
00:15:46.279 --> 00:15:49.169
She is in the caption of every filing too, in

266
00:15:49.230 --> 00:15:52.629
her way. Every filing in this case carries their names

267
00:15:52.690 --> 00:15:55.649
in the caption. Someone has to say them out loud too.

268
00:15:57.009 --> 00:15:59.720
When we come back, a surgeon facing the death penalty

269
00:15:59.759 --> 00:16:02.980
has now given up his lawyers, his motions, and his jury.

270
00:16:19.990 --> 00:16:23.370
Stephen Kazi was 41 years old. He was an attorney

271
00:16:23.409 --> 00:16:28.220
in Largo, Florida. On March 21st, 2023, he walked into

272
00:16:28.259 --> 00:16:31.799
his office building wearing a red sweater. Surveillance cameras recorded

273
00:16:31.840 --> 00:16:35.519
him going in. No camera ever recorded him coming out.

274
00:16:36.279 --> 00:16:38.600
He had stepped away from his desk to use the restroom.

275
00:16:39.259 --> 00:16:42.179
Prosecutors say he was murdered in that bathroom. His body

276
00:16:42.210 --> 00:16:45.289
has never been found. The state's belief is that it

277
00:16:45.350 --> 00:16:48.529
was driven to the Everglades. At the time he disappeared,

278
00:16:48.830 --> 00:16:51.909
Stephen Causey was representing a client in a civil suit

279
00:16:52.029 --> 00:16:58.480
against a plastic surgeon named Tomasz Kosowski. Kosowski is 47, Dartmouth-trained,

280
00:16:58.620 --> 00:17:01.639
and has been in jail since March of 2023. He

281
00:17:02.299 --> 00:17:06.759
has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder. Prosecutors are seeking

282
00:17:06.799 --> 00:17:10.619
the death penalty. Among the things police say they recovered

283
00:17:10.769 --> 00:17:15.009
is a bag containing brass knuckles, a stun gun, duct tape,

284
00:17:15.130 --> 00:17:18.740
and masks. And they say Kozy's DNA was found in

285
00:17:18.779 --> 00:17:22.460
the trunk of Kasowski's vehicle. He is presumed innocent of

286
00:17:22.559 --> 00:17:25.420
all of it. Now, here is why this case is

287
00:17:25.500 --> 00:17:28.140
on our show today. And it is not the evidence.

288
00:17:28.700 --> 00:17:30.579
It is what the defendant has been doing to his

289
00:17:30.640 --> 00:17:34.539
own defense. Kasowski has gone through multiple sets of lawyers.

290
00:17:35.019 --> 00:17:39.170
At least one team withdrew, citing ethical reasons. A fourth

291
00:17:39.230 --> 00:17:42.869
attorney asked out. Last month, he told Judge Joseph Bologna

292
00:17:42.930 --> 00:17:46.099
he intended to represent himself at his own capital murder trial.

293
00:17:46.740 --> 00:17:49.380
And in the email his outgoing attorney sent the court,

294
00:17:49.700 --> 00:17:51.960
there were two lines that should have made everybody in

295
00:17:52.000 --> 00:17:56.180
that building stop walking. That Kosowski refuses to sign consent

296
00:17:56.220 --> 00:17:59.529
forms for a doctor's evaluation. And that he did not

297
00:17:59.569 --> 00:18:03.289
want evidence presented in his defense. Then it kept going.

298
00:18:03.710 --> 00:18:06.410
Two weeks after firing his lawyers, he sat alone at

299
00:18:06.430 --> 00:18:10.769
the defense table. His former attorneys had filed motions arguing

300
00:18:10.809 --> 00:18:16.230
the death penalty was unconstitutional and illegally applied. Kosowski withdrew

301
00:18:16.450 --> 00:18:19.569
all of them. He withdrew all opposition to being executed.

302
00:18:20.390 --> 00:18:22.710
On Monday, he came back and withdrew the motions to

303
00:18:22.750 --> 00:18:27.109
suppress evidence that his previous attorney had filed. Prosecutors then

304
00:18:27.150 --> 00:18:29.630
raised a request to bring jurors to the office building

305
00:18:29.650 --> 00:18:33.160
to see the bathroom. And at that point, Kosowski interrupted

306
00:18:33.299 --> 00:18:35.680
and said he did not want a jury at all.

307
00:18:36.299 --> 00:18:40.269
He asked for a bench trial. judge alone. And in Florida,

308
00:18:40.329 --> 00:18:43.490
a capital defendant has to waive a jury twice, once

309
00:18:43.529 --> 00:18:45.950
for the guilt phase and once for the penalty phase,

310
00:18:46.470 --> 00:18:51.339
because the state considers those decisions that serious. Kosowski waived both.

311
00:18:52.019 --> 00:18:54.859
Attorneys who follow these cases describe a dual waiver like

312
00:18:54.900 --> 00:18:59.140
that as exceptionally rare. Ballone asked him why he wanted it.

313
00:18:59.480 --> 00:19:03.650
Kosowski's answer was, I really have to answer that. And

314
00:19:03.690 --> 00:19:07.210
the judge said, I guess not. Ballone accepted the waiver,

315
00:19:07.349 --> 00:19:11.130
finding that this was a Dartmouth-trained physician who understood his

316
00:19:11.210 --> 00:19:15.210
rights and was making the choice knowingly. And think about

317
00:19:15.250 --> 00:19:18.009
what he gave away in that one sentence, because prosecutors

318
00:19:18.049 --> 00:19:20.509
had just been asking to take a jury to that bathroom.

319
00:19:21.170 --> 00:19:23.990
A jury view is a powerful thing for the state.

320
00:19:24.470 --> 00:19:27.650
Twelve people standing in the actual room where a man

321
00:19:27.730 --> 00:19:30.920
is alleged to have died is worth more than any photograph.

322
00:19:31.589 --> 00:19:34.450
It is also historically the kind of thing a defense

323
00:19:34.529 --> 00:19:39.019
fights hard to prevent. Kosowski's response was not to fight it.

324
00:19:39.500 --> 00:19:42.440
It was to remove the jury entirely, which moots the

325
00:19:42.539 --> 00:19:45.869
whole question. If that was tactical, it is the only

326
00:19:45.910 --> 00:19:48.970
tactical red available. And even then, it trades a small

327
00:19:49.009 --> 00:19:52.880
win for an enormous one. one. And legally, that is correct.

328
00:19:53.259 --> 00:19:55.480
I want to be clear about that. The right to

329
00:19:55.519 --> 00:19:58.920
counsel is yours to waive. The right to a jury

330
00:19:59.180 --> 00:20:02.500
is yours to waive. Courts are not permitted to force

331
00:20:02.539 --> 00:20:05.700
a competent adult to mount the defense a judge would prefer.

332
00:20:06.539 --> 00:20:09.700
And the alternative, where the state decides which defendants are

333
00:20:09.740 --> 00:20:12.680
allowed to make their own choices, is far worse than

334
00:20:12.720 --> 00:20:15.369
what we have. But I am going to say the

335
00:20:15.410 --> 00:20:19.430
uncomfortable thing anyway. Add it up. A man fires four

336
00:20:19.490 --> 00:20:22.390
sets of lawyers. He refuses to sign consent forms for

337
00:20:22.450 --> 00:20:25.910
a medical evaluation. He tells his own attorney he does

338
00:20:26.009 --> 00:20:30.170
not want evidence presented on his behalf. He withdraws every

339
00:20:30.230 --> 00:20:34.009
objection to his own execution. He withdraws the motions that

340
00:20:34.049 --> 00:20:36.809
might have kept evidence out. And then he gives up

341
00:20:36.849 --> 00:20:40.279
a jury for both phases and declines to explain why.

342
00:20:40.970 --> 00:20:43.960
That is not a legal strategy. Nobody has ever drawn

343
00:20:43.980 --> 00:20:46.539
that up on a whiteboard. I am not a doctor

344
00:20:46.660 --> 00:20:49.500
and I am not diagnosing anyone from a podcast studio.

345
00:20:50.039 --> 00:20:53.680
Competency to stand trial is a specific legal test. And

346
00:20:53.720 --> 00:20:55.809
a judge who has watched this man in his courtroom

347
00:20:55.849 --> 00:20:58.710
for three years has found he meets it. And that

348
00:20:58.809 --> 00:21:01.880
judge knows more than I do. It is also true

349
00:21:01.920 --> 00:21:04.940
that a defendant can be perfectly competent and still be

350
00:21:04.980 --> 00:21:09.470
making catastrophic decisions for reasons of pride or exhaustion or

351
00:21:09.509 --> 00:21:12.730
a belief that the whole thing is rigged anyway. But

352
00:21:12.750 --> 00:21:16.410
when a man is systematically removing every protection standing between

353
00:21:16.450 --> 00:21:20.519
himself and an execution chamber and refuses to be evaluated

354
00:21:20.759 --> 00:21:24.180
and will not say why, somebody should be asking harder

355
00:21:24.240 --> 00:21:27.930
questions before that trial starts. That's not a mistake, that's

356
00:21:27.970 --> 00:21:30.029
a choice, and it is a choice being made by

357
00:21:30.069 --> 00:21:32.599
the one person in that room with the least ability

358
00:21:32.630 --> 00:21:36.079
to see it clearly. Stephen Cousy was 41. He was

359
00:21:36.119 --> 00:21:38.940
a lawyer doing his job representing a client in a lawsuit,

360
00:21:39.019 --> 00:21:41.420
which is the most ordinary thing a lawyer does in

361
00:21:41.440 --> 00:21:44.380
this country. He went to the bathroom at work and

362
00:21:44.500 --> 00:21:46.819
never came home, and his family has never had a

363
00:21:46.859 --> 00:21:49.890
body to bury. I keep coming back to the red sweater.

364
00:21:50.190 --> 00:21:52.589
There is footage of him walking into that building in it,

365
00:21:52.890 --> 00:21:55.349
on an ordinary Tuesday in March, and that is the

366
00:21:55.390 --> 00:21:59.269
last image anyone has. No arrest photo, no crime scene,

367
00:21:59.430 --> 00:22:02.369
no funeral. A man in a red sweater going back

368
00:22:02.410 --> 00:22:05.089
to his desk. Three and a half years later, the

369
00:22:05.130 --> 00:22:07.309
man accused of it is preparing to try his own

370
00:22:07.369 --> 00:22:10.369
case in front of one judge, with no suppression motions,

371
00:22:10.769 --> 00:22:15.089
no objection to the death penalty, and no jury. Stephen Kazi.

372
00:22:15.490 --> 00:22:22.289
Someone has to say his name. That's the show for Wednesday,

373
00:22:22.329 --> 00:22:25.990
September 2nd. If this was useful, send it to one person.

374
00:22:26.329 --> 00:22:28.250
That is the whole engine on a show like this.

375
00:22:28.930 --> 00:22:33.210
And if you're listening on Spotify, drop a comment. Three

376
00:22:33.259 --> 00:22:35.420
men this week tried to rewrite the rules of their

377
00:22:35.440 --> 00:22:38.819
own prosecutions. One wants somebody else to pay for his lawyer,

378
00:22:39.220 --> 00:22:41.839
one wants to take back a confession, and one wants

379
00:22:41.900 --> 00:22:44.440
to be tried by a single judge and will not

380
00:22:44.519 --> 00:22:48.490
say why. Tell me which one bothers you most, because

381
00:22:48.549 --> 00:22:52.009
they bother me for completely different reasons. And we are

382
00:22:52.109 --> 00:22:55.559
still on verdict watch in Plymouth. When that jury comes back,

383
00:22:55.930 --> 00:22:58.900
we will be here. I'm Garrett Fisher. Do better. A

384
00:23:00.599 --> 00:23:04.160
few notes on sourcing and timing. This episode was recorded

385
00:23:04.220 --> 00:23:07.579
before court opened Wednesday morning. The jury in the Lindsay

386
00:23:07.619 --> 00:23:10.759
Clancy trial completed a fourth day of deliberations without a

387
00:23:10.819 --> 00:23:14.289
verdict and sent no notes on Monday. If a verdict

388
00:23:14.309 --> 00:23:18.710
was returned after we recorded, this episode does not reflect it.

389
00:23:19.539 --> 00:23:22.940
On the Los Angeles case, David Anthony Burke has pleaded

390
00:23:23.099 --> 00:23:26.609
not guilty to all charges and is presumed innocent. We

391
00:23:26.619 --> 00:23:29.700
have deliberately not described the evidence or the allegations in

392
00:23:29.880 --> 00:23:33.190
any detail, and we will not because the victim in

393
00:23:33.289 --> 00:23:37.490
this case was a 14-year-old child. The claim that Burke

394
00:23:37.569 --> 00:23:40.710
is concealing assets and corporations is a statement issued by

395
00:23:40.750 --> 00:23:44.210
the victim's family, not a finding by any court. A

396
00:23:44.289 --> 00:23:48.390
judge reviewed his financial circumstances and determined he qualified for

397
00:23:48.430 --> 00:23:52.720
appointed counsel. Reporting on his career earnings comes from testimony

398
00:23:52.779 --> 00:23:56.119
given at a prior hearing. The district attorney's office has

399
00:23:56.180 --> 00:23:58.519
said no decision has been made on whether to seek

400
00:23:58.539 --> 00:24:02.829
the death penalty. On the Idaho case, Brian Koberger pleaded

401
00:24:02.869 --> 00:24:06.470
guilty and was sentenced, and his petition to withdraw that

402
00:24:06.529 --> 00:24:10.529
plea has not been granted. Nothing in it has been established.

403
00:24:11.109 --> 00:24:13.529
His claim that his prior attorneys misled him is an

404
00:24:13.589 --> 00:24:16.950
allegation contained in a filing, and those attorneys have not

405
00:24:16.970 --> 00:24:20.589
been found to have done anything improper. Prosecutors have asked

406
00:24:20.619 --> 00:24:23.410
that the petition be dismissed without a hearing. On the

407
00:24:23.450 --> 00:24:27.069
Florida case, Tomasz Kosowski has pleaded not guilty and is

408
00:24:27.130 --> 00:24:31.069
presumed innocent. The items described as recovered by police and

409
00:24:31.109 --> 00:24:34.529
the reported DNA finding are allegations by the state that

410
00:24:34.569 --> 00:24:37.619
have not been tested at trial. Our account of his

411
00:24:37.700 --> 00:24:40.799
former attorney's concerns comes from an email read into the

412
00:24:40.859 --> 00:24:44.269
record at a hearing. We have raised questions about his decisions,

413
00:24:44.549 --> 00:24:46.920
but a judge who has presided over this case has

414
00:24:46.980 --> 00:24:49.980
found him competent to waive counsel and to waive a jury,

415
00:24:50.220 --> 00:24:53.700
and we are not suggesting otherwise. Nothing in this episode

416
00:24:53.740 --> 00:24:57.240
should be taken as a diagnosis of anyone. This episode

417
00:24:57.259 --> 00:25:01.440
discusses violence against children, the death penalty, and the killing

418
00:25:01.460 --> 00:25:04.170
of young people. If any of it is difficult to

419
00:25:04.230 --> 00:25:07.900
sit with, that is a reasonable reaction. If you are struggling,

420
00:25:08.079 --> 00:25:10.900
you can call or text 988 in the United States

421
00:25:11.000 --> 00:25:13.289
to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.